Dude everrrrybody says this about Bresson - I have read / watched at least 85 people make the same comments about Bresson’s perfect simplicity in cinema. It’s true
His restraint from any stylistic flourishes or excesses which might obfuscate to any degree his pure content. Nothing in Bresson is superfluous, just like how every note Bach wrote
Not really. When you read Sculpting in Time, he actually discusses Dostoevsky’s work to a much larger extent as examplary poetic art and only references Tolstoy in passing. I don’t think he was the type to rank writers so simply as one being better than another. He said before he died that he wanted to adapt Crime and Punishment and The Idiot
For those who find Bach, NOT SIMPLE: Perhaps, Bach parodied, mocked at and ridiculed those in Music-making and fellow humans in Life itself...presenting his music as a METAPHOR for the general tendency of nearly everyone to Complicate INSTEAD OF Simplifying... and also simultaneously taking critical potshots at his musical contemporaries practising it and critics who were wowed by such needless, excessive complexity! Even today, the Deceptively Simple and the Purely Simple are NOT accorded the recognition,respect and acclaim in any art form,also in any walk of life! But...Simplifying the Deeply Complex requires Prodigious Genius. Shakespeare had it . Antonioni had it. Rodin had it. Robert Frost had it. Bertolucci had it. Henri Verneuil had it.
@@ubir9743 Bach's music doesn't appear as simple. He was criticized already in his own time for being too complicated. For example, Scheibe wrote about him: "This great man would be the admiration of whole nations if he had more amenity, if he did not take away the natural element in his pieces by giving them a turgid and confused style, and if he did not darken their beauty by an excess of art."
спросил бы у Тарковского, на чём он строил свои фильмы... не на музыке ли Баха....не на живописи ли . не на устоях поэзии ли? отобразил хорошо. но не создал идею. а всех смог принизить. какое кино...очнитесь.
There is nothing difficult to understand about worshiping big names and following the modernist canon in storytelling and visual techniques.@@themoreyouknowfools4974
Bresson, Bach, Tolstoy, Da Vinci, Tarkovsky: like five fingers on a giant's hand.
Thanks for the excerpts.
“Simplicity is the final achievement.” - Frédéric Chopin
Cool last shot.
Dude everrrrybody says this about Bresson - I have read / watched at least 85 people make the same comments about Bresson’s perfect simplicity in cinema.
It’s true
Вот это очень нужный и важный кусок монолога! Он верен, точен... просто бриллиант, особенно для подрастающего ищущего смыслы поколения.
Tank God for having had Tarkovsky roam the earthrealm and share his thoughts.
What did Tarkovsky mean by Bresson's, "asceticism?" Nice vid, I happen to be a fan of Tarkovsky.
His restraint from any stylistic flourishes or excesses which might obfuscate to any degree his pure content. Nothing in Bresson is superfluous, just like how every note Bach wrote
Thank you for clarifying that. Have a good day.@@villain7140
So he's a Tolstoi over Dostoyevsky guy
Not really. When you read Sculpting in Time, he actually discusses Dostoevsky’s work to a much larger extent as examplary poetic art and only references Tolstoy in passing. I don’t think he was the type to rank writers so simply as one being better than another. He said before he died that he wanted to adapt Crime and Punishment and The Idiot
im probably an idiot but who is leonardo? whenever i try to look him up it comes up with da vinci lol
Он ещё книги писал (давинчи)
Jeez man...
Above all is you
Like Andrei Rublev watching the boy cast the bell--that's the distance between Tarkovsky and Bresson, et al.
glazing 10000
💥
For those who find Bach, NOT SIMPLE:
Perhaps, Bach parodied, mocked at and ridiculed those in Music-making and fellow humans in Life itself...presenting his music as a METAPHOR for the general tendency of nearly everyone
to Complicate INSTEAD OF Simplifying... and also simultaneously
taking critical potshots at his musical contemporaries practising it and critics who were wowed by such needless, excessive complexity!
Even today, the Deceptively Simple and the Purely Simple are NOT accorded the recognition,respect and acclaim in any art form,also in any walk of life!
But...Simplifying the Deeply Complex requires Prodigious Genius.
Shakespeare had it .
Antonioni had it.
Rodin had it.
Robert Frost had it.
Bertolucci had it.
Henri Verneuil had it.
xx
Simplicity in Bach's music? He wrote the most complex counterpoints imaginable.
@@ubir9743 Bach's music doesn't appear as simple. He was criticized already in his own time for being too complicated. For example, Scheibe wrote about him: "This great man would be the admiration of whole nations if he had more amenity, if he did not take away the natural element in his pieces by giving them a turgid and confused style, and if he did not darken their beauty by an excess of art."
@@ubir9743 OK.
I dont think he said bach wrote simple music, i think he was listing artists who he felt art flowed from them simply or without effort.
Name a simpler piece of music than the Sarabande from his 5th Cello Suite
@@antoinepetrov Yes, Bach wrote simple music as well (although I don't think that this Sarabande is simple). But most of his pieces are very complex.
спросил бы у Тарковского, на чём он строил свои фильмы... не на музыке ли Баха....не на живописи ли . не на устоях поэзии ли? отобразил хорошо. но не создал идею. а всех смог принизить. какое кино...очнитесь.
The Logos
You should know that already
@@kaykay865 can you explain?
i will never watch a tarkovsky film. because i dont want the my imagination about how fantastical and connective his films are to be reduced.
That's so stupid
Kinda retarded, actually
come on man
Расскажите о том, как Вы представляете эти фильмы. И откуда Вы о них знаете. И почему в Вашем воображении они окутаны флером значительности?
Pretentious as hell
Tarkovsky didn't pretend.
Just because you don’t understand doesn’t mean it’s pretentious.
There is nothing difficult to understand about worshiping big names and following the modernist canon in storytelling and visual techniques.@@themoreyouknowfools4974
midwit alert
@@themoreyouknowfools4974 he is anyway
You have a way with excerpts 🤌