There is no soul to this song anymore when these three ladies sing it. When it was Mutya, Keisha and Heidi, I couldn't stop listening to this song because it was soooo beautiful. R.I.P. Sugababes
Jade is definitely a very good singer. But the Sugababes were always known for unique voices and harmony. Jade always powers through songs and her voice, while powerful, is very generic. Amelle was a good replacement for Mutya because their voices are somewhat similar but Keishas voice is so unique that no one can replace her. Without her, the Sugababes lost their recognition value
Amels voice is nothing like mutya Buena it's an insult to say it is amels voice is dreadful live and so is Heidi's truly awfull.mutya would not sing such crap notes neither would Siobhan..This sounds absolutely terrible
Jade couldn't do the low notes on these because she started out too low! I love her, but if she's going to do Keisha's parts, she'll have to sing a bit higher.
She’s not really fit for singing in the low register of Sugababes she’s more Soprano range in her voice. She stands out for all the wrong reasons in Sugababes and I love Jade and her voice. But just not in Sugababes where most of their songs are in the lower key to Jade’s voice which sucks and makes me feel bad for Jade as she and the rest of the girls are great singers
This is almsot like a tribute cover as 2 of them did not sing this song, and people singing the songs and giving the performance makes a big impact on the chart performance, the song was a hit from the voices that orignaly sang it so its so annoying watching them sing it and calling themselfs the sugababes!!!!!
The whole album launch party should be wiped from existence is does nothing for them it shows off the fact that these songs were written by other people for other peoples voices this is almost karaoke
Heidi shouldn't have been part of this sinking ship...should have gone right after Keisha was put out. It was painful to listen to this song, there is no harmony.
@spineczka this is my favourite sugababes song ever, but these just cant sing it. amelle and jade cant do low notes like kiesha and mutya did on this song, they ruined it, the only thing i did kinda like was how they changed it up. but 3.0 is dead :(
The phoney Sugababes, lol, but tbh I feel sorry for Heidi as she was a part of the Sugababes for ages. And I'm not that mad at Amelle, a good replacement for Mutya.
The most successful line-up was the second. After Mutya had left the group's relevance and success started to go down hill. A huge hit and then....down towards the abyss. That was a clear sign of the irreplaceable status of Mutya. Plus, the only thing that MUTYA and _amelle_ had in commom was a sort of a huskiness to their tones and nothing more. Mutya's voice is light years above, beyond better.
Mutya and Keisha are essential to the sound of the Sugababes. I like Amelle's voice, she could easily replace Heidi as long as Mutya and Keisha are there. Now, Jade just doesn't have anything interesting to her voice and if you add that to Heidi with a very generic pop voice also you are only left with Amelle bringing some vocal character but she just doesn't pull enough weight to carry the other two... Anyway, without Mutya and Keisha it just doesn't sound like the Sugababes but just like a generic Sugababes cover band.
Why does everyone feel sorry for Heidi she shit on Keisha kicked her out with no loyalty at all. Big mistake because now look what happened but I’m glad nobody can tough MKS vocally
Compared to the original line ups up to date version...... this is pitiful!!!!!......, mutya slays Amelie.....Keisha annihilates jade.......and siobhan gives life to Heidi's parts!!!!!!
amele and jade have no power in a low tune... they just good in a high tune... maybe they need to learn how to sing in a low tune but powerfull with keisha and mutia... LOL...
@SilviaLace : well i know that her voice is better than keisha, but keisha has a unique voice and have a character... so if people just hear her voice, they already know that is keisha even they don't see her...
I don't agree: she has a good voice and her belting sounds good. The thing is that she can't hit Keisha's low registers which is why on her solo part between 1.29-1.31 you could barely hear her. In songs like Freak Like Me (The Sun's Biz Session), Girls and Even About A Girl her voice register is really good.
Thomas Lanfranchi the thing that made keisha and mutya stand out is how unique there voices are. Jade is just another singer that has a good voice but nothig special.
This isn't the vibe that the song should give. They clearly need to stick to the music written for their voices, but yet even then Amelle messes up. The girl is the least vocally talented from all the members ever, In my opinion =)
you know, i wanted to hate them, but i did actually kind of like the new line up, but the album and live performances just have jade screaching through them, with no soul or emotion in her voice, even jade and amelle aint performing to their best anymore. i like the wasy theychanged this song up, but again screaching ruined it, maybe they should stick to performing and ruining the newer songs. they've failed.
i agree with you, I loved her tone when i was first introduced with her, but technically has the worse voice. Although, if she was in another band, she'd probably be as lead or co-lead singer.
Maybe this is not her best performace but back in 2006 she sang this song and she was only one live other 2 were just playback and Amelle definitely nailed it with her style! Not just Mutya worked hard! She wasn't only one! Amelle aslo put her hard work into this band! She moved the band forward! You can tell she sang it worse than Muyta but not that she ruined her work in the band, because after release Change album the band became more successful! Plus she improved Red Dress and Gotta Be You! And I heard Mutya praised Amelle's version of Red Dress! So she didn't ruined the band but she put the band into the higher level!
I hate this version. Once again Jade is screaming her way through the song, and wrecking it. Keisha and Mutya sung it much better, these 3 are awful. Heidi looks about 50 is well.
At the end of the day, i love all versions of this band, and tbh i class heidi as an original, mainly because they didnt see virtually any commercial sucess until she joined, they wouldnt have sold 14 million records without her.
@BritneyDigitalLive Since its my opinion. If I think this is a good version, then I'm going to say it, so how about you respect that. You may not like this lineup, but you, or any other hater for that matter, will never change my mind. To me, it's the strongest lineup so far, doesn't mean it's a complete fan favourite, but Jade is undoubtably stronger than Keisha. Please don't bother commenting back saying she's not, because your opinion is yours, not mine.
this performance is good, but with keisha and the girl bevor it was better,i didn#t know that it gives a new girl for keisha, sadly. the new girl looks beautiful and she can sing good,ja. But keisha is a little better.
@arial8black keisha was on overload and co wrote alot of the songs! before you even go against me go on wikki look up writing credits album sales ect, you might have your views but facts and sales is all any company cares about you dont bring in the sales you go home!
some people cant just get over the fact that keisha has left the sugababes. In my opinion jade is better than keisha. Cant people give her credits as she was the one who actually kept the sugababes together!!!
I admit I was skeptical about Jade at first, but as soon as I heard Crash and Burn I had no doubts. The girl can sing, and probably even better than Keisha!!! To be honest, I still believe that this song belongs to Mutya cause I relate it to her voice, and even though I love Amelle's voice, sometimes I can't help but feel that it just doesn't fit in with the rest. But then, it's always very personal...
Wow the last two minutes gave me shivers! Breathtaking! Way to livin up a kinda borin song! Don't get me wrong I luv this song but they added something that this song always needed live!!! Fantastic!
One thing you can’t do is sing a sugababes song without Keisha Buchanan. This looks and sounds like a high school talent show
sorry, i'm too lost listening to this...😂
One minute of silence for the high notes that we were used to.
No worries man. The real thing is back.
@@munkymoo3006 HAHAHA
@@carlocarnaje6918 Hope yir Sugababes 1/2. 🙂
Nobody can hit those low notes like Mutya!
Yeah I agree but she walked out and didn’t give a fukc. So it’s nice they kept going with more albums
@@BASSER81 she had postpartum depression actually and had to take time out to stop herself going insane
@@RyanXRyan but she released a solo album right away. Even before the sugababes released a new album
@@Philipp19967 nuh uh, she left December 2005 and real girl didn’t come out until mid 2007
@@RyanXRyan and Change came out October 2007.
Sugababes tribute band???
You hit the nail right on the head x
There is no soul to this song anymore when these three ladies sing it. When it was Mutya, Keisha and Heidi, I couldn't stop listening to this song because it was soooo beautiful. R.I.P. Sugababes
2022 and the soul is BACK
mutya is still the best sugababes, her voice is so rich and full of soul
Jade is definitely a very good singer. But the Sugababes were always known for unique voices and harmony. Jade always powers through songs and her voice, while powerful, is very generic. Amelle was a good replacement for Mutya because their voices are somewhat similar but Keishas voice is so unique that no one can replace her. Without her, the Sugababes lost their recognition value
Jades vocal control is second up none. Put some respect on her name;)
YES
Amels voice is nothing like mutya Buena it's an insult to say it is amels voice is dreadful live and so is Heidi's truly awfull.mutya would not sing such crap notes neither would Siobhan..This sounds absolutely terrible
Jade couldn't do the low notes on these because she started out too low! I love her, but if she's going to do Keisha's parts, she'll have to sing a bit higher.
She’s not really fit for singing in the low register of Sugababes she’s more Soprano range in her voice. She stands out for all the wrong reasons in Sugababes and I love Jade and her voice. But just not in Sugababes where most of their songs are in the lower key to Jade’s voice which sucks and makes me feel bad for Jade as she and the rest of the girls are great singers
Can’t beat the original.
SUGABABES tribute band at butlins
Lol!
Sugababes tribute band i see
haaahaaaaa @wan done wit u hhhaaaaaaaaa
Hahahhahah
Love this version
Just here to ruin my ears. So glad the OGs are back!
They've lost every ounce of soul that they once had in the first and second line-ups. I cannot deal with this version...
don't worry, the originals are back now and they SMASH this live
KEISHA AND MUTYA
BEST
This is like a tribute band
The should have quit when there were no original members left. No matter how talented they are.
horrible, just horrible. mutya and keisha are way better.
This is almsot like a tribute cover as 2 of them did not sing this song, and people singing the songs and giving the performance makes a big impact on the chart performance, the song was a hit from the voices that orignaly sang it so its so annoying watching them sing it and calling themselfs the sugababes!!!!!
The whole album launch party should be wiped from existence is does nothing for them it shows off the fact that these songs were written by other people for other peoples voices this is almost karaoke
Amelle just struggles so much...
Lol they really tried to do this without the OG’s 😂
They are the last member of sugababes. heidi, amelle, and jade (in order from left)
Oh dear .....these randoms need to leave it to the Sugababes aka mks
Now they did! We have the originals back!!!!
i wil mutya and keisha back !!
that's just wrong!
this song kinda belongs to mutya and keisha not the new ones...
They are amazing, but I think that Jade is a bit too much of a singer for Sugababes... but they soung great
Heidi shouldn't have been part of this sinking ship...should have gone right after Keisha was put out. It was painful to listen to this song, there is no harmony.
It was Heidi who decided to follow Amelle management followed them both
This is like watching a funeral…horrible vocals and glad they are gone. Love the original line up…
Heidi is off ... Amelle doing good mind .. you miss Keisha
This was painful to watch! Terrible singing! They should be prosecuted for ruining such a good song!
Agreed lmao
@spineczka this is my favourite sugababes song ever, but these just cant sing it. amelle and jade cant do low notes like kiesha and mutya did on this song, they ruined it, the only thing i did kinda like was how they changed it up. but 3.0 is dead :(
This song is dead without mutya
sadly not a very good performance
Only Heidi is good in this video , the other 2 are so bad in the song
They just shouldn’t have bothered to sing this at the Sweet 7 launch it didn’t make sense. Should have focused on the new stuff
One of the greatest songs ever...being completely butchered. They shouldn't have touched this song.
not even close
The phoney Sugababes, lol, but tbh I feel sorry for Heidi as she was a part of the Sugababes for ages. And I'm not that mad at Amelle, a good replacement for Mutya.
“a good replacement for Mutya” I have to laugh.
@@iampause Mutya was just untouchable. But they needed someone with a similiar timbre and melodic middle register voice and Amelle was that.
The most successful line-up was the second. After Mutya had left the group's relevance and success started to go down hill. A huge hit and then....down towards the abyss. That was a clear sign of the irreplaceable status of Mutya. Plus, the only thing that MUTYA and _amelle_ had in commom was a sort of a huskiness to their tones and nothing more. Mutya's voice is light years above, beyond better.
Mutya and Keisha are essential to the sound of the Sugababes. I like Amelle's voice, she could easily replace Heidi as long as Mutya and Keisha are there. Now, Jade just doesn't have anything interesting to her voice and if you add that to Heidi with a very generic pop voice also you are only left with Amelle bringing some vocal character but she just doesn't pull enough weight to carry the other two... Anyway, without Mutya and Keisha it just doesn't sound like the Sugababes but just like a generic Sugababes cover band.
Why does everyone feel sorry for Heidi she shit on Keisha kicked her out with no loyalty at all. Big mistake because now look what happened but I’m glad nobody can tough MKS vocally
RIP sugababes.. Im so sad.. This is the end..
it sound horible
it just doesn't sound right...sorry but this song is 2.0 all over, just amazing, no other line up can compare!
Love this version too.. love jades adlibs
What an absolute mess.
Terrible. Bring back keisha Mutya and Siobhan
Compared to the original line ups up to date version...... this is pitiful!!!!!......, mutya slays Amelie.....Keisha annihilates jade.......and siobhan gives life to Heidi's parts!!!!!!
Heidi is way better!
Diana Duff not to day
tomerkei not ever!!!!
Siobhan’s voice is great but watching her perform is like watching paint dry. She has NONE of the stage presence that Heidi has.
Siobhan easily sings Heidi under the table on everything every single time.
amele and jade have no power in a low tune... they just good in a high tune... maybe they need to learn how to sing in a low tune but powerfull with keisha and mutia... LOL...
its not bad but the other version with the other two girls is soo much better. I think the 'sugababes' should just give it up now.
Keisha and Heidi and amelle
Oh no... It's just so bad... Jade really sucks here.They should cover songs like Red Dress and not the ones with soul!
sugababes are so amazing
@SilviaLace : well i know that her voice is better than keisha, but keisha has a unique voice and have a character... so if people just hear her voice, they already know that is keisha even they don't see her...
hmm... they shouldn't do the previous babes' songs. just not right...
maybe they should change their group name too...
@foreverlove006 and you weren't saying things like that when keisha and 2 replacements were singing overload and other stuff
Jade's awesome. but not this song.
Just support them all!
Let us all be happy for Keisha and Jade!
Its windows X now
❤️❤️to lost in you
amelle socks in the mutya lines
Truly awful to listen to this , jade and other new one in the middle can’t sing , Heidi was the only best singer
😂 Heidi is like the worst vocally out of all 73 members.
@@iKETOURAGE “73” I’m dead loooool😂😂
The problem with Jade is that her voice is generic.
I don't agree: she has a good voice and her belting sounds good. The thing is that she can't hit Keisha's low registers which is why on her solo part between 1.29-1.31 you could barely hear her. In songs like Freak Like Me (The Sun's Biz Session), Girls and Even About A Girl her voice register is really good.
Thomas Lanfranchi the thing that made keisha and mutya stand out is how unique there voices are. Jade is just another singer that has a good voice but nothig special.
LISTEN TO BOTH VERSIONS AND YOULL GAG
This isn't the vibe that the song should give. They clearly need to stick to the music written for their voices, but yet even then Amelle messes up. The girl is the least vocally talented from all the members ever, In my opinion =)
She's the least talented of any member I agree.
Who're them?
you know, i wanted to hate them, but i did actually kind of like the new line up, but the album and live performances just have jade screaching through them, with no soul or emotion in her voice, even jade and amelle aint performing to their best anymore. i like the wasy theychanged this song up, but again screaching ruined it, maybe they should stick to performing and ruining the newer songs. they've failed.
I got put off sugabaes when amele and jade joined its not the same
Keisha?????????????????????
awful.....im sorry but let's face it they turned the song crappy...they should quit singing the old songs of the sugababes first two line up...
i rather the originals
This song should only be touched by mutya skeisha and Siobhan
This sounds sad
i agree with you, I loved her tone when i was first introduced with her, but technically has the worse voice. Although, if she was in another band, she'd probably be as lead or co-lead singer.
Amelle ruins mutya's hard work.
Maybe this is not her best performace but back in 2006 she sang this song and she was only one live other 2 were just playback and Amelle definitely nailed it with her style! Not just Mutya worked hard! She wasn't only one! Amelle aslo put her hard work into this band! She moved the band forward! You can tell she sang it worse than Muyta but not that she ruined her work in the band, because after release Change album the band became more successful! Plus she improved Red Dress and Gotta Be You! And I heard Mutya praised Amelle's version of Red Dress! So she didn't ruined the band but she put the band into the higher level!
@@music_lover2211 Mutya hated Red Dress herself, but in fairness she praised Amelle on the record saying it sounded better with her on it.
@@Dukkyjames200 Yeah!
Amelle just sucks. She can't sing live. Always so off and pitchy.
I hate this version. Once again Jade is screaming her way through the song, and wrecking it. Keisha and Mutya sung it much better, these 3 are awful. Heidi looks about 50 is well.
At the end of the day, i love all versions of this band, and tbh i class heidi as an original, mainly because they didnt see virtually any commercial sucess until she joined, they wouldnt have sold 14 million records without her.
@SilviaLace true true.
These ad libs and harmonies trying to make it their own make me cringe 😖
@BritneyDigitalLive Since its my opinion. If I think this is a good version, then I'm going to say it, so how about you respect that. You may not like this lineup, but you, or any other hater for that matter, will never change my mind. To me, it's the strongest lineup so far, doesn't mean it's a complete fan favourite, but Jade is undoubtably stronger than Keisha. Please don't bother commenting back saying she's not, because your opinion is yours, not mine.
JADE JADEEE*-*
@SinisterSlave well said
they sing well. period.
dead fish
Love this version. The girls did great here 👏 😍💜❤
Best lineup EVA.
WHERE IS SIOBHAN?
@@BoulevardeTV she left the band because she was getting bullied and hated being in a girlband. She went on to try out a solo career.
What you listening to? Absolutely dreadful.
Heidi is by far the weakest Sugababe there's been over the years.
I fully agree.
Heidi has a great voice.
@@loveandpeace_totheworld no she does not when you look at ALLLLLLLLLLLLL THE COMMENTS LOL
this performance is good, but with keisha and the girl bevor it was better,i didn#t know that it gives a new girl for keisha, sadly. the new girl looks beautiful and she can sing good,ja. But keisha is a little better.
@danieliuli WHY? CAN YOU SING BETTER THAN AMELLE? DUH.
@arial8black keisha was on overload and co wrote alot of the songs! before you even go against me go on wikki look up writing credits album sales ect, you might have your views but facts and sales is all any company cares about you dont bring in the sales you go home!
i hate the new sugababes i want mutya & keisha back
Fail
Ohh jade îs so lovely
I like Amelle but she's just no Mutya.
some people cant just get over the fact that keisha has left the sugababes. In my opinion jade is better than keisha. Cant people give her credits as she was the one who actually kept the sugababes together!!!
Petal Stem how lol, it could have been any other girl tbh.
I admit I was skeptical about Jade at first, but as soon as I heard Crash and Burn I had no doubts. The girl can sing, and probably even better than Keisha!!! To be honest, I still believe that this song belongs to Mutya cause I relate it to her voice, and even though I love Amelle's voice, sometimes I can't help but feel that it just doesn't fit in with the rest. But then, it's always very personal...
Urgh
3:06 very awful
They need to re-record some of the older songs, would love to hear Amelle/Jade on them.
This is dreadful!
Wow the last two minutes gave me shivers! Breathtaking! Way to livin up a kinda borin song! Don't get me wrong I luv this song but they added something that this song always needed live!!! Fantastic!
Gosh this is awful
This isn't even that bad. Some of you are so dramatic lol