A Blind Review of The Sky Island Saga

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 сер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 24

  • @joeylyngdal9412
    @joeylyngdal9412 Місяць тому +6

    Welp, there goes my next 2 hours

  • @timothywilcox1539
    @timothywilcox1539 Місяць тому +2

    Holy shit, it is here!
    I am so happy, especially since I caught this within the hour it released! It also means I can add some thoughts about things I didn't get to mention during my binge through your shorts!
    1:22 : I interpreted him more-so saying that he was suspicious about that fact, rather than a confirmation. It would probably be widely heard that Smoker defeated Crocodile, because that is what the government wants everyone to think. This ginger marine is just suspicious of the truth.
    Also, side-note, I totally thought that the red-head was an undercover pirate or a descendant of a pirate that got robbed by Zenny, hence why he's so cruel to him specifically and so intent on getting his treasure. As a filler enjoyer, that was *my* one big disappointment of this arc.
    6:33 : My second favorite one piece movie (so far), yes! This is what I was most excited for you to review in this Saga review. Also, I wouldn't have thought that this happens *during* Jaya, I interpreted this happening either directly after Alabasta, or being between the filler arcs.
    I *love* Gasparde as a villain, he's so damn cruel and I even like how he tries to extend compliments to Luffy for challenging him so, (And Luffy managing to cut Gasparde even without the flour after Gasparde destroyed the hat was metal af) but Luffy shrugs it all off to call Gasparde a miserable excuse for a pirate and infuriate the former marine.
    (Also, he resembles a marine in the Enies Lobby arc... it makes me make a connection...)
    But the real highlight was Needless and Shuraia's battle, no doubt. Shuraia tanking the hits he could take and avoiding the hits he couldn't made for a good back-and-forth against Needless, who was seemingly much faster and stronger than him.
    And the end bit with there being three Don Krieg wanted posters gives the hilarious implication that they were preparing for if Don Krieg *came back* to the grand line! They know to fear the world's strongest man!
    17:00 : God created food, but the devil created spices, after all :)
    21:17 : As someone who is watching a version of the dub that still has japanese subtitling, I appreciate you bringing to my attention that this man's name is Jesus.
    27:25 : Indeed, I think the main issue is that, like with Baron Butler (Or Battler) in the third movie, the people making the special were stuck between One Piece being a comedy and an action anime, at least in presentation. So their compromise with making their one off villain was to... make them dumb, incompetent, stupid looking, or a combination of the three, in an effort to make them funny.
    With Gasparde, he was definitively in the role of an action anime villain, with no comedy surrounding him. And with El Duraggo, while he is portrayed as singleminded and a little stupid, he's still treated seriously as a threat. Not because the story yells at us that he's a threat, but because we *see* El Duraggo do some scary shit, like blowing up that castle with his mouth laser. El Duraggo is a villain that has gags. Butler and Bayen(?) are villains that *are* gags. We can't take them seriously even if the story wants us too, because their introduction and most of their subsequent existence is treated as a joke. This is a problem that shows back up in Movie Seven, so watch out for that if you haven't seen it already.
    30:27 : Are you okay after that? I hope a pin didn't land in you.
    33:11 : Fair reaction XD Also, great choice to use TTS and Vocaloid voices for the rando question askers!
    33:29 : It stands for *DAVE*, obviously!
    37:11 : To be fair to you, I think both Enel and Eneru are acceptable localizations, it's just that some people are being needlessly manga-purist about it. And I am not talking about Gasparde's henchman.
    48:08 : I don't have much to say on skypeia, you've mentioned most of the points already, but I will say, your fortnite running joke is great.
    1:21:35 : I mentioned this before in the short, but, on the subject of Eneru (Or Enel, both work) not killing anyone, I think a large part of why they survived is hearing the bell ring.
    Now, that may sound silly, but I think it ties into themes of hope, and how Eneru took his time to deliberately toy with the Shandorians to drain them of hope. Giving them a minute to try and kill him, letting Wyper watch Isa's mother(?) gets shocked. These people have had their homeland stolen from them for so long, and they are fighting for a goal that seems impossible. The soul of their people has been robbed from them, and every moment they fight against heavens forces, it seems more impossible to get it back.
    Maybe it would be better if they laid down and died once Eneru had struck them, they may feel. Determination is also a big theme of One Piece, and its evident that the people's determination is drained rapidly throughout this battle.
    But when the bell rings, their goal, their history, rings out, hope is able to return to the souls of these people. Their bodies may be burned and beaten, but their goal has been achieved. Shandora is alive, and thus, so are it's people.
    I definitely think that this surviving asspull is much better than others, as it ties into the themes. I have no excuses for Pagaya though.
    1:24:54 : "Don't commit genocide on anime egypt" r/brandnewsentence
    1:26:05 : Ah yes, the most shonen anime One Piece movie thus far. Little substance aside from some cool fight scenes and powers. I think comparing it to Chopper's Animal Kingdom is a little harsh, but I do see where you're coming from with that comparison. Maybe I just liked the cool anime battles more than the third movie, and maybe I'm someone that would like the original Broly movie.
    That baseball short is awesome though, I need to see it now!
    1:46:35 : Maybe the safe is intended to have multiple people open it?
    Now I look forward to when you give your full review of the extra content from LRLL to Water 7, as that holds my favorite movie of the ones I have seen. And it goes without saying, but I look forward to the rest of your content too! You're an entertaining and concise reviewer with my kind of humor, and your shorts are some of the highlights of my days!

  • @ashs1076
    @ashs1076 Місяць тому +1

    Ive been waiting for so long for this, i have to sadly skip your shorts ( after like them ofc) i cant wait for W7) IM ONLY LIKE 30 EPS ahead [sprry caps] and i cNt wait for you to catch up :)

  • @drakefire6675
    @drakefire6675 8 днів тому

    I can't wait for this man to learn about space pirates.

  • @fghdftgds
    @fghdftgds Місяць тому

    this was an incredible video

  • @GhadiEdits
    @GhadiEdits Місяць тому +1

    FINALLY THIS CAME OUT LETS GOOOOOO

  • @notsosilentprotag
    @notsosilentprotag 21 день тому

    He hits Hachans cover story....says it's in consequential.....my inner self repeatedly saying....imma tell em

  • @annicajakobsson
    @annicajakobsson Місяць тому

    I hope you’ll watch the Netflix live action at some point as well, “re-watching” the series through/with you makes me realize just how many little Easter eggs they had in that first season! Loved it!

  • @GuyWhoWatchesStuff
    @GuyWhoWatchesStuff Місяць тому

    YESSSSS

  • @ShrkJ
    @ShrkJ Місяць тому

    Cherry pie guy is so goated

  • @GhadiEdits
    @GhadiEdits Місяць тому

    What i do for these videos is i watch some of it then the some of it later and on and on until i finish it (yes im too lasy to watch a video over 1 hr long 😅)

  • @GigabitGigabyte
    @GigabitGigabyte Місяць тому +1

    Cherry pie guy, DOES return, and he does, a lot of stuff, not gonna spoil tho

    • @Scented_Shadow
      @Scented_Shadow Місяць тому +2

      You already spoiled.

    • @GigabitGigabyte
      @GigabitGigabyte Місяць тому

      @Scented_Shadow what did I spoil, I just said he would return, something he already said would definitely happen due to him having such a big build up, I just reassured the assumption that he would return, I didn't spoil anything, I'm sorry if I somehow did

    • @Scented_Shadow
      @Scented_Shadow Місяць тому +1

      @@GigabitGigabyte If someone strongly suspects something they don't "know" it. He also "definitely knew" Zoro would unlock mantra sometime during the fight and he was wrong about that. Confirming a suspicion that isn't certain yet is also spoiling.

    • @GigabitGigabyte
      @GigabitGigabyte Місяць тому

      ​@Scented_Shadow blackbeard is a main antagonist, he may not know what he does, but he most certainly knows that he would come back, it isn't a spoiler if it is blatantly obvious

    • @Scented_Shadow
      @Scented_Shadow Місяць тому +1

      @@GigabitGigabyte It is a spoiler if it has not been outright stated by the show. Things that a viewer might think are "obvious" aren't yet confirmed. They might end up true, but they also might not. They are suspicions. By confirming someone's suspicion or expectation, you are spoiling. This person is NOWHERE near a point in the story where it's obvious that Blackbeard will be a main antagonist, so good job spoiling that now, too. At most you might expect that he's important, but as a new viewer, at this point, you wouldn't know yet whether this is true, and how it will happen. By confirming that it's true, and now elaborating on it too, you 100% are spoiling, whether you believe it or not.

  • @SwaggerDolphin1
    @SwaggerDolphin1 Місяць тому

    Are you going to check out the abridged version? hahhaha

  • @charzardbry
    @charzardbry Місяць тому

    Howdy

  • @FastSickle
    @FastSickle Місяць тому

    Would love to see more longer form content, but I'm not a fan of basically rewatching content I've already seen. Gonna stick around to see if I change my mind, but as a newish viewer I wanted to click off the video the second the shorts clips started playing. This is just feedback to give you an idea what some of your audience might be thinking, please don't take this comment the wrong way, it's not even critism, just an opinion

    • @timothywilcox1539
      @timothywilcox1539 Місяць тому

      In my opinion, I still think this has some value for people that don't like the broken shorts format on PC, or wanna watch it on a TV screen.

  • @dominicgarcia7584
    @dominicgarcia7584 Місяць тому

    Let go