[UPDATED] F-16 VS PROP PLANES OF ALL TIME PERIODS - How Many Needed To Win? - WAR THUNDER

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 239

  • @thepowercreep
    @thepowercreep Рік тому +163

    IR missiles are calibrated to aim just ahead of the hottest heat signatures, which, on jets, is the cockpit. But Prop planes heat is ahead of the cockpit in most instances, so the missiles tend to track ahead of that, which is open sky.
    Lower heat signatures also play a factor.

    • @ThunderWithMuffin
      @ThunderWithMuffin  Рік тому +17

      Oh interesting and thanks for your comment

    • @ricoh9558
      @ricoh9558 Місяць тому +1

      @@SuphaGarb 🤦‍♂️

    • @antiquatedideas1107
      @antiquatedideas1107 8 днів тому

      @@SuphaGarblmmmfffaaaooooo. Maybe read the comment again bro

  • @boguskowalik7528
    @boguskowalik7528 Рік тому +294

    Would be cool if someone took in an ah1h and troll their missiles with flares

    • @TigerJaeger131
      @TigerJaeger131 Рік тому +49

      There were some A-1Hs, and at least one of them got destroyed by an AIM-7.

    • @vitorpilon2014
      @vitorpilon2014 Рік тому +42

      At 5:05 one propreller used flares

    • @jtl-08
      @jtl-08 Рік тому +2

      there were a lot of them

    • @jtl-08
      @jtl-08 Рік тому

      @@TigerJaeger131 aim-9L

    • @commandergeokam2868
      @commandergeokam2868 Рік тому +2

      @@vitorpilon2014 yeah that was the A1H
      Which can carry both chaff and flares

  • @TigerJaeger131
    @TigerJaeger131 Рік тому +185

    Could it be that the radar missiles couldn't hit a target because the props were quite close together, thus confusing the radar?

    • @aname1612
      @aname1612 Рік тому +32

      Props usually use less metal and more lighter materials like wood which absorbs radarbetter, not all in this but generally also smaller profile as a prop type engine takes up less space than a jet

    • @Official_Breslau_Map
      @Official_Breslau_Map Рік тому +5

      @@aname1612 also because of heat

    • @nukelord3121
      @nukelord3121 Рік тому +5

      That would only be for IR missiles

    • @switchblade3601
      @switchblade3601 Рік тому

      Yeah i think the swarm of planes confused the missile. Like 2 planes close together can confuse them, more planes = more confusion

    • @ariq4209
      @ariq4209 Рік тому

      @@aname1612 all the props in the video are full metal

  • @qtippy1414
    @qtippy1414 Рік тому +154

    How to take down a f-16 with prop plane: step one dive from 2000M above it with fw 190 D-13 step two fire.

    • @kxrsed9812
      @kxrsed9812 Рік тому +10

      How are you gonna get 2000m above it lmao

    • @Aviation.Europe14
      @Aviation.Europe14 Рік тому +1

      Or just shoot it... from anywhere

    • @Aviation.Europe14
      @Aviation.Europe14 Рік тому +2

      I took down 2 f16 in my f4u corsair just from comming behind them

    • @ikyunga
      @ikyunga 11 місяців тому

      @@Aviation.Europe14bad players or bad plane

    • @archimedesfromteamfortress2
      @archimedesfromteamfortress2 4 місяці тому +3

      ​@@ikyungahave you considered the possibility of him just being a good pilot

  • @tizanikandothers
    @tizanikandothers Рік тому +30

    I'm going to be extremely honest: the event was not fun to play but seeing the video made me realize how worth the pain it was

  • @Slungus_bunny69
    @Slungus_bunny69 Рік тому +117

    Fun fact: prop planes carrying rockets can fire their rockets as flares

  • @Tanspotty
    @Tanspotty Рік тому +42

    As a prop plane I'd of took the tactic to instead stick as low as possible cause I've noticed the jets mostly boom and zooming from above. They don't turn well so bringing the playing field to the props having more manoeuvrability at lower altitudes, I'd of stuck low and tried to think of a strategy which gave the props the advantage. Only thing you wouldn't win against is those missiles but guns you could win against

    • @admiralpavelnakhimov8755
      @admiralpavelnakhimov8755 Рік тому +4

      Yeah, low flying works quite well against radar, as well as terrain abuse. Pyrenees for example works great for terrain abuse, since you can get behind the enemy team by flanking around to the side
      That's how I bagged 3 F-5Cs and an F-4C in one go

    • @merafirewing6591
      @merafirewing6591 7 місяців тому

      ​@@admiralpavelnakhimov8755 noice.

    • @semajniomet981
      @semajniomet981 4 місяці тому +1

      I'd think that making the terrain the enemy of the jets would be more efficient as well. It'd probably be more of a deterrent than the machine guns that the turboprops would have. Probably also easier to pull that stunt off in biplanes as well, due to their lower overall speed.
      Just speaking as a layman. I'm not actually a pilot or anything like that.

    • @FLMKane
      @FLMKane 25 днів тому

      That was the historical method for prop planes to defend against jets.
      Dive low and keep turning. There was a method were the whole flight would form a giant carousel in the sky, with all the planes turning in the same direction around the same center. That way, no jet could get on someone's six without putting an enemy prop plane at his own six.

  • @cptfrostbite
    @cptfrostbite Рік тому +10

    8:43 i died here in that spitfire

  • @cheesesniper473
    @cheesesniper473 Рік тому +8

    A weapons specialist said that no version of the sidewinder would have trouble tracking a prop plane, the exhaust throws off more than enough heat.

  • @imaheadout8529
    @imaheadout8529 Рік тому +12

    12:58 YAY i can see myself evading he f-16s bullets!

  • @johammedali419
    @johammedali419 Рік тому +15

    1st match wasn’t even fun to watch.
    You CANNOT tell me that first match was x2 F-16 vs x62 props
    That first match was xInfinity AiM-9L’s + xInfinity AiM-7F’s vs x62 props

  • @SteampunkPaperTown
    @SteampunkPaperTown Рік тому +30

    Yoo Muffin! Thanks for letting me in on this game since the shooting of the video i got my F-16 as well. ~VanishedInDeath (Also sorry i didn't get you my side of the combat the replay was being weird for me) Also yea.. That move i pulled at the 2:30 mark, was not the brightest move but, it worked?

  • @furretthefuzzynoodle3896
    @furretthefuzzynoodle3896 Рік тому +15

    I’m very surprised so few people picked the A-1H since it’s a prop with flares and chaff

  • @Donut833
    @Donut833 Рік тому +48

    Really enjoyed this style of commentary. Your other ones kinda feel over scripted/ robotic. This felt much more natural and flowed quite well.

    • @ThunderWithMuffin
      @ThunderWithMuffin  Рік тому +15

      Thank you! I’ve been working on it

    • @Donut833
      @Donut833 Рік тому +4

      @@ThunderWithMuffin Definitely noticeable my man. Keep it up.

    • @samueljohnson717
      @samueljohnson717 Рік тому

      This is a joke right?

    • @Donut833
      @Donut833 Рік тому +1

      @@samueljohnson717 No.

    • @thetoastmaster180
      @thetoastmaster180 Рік тому

      agreed. didn't feel like a human was talking to me beforehand lol, and the laughs felt extremely forced. glad to see his improvement

  • @benpurcell4935
    @benpurcell4935 Рік тому +1

    If the Grim Reapers dogfight competitions taught me in a one on one in a small space a jet will always lose.

  • @alexshepherd1741
    @alexshepherd1741 Рік тому +5

    A homing missile reacts to heat, so heat traps work against it. The missile is easily aimed at the jet blast of modern fighters, as it is very hot, but the old propeller-driven aircraft did not have a jet blast, but only a warm engine, which is much colder than a jet blast. Therefore, it is much easier for a rocket to target a modern fighter than a World War II aircraft.

  • @GUBBS5
    @GUBBS5 10 місяців тому +1

    I think the reason that some of the missiles could not hit was because most of the missiles are designed to be heat seeking (like the sidewinder)
    So since the tiny engines of the prop planes produce little to no heat the missiles can’t lock on to

  • @BASTION1023
    @BASTION1023 Рік тому +8

    Loved participating aswell as being in the second round! And to anyone interested ill be posting a raw vid from the second round when I get home. Fantastic video as always muffin!

  • @sapphiraollivierre
    @sapphiraollivierre Рік тому +8

    Keep up the good content Muffin!😃

  • @sinisterisrandom8537
    @sinisterisrandom8537 Рік тому +3

    To explain how Fox 2 aka your sidewinder's missiles work. They require a heat signature. The reason why they track jets better is that the heat source is behind the aircraft. While the heat source on propellers is in the front taking almost all of the cool air which helps cool it down after faster speeds.
    If I got anything wrong for those who served or serving in the Air Force correct me on anything.

  • @asiangaming8409
    @asiangaming8409 Рік тому +1

    4:57 yay it’s me

  • @_GODSFIGHTER
    @_GODSFIGHTER Рік тому

    Was a little doubtful the f16s could pull it off because of the f14 video but after a couple minutes i thought yeah they could

  • @redkaven
    @redkaven Рік тому +1

    Pretty sure i searched seal clubbing but I got brought here instead

  • @thetoast3889
    @thetoast3889 Рік тому +10

    it would be much more interesting on a mountainous map where you fly low and have to maneuver a lot

  • @engchoontan8483
    @engchoontan8483 Рік тому +1

    2 versus 1 (20mm only)
    Attack/Defend - Both ways
    2xF16 versus 1xBi-Plane (F16 must Attack and cannot hide)
    2xBi-Planes versus 1xF16 (bi-planes must Attack and cannot hide)
    Defend = cannot leave predefined area, within 18000ft
    Bi-plane rotate-pivot straffling on
    = belly, top-wing-center, bottom-wing-center, right-wings-tips, left-wings-tips, stand-on-tail, ... propeller
    = turning radius (pivot) of 20-meters is big bully

    • @engchoontan8483
      @engchoontan8483 Рік тому

      Imagine a 1km by 1km space for bi-plane within a 100km by 100km space for f16. Watch youtube on bi-plane acrobatics-display. Bi-plane is like a stationary air-turret (seemingly not moving, only twisting and rotating), no matter how you fly the f16, bi-plane, with center propeller and therefore 2x20mm, will always be looking-at you.

    • @engchoontan8483
      @engchoontan8483 Рік тому

      Understand further = camel-pak and cigar due to air-time all-the-time

  • @sackthing986
    @sackthing986 Рік тому

    Now this is what should be on "The Shooting Range"

  • @AvidAirEnthusiast
    @AvidAirEnthusiast Рік тому +1

    Early!!! Another great vid

  • @RN_GLXY
    @RN_GLXY Рік тому

    I remember being this guy like top 500 followers sim like that

  • @alankohn6709
    @alankohn6709 Рік тому +3

    My problem with the first round is unlimited missiles it's nonsense all it shows is missile shoot plane now if they had been limited to there standard set up missiles till they used them and then guns it might of been interesting. The second suffered from the unlimited ammo problem the least interesting one of these I've seen plus I wouldn't of taken bombers the AI gunners are crap and if your gunning your not flying making you a sitting duck

  • @PlaySomeGoodCountry
    @PlaySomeGoodCountry Рік тому +2

    Why do they get infinite missiles though. Kinda lame that they never have to fight the prop planes because they don’t run out of missiles

  • @siroglethorpe311
    @siroglethorpe311 Рік тому +5

    Early let’s go I love these vids

  • @Mrskydoesminecraft1
    @Mrskydoesminecraft1 Рік тому +4

    Honestly I’m surprised none of the props brought along some unguided rockets to spoof the missiles with, Rocket engines actually will spoof IR missiles making them a good flare alternative 😂

    • @MistikCo
      @MistikCo Рік тому

      That’s what I was thinking

  • @neopolitan4121
    @neopolitan4121 Рік тому +16

    I love watching jet fighters spam missiles for 9 minutes!!!
    (They still don't know what to do without them)

    • @CrazyDutchguys
      @CrazyDutchguys Рік тому +5

      >conveniently ignores them winning guns only round

    • @shadowknightgaming1874
      @shadowknightgaming1874 Рік тому +1

      Ya they keep missing because they don't even understand the capabilities of there missiles

  • @manhvo242
    @manhvo242 Рік тому +1

    FINALLY I'VE WAITING SO LONG

  • @iclimbeverything2990
    @iclimbeverything2990 Рік тому +2

    thats crazy of the aspect and G tolerance of those missiles. thought i was watching ace combat

  • @KampfTiger1
    @KampfTiger1 Рік тому +2

    A MiG-29 vs Prop Planes would be cool as a comparison which would do better. I volunteer for the MiG-29 Pilot.

  • @SteampunkPaperTown
    @SteampunkPaperTown 2 місяці тому +1

    Man it’s hard to believe it’s been over a year since I went head on with the jet and survived.. I think soon I need to be on another video.

  • @allenliu8820
    @allenliu8820 Рік тому +1

    well there is a reason y the radar missiles don't work against props
    i have played custom battles where the radar missile will not kill a prop because they are too slow for the radar to detect, they have a low radar cross section, or dumb gaijin code
    i really dont know why they dont lock onto props that well unlike in jets
    the average range where I am able to fire a radar guided missile at a prop is around 5k
    a little over 3 miles
    this could explain why the radar missiles were ineffective

  • @Fish79246
    @Fish79246 Рік тому +4

    The prop plane could’ve gotten rockets and used it as flares since missles lock onto hot engines and rockets have a little thrust on the back it can lock onto it

    • @owensks
      @owensks Рік тому

      Only Ir missiles lock onto heat but in this video they were using semi and active Radar missiles

  • @havehfoxxo
    @havehfoxxo Рік тому

    after 46K+ hours and playing sins 2013 this would be fun sometimes cause i never have any good action then doing the same thing over and over. hit me up of ur doing another one of these this would look like alot of fun

  • @mclovin2408
    @mclovin2408 Рік тому +1

    Lol this reminds me of the time I joined a top tier air battle with a prop plane, there was a modern ship I decided to kamikaze in my little German plane, I actually did some damage before I dived into him.

  • @liamsmith433
    @liamsmith433 Рік тому +3

    I think if the prop planes stayed really low to the ground they’d have had a better chance as all the F-16 pilots where doing too down attacks!?

    • @dustyak79
      @dustyak79 Рік тому +2

      Low and if the coordinated like say 10 planes circling clock wise at 1000 feet 10 counter clock at 2000 and so on

  • @colonel_cookies_
    @colonel_cookies_ Рік тому +1

    Yeah we can see my shiny golden skin 😊

  • @F16IQAF
    @F16IQAF Рік тому +1

    Bro is trying to play ace combat in warthunder

  • @thenathan4490
    @thenathan4490 Рік тому +2

    Salut, Monsieur. I would recommend a fight between lotsa props vs the Mirage F1C (C, CT, C-200). Would be interesting to see one of the hardest jets to fly fight against props. This also would be an interesting challenge as the Mirage F1C isn't known for its agility. It's acceleration is not as good as some other aircrafts and even a Phantom can almost outmanoeuvre it. Would be interesting.

  • @rdmcfoxinator2131
    @rdmcfoxinator2131 Рік тому

    so my theory on the missles not tracking properly is that some of the prop planes have equipped Rockets to create a shot burst of High Heat.
    So far I am yet to be killed by missile in my Sea Vixen because whenever i see that Missile indicator I fire a Much brighter AGM for it to track instead.
    However sometimes the players just switch to guns but i have deterred players from getting me through Energy management and then just peeling off because I wasn’t their first target and therefore wasted their Final missile.

  • @raptorf_2255
    @raptorf_2255 Рік тому

    I think the reason why the missiles couldn't hit any targets could be because the missiles are fired at the point where the prop planes are only 10 few meters away from the f16, as soon as the missile launches with the prop planes being that close the missile will lose it's target

  • @Mika-ph6ku
    @Mika-ph6ku Рік тому +1

    Them props flying like bots

    • @asiangaming8409
      @asiangaming8409 Рік тому

      Try fighting a F-16 going at Mach 1 speed in a slow prop fighter

    • @Mika-ph6ku
      @Mika-ph6ku Рік тому +1

      @@asiangaming8409 Irrelevant; I said they were flying like bots cause many were just going in straight lines and not doing anything to avoid catching rounds from the f-16s when they were making their runs.

  • @thecatbims1795
    @thecatbims1795 Рік тому +1

    I love flying my Kee Bird B-29 but it doesn't hold up against a 20mm

  • @Pilot-delta-victor
    @Pilot-delta-victor Рік тому

    Cinematic masterpiece

  • @pharthasa
    @pharthasa Рік тому +2

    Suprised the A-2 didnt use its flares

  • @mc_jan_tryhard1223
    @mc_jan_tryhard1223 Рік тому

    Another Great Video, keep it up, btw what's the song Name at the start?
    Greatings from Germany

  • @StealthyShot
    @StealthyShot Рік тому +1

    Prop planes should be able to bring rockets as flares

  • @spacekat1543
    @spacekat1543 Рік тому +1

    You should do ww2 spaa vs helicopters

  • @mayalopez7992
    @mayalopez7992 4 місяці тому

    that gold f 16 , just like you said , ITS SICK

  • @c0ldyloxproductions324
    @c0ldyloxproductions324 Рік тому

    Love how the only plane that can defend otay from missiles is the a1h pumping out that chaff and flairs

  • @pdonettes
    @pdonettes Рік тому

    How do you do custom battles like this?

  • @danilopanizza7806
    @danilopanizza7806 Рік тому

    Muffin, i wanna be in your videos, you he the link of your discrod server?

  • @Пельмень-т7н
    @Пельмень-т7н Рік тому +1

    Cool

  • @RubberToeYT
    @RubberToeYT Рік тому

    Great video as always

  • @beachside1
    @beachside1 Рік тому +1

    I just love this channel. How do you become a participant of these challenges?

    • @ThunderWithMuffin
      @ThunderWithMuffin  Рік тому +1

      Thank you. Join my discord to receive the announcements on when I do events

    • @beachside1
      @beachside1 Рік тому +1

      @@ThunderWithMuffin Thanks bro. I will

  • @MrRobschnieder
    @MrRobschnieder Рік тому

    The F-16 has Aim9L's which is significantly better than the F-14s Aim9H's. The L can pull 30gs and is all aspect vs the H only being able to pull 18g and being rear aspect only. So the L has an easier time getting a lock as the engines and exhaust are in the front of the props and being able to pull an extra 12g helps guide it in.

  • @johnsmith6266
    @johnsmith6266 Рік тому +1

    hey thunder! would you be willing to consider making some historical battles like Kursk? Thanks for the content always fun to watch.

  • @choclan3336
    @choclan3336 2 місяці тому

    this is useful incase i ever find myself in this situation

  • @kadenbrown-cobarrubias5510
    @kadenbrown-cobarrubias5510 Рік тому

    theres somthing about firing a AIM at a prop that's just really funny

  • @nicholasavasthi9879
    @nicholasavasthi9879 Місяць тому

    I’m surprised none of the props brought rockets to act as makeshift flares. That’s a pretty common tactic in early missile jets.

  • @declanflynn2580
    @declanflynn2580 Рік тому

    Best thing do do as props in go low to the ground prevent the jets from getting real good angles

  • @sandystockmon8561
    @sandystockmon8561 Рік тому

    the lack of heat thery works well with the early biplanes of ww1 using 40hp engins to at best aprox 200 hp, not nearly as mutch as the multi thousand deggree thrusters and jets and rockets the missiles were buiilt to target

  • @YouveYeedYourLastHaw99
    @YouveYeedYourLastHaw99 11 днів тому

    I just can’t believe someone brought mig-3 of all things

  • @mihaly_wt8367
    @mihaly_wt8367 Рік тому

    Clicked the moment i saw it, banger video

  • @hermandelang
    @hermandelang Рік тому

    What i noticed is that the large bombers like the tu-4 on round 2 were pretty effective against the f-16s

  • @danielleung275
    @danielleung275 Рік тому

    Could you do every prop plane vs all jet planes

    • @danielleung275
      @danielleung275 Рік тому

      I haven’t played in a while but I assume that there’s more prop planes than jet planes

  • @joshuacrayford7462
    @joshuacrayford7462 Місяць тому

    Plus I've seen videos on here where players have fired their rockets to trick a fighter jet missiles

  • @matthiashacker7303
    @matthiashacker7303 Рік тому

    How can I remove the reload time of the missile?

  • @RadiantCataclysm
    @RadiantCataclysm Рік тому

    what is this music? It's freaking epic

  • @op_socks4442
    @op_socks4442 Рік тому

    Suggestion you should do a A-10 vs ww2 tanks

  • @HavocAudio
    @HavocAudio Рік тому

    You should do M3 Bradly VS Marder A1

    • @colonel_cookies_
      @colonel_cookies_ Рік тому +1

      M3 Bradley's are way better than Marder, he should do M3 Bradley's vs BMP's

  • @evandowgielewicz5350
    @evandowgielewicz5350 9 місяців тому

    It’s probably because most jets have afterburners which makes heat for most air battles because they are not ment to go against WW2 planes

  • @henrique2456
    @henrique2456 Рік тому

    This video is like putting a Iowa class battleship vs a sailboat

  • @captainkiwii442
    @captainkiwii442 Рік тому

    im still in the prop planes but after this vid im going to grind like never before

  • @kadenbrown-cobarrubias5510
    @kadenbrown-cobarrubias5510 Рік тому

    this has happened before. theres is video of an f16 shooting down a prop plane in venesalu

  • @ShawnF6FHellcat
    @ShawnF6FHellcat Рік тому

    I was too tired that day, and decided to just wait for the next event to participate in...

  • @JadenDiaz-hz8xz
    @JadenDiaz-hz8xz Рік тому

    I ain't the best but this is my motto. I fight to the last plane to the last man, to the last bullet

  • @Lachlan_adventures-d7s
    @Lachlan_adventures-d7s Рік тому

    Another great video

  • @thecatbims1795
    @thecatbims1795 Рік тому +1

    Any Idea when we are gonna see Helis vs Boats

  • @sawsmsgaming6737
    @sawsmsgaming6737 Рік тому

    You should do 10 new players in f-16s vs 1 pro player in f-16s

  • @sukhoisu-27flankerbdude92
    @sukhoisu-27flankerbdude92 Рік тому

    On custom battles the yak 3(ww2 prop plane)is super good at taking down any jet, the f-4S and the A-4E are easy targets to kill

  • @KingGumps
    @KingGumps Рік тому

    I have an idea for a video, what if you took a bunch of p-36 peashooters and maybe like 3 or 4 b-17s or any suitable bomber and have the massive amounts of peashooters try to shoot the bombers down.

  • @dominicnicolson9865
    @dominicnicolson9865 11 місяців тому

    Funny thing is I play top tier with my fren who bought a premium and since I’m at rank 4 I use prop planes and yes we play arcade but I still find it funny that I kill 6 jets almost every time

  • @Bathotten4390
    @Bathotten4390 Рік тому

    No idea on how, but my friend took me in top tier with the p-51 (20 mm) and i just tanked a r-60

  • @C4T4N4
    @C4T4N4 Рік тому

    And there is 5gen that can go head to head with prop planes in terms of maneuverability at low speeds

  • @Nottrules
    @Nottrules Рік тому

    Soon we’ll get to the point where props where lose that maneuvering advantage scary to think about

  • @Assans202
    @Assans202 Рік тому

    Er du norsk?🇳🇴

  • @mak8464
    @mak8464 Рік тому

    I'm pretty sure growling sidewinder did a thunderbolt vs a warthog and won a couple merges

  • @Tsunami_fuego
    @Tsunami_fuego Рік тому

    Cant wait to see an aim-9x with a 60g overload

  • @antiquatedideas1107
    @antiquatedideas1107 8 днів тому

    The prop players seem to be generally oblivious lol. Are most of them newer to the game? Seems like they aren’t really looking around

  • @lukewhitehouse4103
    @lukewhitehouse4103 Рік тому

    guess you just wait for the F-16 to run out of fuel

  • @mrwatersheep1828
    @mrwatersheep1828 Рік тому

    Me in my fw 190 A1: shit, got uptiered again…

  • @Incah2036
    @Incah2036 Рік тому

    Think it would be more interesting if you didn’t have unlimited fuel enabled… homies would’ve bingo’d out in 3 mins keeping AB in like that lol

  • @bernag1832
    @bernag1832 Рік тому

    The missiles miss because the prop plsnes ars trying their best not to be hit, so they maneuver