Händel: Messiah/ Winkel, Romberger, Bostridge, Miles/ Andreas Spering / DRP

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 101

  • @violaschenk7194
    @violaschenk7194 7 місяців тому +7

    Ich höre es immer an den hohen Feiertagen. Der Messias ist wirklich etwas ganz besonderes. Und diese Aufführung ist sehr schön, sehr atmosphärisch.
    Als Jugendliche habe ich einmal im Alt im Chor mitgesungen. Meine erste und intensivste Chorerfahrung. Eigentlich war es nur, weil meine köeine Schwester (damals 11) im Sopran mitsingen wollte und noch nicht alleine abends in die Chorproben durfte...

  • @jensdehbel-qw7wf
    @jensdehbel-qw7wf Рік тому +19

    Habe es als 4jähriger oft gehört und vor allem von meinen Eltern danach erklärt bekommen... Mein Lieblingsoriatorium seit über 60 Jahren!!!

    • @JMW25
      @JMW25 7 місяців тому

      A

  • @neurodivergentwithwilsons
    @neurodivergentwithwilsons 4 роки тому +66

    Part I
    0:01:13 Sinfony
    0:04:01 Comfort ye, my people
    0:07:11 Ev'ry valley
    0:10:19 And the glory of the Lord
    0:13:17 Thus saith the Lord
    0:14:52 But who may abide
    0:19:12 Behold, a virgin shall conceive
    0:19:47 O thou that tellest good tidings
    0:25:10 For behold, darkness shall cover the earth
    0:27:33 The people that walked
    0:30:39 For unto us a child is born
    0:34:29 Pifa
    0:35:27 There were shepherds
    0:35:43 And lo, the angel of the Lord
    0:36:01 And the angel said
    0:36:37 And suddenly
    0:36:55 Glory to God in the highest
    0:38:52 Rejoice greatly
    0:42:59 Then shall the eyes of the blind
    0:43:37 He shall feed his flock
    0:45:49 Come unto Him
    0:48:50 His yoke is easy
    Part II
    0:51:03 He was despised
    1:00:23 Thy rebuke hath broken his heart
    1:02:37 Behold, and see
    1:03:59 He was cut off
    1:04:18 But Thou didst not leave his soul
    1:06:28 Why do the nations so furiously rage
    1:09:19 He that dwelleth
    1:09:34 Thou shalt break them
    1:11:29 Hallelujah
    Part III
    1:15:02 I know my Redeemer liveth
    1:21:21 Behold, I tell you a mystery
    1:22:00 The trumpet shall sound
    1:25:57 Then shall be brought to pass
    1:26:19 O death, where is thy sting
    1:27:21 But thanks be to God
    1:29:41 If God be for us
    1:34:13 Worthy is the Lamb
    1:35:30 Blessing and honour
    1:37:28 Amen
    1:40:42 Applause

    • @김길동-j9z
      @김길동-j9z 5 місяців тому +3

      Thank you very much for information

  • @MrGuckimucki
    @MrGuckimucki 2 роки тому +17

    Hervorragende Aufführung!

  • @cuitlahuacrivas2930
    @cuitlahuacrivas2930 7 місяців тому +3

    Magnificent performance with excelent tempo and excelent sound. Thank you.

  • @felicitysummers9140
    @felicitysummers9140 3 роки тому +18

    I am in awe of Handel so inspired by God to write this wonderful masterpiece from His word truly awesome awesome man. It amazes me that people can listen to this and not be challenged by the message. Praise the Lord! 💖

    • @sungschoo
      @sungschoo 2 роки тому +8

      Yes, his head was filled with the words of God and how to express them, he wrote the entire music in 30 days, so I read. Definitely God inspired music!

  • @최성욱-x2g
    @최성욱-x2g Рік тому +8

    TO GOD ALONE BE ALL THE GLORY. Handel Proved that Jesus is The Messiah. Hallelujah.

  • @karstensturm4198
    @karstensturm4198 3 роки тому +7

    Thanks for this wonderful interpretation - danke für diese wunderschöne musikalische Darbietung,!

  • @MMICGER
    @MMICGER 3 роки тому +6

    *1+ und sehr schöner Begleittext*
    Ziemlich magere Applaus für diese tolle Performance.

  • @artgamesforfun
    @artgamesforfun 4 роки тому +12

    One of the best articulations of "Every Valley" 7:11 - This is incredibly challenging to do to this level. Well done!

  • @Isabel-zm6oe
    @Isabel-zm6oe Рік тому +5

    ¡Impresionante!¡Bellísimo Mesías de Haendel!¡Sea por siempre Bendito, Alabado y Glorificado El Señor, a Él todo el honor y la gloria!

  • @301250
    @301250 4 роки тому +19

    Ian Bostridge, amazing as always! Brings, and gives life to whatever he sings.

  • @arthurfilemon6038
    @arthurfilemon6038 4 роки тому +8

    This is beautiful. So aesthetically pleasing and musically as well. Not used to this glamour anymore when Early Music is performed.

  • @hannslunninger416
    @hannslunninger416 4 роки тому +8

    Tolle Tempi, so schöne Chorstimmen, danke Maestro für das große Verständnis von Musik UND Gesang! (Ein solches Dirigat würde ich mir oft auch in der Oper wünschen...)
    Miles, wie immer, Chapeau! Altistin stellenweise mit einem Timbre nah an einem Counter, nur halt viel, viel schöner! Berührend auch die Sopranistin mit ihrer allzu klaren und engelhaften Stimme. Einzig beim Tenor würde ich mir mehr natürlichen Stimmklang wünschen, aber das ist reine Geschmackssache, auch er macht es natürlich toll.

  • @marjetapeterlin
    @marjetapeterlin 10 місяців тому +6

    This is heaven like.thank you so much!

  • @itryen7632
    @itryen7632 Рік тому +3

    I love this song. I hope my friend who's the pilot of a giant robot doesn't mind it if i play it out loud.

  • @mahamaviche8147
    @mahamaviche8147 2 роки тому +8

    Very good and powerful interpretation

  • @salinsclassicalorganinspir8415
    @salinsclassicalorganinspir8415 4 роки тому +3

    what an extraordinarily moving sequence matched by great signing , 51:38 a man of sorrows, acquainted with grief, --59.55 Thy rebuke has broken his broken his heart-- ------- lovely portrayal of the man of sorrows. The context makes the singing so poignant "John 1: 11-13 "He was the world , and though the world was made through him,the world did not recognize him. He came to that which was his own, but his own did not receive him. Yet, to all who did receive him,--- he gave the right to become children of God."

  • @HexPulsion
    @HexPulsion 5 років тому +16

    This is by far the most beautiful version of the Messiah!

    • @therealtornadosam
      @therealtornadosam 4 роки тому +3

      It is very well performed, but unfortunately incomplete with numbers from Parts 1 and 3 cut out, and the majority of Part 2 gone entirely.

    • @tabneto
      @tabneto 4 роки тому +1

      @@therealtornadosam thank you for the information. I have Mozart's arrangement, but in vinyl... I love it!

  • @m.9243
    @m.9243 3 роки тому +18

    Unfortunately, this is a shortened version of this glorious work.. There's several parts missing (.."Behold the Lamb of God.." etc.)
    It's a real pity as, this is a spiritual work and, in my opinion, should be heard in its entirety.
    That aside, it's an excellent performance by all involved. Thank You!
    Christmas Blessings to all.

  • @cesarbarrachina
    @cesarbarrachina 5 місяців тому +2

    1:11:29 Dies ist der Moment in der Arbeit, der mir die Macht Gottes und Seine Majestät bewusster macht.

  • @miguelangelobarretodamoura2050
    @miguelangelobarretodamoura2050 2 роки тому +4

    Amazing. The comfort for the souls.

  • @javiermontes6970
    @javiermontes6970 3 роки тому +3

    muchísimas gracias, por su explicación y aclaración, lo tendré en cuenta.

  • @Peter-ht5bf
    @Peter-ht5bf 9 днів тому +1

    Zur Ehre Gottes komponiert wunderbar

  • @swordoff7
    @swordoff7 4 роки тому +6

    This splendid rendition is somewhat unusual in that they managed to perform it 25 minutes faster than the BBC did in a 1965 version.

    • @neurodivergentwithwilsons
      @neurodivergentwithwilsons 4 роки тому +1

      Saiful Rimkeit That may be because this rendition cut a lot of movements. I’m not familiar with the BBC 1965 version, but this rendition is missing a few arias, recitatives, etc...

    • @swordoff7
      @swordoff7 4 роки тому

      @@neurodivergentwithwilsons
      Now it makes sense. Frankly, before I read your answer, I was scratching my intuitive head and wondered how this could have happened. Thank you for your explanation.

    • @markchandler001
      @markchandler001 4 роки тому +1

      For me the opening is way too fast as if they want to get it out of the way! I have a slower intro I play in my car that creates a much more powerful mood!

    • @Gott-liebt-Sie_god-loves-you
      @Gott-liebt-Sie_god-loves-you 2 роки тому

      In some passages it is indeed played too quickly, as if the musicians would be in an hurry... In these passages I miss the chance to think about what the text has to tell us...

  • @jormaseppala345
    @jormaseppala345 Рік тому +2

    The Best versio ever!

  • @nikolaj5701
    @nikolaj5701 2 роки тому +4

    Dramatic ! Bravo !

  • @stephenbell-booth2648
    @stephenbell-booth2648 8 місяців тому +1

    Exquisite, hi from New Zealand

  • @kathrindannat4566
    @kathrindannat4566 3 роки тому +1

    Wow!!!! Wunderschön!!! Ich kenne so viele schöne Stücke, aber „Der Messias“ ist das Schönste!!!
    Wenn man diese Bilder sieht, schmerzt es, dass Konzerte nicht mehr stattfinden und man nicht mehr gemeinsam Gott loben kann!

    • @FelixVW
      @FelixVW 2 роки тому +3

      Der "Konzertchor Münster", dem ich als Tenor angehöre, hat den "Messiah" just am 13-11-2021 aufgeführt. Leider gibt es davon keine Bild- und Tonaufnahme. Wir haben standing ovations bekommen. Die Apostelkirche Münster als Austragungsort war bis auf den letzten Platz besetzt - mit einem 3G-Konzept.

  • @kellynorvell5714
    @kellynorvell5714 4 роки тому +9

    PHENOMENALLY SPECTACULAR !!!!!!!!!!

  • @nicholasobida3310
    @nicholasobida3310 Рік тому +2

    So inspiring, very excellent

  • @danielgomesdasilvagomes9209
    @danielgomesdasilvagomes9209 4 роки тому +2

    Muito bom... não consigo ouvir, apenas sentir... essa incrível melodia!!!😊

  • @susannaonrubia5426
    @susannaonrubia5426 2 роки тому +4

    Wonderful, good job

  • @shin-i-chikozima
    @shin-i-chikozima Місяць тому

    We profoundly know 「 how awesome Handel is」❗
    Messiha is an inspirational poem

  • @wilfriedfriedrich3730
    @wilfriedfriedrich3730 3 роки тому +2

    Lovely, a great Interpretation ❤️🙏❤️🙏

  • @josegeraldoqueiroz9922
    @josegeraldoqueiroz9922 Рік тому +4

    Este clasico e totalmente maravilhoso,divino.

  • @otfried
    @otfried 5 років тому +9

    Miles ist stets mein Lieblingsbaß für die Arien von diesem Oratorium.

  • @patriciocristobalgallardoz341
    @patriciocristobalgallardoz341 5 років тому +7

    Gran versión alemana con instrumentación moderna y maravillosa interpretación barroca de un puro y perfecto sonido. El coro tiene la estructura tradicional de los coros alemanes que a diferencia de los ingleses carecen de contratenores en su cuerda de altos y los solistas se dividen entre intérpretes alemanes e ingleses. El resultado final si bien no llega a la perfección de las grandes versiones inglesas de los últimos cuarenta años, es magnífico, noble y de alta cultura artística. Lo único que llama la atención es... ¿Por qué no se hizo completo?

    • @eloygonzalezcorro6486
      @eloygonzalezcorro6486 2 роки тому +1

      Creo que esta obra fue compuesta en su totalidad en Alemán, hay que recordar que el autor, era alemán, aunque luego se nacionalizó inglés, tras su larga permanencia el Reino Unido.

    • @patriciocristobalgallardoz341
      @patriciocristobalgallardoz341 2 роки тому +1

      @@eloygonzalezcorro6486 Fue compuesta en inglés porque Handel ya llevaba muchos años viviendo en Inglaterra y antes ya había compuesto otros oratorios ingleses. La primera representación fue en Dublín para un acto de beneficencia.
      Mozart varios años después efectuó su versión en Alemán con diversos cambios en la orquestación y las arias

  • @LadyKristo
    @LadyKristo 4 роки тому +7

    I miss some of my favourite choir pieces like "And He shall purify" after the alto arie "But who will abide", then "Surely" after "He Was Despised" etc. It seems that in this shortened version exactly the choir pieces were massively cut. A pity. But overall I like the performance and especially the dirigent. Have you noted, that Ian Bostridge sings everything by heart, without looking into the scores?

    • @williamknapper2996
      @williamknapper2996 4 роки тому +3

      I agree. Too many of the choruses are cut. "All we like sheep..." No wonder it's so short. If one is going to do the 'Messiah' - then do it all! Do they think so little of people's attention span?

    • @therealtornadosam
      @therealtornadosam 4 роки тому +1

      @@williamknapper2996 I agree completely. They really cut down on part two. It's really sad.

    • @altpapapi
      @altpapapi 2 роки тому +1

      Agree. No matter how good musically the performance, editing and chopping the work into incongruent sound bites is the death of Handel's Messiah.

  • @garyriebel2617
    @garyriebel2617 3 роки тому +2

    The Soprano Johanna W. Is outstanding

  • @aniloza58
    @aniloza58 8 місяців тому

    No la conocia. Gracias por esta bellísima interpretación.

  • @therealtornadosam
    @therealtornadosam 4 роки тому +2

    In the Sir Colin Davis Messiah on UA-cam also Sir Alastair does the same improv at the end of "The Trumpet Shall Sound"!

  • @dasabendlandprojekt8031
    @dasabendlandprojekt8031 6 днів тому

    Hervorragend!

  • @myyoutube6475
    @myyoutube6475 4 роки тому +10

    Bless them Lord

  • @Gott-liebt-Sie_god-loves-you
    @Gott-liebt-Sie_god-loves-you 2 роки тому +1

    An manchen Stellen wird das Stück zu schnell gespielt, als ob die Musiker es eilig hätten. In diesen Passagen verpasse ich die Gelegenheit, darüber nachzudenken, was uns der Text zu sagen hat. Dann fehlt mir auch die Andächtigkeit, die angemessen sein sollte. Die Aufnahme von Karl Richter 1965 ist für mich weiterhin die Referenz schlechthin.
    ***
    In some passages the performance is played too fast, as if the musicians were in a hurry. In these passages I miss the opportunity to reflect on what the text has to say to us. Then I also lack the devotion that should be appropriate. The recording of Karl Richter in 1965 is still the reference par excellence for me.

  • @jaagolafale5330
    @jaagolafale5330 3 роки тому +2

    Very. Beautiful.

  • @diegoleon6422
    @diegoleon6422 Місяць тому

    Los alemanes son unos de los creadores de la música moderna? Handel, Bach, Pachelbel. O existen otros previos a ellos? Gracias

  • @sinaelbienvos6471
    @sinaelbienvos6471 Рік тому +4

    J'adore

  • @BinderTh
    @BinderTh 4 роки тому +4

    Leider eine gekürzte Aufführung.

  • @antonellabaluganti8109
    @antonellabaluganti8109 2 роки тому +2

    Stupenda sinfonia

  • @fernandoleitao4469
    @fernandoleitao4469 2 роки тому +1

    Beautiful version with great voices and wonderful moments. But the tempi are in my opinion often
    too quick and both female soloists have difficulties with coloratura every now and then, which is not surprising

  • @AWOFOFORMBARadioTV379
    @AWOFOFORMBARadioTV379 4 роки тому +5

    If it’s HANDEL must be good. Blessings all.

  • @juanolague4265
    @juanolague4265 11 місяців тому

    THANKS !❤

  • @dsteely2588
    @dsteely2588 3 роки тому +1

    Was I asleep and missed it, was even the hallelujah chorus eliminated?

  • @germanwowmann
    @germanwowmann 3 роки тому +2

    Einfach nur Hammer.

  • @richardwoollaston3650
    @richardwoollaston3650 10 місяців тому

    A beautiful, beautiful performance. It is difficult to believe that Handel wrote Messiah in - I think - 24 days. He must have been channelled; a deep and holy spirituality oozes from every note.
    However, I don’t know what the significance of the red/black background is, but from some angles it looks utterly demonic.

  • @musicaadventista1970
    @musicaadventista1970 2 місяці тому

    No leíste esto por casualidad Dios te ama👍 el sabe por lo que estás pasando y no te dejará sola confía

  • @sungschoo
    @sungschoo 2 роки тому +1

    I hear some part of soloist, choir are sung in English.

  • @deadbyflatus
    @deadbyflatus 6 місяців тому +2

    Warum muß das alles auf Englisch sein, verstehe das nicht

  • @couldYours
    @couldYours Рік тому +2

    how do you admonish a humanity that prefers to adapt so quickly to adversity

  • @susananogueragarcia5740
    @susananogueragarcia5740 Рік тому +1

    🤩

  • @eloygonzalezcorro6486
    @eloygonzalezcorro6486 2 роки тому +1

    El Cielo y la Tierra pasarán, pero mi cantata no pasará dijo el autor y yo ELOI Ratifico.

  • @defbt5
    @defbt5 4 роки тому +5

    Interesting to me! Germans singing in English!

    • @hannslunninger416
      @hannslunninger416 4 роки тому +2

      German composer ;-)
      It is the same thing as with Gardiner - even after Brexit he will belong to Europe and the whole wolrd

    • @adamw1324
      @adamw1324 4 роки тому +1

      I would like some explanation...

  • @declamatory
    @declamatory 4 роки тому +3

    I cannot stand the Bahrenreiter edition because it turns the bass solo of "But Who May Abide" into an alto solo. Dozens of times, I have been bass soloist in "Messiah" from the G. Schirmer edition. It's definitely preferable to the Bahrenreiter!

    • @LadyKristo
      @LadyKristo 4 роки тому

      Well, a bass opinion :-D I like most the contralto version, preferrably Hilary Summers.

    • @therealtornadosam
      @therealtornadosam 4 роки тому

      @@LadyKristo She's great definitely, but yeah, we don't hear the bass version enough.

    • @FJC76
      @FJC76 3 роки тому +2

      Well, the Baerenreiter edition contains the Alto version because that's what Handel wrote. The Bass version was never performed by him but is a later tradition, and one that should be dispensed with altogether.

  • @52Leszek
    @52Leszek 9 місяців тому

    podobno Zenek miał śpiewać?

  • @spicysesam
    @spicysesam 3 роки тому +1

    2:15 - 4:00 for myself

  • @stevewallschlaeger1379
    @stevewallschlaeger1379 2 роки тому

    Lord of Host!!!!
    What is the matter with you one Lord Three Persons ONE Host.

  • @allenjones3130
    @allenjones3130 Рік тому +1

    Give "But Who May Abide" back to basses and baritones!

  • @푸먹-s1u
    @푸먹-s1u 11 місяців тому

    2:16
    7:10
    10:20
    13:20

  • @expeditodealmeida2586
    @expeditodealmeida2586 4 роки тому +3

    Intro too fast!

  • @hufnagel2025
    @hufnagel2025 2 роки тому +1

    Smukt og sandt.

  • @AdamELKadi-pj1ou
    @AdamELKadi-pj1ou Рік тому +1

    so schlecht

  • @liliankiefer945
    @liliankiefer945 4 роки тому

    Mein Leben mit dem Down-Syndrom anschauen anklicken weiterleiten Indie Radio Rundfunk

  • @stevewallschlaeger1379
    @stevewallschlaeger1379 2 роки тому

    Comfort ye was sloppy at best.