Bosch vs Shimano E-bike Motors Comparison

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 35

  • @scottpratico1315
    @scottpratico1315 Рік тому +2

    I like that you mentioned the natural feel of the shimano. What it lacks in top end speed it makes up for in a more subtle matching of pedal inputs.

  • @tomordr
    @tomordr Рік тому +19

    It’s a shame you overdubbed music on the video. A real missed opportunity to talk about sound levels and clunking.

  • @vincentjohnston8789
    @vincentjohnston8789 11 місяців тому

    Gr8 video review! I'm using the Shimano e6100 on the Triumph motorcycle hybrid bike and the cycling feels like a luxurious natural pedal experience. I sure this older motor still has the 3 sensors of torque, wheel speed and cadence

  • @endoalley680
    @endoalley680 Рік тому +1

    Which has greater range?

  • @piotrtt2801
    @piotrtt2801 4 місяці тому

    Bardzo dobry komentarz! Wybrałem SHIMANO EP8. Jego kultura pracy jest wyważona i naturalna. Nie jest zbyt agresywny. Nie biorę udziału w zawodach. Cieszę się jazdą w trudnym terenie. Nie lubię płacić za kolorowe wyświetlacze i aplikacje smatrfon w stylu Bosch. Jeździłem kilkadziesiąt lat na rowerach analogowych bez wyświetlaczy i znam swój organizm . Wystarcza mi na pamiątkę truck z Garmina . A do jazdy potrzebny jest odpowiedni rower z wyposażeniem i kuturą pracy. Gdybym miał więcej pieniędzy zakupiłbym Specialized, bo na takim analogowym jeździłem przez 30 lat. Pozdrawiam wszystkich zwolenników CIĘŻKICH MOTOCYKLI! :)

  • @patrick.991
    @patrick.991 Рік тому +2

    Can you tell which one (Bosch CX Gen4 or Shimano EP800) is quieter in general? It's hard to hear in your video because of the music ...

    • @S14AA
      @S14AA Рік тому

      I'd also like to know the ep801

  • @emtbtrailrider539
    @emtbtrailrider539 2 роки тому +3

    I want u to do the Real test with the new Shimano Pedal Assist Motor the EP801

    • @ebikes_org
      @ebikes_org  2 роки тому

      as soon as i have one i will!

  • @motoresruedas7357
    @motoresruedas7357 Рік тому +2

    Bosch has the advantage that you can open the motor once its out of warranty and service it or overhouling having more life time to enjoy it.

  • @S14AA
    @S14AA Рік тому

    Does the smoother power help maintain traction ?

  • @pitmastertoby2598
    @pitmastertoby2598 Рік тому +1

    good review

  • @zalle1
    @zalle1 Рік тому +1

    Why guetto urban music when you are in nature?

  • @svanhoogstraten
    @svanhoogstraten Рік тому +3

    The Bosch motor has a more powerful assistance than the Shimano motor. Then there is the EMTB mode which decided the assistance based in your input. It’s a 4 th mode than other Motors don’t offer. The bisch motor is a way more solid motor that the Ep8.

    • @atnfn
      @atnfn Рік тому

      From what I've seen in other videos the Bosch motor also is more energy efficient. Mine is still limited to only 75Nm (or whatever) doesn't have the update, I don't think I need any more power anyway. I also figured if it's limited to 75Nm it probably is less wear on the motor so it'll last longer.

    • @shaneward4065
      @shaneward4065 Рік тому +1

      New new ep801 has more torque lower in the cadence and is more efficient than ep800. I've tested both.
      The trail mode on the new ep801 also acts the same as emtb on the bosch 👍

    • @Adam-vm8kp
      @Adam-vm8kp Рік тому

      The Bosch also has an auto mode that can be added through the diagnostic tool. Ep8 and performance cx are both 85nm.

  • @shaneward4065
    @shaneward4065 Рік тому +1

    Can you confirm you were using the new shimano ep801 or ep800

    • @ebikes_org
      @ebikes_org  Рік тому

      Hey Shane! It was the ep800 motor.

    • @shaneward4065
      @shaneward4065 Рік тому +1

      @eBikesorg
      Ok I'm fitting the new ep801 into my santa cruz bullit which will have a 45km cut out. Here in new zealand we are not limited.

  • @WeileWorld
    @WeileWorld Рік тому

    I like to see a 5 Shimano Nexus test

  • @JoJo-me8ih
    @JoJo-me8ih Рік тому

    NO MUSIC

  • @mmna1151
    @mmna1151 10 місяців тому

    Bosch ❤️💪🏾

  • @antoniorodriguez1836
    @antoniorodriguez1836 Рік тому +2

    under 50's Shimano
    Over 50's Bosch
    Years old :P

  • @hotpeac3889
    @hotpeac3889 Рік тому

    Good content 👍👍

  • @concernedcitizen3254
    @concernedcitizen3254 Рік тому +2

    I would avoid Shimano completely, they force you to replace the entire motor instead of a plastic gear worth about 20p. They are already overpriced and then they want the kind of mark up El Chapo would be jealous of to do a basic repair. Shame, they have a good history but this is a huge scam and probably done entirely on purpose. I expect these will be failing in their thousands in a few years after the 2 year warranty, I got one that failed after a few hundred miles!

    • @Adam-vm8kp
      @Adam-vm8kp Рік тому

      If your in your warranty they would just replace then. Never had shimano turn down a genuine warranty. There are places you can buy the spares and fit yourself.

    • @VMaster1997
      @VMaster1997 Рік тому

      I got an shinamo e6100 60NM and i got 8500 km on it no failures at all the problem is that people use a speedchip or something that breaks the gears

  • @iconaan
    @iconaan Рік тому

    Bosch is certainly faster, proven in several tests, but don't get me wrong, shimano is also a great motor.

  • @manuelcastro449
    @manuelcastro449 Рік тому

    WARNING about BOSCH products and R&M Homage dual battery Bicycles and Bosch systems, look this after 5 months of use, first 2months I have to change the motor BOSCH make noise now again I have to change the Motor Bosch again make noise again, loose the eShifth, covers from the BOSCH battery fall down on the street when I ride, also water get inside the BOSCH switch (made in China) BRC351,BIG MISTAKE to pay Cad$17000 for this shi... brand, this people here are pay by R&M to make that kind of comments about the brand me I am a REAL consumer with the REAL problems...They want keep change BOSCH motors
    I ASK FOR MY MONEY BACK and I don’t ask that now after 5 months I asked since my problems start I mean on my first 200 Km of use that bicycle…

    • @GuyBraget
      @GuyBraget 8 місяців тому

      Are you in Beijing?