The worst part about Rockstar is that her fans (not Blinks but mainly Lilies) try to implement meaning in the lyrics where there is not any. It's just for the rhyme scheme, there is not a particular meaning. I am a Blink and honestly, this is the worst song to have come out from the girls.
The only meaningful line is "can you teach me jpnese, i say hai hai" and you can interpret different ways. 1. Saying it because most western people think Asia is Japan and China. 2. Saying it because one of her "rivals" is from Japan (Momo).
@@misskata8511 this is absolutely completely pulled out of nowhere i can guarantee you lisa nor her songwriters were thinking that hard about it. it's also a lyric that would make anyone who doesn't know lisa think she's japanese or at least fluent in japanese, neither of which are true. it was used because "hai hai" rhymes with "hype hype". this is the kind of thing that i would buy if it were coming from someone who actually has a history of releasing music with a deeper meaning. i'm all for overanalyzing and you can absolutely take whatever you want from this song regardless of whether it was intended or not. but you need to know when to stop giving people credit they don't deserve. lisa has never shown us she has any artistic intent in the first place. if she does, she needs to release music that makes that clear.
@ishathakor the whole song looks like they made it in an hour. I don't think Lisa or her songwriters thought about meaningful lyrics. For me they tried to make Money 2.0.
THANK YOU for talking about lisa's rockstar. I'm not going to sit here saying it was bad when it all just comes down to your own personal taste but the lyrics were... kind of awful. yes, you can argue that not all songs have to have lyrics or have some heroic meaning behind them, which is true, music is just another form of art. but some people DO value lyrics more than the actual beat or music, like my dad, and lyrics DO matter, not in all songs but they do. also, just because a song is centered around SOUNDING good doesn't make the lyrics any better. the only meaningful lyric in the song was 'lisa, can you teach me Japanese?' which COULD be talking about Asian stereotypes but I don't think that was confirmed, it could just be for rhyme scheme. and even if it was talking abt Asian stereotypes it doesn't excuse the rest of the song lyrics. they're all talking abt being a rockstar, being rich, in certain instances being pretty, and being the best. i'm not saying u can't write abt things like this, but if u look at her old songs like money and lalisa, the meaning hasn't changed at all, which I find interesting because money and lalisa weren't written by Lisa herself but rockstar was. like you stated, YG definitely hadn't left her entirely, they're bound together in some way. hopefully she tries something new but that's her choice. (P.S. NO HATE TO LISA! I have nothing against her and wish her the best in her solo career. this is just my opinion! feel free to disagree but don't force ur opinions onto me or be rude abt it. srry for the long paragraph)
If Lisa wrote the lyrics for Rockstar, then I understand why YG didn't let her write lyrics for BP. The lyrics will always matter. The medoly/beat matter too but the sometimes the lyrics are the thing that tells you the vibe of the song like Likey for ex. The beat is happy but the lyrics talk about social medias. The beat and the lyrics matter but the lyrics matter more.
Omg thank you for talking about Rockstar. The song was really bad in my opinion considering many factors. Lisa can do better fs. The worst part is that blinks esp cannot take criticism at all when it comes to people stating their opinions or specifying how they can do better. I think after the whole lilies controversy too its pretty obvious that the group has no intentions to really work together anymore and are using the name for their solo purposes. However I wish the best for the group ig
3. I feel like the only one who does a bit too much is Ahyeon I find that the other members are putting the perfect amount of energy but with Ahyeon it just looks to much she dances and pops too hard which makes the overall performance look awkward and her highnote in Sheesh just is her screaming especially if you look at their fan meetings she is just blatantly screaming so I really hope she could improve more in controlling her energy
She is not screaming, she has really high voice. And Ahyeon is like San from Ateez she gives more and more but in the end of the show you will remember them and secretly you love them because they gives you all😊
@@slavakaripova2172 for me it’s not like that she is actually screaming just watch her fan cams of sheesh in their fan meeting she is literally screaming into the mic and that isn’t having a high voice
I respect your opinion but you misuse the term flop. Flop means failed on charts, likes and views were low, didn’t sell much, no nominations for awards. Rockstar has been nominated for 4 VMAs, charted #1 on billboard hot 100 excl U.S and #70 on billboard hot 100. Most liked kpop mv of the year. You can hate it go ahead idc but you misuse the term flop I think you meant some other word
@@jayaprilyt578 if you live in 2024 flop has meant one and only one thing, “failure, unsuccessful, performed horrible” if you’d like to share your thoughts on the definition of flop ypu May do so in the palaces in England where the first Anglo English language books were written i however choose to follow the English dictionary and not question it.
Okay here we go: 1) I agree, and it KILLS me because their old music was so good. I remember watching the mv and being like "that's it?". I feel like Back 2 Luv should've been the title track, but even that isn't really up to par with their old stuff. Slay wasn't the best song ever but at least it kind of fit in with the rest of their discography. Zombie just feels so out of place. It sounds like a Pixy song, but a bit more empty ( No hate to the girls, they performed it really well). 2) I honestly kinda liked Rockstar, but it was still kind of underwhelming. My two main problems are the length of the song and the lyrics. It's a debut SINGLE and you can't even get it over 3 minutes. The lyrics make no real sense. The whole song feels like LALISA 2.0; it's catchy, but not amazing. 3) I agree SO MUCH with this. I understand that an idol "over-performing" can be distracting if the rest of the group has visibly less energy, but the entirety of BM have close to the same level of energy so it still feels cohesive. Besides, their job was to be entertaining and they did that, why are yall complaining? 4) I'm kind of split on this one. I do agree with the argument that in some cases some members just do better with certain lines so they should sing them. There have also been many cases where members have asked for less lines, so I feel like it's unfair for fans to go as far as they do by calling it "mistreatment". However, in some cases a member barely gets lines in any of their comebacks (I'm so sorry Bahiyyih 😭). I feel like it's a little unfair to those members since they tend to get pushed to the back. Long story short, if a member doesn't get a lot of lines once it's fine, but it's not fair if it happens almost every comeback. 5) I agree. Aespa is the definition of a group that instead of calling criticism "hate", they work to get better. There work is now paying off in their growth and they deserve it so much
I'm not a blink but y'all expect too much from them . Lisa is not a rapper who writes her own lyrics so she can't really talk about her story but yeah she can work with better writers seeing as she is one of the top female idols in the industry and is now not under ygs control. But for me rockstar is 100 times better than money or lalisa her other solos so there's improvement just give her time to come up with substantial meaningful lyrics or work with writers who give her good lyrics.
@@amandahallow1114 she hasn't ever written lyrics for her own songs or blackpink songs maybe she doesn't have the aptitude for it or maybe she wasn't given the opportunity. Not everyone can write, compose, produce everything on their own. She's a singer/rapper/dancer and there's nothing wrong with it most kpop idols don't write their own songs as well. If she wants to dabble in writing now she can as she's not in yg anymore but it'll take time. No one can turn into a lyricist overnight. Or maybe she doesn't want to? I think that's a plausible reason as well. I think many people thought her style of songs was imposed by yg so once she starts her own company she'll break out of the image imposed by yg but maybe it's what she likes? Maybe this is the type of song she likes. Who knows . Fans expected too much from her thinking she'll do something different from the usual yg style, but it's not necessary to do something different.
I couldn't even finish Lisa's MV tbh. I think I watched 30s to 1m max. And honestly the Babymonster and NMIXX take is so valid because so many artists be getting hate for doing their jobs because their faves are *under* performing
I personally loved Golden Hour. I like how different but reminiscent it feels to early Ateez but with a more experimental approach. I think many peoples perception of the album is coming from the promotion of it rather than the music itself because sonically it’s not very off from what Ateez has done previously, just with more experimental sounds. I understand feeling like it’s underwhelming but I never expected this comeback to have the same energy and grandiose as Guerrilla or Bouncy. I think people had set a certain expectation in their head of how they felt it was supposed to be. I do feel like the promotion and build up lacked in giving the proper understanding of how this album would be like. And it actually does connect back to their lore! They are currently back in World A where sounds, color, art, and emotion are not outlawed. Therefore we’re going to hear many diverse sounds that represents the diversity of life itself. Songs such as Work and Blind lean heavy into the hiphop/latin sound, while Shaboom is quite literally a mixture of sounds that people would never think to associate together. The Golden Hour trilogy will most likely consist of many different sounds combined and used as a way to express the many unique moments life has to offer, ie, their Golden Hours.
For me is really bad to change concepts that gave you the opportunity to shine like bouncy.I can truly understand that a group wants to make another concepts and music but hold them for a bside track the main track has to be really close to what made you adorable and Ateez are known for really energetic music with great high level performance. Work isn't a song that shows neither their music neither their dancing ability.
@@slavakaripova2172 This isn’t necessarily true when ATEEZ are known for changing up their concept. Bouncy and Crazy form didn’t even have the same concepts either. Ateez has released songs like Eternal sunshine, Turbulence, Inception, Celebrate, ect that are not as hype or heavy as Bouncy + Crazy form. That’s why they’ve garnered the fanbase that they have bc of how diverse their music is while being able to explore different sounds. I feel like fans who came after Guerrilla era and or Bouncy era only expect heavy and in your face material from Ateez which is fine if that’s your preference but they aren’t always going to produce the same sounds and will constantly explore different genres. Every song may not be your cup of tea and that’s okay! However, they are willing to experiment and find new ways to use sounds, and that’s always been their forte.
@@binaseenya I can't understand what you said but for me as Aitiny i love most of their songs but as a manager my point says no. Most of people are streaming Wonderland, Guerilla, Bouncy,Halazia . That's why i said that for me if the recipe is good don't change it. I'm fan from Black cat Nero .
@@slavakaripova2172 Your point is very contradictory when every song you listened sounds completely different from one another and all had unique concepts of their own. Wonderland was a more theatrical pirate sound, Guerrilla used heavy metal and screamo, Bouncy was more kpop/dance oriented, and Halazia used a mixture of dance hall/ drum and bass, and electro pop. None of these songs are sonically the same and offer a completely different sound than the other. I understand wanting to hear a similar sound to these, but to say that they should stick to doing the same sounds when they aren’t known for that is an interesting take. They are the most streamed bc they are title tracks and most ppl listen to title tracks and not full albums. However they do have many popular b sides that ppl adore and appreciate such as Arriba, Leaders, Django, Dune, To The Beat, Take Me Home, ect. I can name many more and these all are well loved by the fandom.
thank you so much!! I hate when people who aren't actually interested in the lore and the diary run their mouth about how ateez don't stick to their lore, especially now that we have changed dimensions again. Most people that complained about golden hour seem to only really enjoy heavy concepts so they assume ateez is always like that. Although i can agree that the concept art and photos were less creative than previous ones , it would be crazy to think that they would have the same sound and look in world A as they did in world Z.
1. I’m glad someone said it cus I felt like I was scared to say slay wasn’t as much as a banger as their previous stuff. Like that’s not my girls those are doppelgängers 2. HEAVY ON THIS but also imma add on to. Many blinks will support her Ofcourse but my concern is the fact she won’t be respected as a rapper and won’t get new fans on her own. It’s bad too cus I seen people compare her to ice spice which isn’t good but I understand why they say it. This song got that ice spice issue. It’s catchy and u can dance but it’s more of a TikTok moment than a song u play on repeat after a few months let alone years. 3. CLOCK IT. It reminded me about people complaining about Lily vocals from Nmixx saying she was doing too much 😭 same with jongho from ateez. 7. Someone had to say it. I LOVE ateez but this wasn’t giving, I’ll still dance to work cus it’s a fun song but it’s still not it
I also thought of Ice Spice when I heard it. I am a Blink myself but can't stand that song at all. And I say this as someone who likes Ice cream which is the most hated song by BP. Rockstar is just sooo flat and cringe - I got goosebumps on the Japanese part but in a bad way
People don't say Ahyeon is over-performing because she is dancing or singing too hard, it's because she isn't in sync with her group. That's all. They step up or she needs to regulate down. Also, sorry, straight out of YG's playbook. Get a great member stand out and attacked, so people praise and defend them. Wouldn't be too surprised if it's all orchestrated.
If you go down the rabbit hole of conspiracy theories it ties to a lot to Aespa's lore. Different dimension, alien and or spiritual warfare, spiritual superpowers and more. Makes me wonder who in SM believes in the conspiracy theories.
When an artist doesn't write their own lyrics they are only as good as their writer's, Lisa needs to do some investing because I agree the lyrics were horrible.
Just to finish those texts of mine... I think Aespa (+Kiof) is getting recognized for doing something different from the other 4th-5th ggs, they didn't follow that y2k, cute, coquette vibe at all. Aespa is what's keeping me on kpop rn I got obssessed in their debut, but after next level I've lost interest on them. But after better things I feel like they're just making masterpieces? I saw MY world (Spicy's album) and I got like eh, alright. It didn't catch my attention. But this was way different with Drama (except for that mini album), Supernova, Bahama, Licorice or Armageddon. I'm really obssessed with their new album, and now with hot mess. In this case, it's literally just my opinion, lol. But their songs are different from one and other or from anyone in kpop. THANK YOU AESPA FOR DOING THOSE SONGS, PLEASE DO MORE 😭😭 NO ONE'S STEPPING ON AESPA!!
AND YES, SAY IT LOUDER. I know we all have tastes in different things, but we all can see when something just don't make sense at all? I mean, I got really excited for them (blackpink) finally getting to do their own songs in their solos, but then I see Lisa's rockstar. IT'S JUST THE SAME THING. I don't want y'all saying "but that's blackpink concept" when bp concept isn't those mid ass songs at all?? Whistle, boombayah, playing with fire, As if it's your last, really, forever young, kiss and makeup were the ACTUAL blackpink, and those songs were def not mid and don't have pointless lyrics. I'm a blink since their debut, they were my second kpop group (my first was Red Velvet), and I always get sad when I remember how they're doing in this days. Say anything you want, but blackpink did changed. Their songs, the way they perform at stage... Their current songs aren't bad, but THEY'RE ALSO NOT GOOD. Rockstar was honestly disappointing, as I said, I got happy that they got a solo contract outside YG, but rockstar is the same thing as Lalisa: repetitive song, normal dance break, meaningless lyrics... AND WHAT GETS ME SICK ARE THOSE "BLINKS" THAT JUST LIKE ANYTHING THEY DO. Yes, I'm a blink, but no, I won't shut up and listen while giggling or fangirling to THIS thing.
The only disappointment I have with Rockstar is that it’s mainly just objectless & really just naming stuff or encounters. If there was more of a streamlined idea and “story” I’d be into it more. The only reason I’m gagged forreal is because of the visuals, choreography, her filming in Thailand, & that smooth ass transition into sampling Same Ole Mistakes by Tame Impala later remade by Rihanna for 2017’s ANTI. It’s clear it’s for a quick little buzz & honestly a dancer based/tik tok audience.
Rockstar is a good addition to my running playlist, and the video was a fun one time watch. But I also wasn’t expecting anything life-altering like Halazia❤lol. I do think Lisa is an excellent dancer, but the thing that’s the GOAT is her PR/marketing machine. I’m not saying that in a bad way I used to do PR/marketing, and there’s nothing wrong with success. But just like you say, it’s a fun game of opinions not the apocalypse.
Babymonster is one of the three best 5th Gen groups and there’s no denying it. They sing live, they perform fantastically, hype up the crowd and not one member never doesn’t give her all. Ahyeon giving more shows what kpop idols are actually capable of but chose not to. Keep rocking babymonster ❤
I admit with your opinions for Everglow, Lisa and Babymonster, Aespa,Nmixx, Ateez but for line distribution i see some groups have really skilled singers because they aren't so much popular or they don't have the same amount of ambassadors to give them the opportunity to shine. For example Jisoo from BP , she has a good voice and her voice is great for every concept yg treated to her really bad when it came for line distribution they left her last with extremely big difference with other members. That's a case that puts me angry
😮... Oh my gosh, thank you. I thought I was the only one who didn't like ROCKSTAR. Sorry to say girlie but I honestly thought it was a flop. But honestly love her but the song is TOO forgettable. To be FAIR, I didn't like it either girl.
I respect your opinion but you misuse the term flop. Flop means failed on charts, likes and views were low, didn’t sell much, no nominations for awards. Rockstar has been nominated for 4 VMAs, charted #1 on billboard hot 100 excl U.S and #70 on billboard hot 100. Most liked kpop mv of the year. You can hate it go ahead idc but you misuse the term flop I think you meant some other word
uh a full album has always (before kpop) been considered an album with 8 or more sonsg....albums dont need to have 20+ songs to be considered an album/a good album lol alot of western soloist have short full albums as well.
I know you can write a song for 1 hour because I have done it. It was not the best song tho. I think Lisa's team wrote it for like 1 hour or less because what?! The only cool thing were the pre-chorus and the bridge. I don't think Beyonce is something special but yeah, Lisa can be close to Beyonce only if we talk about dance which reminds me of the mediocre choreo of Rockstar. They should at least give her something in her category.
BABYMONSTER is packet of visual,vocals,talent etc They're bringing back the Live singing About AHYEON she is enjoying her Job I don't know why K-pop stan being Bipolar If a idol dance lazily or Lip-sing they will Throw hate on them for ex Jennie. Even when a Idol Dance energetic and Sing live Again throw Hate on them 🤦 Get a life Haters
Hard agree on the line distribution. For Ateez in particular, I took their last 25 songs minus unit tracks, from Siren to Lets get Together, and using line distribution placement of 1 through 8 averaged their place, and 6 members were within a 1.5 rank of each other from 4.48-5.92. Anyways, point being, the member with the lowest average placement in line distribution for almost the last 2 years is Mingi, but his fans arent up in arms about it. people just need their member to be the victim so they can champion how great they are.
For the first opinion, I do not agree with the YG x BP fault for 8 songs in a album. That's their strategy, their move that works with us, their fans. Just because other groups do the same (it is mainly female btw - look into NJ, LS, Red Velvet, Twice, G-idle discographies) does not mean that they will succeed the same way which is obvious. Plus, I don't mind short albums. I prefer eras - for example two eras within a year with two albums of 8 songs for example. Because idols, especially from the big 3, are not allowed to talk about themselves - their beliefs, love life, etc., so I want different eras with define images and define music for each - so less songs is not a problem.
I personally liked rockstar cause I don’t care about the meaning of a song unless it’s sexual, since it was catchy and repetitive I liked that. K-pop songs have been getting shorter since 2020 so people yapping about it being short shouldn’t talk. The bragging that she does I like, I know she’s a down to earth person based of everything she’s done for others but I’m not a fan of like something that’s supposed to be super deep like feel my rhythm, one Spark, scientist, Midas touch, fake love or wtv the songs if they have some message that 3rd graders should learn I don’t care my type is stuff like sheesh, rockstar, LALISA, shut down, d4, fire(bts & 2NE1), loco or dun dun. Stuff that meaning is not important who cares but having catchy lyrics and stuff that makes you scream is what I like.
I have nothing in particular to say about the other points but gurl it was buckwild to talk about line distribution like that and making the choice to have IVE of all ppl playing in the background then even bringing them up within a general lament that can be summed up as "what if the member (of whichever group) just aren't that good so they don't get much lines" when the crux of the uproar about line distribution for IVE in particular centers especially around LIZ who is one of the best and most promising vocalists of her gen (not exaggerating, she's that good) constantly getting robbed off of doing her literal JOB. It's so frustrating cause she's hands down singing better than all of her members combined, by far, and then some than other groups even and it's been so painfully obvious she gets little lines that even folks who causally listen to them would notice it. Why put such a good singer in a group and then not utilise the talent? It's a valid complaint. Other than that I am not too concerned with line distribution if the member is vocally weak as long as they aren't silenced completely bc I for example like exo and you won't ever catch me complain when Sehun has a bit less of lines bc he simply isn't the strongest vocally, it just is what it is but he's treated way better when before he would say nothing or 3 words. Just like in IVE it is fine if- I was gonna say my bias but they're one of those bands where I like everyone equally-anyway if vocally less strong members don't get lines, that's cool, it's FINE. But line distribution IS a big deal when the idol in question is literally the best vocalist in the group and most of the singing is handed to the other members. I'm not saying vocal performance is the only important thing, just that an amazing vocal performance can add so much value and life to a song as well and yet at the same time, I couldn't imagine certain lines being sung by LIZ regardless of how technically better she is bc I simply enjoyed the way Rei or Gaeul would sing their parts, but there has to be a BALANCE. I wished you would've put more nuance in that part bc it's a big difference if a bad vocalist gets no parts vs a very good vocalist. It's not even about selfish reasons like "I need to hear my bias sing" but the art itself. Kpop is already soulless enough as it is and they have a chronic issue with creativity and technicality in regards to vocal performance (adlibs, harmonies, PROPER harmonies, runs etc) that a lot of songs tend to feel flat and it's why it's all the more satisfying when a song is actually interesting in a technical aspect. I didn't even mean to rant that much but the other day I saw ole girl sing her thing and it saddened me bc you could tell she revels in it. Ik some idols are glad when they don't have too much lines since they work sm but when you can feel the idol WANTS to sing, for gods sake their companies need to fucking LET em. Kpop companies are notorious for wasting talent bc they only care about the new hottest thing once they debuted their other and dgaf about nurturing who they debuted after that and those idols really suffered to get where they are it shouldn't be in vain.
Single Albums aren't YG s idea but Kpops. I know why you would think, why YG not releasing music contributes to it but back in the old days producing Kpop was expensive to a degree that it wasnt done during hard times until the comunity starten to produce single and mini albums, which were treated like full albums (with tours and merch) Honesty a single album is a very kpop think to do and contributes to the succes oft kpop (back than and even now) 😁
I liked Rockstar, it felt refreshing. Some people need to understand that not all songs need to have a deep meaning, some are just meant to be catchy. In my opinion is a lot better than lalisa or money, I feel like she fits the style better. I would love if her next music focuses more on dancing.
I love Lisa but her music pretty mediocre considering how talented she is and the access she has to great music producers and such and this was her time to shine but she kinda dropped the ball, blackpink in general music has been pretty subpar and forgettable, their kinda overrated if you match their music to their success, it doesn’t add it and they seem like a group more popular cause of hype than how good their music has been throughout the years, yes their talented but their talent has not accounted for their success its more so hype and riding off that hype and your right kpop fans don’t seem to know what they want and just like to find things to complain about that’s why idols should just do them and do their best and not focus so much on what wishy washy fans want as long as their not being disrespectful or offensive, I never cared about line distribution cause those that gonna shine gonna shine and stand out regardless, winter stage presence is fine, I like her icy cold vibe onstage hence the name, there’s something drawing people to her fancams over and over again and it ain’t just hate watching otherwise they’d just stop watching her fancams since they find her so “robotic” if you don’t like it focus your attention on a member that appeals to you instead of constantly complaining about the ones that don’t
Ok ~OPINION DUMP~ Personally I LOVED Rockstar call me biased. Lisa didn't play it safe at all, she could've been between vocal kpop performance and full hyperpop and given average of nothing. But she dared and went the cyberpunk route which was PERFECT This gave be Brat By Charlie XCX vibes (it's good 👀) and cyberpunk and I LOVED IT the chorus was finally complete and not just catchy. The verses were cool. People hate autotube, but lisa used it in the BEST way, the rap was sick and the final beat synth fusion was everything. In my opinion i loves this song. Lalisa felt missing yet it felt like 10 songs, this feels like a COMPLETE good good song, though a bit short
I Dislike about Jennie acting in that kinda Show And Lisa in crazy horse show but i Respect them I really lose Hope in jennie,rose,jisoo album/ song even tho they left the Company but lisa also disappointed me with her Songs i really don't like rockstar but she slayed the new woman with Roselia.
@@misssunnybae1074can u painfully stfu about Lisa damn y'all always complaining god damn ok it's ur opinion but girl some people like Lisa tittle tracks btw Lisa actually wrote this song herself bitch so yea.
another opinion Is that y'all are sleeping on kiss of life way too muchhhh like those girls have overflowing talents and have amazing songs but they're still slept on this just shows that kpop fans nowadays don't really care about talent
I don’t agree with the Lisa one. Please listen to the song and try to understand it, it has nothing to do with being pretty. It’s about people thinking that because you’re Asian so you’re Japanese or Chinese. Because you’re Asian so everyone looks the same. She also talks about being a catch and kill for the third party. And all this going with the MV.
@@Yunjin___ rockstar here is not to with the rockstar artist or the genre. Rockstar here is more being rebellious. If you noticed in the mv there is some famous people from the LGBTQ community
The worst part about Rockstar is that her fans (not Blinks but mainly Lilies) try to implement meaning in the lyrics where there is not any. It's just for the rhyme scheme, there is not a particular meaning. I am a Blink and honestly, this is the worst song to have come out from the girls.
The only meaningful line is "can you teach me jpnese, i say hai hai" and you can interpret different ways.
1. Saying it because most western people think Asia is Japan and China.
2. Saying it because one of her "rivals" is from Japan (Momo).
@@misskata8511 idk it seems like someone just made that up and it spread
@@hayleyconlonmills3288 The company and Lisa herself haven't confirmed it so I don't believe it's used to stop the generalisation of East Asian people
@@misskata8511 this is absolutely completely pulled out of nowhere i can guarantee you lisa nor her songwriters were thinking that hard about it. it's also a lyric that would make anyone who doesn't know lisa think she's japanese or at least fluent in japanese, neither of which are true. it was used because "hai hai" rhymes with "hype hype".
this is the kind of thing that i would buy if it were coming from someone who actually has a history of releasing music with a deeper meaning. i'm all for overanalyzing and you can absolutely take whatever you want from this song regardless of whether it was intended or not. but you need to know when to stop giving people credit they don't deserve. lisa has never shown us she has any artistic intent in the first place. if she does, she needs to release music that makes that clear.
@ishathakor the whole song looks like they made it in an hour. I don't think Lisa or her songwriters thought about meaningful lyrics. For me they tried to make Money 2.0.
THANK YOU for talking about lisa's rockstar. I'm not going to sit here saying it was bad when it all just comes down to your own personal taste but the lyrics were... kind of awful. yes, you can argue that not all songs have to have lyrics or have some heroic meaning behind them, which is true, music is just another form of art. but some people DO value lyrics more than the actual beat or music, like my dad, and lyrics DO matter, not in all songs but they do. also, just because a song is centered around SOUNDING good doesn't make the lyrics any better. the only meaningful lyric in the song was 'lisa, can you teach me Japanese?' which COULD be talking about Asian stereotypes but I don't think that was confirmed, it could just be for rhyme scheme. and even if it was talking abt Asian stereotypes it doesn't excuse the rest of the song lyrics. they're all talking abt being a rockstar, being rich, in certain instances being pretty, and being the best. i'm not saying u can't write abt things like this, but if u look at her old songs like money and lalisa, the meaning hasn't changed at all, which I find interesting because money and lalisa weren't written by Lisa herself but rockstar was. like you stated, YG definitely hadn't left her entirely, they're bound together in some way. hopefully she tries something new but that's her choice. (P.S. NO HATE TO LISA! I have nothing against her and wish her the best in her solo career. this is just my opinion! feel free to disagree but don't force ur opinions onto me or be rude abt it. srry for the long paragraph)
If Lisa wrote the lyrics for Rockstar, then I understand why YG didn't let her write lyrics for BP. The lyrics will always matter. The medoly/beat matter too but the sometimes the lyrics are the thing that tells you the vibe of the song like Likey for ex. The beat is happy but the lyrics talk about social medias. The beat and the lyrics matter but the lyrics matter more.
Omg thank you for talking about Rockstar. The song was really bad in my opinion considering many factors. Lisa can do better fs. The worst part is that blinks esp cannot take criticism at all when it comes to people stating their opinions or specifying how they can do better. I think after the whole lilies controversy too its pretty obvious that the group has no intentions to really work together anymore and are using the name for their solo purposes. However I wish the best for the group ig
3. I feel like the only one who does a bit too much is Ahyeon I find that the other members are putting the perfect amount of energy but with Ahyeon it just looks to much she dances and pops too hard which makes the overall performance look awkward and her highnote in Sheesh just is her screaming especially if you look at their fan meetings she is just blatantly screaming so I really hope she could improve more in controlling her energy
I don’t think she over performs her high notes are just severely strained I hope she learns how to hit those notes safely
She is not screaming, she has really high voice. And Ahyeon is like San from Ateez she gives more and more but in the end of the show you will remember them and secretly you love them because they gives you all😊
@@slavakaripova2172 for me it’s not like that she is actually screaming just watch her fan cams of sheesh in their fan meeting she is literally screaming into the mic and that isn’t having a high voice
Frr
If you watch Taipei, Bangkok, Seoul and Jakarta fanmeets she isn’t screaming, which fanmeet is it since it’s not the ones I mentioned
Rockstar is kind of a flop for me bcuz some lyrics doesn't make sense
Also Lisa's pic (like in the thumbnail) its kind of bad...
@@jayaprilyt578 that comment on the photo being kinda eh
Thank god i wasn’t the only one thinking that😭
@@siri5784 it's like she changed her race in that photo and made it look emo/goth/gangster/f* boy
I respect your opinion but you misuse the term flop. Flop means failed on charts, likes and views were low, didn’t sell much, no nominations for awards. Rockstar has been nominated for 4 VMAs, charted #1 on billboard hot 100 excl U.S and #70 on billboard hot 100. Most liked kpop mv of the year. You can hate it go ahead idc but you misuse the term flop I think you meant some other word
@@AsaQueenAceOfBabymonster flop has alot if meaning
@@jayaprilyt578 if you live in 2024 flop has meant one and only one thing, “failure, unsuccessful, performed horrible” if you’d like to share your thoughts on the definition of flop ypu May do so in the palaces in England where the first Anglo English language books were written i however choose to follow the English dictionary and not question it.
Rosè is my only hope now 😢 i hope she takes her time with her album. she's a songwriter anyway so I'm not gonna worry about her too much ❤
@@Teddy_Gruett jisoo, Jennie??
Okay here we go:
1) I agree, and it KILLS me because their old music was so good. I remember watching the mv and being like "that's it?". I feel like Back 2 Luv should've been the title track, but even that isn't really up to par with their old stuff. Slay wasn't the best song ever but at least it kind of fit in with the rest of their discography. Zombie just feels so out of place. It sounds like a Pixy song, but a bit more empty ( No hate to the girls, they performed it really well).
2) I honestly kinda liked Rockstar, but it was still kind of underwhelming. My two main problems are the length of the song and the lyrics. It's a debut SINGLE and you can't even get it over 3 minutes. The lyrics make no real sense. The whole song feels like LALISA 2.0; it's catchy, but not amazing.
3) I agree SO MUCH with this. I understand that an idol "over-performing" can be distracting if the rest of the group has visibly less energy, but the entirety of BM have close to the same level of energy so it still feels cohesive. Besides, their job was to be entertaining and they did that, why are yall complaining?
4) I'm kind of split on this one. I do agree with the argument that in some cases some members just do better with certain lines so they should sing them. There have also been many cases where members have asked for less lines, so I feel like it's unfair for fans to go as far as they do by calling it "mistreatment". However, in some cases a member barely gets lines in any of their comebacks (I'm so sorry Bahiyyih 😭). I feel like it's a little unfair to those members since they tend to get pushed to the back. Long story short, if a member doesn't get a lot of lines once it's fine, but it's not fair if it happens almost every comeback.
5) I agree. Aespa is the definition of a group that instead of calling criticism "hate", they work to get better. There work is now paying off in their growth and they deserve it so much
I'm not a blink but y'all expect too much from them . Lisa is not a rapper who writes her own lyrics so she can't really talk about her story but yeah she can work with better writers seeing as she is one of the top female idols in the industry and is now not under ygs control. But for me rockstar is 100 times better than money or lalisa her other solos so there's improvement just give her time to come up with substantial meaningful lyrics or work with writers who give her good lyrics.
can i ask why she cant write her lyrics?
@@amandahallow1114 she hasn't ever written lyrics for her own songs or blackpink songs maybe she doesn't have the aptitude for it or maybe she wasn't given the opportunity. Not everyone can write, compose, produce everything on their own. She's a singer/rapper/dancer and there's nothing wrong with it most kpop idols don't write their own songs as well. If she wants to dabble in writing now she can as she's not in yg anymore but it'll take time. No one can turn into a lyricist overnight. Or maybe she doesn't want to? I think that's a plausible reason as well. I think many people thought her style of songs was imposed by yg so once she starts her own company she'll break out of the image imposed by yg but maybe it's what she likes? Maybe this is the type of song she likes. Who knows . Fans expected too much from her thinking she'll do something different from the usual yg style, but it's not necessary to do something different.
She did right the lyrics in rockstar if you Google it you can find out
I couldn't even finish Lisa's MV tbh. I think I watched 30s to 1m max.
And honestly the Babymonster and NMIXX take is so valid because so many artists be getting hate for doing their jobs because their faves are *under* performing
Lisa song is not even mid... It is low low... These blinks just supporting because it's Lisa.
I personally loved Golden Hour. I like how different but reminiscent it feels to early Ateez but with a more experimental approach. I think many peoples perception of the album is coming from the promotion of it rather than the music itself because sonically it’s not very off from what Ateez has done previously, just with more experimental sounds.
I understand feeling like it’s underwhelming but I never expected this comeback to have the same energy and grandiose as Guerrilla or Bouncy. I think people had set a certain expectation in their head of how they felt it was supposed to be. I do feel like the promotion and build up lacked in giving the proper understanding of how this album would be like.
And it actually does connect back to their lore! They are currently back in World A where sounds, color, art, and emotion are not outlawed. Therefore we’re going to hear many diverse sounds that represents the diversity of life itself. Songs such as Work and Blind lean heavy into the hiphop/latin sound, while Shaboom is quite literally a mixture of sounds that people would never think to associate together. The Golden Hour trilogy will most likely consist of many different sounds combined and used as a way to express the many unique moments life has to offer, ie, their Golden Hours.
For me is really bad to change concepts that gave you the opportunity to shine like bouncy.I can truly understand that a group wants to make another concepts and music but hold them for a bside track the main track has to be really close to what made you adorable and Ateez are known for really energetic music with great high level performance. Work isn't a song that shows neither their music neither their dancing ability.
@@slavakaripova2172 This isn’t necessarily true when ATEEZ are known for changing up their concept. Bouncy and Crazy form didn’t even have the same concepts either. Ateez has released songs like Eternal sunshine, Turbulence, Inception, Celebrate, ect that are not as hype or heavy as Bouncy + Crazy form. That’s why they’ve garnered the fanbase that they have bc of how diverse their music is while being able to explore different sounds.
I feel like fans who came after Guerrilla era and or Bouncy era only expect heavy and in your face material from Ateez which is fine if that’s your preference but they aren’t always going to produce the same sounds and will constantly explore different genres. Every song may not be your cup of tea and that’s okay! However, they are willing to experiment and find new ways to use sounds, and that’s always been their forte.
@@binaseenya I can't understand what you said but for me as Aitiny i love most of their songs but as a manager my point says no. Most of people are streaming Wonderland, Guerilla, Bouncy,Halazia . That's why i said that for me if the recipe is good don't change it. I'm fan from Black cat Nero .
@@slavakaripova2172 Your point is very contradictory when every song you listened sounds completely different from one another and all had unique concepts of their own. Wonderland was a more theatrical pirate sound, Guerrilla used heavy metal and screamo, Bouncy was more kpop/dance oriented, and Halazia used a mixture of dance hall/ drum and bass, and electro pop. None of these songs are sonically the same and offer a completely different sound than the other. I understand wanting to hear a similar sound to these, but to say that they should stick to doing the same sounds when they aren’t known for that is an interesting take.
They are the most streamed bc they are title tracks and most ppl listen to title tracks and not full albums. However they do have many popular b sides that ppl adore and appreciate such as Arriba, Leaders, Django, Dune, To The Beat, Take Me Home, ect. I can name many more and these all are well loved by the fandom.
thank you so much!! I hate when people who aren't actually interested in the lore and the diary run their mouth about how ateez don't stick to their lore, especially now that we have changed dimensions again. Most people that complained about golden hour seem to only really enjoy heavy concepts so they assume ateez is always like that. Although i can agree that the concept art and photos were less creative than previous ones , it would be crazy to think that they would have the same sound and look in world A as they did in world Z.
1. I’m glad someone said it cus I felt like I was scared to say slay wasn’t as much as a banger as their previous stuff. Like that’s not my girls those are doppelgängers
2. HEAVY ON THIS but also imma add on to. Many blinks will support her Ofcourse but my concern is the fact she won’t be respected as a rapper and won’t get new fans on her own. It’s bad too cus I seen people compare her to ice spice which isn’t good but I understand why they say it. This song got that ice spice issue. It’s catchy and u can dance but it’s more of a TikTok moment than a song u play on repeat after a few months let alone years.
3. CLOCK IT. It reminded me about people complaining about Lily vocals from Nmixx saying she was doing too much 😭 same with jongho from ateez.
7. Someone had to say it. I LOVE ateez but this wasn’t giving, I’ll still dance to work cus it’s a fun song but it’s still not it
I also thought of Ice Spice when I heard it. I am a Blink myself but can't stand that song at all. And I say this as someone who likes Ice cream which is the most hated song by BP. Rockstar is just sooo flat and cringe - I got goosebumps on the Japanese part but in a bad way
@@jensetter-dib Exactlyyy also heavy on the Ice cream part cus that song is so hated but it’s still a bop 😭
People don't say Ahyeon is over-performing because she is dancing or singing too hard, it's because she isn't in sync with her group. That's all. They step up or she needs to regulate down.
Also, sorry, straight out of YG's playbook. Get a great member stand out and attacked, so people praise and defend them. Wouldn't be too surprised if it's all orchestrated.
If you go down the rabbit hole of conspiracy theories it ties to a lot to Aespa's lore. Different dimension, alien and or spiritual warfare, spiritual superpowers and more. Makes me wonder who in SM believes in the conspiracy theories.
When an artist doesn't write their own lyrics they are only as good as their writer's, Lisa needs to do some investing because I agree the lyrics were horrible.
Just to finish those texts of mine...
I think Aespa (+Kiof) is getting recognized for doing something different from the other 4th-5th ggs, they didn't follow that y2k, cute, coquette vibe at all.
Aespa is what's keeping me on kpop rn
I got obssessed in their debut, but after next level I've lost interest on them.
But after better things I feel like they're just making masterpieces?
I saw MY world (Spicy's album) and I got like eh, alright. It didn't catch my attention. But this was way different with Drama (except for that mini album), Supernova, Bahama, Licorice or Armageddon. I'm really obssessed with their new album, and now with hot mess.
In this case, it's literally just my opinion, lol.
But their songs are different from one and other or from anyone in kpop.
THANK YOU AESPA FOR DOING THOSE SONGS, PLEASE DO MORE 😭😭
NO ONE'S STEPPING ON AESPA!!
7: It was fine. I like the other songs more than the title. I commented somewhere that the whole comeback feels like the calm before the storm.
I don’t understand what some of you find so unappealing about ateez newest album, i personally loved it, it deserves aoty in my opinion
My great niece loves them, I will listen to the album TY.
it's a mess of an album there's nothing cohesive and just random songs that were thrown in there
AND YES, SAY IT LOUDER.
I know we all have tastes in different things, but we all can see when something just don't make sense at all?
I mean, I got really excited for them (blackpink) finally getting to do their own songs in their solos, but then I see Lisa's rockstar. IT'S JUST THE SAME THING.
I don't want y'all saying "but that's blackpink concept" when bp concept isn't those mid ass songs at all?? Whistle, boombayah, playing with fire, As if it's your last, really, forever young, kiss and makeup were the ACTUAL blackpink, and those songs were def not mid and don't have pointless lyrics.
I'm a blink since their debut, they were my second kpop group (my first was Red Velvet), and I always get sad when I remember how they're doing in this days.
Say anything you want, but blackpink did changed. Their songs, the way they perform at stage...
Their current songs aren't bad, but THEY'RE ALSO NOT GOOD.
Rockstar was honestly disappointing, as I said, I got happy that they got a solo contract outside YG, but rockstar is the same thing as Lalisa: repetitive song, normal dance break, meaningless lyrics...
AND WHAT GETS ME SICK ARE THOSE "BLINKS" THAT JUST LIKE ANYTHING THEY DO. Yes, I'm a blink, but no, I won't shut up and listen while giggling or fangirling to THIS thing.
The only disappointment I have with Rockstar is that it’s mainly just objectless & really just naming stuff or encounters. If there was more of a streamlined idea and “story” I’d be into it more. The only reason I’m gagged forreal is because of the visuals, choreography, her filming in Thailand, & that smooth ass transition into sampling Same Ole Mistakes by Tame Impala later remade by Rihanna for 2017’s ANTI. It’s clear it’s for a quick little buzz & honestly a dancer based/tik tok audience.
Every song has a meaning even if not implicated in the song. I think that looking up at the meaning is important before judging the lyrics.
and also, I agree with you with the fact that some stans are hypocritical. like they don't know what they want, they just want to hate.
Imo :) your opinions are valid btw!! These are just what i think personally
Rockstar is a good addition to my running playlist, and the video was a fun one time watch. But I also wasn’t expecting anything life-altering like Halazia❤lol.
I do think Lisa is an excellent dancer, but the thing that’s the GOAT is her PR/marketing machine. I’m not saying that in a bad way I used to do PR/marketing, and there’s nothing wrong with success. But just like you say, it’s a fun game of opinions not the apocalypse.
Another banger sunny❤️
Babymonster is one of the three best 5th Gen groups and there’s no denying it. They sing live, they perform fantastically, hype up the crowd and not one member never doesn’t give her all. Ahyeon giving more shows what kpop idols are actually capable of but chose not to. Keep rocking babymonster ❤
I admit with your opinions for Everglow, Lisa and Babymonster, Aespa,Nmixx, Ateez but for line distribution i see some groups have really skilled singers because they aren't so much popular or they don't have the same amount of ambassadors to give them the opportunity to shine. For example Jisoo from BP , she has a good voice and her voice is great for every concept yg treated to her really bad when it came for line distribution they left her last with extremely big difference with other members. That's a case that puts me angry
It's sad to see people hate Zombie. It's so good. It's giving Purple Kiss.
@@jasoninthea.m7471 and that’s the problem it’s just not a song for everglow but for a different group at least it would have sounded better
@@misssunnybae1074 Maybe, but I guess people have different tastes. I loved the vibes actually.
This is such a great video, I agree with all of these :)
i think that sm is doing a great job with aespa's and riize's music consistency -- especially aespa! drama -> supernova -> armaggaedon is insanityyy
THE INTRO THO?!?! CONSIDER MY NON EXISTENT WIG SNATCHED!
Lmao 🤣
😮... Oh my gosh, thank you. I thought I was the only one who didn't like ROCKSTAR. Sorry to say girlie but I honestly thought it was a flop. But honestly love her but the song is TOO forgettable. To be FAIR, I didn't like it either girl.
I respect your opinion but you misuse the term flop. Flop means failed on charts, likes and views were low, didn’t sell much, no nominations for awards. Rockstar has been nominated for 4 VMAs, charted #1 on billboard hot 100 excl U.S and #70 on billboard hot 100. Most liked kpop mv of the year. You can hate it go ahead idc but you misuse the term flop I think you meant some other word
@@AsaQueenAceOfBabymonster I’m really sorry, when I mean flop, I say that it in my opinion failed to get ME.
@@iSunnyBunny_ that I can understand. I wasn’t trying to start a conflict by the way
@@AsaQueenAceOfBabymonster Oh don’t worry about it please, no conflict has started. I appreciate your opinion though :)
I feel like if it’s not about break up or love story people don’t pay attention or try to understand a song.
Why do y’all get on here to lie.
@@AUGHHHHHBBG huh? Like about what?
@@jessicadalletur WHOLE coment
@@AUGHHHHHBBG I’m not lying it’s just something that I noticed. You might not agree but I’m not lying
@@jessicadallet u are darling
uh a full album has always (before kpop) been considered an album with 8 or more sonsg....albums dont need to have 20+ songs to be considered an album/a good album lol alot of western soloist have short full albums as well.
I know you can write a song for 1 hour because I have done it. It was not the best song tho. I think Lisa's team wrote it for like 1 hour or less because what?! The only cool thing were the pre-chorus and the bridge. I don't think Beyonce is something special but yeah, Lisa can be close to Beyonce only if we talk about dance which reminds me of the mediocre choreo of Rockstar. They should at least give her something in her category.
BABYMONSTER is packet of visual,vocals,talent etc They're bringing back the Live singing About AHYEON she is enjoying her Job I don't know why K-pop stan being Bipolar If a idol dance lazily or Lip-sing they will Throw hate on them for ex Jennie. Even when a Idol Dance energetic and Sing live Again throw Hate on them 🤦 Get a life Haters
Hard agree on the line distribution. For Ateez in particular, I took their last 25 songs minus unit tracks, from Siren to Lets get Together, and using line distribution placement of 1 through 8 averaged their place, and 6 members were within a 1.5 rank of each other from 4.48-5.92. Anyways, point being, the member with the lowest average placement in line distribution for almost the last 2 years is Mingi, but his fans arent up in arms about it. people just need their member to be the victim so they can champion how great they are.
For the first opinion, I do not agree with the YG x BP fault for 8 songs in a album. That's their strategy, their move that works with us, their fans. Just because other groups do the same (it is mainly female btw - look into NJ, LS, Red Velvet, Twice, G-idle discographies) does not mean that they will succeed the same way which is obvious. Plus, I don't mind short albums. I prefer eras - for example two eras within a year with two albums of 8 songs for example. Because idols, especially from the big 3, are not allowed to talk about themselves - their beliefs, love life, etc., so I want different eras with define images and define music for each - so less songs is not a problem.
I personally liked rockstar cause I don’t care about the meaning of a song unless it’s sexual, since it was catchy and repetitive I liked that. K-pop songs have been getting shorter since 2020 so people yapping about it being short shouldn’t talk. The bragging that she does I like, I know she’s a down to earth person based of everything she’s done for others but I’m not a fan of like something that’s supposed to be super deep like feel my rhythm, one Spark, scientist, Midas touch, fake love or wtv the songs if they have some message that 3rd graders should learn I don’t care my type is stuff like sheesh, rockstar, LALISA, shut down, d4, fire(bts & 2NE1), loco or dun dun. Stuff that meaning is not important who cares but having catchy lyrics and stuff that makes you scream is what I like.
I have nothing in particular to say about the other points but gurl it was buckwild to talk about line distribution like that and making the choice to have IVE of all ppl playing in the background then even bringing them up within a general lament that can be summed up as "what if the member (of whichever group) just aren't that good so they don't get much lines" when the crux of the uproar about line distribution for IVE in particular centers especially around LIZ who is one of the best and most promising vocalists of her gen (not exaggerating, she's that good) constantly getting robbed off of doing her literal JOB.
It's so frustrating cause she's hands down singing better than all of her members combined, by far, and then some than other groups even and it's been so painfully obvious she gets little lines that even folks who causally listen to them would notice it. Why put such a good singer in a group and then not utilise the talent? It's a valid complaint.
Other than that I am not too concerned with line distribution if the member is vocally weak as long as they aren't silenced completely bc I for example like exo and you won't ever catch me complain when Sehun has a bit less of lines bc he simply isn't the strongest vocally, it just is what it is but he's treated way better when before he would say nothing or 3 words.
Just like in IVE it is fine if- I was gonna say my bias but they're one of those bands where I like everyone equally-anyway if vocally less strong members don't get lines, that's cool, it's FINE. But line distribution IS a big deal when the idol in question is literally the best vocalist in the group and most of the singing is handed to the other members.
I'm not saying vocal performance is the only important thing, just that an amazing vocal performance can add so much value and life to a song as well and yet at the same time, I couldn't imagine certain lines being sung by LIZ regardless of how technically better she is bc I simply enjoyed the way Rei or Gaeul would sing their parts, but there has to be a BALANCE. I wished you would've put more nuance in that part bc it's a big difference if a bad vocalist gets no parts vs a very good vocalist. It's not even about selfish reasons like "I need to hear my bias sing" but the art itself. Kpop is already soulless enough as it is and they have a chronic issue with creativity and technicality in regards to vocal performance (adlibs, harmonies, PROPER harmonies, runs etc) that a lot of songs tend to feel flat and it's why it's all the more satisfying when a song is actually interesting in a technical aspect.
I didn't even mean to rant that much but the other day I saw ole girl sing her thing and it saddened me bc you could tell she revels in it. Ik some idols are glad when they don't have too much lines since they work sm but when you can feel the idol WANTS to sing, for gods sake their companies need to fucking LET em. Kpop companies are notorious for wasting talent bc they only care about the new hottest thing once they debuted their other and dgaf about nurturing who they debuted after that and those idols really suffered to get where they are it shouldn't be in vain.
Single Albums aren't YG s idea but Kpops. I know why you would think, why YG not releasing music contributes to it but back in the old days producing Kpop was expensive to a degree that it wasnt done during hard times until the comunity starten to produce single and mini albums, which were treated like full albums (with tours and merch)
Honesty a single album is a very kpop think to do and contributes to the succes oft kpop (back than and even now)
😁
Everglow Zombie was more Purple Kiss than Purple Kiss' Zombie
And you really made me realizie how idc about line distribution anymore after this vid.
I liked Rockstar, it felt refreshing. Some people need to understand that not all songs need to have a deep meaning, some are just meant to be catchy. In my opinion is a lot better than lalisa or money, I feel like she fits the style better. I would love if her next music focuses more on dancing.
I love Lisa but her music pretty mediocre considering how talented she is and the access she has to great music producers and such and this was her time to shine but she kinda dropped the ball, blackpink in general music has been pretty subpar and forgettable, their kinda overrated if you match their music to their success, it doesn’t add it and they seem like a group more popular cause of hype than how good their music has been throughout the years, yes their talented but their talent has not accounted for their success its more so hype and riding off that hype and your right kpop fans don’t seem to know what they want and just like to find things to complain about that’s why idols should just do them and do their best and not focus so much on what wishy washy fans want as long as their not being disrespectful or offensive, I never cared about line distribution cause those that gonna shine gonna shine and stand out regardless, winter stage presence is fine, I like her icy cold vibe onstage hence the name, there’s something drawing people to her fancams over and over again and it ain’t just hate watching otherwise they’d just stop watching her fancams since they find her so “robotic” if you don’t like it focus your attention on a member that appeals to you instead of constantly complaining about the ones that don’t
Ok ~OPINION DUMP~
Personally I LOVED Rockstar call me biased. Lisa didn't play it safe at all, she could've been between vocal kpop performance and full hyperpop and given average of nothing. But she dared and went the cyberpunk route which was PERFECT This gave be Brat By Charlie XCX vibes (it's good 👀) and cyberpunk and I LOVED IT the chorus was finally complete and not just catchy. The verses were cool. People hate autotube, but lisa used it in the BEST way, the rap was sick and the final beat synth fusion was everything. In my opinion i loves this song. Lalisa felt missing yet it felt like 10 songs, this feels like a COMPLETE good good song, though a bit short
I like the song and I’m not saying this because I’m a Lisa biased but I like these type of sounds and that chorus “I’m a rockstar” is addictive to me
The song isn’t my cup of tea but she is killing it. Congrats!
I Dislike about Jennie acting in that kinda Show And Lisa in crazy horse show but i Respect them I really lose Hope in jennie,rose,jisoo album/ song even tho they left the Company but lisa also disappointed me with her Songs i really don't like rockstar but she slayed the new woman with Roselia.
BOO for single albums!
I AN GONNA SAY IT, BP and specially Lisa, are OVERRATED OVER HYPED FOR LITERAL NOTHING. They are giving us NOTHING
Fr I used to love them
You should credit fancams that you use.
Heyyyy
Hey how u been
@@misssunnybae1074can u painfully stfu about Lisa damn y'all always complaining god damn ok it's ur opinion but girl some people like Lisa tittle tracks btw Lisa actually wrote this song herself bitch so yea.
another opinion Is that y'all are sleeping on kiss of life way too muchhhh like those girls have overflowing talents and have amazing songs but they're still slept on this just shows that kpop fans nowadays don't really care about talent
I don’t agree with the Lisa one. Please listen to the song and try to understand it, it has nothing to do with being pretty. It’s about people thinking that because you’re Asian so you’re Japanese or Chinese. Because you’re Asian so everyone looks the same. She also talks about being a catch and kill for the third party. And all this going with the MV.
The song isn’t about that it’s one single line that y’all assume is about that.
@@AUGHHHHHBBG no you can read it yourself and look at the video. There are some rappers who did the reaction video and also said the same things
You can’t make the whole song about one line she says. Tell me what has being a rockstar to do with racism
@@jessicadallet they didn’t say the whole song was about racism…
@@Yunjin___ rockstar here is not to with the rockstar artist or the genre. Rockstar here is more being rebellious. If you noticed in the mv there is some famous people from the LGBTQ community