EXACTLY!! i was just about to comment this same thing. they know the game better than anyone lol then try to play victim it’s so pathetic they have the facilities to not even need to run their own accounts. it really is so annoying
Unfortunately the only people that ever had true responsibility in protecting Justin are the only people he likely won't ever get rid of - his parents.
@@v25467 the video that said people made assumptions based on lyrics & then both Justin & Hailey debunked that anything negative was going on between them? … yea we watched it, which is why she said what is there to fix?
Hailey needs to stop acting like she and Justin are the perfect couple she keeps making them out to be. Then want to get mad when people post evidence online that there's trouble in paradise.
Hate to tell you, but she’s right. Anybody worrying about speculating on celeb posts is not well. People need to stop worrying so much about reading into the lives of those they will never even be in the same room as.
I feel like now all the diddy stuff is coming out (i feel like some stuff definitely went down there), Justin is now feeling he can cut ALL of the other people out of his life that never truly had his best interests in mind (those who only cared about the money/fame/influence connected with justins name). Definitely not a fan of justin but i do hope he finally finds some peace in his life.
@MariaEsparza-kc6ni no, that's not what I meant at all, please don't try to put words in my mouth. I think it's also somewhat narrow minded to assume he no longer has black friends from the snippet of his life you see online.
I like how you at least said POSSIBLE post partum (there’s people in the comments that are acting like they know for a fact that she has post partum and I find that really weird) also people giving me crap for what I said obviously I don’t know what having PPD is like because I’ve never had a BABY before but just because I said I think she should be spending time with her baby (especially on Christmas) the d-rider fans got mad at me for saying this 🤦🏻♀️
Sad because Justin is clearly very mentally unstable. And now she has to deal with that AND potential postpartum and a new baby. I would absolutely crumble
She isn't the only one making weird posts it's both her and Justin. I'm not saying she doesn't have PPD, but I don't understand how chalking this ridiculous "drama" up to PPD makes as much sense. She's always been like this and done stuff like this with posting cryptic nonsense on social and then acting like everyone is "unwell" and making stuff up when people justifiably read into her posts. It always feels like a desperate attempt for some attention or relevance. Same shite, different day.
Same. My son was an awful sleeper and never slept more than 30 minutes at a time. I was legit losing it. I waited until I was 33 to have a baby because I knew it was going to be hard, and I was still losing my mind after he was born. It's hard to convey in words how challenging it is, you just have to experience it and find out yourself.
Not going to even try to pretend I know what actually happens behind closed doors with these two, but their "fights" give high school. Like that one couple that fights and get cryptic online to get attention/dunk on their partner, but as soon as they work it out act like nothing is wrong and their partner is nothing short of perfect.
@Lulu Garcia Navarro’s Tweet after interviewing Selena for NPR interview in 2020: «Selena: He (Justin) was no longer delighted with us. (Their former relationship)»
@@sydneyelise7260 Selena for Spotify interview in 2020: “What’s your favorite thing of this album?” Selena: «I was vulnerable. I was honest. I found my sound and my comfortable place. *After a person broke up with me* i was able to realize a lot of things, and I just wrote songs about it. I wrote songs about having fun and cutting that person out of my life. This is an album is about me.»
i may be chronically online but at least im not "telling everyone about the instability of my relationship through vagueposting lyrics on my IG story" bad
SZA came out with a new album, Hailey is a fan of her music. If you think Hailey showing love to SZA’s song is a “cryptic post” then you are indeed not well. Touch grass
What unresolved problems do they have? Did they tell you something or are you obsessed with the idea of them being unhappy because you want him to get back with his ex?🤭🤭
@@spectre9340 Showing love to artists and their music, reposting a funny/cute video from a meme channel is being messy as teenagers, Indeed. You’re right!
the thing is: she's been doing shit like this for YEARSSSSSS, and she always plays the victim in the end. she also always post things about her brands after she goes insane on stories.... she knows what she's doing. she's not stupid, just awful
She creates drama with her child and her husband just to turn around and sell rancid lip oils to Bieber fans. I’m not even a Bieber fan girlie but I still feel bad for the way she exploits his fans. She knows they will look at her IG and dissect everything because they want info on Justin, so she does this in an attempt to get people to notice her. It’s sad really. It’s giving high school mean girl. She’s a wife and a mother now, she could at least pretend to be more mature
i think he relapsed on drugs and the media is trying to pin it on her when it’s him. he is an addict and she most likely took the kid away and went away
He literally wrote an unreleased song called can't stand it .. he talks about her using psychology to manipulate him. Wonder why that didn't make the album lol .. she defos told him not to release it. It's out there though .. go listen
@@TheAlicesmithxo That song is old and it is unknown when the song was written. It could be about his ex girlfriend because it describes her really well. Her exes said the same thing about her soo😜😜
@RespectJustinsDecisions Why are under every comment section 😂😂 justin is a narcissistic person and his wife is a stalker nepo baby Selena is much better than them at least she grew up but this couple had a baby and still acting like a teenager
i never feel sorry for hailey , like her fangirl obsession with justin is insane , there's a great yt channel that collected crazy details , like how hailey tracked jb's hotel he'd stay in , and rented the rooms and pretended to just coincidentally be there as well, booked the same restaurants , and forced herslef onto parties he'd perform on , mind you she was a teen craze , you would think growing up you would feel so cringe that if anyone mentionne JB she would be like oh no he was a crush and damn i was obsessed let's move on , well nope she continued her tracking even when the guy was with selena and later richie girl and idk who , she was always lurking , and now she's complaining ? complaining that the MASSIVE WORLD WIDE superstar that got into scandals and huge childhood trauma is scared to have his kid face bullying or media obsession for being jb's kid (see how zayn and gigi tried to hide their daughter from paparazzi but failed over and over , they paid million of dollars to not have their daughters image released yet its online ) like is it not normal for Justin to be scared for his kid's safety and future since he's way more famous than zayn and gigi combined
@abbied I believe theyre talking about Internet Oddities video because they did go in depth and they also posted dates on everything so you can kinda feel Haley's very eerie behavior
i’m not super caught up in all this but i had no idea haley was his fan… that’s uncomfortable and i honestly feel bad for justin for everything he has been through. i hope he gets all the help he needs
Scooter Braun needs investigating. Way before we all knew about Diddy etc. I remember seeing Scooter talk about how he took a very young Justin on tour working, doing concerts. I wondered where Justins parents where. Scooter said he was the one to introduce Justin to Usher. Just the way Scooter spoke about Justin made me fee unsettled, at the time. Now, with all we know. Well.
@@dariasdouble212exactly he had so many people drop him in such a short period of time, I have been thinking he may be under federal investigation but recently I have seen him in pictures with Jeff Bezos which also gives me red flags
Hailey and Justin have a love and hate relationship. Very childish, she is trying to stay relevant and he also is looking for attention. Then they act like is their fans fault to try to understand what is going on. Very childish.
All I can think is that he is actually getting away, he's making it out of the mess of hollywood alive. Britney and so many others deserved the same. I'm happy for him.
@@bb.yani1 Yes, and that was Selena and Justin’s relationship. Justin himself said he’s at peace for the first time in his life and that Hailey is the best thing that ever happened to him.
@RespectJustinsDecisions oh really? The best thing and they are having relationship problems??? Bro thought having a baby with a stalker fan would heal his depression 🤣.
On another note I've unfortunately heard many parents say they wish they didnt have a child(ren). Big names i can think of right now, Ruby Franke said it, Colleen Ballinger has said it, people in mom groups, my mother On another note we can tell when you dont like having children. Stop having kids just because you can or you feel like its what youre supposed to do. Its a profession that unfortunately every one can apply for.
Oh yes. I saw that tweet and thought "really? Never? NEVER?" because as far as I'm aware a lot of parents have at least a brief period of regret/questioning. Not to mention those who genuinely wish they could go back and do things differently
@@wakeupcecil I really hope he didn't say that about Justin who might have told him his feelings in confidence, to isolate him even further after getting married to someone he barely knew and everything he's been through up to this point though. It always looked like he was a bit trapped as a child and as an adult.
@@yea0000 I’m subscribed to this channel and it popped up on my feed (more importantly I can do whatever I want) shouldn’t you be taking care of your baby instead of arguing with people in the comments Hailey? 🤡
@@abbied because her current routine was causing her stress and she needed a few days away. I love my work but if work was causing me to be depressed i would take a few days away to recenter.
I wish Justin would go for an agnostic approach. I'm afraid that extreme religiosity is just a mask to cover up facing the harsh reality that those closest to him betrayed him.
His extreme religiosity is because *drumroll* he's religious! If you truly believe in the gospel, you don't just choose to take "an agnostic approach". Religion is not a hobby you pick and drop when you feel like it. He's been super religious since he was a kid. His faith is not stopping him from realising betrayal of people around him. It's in fact helped him cope with the constant problems in his life. I have strong doubts Justin would still be here and still be trying if he didn't have his faith.
@@Nicole-kc1vx I'm not reading any of that. We all know premarital smex, binge drinking, drugs, tattoos, and ghey smex is not Christian LOL! Justin should explore more science-based information on what he's going through because he clearly is struggling with the Xstian, spaghetti monster stuff, especially with the Xstian rpiest chyld SA scandals against.... boys. So...
I'm not reading any of that. We all know premarital smex, binge drinking, drugs, tattoos, and ghey smex is not x-stian LOL! Justin should explore more science-based information on what he's going through because he clearly is struggling with the x-stian, spaghetti monster stuff, especially with the xstian rpiest chyld SA scandals against.... boys. So...
I'm not reading any of that. We all know premarital smex, binge drinking, druhgs, tattoos, and ghey smex is not Christian LOL! Justin should explore more science-based information on what he's going through because he clearly is struggling with the Xstian, spaghetti monster stuff, especially with the Xstian rpiest chyld SA scandals against.... boys. So...
I will be soooo happy when I can open UA-cam, TikTok, or any social media and NOT see/hear anything about Hailey Bieber or Michaela Nogueira. Can’t stand either of them 🤮
I feel second hand embarrassment every time I see a grown ass celebrity sub posting on their stories… it’s something I admit to doing in middle school and high school, but jeeez even I realized it’s like low key embarrassing, especially if you start posting again with the person you’re always subbing; stop showing the world your drama and everything you have going on , some things are meant to be private and protected and when they’re not they fail.
i wonder if Hailey/Justin is going through some unresolved postpartum depression and maybe this is why things are coming out the way they are… just food for thought. (and yes postpartum depression also affects men.)
the thing is: she's been doing shit like this for YEARSSSSSS, and she always play the victim in the end. she also always post things about her brands after she goes insane on stories.... she knows what she's doing. she's not stupid, just awful
he most likely relapsed on drugs. he’s a former addict and relapse will happen and cause consequences w/ his relationship. him being depressed has nothing to do w her. he thought she would change him since she lives this sober and healthy lifestyle. temporarily yes but he relapsed
these people have been messy online from the beginning. i’m so over their digital gaslighting by posting cryptic things that they know people will speculate on and then call people crazy
What I think is wild is their wedding video didn’t seem genuine at all! It felt forced and emotionless. They act like they’re the perfect couple but I think there’s a lot of toxicity behind closed doors..
He said it was an arranged marriage on the Ellen show when Demi Lovato interviewed him on there (it was a few years ago, but you can look it up on here)
@@Mewsette1 I didn’t say he was a child when he said this though did I? (I’m confused as to why you said “He was an adult” there) because I already knew that
@@saiyamoru Well I actually heard that he does go to therapy (but can’t confirm for sure whether or not it’s true without a doubt) I myself am in therapy and have been since I was a child but it can be a little difficult finding the right therapist sometimes (I don’t know if, with his wife being his handler that he can get help) he’s a puppet in the music industry whose controlled by many people and has been for a long time. I hope he can get a divorce (seeing as, this would probably help his case) but I don’t know how this all works because even if he divorces his wife he would probably just be assigned a new handler. Long story short, fame and money aren’t worth all of these things
@@saiyamoru I hope you can understand my comment and don’t think I’m kooky for saying these things (yes, I believe in these things and that they’re real) but to your point therapy would be a good option for him if he hasn’t already sought out help professionally
@@abbied Yeah, if you're a child star I think everyone knows that you should be seeing mental health experts throughout that experience. My point is more that he's had plenty of time to see the problems, seek help, and correct the behavior. The public has generally given Justin a lot of slack because we know it's hard to grow up like that, but when does it end? Is ten years of getting to act like a frat boy freshman enough for him to get it out of his system or are we going to make it 20? I agree that this divorce will probably be good for both of them. Justin's 'brand image' never matched Hailey's and some of the disrespect he's shown her should have been grounds for separation years ago.
Not to be a theorist but it was proven that Hailey had stalked him for years before they got married. She’s not a very safe or mentally stable person in my opinion
okay pookie i may not be well...but the dots were just dotting and we all thought it was kind of suspicious that a couple...that is married were posting lyrics of songs that basically related to each other in a "battle" format... I mean do I wish you + justin well? Yes. But you can't tell me you don't understand where we all got our thinking lol.
I mean it’s their fault. If you don’t want people thinking something’s wrong, don’t post stuff that makes it look like something is wrong. I don’t see Keanu doing this to his girlfriend Alexandra Grant, I don’t see Kurt Russell doing this to his gf/basically wife Goldie Hawn, I don’t see Matthew McConaughey doing this to his wife Camila Alves, I don’t see Ryan Gosling doing this to his wife Eva Mendes and these are some of the most beloved and long lasting couples in Hollywood. Shit even though they divorced, and I’m not a Kat-Jenner fan, we can call a spade a spade and can honestly say Kim was good wife in defending her husband Kayne against the public; Kim was defending Kayne and standing by his side during his sideshow shit when she very easily could have been “subliminally” blasting him- which as a Kardashian could have easily made her money if she went the opposite route, so it’s surprising she didn’t do that. Ok you can argue those are all different generations of people and are much older but the point still stands. I don’t see Tom and Zendaya doing this to eachother and I don’t see Selena and Benny doing this to eachother who are young same age, if not younger, than Justin and Hailey. Act and be couple and people won’t question if you guys are actually a couple. It’s not rocket science.
Idk what's going on but it doesnt surprise me if things are complicated right now because the whole Diddy situation came out right around the time they had their first child (i think it was like a few days after or something). It's hard enough to face possible past trauma, then to do it under the public eye and while you're raising a newborn. I definitely expected it to affect Justin and therefore Hailey, as well.
I don’t know if these post have multiple meanings or not but if you post cryptic messages on your story rather that talking to your partner is actually wild
Um, Hailey stalked Justin for years. So...any super fans out there, don't stalk famous people because believe it or not, the relationship will never live up to your expectations and fantasies. Of course they're having trouble...and if Hailey is experiencing PPD, I really hope she has help
I dunno man, they are married for about ten years. People, especially young ones don't stay to endure a relathionship for such a long time if it's bad. I think this is keeping them relevant while they have nothing to present as businesses 🤷🏻♀️
Are they literal kids go talk to each other rather than posting on social media personal life matters they literally have a child together I feel sorry for the baby not them because they are literal definition of drama
Hayley and Justin are just making fun of all those people who constantly look for news about their private life, which is not public... In their place I would do the same, I would publish a song or a phrase and I would watch what happens. And while most believe there is a crisis, a divorce, etc. etc., they live their private life. And I'm not a fan of them, but that's what I think about
Kind of reminds me of how people can get real messy on Facebook and sometimes you just want to post something impulsively but maybe they should have just done it on their finstas
The more people hate on their relationship, the more they thrive. They are not going to get a divorce. Their marriage is built around god and faith. They've been married for 6 years now. One of the most stable couples in Hollywood. They had the wedding when they wanted to. They got pregnant when they wanted to. They don't care about the outside noise and I'm glad about that. Hailey is Justin's rock. They have a beautiful family. ❤
Obviously, I don't know them at all, but Justin posting that coparenting is failing feels to me like some christians that believe under no circumstances should people ever divorce and his dad posting that no one has ever regretted having children feels like he is trying to say something against abortion or people nowadays not wanting to have children and wanting to live differently. Fans interpreting these posts as cryptic messages about their relationship and not religious and political messages seems weirder to me.
Wait isn't justin buying stupid rings? 20 million dollar mansions? Who is spending money himself and his money hungry wife... keep an eye out for that wife
yall are so desperate honestly... why do you all want them to divorce? and also u don't know them personaly so how can you know whats going on in their marriage? also hailey probaby just posted that song cuz she liked it yall need to grow up and start acting like adults instead of being so investend in this celebrities yall are acting like little teenage girls
The real tea is Lou Taylor's name mentioned in Britney Spears's conservatorship, pdd's horrendous case, and potentially mismanaging Justin's finance. Oh, sure, she absolutely doesn't have any involvement. It's just pure coincidence that her and her company keep being mentioned. Sure.
I hate when celebs do f*ck sh*t like this on social media and then turn around and not only gaslight everyone but act as if everyone is being stupid…
It feels like they totally do that when they run out of relevance
EXACTLY!! i was just about to comment this same thing. they know the game better than anyone lol then try to play victim it’s so pathetic they have the facilities to not even need to run their own accounts. it really is so annoying
They’re annoying asf
ESPECIALLY coming from Hailey Bieber
They’ve all become irrelevant because social media finally revealed to everyone that celebs are JUST PEOPLE and need to be taken off pedestals.
I hope he is getting rid of everyone who didn't protect him
👏
tbh i wish justin was this aware and woke
Yeah, like his evil mama, who let him go with these awful people when he was underage.
Agreed ❤
Unfortunately the only people that ever had true responsibility in protecting Justin are the only people he likely won't ever get rid of - his parents.
Are they children. They’re in the same house. Get off the phone and talk to each other. God help their offspring.
He was away they were not together
@@pandabearmycat5206 did the voices in your head tell you that? Did you forgot to take your meds again?
Are you a child to believe everything you see online???
They both barely have a high school education
She was on vacation with her girl friends during this time.
It’s almost like babies don’t fix relationships
Who said that there was something to fix?
@ I would think their weird ass passive aggressive posts would be a big hint but that’s just me
@@anniewalkamay’all were the one who made assumptions over song lyrics 😂😂😂 they’ve been married for almost a decade , let them be. It’s so weird
@@katekadkina9312 did you not watch the video? It was a good one too😕
@@v25467 the video that said people made assumptions based on lyrics & then both Justin & Hailey debunked that anything negative was going on between them? … yea we watched it, which is why she said what is there to fix?
No haley posting "youre not well" to fans like guuuuuurl dont cryptic post on your story if you dont want speculations 😂😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣
Hahaha true.... And not her saying that when she stalked her way for years to get justin. We have not forgotten
Hailey needs to stop acting like she and Justin are the perfect couple she keeps making them out to be. Then want to get mad when people post evidence online that there's trouble in paradise.
If you think showing love to SZA’s new song is a cryptic post then you are indeed not well 🫶🏻
Hate to tell you, but she’s right. Anybody worrying about speculating on celeb posts is not well. People need to stop worrying so much about reading into the lives of those they will never even be in the same room as.
I feel like now all the diddy stuff is coming out (i feel like some stuff definitely went down there), Justin is now feeling he can cut ALL of the other people out of his life that never truly had his best interests in mind (those who only cared about the money/fame/influence connected with justins name). Definitely not a fan of justin but i do hope he finally finds some peace in his life.
You mean all the black people who were friends with him. Because since HB he doesn't have black friends anymore.
@@MariaEsparza-kc6ni can't help making this about race🙄 plenty of black people don't have white friends.
@MariaEsparza-kc6ni no, that's not what I meant at all, please don't try to put words in my mouth. I think it's also somewhat narrow minded to assume he no longer has black friends from the snippet of his life you see online.
Her: possible post partum
Him: Diddy news, past trauma etc
The fam may need therapy
This right here
I like how you at least said POSSIBLE post partum (there’s people in the comments that are acting like they know for a fact that she has post partum and I find that really weird) also people giving me crap for what I said obviously I don’t know what having PPD is like because I’ve never had a BABY before but just because I said I think she should be spending time with her baby (especially on Christmas) the d-rider fans got mad at me for saying this 🤦🏻♀️
Her: Justin Bieber enjoying being groped Jaden smith
Becoming a new parent is hard as heck. Postpartum depression maybe? I felt insane for months
Sad because Justin is clearly very mentally unstable. And now she has to deal with that AND potential postpartum and a new baby.
I would absolutely crumble
Great point! I feel bad they are going threw so much plus the baby they need to take time and just be normal
She isn't the only one making weird posts it's both her and Justin. I'm not saying she doesn't have PPD, but I don't understand how chalking this ridiculous "drama" up to PPD makes as much sense. She's always been like this and done stuff like this with posting cryptic nonsense on social and then acting like everyone is "unwell" and making stuff up when people justifiably read into her posts. It always feels like a desperate attempt for some attention or relevance. Same shite, different day.
Same. My son was an awful sleeper and never slept more than 30 minutes at a time. I was legit losing it. I waited until I was 33 to have a baby because I knew it was going to be hard, and I was still losing my mind after he was born. It's hard to convey in words how challenging it is, you just have to experience it and find out yourself.
@crazy_haze I took a lot out on my husband..he also had new baby depression. For some ppl it's just...hard
Not going to even try to pretend I know what actually happens behind closed doors with these two, but their "fights" give high school. Like that one couple that fights and get cryptic online to get attention/dunk on their partner, but as soon as they work it out act like nothing is wrong and their partner is nothing short of perfect.
Justin realized that Selena has moved on
@@katjaxxx7353 Justin was the first one to move on. He choose to move on from Selena by replacing her in 2 months in 2018 😛
@RespectJustinsDecisionsThat means nothing lol. She could’ve said she was done with him so he found a replacement. There’s no way to know.
@Lulu Garcia Navarro’s Tweet after interviewing Selena for NPR interview in 2020:
«Selena: He (Justin) was no longer delighted with us. (Their former relationship)»
@@sydneyelise7260 Selena for Spotify interview in 2020:
“What’s your favorite thing of this album?”
Selena: «I was vulnerable. I was honest. I found my sound and my comfortable place. *After a person broke up with me* i was able to realize a lot of things, and I just wrote songs about it. I wrote songs about having fun and cutting that person out of my life. This is an album is about me.»
i may be chronically online but at least im not "telling everyone about the instability of my relationship through vagueposting lyrics on my IG story" bad
SZA came out with a new album, Hailey is a fan of her music. If you think Hailey showing love to SZA’s song is a “cryptic post” then you are indeed not well. Touch grass
Or you know, people can just post songs they like
@@carrela1000 😂 yeah okay. She’s been doing it since she was a teen.
@@sydneyelise7260 You mean Hailey Bieber though?
@@sydneyelise7260 Doing what? Posting songs she likes? Yeah, so do a lot of teenagers today. Are you okay?
Please note…. A baby will not fix your relationship it will exasperate your unresolved problems.
So freaking true!!!
What unresolved problems do they have? Did they tell you something or are you obsessed with the idea of them being unhappy because you want him to get back with his ex?🤭🤭
Didn't watch the video then?
CORRECT!
Exacerbate, but yeah...THIS.
Take 👏 celebrities 👏 off 👏 pedestals 👏 They are literally just humans 🙄
they're as messy as teenagers going through their first breakup
it's so weird
@@spectre9340mentally they probably are teenagers. Celebrities brains just stop developing after they became famous.
@@spectre9340 Showing love to artists and their music, reposting a funny/cute video from a meme channel is being messy as teenagers, Indeed. You’re right!
Tbh that’s why I worry about Justin, he is a human who has been through too much during his teenage years and should be supported.
Tell them to take themselves off first by not posting speculations on the internet.
me: im not chronically online
me: uploaded 19 seconds ago
Same😭
real
Dude is just being forced to face his Diddy drama before he's ready & he's spiraling, that's all. Everyone leave him alone
thats what i thought too. ppl are most likely thinking into it too much 😭
“Eggs & Caviar” what in the reptilians is going on with these nepo babies
It makes me laugh though “look I put eggs on my eggs!” 😂
@@NikkiV. MY EXACT THOUGHT!💀😭 “so… eggs and fish eggs?”
She's sooo relatable 😂😂
Just rich people things 🥰 lol
Pin this comment right now 😂😂😂😂
I love how everyone is treating this dude like a little boy instead of the grown man that he is
I'm not saying it's right, but trauma tends to get you stuck in some mindsets that were present while the trauma occurred, aka present immaturity
I had a child the same year my partner came out about his child SA…… I just think this is a very difficult time for both of them.
I agree
the thing is: she's been doing shit like this for YEARSSSSSS, and she always plays the victim in the end. she also always post things about her brands after she goes insane on stories.... she knows what she's doing. she's not stupid, just awful
She creates drama with her child and her husband just to turn around and sell rancid lip oils to Bieber fans. I’m not even a Bieber fan girlie but I still feel bad for the way she exploits his fans. She knows they will look at her IG and dissect everything because they want info on Justin, so she does this in an attempt to get people to notice her. It’s sad really. It’s giving high school mean girl. She’s a wife and a mother now, she could at least pretend to be more mature
i think he relapsed on drugs and the media is trying to pin it on her when it’s him. he is an addict and she most likely took the kid away and went away
@@camillab8830 I dont think he ever stopped to be real
@@camillab8830 She wasn’t with the baby on Christmas sweetheart
@@abbied She was with her baby and her husband in Canada celebrating Christmas sweetheart
Hailey is the queen of gaslighting
He literally wrote an unreleased song called can't stand it .. he talks about her using psychology to manipulate him. Wonder why that didn't make the album lol .. she defos told him not to release it. It's out there though .. go listen
She's annoying 🤔🤔🤔
@@TheAlicesmithxo That song is old and it is unknown when the song was written. It could be about his ex girlfriend because it describes her really well. Her exes said the same thing about her soo😜😜
@RespectJustinsDecisions Why are under every comment section 😂😂 justin is a narcissistic person and his wife is a stalker nepo baby Selena is much better than them at least she grew up but this couple had a baby and still acting like a teenager
@RespectJustinsDecisionsthis is you heatly badlwiin!!!
Wtf. Eggs and caviar? Why i never...
yeah that looked NASTY lol
When you think about it that's just chicken eggs and fish eggs
That is very yummy and super healthy.
i never feel sorry for hailey , like her fangirl obsession with justin is insane , there's a great yt channel that collected crazy details , like how hailey tracked jb's hotel he'd stay in , and rented the rooms and pretended to just coincidentally be there as well, booked the same restaurants , and forced herslef onto parties he'd perform on , mind you she was a teen craze , you would think growing up you would feel so cringe that if anyone mentionne JB she would be like oh no he was a crush and damn i was obsessed let's move on , well nope she continued her tracking even when the guy was with selena and later richie girl and idk who , she was always lurking , and now she's complaining ? complaining that the MASSIVE WORLD WIDE superstar that got into scandals and huge childhood trauma is scared to have his kid face bullying or media obsession for being jb's kid (see how zayn and gigi tried to hide their daughter from paparazzi but failed over and over , they paid million of dollars to not have their daughters image released yet its online ) like is it not normal for Justin to be scared for his kid's safety and future since he's way more famous than zayn and gigi combined
Which YT channel is it? (Just asking) thank you
Well she being stalker and she is being pathetic person is different..still far better than Selena Gomez the manipulator,gaslighter
@abbied I believe theyre talking about Internet Oddities video because they did go in depth and they also posted dates on everything so you can kinda feel Haley's very eerie behavior
i’m not super caught up in all this but i had no idea haley was his fan… that’s uncomfortable and i honestly feel bad for justin for everything he has been through. i hope he gets all the help he needs
@ Thank you
Scooter Braun needs investigating. Way before we all knew about Diddy etc. I remember seeing Scooter talk about how he took a very young Justin on tour working, doing concerts. I wondered where Justins parents where. Scooter said he was the one to introduce Justin to Usher. Just the way Scooter spoke about Justin made me fee unsettled, at the time. Now, with all we know. Well.
It's the fact that the women under Scooter's management left years ago that gave me the first red flags. 👀
Exactly what I’m saying, scooter LEAD Justin to monsters and was more than old enough himself to see they were monsters.
@@dariasdouble212exactly he had so many people drop him in such a short period of time, I have been thinking he may be under federal investigation but recently I have seen him in pictures with Jeff Bezos which also gives me red flags
@brynndally9869 I sure hope he's being investigated! The man is an absolute creep.
@@brynndally9869 Omg, fr? 🙀
Hailey and Justin have a love and hate relationship. Very childish, she is trying to stay relevant and he also is looking for attention. Then they act like is their fans fault to try to understand what is going on. Very childish.
What’s going on is……………………… they’ve were enjoying songs from great artists!
Yeah but what else was gonna happen when a person marries their stalker
Where there’s smoke, there’s fire…
I think Justin unfollowing scooter means he’s separating from people linked to scooter also
I just dont like Haley....
Atp I don't think a lot of people like her
I can't stand her
My mom doesn't like her and she likes everyone
@@ferncruz4250lmao underrated comment
I'll alert the townspeople immediately!
All I can think is that he is actually getting away, he's making it out of the mess of hollywood alive. Britney and so many others deserved the same. I'm happy for him.
Yall something is OFF about hailey theres no way! I feel it now. I used to ship them. THERES DEFO SOMETHING GOING ON
People have been saying this for years, that's why everyone like Justin better with Selena
@@Aterriismystalker everyone? Their relationship wasn't better at all. Maybe he just needs to be alone atp
she stalked him for years before they got together
@eeebo3955 that's scary after no joke, obsession is no joke, I had an ex obsessive over me and I went to a lawyer
Thank you spill sesh perfect timing for my lunch break lol
when was the last time Hailey Bieber *wasn't* upset?
I don’t understand how she can leave her baby to go party on his FIRST Christmas… smh
Bc parents should have lives outside of their kids too
respectfully that baby not gonna remember it lmao
It’s literally insane 😭😭😭😭
@@abiStalli Yes he will!
@@abiStalli Babies are smarter than you think! (Hell, the baby’s probably smarter than her) 😂😂😂😂
Hailey is the one controlling justins ig
and he only wants Selena. Hailey was a re-bound
@@katjaxxx7353 If he wanted Selena why did he replace her in 2 months and left her miserable? 😂
@RespectJustinsDecisions toxic relationships exist.
@@bb.yani1 Yes, and that was Selena and Justin’s relationship. Justin himself said he’s at peace for the first time in his life and that Hailey is the best thing that ever happened to him.
@RespectJustinsDecisions oh really? The best thing and they are having relationship problems??? Bro thought having a baby with a stalker fan would heal his depression 🤣.
She’s mad she can’t control him.
On another note I've unfortunately heard many parents say they wish they didnt have a child(ren). Big names i can think of right now, Ruby Franke said it, Colleen Ballinger has said it, people in mom groups, my mother
On another note we can tell when you dont like having children.
Stop having kids just because you can or you feel like its what youre supposed to do. Its a profession that unfortunately every one can apply for.
Omg, thank you!
Oh yes. I saw that tweet and thought "really? Never? NEVER?" because as far as I'm aware a lot of parents have at least a brief period of regret/questioning. Not to mention those who genuinely wish they could go back and do things differently
@@wakeupcecil I really hope he didn't say that about Justin who might have told him his feelings in confidence, to isolate him even further after getting married to someone he barely knew and everything he's been through up to this point though. It always looked like he was a bit trapped as a child and as an adult.
@@Thatsokayiwaswrong You mean Justin though (right?)
It’s obvious from the beginning, if you didn’t start right sometime you will end up wrong
This is like an immature college relationship
More like high school 😂
Nobody does just argue in the privacy of their own living rooms like the good old days? 😂
Hailey really needs to focus on her baby.
Yes! She DOES
@@abbied you guys act like your with her all day everyday. you don’t know anything
@@abbiedlike what should you be focused on right now? def not this shit
@@yea0000 😂
@@yea0000 I’m subscribed to this channel and it popped up on my feed (more importantly I can do whatever I want) shouldn’t you be taking care of your baby instead of arguing with people in the comments Hailey? 🤡
Not the girl who stalked her way to a husband telling other people they’re “not well” 😂😂😂
Right like the projection is real 😭😭😭😭
Are we sure she doesn’t have post partum? The new baby could be effecting her mental health and putting relationship strains.
Also with everything happening to Diddy, I get why Justin would be mentally fragile right now .
@@abbied because her current routine was causing her stress and she needed a few days away. I love my work but if work was causing me to be depressed i would take a few days away to recenter.
Postpartum can cause you to feel disconnected from the baby and your spouse . To be fair I don’t have a lot of experience with this too lol
@@neilgallagher7923 I just think it’s sad for the baby tbh the baby deserves to be loved and know that he’s loved unconditionally 🤧💕
@@abbiedYou clearly know nothing about PPD.
Just in time for my lunch break 😋🩷
🙄half of the drama is due to u girls
I wish Justin would go for an agnostic approach. I'm afraid that extreme religiosity is just a mask to cover up facing the harsh reality that those closest to him betrayed him.
His extreme religiosity is because *drumroll* he's religious!
If you truly believe in the gospel, you don't just choose to take "an agnostic approach". Religion is not a hobby you pick and drop when you feel like it.
He's been super religious since he was a kid. His faith is not stopping him from realising betrayal of people around him. It's in fact helped him cope with the constant problems in his life. I have strong doubts Justin would still be here and still be trying if he didn't have his faith.
@@Nicole-kc1vx I'm not reading any of that. We all know premarital smex, binge drinking, drugs, tattoos, and ghey smex is not Christian LOL! Justin should explore more science-based information on what he's going through because he clearly is struggling with the Xstian, spaghetti monster stuff, especially with the Xstian rpiest chyld SA scandals against.... boys. So...
I'm not reading any of that. We all know premarital smex, binge drinking, drugs, tattoos, and ghey smex is not x-stian LOL! Justin should explore more science-based information on what he's going through because he clearly is struggling with the x-stian, spaghetti monster stuff, especially with the xstian rpiest chyld SA scandals against.... boys. So...
I'm not reading any of that. We all know premarital smex, binge drinking, druhgs, tattoos, and ghey smex is not Christian LOL! Justin should explore more science-based information on what he's going through because he clearly is struggling with the Xstian, spaghetti monster stuff, especially with the Xstian rpiest chyld SA scandals against.... boys. So...
Their relationship is bipolar
I think 2025 we should start minding our business because this is exhausting
I can’t believe he unfollowed the bodyguard! He’s been with him since the very beginning!!….
all of these sub posts makes me feel like I’m living in 2016 I can’t describe it
I will be soooo happy when I can open UA-cam, TikTok, or any social media and NOT see/hear anything about Hailey Bieber or Michaela Nogueira. Can’t stand either of them 🤮
If one of them said that about the baby, I hope that info doesn’t get back to the child when they’re older
The dumb butt dad posted it already so 😭
I feel second hand embarrassment every time I see a grown ass celebrity sub posting on their stories… it’s something I admit to doing in middle school and high school, but jeeez even I realized it’s like low key embarrassing, especially if you start posting again with the person you’re always subbing; stop showing the world your drama and everything you have going on , some things are meant to be private and protected and when they’re not they fail.
Amen
i wonder if Hailey/Justin is going through some unresolved postpartum depression and maybe this is why things are coming out the way they are… just food for thought. (and yes postpartum depression also affects men.)
Fr. Even through pregnancy hormones I had to relearn self-control and self-regulation
the thing is: she's been doing shit like this for YEARSSSSSS, and she always play the victim in the end. she also always post things about her brands after she goes insane on stories.... she knows what she's doing. she's not stupid, just awful
he was depressed far before the news of her being pregnant even came out
he most likely relapsed on drugs. he’s a former addict and relapse will happen and cause consequences w/ his relationship. him being depressed has nothing to do w her. he thought she would change him since she lives this sober and healthy lifestyle. temporarily yes but he relapsed
@@camillab8830 I read a comment that said he was going to rehab (I hope it’s true, but maybe it’s not) 😥🤧
these people have been messy online from the beginning. i’m so over their digital gaslighting by posting cryptic things that they know people will speculate on and then call people crazy
They were only posting reel and music lyrics you guys reach too much
What I think is wild is their wedding video didn’t seem genuine at all! It felt forced and emotionless. They act like they’re the perfect couple but I think there’s a lot of toxicity behind closed doors..
He said it was an arranged marriage on the Ellen show when Demi Lovato interviewed him on there (it was a few years ago, but you can look it up on here)
@abbied He was an adult. That is him saying he doesn't love her.
@@Mewsette1 ???? It’s pretty obvious he doesn’t actually love her
@@Mewsette1 I didn’t say he was a child when he said this though did I? (I’m confused as to why you said “He was an adult” there) because I already knew that
@@abbiedthis is true. He was paid a LOT of money to get with her.
Justin Bieber is not a good man and we could have made that call like 5 years ago minimum.
That’s kinda harsh he’s been through a lot bruh
@abbied He's 30. By his age everyone has 'been through a lot' and they are expected to seek therapy (which he can certainly afford) and work it out.
@@saiyamoru Well I actually heard that he does go to therapy (but can’t confirm for sure whether or not it’s true without a doubt) I myself am in therapy and have been since I was a child but it can be a little difficult finding the right therapist sometimes (I don’t know if, with his wife being his handler that he can get help) he’s a puppet in the music industry whose controlled by many people and has been for a long time. I hope he can get a divorce (seeing as, this would probably help his case) but I don’t know how this all works because even if he divorces his wife he would probably just be assigned a new handler. Long story short, fame and money aren’t worth all of these things
@@saiyamoru I hope you can understand my comment and don’t think I’m kooky for saying these things (yes, I believe in these things and that they’re real) but to your point therapy would be a good option for him if he hasn’t already sought out help professionally
@@abbied Yeah, if you're a child star I think everyone knows that you should be seeing mental health experts throughout that experience. My point is more that he's had plenty of time to see the problems, seek help, and correct the behavior. The public has generally given Justin a lot of slack because we know it's hard to grow up like that, but when does it end? Is ten years of getting to act like a frat boy freshman enough for him to get it out of his system or are we going to make it 20?
I agree that this divorce will probably be good for both of them. Justin's 'brand image' never matched Hailey's and some of the disrespect he's shown her should have been grounds for separation years ago.
Not to be a theorist but it was proven that Hailey had stalked him for years before they got married. She’s not a very safe or mentally stable person in my opinion
The late Kyle Marisa Roth nicknamed her “Swimfan Baldwin” (it’s after the movie Swimfan) 🤭🤭🤭🤭
okay pookie i may not be well...but the dots were just dotting and we all thought it was kind of suspicious that a couple...that is married were posting lyrics of songs that basically related to each other in a "battle" format... I mean do I wish you + justin well? Yes. But you can't tell me you don't understand where we all got our thinking lol.
"What do you mean?" Justin should apply his own song
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
‘His Swagger Coach’ - that is the WHITEST thing I have ever heard in my life
*fully goes to war for everyone to see*
Everyone: What
*surprise pikachu face*
Damn right in time for my lunch break 😅
I mean it’s their fault. If you don’t want people thinking something’s wrong, don’t post stuff that makes it look like something is wrong.
I don’t see Keanu doing this to his girlfriend Alexandra Grant, I don’t see Kurt Russell doing this to his gf/basically wife Goldie Hawn, I don’t see Matthew McConaughey doing this to his wife Camila Alves, I don’t see Ryan Gosling doing this to his wife Eva Mendes and these are some of the most beloved and long lasting couples in Hollywood. Shit even though they divorced, and I’m not a Kat-Jenner fan, we can call a spade a spade and can honestly say Kim was good wife in defending her husband Kayne against the public; Kim was defending Kayne and standing by his side during his sideshow shit when she very easily could have been “subliminally” blasting him- which as a Kardashian could have easily made her money if she went the opposite route, so it’s surprising she didn’t do that.
Ok you can argue those are all different generations of people and are much older but the point still stands. I don’t see Tom and Zendaya doing this to eachother and I don’t see Selena and Benny doing this to eachother who are young same age, if not younger, than Justin and Hailey.
Act and be couple and people won’t question if you guys are actually a couple. It’s not rocket science.
Idk what's going on but it doesnt surprise me if things are complicated right now because the whole Diddy situation came out right around the time they had their first child (i think it was like a few days after or something). It's hard enough to face possible past trauma, then to do it under the public eye and while you're raising a newborn. I definitely expected it to affect Justin and therefore Hailey, as well.
when will y’all just leave this couple alone? it’s so weird how many ppl are praying on their downfall.
People won't leave them alone if they make attention-seeking posts
Why does unfollowing and following someone matter so much lol crazy
People really look into that way too much its weird lol
Literally
Scooter is asking "is it too late to say sorry." and I'm here for it.
Eggs and caviar 😬
Eggs cost as much as caviar the two most expensive paired together wow she's just showing off how she spends Justin's money lol
I don’t know if these post have multiple meanings or not but if you post cryptic messages on your story rather that talking to your partner is actually wild
no way im this early!!! but ive been waiting for these topics
Can't really blame him with all the slip Diddy stuff, and fans always on his neck for bs.
😭 this popping up right after i seen ppl joking about him commenting on Chloe Bailey post. 😂
Justin?
@ yeah, he said something like “you snapped here” when she posted a pic and the comments I saw were laughing bc it seemed so random 😂
@@pinklatte4655 UA-cam is deleting my comments, but anyways thanks for the explanation 👍🏻👌🏻
Your videos are fantastic! Your modesty keeps me coming back.
Um, Hailey stalked Justin for years. So...any super fans out there, don't stalk famous people because believe it or not, the relationship will never live up to your expectations and fantasies. Of course they're having trouble...and if Hailey is experiencing PPD, I really hope she has help
Literally just had a dream about Justin the other day actually…crazy how this all popped up
I dunno man, they are married for about ten years. People, especially young ones don't stay to endure a relathionship for such a long time if it's bad. I think this is keeping them relevant while they have nothing to present as businesses 🤷🏻♀️
Super awesome! Your humility in success is noteworthy.
Him unfollowing all those peoples, I have to say it feels like it's connected to the diddy case, somehow some way
Y’all want something to be wrong with their relationship so bad , all these over done lyrics😂leave them alone
lets leave Justin Bieber and his family alone already GOTDAMN...... yall already gave him a hard time while he was growing up let that man live geez
…but why are you even here if not for the drama?
Goddamn?
Obviously I don’t personally know Justin or Haley, but please grow up. As a fan I love Justin.
But you both need to really grow Up!!
Are they literal kids go talk to each other rather than posting on social media personal life matters they literally have a child together I feel sorry for the baby not them because they are literal definition of drama
hailey is so strong to be able to put up w all this bs. if i were her i would be behind bars rn.
I can see who the woman and who the man is here! Literally!
So is Hailey the man in the relationship and Justin is the woman then?
hasn’t really done anything wrong. i don’t understand the constant hate she gets.
Yay! I'm early lol, I love this channel!
One time they are in love , another time posting how much they love sza !! I cant really understand them
Hayley and Justin are just making fun of all those people who constantly look for news about their private life, which is not public... In their place I would do the same, I would publish a song or a phrase and I would watch what happens. And while most believe there is a crisis, a divorce, etc. etc., they live their private life. And I'm not a fan of them, but that's what I think about
Christmas Breakfast: eggs and caviar ... 😶😐😂
Kind of reminds me of how people can get real messy on Facebook and sometimes you just want to post something impulsively but maybe they should have just done it on their finstas
Baby, baby, baby ooohhhh.
Postpartum is a very tricky time , with all the hormonal changes and the most important HAVING THE BABY! Hopefully they're are doing well.
Sorry if this sounds rude, but what kind of mother wouldn’t want to spend Christmas (their baby’s first Christmas) with them? That’s kinda weird js
The more people hate on their relationship, the more they thrive. They are not going to get a divorce. Their marriage is built around god and faith. They've been married for 6 years now. One of the most stable couples in Hollywood. They had the wedding when they wanted to. They got pregnant when they wanted to. They don't care about the outside noise and I'm glad about that. Hailey is Justin's rock. They have a beautiful family. ❤
I checked Jeremy Bieber's X account.. and I can't find that specific post. Is that deleted or what? I am so confuse
It’s like…are yall not getting enough attention or something? 😭🤣
Isn't something wrong with the two of them every other week? Like at this point, who's surprised?
I sense an inminent divorce
😂😂😂😂😂 we know we know
The first year is the hardest they say & the real test of your relationship. I know with my man we had a rough patch after my son was born.
Everywhere that there's shady business, Lou Taylor's name is in the mix. That's no coincidence
Obviously, I don't know them at all, but Justin posting that coparenting is failing feels to me like some christians that believe under no circumstances should people ever divorce and his dad posting that no one has ever regretted having children feels like he is trying to say something against abortion or people nowadays not wanting to have children and wanting to live differently. Fans interpreting these posts as cryptic messages about their relationship and not religious and political messages seems weirder to me.
Wait isn't justin buying stupid rings? 20 million dollar mansions? Who is spending money himself and his money hungry wife... keep an eye out for that wife
Yes
yall are so desperate honestly... why do you all want them to divorce? and also u don't know them personaly so how can you know whats going on in their marriage? also hailey probaby just posted that song cuz she liked it yall need to grow up and start acting like adults instead of being so investend in this celebrities yall are acting like little teenage girls
Lou Taylor has always given me bad vibes. Her name comes up in connection with too many scandals & unethical behavior.
The real tea is Lou Taylor's name mentioned in Britney Spears's conservatorship, pdd's horrendous case, and potentially mismanaging Justin's finance. Oh, sure, she absolutely doesn't have any involvement. It's just pure coincidence that her and her company keep being mentioned. Sure.