Thank you for doing this video on Nichole Cable. I live in Glenburn, Maine just up the road from where Nichole lived. I know her mom Christine Wiley and her father David Cable. When I was pregnant with my son Jordan, Nichole and her dad Dave came to my baby shower and Nichole gave me my baby book 📖. She was such a sweet little girl she was about 9 or 10 years old. I also know Kyle Dube. It's such a small world. But this really hit too close to home. I cried my eyes out!!!!. REST IN PARADISE BEAUTIFUL ❤️ NICHOLE CHRISTINE ELLEN CABLE!!! You'll be in our hearts forever babygirl
@@jillijane9793 I’m so very sorry for you. I remembered my son everyday for more than 20 years. It still hurts, but it does get easier. Three years ago was the first time I Didn’t think about him on his birthday. Now on his birthday, I know where my son is now and that when my body lays down for the last time, I’ll be able to see him throughout eternity.
The “24 hour rule” which is apparently still in place in some states only applies to adults, the disappearance of a child is always treated as an emergency. The sheriffs office was initially negligent
@@MissMariQueen totally agree. I wanted to highlight that policy wasn’t the cause of the delayed investigation, the authority’s decisions were. It wouldn’t have mattered in this case, sadly, but they wouldn’t have known that at the time
I live in New Brunswick and have travelled to Maine many times to shop. This is too close to home for me too! Heartbreaking to see her mum in so much pain, must be awful! 😢
@@frankfestus114 If I were her mum, I would have gone up that isolated road with her and if I hadn't, I'd have stayed up til she got back, given the fact she was only supposed to be going out for a few moments.
My anxiety is bad. If my daughter said she was going to meet a boy on the front porch I wouldn't be able to sleep until she came back in. No way I'm falling asleep while my daughter is outside. My anxiety is too bad.
I know the feeling! I get anxious to the point I feel sick. I had to go to therapy as my anxiety was really crippling. I did CBT, it helped for a while, but I have relapsed 😬
I was just going to say the same…i wouldn’t be going to bed at any time knowing my 15 year old daughter was out of the house. Only when she came in could I relax and rest… x
Anxiety or not the mom going to sleep, or even being able to sleep, was incredible. She must be the kind of person that drops a person off in the dark and doesn't wait to make sure they get into their house safely- just speeds off.
@sariyaimanokoye4218 I remember the first time my son and I dropped off his girlfriend at her house. They were the same age. As she was walking towards her house, my son asked me what I was doing. I told him waiting to make sure she got in ok. Initially he thought I was crazy but I explained that it's not only good manners, it's a safety precaution. (Plus, you never know if the parents had an unexpected emergency, she forgot her key, etc., etc.) Male or female, we always make sure my children's friends are in the house.
Looking at his smug face makes me so mad! Because of him, a mother is now without her child. No parent should ever have to experience the heartache of outliving their child. I hope Kyle never sees the light of day again.
Who keeps telling everyone that parents aren’t supposed to outlive their child? People keep saying that. Why? It has been happening since the beginning of man kind. Is it some kind of denial or a fantasy of some sort? Losing a family member of or at any age is difficult.
Said this for years. It was never a law to wait before reporting a person missing. If they say that to you, demand to speak to the head of missing persons.
I can't believe the cops put her off. You have to act immediately for the best chance of finding missing persons. I hope the right people were held to account.
Not a single police station has been "defunded" and putting off missing teenagers as runaways is on old outdated practice some lazy police still use sadly.
I'm utterly baffled by his logic. He wanted to kidnap her, hide her, and then find her so he could play hero?! But she fought, so instead of giving up and fleeing, he held on tighter and-- That is crazy. Poor girl killed for something so stupid.
Poor Nichole... she must have been so frightened, but at least she was able to put up a fight for her life. How heartbreaking that she lost her life and at such a young age. I feel so bad for her family, especially her mom... I'm sure she probably has some regrets about that night. Anyhow, wonder what the plea deal was/how many years? Even with his sentence, he could get out in about 1/2 that time with time off for good behavior, so I think he should have gotten life. You take one, you give yours in return. Anyhow, thanks for the video; never heard of this case before.
And I forgot to mention, seeing that Sara and Kyle's brother knew what happened, why did they wait for the police to question them and not come forward right off the bat?!? Truly disgusting as well.
Hello friend!! And I don't know. I just don't understand it. I couldn't sit on that knowledge. But it happens all the time and I seriously will never get it. In my mind if you know about something and you do nothing about it, it's almost as bad as if you had done it yourself.
Now that I've seen it, I'm wondering if the girlfriend said nothing because she hated Nichole. She clearly thought Nichole was trying to steal her boyfriend or something even though she wasn't doing anything wrong. Maybe she was just pleased that Nichole was out of the way.
that girlfriend is a horrible person. you discover your 20 year old boyfriend is trying to romance a 15 year old, so you go after the girl?? how about kick his ass as you kick him to the curb and warn the teenagers mother? supporting his goofy behavior is apparently all she knows
@TK-ui2th I know right? I'm like, oh of course, blame Nichole, the innocent CHILD for the way your idiot boyfriend behaves? That's why I wasn't too surprised that she didn't go to the police. She didn't care. Horrible person.
You really gotta pay attention to who you talk to… these days you can’t just meet and go get in random cars… even if you think it was someone you know. As we can see it’s easy to fake who you are; all you have to do is put up some pictures and talk sweet. That being said, she was a sweet girl and she gave this person the benefit of the doubt. This person took advantage of that and they are evil for doing so. Can’t imagine thinking you are going to hang with an old flame but someone kidnaps and kills you instead. Truly horrifying.
You shouldn’t be getting into stranger calls even back then! They just didn’t know that it was dangerous to hitch hike, strangers equal danger. And that nice looking charismatic man waving you over? Well he’s a serial killer and he’s not there to just ask for directions
Im sorry but her mom allowing a 15 year old to leave the house alone at 10 p.m. to meet a strange man then falling alseep is utterly insane to me. Even if it would have been who it was supposed to be, letting your daughter walk out late at night to meet up with a 19 year old because he "had something to give her" just baffles me. Sad case on all fronts, but I feel that this one could have been prevented.
I agree, there's no way my daughter would be going out to meet a much older boy at 10pm, it's ludicrous and my mami stayed awake till I got home no matter what age I was if out partying for example, she "couldn't sleep till she knew I was safe" - quote Nor sure about the lip piercing, either
I agree. Not to mention he was a complete stranger to the mom. I would be like "No"! He can come back in the morning and introduce himself properly and drop whatever he needs to drop off at the door. Beyond all that, my kids are not allowed social media, much less talk to and give their address to someone I don't know. A lot of these case could be prevented if the parents did the bare minimum.
It’s easy to judge someone’s parenting when they lose a child like this. Not that I agree with her being allowed to go out or what not, but I’m absolutely certain her poor mother thinks about that every damn day. Doubt that woman needs anyone judging her, she has lost a child. Furthermore, lip piercing? Really? Knocking on a murdered 15yo’s facial piercing…? Confused why anyone feels comfortable enough to even type that, then post it. Whew.
As for being her cousin, and being to young to remember what happened at the time, I'm glad I got to watch this video to actually understand what happened. Thinking about this monster has made me sick to my stomach, I hope he never gets out of prison and lives every second of his miserable life regretting what he did, and never has a moment where he's at peace. It's genuinely terrifying to think what she had gone through. RIP Nichole, may she rest in peace forever.
Police: "the first 24 hours are the most important in solving crimes" Also Police: "we're going to wait at least 24 hours before even starting to investigate missing persons"
I think about and talk about it with my family everyday. My son is 22 with his own family, but I still make sure they do not trust everyone fully. 😢 Some of these stories make me sad and others infuriate me. Be careful out there!! 🙏
This right here. Like Oh My God... you as the parent are letting your child go met up with a boy who DROVE there who you have NEVER met? And not at least make sure she made it back into the house? I really want to believe there is some wholesome reasoning behind this like the mom is handicapped or mentally disabled in some way. Okay so you have THAT much trust in your daughter... but also don't think about her safety? Seems more likely they didn't care...
When I was a teenager, my family lived in a very rural part of Idaho. My parents were very trusting, and would’ve had no problem at all doing exactly what this woman did. It’s different when you live in a very rural, normally very safe part of the world. You look at the world in a totally different way. You’re way more trusting, to the point of what looks like naïveté and stupidity to people who live in a larger city. 🤷🏻♀️
Thank you for telling this story. I am from Maine and remember this case. So sad RIP Nichole. Hard to believe it has been 10 years since this happened.
Dear young people.. I understand firsthand how exciting it can be to encounter handsome strangers online. The key is maintain your dignity on the first real life meet. It can be rewarding so long as you take responsibility for your own safety. Please do not ever give your address or arrange to hang out privately. Meet them at a busy market/mall, no later than sunset for a casual stroll, you don’t need a ride to or from. Allow them to pass or fail a public litmus test, keep your home separate & safe :}
I wish an adult had said all that to me years ago. Whenever an adult speaks reasonably kids listen and it would have saved me from some awful stuff. A lot of parents think if they make something sound as dangerous or horrible as possible that it's better. But literally nothing could be less helpful. Kids aren't stupid and they know when they are being misled so what happens is they just don't trust anything the parent says after that.
my older sister used to get mad that when she went on dates I would ALWAYS come out meet dude and take pics of licsence plates, but oh well may have saved her life and we dont know. every dude who would get mad I did that always turned out to be a looser too
If my child was meeting someone they met online. I would not let them go on their own. You can’t trust anyone even strangers you meet on the internet. Be mindful about who you met, in person or on internet. Just be careful and don’t ever meet someone you don’t know by yourself.
She shouldn’t have been doing that at 15 anyway. The internet was fairly new when I was that age and my mom would never allow me to meet anyone in person. I now understand why she was so concerned about us being on the internet.
When we were still raising our girls, there was not a single minute from birth to college when we didn’t know where they were and who they were with. We also monitored all of their online activity. We weren’t overbearing, rather just responsible parents because of these stories. They’re also both absolutely beautiful, so that was my extra headache!
Mom stop letting your 15,16 just turned 17 yr old daughter date a Adult male especially with a child. Unless your child is about to be 18 they have no business with a boyfriend any to be legal to buy n contribute alcohol into your childs life
So his brother n Guy girlfriend knew but said nothing as this dude offers to babysit this young ladies sister? They need to be charged. It was his girlfriend that I'm sure pushed his loyalty to her that he went to prove it
We have a long drive in a rural area. I would never have gone to bed if my daughter was going to the end of the driveway to meet someone she’d never met in person. Sorry, not trying to be mean, but I would have walked at least halfway and waited or most likely taken her to the end of the driveway and met the person as well. RIP Nichole.
WAIT WHAT... her daughter went to meet a guy in the driveway at like 8pm, and her mom didnt check to see when she came back? didnt notice her missing till the AM.. stellar mom
Well she could've started by not letting her daughter go out to meet some boy that late at night, or at the very least made sure she came back in BEFORE SHE WENT TO BED!!!! All she had to do was make that boy come up to the house to drop off whatever he needed to drop off and this whole thing would've been prevented.
How is it that someone who has a history with crime, and lead police with a high speed chase with a motorcycle and hit a police officer be free to be sentenced later (at the time) to murder someone in cold blood? This all could've been averted.
not saying its any less bad but the real brian butterfield was 19 and the one behind the screen was 20, still horrible and disgusting but i can understand somewhat why the mom would be okay with it, she had probably done it many times before and listened like her mom said.. i feel so bad for her and her family. also poor real brian, i would change my name if i was him like damn bro seemed kind. which is why the mom was probably okay with it (the 20yr old had a whole record of crimes so im sure thats why he had to hide behind his friends name)
So the mother claims to be this protective mother, but she lets her 15yo daughter go to the end of the road after 9pm, when it's dark, to see some boy she's never met, and she just goes to bed before she returns? That just doesn't seem right. I would've had that boy come up to the house.
I'm sorry, but who lets their 15 year old child date a 20 year old guy with a kid, then lets them meet up with a stranger at night and goes to bed and doesn't at least wait up to make sure they come back home. Some very bad choices, RIP Nichole.
Her mother told her don’t go anywhere with anyone and instead of watching her or wait for her, she goes to sleep like a moron what kind of mother is that?
@@michelerenem shit up clown and listen to your mother and your mother should of drive her home or have her spend the night the mother let her go in the streets at night and then to sleep like a moron
I dont know why it is this 24 rule to try to find anyone missing in the US? In my country the police can search right away something they usualy do as long as people dont call about they're partner breaking up with them again or are just waisted.
This case being close to me makes me wanna see one of these channels pick up the case that just finished here in Washington County Maine. Native reservation, 3-4 miles from my town, a female was stabbed nearly 500 times. Arrested a male and female, end of the trial, female was found guilty, male it was a hung jury.
I am also in ME. Recently moved from MA to the southern border of ME and have not heard of that case. That sounds horrific! ❤ RIP to those taken by these evil creeps!!
I am a lifelong resident of Maine. This was a truly heartbreaking case. People think Maine is great and all but there have been numerous gory deaths that have hit the news in recent years. Hoping your channel will look into several other murders and/or disappearances that have stumped even the experts.
@@phoebebennett3024 - Absolutely. No one even got up during the night to pee and thought to check to see if she made it back safely? Teens with that much freedom unfortunately make prime candidates for evil people.
i was raised strict as ever and i still found ways to be sneaky and do the same things she did.. 30 now and i wish i would’ve been smarter about things..but nothing to do with parenting.
The mother didn't want to be too intrusive in her daughter's affairs by letting her meet the boy by herself in the dark. Big mistake. These young girls are precocious and should definitely not be left to deal with life on their own. It wasn't even the guy she thought she was on the phone with. You have to be kidding me. That's how ignorant these girls are. Mothers carry your daughters until they are settled in with a good guy. Use your experience to watch over them. Take nothing for granted.
I agree, she should of told her not to meet the guy in the dark and could see him in the day. And don’t go to bed and let your kid worry if it’s a stranger outside or someone else who pulled up.
This has weird old timey nice guy feels. She wasn't just a young girl, she was a kid who didn't understand the danger. Do I blame the mom? Yeah a bit. I blame the dad too, where was he? I blame the parents of the murderer, an obviously troubled dude with a history. Daughters don't need a 'good guy' to take care of them, they need the knowledge to take care of themselves. Daughter or son, gender doesn't really even matter. Teach your kid the dangers of the world but don't suffocate them. Teach your kids to be decent human beings.
How many young people have lost their lives due to the inaction of the police because of the teenage runaway stereotype? Like who cares if most teens turn up before long, why take the chance? That's insane to me.
It's not a stereotype. 99.999% of the time, the kid has either run away or they've snuck over to a friend's house. Police need reason to believe there's foul play.
His Lawyer is the perfect reason why I hate Defence Lawyers. Everybody deserves a defence i know that, But the Lawyer trying to get those note kicked out is disgusting. At that moment he knew very well that his man was guilty yet still tried pulling dirty tricks, And eventually putting other females at risk of loosing their lives. 🤮
When guilt is clear, all they should be doing is making sure their client gets a fair trial. All the dirty tricks they play are not what the justice system is about. So many of them lack any ethics or decency.
They say Moms never recover from this type of loss. They take their broken hearts w them to the grave once their body finally stops working and let's them die. The agony they endure thru the rest of their life, is much more than most of us ever know. Look into her eyes...she's broken smfh He should serve 2 life sentences. He's Killed two females
@@aaa4181 u must not have kids lmfao U better watch ur words missy!! That type of shit always comes back on ya!! Smh wouldn't be me!! Lmao u just created ur OWN karma there!! Good luck w that! Ur definitely gonna need it! Or...u could stay childless n single forever! I mean lmfao that's always an option!!🤡💩👹😆
I wonder if she lied about how old he was. If I saw a guy when I was in my teens, I just said I was seeing a female friend. Kids are honest these days, but I still wouldn't allow my teen to date until 17 or 18, that being said, they could just lie to me like I used to. And I did often meet friends from online in the late 90s. Ohhh the naivety.
The company is shut down for illegal practices they would take just about anyone. The owner of said company was sued for firing someone without reasoning a year or two after this
That 24hour rule is outdated. It was put in place during the time of no cell phones, when people didn't have a mode of communication on their person at all times. 24hours was enough time given for your missing loved one to get incontact.
If you loved your daughter that much, you would’ve never let her meet anyone in the driveway without watching her or going to bed without making sure she was in the house safely plain and simple🤷🏾♂️
I recommend yall covering the Breana Rouhselang case. Happened in mishawaka indiana a few years ago. Very sad story about a pregnant girl getting dumped in a dumpster behind a restaurant
C I was just about to say they needed to get rid of the 24hrs crap. The most crucial information, evidence etc is within the first 24-48 hrs of a missing persons cases. It's best to interview family members, friends, witnesses & suspect then. So many cases have gone cold cause sum law enforcement agencies make people wait to report it. It's 2024 back n the day law's need to b updated ASAP smh 🤦🏽♀️
All you perfect, self-righteous moms in these comments…smh. Nichole didn’t go out to meet “some guy” or a “stranger” at the end of her own driveway. Nichole wouldn’t have even left her own property, had it been legit. It was supposed to be a friend of hers. Her mom went over the rules with her and trusted her daughter. It is not the moms fault nor Nichole’s fault that an evil, predator faked the identity of one of her friends and took advantage. Stop victim blaming and put the blame on the right person.
I'm shocked 2:49 as a mother..I kind of blame the mum who should have at least waited until she came back or heard of a call..she said she's just picking something..at 9 pm!
So Mom let her date an adult with a criminal record to boot, are you kidding me.Where the hell is the sense in these parents heads.The problem today is we don't have parents we have friends that act part time like parents.
If that were the case, the narration would have stated "he babysat" or "he even babysat"; what was stated was "he offered to babysit", which more than likely means that he wasn't taken up on his offer... thank God! Can you imagine?!?
How did nobody not know she was missing until the following morning? If my kid goes out im not sleeping until my kid is back in the house unless they have planned to stay overnight elsewhere.
what a scummy thing to do... not only did he take the life of an innocent girl, her last moments were full of butyral, hurt, heartache and fear. then on top of that, someone else who had NOTHING to do with anything, is going to feel some kind of guilt or worse because she was catfished using that person's name and will be forever associated with this case :( so fkn sad i hate people this is absolutely disgusting
![[NEW] Dateline 2024 Full Episodes - The End of the Affair- 48 Hours Murder Documentary 2024](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KMW9E0nIzp8/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you for doing this video on Nichole Cable. I live in Glenburn, Maine just up the road from where Nichole lived. I know her mom Christine Wiley and her father David Cable. When I was pregnant with my son Jordan, Nichole and her dad Dave came to my baby shower and Nichole gave me my baby book 📖. She was such a sweet little girl she was about 9 or 10 years old. I also know Kyle Dube. It's such a small world. But this really hit too close to home. I cried my eyes out!!!!. REST IN PARADISE BEAUTIFUL ❤️ NICHOLE CHRISTINE ELLEN CABLE!!! You'll be in our hearts forever babygirl
I thought her father was Jason?
I'm so sorry for your loss. This is such a sad story. What an evil man
The parents let their daughter go outside to meet a guy and then never made sure she came back inside ????? And then just went to bed ?? Insane.
I remember hearing about this when I lived in Maine, shit was so sad
@Darian825 Jason is the stepfather, David is the father.
I lost my son 24 years ago.
I still miss him.
Parents should never have to bury their child. It’s not supposed to be that way.
I'm sorry for your loss.
My condolences❤
You lost your son? Have you checked downt the side of the sofa, thats where things usually end up
It has been 7 yrs since my son died. I miss him every day
@@jillijane9793 I’m so very sorry for you.
I remembered my son everyday for more than 20 years.
It still hurts, but it does get easier. Three years ago was the first time I Didn’t think about him on his birthday. Now on his birthday, I know where my son is now and that when my body lays down for the last time, I’ll be able to see him throughout eternity.
The “24 hour rule” which is apparently still in place in some states only applies to adults, the disappearance of a child is always treated as an emergency. The sheriffs office was initially negligent
I would scrap it altogether. To me, it's a stupid rule.
@@MissMariQueen totally agree. I wanted to highlight that policy wasn’t the cause of the delayed investigation, the authority’s decisions were. It wouldn’t have mattered in this case, sadly, but they wouldn’t have known that at the time
Yes it's a proven bad behavior and absolutely detrimental to the safety of the community!
There should never be a 24 hour rule. Perps use it
There should be a defunding rule, with grossly negligent PDs losing funding
It’s scary to think you can just be living your life, minding your business and randomly be killed because someone decides to.
God be power tripping, right?
I live in New Brunswick and have travelled to Maine many times to shop. This is too close to home for me too! Heartbreaking to see her mum in so much pain, must be awful! 😢
She was not right if not why we she go out to meet a,man at night to get weed at 15
Except that's not what happened here though.
@@frankfestus114 If I were her mum, I would have gone up that isolated road with her and if I hadn't, I'd have stayed up til she got back, given the fact she was only supposed to be going out for a few moments.
RIP Nichole. Thank you Jason and team for your hard work and consistency. Even back when your channel was called The Fear Files.💠
Thank you for supporting us throughout these years.
My anxiety is bad. If my daughter said she was going to meet a boy on the front porch I wouldn't be able to sleep until she came back in. No way I'm falling asleep while my daughter is outside. My anxiety is too bad.
I know the feeling! I get anxious to the point I feel sick. I had to go to therapy as my anxiety was really crippling. I did CBT, it helped for a while, but I have relapsed 😬
I was just going to say the same…i wouldn’t be going to bed at any time knowing my 15 year old daughter was out of the house. Only when she came in could I relax and rest… x
Anxiety or not the mom going to sleep, or even being able to sleep, was incredible. She must be the kind of person that drops a person off in the dark and doesn't wait to make sure they get into their house safely- just speeds off.
Right!? And sleeping soundly through the night and not checking??? Nope.. I couldn't do it. 😢
@sariyaimanokoye4218 I remember the first time my son and I dropped off his girlfriend at her house. They were the same age. As she was walking towards her house, my son asked me what I was doing. I told him waiting to make sure she got in ok. Initially he thought I was crazy but I explained that it's not only good manners, it's a safety precaution. (Plus, you never know if the parents had an unexpected emergency, she forgot her key, etc., etc.) Male or female, we always make sure my children's friends are in the house.
Looking at his smug face makes me so mad! Because of him, a mother is now without her child. No parent should ever have to experience the heartache of outliving their child. I hope Kyle never sees the light of day again.
Moms fault.... She didnt bother to notice if her CHILD came back from the driveway until the next day?????
Who keeps telling everyone that parents aren’t supposed to outlive their child? People keep saying that. Why?
It has been happening since the beginning of man kind. Is it some kind of denial or a fantasy of some sort? Losing a family member of or at any age is difficult.
@@michelleMYHELL5244stop victim blaming
Poor girl.
Let's hope he never gets released.
It'd be a big mistake to let the Coward go free. 😡🤬
Said this for years. It was never a law to wait before reporting a person missing. If they say that to you, demand to speak to the head of missing persons.
When I look in her eyes my heart hurts. She should be still here and live her life.
I can't believe the cops put her off. You have to act immediately for the best chance of finding missing persons. I hope the right people were held to account.
Probably "defunded" and didn't have the resources they used to.
Not a single police station has been "defunded" and putting off missing teenagers as runaways is on old outdated practice some lazy police still use sadly.
Heh, I can't believe you're in disbelief.
Most teen girls that have gone "missing" have just snuck over to their boyfriends place. Police time and resources are limited.
@@broeheemed32LMAO trust me, no police forces are getting defunded. in fact the only ones that have , have been republican counties.
I'm utterly baffled by his logic. He wanted to kidnap her, hide her, and then find her so he could play hero?! But she fought, so instead of giving up and fleeing, he held on tighter and-- That is crazy. Poor girl killed for something so stupid.
The pictures at the end of the video were so painful to watch. RIP, girl, you didn’t deserve any of that.
Poor Nichole... she must have been so frightened, but at least she was able to put up a fight for her life. How heartbreaking that she lost her life and at such a young age. I feel so bad for her family, especially her mom... I'm sure she probably has some regrets about that night. Anyhow, wonder what the plea deal was/how many years? Even with his sentence, he could get out in about 1/2 that time with time off for good behavior, so I think he should have gotten life. You take one, you give yours in return.
Anyhow, thanks for the video; never heard of this case before.
This monsters should never be let free. Whats happening to our laws that privilege the monsters over the victims. I pray for this kid. ❤
And I forgot to mention, seeing that Sara and Kyle's brother knew what happened, why did they wait for the police to question them and not come forward right off the bat?!? Truly disgusting as well.
Hello friend!! And I don't know. I just don't understand it. I couldn't sit on that knowledge. But it happens all the time and I seriously will never get it. In my mind if you know about something and you do nothing about it, it's almost as bad as if you had done it yourself.
Now that I've seen it, I'm wondering if the girlfriend said nothing because she hated Nichole. She clearly thought Nichole was trying to steal her boyfriend or something even though she wasn't doing anything wrong. Maybe she was just pleased that Nichole was out of the way.
that girlfriend is a horrible person. you discover your 20 year old boyfriend is trying to romance a 15 year old, so you go after the girl?? how about kick his ass as you kick him to the curb and warn the teenagers mother? supporting his goofy behavior is apparently all she knows
@TK-ui2th I know right? I'm like, oh of course, blame Nichole, the innocent CHILD for the way your idiot boyfriend behaves? That's why I wasn't too surprised that she didn't go to the police. She didn't care. Horrible person.
@@TK-ui2th this. I’m still trying to figure out why the parents all apparently supported the relationship too
You really gotta pay attention to who you talk to… these days you can’t just meet and go get in random cars… even if you think it was someone you know. As we can see it’s easy to fake who you are; all you have to do is put up some pictures and talk sweet. That being said, she was a sweet girl and she gave this person the benefit of the doubt. This person took advantage of that and they are evil for doing so. Can’t imagine thinking you are going to hang with an old flame but someone kidnaps and kills you instead. Truly horrifying.
'these days' are the safest days in history
@@spiff1 yeah lots of creeps out there
You shouldn’t be getting into stranger calls even back then! They just didn’t know that it was dangerous to hitch hike, strangers equal danger. And that nice looking charismatic man waving you over? Well he’s a serial killer and he’s not there to just ask for directions
Im sorry but her mom allowing a 15 year old to leave the house alone at 10 p.m. to meet a strange man then falling alseep is utterly insane to me. Even if it would have been who it was supposed to be, letting your daughter walk out late at night to meet up with a 19 year old because he "had something to give her" just baffles me. Sad case on all fronts, but I feel that this one could have been prevented.
She should of made her block him after finding there was a “romantic” interest thing. That age thing is stat r level pedo.
I agree, there's no way my daughter would be going out to meet a much older boy at 10pm, it's ludicrous and my mami stayed awake till I got home no matter what age I was if out partying for example, she "couldn't sleep till she knew I was safe" - quote
Nor sure about the lip piercing, either
@@colettegibson6516yesss I couldn’t stop thinking how nasty that piercing was
I agree. Not to mention he was a complete stranger to the mom. I would be like "No"! He can come back in the morning and introduce himself properly and drop whatever he needs to drop off at the door. Beyond all that, my kids are not allowed social media, much less talk to and give their address to someone I don't know. A lot of these case could be prevented if the parents did the bare minimum.
It’s easy to judge someone’s parenting when they lose a child like this. Not that I agree with her being allowed to go out or what not, but I’m absolutely certain her poor mother thinks about that every damn day. Doubt that woman needs anyone judging her, she has lost a child. Furthermore, lip piercing? Really? Knocking on a murdered 15yo’s facial piercing…? Confused why anyone feels comfortable enough to even type that, then post it. Whew.
As for being her cousin, and being to young to remember what happened at the time, I'm glad I got to watch this video to actually understand what happened. Thinking about this monster has made me sick to my stomach, I hope he never gets out of prison and lives every second of his miserable life regretting what he did, and never has a moment where he's at peace. It's genuinely terrifying to think what she had gone through. RIP Nichole, may she rest in peace forever.
Poor sweet girl. RIP Nicole and peace to your family ♥
Police: "the first 24 hours are the most important in solving crimes"
Also Police: "we're going to wait at least 24 hours before even starting to investigate missing persons"
Been saying same thing for years. Biggest contradiction of all time.
This Kyle dude was trouble the day he was born. Nothing but bad decisions.
Since he was a newborn baby?
@@shinzaguyup. Pick up a newspaper 📰
babies can't make bad decisions@@Tiffani_AnnA
He was only 20 but had produced a daughter, now 4 and he wanted to be with a 15 year old girl. Something was very wrong with this dude.
B-b-but he was a good boy, just started community college and was turning his life around xD.
Remember they thought he was someone they already knew. They didn't know he was a stranger stealing someone's identity online
He wasn't a stranger and he was someone they already new. Did you watch the video with audio on mute? 😅
😂😂😂 did you watch the video?
Horrid, I just can’t get over the ease with which young people kill for no reason and then have the audacity to plead not guilty! RIP sweet girl 🙏
So sad for the girl and family. Devastating. That POS showed no remorse either.
Why refer to a child as a “young woman”? It diminishes the severity of a horrific crime!
Well, 15 year olds do quinceañeras all the time, because they are considered young woman now.
absolutely horrific either way
She was a young woman!
@@ninagarrard883915 is a child
It really doesn’t diminish it at all
Between this channel and EWU the amount of evil there is out there is saddening
I think about and talk about it with my family everyday. My son is 22 with his own family, but I still make sure they do not trust everyone fully. 😢 Some of these stories make me sad and others infuriate me. Be careful out there!! 🙏
lol thats just a fraction
Yeah.. why do I keep watching?
The parents let their daughter go outside to meet a guy and then never made sure she came back inside ?????
Exactly…there’s no way on earth I would go to bed whilst my daughter was out, at night.
Exactly! Poor parenting! I would have stood right there and watched. She was only FIFTEEN! She shouldn’t have been meeting boys anyway!
This right here. Like Oh My God... you as the parent are letting your child go met up with a boy who DROVE there who you have NEVER met? And not at least make sure she made it back into the house? I really want to believe there is some wholesome reasoning behind this like the mom is handicapped or mentally disabled in some way. Okay so you have THAT much trust in your daughter... but also don't think about her safety? Seems more likely they didn't care...
When I was a teenager, my family lived in a very rural part of Idaho. My parents were very trusting, and would’ve had no problem at all doing exactly what this woman did.
It’s different when you live in a very rural, normally very safe part of the world. You look at the world in a totally different way. You’re way more trusting, to the point of what looks like naïveté and stupidity to people who live in a larger city. 🤷🏻♀️
@@HavaWMInteresting when you consider meth use & child traffiking are a real issue in rural USA areas. Cornbread Mafia I think they call it.
Thank you for telling this story. I am from Maine and remember this case. So sad RIP Nichole. Hard to believe it has been 10 years since this happened.
Dear young people.. I understand firsthand how exciting it can be to encounter handsome strangers online. The key is maintain your dignity on the first real life meet. It can be rewarding so long as you take responsibility for your own safety. Please do not ever give your address or arrange to hang out privately. Meet them at a busy market/mall, no later than sunset for a casual stroll, you don’t need a ride to or from. Allow them to pass or fail a public litmus test, keep your home separate & safe :}
I wish an adult had said all that to me years ago. Whenever an adult speaks reasonably kids listen and it would have saved me from some awful stuff. A lot of parents think if they make something sound as dangerous or horrible as possible that it's better. But literally nothing could be less helpful. Kids aren't stupid and they know when they are being misled so what happens is they just don't trust anything the parent says after that.
my older sister used to get mad that when she went on dates I would ALWAYS come out meet dude and take pics of licsence plates, but oh well may have saved her life and we dont know. every dude who would get mad I did that always turned out to be a looser too
You're a totally awesome sister!!!
You had to do that for your OLDER sister xD?
@@reignman30 yes 11 years older too
This story is crazy 😧. Great work Beyond Evil
Yeah I remember this. I lived in Bangor at the time. I can’t believe it’s been over 10 years now! Still utterly heartbreaking 💔 RIP Nichole
Great summary and commentary. Prayers for mom.
You guys are so respectful to the victims and mindful of their loved ones and it puts you miles above other true crime creators. ❤❤
But I don’t think it‘s respectful to call a 15 yo Teenager Girl a young woman.
Poor kid and family. Horrible
I love the opening music! It makes me feel calm. Don’t ever change it!
So sad, so senseless. What a loss, such a lovely young girl.
Thanks for the upload!
Thank you for sharing this story.
If my child was meeting someone they met online. I would not let them go on their own. You can’t trust anyone even strangers you meet on the internet. Be mindful about who you met, in person or on internet. Just be careful and don’t ever meet someone you don’t know by yourself.
She shouldn’t have been doing that at 15 anyway. The internet was fairly new when I was that age and my mom would never allow me to meet anyone in person. I now understand why she was so concerned about us being on the internet.
I wouldn't allow my children at all.
And at 15yrs old Nichole shouldn't have been involved with boyfriends.
You can't trust anyone even strangers 😂
@@patrickmcdonagh539 so true
When we were still raising our girls, there was not a single minute from birth to college when we didn’t know where they were and who they were with. We also monitored all of their online activity. We weren’t overbearing, rather just responsible parents because of these stories. They’re also both absolutely beautiful, so that was my extra headache!
I always look forward to your newest videos dropping
Thanks for making great content! Keep it up ❤
Mom stop letting your 15,16 just turned 17 yr old daughter date a Adult male especially with a child. Unless your child is about to be 18 they have no business with a boyfriend any to be legal to buy n contribute alcohol into your childs life
So his brother n Guy girlfriend knew but said nothing as this dude offers to babysit this young ladies sister? They need to be charged. It was his girlfriend that I'm sure pushed his loyalty to her that he went to prove it
So looking forward to your videos. Thank you❤
We have a long drive in a rural area. I would never have gone to bed if my daughter was going to the end of the driveway to meet someone she’d never met in person. Sorry, not trying to be mean, but I would have walked at least halfway and waited or most likely taken her to the end of the driveway and met the person as well.
RIP Nichole.
He was pretending to be someone she knew well, remember?
This story is just beyond heartbreaking 💔 😢
R.I.P beautiful Nichole, you won't ever be forgotten princess ❤️ 🕊
Such a tragic loss for her family and friends and he is a complete waste of space. Thanks for sharing this video!
Imagine your life ending because you fought back too hard. Absolutely horrible.
WAIT WHAT... her daughter went to meet a guy in the driveway at like 8pm, and her mom didnt check to see when she came back? didnt notice her missing till the AM.. stellar mom
Poor Momma... What can you say? Only worry and hurt... I'm so sorry she went through this. I can't even imagine...
Well she could've started by not letting her daughter go out to meet some boy that late at night, or at the very least made sure she came back in BEFORE SHE WENT TO BED!!!! All she had to do was make that boy come up to the house to drop off whatever he needed to drop off and this whole thing would've been prevented.
How is it that someone who has a history with crime, and lead police with a high speed chase with a motorcycle and hit a police officer be free to be sentenced later (at the time) to murder someone in cold blood? This all could've been averted.
Because eluding isn’t a life sentence 😂😂?
Happy New Year!
Keep on being awesome.
❤, from Texas!!!
Happy New Year to you as well.
Sending positive vibes from the Windy City 💚
@Curious-Irish-Angel Happy New Year Chicago!
Happy new year to you too 🌹! Greetings from the UK 🇬🇧
@@MissMariQueen Hello 👋 across the pond! (I've always wanted to say that!! Lol)
Awesome content! Much love from South Africa 🇿🇦 ❤
Why did a 20 year old want to be with a 14 year old? Why did her parents let her go out with him 😑
he likes em tight
This is what I was saying! How is everyone just okay with her dating a 20yr old?
She was 15. 15 is a young adult now days. Look at all those girls wanting a quinceañera for their birthdays.
Girls are getting slootier younger now, Western wahmen teach girls to be 304s tut tut @@KrisFlix
not saying its any less bad but the real brian butterfield was 19 and the one behind the screen was 20, still horrible and disgusting but i can understand somewhat why the mom would be okay with it, she had probably done it many times before and listened like her mom said.. i feel so bad for her and her family. also poor real brian, i would change my name if i was him like damn bro seemed kind. which is why the mom was probably okay with it (the 20yr old had a whole record of crimes so im sure thats why he had to hide behind his friends name)
So the mother claims to be this protective mother, but she lets her 15yo daughter go to the end of the road after 9pm, when it's dark, to see some boy she's never met, and she just goes to bed before she returns? That just doesn't seem right. I would've had that boy come up to the house.
Right!!! No motherly instincts at all
I'm sorry, but who lets their 15 year old child date a 20 year old guy with a kid, then lets them meet up with a stranger at night and goes to bed and doesn't at least wait up to make sure they come back home. Some very bad choices, RIP Nichole.
Her mother told her don’t go anywhere with anyone and instead of watching her or wait for her, she goes to sleep like a moron what kind of mother is that?
stop with the victim blaming. you're disgusting, and nobody is perfect....
@@michelerenem shit up clown and listen to your mother and your mother should of drive her home or have her spend the night the mother let her go in the streets at night and then to sleep like a moron
I dont know why it is this 24 rule to try to find anyone missing in the US?
In my country the police can search right away something they usualy do as long as people dont call about they're partner breaking up with them again or are just waisted.
This case being close to me makes me wanna see one of these channels pick up the case that just finished here in Washington County Maine. Native reservation, 3-4 miles from my town, a female was stabbed nearly 500 times. Arrested a male and female, end of the trial, female was found guilty, male it was a hung jury.
I am also in ME. Recently moved from MA to the southern border of ME and have not heard of that case. That sounds horrific! ❤ RIP to those taken by these evil creeps!!
She'll be out in 5, shes a woman
I am a lifelong resident of Maine. This was a truly heartbreaking case. People think Maine is great and all but there have been numerous gory deaths that have hit the news in recent years. Hoping your channel will look into several other murders and/or disappearances that have stumped even the experts.
Nicole was so beautiful ❤️ RIP angel 😔
So she was 15 smoked pot and was already getting out of a controlling relationship after having other relationships Great parenting mum
The fact that the mum went to bed whilst Nichole was out says it all for me…x
@@phoebebennett3024 - Absolutely. No one even got up during the night to pee and thought to check to see if she made it back safely? Teens with that much freedom unfortunately make prime candidates for evil people.
i was raised strict as ever and i still found ways to be sneaky and do the same things she did.. 30 now and i wish i would’ve been smarter about things..but nothing to do with parenting.
That final picture 😢
The mother didn't want to be too intrusive in her daughter's affairs by letting her meet the boy by herself in the dark. Big mistake. These young girls are precocious and should definitely not be left to deal with life on their own. It wasn't even the guy she thought she was on the phone with. You have to be kidding me. That's how ignorant these girls are. Mothers carry your daughters until they are settled in with a good guy. Use your experience to watch over them. Take nothing for granted.
That shouldn’t have been allowed. She was far too young to be meeting boys online.
I agree, she should of told her not to meet the guy in the dark and could see him in the day. And don’t go to bed and let your kid worry if it’s a stranger outside or someone else who pulled up.
I agree 💯 exactly my comment above too..
The mother failed her daughter in the worst way here.
This has weird old timey nice guy feels. She wasn't just a young girl, she was a kid who didn't understand the danger. Do I blame the mom? Yeah a bit. I blame the dad too, where was he? I blame the parents of the murderer, an obviously troubled dude with a history. Daughters don't need a 'good guy' to take care of them, they need the knowledge to take care of themselves. Daughter or son, gender doesn't really even matter. Teach your kid the dangers of the world but don't suffocate them. Teach your kids to be decent human beings.
hadithi ya tahadhari..
Utafiti mkubwa na Uwasilishagi..
Kuvunja moyo Pumzika Kwa Amani..
How many young people have lost their lives due to the inaction of the police because of the teenage runaway stereotype? Like who cares if most teens turn up before long, why take the chance? That's insane to me.
It's not a stereotype. 99.999% of the time, the kid has either run away or they've snuck over to a friend's house. Police need reason to believe there's foul play.
Please leave the young ladies mother alone with this creep for a couple hours
Why was a 15yr old dating adults? There are so many things about this case that don't make sense. She was 15!!
Grooming
Go to bed while your daughter is not in the house? !
Come on....
His Lawyer is the perfect reason why I hate Defence Lawyers.
Everybody deserves a defence i know that,
But the Lawyer trying to get those note kicked out is disgusting.
At that moment he knew very well that his man was guilty yet still tried pulling dirty tricks,
And eventually putting other females at risk of loosing their lives. 🤮
When guilt is clear, all they should be doing is making sure their client gets a fair trial. All the dirty tricks they play are not what the justice system is about. So many of them lack any ethics or decency.
How can you allow a 15 year old girl to go out at 10pm??!!??😢
They say Moms never recover from this type of loss. They take their broken hearts w them to the grave once their body finally stops working and let's them die. The agony they endure thru the rest of their life, is much more than most of us ever know.
Look into her eyes...she's broken smfh
He should serve 2 life sentences. He's Killed two females
💯
The haunting sadness in her eyes just kills me. Sure doesn't look it will ever go away
@@jamiemetcalfe7945 rite smh 💔🥺sad situation
I'd never survive something like this, idh what it takes
@@aaa4181 u must not have kids lmfao
U better watch ur words missy!! That type of shit always comes back on ya!! Smh wouldn't be me!! Lmao u just created ur OWN karma there!! Good luck w that! Ur definitely gonna need it! Or...u could stay childless n single forever! I mean lmfao that's always an option!!🤡💩👹😆
@@aaa4181absolutely agree with you…there’s no way on this planet I’d be going to bed whilst my daughter was out at night SMH x
He got 60 years if anyone wanted to know.
Thanks. x
This should be an automatic death sentence.
Letting your 15 yo date a 20 year old is never gonna end well. I feel for the mom, but god.
I wonder if she lied about how old he was. If I saw a guy when I was in my teens, I just said I was seeing a female friend.
Kids are honest these days, but I still wouldn't allow my teen to date until 17 or 18, that being said, they could just lie to me like I used to.
And I did often meet friends from online in the late 90s. Ohhh the naivety.
@@justagrrl1981 I sure hope so.
That all you say yet smoke weed at 12 dusvirgin at 10
@@frankfestus114 lol what?
If she knew she should be locked up
Am I the only one who laughed when he said “resauce” at 6:39😭
Yes
This guy was a home health aide for a disabled person? They will hire anybody
The company is shut down for illegal practices they would take just about anyone. The owner of said company was sued for firing someone without reasoning a year or two after this
That 24hour rule is outdated. It was put in place during the time of no cell phones, when people didn't have a mode of communication on their person at all times. 24hours was enough time given for your missing loved one to get incontact.
That poor little petal 😢 and her mum just breaks your heart what a tragedy....hold your loved ones while you can..
patiently waiting 😅
That poor mother. We live for our children.
If you loved your daughter that much, you would’ve never let her meet anyone in the driveway without watching her or going to bed without making sure she was in the house safely plain and simple🤷🏾♂️
so sick of victim blamers...
@@michelerenem her mother isn’t the victim Jack @$🤡
the mother goes to bed knowing her young daughter is out? Neglectful and selfish.
She's in heaven
The mom holds some accountability
How does a county sheriff slow their child to get that bad? Poor parenting
Can't wait, love your channel ❤️
I recommend yall covering the Breana Rouhselang case. Happened in mishawaka indiana a few years ago. Very sad story about a pregnant girl getting dumped in a dumpster behind a restaurant
C I was just about to say they needed to get rid of the 24hrs crap. The most crucial information, evidence etc is within the first 24-48 hrs of a missing persons cases. It's best to interview family members, friends, witnesses & suspect then. So many cases have gone cold cause sum law enforcement agencies make people wait to report it. It's 2024 back n the day law's need to b updated ASAP smh 🤦🏽♀️
All you perfect, self-righteous moms in these comments…smh. Nichole didn’t go out to meet “some guy” or a “stranger” at the end of her own driveway. Nichole wouldn’t have even left her own property, had it been legit. It was supposed to be a friend of hers. Her mom went over the rules with her and trusted her daughter. It is not the moms fault nor Nichole’s fault that an evil, predator faked the identity of one of her friends and took advantage. Stop victim blaming and put the blame on the right person.
Thank you!
I'm shocked 2:49 as a mother..I kind of blame the mum who should have at least waited until she came back or heard of a call..she said she's just picking something..at 9 pm!
At least his four year old daughter will be spared from having to grow up under the influence of that pos.
Well the mother seemed like a real piece of work too. The 4yo is just going to end up with a real loser for a step daddy probably.
So Mom let her date an adult with a criminal record to boot, are you kidding me.Where the hell is the sense in these parents heads.The problem today is we don't have parents we have friends that act part time like parents.
Was so hard watching her mom struggle to speak. 😢
Imagine being 20 and someone just told you that you'll spend at least 60 years in prison. I'd off myself on the same day.
I can’t believe he babysat while mom and everyone else was searching for Nichole!!
Goes to show the depth of his depravity
If that were the case, the narration would have stated "he babysat" or "he even babysat"; what was stated was "he offered to babysit", which more than likely means that he wasn't taken up on his offer... thank God! Can you imagine?!?
@@loveforeignaccentsexactly, ppl need to really listen to the story before they comment
@@ukohiko5009 People need to really listen to the story, PERIOD.
Instead of offering to help search, he offered to babysit a little girl. Bit odd init
I would never let my daughter meet anybody for any reason unless I was there. This stuff happens all the time. You can never trust anyone.
How did nobody not know she was missing until the following morning? If my kid goes out im not sleeping until my kid is back in the house unless they have planned to stay overnight elsewhere.
what a scummy thing to do... not only did he take the life of an innocent girl, her last moments were full of butyral, hurt, heartache and fear. then on top of that, someone else who had NOTHING to do with anything, is going to feel some kind of guilt or worse because she was catfished using that person's name and will be forever associated with this case :( so fkn sad i hate people this is absolutely disgusting
I've been watching true crime channels on youtube for over 6 years and I can safely say this is dumbest killer I've ever seen.