Grundig Eton Elite 750 aka Tecsun S-2000 VS Tecsun S-2200x personal observations and differences

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 42

  • @bigmike5678
    @bigmike5678 Місяць тому

    I ordered my 2000x for Christmas. Pretty excited.

  • @audiophileman7047
    @audiophileman7047 5 місяців тому +15

    I really appreciate you getting down to brass tacks on all of the radios you review. The truth is much appreciated. I really like to know what flaws a radio has and the best value for what I want to do with a radio. 👍👍👍

    • @RJDA.Dakota
      @RJDA.Dakota 5 місяців тому +6

      Agreed especially since it’s not like you can just buy it from a store. I like to be educated about the product before I would purchase it.
      Thank you for sharing your research. Your videos are greatly appreciated and helpful.

    • @thomastammaro693
      @thomastammaro693 5 місяців тому +1

      ​@@RJDA.Dakota Agreed. I'm glad to see this rig is living up to the billing.

  • @rkmklz7562
    @rkmklz7562 5 місяців тому +1

    I have been a viewer of the Shortwave Radio channel....👍👍 Two Thumbs up....U are doing a fantastic job.... keep it up

  • @bradmann85
    @bradmann85 3 місяці тому +1

    I have the satellite 750 for over 10 years. It's been a good radio. Yes it has some flaws. I've learned to work around these flaws to a point I no longer notice them. I do like how a ham operator sounds like they are in a studio. Music from am and shortwave have a nice warm tone to the sound. Biggest flaw surfaced a few years later when tuning started jumping around making it a bit hard to tune into the last number. Taking the radio apart to clean the contacts fixed the issue. Still going strong. That new one looks pretty cool.

  • @davidsradioroom9678
    @davidsradioroom9678 5 місяців тому +2

    Waiting to see it in action

  • @Kw1161
    @Kw1161 5 місяців тому +3

    Thanks Gilles for another excellent review!
    73!

  • @rainer4030
    @rainer4030 5 місяців тому +4

    Please compare with 990x

  • @christianwootton100
    @christianwootton100 5 місяців тому +1

    I would like to see a comparison between the new Tecsun 2200 and the Grundig Satellit 800.

  • @ry491
    @ry491 5 місяців тому +3

    I'm sorry if you had unpleasant comments about your reviews of the s2000 . Your job of couse is to delve into any shortcomings and you do that well . While I agree with your findings I would like to give my thoughts on the matter . I bought the a2000 shortly after my wife died to try to find an interest and reignite my interest in swl . It suits me so well . The audio , sensitivity , battery life and ease of use are just what I wanted . I know there are better recievers . If you buy a car , there is always a better one out there but it doesn't prevent you being totally happy with the one you have . I bought a 501 but still prefer the s2000 . The 501 eats batteries and for my use doesn't perform any better . It's really a case of what you want and expect from a radio . I do wish Tecsun would include rds on fm though .
    I guess people get attatched to certain radios and don't like them critisised but that's no excuse for being rude . Have to say I like the idea of the 2200 and I may well be tempted but nothing will make me part with the 2000 . I prefer the black case to the new grey but that's just personal choice . All in all , it's a great hobby for us all to enjoy in our own way . Thanks for all you put into your reviews . I watch them sll with interest . Thomas in the UK .

  • @MDK2_Radio
    @MDK2_Radio 5 місяців тому +5

    Every picture I’ve seen of the 750/S2000 is black. Pretty sure that every single one of them, regardless of branding, were black. It’s smart to go with a different color with an entirely different radio that’s otherwise being packaged identically.

  • @winexprt
    @winexprt 5 місяців тому +4

    Ghost enters the room @4:09.

  • @oyarzun8871
    @oyarzun8871 5 місяців тому +1

    Hi Gilles its was my first choise for entering SW
    But finally i bought a Malahit Dsp Sdr 2

    • @dave10524
      @dave10524 5 місяців тому +1

      While mine is an original Russian DSP2 that I got before the Ukraine conflict , that is my choice for a higher end receiver as well . The superb noise reduction and noise blanker of even the cheaper Malahit clones put them on top for sheer listening pleasure, almost 40 years of static in the hobby and the first time using the NR on a Malahit was a WOW, It really works moment

  • @jesseayala7869
    @jesseayala7869 5 місяців тому

    Thank you for the honest review. Would you please do a comparison on random frequencies sometime? Thanks 😊

  • @KarenLopez-in5ih
    @KarenLopez-in5ih 5 місяців тому +1

    Truth. I saw same issues that you said...

  • @Cryogenic1970
    @Cryogenic1970 5 місяців тому

    Hi Giles
    I am impressed by your videos, your approach and experience.
    And I am very curious if this DSP radio sounds the same as all the other top DSPs (880, 501x, 990x)?
    I mean the difference in sound between DSP and a real superheterodyne on SW.

  • @QmPkM
    @QmPkM 5 місяців тому

    I have the Etón version, I'm also not in the market for another radio. I don't normally comment on your videos but could you check if the MediumWave ferrite antenna cracks and pops as one moves/swivels it around? That was a big problem on my model 750 radio.

    • @QmPkM
      @QmPkM 5 місяців тому

      I have to say the new coloring looks really good compared to the black one, it's not all the same, the case that is. :P

    • @OfficialSWLchannel
      @OfficialSWLchannel  5 місяців тому

      I did notice that it does crackle a little .

  • @W5NWA
    @W5NWA 5 місяців тому +1

    I enjoy your posts to be sure. I have an Eaton Elite 750 (and host of others as I'm sure you do) While I can't post pictures of it or the others here obviously you can see them on QRZ if you are so inclined at W5NWA. No disrespect intended, but I tend to agree with the HAM less harshly of course BUT I have not got the Tecsun (which I am a huge fan of if you look) to compare it with so I will refrain from comment on that score. I would tell you that the Malahit-DSP2 SDR makes both of these look like two tin cans with a string between them however for $400 and change and it's the size of the Qodosen DX-286 only MUCH heavier in a heavy aluminum casing, never mind the ICOM IC-R8600 which is the pinnacle IMHO for SWL.

  • @raymondmartin6737
    @raymondmartin6737 5 місяців тому +1

    Yes, I had the Eton 750 years ago, did
    not like it's performance and sold it. 😊

  • @gerardlemoine6594
    @gerardlemoine6594 3 місяці тому

    Where can I buy one?

  • @ritmo1130
    @ritmo1130 5 місяців тому

    Please if you can give a report about the MW antenna input? Does it overload?

  • @paulnakroshis9732
    @paulnakroshis9732 5 місяців тому

    how does it compare to the pl-990?

    • @OfficialSWLchannel
      @OfficialSWLchannel  5 місяців тому +1

      from my early observations ...unless you want a big radio and add airband... the 990 is fine

  • @jjhays36
    @jjhays36 5 місяців тому +1

    The radio on the left is garbage, went thru 3 of them in 12 years. They all failed after a few years of use. Excited for this new Tecsun

  • @perliss2363
    @perliss2363 5 місяців тому +1

    Interesting how people can be so emotionally tied to their S2000 that they feel hurt by a comparison. My S2000 is anyway inferior to my Icom IC-703. Perhaps an unfair comparison but anyway true. Please also consider to compare the supply current from the batteries in both S2000 and S2200x

  • @SouthernIllinoisShortwave
    @SouthernIllinoisShortwave 5 місяців тому

    I had the Grundig badge version or the 750 back 8 Years or so ago. That radio was not good at all. I sold it less than a year after I got it and I was not disappointed that I sold it. I'm not in the market for any new radios now, because the ones I have are enough. Does it have MW breakthrough? The 750 I used to have was bad at mw breakthrough in the SW bands.
    Just keep up with the straight to the point unbiased reviews. It's better and more trustworthy. I personally will not buy another Tecsun. Not because of the radio, but because of an experience I had when I contacted them not long ago on a matter I was inquiring about. The person that got back to me was pretty hateful and rude. So that's just me.

  • @dayleedwards3521
    @dayleedwards3521 5 місяців тому +2

    CB radios are not the best way to evaluate any receiver, they purposely overmodulate to "increase" power, and overdrive the output with amplifiers. Any "distortion" is likely at that end.
    To do any real testing, you need the correct test equipment, and the knowledge to use it..... otherwise there are just too many variables to make any sensible judgment.

    • @OfficialSWLchannel
      @OfficialSWLchannel  5 місяців тому +7

      980 SSB would do the job... it is mostly to see if there is some SSB distortion

  • @peter.marshall
    @peter.marshall 5 місяців тому

    All previous incarnations of the Tecsun 2000 were black.

  • @ronaldzuccala-pv8tu
    @ronaldzuccala-pv8tu 5 місяців тому

    The eton is the same. I own 130 receivers .and the bandwidth is very very wide which makes the receiver of very little use. SORRY thats just the way it is. WA3090SWL.

  • @Wally46
    @Wally46 5 місяців тому

    I have the original and the main speaker stopped working after a week. Piece of crap.

  • @davidcmather
    @davidcmather 5 місяців тому +1

    I know it's not relevant , but I don't like the colour of the new Tecsun.

  • @gloomyvale3671
    @gloomyvale3671 5 місяців тому

    I can’t stand so called reviews like this, right off the bat negative and more negative, one thing you learn with radios is It depends on so many variables, weather, setup, location, Ariels, ect ect ect, this is just such a negative and poor review makes me sad that people will be influenced by you in choosing radios wether it be Tecsun, sangean ect. Just poor.

    • @OfficialSWLchannel
      @OfficialSWLchannel  5 місяців тому +1

      Yeah there is nothing weather or propagation in this ... a bad radio is a bad radio..but you must be offended as you got it. wake up and choose another channel if honest reviews make you sick