“If You Won't Answer My Question, We’ll Give Up” Julia Hartley-Brewer Clashes With Palestinian Envoy
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 жов 2023
- Britain is urging Israel to restore the supply of water to Gaza as Downing Street refuses to say whether the ally is complying with international law during its siege.
Rishi Sunak’s spokesman said on Tuesday that water is a key issue in UK efforts to “relieve the unfolding humanitarian issues” facing Palestinians.
The official said that talks are ongoing with Israel as the UK is “keen to see water restored”, while fuel, food and medicine is also being prevented from entering the territory.
Former Palestinian envoy Manuel Hassassian tells TalkTV’s Julia Hartley-Brewer that thinks a “proportionate response” from Israel would be: “Killing the entire 2.2 million people, because this is what Israel is doing.”
Julia Hartley-Brewer: "Would you invite Hamas to tea? What are you suggesting?"
#talktv #talkradio #israel #israelconflict #hamasattack #palestine #gaza
Hamas accusing Israel of bombing civilians while hamas is using those civilians as a human shield is the typical mind games you'd expect from a narcissist.
They are evil, plain evil.
What about when Israel was bobming civilians before hamas existed?
@@user-di2nf5ym5l give ONE example of when that happened. You can't.
They improsined them. Thiefs.
@@user-di2nf5ym5ldo you have example of Israel bombing Palestinians before Hamas exist and outside of war?
@@osamamanasserathey imprisoned “people” that were involved in the terror attacks against civilians (including Muslim Arabs)
Palestinians should be self sufficient in water and electricity.
I'll go further by saying the multiple billions given in aid, Gaza should be a luxury resort, 'but' Palestinians prefer to vote in terrorists who spend humanitarian money on rockets, guns ammunition and luxury homes elsewhere.
Palestines are trying to get their land back Israeli is doing everything to get rid of Palestine people what a shame It was theirs before and after Free Palestine
Who gave billions dollars in Aid?
It wasactually looking pretty nice before last week. Check the before and after pictures they're posting ....
FFS Israel does not allow Gaza to be self sufficient. They control everything that goes in or out.
Gaza has some very nice places, restaurants shops etc it's not all bombed out buildings as the media show you that's just propaganda
It’s impossible to talk with them. What a curse to have neighbours like this.
true
Welcome to life in Israel...
Reaching our arms forward just to get bitten and then getting condemned by the UN for slapping back.
Terrible!!@@intsccents
@@etstamar4063yeah reaching your arms or stealing a land and killing the people of that land for refusing to hand it over. Man it is crazy how the world is still justifying this and accusing Palestinians of hatred 😂
@@DimaObeidat-pn9ls Palestinian officials use their people as pawns in order to bank money from foreign aid.
Say what you want about peace but the moment it is offered they say no.
Every Palestinian leader is a billionaire.
I hate when somebody is refusing to answer a direct question.
His refusal to answer says it all
totally!
No, the Israelis are exactly the same, they answer a question with another question because neither side can ever admit that what THEY have done is wrong even when that is blindingly obvious to everyone. That is why there is no progress in 50 years and won't be for another 50.
Exactly
Don't attack another country, and stop using your own people as a shield.
Don't imprison 2.3 million people in a concentration camp and humiliate them and play the victim when they've had enough
The funny thing is that it's not their land. Israel is a state of occupation that has engaged in ethnic cleansing and the forced removal of the original inhabitants from their land for many years. You should read the history first.
@@sturdevantphotography5726- Exactly, and that’s from a white British native!
@@Phil_Downawell6 - the rainbow flag is an obvious plant, but thick people like to think there is a link … 🤣😂🤣 It’s folk like you that believe in School Plays! Beyond the media, have you any kind of critical thought process beyond Google? 🤔
@@sturdevantphotography5726 No it's not you're lying or know nothing about this. Israel was supplying water, electricity, food. They have a border with Egypt the whole time as well, is Egypt also responsible for creating a prison or was it just your bad rhetoric?
They have no answer for their actions.
I think Julia is my new favourite journalist! no BS and she is only interested to getting to the truth and saying exactly what she thinks.
Yeah right..."the truth".....are you actually aware who she work for, and who owns News Corp. which is holding company of subsidiary companies News UK and Talk TV?? Do your due diligence and educate yourself before posting nonsense
You might like to add Goebbels, Himmler and Hitler to your "favourites".
BTW: Since when is it "journalism" to be "saying exactly what the journalist thinks" talking like a cheap parrot over the person being interviewed ?
... and Where the truth has since emerged (e.g Haaretz reporting) that the name "Hannibal" should replace "Hamas" for the majority of 7 Oct killing ... and as the vast majority of world look on with absolute REVULSION at USUK (Father & Mother of the vile colonial carbuncle) military, financial and political support & protection of their theocratic Zionist nuke armed military outpost ... and the grossest GENOCIDE atrocity unfolded:
Answer to yourself this question:
What is the difference between "Hamas" / Palestinian resistance and ZZW-ZOB Warsaw Ghetto Resistance uprising against the invader-occupation Nazis who dispossessed = stole from, mass murdered and corralled Jews under siege .. or those in Treblinka & Sobibor concentration extermination camps?
I'll tell you 1 difference: The ZS=Zionist State colonials average daily kill rate of Gaza women and children exceeds what Nazis did in Auschwitz.
"getting to the truth and saying exactly what she thinks" are rarely the same thing with this lot. You people! :D
He’s a great representative for the people of Hamas, Gazans and all their sympathizers, showing the world how morally and factually dishonest they are.
Well said!
'the people of Hamas' ?? You mean Palestinian people of course. Hamas is 30,000 people in a population of 2.2m! You think Hamas is a country? The country is called Gaza.
Absolutely. He has no rational answers because evil doesn't make any sense.
@@autumnsea7848Israel makes no sense at all then.
So true, evading questions with nonsense 75 years digression, answer the damn question, what is the suitable response? Give more money to Hamas to buy more rockets?
Has anybody seen an interview with any reasonable representative of Palestine that's willing to answer these kinds of questions?
Because they all support what Hamas did.
Yeah, kinda, Piers Morgan interviewed some Oxford educated dude who started the interview by saying how appalled he was at the apparent behavior of those Hamas asswipes, of course he quickly continued that he was also appalled by the mounting death toll on the Gaza side, which I guess I mostly agree with, however my problem is just how "innocent" is the average Palestinian living in Gaza, I'd like to think the vast majority are civil folk, but those images of men and adolescents swarming the returning pickups with the Hamastards so they could beat or in some way devile the poor souls lying on the back of the truck made my blood boil.
Do you think the question is reasonable?
Asking a person how much of your people must be killed to be a proportionate response from your enemy is not a reasonable question to answer.
@@alienfish8521yeah the same way the west support what israel did for the last 70 years.
@@m_sh_shokouhiit is a reasonable question. When they say “it’s a disproportionate” response
They are the asked “well, what would be an acceptable and proportional number of civilians that Israel should kill in this conflict?”
Hamas murdered 1000 Israeli civilians in this attack. There must be a response - and a ground war will happen.
He said “if somebody plans something they have to bear the consequences”. So?
And he is right
The irony of that statement!
When they say “occupation” they are never referring to Gaza or the West Bank as people suppose- they mean the state of Israel.
Occupation in israel Is like England occupied land from the Muslims in london today🤣
For what purpose would ordinary civilians dig a labyrinth of tunnels?
To resist occupation?
Nah, Israel gave Gaza to them.@@JH-lf4ql
To take cover when being bombarded. But ‘Hamarse’ are using them for their own protection.
ask the vietnamese
Because that's how rat's live
It’s literally like banging your head against a wall with these people.
Now you are beginning to know what Israel has been putting up with for the last 75 years.
It's like it's been 75 years and they still havn't figured out they lost the first war yet.
@@twelvecatsinatrenchcoatwell that's called resistance
That's exactly it.@@twelvecatsinatrenchcoat
@@mya4126 What happened at that concert was not resistance. Do you know what the tagline of that festival was? "friends, love and infinite freedom."
Thank you Julia for being the voice of reason!
Julia, your Mom.
Yeah the voice of ignorance
Amazing how incoherent they become
When hit with a simple question
this man makes the case for how you can't reason with these people
He makes the case for why siblings shouldn't procreate.
These people?
OF course you only want to hear “WE CONDEMN HAMAS “ . You will never get it lol
@@ricardodeguzman8287yes, this people.
That’s right
A beautiful display of evil by Manuel Hassassian.
Evil = Brainwashed fanatic. He bluntly says so many lies....
What is the evil he displayed here?
@@Potato-tf3hv ignore the massacre of oct 7 and accuse israel of lies while hamas-isis
@@Potato-tf3hv
It is evil to call that which is wrong as it being right.
Since Hassassian cannot identify or admit, to anything being wrong on his side, he is claiming perfection.
Check the facts and see how righteous his Judgment is.
She’s good. She asks very precisely the right questions.
It seems as if these people truly believe their own lies...
They do!Thats why you can’t reasoning with them.
Talking about the Pro Israelis right?
The only good aspect of these interviews is that the real views of these people is clearly shown to us. The lies are mind blowing.
Sort of like most politicians, huh? 😏😏
These are not serious people.
could not agree with you more, thankfully Julia is very good are drawing this out, ironically as a woman she would not be allowed to have her job in Gaza.
😂😂😂😂
Yes, the western MEDIA lies! They are NOT reporting the news ANYMORE! They are reporting THEIR views, so ANYONE who disagrees with their views is labelled as anti-whatever! There you have it, FAKE NEWS!
Those people can never answer questions about their wrong doing.
Which is telling because it's absolutely possible to find Israelis who will condemn the IDF and Bibi. The Kibbutz' hamas attacked are famously super liberal places, they're literally socialist communes, the people Hamas attacked were Israel's peaceniks, a bunch of hippies at a music festival.
BOTH sides can’t admit it
@@JeromeBirdshead-yt1hu incorrect. This "both sides/Israel is the bad one" has been engraved into people's head for decades now. There is no moral equivelance between both sides. In the handful of cases throughout this conflict where Israeli citizens/organizations or the government has committed appauling murders, there has been a taking of responsibility.
Problem is, everytime Israel retaliates to a terror attack and in the gunfight between IDF and terrorists innocents die, this is being marketed as an "atrocitie" and a "crime" israel has to admit fault in.
The many casualties in Gaza from the start of this war, and the many more yet to come, are not Israel's wrong doings they are Hamas's.
Because the gist of the issue is not what she is asking. She is a typical UK media talking head
In the Middle East "NOW!" Doesnt exist just the irrational momentum of unreflective belief...
In year 2005 Israel removed from Gaza.
2006 Hamas won election and remove all rivals.
In year 2007 to 2012, United Nations give 7.7 billions to Hamas.
In year 2014, another 5.4 Billions was given to develop Gaza.
Another 2014 to 2020 4.5 billions was given to Gaza by international community and many more.
Total 17.6 Billions went into Gaza.
Yet Gaza still look like slum while Hamas leadership live in luxurious lifestyle???
What did Hamas do with the fund ? Give to Palestinians??
The "oh here we go" is priceless
They don't have food or medicine, but they seem to have a lot of rockets and rifles.
Israel gave them money, allowed hundreds of millions of dollars to come from Qatar, and what did they do with that money?
In the last 5 years, no school and no hospital was built in Gaza.
Guess what was bought and built in this time?
Exactly! If Palestine was given the freedom they're asking for, God knows what would happen to humanity!
@tluangafanai8202 there wouldn't be any
Ben Shapiro is one of the smartest men who ever walked the earth 😂😂 you remind me of him
No food or medicine and yet they went from 200,000 in 1948 to 2.2 million today....... wow. defies science
"Open air concentration camp..."
Give me a break. How do prisoners get so many rockets?
And hospitals, university… etc etc…
Very expensive one considering the amount of international financial aid to Palestine throughout the years.
The Egyptian border has been open for at least 10 years so palistinans are not prisoners what they hate is Israel have put up blockades to stop palistinans entering Israel to kill Jews ,so there are check points.egypt have now closed their border to Gaza/ palistine because of the Hamas attack on Israel,so it's Egypt who have put them in prison not Israel.
No only that. Look at the individual combat equipment they are sporting...They all carry between 1000 and 2000 dollars in military gear. Not old and worn stuff but prime quality killing equipment.
One of the richest terrorist groups with the the poorest people in the middle east. Couldn't agree more...it ain't a prison if they received until the war work permits,food,water,medicine,money 😅 also hamas officials have a revenue of 4 billion dollars each living in Qatar just saying
'They' cannot ever answer the question, cause they don't have an answer...
he simply can’t answer a straightforward question.
go search what israel did tge last time gaza protested peacfully , i'll give you a hint many got killed by snipers .
Of course he can't because he is on the side of IQ60 scum's "logic"
@@peloleoj691once again, not talking about the topic at hand.
Those were riots not protests. They were actively calling for the death of Jews and trying to break passed a wall that Israel was protecting. Please wake up and read more beyond headlines. In fact, I would suggest you take more time to get into Israel’s reasons for doing what they are doing instead of ignoring that for your own political convenience.
@@randomdude6675they like the what about
Palestinians elected Hamas ..wtf?!
%44.75 of palestinians voted for Hamas'. The rest voted for FATA.
Not quite so 'innocent' civilians?....
Well duh
Yeah, they did. These were the last elections for parliament in Gaza - Hamas won. Then they overthrew the Fatah government in an armed coup. The support for Hamas in Gaza is immense.
Yeah but from what I have learned it was more of a "if we find out you didn't vote for us, we will kill you" type thing. I also have been told they killed those who ran against them after the "election."
Yes, back in 2006 and then stopped any further elections. Nearly half of Palestinian citizens weren't even ALIVE in 2006!
Wow frustrating. I don't think i would have the same patience and composure as Julia consistently demonstrates while dealing with these people. It was a SIMPLE QUESTION that deserved a direct answer. Ughhhhh!
Yeah I get the frustration he didn't handle the questions correctly however still he was talking facts and he is clearly frustrated himself we don't blame him we talk about the Palestinian ppl and all the news can talk about is Hummus and when we mention Israel war crimes here comes the diplomatic BS escape answers
Julia is incredible. I would have lost my cool 2 seconds into the interview
She is amazing. Never knew her. But I admire her from the few videos I am seeing.
Rediculas perception,she is very bias
“It’s ok to invade others but it’s not ok when they get back at you” is what he’s saying
Exactly, you don't want issues, don't invade and oppress in the first place!
Absolutely right. The West Bank is being colonized by a larger and larger number of people accompanied by killings and noone ever cared about that or gave voice to that. Right! Do not invade the territory of others. I agree
Israel is the illegal Occupier, by International Law, you forget that small detail. And it is not defending itself if it is the Occupier. Just use your logic and don't fall for the lies.
1400 YEARS OF MUSLIM EVIL, IT WILL NEVER STOP!
@@lejlachandraromano8951Do your history and research. Jewish people have been walking the land of ancient Israel which was known as Judea back then before Islam was even founded. History didn't start in 1948.
He is defending the people who have been ruling over his people for years and making their lives hell .
Because he is one of those responsible.
Yes. He’s a supporter.
Why should the Jews care, when Islam demands the death of all non believers.
Because if he badly talk about them he is gone
do you even understand what occupation means 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Great juournalism. One of the best intervews I saw in decades.
He didn't want to a answer any question she asked, and yet, she managed to expose his lies and true opnion.
What lies? If you deny that Israel is an instigator here you are complicit in the genocide by Israel.
Impressive! A professor, this stupid and totally void of empathy is just sad.
A professor in ... evil
You clearly havn't met many professors.
when he said to kill all 2.2 m Gazans - thats the only thing he said that makes sense.
He made a lot of good points. But it is difficult to debate a woman who wants to talk only about babies, hostages and the elderly .... the typical women's talk points
@@gdiwolverinemale4thhe didn't give even one good point.
He has a mental block against condemning Hamas.
The same way you couldn't do it neither the western wold when it comes to israel crimes in the last 70 years against palestinians.
That is because he supports them
I agree
.I agree df
He's a Muslim logic in denail it's BN Palestine tat always BN causing the trouble in the past
Its because their Ministry of Health is a Hamas entity and they say they don't differentiate between a terrorist killed or a civilian.
A crash course on history of the PALESTINIAN STATE:
1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, not a Palestinian state
2. Before the British Mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
3. Before the Ottoman Empire, there was the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state.
4. Before the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish Empire, not a Palestinian state.
5. Before the Ayubid Empire, there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state.
6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, not a Palestinian state.
7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, there was the Byzantine empire, not a Palestinian state.
8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, not a Palestinian state.
9. Before the Sassanid Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state.
10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
11. Before the Roman Empire, there was the Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state.
12. Before the Hasmonean state, there was the Seleucid, not a Palestinian state.
13. Before the Seleucid empire, there was the empire of Alexander the Great, not a Palestinian state.
14. Before the empire of Alexander the Great, there was the Persian empire, not a Palestinian state.
15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state.
16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state.
17. Before the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was the Kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state.
18. Before the kingdom of Israel, there was the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, not a Palestinian state.
19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an agglomeration of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state.
20. Actually, in this piece of land there has been everything, EXCEPT A PALESTINIAN STATE.
A little more history for those wanting to 'restore Palestine'.
In 132 AD the Emperor Hadrian resolved to stamp the Jews and their religion out of existence. He sold all Jewish prisoners into slavery after the revolt of Bar Kikhba, forbade the teaching of the Torah, renamed the province Syria Palaestina, and changed Jerusalem’s name to Aelia Capitolina. He renamed Israel to wipe out the national identity of Israel and the Jews.
So if you are looking to 'restore Palestine to the Palestinians', you need to give it back to the Jews.
Brilliant!!!
He ultimately excuses hamas, they all do.
That's not the issue though, we expect this from Arab and Africa, what we do not accept is why britain and france continue to pander to Arabs whilst holding Israel by the balls with a bullshit Balfour declaration and 2 state solution. Europe is an absolute embarrassment to the west
he is the same as hamas
@@mohamedmoussa8028Judging by your comment you are exactly like him. Incapable of discerning between good and evil
@@lucasrealesOn point response 👍
@@lucasrealesthe occupation is simply evil.
You have never ever accepted the 2 state solution from 1947 onwards!
Who would give away their land No one
Yeah 2 state where israel takes the house and palestine takes the bathroom when palestinians owned the whole house.
So please my family is Jewish and lived in Morocco and got kicked out. Why don’t you give me their land back?
And on that note, Jews who lived in iraq, Iran, Syria, Egypt, Germany, Poland, Hungary and more - give us our lands back!
They are just incapable of making everything good.
Look at the Rimmal neighborhood, of the leaders of Hamas. How come is this neighborhood so rich and nicely built?
@@EdenBados Where are you living in tents you have nothing to eat than fight your own land because you have nothing but you have everything why would u care
@@Cindy22794it wasn’t their land in the first place.
He said and me no food no electricity but his back ground looks safe and wear looks clean
Sadly,the majority of palestinians support hamas,
Pokes the bear, gets mauled by the bear, blames the bear.
According to them, Hamas murderous, animalistic, attack, was a natural answer to Israeli aggression. But Israeli bombings cannot be a natural answer to a murderous, animalistic attack by Hamas...Arab logic. Go figure!
So he's saying Hammas acted, Israel responded and the homelessness of 1.2 million Palestinians is proof of Israel's poor treatment of Palestinians. The logic is utterly insane.😢
He is correct. Ask Hamas these questions. Y ask him?
No. Did you not listen.
He said that Israel acted for 75 years, then Hammas acted.
How on earth did you misunderstand that?
@@SamS-uv2qlThat's an over simplification. The history is very complex and its possible to see for most of those 75 years the reasons why Israel did what they did and same goes for the Palestinians. It's not clear cut at all. Yes the Isralies have committed war crimes but so have Hamas and the reason for this is that Israel is ruthlessly shall we say trying to survive and Hamas want to wipe Israel off the face of the earth. None of the Arab states particularly want Jews to have their own State and many attempts have been made to ensure that Jews not only shouldn't have a homeland but should be erased altogether. It's ugly but this is primitive human nature in action - Tribal War where the innocent always suffer.
Bc it's BS@@SamS-uv2ql
@@SamS-uv2qlIs that the first time Hamas have attacked?
This woman should Not be allowed on air …. She dismisses the loss and Ethnic cleansing of ppl….
He talks about 75 years of occupation and genocide. How about 2005? If Israel is an occupier and a terrorist, then why did they give all of Gaza to the Arabs for independence in 2005? Jews left Gaza, leaving their homes and plantations.
So far, every Palestinian apologist has proven themselves to be batshit crazy
Of course, they are muslim.
I question if people like you are real or bots because there’s no way…😮
@@Phenomshooter ... I'm sorry, but your reply confused me. Could you please rephrase it?
I've watched Palestinian Solidarity Campaign’s Professor Kamel Hawwash; Palestinian Ambassador Husam Zomlot; Bassem Yousef; Mohammed Hijab and Hasan Abi. They all shouted, interrupted and acted like what we in the West call "rude people" to say the least. But that's the standard in the Middle East and the image they put forward, to their own disgrace.
@@davidgreen6490 shame on you zioniste .
'Here we go!' Ask him if he's visited Palestine recently. If the answer is yes, ask him how he managed to escape from, as he claims, this open prison?
Should have asked him where the factual proof of a place called Palestine is. Other than east Palestine found in America.
20,000 of the 2 million are allowed out per day.
Palestine isn’t an open prison. Gaza is.
he didn't need to escape....he's a friend of the jailers.
They came out from Gaza totally in 2005, uprooting ancient Jewish existence from there too. And for what? They just talk about ‘occupation’ like before the withdrawal.
2.2m voted HAMAS into government. So in Gaza, HAMAS is Gaza. Sadly so.
Impossible when one side refuses to acknowledge the right of the other to exist..
There is no basis in international law to acknowledge a countries 'right to exist'. Countries simply come and go.
@@deficrypto1234Did the person you are responding to cite international law? Because if they didn't, your point is irrelevant.
@@SamS-uv2ql Doesnt matter cos he used the word 'right'. that word is always enshrined in law. If a law doesnt categorically state a right, ur not entitled to it. No law states that any entity or country must acknowledge another countries 'right to exist' (whateever that meaningless statement means).
@@deficrypto1234 No one made the claim that anyone is breaking the law by not recognising a other countries right to exist.
You are barking up the wrong tree here
But they keep losing and losing every single war they start against them, and then complain that they win too hard.@@deficrypto1234
How Hamas can get finance for 5000 rockets but they cant get money for food and medical care? Seriously. Thats the issue with the Palestinians they can’t have people who can debate apart the ambassador of Palestinian in UK.
Hamas use all the so many Billions they get from other countries for terror. Gaza could be like Hong Kong
Cos Palestine get millions each year from foreign aid
@MrRic716... That's an excellent question. It takes a ton of money and resources to run a war campaign. There's a lot of moving parts, logistics etc and all this require donors. Where/who is this money from?
@@LoinheartleoEveryone! Including the US AND Israel!!
@@madmelwood3778 billions
If he could only hear the contradictions coming out of his mouth.
He did not know where to get his answers to a simple questions😂😂😂
They never answer ONE question. It's as if they were trained to deflect.
Their atitude often reminds me of the way narsicists answer questions.
live one day like they do. after that try to not be like them
Trained by RUZZIA.
Like that irritating repeating promotion on radio every 10 minute for a product that promise something totally different than what you actually get if you buy the product...
Of course.. they are muslims..
CAN YOU JUST ASNWER YES OR NO, he didn't answer BUT HIS HEAD WAS SHAKING HE KNOWS!
This man KNOWS he is lying.
Israel has offered Arabs the possibility of State in the 2006 Peace Proposal where Israel would remove settlers from Arab territories, just as it did in Gaza in 2005 and Sinai in 1982. People insist on talking about settlers as permanent issues when in reality Israel has removed settlers from territories whenever peace was at stake. Apart from that, they offered Arabs a corridor connecting the Gaza Strip to the West Bank.
India does not give Bangladesh a corridor to connect the enclave of Dahagram-Angarpota. Azerbaijan does not give Armenia a corridor to Artsvashen. Germany does not give Austria a corridor to connect to Jungholtz. Congo does not offer a corridor to Angola's enclave of Cabinda. Servia does not offer a corridor to Bosnia and Herzegovina's enclave of Medurecje. Nicaragua does not offer a corridor to Colombia's enclave of Quintasueno. Mozambique does not offer a corridor for Malawi to connect to its enclave of Likoma Island and Chizumulu Island. Papua New Guinea does not offer a corridor to Australia's enclave of Torres Straight Island. In reality, no country, apart from Israel, ever offered a neighbour a corridor to connect an enclave. Nevertheless, for the Arabs, Israel's offer was not enough. The proposal was rejected because Arabs did not want to accept the Arabs in Israel into their territories, despite Israel accepting back any Israelis from Arab territories.
Up until today, the Palestinian Arabs have not put forward their own proposal of Peace with a Two State Solution...But they have criticised every single proposal the Israelis made. I think, at one point, we have to start thinking that Arab political elites are not really interested in Peace and Prosperity and free elections (which have not occurred in Gaza or West Bank since 2005). A Palestinian State would mean free elections and the end of both Hamas and Mahmoud Abbas.
They always answer a question with a reference to something completely different
His problem is he thinks that Israel is Palestinian land. Which it's not. She should have asked him, "If Israel belongs to the Palestinians, where is the Jewish state ?". He probably thinks there is none.
ugh, i was seriously listening and trying to understand his answer, when it was it feels like he was spewing the right word, advertisement played. I had to finish the advertisement, at least im helping TalkTV. Going back, the answer becomes the victim card, circling, and was not addressed. What was for me is clear. He doesnt want 2 state resolution. If I am Israeli, it is very difficult to deal this kind of people. it feels like im talking to a wall i get nothing at all.
He goes on about the "occupation" of Gaza. How is Gaza occupied? Israel, in 2005, evacuated all 21 settlements and all 8000 residents plus soldiers, leaving not a single Jew in Gaza. They hoped for peace, but it became a disaster. Again, how is Gaza occupied?
They did not hope for peace, they hoped that a people who had their land stolen from them would just accept it. If you were forcibly removed from your home would you resist?
When you control food,water,medicine that goes in and don't let anyone out or in that''s what you call evacuated ?
Go educate yourself, just because they left in 2007 don't change the fact the built a wall arpund Gaza, they controll what goes in and goes out in terms of Import/export, they monitor the whole strip, the sea is controlled by Israel they can't leave when you want, their is no airport. Egypt has to approve your entry. Its an open air prison with the Hamas running the cells.
@@peloleoj691here’s a novel idea … build your own fucking country and water and power grid.
Jeez, they clearly have ability to build a tunnel system under 200 foot of earth. Instead of cutting water pipes up to make rockets …. Join them together and build water sysyem.
They left on condition of non agression and in return got rocket attackd every time hamas didnt agree with israel policy🙄
If this man represents anyone, G'd help them!
Has corruption filled their government positions with the complete incompetent and brought this mess on?
Why God would help them? They are such an embarrassment and disappointed of human race. I actually not sure they are completely god fearing humans.
There imaginary sadistic God already abandoned them.
@@angelakakaras1997ask israel if they are any better .
YES TERRORISTS
God's pacince is enormous but when his punishment come woe to Israel she will be doomed.
So Hamas has taken a stand on behalf of the Palestinians..... then Isreal has right to take a stand on behalf of Israelites.
This so called Journalist should be removed from her position. She is biased and very unprofessional in her approach. She shouts at all her guests & refuses to understand that the Palestinians have been oppressed for 75 years. Journalists should not be allowed to express their personal option. Julia is a word that rhymes with hunt.
He is wrong that "Israel is attacking civilians" as the target. That is NOT the target. The target is to attack hamas, and unfortunately people who are near Hamas might die there, but they are not the target. He is illogical.
Erm, Gaza is one of the most densely populated areas on earth. Half of the entire population are children. If we remove women and the elderly, hamas represents a tiny minority of the population. As mentioned in the interview they have access to tunnels, so it's likely they won't even be on the land. Anyone who thinks that bombing Gaza will destroy hamas is either completely stupid, or supports targeting innocent civilians on purpose.
If u hit a residential building knowing fully well I am sitting eating a meal with my family, ur attacking me. Till u provide conclusive evidence that Hamas militants are in the buidling, once I see that missile coming into my living room, ur attacking ME! Its not complicated.
So when Ukraine defend their land they are welcomed as hero’s by the western media.
When the Palestine defend their land they are called terrorist.
Media are cancer of this world 🌎!
He is playing a fool, but he is a cunning fox, who will never condemn Hamas
They live in the past 2000yrs ago and contribute nothing but grief to the world.
Julia had him absolutely rattled.
Yeah, he was probably thinking "if we were in my Islamic country we'd all be out stoning you right about now!!!" Honestly, it's like these people are a different species to us "normal" folks!!! As my father was fond of saying, "the easiest way of living is the best", God knows haven't we enough to worry about with disease, global warming etc etc etc without trying to kill each other?
@@brendandoherty2159yeah you lot and your moral high ground exactly why israel is in this right now the same thinking you have to treat palestinians as second class citizens.
@@brendandoherty2159you know this type of thinking is what brought slavery and colonialism upon the world. Go read the history of Palestine and Israel to see that those Palestinians, Hamas included, are doing what every American would do if someone came to their land and killed them and their loved one out of it because they want to create the so called “Jews state” in the expense of innocent people.
She was crying zzzz
@@peloleoj691Yeah, just the type of moral high ground that said Charlie Hebdo wasn't justified or Manchester and Beslan. Closed minded moralists.
What was Palestinian government doing when tunnels were being dug , if Hamas is not Palestine. It's a pity that a country resorts to seek help from terrorists to undo the wrongs they have been facing for 75 years. Decades ago the patriots & nationalists would fight for their sovereignty. Why couldn't they invest on their county's development instead of building tunnels across the country! Such sturdy constructions must have huge investments while the people were still poor!
They want a two state solution? Since when? He says they've rescued it for 30 years, but it has been offered to them many times over 75 years, including a bunch in the last 30 years.
This dude, what a snake! Well done Julia !
Julia is spot on! How many times have we heard "The hospital has 12hours of power left"?? I've heard it for 4 days straight now.
You don't need to worry about that anymore
What is your point?
@rickokabir94 the point being that the goalpost kèep moving, just like the cameras in the faces of the people who are crying and hurt. How do these news items get through the barricade and how come there are so many people filming.
Well Israel has just blew it up so that's the end of the fuel problem.
@@ethalminiellis3032 news reporters are probably scared of Hamas. Hamas controls Gaza and the only way journos can report is by doing so with Hamas approval. Reporters want their stories out and there we are.
If as he says Hamas does not represent the Palestinian people, why are they still holding on to power since 2006? The strong case for Palestinians was the need for "self-determination"! The world agreed with them and gave all support. So, what is the next stage for those in Ghaza in the direction of "self-determination"? It looks like they are not going to get it from their own people or their occupiers!
This tragic situation in Gaza is why I was so confused when I saw “Free Palestine” supporters dancing in the streets and celebrating all across the West after the October 7th attacks. Cuz like…..y’all HAD to know this was coming next, right? Especially if you think the state of Israel is an evil government. I’d be interested in speaking to the Muslim preacher who yelled at one of these protests that he was “happy” and “elated” to see if he still feels that way today.
Why are you not bringing up the fact that the land has always belonged to Israel for thousands of years and it is actually Palestinians who are occupying Israeli land and making life for them and the rest of the world
Well done Julia, its not easy dealing with these slippery war mongers.
Julia did great. Much better than Piers.
@@PB2001PB 👍
The best part of this interview
Julia : " oh here we go"
😅😅😅
ye, haha she did similar thing in couple of interviews already
She really knows how to deal with these loonies 😅
That's funny is it? These people have suffered for 70 odd years, she wants to be flippant and act like it's nothing and you find it funny?
@@alyssarosa1398 oh dear. It's a bit late to tug on the heartstrings, dear. We know the facts now. Maybe you should instead of trying to emotionally blackmail people into ignorance.
You hear the same talking points. Every. Time.
They see no wrong in what hamas has done.
But the retaliation they think is wrong .
Hamas is using the Palestinian people as a shield .
They should be condeming hamas for what they do to them.
I like your line of questions it's on point and addressing who acted and who reacted ❤
I worked in the M East for many years. They have a great ability to ignore the truth and divert your question. They will lie and look you straight in the eye. I had to record every meeting I went to to cover myself.
Yes. They say yes when they mean No.
Same here. I worked with and really with rich Muslim businessman and westernised Muslims but once you get on this topic they are all the same. Avoid taking religion and all will be ok, but scratch beneath the surface and to a man they are all dangerous extremists.
They seem to have no moral compass at all. They have rejected Judeo-Christian ethics in favour of a warped ideology in which those in power have no desire to help anyone except themselves. This warps everything they do and say. The disdain for the truth is the biggest problem, everything else stems from that.
leerobinson4078. you mean the Israelis right?
@@barflytom3273why are you assuming that? Do you have evidence.
The Palestinian authority has rejected peace plan for a separate Palestinian states and co-existence with Israel not one time but five times over the past decades. There nothing much can be done😢
Israel has offered Arabs the possibility of State in the 2006 Peace Proposal where Israel would remove settlers from Arab territories, just as it did in Gaza in 2005 and Sinai in 1982. People insist on talking about settlers as permanent issues when in reality Israel has removed settlers from territories whenever peace was at stake.
Apart from that, they offered Arabs a corridor connecting the Gaza Strip to the West Bank. India does not give Bangladesh a corridor to connect the enclave of Dahagram-Angarpota. Azerbaijan does not give Armenia a corridor to Artsvashen. Germany does not give Austria a corridor to connect to Jungholtz. Congo does not offer a corridor to Angola's enclave of Cabinda. Servia does not offer a corridor to Bosnia and Herzegovina's enclave of Medurecje. Nicaragua does not offer a corridor to Colombia's enclave of Quintasueno. Mozambique does not offer a corridor for Malawi to connect to its enclave of Likoma Island and Chizumulu Island. Papua New Guinea does not offer a corridor to Australia's enclave of Torres Straight Island. Nevertheless, for the Arabs, Israel's offer was not enough. The proposal was rejected because Arabs did not want to accept the Arabs in Israel into their territories, in spite of Israel accepting any Israelis in Arabs territories.
Up until today, the Palestinian Arabs have not put forward their own proposal of Peace with a Two State Solution...But they have criticised every single proposal the Israelis made.
I think, at one point, we have to start thinking that Arab political elites are not really interested in Peace and Prosperity and free elections (which have not occurred in Gaza or West Bank since 2005). A Palestinian State would mean free elections and the end of both Hamas and Mahmoud Abbas.
This is a big lie.
President abu Mazen accepted that and he has and still defending the security of Israel but unfortunately the stupid radical government represented by Netanyahu refused and continued on building new settlements on the occupied territories meaning they don't care about having a state for the Palestinian.
HAMAS attack on Oct 7 is not constitute a massacre according to Palestine🙄
Shame on this eccentric diplomat, can't answer a direct question.
Its a broken record, Only way this will end is if the people rise up and remove Hamas from power and allow Israel to remove weapons from the area.
That would be like saying in 1933 the Germans, after seeing where the Nazis were heading for, should have risen up against them. The East Germans couldn't do that. Propaganda plus fear of reprisals. Agents even within the family.
go search what israel did tge last time gaza protested peacfully , i'll give you a hint many got killed by snipers .
@@peloleoj691Show proof of it
@@slava-glory-ua8356 Ask Avi Yemeni. He was a sniper with the IDF, shooting Palestinians in the head and laughing about it with his colleagues.
@@peloleoj691 ive seen a lot of your replies, you need help and a lot of it.
I think there's a bigger chance of you winning the lottery than him answering the question.
If he could get an answer in edgeways the poor man she is so rude 😂
Or.... "it could be you!" (euromillions slogan) 😉👉🎫
Ms Julia, thank you for your endless patience in the dialogue with that Palestinian blue face journalist. She would not answer your question.
It looks like it is something in their genes.
Piers Morgan talked to many Palestinians by now. It was exactly the same! You ask them a question and they start speaking about something else.
SOOO FRUSTRATING !!!!
This man is part of problem. How will he criticize Hamas?
It's impossible to talk to people who claim that Gaza has been without food for 16 years, while 2 million people are still alive there.
Imagine thinking that you can't starve people without leting die.
And they’re breeding like rabbits too
@@mogznwaz Their goes the genocidal talk...
You can also see their “small bellies” in the videos
The usual Hama's tosh
You can never have a sensible conversation with a fanatic, Their logic is, we can commit an atrocity, that's okay, you retaliate and that is a crime against humanity ...!!! Old saying,, "You reap what you sow"..
True what they are seeing they indeed invited it.
From what I gather, he seems to say that Hamas's animalistic rampage was a natural answer to decades of Israeli oppression, but Israel is not allowed to answer to decades of terrorism. More than 2000 Israelis died in Arab/Muslim terrorist attacks since the Oslo accords (where Arabs promised not to use terrorism to achieve political aims).
Reasonable questions please only for reasonable people!!! Not for abject liars as him. Stop giving those guys any time and space!!!
Why you don't ask the same questions to Occupier & Zionist officials?!?
The people that represent/support Hamas or even Palestinian people deflect, deflect, deflect when asked reasonable questions. I’ve seen others ask the same question she asked about what would have been a proportionate response by Israel and not one of those who supposedly speak on behalf of the Palestinian people answer. Not once. Not one country in the world would just take it on the chin if the same happened to them.
Israel has offered Arabs the possibility of State in the 2006 Peace Proposal where Israel would remove settlers from Arab territories, just as it did in Gaza in 2005 and Sinai in 1982. People insist on talking about settlers as permanent issues when in reality Israel has removed settlers from territories whenever peace was at stake.
Apart from that, they offered Arabs a corridor connecting the Gaza Strip to the West Bank. India does not give Bangladesh a corridor to connect the enclave of Dahagram-Angarpota. Azerbaijan does not give Armenia a corridor to Artsvashen. Germany does not give Austria a corridor to connect to Jungholtz. Congo does not offer a corridor to Angola's enclave of Cabinda. Servia does not offer a corridor to Bosnia and Herzegovina's enclave of Medurecje. Nicaragua does not offer a corridor to Colombia's enclave of Quintasueno. Mozambique does not offer a corridor for Malawi to connect to its enclave of Likoma Island and Chizumulu Island. Papua New Guinea does not offer a corridor to Australia's enclave of Torres Straight Island. Nevertheless, for the Arabs, Israel's offer was not enough. The proposal was rejected because Arabs did not want to accept the Arabs in Israel into their territories, in spite of Israel accepting any Israelis in Arabs territories.
Up until today, the Palestinian Arabs have not put forward their own proposal of Peace with a Two State Solution...But they have criticised every single proposal the Israelis made.
I think, at one point, we have to start thinking that Arab political elites are not really interested in Peace and Prosperity and free elections (which have not occurred in Gaza or West Bank since 2005). A Palestinian State would mean free elections and the end of both Hamas and Mahmoud Abbas.
@@geraldrada👍🏻
What about people who represent / support Israel ? Stop the occupation, let Palestinians have their own country and you will have the peace !!!
@@TheNedlin Dude, Arabs had the Gaza Strip all for themselves and look at how much Peace they've made...Get a life.
The reason they deflect is because they hate Israel, and approve Hamas atrocities. By deflecting they try to hide they real thoughts and feelings.
These interviews sound the same. Same arguments, same justifications. Never listen, they read from the same script. Can’t reason with this individual.
you simply can't argue with some people. How does she merit any sort of media job when she obviously has no understanding of the facts. She should talk with Douglas Murray, Eylon Levy and Mark Regev instead.
Palestinians will pay a price for shielding and supporting hamas....the two are not 2 different entities as this gentleman is trying to make out
I like how she continues to press on what the appropriate response would be. Very telling.
"What would have them (Israel) do ? Invite them (Hamas) for tea? Perfect summary of the dilemma Israel faces
This final question she asks stumps them all!
This is very big problem no one is able to answer that question
He said if bombardments will stop, the hostage issue will be resolve. Question is, what is the purpose of hostaging? Why they are doing it.
The Nazis once said the same ignorant garbage. It’s disgusting how people so openly and in public spew their hatred towards a group of people who had no ill intent towards anyone yet over the centuries have endured the most horrific crimes against them known to mankind. This is just disgusting allowing these rabid antisemites airtime. Israel has a human right to exist and to live in peace. The world has gone batshit insane and there’s no getting better.
“That man said 800 babies have been killed” (By Israel) what a liar (just before 0:55)
Timjarvis, that is quite correct, Israel has every right to live in peace , what most of the people spewing their bile and vile hatred will not admit is that there are two sides to this conflict , two conflicting view points , Hamas has but one aim , the total destruction of Israel and all Jews at ,it would appear at any cost . Israel must defend itself otherwise there would be genocide on a scale to dwarf the Nazi atrocities. Whatever Hamas and it's supporters say , there is absolutely no justification for the appalling attack and the slaughter of innocent civilians, Hamas care nothing for the Palestinians and use them as human shields , contrary to popular belief Hamas do not have the overwhelming support of the Palestinian people but there is no tolerance for any dissenting view in that nation .I can see no end to this madness, such a bleak outlook.
@@FamilyViewers What a disgrace this Talkxic TV is with Julia Hartless Brewer, and her colleagues do these Churnalists think we are stupid and don't see the vile nature of the Israeli regime, even the True Jewish people have had enough of these war Crimes perpetrated in their name and have been demonstrating raising this issue for years, zionists hiding behind their anti semitic tropes, tens of thousand slaughtered in their Own homes unrelenting wholesale massacres these churnalists on their sickening moral high ground, while western arms manufacturers go laughing to the bank and she is trying to blame civilian Palestinians, some KARMA coming down the line for these individuals All attacks on people are inexcusable, but lets keep the attention on the victims as the culprits.
How about getting the arms dealers and producers on the " show " highlight them, but fat chance as these are the " people " behind these propagandists. " Let the welfare of the People be the Ultimate Law ' Cicero
I think it is valuable that people see them lying.
The Nazis Also managed to dehumanise the Jewish people this is how German people were able to turn a blind eye to the atrocities of the Nazi party. The Israeli and US government has managed to dehumanise Palestinians, whether it be the current defense minister referring to Palestinians as "human animals" or the former justice minister refering to palestinians as "snakes" and it goes well beyond that.
The idea that palestinians are supposed to sit quietly under a medieval siege that has lasted for 17 years, beraft of any dialogue that israel ever wishes to end it and just just accept it without any form of resistance is beyond the logic of any rational human. At the 2018 peaceful march of return 214 palestinians were murdered and 36,100 injured. This was without a single Israeli causality.
In the west bank where there has been a 50+ year millitary occupation over us, in which there has also been very little hope of an end. There is not only no dialogue for an end to it, but we are slowly watching our land being taken before our eyes to make way for settlements. When 2 of my uncles on seperate occasions were assaulted and threatened to be killed if they didnt leave our land, and the third time our olive plantations were burnt to ashes by settlers, there was never any possibility for us to seek any justice. In the west bank this year before Oct 7th there were over 200 palestinians murdered by settlers and soldiers and uncountable instances of assaults, vandalism and harrasment. My family are not hamas militants, they are peace loving people who just want to live with dignity.
Killing of innocent people is not something that any human with a conscience would ever be okay with and there is no justification for the deaths of so many innocent lives on October the 7th. But it must be said, that the event does not exist in a vacuum. And it should not be used as a green light to slaughter Palestinians in the masses.
We are not Nazis, All that we as Palestinians want is our sovereignty and to live with dignity.
I do get annoyed hearing media say the Hamas and Palestine issues are different, the are not, the people know what the stand for and the voted for them
So you agree with every action of your government? Every government that's been in power had your vote?
On the main Hamas policy of murdering Jews , most Gazans are in agreement with their government and must now face the consequences .
Israel has voted terrorists 2. Wats ur point?
Hamas were elected 17 years ago, there have been no elections since.
The average age of a person in Gaza is 14.
Hopefully you are now educated and will not get annoyed hearing that in future.
You can discern dishonesty or attempts at propaganda when someone avoids straightforward questions and tries to present them in a more favorable light.
I think that the Professor did not understand her English 😅