Comparing CFG STE35SR, KU45, and NT45 Chinese mini excavators

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 гру 2023

КОМЕНТАРІ • 60

  • @nickruzicka2356
    @nickruzicka2356 7 місяців тому +2

    Great video, it is nice to see you do a side to side comparison on your opinion of the quality and positives and negatives on these machines. I'd really like to see you do a routine maintenance video of your STE35! Keep up the good work. Thanks again, Nick.

  • @sonnykwan6845
    @sonnykwan6845 4 місяці тому +1

    Thanks for making this Video, You are probably the only one who has done one in the two years I've seen these pop up in the Auction sites. Hate that the Auction doesn't give more info on them, or maybe they rather give less so buyers can't complain once its out the door. Seattle/Tacoma, WA

    • @SmartestDumbGuy
      @SmartestDumbGuy 2 місяці тому

      They are an auction house. Not a dealer. They don't know anything about these machines. They are just the place sellers come to sell them.

  • @450rhino1
    @450rhino1 10 днів тому

    Great to see the drive motors covered, similar to Kubota.

  • @claytonnicholson4639
    @claytonnicholson4639 Місяць тому

    New Sub, first video. I quite like your style on this one! Nothing too fancy or Hollywood like, just straight forward info, as you do your walk around and explain what you're seeing. Zero bullshit --PERFECT!

  • @homeplaceadventures
    @homeplaceadventures 6 місяців тому +4

    I looked the NT45 and the CFG (yellow one in your video) the other day at auction. I agree that the CFG is way nicer fit and finish than the AGT. Biggest concern I had with the CFG is the computer screen. If it goes out or you have computer issues I'd be concerned there would be zero support to resolve it from the manufacturer. I liked the simplicity of the AGT just from a lack of warranty perspective. Good video!

  • @hhunt2527
    @hhunt2527 6 місяців тому +2

    Appreciate this video, I was torn between the KU-45 & STE35SR. Given the extra weight of the KU-45 I was leaning towards it however I could not get past it not having a hydraulic thumb and from the looks of it I do not know how you would add one w/o some cutting and welding involved. Appreciate you pointing out the other details as well like the A/C unit and build quality of the 2 units.

    • @restoration-projects
      @restoration-projects  6 місяців тому

      Thank you, there's a lot to consider when buying one of these

  • @TimShieldsPhotography
    @TimShieldsPhotography Місяць тому +1

    How do you turn on the heat in the CFG KU45? The rotating knob only appears to operate the A/C.

  • @Anon-qj5sd
    @Anon-qj5sd 7 місяців тому +5

    The KU-45 swing boom operates by pressing the button down on the left joystick

    • @Anon-qj5sd
      @Anon-qj5sd 7 місяців тому +1

      Also, the green button and red button in the cab operate the front lights.

    • @restoration-projects
      @restoration-projects  6 місяців тому

      Thank you! the manual had it only on the floor. Next time I see one I will try that.

  • @gregs.2821
    @gregs.2821 5 місяців тому

    I'm so close to picking this one (ste35]. Very helpful. Show it in action next ?
    The fitment says soo much. The blue one makes the STE look like a Mercedes.

  • @DougsMessyGarage
    @DougsMessyGarage 14 днів тому

    Keep in mind that these machines are in metric. A 2800kg machine is 2.8 tonnes. That may be indeed 3 tons (6000lbs) but they are rated in metric. Realistically, it doesn't really matter as they would all be considered to be in the 3 tonne class.
    Thanks for review/comparison. The mystery green button in the orange/red one is for the lights on the front of the cab (from another use/review video).

  • @t.p.9232
    @t.p.9232 7 місяців тому +2

    Nice video. At one point I considered each of these models and ultimately went with Jiahe JH35. Rated 3.5 ton machine, weighs in at almost 4000kg. So much better with Kubota D1703 and since I ordered it from China direct, got to spec it to my use.

    • @hhunt2527
      @hhunt2527 6 місяців тому

      I suppose most people don't want to deal with all the importing hassle and uncertainty of the buying process etc. At least that's what steers me away from buying a machine direct.

    • @restoration-projects
      @restoration-projects  6 місяців тому

      I want to try specing out a machine, but the import process is intimidating. It is so easy to buy machines that are already here at auctions

    • @davidrussell8795
      @davidrussell8795 5 місяців тому

      @@hhunt2527 that's kind of dum thinking! Why not go directly to the farmer for fresh chicken ,rather then pay the butcher his upcharges!
      Never be afraid of dealing directly with a wholesaler,or retailer, they don't bite,and you just might get a better deal from tge wholesalers!

    • @jeffharrison7003
      @jeffharrison7003 3 місяці тому

      They lie about weights

  • @jw4227
    @jw4227 2 місяці тому +1

    To use the swing boom there should be a button on top of the left joystick, press and hold it while moving the joystick left and right. Took me forever to figure it out on mine. I really don’t like the design of it

  • @dandoe7260
    @dandoe7260 2 місяці тому

    Thank you for making this video, very informative. How can you tell which one is the better brand, does it say it on the info plate ?

  • @PaulM708
    @PaulM708 23 дні тому

    Does that yellow one have an AC option? Does it have cooling fans for the engine?

  • @100-AcreWoods
    @100-AcreWoods 4 місяці тому

    Helpful, thank you

  • @styledliving
    @styledliving 6 місяців тому +2

    what kind of auctions can i find these at and what price do they normally go for? I'm thinking about getting one to do some projects around the property.

    • @restoration-projects
      @restoration-projects  6 місяців тому +1

      If you google heavy equipment auction in your area, they should have a catalog of equipment for their upcoming auction. Pirce depends on where your located and the local market. Prices are all over the place

  • @pete90603
    @pete90603 5 місяців тому

    I own the ste 35sr , great machine no problems at all. That being said that the machine is good, I can’t find maintenance filters anywhere. I contacted AGT through e-mails and they say out of stock on all filters yet they still are selling them brand new on there website. You can’t maintain the machine. Does anyone know where to find the filters?

  • @tangoseal1
    @tangoseal1 2 місяці тому +1

    I could have bought that yellow one a few months back at auction for around 25k. But I passed. Im.gearing up, God Willing, for a Kubota Kx057

  • @davidrussell8795
    @davidrussell8795 5 місяців тому

    You didnt mention the boom is set offside! Which is nice to veiw your work area!😊
    but for the money,u can't beat the prices!

  • @michaelrichards7223
    @michaelrichards7223 6 місяців тому +1

    Thanks for the comparison. I have seen these showing up at auctions and your video shows a lot that you can't see in the photos.
    The poor fit and finish is evident on the red one. The green one looks easier to work on and bigger inside the cabin. Others complain they are hard to get in and out of. Is this an issue, or only for American sized humans?
    I hope you publish more footage when you start using yours.

    • @restoration-projects
      @restoration-projects  6 місяців тому

      The design of the cab makes it hard to get in and out of for most people, I think Americans complain more because we're more likely to be plus sized

  • @JaredBeaucage
    @JaredBeaucage 6 місяців тому +2

    No you dont want the hydraulic hoses running thru the boom like that.. because they will leak and they will rub and you will hVe to change those hoses. If your in tree tops with a mini and bush whacking you clean your work area so that you dont break hoses off them. I run a 330-336 and 349 cats and no matter what some operators find a way to bust them off, or good ones manage to not break anything off.

    • @restoration-projects
      @restoration-projects  6 місяців тому

      I use to work for a machine rental company and broken hydraulic lines were a common issue. Based on that is why I prefer them through the boom. That does make sense about them rubbing and leaking

    • @JaredBeaucage
      @JaredBeaucage 6 місяців тому

      @@restoration-projects i run excavators for a living, and if your careless and not watch for big branches and buildings, sharp objects then yea your gonna bust fittings, maybe not bust hoses but bend and break crimp fittings. I am currently on a Rottne F15D Forwarder in the bush logging and I can keep it off the big branches, a mini that size I couldn't see a issue of busting hoses inless its just careless. Same goes for counterweights on the 313, 323, 330 Nex Gen cats, and a cat 336E, ppl scratch them, but I manage to not scratch them being abit more cautious

  • @davidrussell8795
    @davidrussell8795 5 місяців тому +1

    To add to my comments;I've been looking at these for about 2 yrs,for the either .8 ton or 1 ton first you should notice,is 90% of the smaller diggers have a very short and narrow track, which means it's only good on flat ground, not on a mining claim...maybe,and the stability is bad,another utuber had his flip over!
    #2 is the speed,but let me stop there,the web pages of these Chinese mini excavators used to have more detail, including the speed of these,engine type, hydraulic pump make,and other data.
    The speed of some is at or about 2 kilometres, which is about 1.2 mph,and babies crawl faster!
    I said to High Top,( High top brokers these under differen labels)that,and they said that if I buy the dual pump hydraulic system,it goes faster, do they did "race two ,1 only supposedly had just a single pump,the other a deal pump,which is supposed to make it go faster,neither go very fast in the race demo!
    Decals,all in Chinese! Why,if you sell to an English speaking country, put it in English! Or whatever is the current language.
    The digging depth ,look at how short the forearm is,this is good for trenching to about 5 feet or so,but not deeper!
    I noticed a lot copy each other ! Cab size,made for Chinese size man,not us!
    I could go on,but one Chinese sales person said ,if you want a better machine, go to 2 tons or higher!
    I forgot to mention some have retractable tracks,nice option.
    The engines on the smaller one are a single piston job,but choices are available .😅

  • @stephenfourman5173
    @stephenfourman5173 6 місяців тому +1

    Will you be there next Thursday? I am thankful for your video because I am not able to preview and want to buy a couple of these. I know now which ones I will be bidding on!

    • @restoration-projects
      @restoration-projects  6 місяців тому

      I didnt make it. were you able to buy the one you wanted?

    • @stephenfourman5173
      @stephenfourman5173 5 місяців тому

      I wasn’t able to secure one, I was shy the dollars. Saving up hoping for next auction

  • @privateprivate5928
    @privateprivate5928 10 днів тому

    How come noention that tracks dont stay on the nt45?

  • @anonanon7278
    @anonanon7278 3 місяці тому

    @Restoration Projects
    A metric tonne is 1000 kgs (2200 lbs), whereas a ton is 2000 lbs.

  • @jcamp24661
    @jcamp24661 6 місяців тому +1

    You have to hold the button down on the left joystick while you turn to the left or right and it will control your boom while you hit that pedal

    • @restoration-projects
      @restoration-projects  6 місяців тому

      I will try that next time I see one of these. I pulled out the manual and all it showed was a peddle for that control

    • @restoration-projects
      @restoration-projects  6 місяців тому

      I will try that next time I see one, the manual only had the extra peddle

  • @MonroeTractorGuy.16
    @MonroeTractorGuy.16 Місяць тому

    The Yellow looks alot like a Hitachi machine.
    2.5T? Maybe metric tons?

  • @herndondumptrucking
    @herndondumptrucking 5 місяців тому

    Are you happy with your machine

  • @superdrew99
    @superdrew99 5 місяців тому

    Swing the boom with the button on the left stick.

  • @herndondumptrucking
    @herndondumptrucking 5 місяців тому

    How could you fix the thumb problem

    • @restoration-projects
      @restoration-projects  5 місяців тому

      Cutting and welding the hydraulic ram mounts further up the boom. or changing where the cylinder mounts to the thumb

  • @JustinHolloway307
    @JustinHolloway307 2 місяці тому

    I like bare bones I have late model hitachi great machine but I hate electronics so the less of those the better

  • @SteveLouzon
    @SteveLouzon Місяць тому

    It's a bad sign when they can't even be bothered to put the tag on straight!

  • @tangoseal1
    @tangoseal1 2 місяці тому

    Dude, excavators globally even the US are measured in metric tons based on kg not imperial.

  • @pueowright7467
    @pueowright7467 Місяць тому

    Buy a cat don’t waste your money on throw away equipment.Parts and service availability is a major factor with equipment longevity

  • @JaredBeaucage
    @JaredBeaucage 6 місяців тому +4

    Those Chinese Excavstors are not the thing to buy if you are looking for a "great fit and finish"... your getting what you pay for, a cheap and easy way into the excavation industry. If you go and buy a Chineze Side By Side compared to a Polaris, same thing, you wont get the same customer service and also the support, parts and stuff like that. Your acting like your buying a Cat 301 or 303... but with a Chinese market budget.

    • @JaredBeaucage
      @JaredBeaucage 6 місяців тому +3

      Also be careful with thumbs, you may not know but these little machines dont come with Relief valve pressure set for the thumb.. so you go and pick up a rock and you try to curl at the same time you will bend the cylinder, because the bucket pressure is supposed to be greater then the thumb cylinder.. so you want to never curl at the same time your picking something up. You can get someone to set that, so the thumb goes back into place and fluid goes back to the tank as you curl the bucket. Or take your chances of bending the rod and trying to do it with your thumb/foot, opening the thumb as you curl the bucket.

    • @restoration-projects
      @restoration-projects  6 місяців тому

      That's a great point, I never considered that. Thanks for the tip

  • @user-vq6rx5jo8c
    @user-vq6rx5jo8c Місяць тому +1

    Stop putting down machines just because you don't know . Kubota was the same way . Now one of the biggest brands . You talk like you are upset that you can't get the machine you want .