THIS LIST IS OUTDATED!!! I made a newer one that is actually more well thought out than my other ""update"" video Here it is: ua-cam.com/video/h1e8EcLm6QU/v-deo.html You can of course watch this video first if you want too (please watch it i spent a lot of time on it)
I love the representation of the deaf community when creating this tierlist, but it would also be interesting to see a list done by people who can hear
I like that that they like flipped the roles of the Celestials for both games, like in My Singing Monsters, they're babies when all the others are grown, but during Dawn of Fire when all the other monsters are babies, the Celestials are grown.
The reason why they are baby’s in MSM is because the celestials sacrificed them selfs in DOF when the mirror islands were still connected and the reason why they sacrificed them selfs were because in DOF there is a event called the “cataclysm” when cloud island and cave and party island were collapsing so the celestials sacrificed them selfs to save the monsters but somehow red prismatic quibble survived and it evolved into epic quibble.
Fun fact: the shugabush island is actually based on an original song called “love or money” by Kristin bush. Which is the voice actor for the shugavox. Just wanted to give a little bit of backstory for the shugabush island as an attempt for people to be more interested in the island because I personally find it underrated and I like it a little more after learning about the lore of shugabush islands making.
@@KrispyKitty66 I do not stand for the light island slander. It’s beautiful and yes it’s supposed to be repetitive and only 4 monsters play the whole song and the rest are great and well spaced.
Fun fact: gold islands sounds like a "credits" song because it was originally intended to be the last island of the game, thankfully the game got more popular and they kept working on it because over half of the content wouldn't even exist. Edit: I'm very glad you didn't shit on light island because literally everyone hates on it.
Earth island now that it has epic wubbox, should be AT LEAST B tier. If not S (And I know this is not how you rank them, but the song sounds better if you just, you know, *mute the werdos)*
The bad thing about his tiers is that he makes one monster bring the whole island down even though you could just get rid of the monster and you don't have to have all the monsters.
I mean it's pretty obvious that he's rating them as their full, unaltered versions so yeah if that one monster ruins it it's reasonable for it to be knocked down a tier if it's being judged by the sound of every monster all at once
And thumpies, he’s way too quiet, which is a shame because he always has cool parts Which is ironic because the actual instrument in orchestras is loud and booming
@@TheRandomWolf It is possible to hear the thumpies, especially in the version before the pongping was added because of their placement, but yeah the thumpies are really good on cave island
I agree with your placement of Ethereal Island. It's my favourite song of all of the Islands in the whole damn game. Frankly, I feel like Whisp ties the whole thing together. Absolutely beautiful song. Also yeah, the Wubbox kills the whole vibe.
the reason why Wubbox fits Wublin island its because he created the wublins. in the other islands he kinda feels like the uninvited guy in the party(still love him), but in wublin island he strongly fits
@@luckychicken1563 i gotta agree with the video tho, the singing guys bring down the sound of all the islands theyre in they just drown out everything. Also plant island does not need fucking dubstep
I love how the monsters on Starhenge just seem more talented and professional than any other monsters. They've been doing this for potentially thousands of years, I love it.
I love the wubboxes I didn’t know people didn’t like them. I think they should be on every island eventually. Ironically the only island where I don’t like the sound is on wublin island. I just feel like that wubbox is under utilized, it doesn’t really make any or it’s signature beeps or chirps and it just ends up sounding like just another drum monster.
Honestly wublin wubbox’s is the only one that doesn’t make in island a little messy that’s why it’s not liked on any other island + wublin wubbox’s is 100% worth it
Ethereal island wubbox is utter garbage. Ethereal island is one that could have either been left alone and without a wubbox OR had more time put into the creation of the wubbox for the island, as it is so out of place with the song.
@@MelatoninMashups…it’s not. it’s fine. random sounds thrown together is cave island, and it still sounds half-decent. shanty has great sounds and alright sounds. a random sound would be gobbleygourd anywhere else except for shanty. monculus is absolutely amazing, same with schmoochle. castle bass is great too. how does anyone say that this island is dogshit?
Seeing people hating denchuhs really hurts me being the first monster I every saw and got me into the game being hated just hurts me there still my fav
in my opinion earth island is not cringe I do not see how do the earthquake is cringe and also shugabush is a decent song and lastly cave island was meant to be a rock song
Seasonal shanty had the best rating I've seen. I've seen too many people put it all the way at the bottom when in my opinion its tied best with cold island
My s-rank list is: cold island, earth island, bone island, magical sanctum, wublin island, tribal island, and star henge. This is my s-rank, now I’m going to bed as it is 4:47 AM in my time as I’m writing this lol, good night everyone
Gobbleygourd basically on both islands (not talking about seasonal shanty) “Ah yes, this song is really good, I like I-“ GOBBLEY GOBBLEY GOO GAH6WNYEGAGEYW6YA6W5567W “….shit.”
my list: S: Water Island, Wublin Island A: Ice Island, Earth Island, Bone Island, Mythical Isand, Seasonal Shanty, Tribal Island B: Plant Island, Air Island, Light Island, Psychic Island, Magical Sanctum C: Faerie Island, Ethereal Island, Celestial Island, Gold Island D: Fire Haven, Fire Oasis.. (omg these are absolute garbage) F: Shugabush Island🤮 If you don't agree with water and wublin.. you simply don't deserve an opinion.. they are obvi the best like bffr
Seasonal shanty is my #1 favourite song i love that island the amazing event mix is perfect and there’s no way I’m gonna hate it even with Wubboxes i would still love it it’s just a dream come true I once dreamed i played my singing monsters as usual and there was a seasonal island in the game And a few months later they added seasonal shanty i was so happy when it was added I would instantly putt it in S Tear
Tbh I only disagree with the shuggabush island ranking, shit goes hard fr fr. Ethereal Island I completely agree with, I think it is the best island in the game but THAT WUBBOX MAN it ruins the whole vibe of the song.
Yall didn't really put Air in C tier? The final medley bit is honestly really smoothing, and the contribution of Maw, Riff, Trox, Yawstrich, the Pom Poms (and Hoola) and the werdos all mix really well together
THIS LIST IS OUTDATED!!!
I made a newer one that is actually more well thought out than my other ""update"" video
Here it is: ua-cam.com/video/h1e8EcLm6QU/v-deo.html
You can of course watch this video first if you want too (please watch it i spent a lot of time on it)
DID YOU JUST PUT MY FAVORITE SONG IN D TIER?? WHY
The fuck?!
Whyd the focken Hell u Rated earth a SHITTY D TEAR?
@@KINGER121 this is outdated
Ain't no way put earth island in d tear
It is (weird-oh)
I love the representation of the deaf community when creating this tierlist, but it would also be interesting to see a list done by people who can hear
True
bro really put seasonal shanty on S tier and Earth island on D tier
You didn't need to KILL him, damn.
💀💀💀 damn
@@frostflamegames673 We need to report this murder to 911
Fun Fact: Gold Island was actually supposedly to be the thank you song and final island
And yet they still went and added more islands 😂 I’m glad they did otherwise I would’ve quit
i miss when it was that
@@kaydencearman3657 yeah, they didnt expect the game to become as popular as it did so they continued adding islands
@@kaydencearman3657 me too
Fun fact: everyone knows this already
For the whole "I can't hear this monster" problem...
just group multiple of the same monster together to increase it's overall volume.
@allanday6606 all monsters volume when placed is already max
@@hmmm6476 he means lower the other monsters to hear the quieter ones
also for the ppl reading replies only do this if youre okay with that monsters quality sounding terrible in the actual song. it will be louder tho
Ain’t no way this man put earth island in d tier
Thats because he didnt hear the beatdrop
He didnt..
earth is literally the best island like what the hell
I disagree with all of you
Earth island is a bop yes, but personally I think Bone and mythical can top earth.
True
"DO THE EARTHQUAKE?.......EWWWWWW" And I took that personally.
Bro also said it was cringe💀
Good
*they hated him for he told them the truth*
werdos aren’t even monsters, they’re just pathetic.
@@Dumboi-ll1xg true words said by a wise man.
Bone is in a very respectable spot,the rest I mostly disagree with but that one placement earns my respect
I like that that they like flipped the roles of the Celestials for both games, like in My Singing Monsters, they're babies when all the others are grown, but during Dawn of Fire when all the other monsters are babies, the Celestials are grown.
Oh thats why they were looking weird
The reason why they are baby’s in MSM is because the celestials sacrificed them selfs in DOF when the mirror islands were still connected and the reason why they sacrificed them selfs were because in DOF there is a event called the “cataclysm” when cloud island and cave and party island were collapsing so the celestials sacrificed them selfs to save the monsters but somehow red prismatic quibble survived and it evolved into epic quibble.
we aint gonna talk about how we have literally the exact opposite opinions
ESPECIALY with shugabush island
Shugabush had amazing sounds
No bc I play since 2015 and I hate this fucking island
real sugarbush is such a w
What about magical sanctum?
he did shugabush and earth island dirty, there aren't any D or lower tier islands in the game (besides for light island)
Water island and earth island were at a low tier because they didn’t have their epic wubboxes yet, rethink your ranking
Don’t think he likes wubboxes very much
Bro earth island a tier
Woah, a time capsule
bro fr i fucking love earth island
@@7h2ubfn9h35 frfrongong
Fun fact: the shugabush island is actually based on an original song called “love or money” by Kristin bush. Which is the voice actor for the shugavox. Just wanted to give a little bit of backstory for the shugabush island as an attempt for people to be more interested in the island because I personally find it underrated and I like it a little more after learning about the lore of shugabush islands making.
fun fact: MSM was supposed to end on the gold island, that's why it's like a sad song, or like a "thanks for playing" type song, so you were right.
an island will have one bad monster that plays in 2 measures of the song and he'll knock it down 2 tiers 💀
Exactly, he's too generous towards the actual bad songs😭
Yeah and then he puts light island in S...
@@KrispyKitty66 I do not stand for the light island slander. It’s beautiful and yes it’s supposed to be repetitive and only 4 monsters play the whole song and the rest are great and well spaced.
@@Blankspace-unrelated-to-song its... decent. Its not better than most of the A's tho
@@KrispyKitty66 it should be A at the very least 😁
For me, the island of earth and cave is very good
Cave is my favourite
Wow I actually love those two islands, thank you for making my day better!
i can't tell if the replies are sarkazm or not
WTF IS CAVE???
@@Mr.Who...2 it’s from dawn of fire
Ain't no way Shugabush Island is considered an 'Easy F Tier'. It's one of the best in the game
Based
Based
Country music is kinda ass
*his opinion*
@@rodolforosas4590 and it's wrong
FINALLY SOMEONE WHO LIKES COLD ISLAND! I agree it’s not the best, but it gets way too much hate.
Wait it gets hate!
?
It has an animation meme
@@Oak_Eggar animation memes are too edgy, and about a game about singing monsters? Tf
@@NyBrix1 i'm gonna make an animation meme with my msm ocs because of this comment. suffer
@@GhostBrimstone atleast its related lol
as he reviews WUBLIN ISLAND
“i THINK Wubbox actually fits on this island”
gee, i wonder why?
OMG HE ACTUALLY REFERED TO THE BLASSOOM AS A BASSOON!!! as a bassoon player this makes me so happy that someone actually knows what my instrument is.
Fun fact: gold islands sounds like a "credits" song because it was originally intended to be the last island of the game, thankfully the game got more popular and they kept working on it because over half of the content wouldn't even exist.
Edit: I'm very glad you didn't shit on light island because literally everyone hates on it.
Cave island slander, you have forfeit your existence
word
Boostyour3'sups Red flags
1. Earth Island D Tier 3:38
2. Psychic Island C Tier 6:12
3. Shugabush Island F Tier 10:34
Party D tier
Celestial C tier
CAVE F TIER
Psychic should switch with shugabush, it's so lifeless and boring, he was very generous towards it.
Wublin Island deserves to be higher
@@joaovictornogueira323 no it feels alive and periscorp with tapricorn sounds *g o d*
Seasonal shanty s
Earth island now that it has epic wubbox, should be AT LEAST B tier. If not S
(And I know this is not how you rank them, but the song sounds better if you just, you know, *mute the werdos)*
Are we not going to talk about plague doctor pipe organ guy. Come on, he’s so fucking cool.
You mean Poewk?
The epic wubbox on earth island is a banger
The bad thing about his tiers is that he makes one monster bring the whole island down even though you could just get rid of the monster and you don't have to have all the monsters.
I mean it's pretty obvious that he's rating them as their full, unaltered versions so yeah if that one monster ruins it it's reasonable for it to be knocked down a tier if it's being judged by the sound of every monster all at once
I don't think he ever played the game.
Ik you can get rid off a monster that is bringing down the song but then what the point in making the video cause your not ranking the actual song
“Do the earthquake is cringe” like yeah I agree but my guy. have you never heard cold island?
To me, I’d like Cave Island better if you could hear bowgart better, he adds so much to the song, and dang it all.
And thumpies, he’s way too quiet, which is a shame because he always has cool parts
Which is ironic because the actual instrument in orchestras is loud and booming
@@TheRandomWolf It is possible to hear the thumpies, especially in the version before the pongping was added because of their placement, but yeah the thumpies are really good on cave island
My favorite islands are psychic island, earth island, and cold island.
Finally somehow who liked psychic island
Cold island ranked high before Strombonin 🤯🤯
Strombonin is the best monster???
I was absolutely livid till I saw the bone island ranking. Perfection
When you said the earthquake I just realized I was shocked
Unpopular opinion space island is the best island in all of my singing monsters history
I love Space Island too :D
I agree with your placement of Ethereal Island. It's my favourite song of all of the Islands in the whole damn game. Frankly, I feel like Whisp ties the whole thing together. Absolutely beautiful song. Also yeah, the Wubbox kills the whole vibe.
Respect for the guy put seasonal shanty in s,but not sure about earth island..,
the reason why Wubbox fits Wublin island its because he created the wublins.
in the other islands he kinda feels like the uninvited guy in the party(still love him), but in wublin island he strongly fits
I agree “do the earthquake” is cringy, but cold island is so much worse. Like what is “lOoK aT tHe StArS iN tHe BiG bLaCk InK”
I thought I was the only one who thought that.
My only complain is that when you have an island that you don't like sometimes you ignore the good things about it but you have respectables opinion
Fr this guy has the most god awful opinions though
@@luckychicken1563 i gotta agree with the video tho, the singing guys bring down the sound of all the islands theyre in they just drown out everything. Also plant island does not need fucking dubstep
@@luckychicken1563 fr
@@calvingoshe7588 everyone knows most wubboxes ruin the songs
“It’s just a fast paced GO GO GO song” congle and pompom: I wonder why
Guys, calm down, he made this before the earth island epic wubbox
Its.. it's still bad
High asf watching a msm island tier list at midnight with school tomorrow
If you actually listened to Kristen Bush's "Love or Money" you'd appreciate shugabush island more, maybe actually listen to the song
I love how the monsters on Starhenge just seem more talented and professional than any other monsters. They've been doing this for potentially thousands of years, I love it.
Cave Island and the Magical Sanctum are my two favorites.
Me too. My favorite is definitely starhenge, then it would be cave. Then magical Sanctum
Thank you for calling Monculus (the stone hands guy) one of your favorites (He's the best in the game in my opinion)
I love the wubboxes I didn’t know people didn’t like them. I think they should be on every island eventually. Ironically the only island where I don’t like the sound is on wublin island. I just feel like that wubbox is under utilized, it doesn’t really make any or it’s signature beeps or chirps and it just ends up sounding like just another drum monster.
I think its pretty good, i do agree that it doesn't really do much, and its a major pain to wake it up too.
Honestly wublin wubbox’s is the only one that doesn’t make in island a little messy that’s why it’s not liked on any other island + wublin wubbox’s is 100% worth it
Ethereal island wubbox is utter garbage. Ethereal island is one that could have either been left alone and without a wubbox OR had more time put into the creation of the wubbox for the island, as it is so out of place with the song.
@@F1ddleMars I do really like the Wublin island wubbox, with how techno... chaotic the song is the wubbox really fits into such a song.
Mate Uve got it the wrong way round
'The Goat Guy'
'The Spider Guy'
'These Two Midgets'
'The wum Guy'
The genuine joy and happiness he has in his explanation of why seasonal shanty is S tier makes me feel great
Sorry but it’s below F tier it’s so bad and incoherent it’s just random sounds thrown together
@@MelatoninMashups…it’s not. it’s fine.
random sounds thrown together is cave island, and it still sounds half-decent.
shanty has great sounds and alright sounds. a random sound would be gobbleygourd anywhere else except for shanty. monculus is absolutely amazing, same with schmoochle.
castle bass is great too.
how does anyone say that this island is dogshit?
@@cheesepufss to me it’s just not cohesive - as someone who makes music it sounds like something I made when I was starting off on garageband 😭
@@MelatoninMashups ffydill's verse and punkleton's verse are actually well composed tho
@@joaovictornogueira323 yeah some parts are good but overall I just don’t think any of the sounds are made to go with each other
Seeing people hating denchuhs really hurts me being the first monster I every saw and got me into the game being hated just hurts me there still my fav
in my opinion earth island is not cringe I do not see how do the earthquake is cringe and also shugabush is a decent song and lastly cave island was meant to be a rock song
If you think that the werdos in earth island sound good wtf are you listening to
It’s ur opinion tho so u go u
Earth is kinda overrated for me idk
Shugabush is decent
@@snoweex earth is overrated af, some songs are just better and people are like dream stans trying to prove your opinion is invalid
Pretty good ranking!
Cave and earth are 2 of the best Islands in the game man
Man this video was great, I Especially like your voice. You deserve more subscribers.
So im the only person who likes the pink midgets on bone island? Cool.
No?
Yes?
"Um, actually, they're called Denchuhs." 🤓☝
@@worst_channel_ever 💀
When I see him put cave island on f and say its way worse than shugabush my face went like:
👁👄👁
I wanna see what the list would look like without the wubboxes and werdos
Seasonal shanty had the best rating I've seen. I've seen too many people put it all the way at the bottom when in my opinion its tied best with cold island
bro doesn’t realise monsters aren’t meant to look good 💀
My s-rank list is: cold island, earth island, bone island, magical sanctum, wublin island, tribal island, and star henge.
This is my s-rank, now I’m going to bed as it is 4:47 AM in my time as I’m writing this lol, good night everyone
Ain't no way he put cave island in front tier 💀
Gobbleygourd basically on both islands (not talking about seasonal shanty)
“Ah yes, this song is really good, I like I-“
GOBBLEY GOBBLEY GOO GAH6WNYEGAGEYW6YA6W5567W
“….shit.”
strombonin, epic wubb and deedge carry cold island tbh.
nOgGiN cArRiEs CoLd IsLaNd
@@ChrysanthemumQwertytrue dat
Quibble is also very based
Ain’t no way this man hating on the Turkey
My respect for you putting cold island A tier: ⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️
Respect. 👌
How does this guy only have 96 subs (now 97 Becouse I subbed) he deserves a lot more
Me: Shugabush island can’t be that bad
Also me: it should be on R tier. It means remove from game.
That island is under rated the songs decent they collab with a small singer shugabush is a pretty interesting island.
Idk what you talking about, shugabush is fire
When he put earth island in D list.... Made me hurt
Such disrespect to shugabush man 😢
earth island is so good with the wubboxs and the lyrics for earth island just hit
I personaly think that earth should be higher
Yes
Him : Earth island is very cringe
The Whole Community : That's a joke.. right..?
You do know there's a volume slider for all monsters?
You massacred my boi. (Shugarbush)😢 No hate tho, good video!
And also, how do you the new season? Worm granny with books!
Oh i love the new monster they added for seasonal shanty! It really adds so much to the song
@@YungMarinara you literally ignored his question
Bro did Tiawa so dirty 💀💀😭
Bro earth island in d tier is a crime bruh. and snugabush in f tier physically hurts me like we about problems bro😭
Shugabush and earth are so goated
Cave F and gold island S?
Please never rate anything again
I feel like I’m the only one who agrees that Earth is mid, I think it relies on Plant’s motif too much
Wublin is a banger
*where was the earth and water epic wubboxes? i wanted to hear the earthquake bop*
Bro there are so many L takes in this video that it’s actually making me mad I’m getting mad over a fucking my singing monsters video
Earth island: gets a D tier
Epic wubbox: Dang bro I could’ve saved the island ranking *IF HE GOT ME* -
For water and earth, if you kill the dipsters and Werdos and add the epic wubboxes their a LOT better, in my opinion S and B tier.
my list:
S: Water Island, Wublin Island
A: Ice Island, Earth Island, Bone Island, Mythical Isand, Seasonal Shanty, Tribal Island
B: Plant Island, Air Island, Light Island, Psychic Island, Magical Sanctum
C: Faerie Island, Ethereal Island, Celestial Island, Gold Island
D: Fire Haven, Fire Oasis.. (omg these are absolute garbage)
F: Shugabush Island🤮
If you don't agree with water and wublin.. you simply don't deserve an opinion.. they are obvi the best like bffr
fr wake up the wublins
Red flags all over the place
I’m concerned about your ears’s health for putting ethereal and gold island in C tier and Shugabush in F tier
@@candylandish Wublin, bone, earth????
@@joaovictornogueira323 cool mid and mid
How do you only have 500 subs youre so funny XD
Seasonal shanty is my #1 favourite song i love that island the amazing event mix is perfect and there’s no way I’m gonna hate it even with Wubboxes i would still love it it’s just a dream come true
I once dreamed i played my singing monsters as usual and there was a seasonal island in the game And a few months later they added seasonal shanty i was so happy when it was added
I would instantly putt it in S Tear
The audacity of this guy for putting shugabush island in F teir
I love how everyone is hating on this man because he is having an opinion???? Dude, you can have your own my guy, just let him have his.
Fun fact, if you don’t like the sound of A SINGLE MONSTERS, you just put its volume down! 😮🤯🙄
Tbh I only disagree with the shuggabush island ranking, shit goes hard fr fr. Ethereal Island I completely agree with, I think it is the best island in the game but THAT WUBBOX MAN it ruins the whole vibe of the song.
You are going to hear from my lawyers for that shugabush disrespect
Bro Thinks That Light Is Better Than Psychic💀
I love shugabush island top 5
Ain’t no way ShugaBush island in E
“Every monster sounds perfectly fine in Seasonal Shanty”
Spurrit: Am I a joke to you?
Bro don't diss the huzzah 😤
Yall didn't really put Air in C tier? The final medley bit is honestly really smoothing, and the contribution of Maw, Riff, Trox, Yawstrich, the Pom Poms (and Hoola) and the werdos all mix really well together
we have almost the same opinions . this is so epic
i agree with u on tribal, idk why people don't like it it's honestly pretty fire
Him: I can’t hear drumpler
Pummel:am i a joke to you?
I love the werdo’s lyrics on earth and the song itself
thats crazy, earth island is amazint