@@jacobjacob6334 it's not about technicality, it's about voice quality in Playback singing, it should be soothing and young, better for picturization and treat to ears. Technicality comes to work when music director really want to experiment with something so the singer should be able to deliver.
@siddiquiubaid4275 music creator is above play back singing. Your rafi sab ran away while singing tansen and yesudas sung it. There are better singers...
This clip is brilliant THE KING ELVIS singing with RAFI both fantastic singers both from the 60 s who is still listening today in 2024 both legends R.I.P.to both ELVIS and RAFI🇬🇧👍👍👍👍❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Beautiful song from the "king" Elvis. Even if it was copied in Hindi, the magic of Rafi makes it refreshing. One of my favourite songs, I don't know how many times I sang this song to the entertainment of my family and friends.
If a voice has ever reached the point of perfection in terms of melody and sweetness, then it is the voice of Mohammed Rafi. Definitely soul stirring and melody at its peak.
Thats NOT Dear Mohammed Rafi's fault, its the Musician who stole the music, not the singer! So Why drag Rafi's name in the Caption???? EVIL Duffer uploader
Truly, Rafi Sb is incredible, the sweetness,clarity,rendition, range n above all, the versatility with a range of mesmerising tones no one anywhere across the globe has been found to exhibit, and even more incredible is the dimension of his heavenly voice not to thin out in tone or texture when singing the high notes , in fact, the resonance n sweetness would get more mystical, a quality none has surpassed! Hats off to the Shahanshah of playback singing!
Song is copied but the skills of Rafiji is not under question.. Great singers.. Rafi, kishore, mukesh .. etc... Music composers are at fault, not singers.
I love the way that Western music and Indian music blend so effortlessly. I can't be certain that Indian music includes Western influences very often, but when Western music experiments with Indian traditions, and gives it space to breathe, it never fails to add something important; and over a wide variety of styles too...rock, Jazz, Hippie, Country, Blues, HipHop, Jam....well, you get the idea.
Both Elvis and Rafi are legends in their own way. Marguerita was made in 1963. Kaun hai jo song made in 1968. So who copied from whom? It is obvious SJ duo stole the tune from the original English one. Analysing thus will lead only to unnecessary squabbles and verbal altercation in which each side will try to bring down the other singer, causing insults to be heaped on both the singing greats. So just, let us sit back and enjoy the God-given voices of these 2 geniuses.
The range of Rafi was unbelievable and he commanded absolute perfection in all that he undertook. Elvis was a western singer with a emotional voice but limited in range in comparison although he was also a very talented and beautiful singer and a performer with star value. I must both are great in their own ways
I am Guyanese and I grew up on all kind of music..calypso, pop, rock n roll, reggae, hindi, jazz, country, etc. In my humble opinion, Mohammed Rafi had the most beautiful voice ..gift of God as some would say and the most versatile of all singers. he could do pop, the sad songs, the rock n roll and the classical all with ease. No disrespect to any other singer, but its not even close. The mere fact that the majority of Hindus feel the same about a Muslim is all you need to know.
+Mohamed Rahaman The maestro Rafisab was a Muslim, the great Jesudas is a christian and uncomparable Lathaji is an Hindu by birth only. But for them their religion is Music only. So please do not tarnish them with such religious version. Just be proud of being with them on this earth to hear such God's own voice.!!
Mohamed Rahaman Totally disagree. Rafi is nothing in front of Freddie Mercury Elvis Presley Michael Jackson Frank Sinatra Axl Rose John Lennon Paul McCartney Bob Dylan Prince Nelson Billie Joel Bob Marley Jimmy Hendrix.
Shivam Kumar then you don't know who Mohammad rafi is. Listen to all his songs . You will get to know rafi was god gifted singer. He can sing any type of song. He was gem.
Mohd. Rafi's voice is considered to be the voice of God ! So pure and melodious. Rafi did not copy the style or anything, he was classically trained and had his own style. It is the composer and music director's fault, not Rafi's. I'm a fan of both and both are not comparable.
@@sauravmitra5885 আরে ভাই Copy করে যদি সেটা আরও better তাহলে সেগুলোতে অসুবিধা কোথায় ? কিশোরদার Do pal Ki hai , Neele Neele ambar par এই গান গুলোও Copied তা বলে কি এই গুলো sahi নয় ? আর এখানে রফি সাহাব Elvis Presley এর চেয়ে গানটা আরো better গেয়েছে তাহলে অসুবিধা কোথায় ?
These are two of the greatest singers in history . Both were legends in their own time .Rafi sang more songs with his heavenly voice than any singer living or dead . Beautiful vid . Tq
Elvis and Rafi were the best singers in their own right. Besides being great singers were loving, sweet, kind and generous. Nice comparison in song. God blessed them both. Long gone but will never be forgotten. Still make their fans very happy❤️😍😍❤️
Rafi Saab as always be ahead of all the Legends in this world. Elvis ji was great at his place but Rafi Saab... speechless.. no words can describe his Legendary.. Even Kaun yeh aya mehfil mein...Oh... meri Neeta... he did excellent job..
@@ravindersangwan5098 neither Rafi nor Elvis need to touch each other's level...Just like Elvis is an western world legendary singer and so as Md. Rafi is an ultra legend of subcontinental semi-classical music...Both are great..and belong to the elite group of vocalists.... Respect both.👍
@@ravindersangwan5098 how Elvis or any other could be able to touch or reach upto Rafi's stature. The thing you've explained is just piece of shit and let this shit remain in your mind. Outshining Rafi is just myth and unreachable aim. Hope, it's sorted now !! 👍🏻 EDIT : BTW, just to remind you Rafi is at invisible Altitude.
Estás bromeando ? ELVIS PRESLEY es mundialmente famosos , Rafy es una copia barata de Presley , este vídeo lo observé por Elvis Presley el otro tipo es absolutamente desconocido mundialmente , con respeto a tu cultura (hindú) jamás ha tenido un impacto global su cultura es regional .
Now lived in both worlds - Memphis for the Elvis Presley and India - Mohd Rafi Saab. Looks clear copy in lyrics & music - yet they both are master pieces. Loving both versions and the legends of music.
Yes yes yes i noted Muhammad Rafi ikut elvis presley punya lagu starting point dia Ada persamaan introduction nya, kon hey jo sape no mere aya Hindustan song n my favourite song 70'an very nice song.
Rafi was a great singer and I loved his voice above all other voices that I have heard where hindi songs are concerned ,he even overshadowed Lata in the duets on the other hand Elvis is a legend and a king of rock and roll and I don't think that any one can compare with these two legends.Like Elvis cannot sing Hindi songs Rafi too cannot sing English songs.Regarding singing to a similar tune both have done justice to their respective songs.
Krishan Kant I have heard both the numbers sung by Rafi he has sung ok but if some one like Elvis , Cliff Richards, Engelbert Humperdink and the list goes on they would have definitely sung much better than Rafi has the same way these singers that I have just mentioned even with the great voices that they have cannot sing Hindi numbers like Rafi.There is no comparision in their respective fields.
Muhammad Rafi's voice inspires me till this day. It appears to me that his voice comes from a different planet. He was not from this world, he was not for this world. His voice was voice of God and God recalled him to Himself.
Elvis has a deeper voice going to a lower note very and clearly articulating the words. Very well sung by him.Rafi's voice is softer and suiting to the actor. I am glad these comparative songs have been uploaded. SJ has done a service in bringing this tune to us.It does not belittle him in any way.After all how can we forget the great tunes in his other films based purely on classical Indian ragas.
Read the comments of various music lover but, no body talks about the melody of Signing God Rafi sb. His voice is of God. Rafi sb can't be compared with any body in any era.
@pariapsara exactly!! they took it and made it their own, not just simply taking n presenting as it is... then the lyrics n the beautiful voice of Rafi sent it to an another level
The singers sang from their hearts , gave life to voice from depth of lungs ....... They belong to the world ...... Nobody can claim them on national or religion ........ Thank the Devine that we are alive to absorb ......
SHANKAR-JAIKISHAN improvised the tune and made it even sweeter and evergreen with Rafi's voice. Shammi Kapoor was supposed to be the star but ended up with Rajendra kumar.
Elvis is the great.But when it comes about Rafi,nobody can be compared to Rafi sahab.We Indian love Muhammad Rafi sahab as English people(England)love Shakespear.There will be no another Rafi until the end of the earth.
+sagar talekar In the same way there will never ever be another Kishore Kumar .Mahendra Kapoor ,Lata, Asha, Mukesh, Engelbert,Elvis, Jim Reeves and of course the list goes on and on.
+Michael Edwards Rafi sang in 15 different languages and was super hit everywhere ? English is just a matter of language as Music has no language ... sorry to differ your opinion ... I would say both were good ...both were legends ..... unfortunately Rafi has larger fan following than Elvis !
sorry to disagree with you in this respect- you know amit kumar KK's son was far more superior to KK but he was arrogant and very moody and temperamental that is the reason he lost on to other singers but what ever work he has done is far far superior to KK's work with due respect to KK but there is another singer who started as a copycat but he was far better than KK in all genre's of music and songs but again the fame went to his head and caused his downfall. In this list i can only say Asha was the only inimitable and uncomparable but others have been copied, immitated and even bettered at times except Rafi and Asha Bhosle and Usha Uthup I am a big fan of music and singers of all types but being a professional analyst, i do analyse things very critically and I am telling this with so much conviction because i have listened to them all without any bias or prejudice, this is my opinion.
This was a very minor number for Elvis but the Rafi version is epic! Both are great, but let’s face it as great as Rafi was Elvis had a much more beautiful voice!
I love how the indian music directors take a song and then make it their own, the song " Bolo bolo kuch to bolo pyar ho to kehdo yes, pyar nahin to kehdo no" ---starts out like the original song then the song becomes so beautiful. Also the song "'lehoron pe lehar" takes beautiful nuances and is a beautiful variation of the original copy
Classic Era N Classic Legends I like the classic both Hollywood and Bollywood... The Elvis Presley Version ❤❤ Or my fav Rafi saab's version ❤❤ Again came here to this video here in 2025 after years...❤
"Nakal mein Bhi akaal honi chahiye" - doesn't matter if this song is copied. It is well copied. And no one can question the singing prowess of the great Rafi. It is on par with Elvis Presley in every aspect.
@@buzztube1738 OG as in? Original doesn't need to be better. That's like saying if Rafi Sahab sings "tum hi ho" (Hypothetically us he was alive, young and sound) , then it would not be as good as the Arijit version. LOL.
This tune is very special because it’s been sung by three living instruments first elvis presley king of pop of hollywood, then mohammad rafi the king of pop of bollywood and then the legendary incomparably beautiful king of pop of afghanistan ahmad zahir! All sung in as equally beautiful forms sharing the same chorus but different moods and different philosophy. Let’s focus on how beautiful it gets in whichever form, and not compare people.
Mohd. Rafi's most beautiful songs have been mostly pictured on Rajendra Kumar another super personality he always attributed his movies successes to all the movie crew and the greatest to Rafi ji's singing!
Rajendra Kumar is not even 2% of Rafi. Take your words back please. Without Rafi, he could not even have become a star. The same applies to Shammi. No less than, 100 heroes have sung Rafi's songs. Rafi belongs to nobody, but everybody belongs to Rafi.
Syn Hope we all get sucked into debating apples vs oranges. It's a pity that we must let our egos dictate our thoughts to "who is better" rather than appreciating everyone's uniqueness. No one belongs to anyone. Let us just enjoy what goodness we have in front of us in the form of great Indian film music and the great musicians, composers and singers and let it end there.
Spandan Behera U R avoiding to praise The Legendry Singer BuT majority of Sikhs Hindus & Muslims who know about sangeet, They are be with The Only Legend MUHAMMAD RAFi SAHiB ji♡♡♡♡♡♡
@Nen stupidity occurs when you see garbage next to you. What Rafi is that everyone knows, he didn't became popular because he never wanted to be and at erstwhile era there wasn't digital media.
@Nen Rafi ji is God no doubt. I just wish he and many other gems of India got a fair opportunity to express their talent in songs which were their own and nobody else's. Perhaps I'm wrong but somehow I feel that the artist is the one to get cheated by the money mafias in such cases of plagiarism
Elvis maybe famous among western world he was good singer, but when it comes in versatility Rafi has an edge over Elvis and the beautiful voice of Mohammad Rafi is superb.
Elvis Presley es mundialmente famoso , en todos los rincones del planeta , es absurdo que trates de decir que Rafi ( un cantante completamente desconocido mundialmente tiene una ventaja sobre Presley ) no puedo tolerar la música que canta ese tipo ( Rafi) lo acabo de conocer hace unos segundos no lo volvería a escuchar más , este vídeo lo observé por Elvis Presley y apareció el otro sujeto . Rafi es una de las tantas copias baratas de Presley que hay en el mundo .Considero que toda cultura tiene sus tradiciones y es respetable , la cultura Hindú jamás ha tenido un impacto mundial, su música , tradiciones es éxótica , lo único famoso de India es el TAJ MAHAL.
The only edge Elvis had over Rafi was that Elvis began as a live performer... blessed with the looks of an angel he strummed the guitar, gyrated, danced and sang with his four piece band -Nothing much is known about Elvis' accompanying musicians except for John Black... (Paul McCartney loves Elvis's bassist John Black's style of playing so much that he owns the double base that Mr. Black played on all of Elvis' early songs) - Rafi on the other hand was a studio performer - and almost all of Rafi's songs had massive fillings by classical instrumentalists who were maestros in their own right.... Shiv Kumar Sharma's Santoor, Hariprasad's flute, Kartik Kumar's sitar, Louis Banks' piano and several other instrumentalists wove in and out of a Rafi song embellishing it with flashes of their brilliance.... Rafi and Elvis are musicians of different cadres... they cannot be compared...but as far as the quality of voice goes.... Man o man... I love them both and I am sure both will remain eternal....
I have grown up in India and my dad had all the latest LP'S of the various pop , jazz ,country etc. singers (English) I also used to watch a lot of Indian movies and listen to Indian songs . I honestly enjoyed both and it is very difficult to say which is better .I am settled in Australia and still listen to Indian songs as well as English...so I really do not understand what these only Rafi lovers or Elvis lovers are arguing about .....Life would be so boring if we only heard either one of these singers...all singers have their own style of singing and I enjoy all of them so people must stop bullshitting as to who is the better singer and enjoy the variety of talent on display .
Nothing much is known? That is like me saying 'very little is known about Rafi'! Elvis' band was legendary. While Elvis may have been molded into some swingin', singin' movie star, he had a righteous beginning. And good or bad - he always had excellent musicians behind him! (while he hogged the spotlight and took all the credit). And it was producer Sam Phillips that put Elvis together with Scotty Moore, Bill Black, and DJ Fontana. And as a bonus - he got the Jordanaires, as singers! He used them exclusively for the next 14 years!
Subodh Maratt first of all indians have no idea who king elvis was I am American I don't give a fuck to this unpopular guy remember elvis is worshiped in usa king of rock and roll never forgotten he copy and he sucks
Undoubtedly ra
Rafi sahab, awesome , superb, excellent, outstanding. Most melodious voice in the world.
Yesudas is better. He has sung many songs which mhd rafi couldnt sing...
@@jacobjacob6334 it's not about technicality, it's about voice quality in Playback singing, it should be soothing and young, better for picturization and treat to ears. Technicality comes to work when music director really want to experiment with something so the singer should be able to deliver.
@siddiquiubaid4275 music creator is above play back singing. Your rafi sab ran away while singing tansen and yesudas sung it. There are better singers...
@@jacobjacob6334
this is not good comparison
@@jacobjacob6334
ക്രിസംഘി p00ran
This clip is brilliant THE KING ELVIS singing with RAFI both fantastic singers both from the 60 s who is still listening today in 2024 both legends R.I.P.to both ELVIS and RAFI🇬🇧👍👍👍👍❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Rafi sahab to khushboo hai jub bhi sangeet ka mausam hota hai unki awaj mahak udhti hai.
Ishwar ki awaj ka jaadu
ye gaana inspired hote huye bhi rafi saab ka singing aur awaaz kya kehne, just excellent
Who is here after karunesh talwar's Master chef stand up comedy 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Me 😂😂
Arre bhai...kurta pehen ke churaya hai
🤣🤣🤣
me
Me
Beautiful song from the "king" Elvis. Even if it was copied in Hindi, the magic of Rafi makes it refreshing. One of my favourite songs, I don't know how many times I sang this song to the entertainment of my family and friends.
Great fabulous 💐Engel Voice from Elves Presley 💐
💐Mohamed Rafi with Engel voice 💐Amazing Quality 👍👏👏👏👏💐💐💐💐💐👍💛se
If a voice has ever reached the point of perfection in terms of melody and sweetness, then it is the voice of Mohammed Rafi. Definitely soul stirring and melody at its peak.
All these people never thought their plagiarism would ever be caught, fortunately internet happened..😂😂
True
UA-cam more specifically
be positive
Music is shit today. Indian, American. Asian All of it
Thats NOT Dear Mohammed Rafi's fault, its the Musician who stole the music, not the singer! So Why drag Rafi's name in the Caption???? EVIL Duffer uploader
,;-)
Karunesh talwar
I was looking for this very comment in this section 😂 😂 I came here because of Karunesh Talwar
Kurta pehenke churaya hain
😂😂
Haha😂
😂😂😂😂
The way Elvis says 'heart' everytime, though..
Irony...he died from heart attack
खुशनसीब हूँ कि मेरी मातृभाषा हिंदी है, Rafi जैसा कोई नही
Rafi Sahab ka gaaya gaana Elvis Presley se bhi jyada accha hai. Rafi Sahab jaisa koi na tha, na hai aur na koi hoga ❤
Elvis is the creator of this song. Creator is more important....
I feel Rafi's voice, background music & songs picturisation is outstanding.
Perfect ❤
M i the only one who is enjoying both the singers... ??
bhushan mapuskar yes you are
Me too
bhushan mapuskar Enjoying them both!!! But Rafi Saab is another level!!!
MUJHE RAFI SAHAB KA ENGLISH VERSION JADA PASAND AAYA
Rafi saab probably didn't know about this being a copy. Nevertheless both sang this beautifully !
Truly, Rafi Sb is incredible, the sweetness,clarity,rendition, range n above all, the versatility with a range of mesmerising tones no one anywhere across the globe has been found to exhibit, and even more incredible is the dimension of his heavenly voice not to thin out in tone or texture when singing the high notes , in fact, the resonance n sweetness would get more mystical, a quality none has surpassed! Hats off to the Shahanshah of playback singing!
Song is copied but the skills of Rafiji is not under question.. Great singers.. Rafi, kishore, mukesh .. etc... Music composers are at fault, not singers.
Maybe all of them liked the song and copied it
True
It's not fault.. It's talent... Aap bhi copy kar ke india ke best music director ban jao na...kisne roka hai
@@subhrojyotisinha2064 yessssssss i support u
cant be that talented if ur copying
I love the way that Western music and Indian music blend so effortlessly. I can't be certain that Indian music includes Western influences very often, but when Western music experiments with Indian traditions, and gives it space to breathe, it never fails to add something important; and over a wide variety of styles too...rock, Jazz, Hippie, Country, Blues, HipHop, Jam....well, you get the idea.
Liked it for only Rafi sir he takes me to 1960's awsome era
Whatever man...when mohd rafi started singing...my eyes closed automatically....voice so soothing plus my own language. :D
Only Mohammad Rafi could sing that lovely tune. Elvis Presley and M Rafi, both greatest of their times. Superb 👌
Two legends!
TRue legends
Mohd. Rafi saab!! Velvet soft! Clean
Hindi song has broader range and thus is more difficult. Rafi sahab as usual has made it sound so easy and light.
hindi songs are shir. shitty lyrics
@@sohelbashar6925 what the f**k probably you are talking about modern hindi sings not of golden era of bollywood
Both Elvis and Rafi are legends in their own way. Marguerita was made in 1963. Kaun hai jo song made in 1968. So who copied from whom? It is obvious SJ duo stole the tune from the original English one.
Analysing thus will lead only to unnecessary squabbles and verbal altercation in which each side will try to bring down the other singer, causing insults to be heaped on both the singing greats. So just, let us sit back and enjoy the God-given voices of these 2 geniuses.
Apki angreezi bhut achi ha
@@ahmed1758 Thank You, bro
RAFI Sir’s voice , OHH MY GOD, can’t get enough of him. Today’s Bollywood is total shit, anyone agrees with me?
We get some good music today as well but they r rare now a days
Jasleen royals music
Correct
Gtrrrrreattttt
Since English songs are shit so now indian musician cant copy good english song.. thus the hindi songs have become shit too
Both are Ultra Legends...but, the thief is the music composer!
Shankar Jaikishan
No bro elvis is real legend
If Elvis was born in India, he wouldn’t be a true legend
@@gamingstriker6219 elvis cannot match mohammad rafi's level
@@ajayhooda2723 kon hai Muhammad rafi pehle history pad fir pata chalega chutiye Elvis ka level kya hai . He is the king of Rock n Roll
The range of Rafi was unbelievable and he commanded absolute perfection in all that he undertook. Elvis was a western singer with a emotional voice but limited in range in comparison although he was also a very talented and beautiful singer and a performer with star value. I must both are great in their own ways
What are you talking about? Elvis was particularly famous for his exceptional vocal and musical range.
Elvis has higher range than md rafi
I am Guyanese and I grew up on all kind of music..calypso, pop, rock n roll, reggae, hindi, jazz, country, etc. In my humble opinion, Mohammed Rafi had the most beautiful voice ..gift of God as some would say and the most versatile of all singers. he could do pop, the sad songs, the rock n roll and the classical all with ease. No disrespect to any other singer, but its not even close. The mere fact that the majority of Hindus feel the same about a Muslim is all you need to know.
well said
+Mohamed Rahaman
The maestro Rafisab was a Muslim, the great Jesudas is a christian and uncomparable Lathaji is an Hindu by birth only.
But for them their religion is Music only. So please do not tarnish them with such religious version.
Just be proud of being with them on this earth to hear such God's own voice.!!
+Prabhu Bhaskaran hope Mr. Mohammed learns from your wisdom..
Mohamed Rahaman
Totally disagree.
Rafi is nothing in front of
Freddie Mercury
Elvis Presley
Michael Jackson
Frank Sinatra
Axl Rose
John Lennon
Paul McCartney
Bob Dylan
Prince Nelson
Billie Joel
Bob Marley
Jimmy Hendrix.
Shivam Kumar then you don't know who Mohammad rafi is. Listen to all his songs . You will get to know rafi was god gifted singer. He can sing any type of song. He was gem.
beautiful song and beautifully sung by Rafi Saab Ji...
A man without no high quality and High attention and no high showop this is the proper generation Legend of song
Mohd. Rafi's voice is considered to be the voice of God ! So pure and melodious. Rafi did not copy the style or anything, he was classically trained and had his own style. It is the composer and music director's fault, not Rafi's. I'm a fan of both and both are not comparable.
Haa thik hai tassalli le lo
@@sauravmitra5885 😂😂😂
@@sauravmitra5885 বাঙালী হয়েও বিদেশের তারিফ করছো ভাই 😏
@@imtiazmallick5442 bhai bangali hone ki baat nahi hai bhai copy ki hui koi bhi chiz sahi nahi hoti chahe gana kyu na ho
@@sauravmitra5885 আরে ভাই Copy করে যদি সেটা আরও better তাহলে সেগুলোতে অসুবিধা কোথায় ? কিশোরদার Do pal Ki hai , Neele Neele ambar par এই গান গুলোও Copied তা বলে কি এই গুলো sahi নয় ? আর এখানে রফি সাহাব Elvis Presley এর চেয়ে গানটা আরো better গেয়েছে তাহলে অসুবিধা কোথায় ?
There are many Rafi Songs and each one is better than other ,It is hard to say which one is best.
The legend......Mohd. Rafi
Kaun hai jo sapne me aaya? Both Elvis n Rafi are awesome ❤
These are two of the greatest singers in history . Both were legends in their own time .Rafi sang more songs with his heavenly voice than any singer living or dead . Beautiful vid . Tq
Only Elvis Presley
Both great singers and considered to be still alive by millions.They both live on as immortals.
Elvis and Rafi ji, the legends we all love.
Elvis and Rafi were the best singers in their own right. Besides being great singers were loving, sweet, kind and generous. Nice comparison in song. God blessed them both. Long gone but will never be forgotten. Still make their fans very happy❤️😍😍❤️
Wonderfully adapted. Liked both.
Mohm rafi sungs it very well
Rafi the finest singer ever. This is one of my favorite songs.
Rafi Saab as always be ahead of all the Legends in this world. Elvis ji was great at his place but Rafi Saab... speechless.. no words can describe his Legendary.. Even Kaun yeh aya mehfil mein...Oh... meri Neeta... he did excellent job..
Bro Rafi was excellent but Elvis was ahead.Elvis doesn't need to touch rafi saab's level.It is rafi saab who needed to touch elvis' level.
@@ravindersangwan5098 neither Rafi nor Elvis need to touch each other's level...Just like Elvis is an western world legendary singer and so as Md. Rafi is an ultra legend of subcontinental semi-classical music...Both are great..and belong to the elite group of vocalists.... Respect both.👍
@@ravindersangwan5098 how Elvis or any other could be able to touch or reach upto Rafi's stature. The thing you've explained is just piece of shit and let this shit remain in your mind. Outshining Rafi is just myth and unreachable aim. Hope, it's sorted now !! 👍🏻
EDIT : BTW, just to remind you Rafi is at invisible Altitude.
@@mitboricha9 in log lo kya pata rafi sahab ke baare me 😂🤣
Ye elvis SPB ke aage hi feeka pad jaega to fir Rafi Sahab to door ki baat hai
Estás bromeando ? ELVIS PRESLEY es mundialmente famosos , Rafy es una copia barata de Presley , este vídeo lo observé por Elvis Presley el otro tipo es absolutamente desconocido mundialmente , con respeto a tu cultura (hindú) jamás ha tenido un impacto global su cultura es regional .
Good find, never knew that the Jhuk Gaya Aasman song was based on Marguerita of Elvis. Both are beautifully sung. Thanks.
Now lived in both worlds - Memphis for the Elvis Presley and India - Mohd Rafi Saab. Looks clear copy in lyrics & music - yet they both are master pieces. Loving both versions and the legends of music.
Yes yes yes i noted Muhammad Rafi ikut elvis presley punya lagu starting point dia Ada persamaan introduction nya, kon hey jo sape no mere aya Hindustan song n my favourite song 70'an very nice song.
Rafi was a great singer and I loved his voice above all other voices that I have heard where hindi songs are concerned ,he even overshadowed Lata in the duets on the other hand Elvis is a legend and a king of rock and roll and I don't think that any one can compare with these two legends.Like Elvis cannot sing Hindi songs Rafi too cannot sing English songs.Regarding singing to a similar tune both have done justice to their respective songs.
Rafi saab sung 2 english songs also....search The She I Love and The World Is One
Krishan Kant I have heard both the numbers sung by Rafi he has sung ok but if some one like Elvis , Cliff Richards, Engelbert Humperdink and the list goes on they would have definitely sung much better than Rafi has the same way these singers that I have just mentioned even with the great voices that they have cannot sing Hindi numbers like Rafi.There is no comparision in their respective fields.
Best comment here...
We are no one to compare the legends...
We love Rafi
And love to Elvis from India...
Have many english songs
you are right my friend.
Muhammad Rafi's voice inspires me till this day. It appears to me that his voice comes from a different planet. He was not from this world, he was not for this world. His voice was voice of God and God recalled him to Himself.
God sent an angel to sing copied versions of classic songs without giving credits to the original?
Devil makes more logic now...
Very much correct
Probably he didn’t even knew.If u want to blame some blame the music composers not singers
RAFI IS GREAT SINGER BUT ELVIS IS MOST BETTER For THIS SONG
@@subhrojyotisinha2064 just food for thought;
I wonder how wud you have treated him if mohd Rafi was a Brahman Hindu...
Raffi ji really grt singer the
Elvis has a deeper voice going to a lower note very and clearly articulating the words. Very well sung by him.Rafi's voice is softer and suiting to the actor. I am glad these comparative songs have been uploaded. SJ has done a service in bringing this tune to us.It does not belittle him in any way.After all how can we forget the great tunes in his other films based purely on classical Indian ragas.
no one can beat them, nor can anyone compare them, they are legends of their own genre.
i feel personally md rafi's voice is
melodious
Read the comments of various music lover but, no body talks about the melody of Signing God Rafi sb.
His voice is of God.
Rafi sb can't be compared with any body in any era.
I share his first name 😇🙏
Rafi saab ki ruhaani aawaaz ...no comparison..
Huh? He had good voice but don't far fetch it. It's pedantic next to Caruso, Gigli or Pavarotti. But all well in respective genres.
@@dawood2u and you share a blasphemous last name dear.😅
There were many artists who were better than him, like Michael, Freddie and Elvis.
Kya gaana hai bhi...rula diya
Look at the ways he sings Kon hai the second time
It is just mesmerizing
The whole valley seems to reverberate
Rafi sahab was rafi sahab . Behetreen aawaz thi unki❤❤
I thoroughly enjoyed both the songs and reading the comments too..haha..thank you all for this extra entertainment..:-)
@pariapsara exactly!! they took it and made it their own, not just simply taking n presenting as it is... then the lyrics n the beautiful voice of Rafi sent it to an another level
The singers sang from their hearts , gave life to voice from depth of lungs ....... They belong to the world ...... Nobody can claim them on national or religion ........ Thank the Devine that we are alive to absorb ......
East or West Mohd.Rafi is the best.
SHANKAR-JAIKISHAN improvised the tune and made it even sweeter and evergreen with Rafi's voice. Shammi Kapoor was supposed to be the star but ended up with Rajendra kumar.
Yes, Elvis did sing to the tune and a wonderful one ... but Rafi took that tune to a whole new level
No comparison...... Rafi sahab is always Great.
Rafi is great
More passion than presely
How sweet to listen to him
Absolutely right true legends
Elvis is the great.But when it comes about Rafi,nobody can be compared to Rafi sahab.We Indian love Muhammad Rafi sahab as English people(England)love Shakespear.There will be no another Rafi until the end of the earth.
+sagar talekar In the same way there will never ever be another Kishore Kumar .Mahendra Kapoor ,Lata, Asha, Mukesh, Engelbert,Elvis, Jim Reeves and of course the list goes on and on.
+Michael Edwards Rafi sang in 15 different languages and was super hit everywhere ? English is just a matter of language as Music has no language ... sorry to differ your opinion ... I would say both were good ...both were legends ..... unfortunately Rafi has larger fan following than Elvis !
+Jumi Kaka For your kind information I was born in India don't get confused by my name.
Michael Edwards Uddibaba ..tu Elvis ki aulad nahin hai tu toh Kishore Da ki aulad hai ! ;)
sorry to disagree with you in this respect- you know amit kumar KK's son was far more superior to KK but he was arrogant and very moody and temperamental that is the reason he lost on to other singers but what ever work he has done is far far superior to KK's work with due respect to KK but there is another singer who started as a copycat but he was far better than KK in all genre's of music and songs but again the fame went to his head and caused his downfall. In this list i can only say Asha was the only inimitable and uncomparable but others have been copied, immitated and even bettered at times except Rafi and Asha Bhosle and Usha Uthup I am a big fan of music and singers of all types but being a professional analyst, i do analyse things very critically and I am telling this with so much conviction because i have listened to them all without any bias or prejudice, this is my opinion.
True Rafi was SJs main singer, infact rafi was many music directors main singer. I miss Rafi a lot..
Elvis presley you are great..
Rafi sahab lots of love and respect for you
Thanks for uploading.
Well well well nobody can beat Rafi that is for sure straight away touches heart
This was a very minor number for Elvis but the Rafi version is epic! Both are great, but let’s face it as great as Rafi was Elvis had a much more beautiful voice!
I FORGET EVERYTHING ..AFTER HEARING MOHD. RAFI SIR....it seems to compare stars with MOON...one n only Rafi sir....
I love how the indian music directors take a song and then make it their own,
the song " Bolo bolo kuch to bolo pyar ho to kehdo yes, pyar nahin to kehdo no"
---starts out like the original song then the song becomes so beautiful.
Also the song "'lehoron pe lehar" takes beautiful nuances and is a beautiful variation of the original copy
R.I.P. TO THE GREAT M.R. ----- BLENDING IN R.I.P. ELVIS PRESLEY'S MOVIE SONG TO HIS VERSION INDEED !! SUPERB !! MANY THANKS FROM U.K.
Classic Era N Classic Legends
I like the classic both Hollywood and Bollywood...
The Elvis Presley Version ❤❤
Or my fav Rafi saab's version ❤❤
Again came here to this video here in 2025 after years...❤
Rafi's skills are original and song has its own soul.
Rafi is the greatest, no doubt and he was SJs main singer...
"Nakal mein Bhi akaal honi chahiye" - doesn't matter if this song is copied. It is well copied. And no one can question the singing prowess of the great Rafi. It is on par with Elvis Presley in every aspect.
Maine apne teacher ko bhi yahi kaha tha...
LOL Rafi sahab is better.
@@mdbahrozbaburali No man Elvis is OG
@@buzztube1738 OG as in? Original doesn't need to be better. That's like saying if Rafi Sahab sings "tum hi ho" (Hypothetically us he was alive, young and sound) , then it would not be as good as the Arijit version.
LOL.
I'm gonna show this to my parents. They always say old is gold. Well here is your gold LOL
Rafi sahab is superb
Don't break heads by criticising, simply enjoy the songs.
just listen " O PRIYA ...." with different WAYS ..shows .WHY RAFI & INDIAN CLASSICAL MUSIC IS GREATER
indian greater in bobs and vegans. Can't even do moon landing properly.
shit countries like india will be always behind first world countries
@@sohelbashar6925 shut your mouth fuckistan.. 🤣🤣
Elvis was the real deal bro
@@sohelbashar6925 But your pakistan is eve less.I do not mean to disrespect a country but you crossed the limit.
Mohammad Rafi.. magical voice
god is great who created this two legendary artist Elvis n Rafi ji 😍😍😍🤗🤗🤗😆😆😆😘😘😘🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Chahe kuch bhi kaho Rafi Sahab ki awaz me jaadoo hai❤
This tune is very special because it’s been sung by three living instruments first elvis presley king of pop of hollywood, then mohammad rafi the king of pop of bollywood and then the legendary incomparably beautiful king of pop of afghanistan ahmad zahir! All sung in as equally beautiful forms sharing the same chorus but different moods and different philosophy. Let’s focus on how beautiful it gets in whichever form, and not compare people.
Mohd. Rafi's most beautiful songs have been mostly pictured on Rajendra Kumar another super personality he always attributed his movies successes to all the movie crew and the greatest to Rafi ji's singing!
Rajendra Kumar is not even 2% of Rafi. Take your words back please. Without Rafi, he could not even have become a star. The same applies to Shammi. No less than, 100 heroes have sung Rafi's songs. Rafi belongs to nobody, but everybody belongs to Rafi.
Syn Hope we all get sucked into debating apples vs oranges. It's a pity that we must let our egos dictate our thoughts to "who is better" rather than appreciating everyone's uniqueness. No one belongs to anyone. Let us just enjoy what goodness we have in front of us in the form of great Indian film music and the great musicians, composers and singers and let it end there.
Rajendra Kumar and Shammi Kapoor.
Spandan behera👹
..........
Dont talk against The Biggest Legend💗
MUHAMMAD RAFi SAHiB ji♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡
Spandan Behera
U R avoiding to praise
The Legendry Singer
BuT majority of Sikhs Hindus & Muslims who know about sangeet,
They are be with The Only Legend
MUHAMMAD RAFi SAHiB ji♡♡♡♡♡♡
John Lennon himself said that before Elvis, there was nothing.
But this is plagarism level 100
I support this i'm a huge beatles fan❤
If there's voice of GOD then it's none other than Mohammed Rafi.
@Nen stupidity occurs when you see garbage next to you. What Rafi is that everyone knows, he didn't became popular because he never wanted to be and at erstwhile era there wasn't digital media.
@Nen Rafi ji is God no doubt. I just wish he and many other gems of India got a fair opportunity to express their talent in songs which were their own and nobody else's. Perhaps I'm wrong but somehow I feel that the artist is the one to get cheated by the money mafias in such cases of plagiarism
@@mitboricha9 pretty sure he was referring to rafi when said god bro...
Elvis was an endlessly gifted human being.
Enjoyed both songs,
There is nobody quite like Rafi sahab ....he is beyond excellence..incomparable
Golden voice of Rafi Sahab.👍
Rafi saab voice is amazing.
Fact is both are Legend's 🙏🏻.
Elvis maybe famous among western world he was good singer, but when it comes in versatility Rafi has an edge over Elvis and the beautiful voice of Mohammad Rafi is superb.
Elvis Presley es mundialmente famoso , en todos los rincones del planeta , es absurdo que trates de decir que Rafi ( un cantante completamente desconocido mundialmente tiene una ventaja sobre Presley ) no puedo tolerar la música que canta ese tipo ( Rafi) lo acabo de conocer hace unos segundos no lo volvería a escuchar más , este vídeo lo observé por Elvis Presley y apareció el otro sujeto . Rafi es una de las tantas copias baratas de Presley que hay en el mundo .Considero que toda cultura tiene sus tradiciones y es respetable , la cultura Hindú jamás ha tenido un impacto mundial, su música , tradiciones es éxótica , lo único famoso de India es el TAJ MAHAL.
Elvis was very good... but Rafisaab was simply the best!
arjin kn
Don't need a shithead like you telling me the difference between Elvis n Rafisaab!
arjin kn
No one cares for the opinion of a dumb fool like you...best to mute off idiotic persons such as you who speak through their arse.. ..!
@@drviveksharma2196 And Nobody cares a about dumb opinion of dumb person like you.
That's the nationalism in you talking.
@@danksamosa3952 drunkens are shit to the world, hope you're one among them. 🤣😂
Rafi's voice is something which u cannot compare
The only edge Elvis had over Rafi was that Elvis began as a live performer... blessed with the looks of an angel he strummed the guitar, gyrated, danced and sang with his four piece band -Nothing much is known about Elvis' accompanying musicians except for John Black... (Paul McCartney loves Elvis's bassist John Black's style of playing so much that he owns the double base that Mr. Black played on all of Elvis' early songs) - Rafi on the other hand was a studio performer - and almost all of Rafi's songs had massive fillings by classical instrumentalists who were maestros in their own right.... Shiv Kumar Sharma's Santoor, Hariprasad's flute, Kartik Kumar's sitar, Louis Banks' piano and several other instrumentalists wove in and out of a Rafi song embellishing it with flashes of their brilliance.... Rafi and Elvis are musicians of different cadres... they cannot be compared...but as far as the quality of voice goes.... Man o man... I love them both and I am sure both will remain eternal....
+Subodh Maratt Very well said. So very true :-)
I have grown up in India and my dad had all the latest LP'S of the various pop , jazz ,country etc. singers (English) I also used to watch a lot of Indian movies and listen to Indian songs . I honestly enjoyed both and it is very difficult to say which is better .I am settled in Australia and still listen to Indian songs as well as English...so I really do not understand what these only Rafi lovers or Elvis lovers are arguing about .....Life would be so boring if we only heard either one of these singers...all singers have their own style of singing and I enjoy all of them so people must stop bullshitting as to who is the better singer and enjoy the variety of talent on display .
Michael Edwards
yes, agree :-)
Nothing much is known? That is like me saying 'very little is known about Rafi'! Elvis' band was legendary. While Elvis may have been molded into some swingin', singin' movie star, he had a righteous beginning. And good or bad - he always had excellent musicians behind him! (while he hogged the spotlight and took all the credit).
And it was producer Sam Phillips that put Elvis together with Scotty Moore, Bill Black, and DJ Fontana. And as a bonus - he got the Jordanaires, as singers! He used them exclusively for the next 14 years!
Subodh Maratt first of all indians have no idea who king elvis was I am American I don't give a fuck to this unpopular guy remember elvis is worshiped in usa king of rock and roll never forgotten he copy and he sucks
Beyond all the controversial comment,,,,, I just want to say thanks for sharing this,,,, I enjoyed them both very much......!
I love both songs, it's great
But Rafi sahab is the Best.....All time
lol who is he
@@sohelbashar6925ask your father or your neighbor.