Modi govt’s criminal law ‘reform’: Sedition/treason/hate crime/lynch mobs, crime against women, kids
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 сер 2023
- The Modi government Friday moved three bills to overhaul India’s colonial-era criminal law. The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita Bill, Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita Bill, and Bharatiya Sakshya Bill seek to replace the Indian Penal Code (IPC), 1860, Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC), 1898, and the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, respectively. While all three bills will now be scrutinised by a standing committee, their proposals are out in the public domain. In episode 1289 of #CutTheClutter, Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta looks at the some of the important reforms proposed for the IPC - the more complex charge that takes sedition’s place in the books, the definitions introduced for terrorism and organised crime, and what the bill means for failed suicide attempts, sex on the premise of marriage, and mob lynchings.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
@kumarakomlakeresortkerala
@pauljohnresortsandhotels
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Member benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
46' election result ---mosslim constituency ( Bombay Province 100% seat goes to M. League, Madras Province 100%, Bengal 95%, Assam 91%, Orissa 100%, Central Province 93% so on & so on ...) still this librandu congress did not do popul. xchange. ....
@@urrasscal83803:45 3:46 3:46
0
L
0
L
0
L
These laws are transformational, they will reform Police & Judiciary. The objective of the laws are.
-Zero FIR filing
-Enquiry with clinical evidence to be completed within 90 days
- Justice to be delivered in 3 years or before
- Digital diary & complete computer/digitization of all courts in India
I hope we deliver the justice within time frame, it is imperative for foreign investors' confidence (speedy justice)
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
These laws also increased the detention of suspects for up to 90 days from 60 days making innocent people more susceptible to false confessions.
@@rahallivex which is atmost 5-8% of all cases
@@user-yk5vc8kx6f how do you mean 5-8%. It applies to all cases like burglary, robbery, physical assault, attempted murder and murder. They can take people into custody for 90 days now in almost all cases.
how they would transform? it's like putting old wine in new bottle, sedition law has been made extremely stringent, it will fill the jails because even words and signs could be considered as deshdroh.
MODI government is already working on building consensus on judiciary reforms. Third term will see bills related to it along with UCC and implementation of CAA and NRC
We are on road to dictatorship.
Want to see implementation of CAA-NRC before I die.
The same way farm laws was repealed, these laws will too not see the lime light
Before bringing UCC, Hope they bring back the farm laws (which will benefit lakhs of small farmers, remove middle men and bring down the horrible Mandi system which is the root cause for inflation- creating artificial demand by hoarding/storing goods illegally. This not only impacts farmers but also middle class)
People in opposition unnecessarily creating issue by bringing names like adani Ambani and scaring farmers by telling they will be robbed of their lands.
Govt had no spine to go ahead with their farm laws and had to withdraw because of the backlash
I believe more than UCC/CAA/NRC, farm laws will truly benefit ppl (economically)
Demonetization stupidity again
A big failure and we need to suffer
Looks like the government has been working hard behind the scenes
Very hard. It was clear when govt filed affidavit in Sedition law abolition PIL.
4 years. Amit Shah said. 200+ meetings he himself attended. Hundreds of judges, professors and consultants were referred
Will wait to hear from you when tables turn. Going by your history you will be the first cry baby against these laws.
Devil's in the details, don't be happy too soon. The entire politics of this country stands on flaky criminal laws which give impunity to politicians.
I don't see drastic change, there may just be cosmetic reframing of same codes instead of making laws foolproof and bringing speedy justice
That's why we should give our vote for BJP again😊
Hope we will see Common Civil laws too in parliament in 2024
irrespective of Gender,Religion & Caste. With Equality for both Men & Women.
Govt. should take serious steps towards Uniform Civil Code.
That won't happen😂. Just like CAA
@@parvadhami980 But Uttarakhand BJP just passed it
(UCC)
The draft is almost Ready now !!
Gujarat has also made a commitee under Retd.supreme court & High court Judges.
& Under CAA Afganistan Sikhs Were brought in India gave them refugee status.
& last year in Gujarat central Govt. Gave citizenship to Hindu refugees from pakistan.
Its a Long process it is not Like Article 370 & 35A to Remove eveything in just one speech.
through presidential Order.
@@Kang.31 u do know right that CAA is applicable to those refugees who fled India BEFORE 31st December 2014?
Then how come Sikhs came in 2021 under CAA?
Passing UCC is more tougher than anything u can imagine even NRC.
In CAA & NRC u face resistance from Muslims but in UCC, U face from Muslims, Christians, Sikhs, Especially ST's.
Our country will be on Fire..
@@parvadhami980 Thats What I said Refugee status for afgan Sikhs not citizenship. for
Citizenship has to go process of naturalization.
& on other hand i also Said Gujarat govt. gave citizenshio to 40 hindus from pakistan.
Damn, sex crime related laws under section "69". Sooooooo appropriate 😂
That brings some humour in law!
@@ashokjain5940dirty and logical mind
Dont glamorise sex .
This is left for congress to bring in.
Vatsayanas blessings from above !!😄
This Parliament session solely belongs to one man without a doubt, and its no other den, H.M Amit Shah....Delhi services bill, no confidence motion & this acts....
I always see Amit shah has more courage & Guts than Modi in parliament.He alone can handle Opposition Single Handedly
whether its Article 370,35 A,CAA NRC or any other steps Relating To National Interest or National Security.
Or Upcoming Uniform Civil Code
@@Kang.31this is a really tragic law! If u r bjp supporter think how congress can use this law if they come to power
He has to hide his incompetence somehow.
@@chinmayshetye3 May be !! But it seems that Congress does more appeasement & Gandhi dyansty politics
so i dont think Congress will get in power in full majority
they Have lost Everything after 1985 Shah bano Case.
They were 400+ seats in 1984 which They came down To nearly 40 seats today. Remember they never got Fully majority after 1984 election
becoz of Shah bano case Curse
on congress
Becoz Hindus understand Congress is More Pro muslim than pro indian.
Thats why BJP seats Rose From 2 seats in 1984 to 90 seats in 1989-90 elections.
so u thin delhi service bill is ligit.. people like u deserve to be a slave.
Hope we will become a country of law and order. We have a long way to go from being a mobocracy ..
In which case tge two Gujjus at the top should be behind bars….
News Kam dekha karo..
@@vivek1raja R u a Pakistani BOT
Y9u will be the first one to cry when tables turn. bjp Will not be in power forever but this law will. It will be used against you guys in the same way as it will be used against Indians.
@@stardragon7954 And you too, to wipe their asses clean in the morning. You have developed expertise in that field doing the same for BJP leaders.
Lot of paperwork will be done, lots of PILs will be filed and lot of noise will be made by specifically the lawyer community. But in time, this day and these Bills will be celebrated. The aura of Modi & Shah will be part of folklore and soon will be turned to demi-gods.
Good or bad, history is being written everyday by this duo. Some others are - NITI Aayog, GST, IBC, A370, Parliament, Ayodhya, CDS, etc.
Yeah but still UCC is still pending
@@Kang.31mullo na aag laga di desh ko to kya karoge
@@shivmohan99681 Lol, Indian Army is Dealing with these mullah for Past 70 years in kashmir.
& mullah's did nothing when UCC was getting implemented in Uttarakhand state.
these Mullah's r not Arabs. Arabs follow religious Islam
These Muslims in Sub continent follow Politicial Islam.
especially in Afganistan,pakistan & India.
with ideology of Dar-ul-islam throughout indian Sub continent.
Dar-ul-Islam throught process of Religious conversion, Demographic changes just like in kashmir & pakistan
u will find many muslims with surname Of Bajwa,Rajput,chauhan,chaudhary,
Bhat,Sarkar,Pandit,Dhillion etc.
@@Kang.31 It will get done as well. If anyone can, that has to be NaMo.
@@Kang.31it won't happen. UCC is only to polarize people on religious lines. 2024 elections
The proposed reform is really promising. But this won't pass in the current term though. Jan Vishwas Bill took roughly 3 years of work before it was passed by both houses. I anticipate this will take roughly the same amount of time.
Under the new laws, Sedition now specifically target Anti-nationals (calling for division of India) rather than folks who express displeasure towards Govt policy. Arresting people because they called a progeny of a Politician Penguin is no longer sedition. This is a step in the right direction.
The new laws completely removed references to "unnatural carnal desires" aka gay sex completely. Also a step in the right direction
Mandatory chargesheets notification and publications!!
Time limits for chargesheets with automatic bail!
This is a huge step in the right direction.
One has to wonder, why so called "liberal, progressives" did not bother to pass such comprehensive reforms? Instead we get essays that extols the beauty and genius of IPC.
Edit: So "Liberal, Porgressives" are calling these reforms as a work of an Autocratic regime and quoting Nazi concentration camp survivor Hannah Ardent (Hai Bhagwan!). Long overdue reforms occur because Mudiji is fuscist. Hot take ke bhi haad hoti hai.
But Shashi Tharoor submitted a 1000 word private bill way back in 2017. It may have sounded like a sophamore ChatGPT generated essay but he should be given credit for it when it invariably works.
Till then "keep calm and Mudi ze musht rejin".
And govenment will decide whether its displeasure or treason
- Any one who do Darna should be sent to jail for treason
- Any journalist who say anything against govt should be sent to jail for treason.
@@rutvikrs1000 words only ? An entire bill ?
@@tapanthakur read his private member bills. Available on his website
Remain like this only
Mr Shekhar Gupta lets it slide while quoting Sharjeel Imam that "somebody" may say that it is just a irresponsible statement ...afterall what wherewithall he had to acheive that objective.
This man overlooks the fact that this was found to be an act of treason by the SC whose independent views his ilk celebrates. Just imagine that this guy and his kind set the narrative in India for decades.. .
I didn't understand his logic of connecting abilities or wherewithal to be a criterion for determining seriousness of an already treasonous statement.
Very aptly said sir ever I was flabbergasted to hear SGs defence of the statement
Someone issuing a call for violence can use the same argument. "How can I organise a riot, when I don't have friends 😢"
Mr. Gupta might've said what capabilities does Osama has to destroy twin towers? 😢😢
All those Maulvis who escaped after having made stupid statements that lead to the death of many like Kamlesh Tiwari will not escape lightly in the near future. In fact these crimes should be prosecuted retrospectively under these new laws.
Some Police Reforms are also needed , from law to training.
सहमत।
We need to make police more powerful
@@nmn8829 Police is already extremely powerful, issue is they are reporting to bureaucratic bosses, on contrary they should report directly to people, like sheriff in USA, A sheriff is a peace officer who holds public office; the voters in each county elect their sheriff once every four years, no one should be above people.
@@krishanrathi9119 theh arent powerful enough, they cant be reporting to the people, stupid idea.
Bro it's process judicial reform than police reform
When a government actually puts in the work to make these changes to better tackle a country is indeed commendable. I can’t imagine anyone from any other party doing that. If opposition wants power, they need to work hard.
Opposition will offer freebies,, just like Karnataka delhi punjab bengal. And ensure they capture power
All laws in India had been and still is used against Hindus and Hindus only. No one will arrest a Mullah or Christian priest for insulting Hinduism, but Modi Government will arrest any Hindu for saying something Muslims do not like - Nupur Sharma, MLA Raja, Kajal Hindustani.
@@MrCMVikrambro you need to change perception a bit, don't be over-influenced by some creators who just rant that Modi is Anti-Hindu. Everybody knows he isn't.
@@rajbiswas249 Think about it this way, if you want drgs, and I know you want it... then you become my potential customer and I'll approach you because I know you'll buy it. It's the same story with politics. Politicians know people want freebies, people like freebies, so they approach them with freebies and in return they get votes.
If people start rejecting freebies, do you think Politicians would still come to them offering freebies?
India's name itself is colonial - The institutions, laws & their execution are colonial & anti Hindu too!! No people, nation & civilzation is as self flogging & enslaved as this anti Hindu state!!
Excellent analysis from SG and great initiative from the government - congratulations all around! 👍👏
Finally a government that is actually doing some real work & reforming these antiquated laws 🙏
I am a Lawyer
अति सराहनीय कदम🎉
You can bring any number of reforms in overtly legislated and under enforced country, Unless the conduct of street level bureaucrats change on the ground, it will not make any difference to the life of a common man.
Dealing with Govt departments, police, bureaucrats is still rather worse than how it used to be earlier.
I personally experienced it recently at a post office, went there for some work related to my father’s old account .
While visiting 3 days in a row to get it closed. Asking for own money back felt like begging or asking for a loan 😀 The Experience was anything but frustrating. I also witnessed How some people were being shoed away and treated. Like a peace of sh..t ..Was wandering why these frontline Clerks are being called public servants, they should be called kings 👑 and we as commoners. 😊
Nice, educating episode. Thanks also to this government which is inteoducing long awaited reforms.
You call it reform? What was so bad then under British rule?
welcome move. 👍
Hmm😅
Amit Shah is proving to be one of the most active Home Minister ever. I feel even his Parliament debate on the Manipur issue was far better than Modi's presentation.
Is that not the case for last 9 years. One of the major achievement of this Government is minimum talk before changes happen. This is why they have been able to change too many issues affecting people in day to day life.
That's what a good HM should do .. 🙄
Absolutely. Amit Shah's speeches are much more pointed, laced with comparative data and sharp facts.
BUT.. you can not take away the hard work of SICK-ular Congress leadership when they brought the communal laws where Hindus were always responsible; no matter who was at fault!!
2026 PM
Hope Modi-Shah are back in 2024. Next round should be Judicial reforms and Police reforms. That will totally change the landscape in India.
😂 you must be a blind Modi fan and not an Indian
@@amoseannamalai4506 do u know u sound absolutely stupid when u give such arguments?
@@amoseannamalai4506Modi will be PM after 2024 election 🔥🔥🔥
@@amoseannamalai4506 U looks like a terrorist
@@amoseannamalai4506
🔥 in the 🍑 🕳 Burnol laga do!!
We got independence in 1947...But truly under this govt.. We are coming out of shackles of colonial Era...
Real independence was in 2014 for Hindus, 2025 our nation Hindurashtra will be named
Hats off to Amit Shah who conducted 158 meetings across the country over 4 years to come up with these reforms! Copying someone else's constitution was much easy.
Have u read the old and new law ? I m a lawyer. I can say these laws r not new. 99% of content of old law has been retained just the numbering of sections have been modified and rearranged.
IPC has seen some cosmetic changes.
Crpc and Evidence Act r ditto as they were with change in name and change in sequencing only.
To say that british era has been done away with is untrue.
Changes in IPC r the only material changes. But those could have been done simply with an Amendment Act jnstead of renaming the law.
If british era was to be done away with then power procedure of police investigation should have been changed in CrPC. But no such change has been made.
Similarly in Evidence the manner of proof and admissibility of evidence which is british designed should have been changed. But no such changed has been done.
Changing name of a city doesn't change the lives of its people.
Same is true for these so called new laws.
By Shah's own admission, only few sections have been added to new legislations. They have rearranged the provisions, that is it.
@@offred6013 Simplification in itself is a great achievement. Since they have reduced number of sections by 30 percent, it is unlikely that it is 99% the same. Also, provisions to improve justice system and reduce delays is amazing.
Yes, you are right amit shah is better than ambedkar
yes absolutely right. @@parikshithj8636
some laws are on point but some still leave a lot of room for misuse.
The terrorism one will be misused.
There are degree of hateful acts that should not be swept under the common blanket of terrorism.
Such acts should be treated corresponding to the degree of the severity of the act.
Nonsense.
Where did u see that in new law ?
Terrorism is clearly defined.
All laws have loopholes and can be misused
@@jaideepmathur6315 To some extent yes. But sometimes there is scope to tighten the law by not using vague words that can be interpreted by the enforcer on a whim
And also some laws have consequences greater than the others and therefore should be worded even more carefully.
Any opposition to Hindurashtra must be treated as terrorism, I support everything that bjp is doing
@@jaideepmathur6315 so don't have any laws?
Thanks a lot to Sekhar ji for explaining key changes so comprehensively. Can't find this analysis anywhere else. Finally, the rightful implementation depends on the person in the power. Any great law can either be used for the rightful purpose or be used for political gains
Very progressive reforms. Well done, BJP and Modi government. What does Rahul Gandhi have to say about these reforms?
Maybe something like ...Punish the Bjp Rapists immediately using your law reform
Nothing earlier Adani now Manipur and Ambani . Earlier in congress Era all seven states were burning
Pappu is still a kid how do you expect a kid to understand such a serious matter
These laws don't apply to BJP supporters
Nice analysis, looking forward to more detailed insights
While oppositions are shouting and making a ruckus about manipur modi government is bringing the exact law against lynch mob ( @15:41 ) required to prevent such crimes ever again and rahul gandhi total useless opposition just worried about getting the seat and not what he will do if and when he comes into power.
Your understanding of the way the criminal law system works is commendable
the modi government has totally failed in Manipur (both state and central government) and that's a fact. It's because of them that the violence spread so quickly and it's still continuing. They have still not imposed president's rule in Manipur which can stop the violence. And the PM has still not accepted that they have failed to maintain peace. They only took action after the video went viral but they knew about that incident and many such incidents like that for more than 2 months.
You can lock up Rahul Gandhi for treason. Do it. Do it. 😂😂
@@hawkingdawking4572 lol many bark all over country if we we started arresting everyone then we can't have anything done anymore.
True .
Law against mob violence
For shekar ...sharjeel make a irresponsible statement, this is the guy who interviwed great geoge sores
Good work by parliament, a step to establish rule of law and a good analysis and presentation by SG an team to educate people. Thanks and best regards, 🙏🏻
7:14 excellent point. We Indians must save India from Foreign powers, interest ❤
No dhruv rathee was hurt during making of this video
@@equivalentexchange5928 😂
Which Foreign powers are you referring to?
@@equivalentexchange5928Dhruv made perticular video against khalistani supporters bro he don't support them
@@pardeeptandon gorge Soros Chinese secret Agent Raul Vinci etc
The best.
We youngsters need a lot many elders like you.
Dhanyawaad Shekhar Chacha.
These bills look comprehensively covered and your presentation made it better SG. However concerns remain of misuse, but we could always do with simplification and clarity of offences and punishment. Hope this bill gets further scrutinised and gets passed eventually, IPCs from colonial era has to expire at least now.
Thank you, my friend. I'm glad you liked this episode. The bills have been referred to a standing committee, so further scrutiny is expected. Do keep watching and writing in...best wishes, Shekhar
13:00 I am happy that a "call like that" will be treated as a terrorist act. Anyone who utters such provocative statements should face the music of law, no matter how much SG tries to pass it as "ladke, ladke hain… galti ho jati hai"
Not only as a terrorist act but as treason too. 😊😊
Will the BJP apply it to their own goons? or use it to jail anyone who raises their voice against those goons? what is your honest opinion?
@@nehakurian6502. Well .... What is BJP? It is khangress + Cow. While khangress would like to appease the
so called minorities who could break this country....the BJP appeases the Majority.
You never had such questions for khangress when it was in power....because it was convenient for you.
So the BJP too will have its supporters who may not question it.
@RAMESH-js9lc
Can you specify how BJP appeasement to majority is like?
He is perhaps warning the handlers... As he won't be able to support people making statement like that anymore. Spreading news about fake coup by army would also be difficult from here on....
Rebellion against the nation has to be severely punished. Funding these agencies to break up India must be crushed.
It should be sharp and clear. The problem is anything can be construed as attack against India.For example the GOI of the day can see itself as India, any question against the GOI can be taken as an “attack on the integrity of this country” they suppress speech with this
Saffron fascists jumping up and down for joy.
Yes they are rascals. For money these scoundrels and bastards can stoop down to any extent. Anti nationals
@@vivek1raja Indeed. A very sad day for commie anti-nationals.
@@tony16991the last time i checked communism started in russia, ironically the same country our govt is buying cheap discounted oil and weapons from, whilst they're invading their neighbouring country .....so are you suggesting that the indian govt is secretly pro communist and therefore anti-national themselves?
I am hopeful that the new laws will effectively address the issue of vague or ambiguous language, which can lead to misinterpretation and potential misuse. It is crucial for the legal framework to provide clear distinctions between lawful and unlawful actions, while also establishing well-defined rights for citizens, including those accused of crimes, and reinforcing the principle of "innocent until proven guilty." Additionally, I anticipate the implementation of comprehensive regulations governing the behavior of public servants, especially those in authoritative roles such as the police, ensuring proper treatment of individuals, whether they are accused parties or criminals. Concurrently, it is important to offer necessary protections for individual police officers who take lawful actions, safeguarding them from harm and granting them the authority to use proportionate force including lethal for self-defense and protection of others, thereby facilitating the much-needed professionalization of both the police force and the legal system.
I like the new laws much more clear defination with solid action.
Again good step by Modi Sarkar❤❤❤
Commendable work by both Modi-Shah duo and Shekhar Gupta Ji.... one formed the changes and other made us understand those changes best.
This is really commendable judicial reform. I understand you have highlighted a small portion of it.. thank you for doing that in great detail. Looking forward to understanding more of the changes. Congratulations to the government and everyone involved!
Thanks SG Sir, for excellent analysis 🙏
Hope NDA next brings in UCC ....long overdue. "Equal law for all".
Dont worry everything will be fulfilled, press Kamal again in 2024 to establish Hindurashtra
Just one word for this Government, THANK YOU. And Mr. Shekhar sir, Thanks for elaborating it so well.
This reform is very positive. In fact the section 4 quote can probably also be used against the "sar tan se judah" mobs. This is why I will vote for Modi. The only issue I see is of proportionality. While a terrorist act should be punished with life imprisonment or death, what Sharjeel Imam did needs to have a more proportionate punishment. Maybe this thought is already there in the reform.
that is for the courts to decide. Laws don't have doctrine of proportionality, judgements should have that - that is why there are always ranges of minimum and maximum punishment.
The "sar tan se judah" is pure hate speech & terrorism!! What Sharjeel Imam said too is about the same kind!!
Shekhar ji, as always, showing his true secular colours by defending Sharjeel. Chor chori se jaye par hera-pheri se na jaaye. 😊
Great work done here by the NDA - well done 👍✅
if you think about it, all these issues could have been the focus on opposition, but they didn't bother. now bjp itself is fixing yet another big issue. they are doing the job of opposition better than them. kudos bjp. brilliant moves to fix the legal system.
Excellent changes to the laws ! Amith Shah has delivered
FINALLY SOMETHING IS BEING DONE IN THE PARLIAMENT. AFTER INDEPENDENCE. 😢
bro , you look like just born. 😆 Much more has been done in parliament before you were born. Dont worry.
This is what happens when uneducated get access to cheap internet
@@Valkyri3Zdon't you feel these bills will drastically change the basis of punishment, or you just a govt hating bot
@@Valkyri3Z I would wish military Rule in india rather than to see Rahul Gandhi As Prime minister.
Finally performing govt is in place.
So called protector of democracy( Congressi) ... Never repealed this laws...
Neither did they repeal 370 😢
46' election result ---mosslim constituency ( Bombay Province 100% seat goes to M. League, Madras Province 100%, Bengal 95%, Assam 91%, Orissa 100%, Central Province 93% so on & so on ...) still this librandu congress did not do popul. xchange. ......... plus kkuffar desh main rehna & secularism is hharram in iislamb ( kkuran 4.97) inko bolo apna iislamb follow kare aur nikle bharat se..
Gand b bjp se marwalo tab😂
They were busy counting money. Time Kahan tha to do these silly things?
Congress does not care about democracy nor do BJP
Nor the supreme court of India
Nor the beurocrats of India.
Nor the people of India. They care about democracy when there ass is on fire.
Please do a CTC or National Interest on the new bill for selecting the Chief Election Commissioner
One area i feel is that while the fines are defined, these should be minimum fine hut the maximum sjould be based on the persons wealth level.
While time is same for everyone. The monetary amount chnages for the person and time.
You haven't begun deal with the illegal drug problem. Don't worry it coming. The more successful you are the more illegal drugs will flood the Indian homeland because now Indians have money.
Yeah, rich can get away with small fine but for poor it's too much.
"Justice delayed is justice denied, the never ending court procedures should be time bound. Faster justice should be done in cases involving politico-criminal nexus. Rioters should be given the strictest punishment in a timely manner. Judges who are involved in any wrong doings should be punished in "army style".
Yes .
Not just faster justice but faster administration..
No long delays
Wait and watch we will have hindu courts working by our religious laws, justice will be quick
When Judges are involved, then their punishment should be double!!
Was waiting for this till now!!!
And also for DK, may be tomorrow!!! And for Apurva - may be few more days!!!
Paisa vasool (got value for money)
Thank you for this overview and insight on the subject.
High poverty states in India are also states with least English penetration.
Bihar, Jharkhand, Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Assam, Chattisgarh, Odisha, Rajasthan, West Bengal, Gujarat.
Promoting Hindi over English is counter-productive(self-defeating) to a country like India🇮🇳
It's a result of focussing on services without a manufacturing base. Most of East Asia progressed without learning English. An internal link language is a must.
Correlation is not causation ret@rd
The reason is not language but centuries of loot in the northern areas and post independence most of the critical infra came in southern states because of distance from border areas
@@rutvikrs Let internal link language be English. South India is already comfortable with English. The Hindi belt should catch up. Otherwise we'll go ahead. What should I do if feel alienated by the govt with their support for one type of culture, language, religion?
@@adityaaima3302 Language is not the only factor. But anyday, learning English is much better than Hindi. English opens up MASSIVE, Hindi won't even come close. A fellow who wants to do engineering or MBA or medicine.. English would help you much more than Hindi in this digitalised era dominated by Internet.
This is such an essential and progressive initiative taken by the government. Kudos!
Kudos to HM + PM for overhauling ancient laws
New law is more draconic... what dont you understand... maybe try to hear it again...
🤭😂😂😂
🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮
@@bonaku20only hateful idiots like you can take it as such. 😂😂
@@bonaku20 for deshdrohis and for rahul who keeps on insulting india in foreigh lands.
Earlier sedition under 124 had 3 year imprisonment now in section 150 as subversive activity ( synonym in Oxford dictionary is sedition) have life imprisonment.
Mob lynching sentence reduced from life imprisonment or death to 7 yrs -life imprisonment.
Finally
A ray of hope against the terror of Taarikh p Taarikh
Yes i know implementation matters too, but just the proposal means there's a hope.
The future is looking bright
Only modi Shah can do this i salute you both... Jai bharat jai hind
Good decision by the government
Thank you for explaining like a legal professional the new amendments
You have not covered the multiple provisions that ensure faster and easier delivery of justice:
Filing zero FIR anywhere in India,
zero FIR must have section number,
video conference hearing (no need to travel to the HCs/SC)
video and other electronic evidence to be admitted in courts,
all cases to be disposed within 3 years (no endless adjournments),
full digitization of court data,
extension of court case to be justified in writing, etc.
This is vintage Shekhar. Well studied, coherent and clear in explaining!!😅
Sometimes I feel just because you are 'committed' to airing this CTC everyday you look for 'some' topic or the other, maybe at the last minute and then your programme becomes boring. Because you then you stutter and fumble, repeat things and so on.
This is really good. And I'm looking forward to the forthcoming 'cutting of clutter' on this subject.👏👏👏
It wasn't Indian Penal Code but Irish Penal Code which the brits used to punish the Irish people inhumanly. And the congress rule continued to use the same to punish we Indians!
The content of new IPC and old IPC is 98% same.
I u run the two laws through a plagiarism software u will be amazed .
@@offred6013 That 2% is what judicial system use as loophole to set their favored people free.
@@marshalLannes1769 have u read the law. Have u seen how those laws r used in courts of law.
Do u know exactly which provision of that 2% is misused ?
@hulagukhan-we3fw read both and compare. Simple.
Also simplification of procedure is something which has not been done in these laws.
@@offred6013 Have you?
Are you saying Indian laws and judicial system is best in the world? No change is required? This 3rd grade judicial system needs an complete re construction. And yes, these laws are a start but not sufficient,
This is why I like print...such a good explanation ❤
Superb changes in the Law . Now the government should implement it and Courts should be aligned to the changes as in India , Most of powerful people in judiciary are against the Nationalism and Country .
Unfortunately, sometimes criminals are in charge of making laws. Devil is in the details.
Yes, British were criminals from Indian perspective. So you are right in that context.
Abe hatt Khangressi pille
What about misuse of section 498A which deals with dowry related crimes. This is highly misused by the wife side
All laws are misused. The only way to fix it or ease the pain would be to make the police system more liberal.
Feel very sorry for you
Thanks for the insights sir !
Excellent description. Thanks.
This is absolutely awesome! All
The scum bags will be in trouble
Except for the ones in the ruling party who'll get away with all their crimes absolutely scot free...2 tiered justice system.
@@poo-tinthedwarfbunkerb1tch535 that is no different than last 75 years , but atleast tukday tukday gangs will be answerable and 309 and 377 are gone which were archaic . Any positive change also is negative to most biased minds unfortunately.
@@ank337 i'm not exactly sure what positives can come out of criminals ruling the country introducing so called reforms ( which btw are mostly just name changes to make them sound more sanskaari and brainwash blind bhakts like you into thinking they're making real changes) to "protect their own". but whatever makes you sleep at night i guess. Let's see whether you still support them when they eventually come for you and your family.
Pappu's fans will come here complaining about this as well
AIMIM too 😂.
Sharia criminal law for Muslims 😂😂
46' election result ---mosslim constituency ( Bombay Province 100% seat goes to M. League, Madras Province 100%, Bengal 95%, Assam 91%, Orissa 100%, Central Province 93% so on & so on ...) still this librandu congress did not do popul. xchange. .
Better late than never. These were long-awaited reforms. Game over for Tukde Tukde Gang.
Thank you Shekharji. We depend on you for summery of such a important step. Just wanted to know if you think it it a step in a way of common civil code anyway??
Do you think change in criminal law will follow civil law? The idea of fixing the law before it applies to similarly to all .
Thank you, Ritesh, I'm glad you liked this episode. The rest is speculation at the moment, so there isn't much point getting into it. Do keep watching and writing in...best wishes, Shekhar
You are doing good work..... impressive
love from west bengal
IPC was framed by none other than Thomas Babington Macaulay 😉 the same guy who design Indian education system to produce coolies and loyal subjects for the Raj.
And.. Don't forget the history books made to produce permanent slaves that Congress/allies have promoted & BJP has yet! to radically reform & transform!!
True 😢😕🥺
Does 'Print' hate Modi govt? When I first read the title, it gave me a wrong impression.
That's becoz to attract people from the left Wing & give them information from Right wing perspective.
Just algorithm things
Chinese funded media
it's not about hate or love .....no journalist should love or hate any government but their job is to critically analyse every thing the government is doing.
Yes..SG is a khangress supporter
Very well narrated and explained, beautiful ❤
In addition to my earlier comment applauding the reforms presented here, another thought comes to my mind. Democracies outside of India have not had the kind of diversity of population that India has. Now, with mass immigration and movement of people, other countries are facing the challenges of managing multi ethnicity, multi religious and even multi-patriotic sensibilities among their populations.. resulting in challenges/situations of a unique kind. India can light the path in how to effectively and responsibly address these situations. We borrow, adopt and adapt in technology, entrepreneurship, scientific arenas from the world; this can be a very valuable’giving back’ :)
You explain so well, thank u, u could hve been a bit magnanimous to d present govt, these laws were needed frm eternity 👍
Mr Gupta’s loyalty remains with the powers of yesteryears
On personal note thank you Shekhar sir this is nice and positive news with a touch of quality in journalism.
We need much strong laws against the crimes committed by women. Change dowry case that if proved false the lady gets mandatory minimum of 15 years.
Thanks Gupta Ji for an excellent summary as always
Give credit to BJP government especially modi vision.
Yes for making Manipur like Syria
@@honestyisthebestpolicy1680keep hating BJP will keep developing and mainstreaming North East.
And yes that means full integration with the mainland.
U got to revisit this video again
The new law seems to be progressive, bringing greater clarity. SG is Class as usual . 🙏🏽🙏🏽👍🏽
The wheelers dealers who directly or indirectly supported terrorism, treason and undermining the country exploiting the loopholes of loosely defined laws and the most expensive lawyers magically at their disposal are finally tackled. Must be a sad day for whom it was good business...
as always great analysis and we welcome reforms in law❤
Why unpronounceable Hindi names for every central scheme, proposal, law, etc.? This further alienates those who don't speak or understand Hindi. At least, have a parallel English names for all these.
Why english names ? You can an alternate names in tamil.
@@subham.biswas Sure. Take turns naming in different indian languages. Let those speaking only Hindi get exposed to other languages.
When original name were in english they were translated into hindi and other indian languages. Same will happen here.
And in my opinion these will be known as NEW ipc, crpc & evidence act in popular imagination rather then these hindi names.
मीडिया को भी रिस्पांसिबल बनाना चाहिए।
We need stricter punishment in rash driving causing death😢
Also for people crossing road out of no where without any zebra crossing and then blaming car drivers. And those driving wrong side.
Would be eagerly waiting for more on this with the trademark SG flair and clarity. Such a transformational step.
Happy to see these amendments, Thq for noticing and making corrections to protect our country.
Great analysis. Thanks so much!!!
Probably biggest reform of this term of modi govt lot of key laws to be amended when these bill come out of select committe, very news channel covered these, good job by sg and print and more clarity will be given by Apoorva video
but implementation of CAA NRC &
Uniform Civil code is still pending
by BJP govt.
यह एक अच्छी पहल है पुराने कानून अंग्रेजों द्वारा बनाए गए थे हम राष्ट्र भक्त लोगों पर अन्याय करने के लिए ताकि उनकी दादागिरी के विरोध में कोई आवाज ना उठा सकें।
@@Kang.31 See what sT status did in manipur. What do you think UCC and NRC will do in whole india ? These will take time. Probably will be done in 3rd term.
शेखर जैसे पत्रकारों केलिए भी कड़े से डी कड़े कानून होने चाहिए जो देश और हिंदू विरोधी क्रियाओं में संलिप्त ही ।
Good work and depth analysis. That’s why I am here…
Kudos to Government wonderful job …JNU leftists and Jamia Islamists will have to attend English class in search of vocabulary before hitting street on the drop of an hat 😂 Aur ek Naya zakam - Arfa Khanumm
my respect for this govt is increasing day by day.
As always excellent analysis
This govt has been doing some tremendous work and genuinely trying hard to take India forward. However, there is a fundamental attitude problem with most Indians. They dont respect the law and order and are more of a mobocracy. The less said about law enforcement agencies, the better. Hope this mentality changes in the next 2-3 generations as India develops more and more.