5W-30と5W40

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 січ 2018

КОМЕНТАРІ • 89

  • @cskye6529
    @cskye6529 2 роки тому +27

    I appreciate the ticking of the clock helping me keep time.

    • @skie6282
      @skie6282 Рік тому

      Its synced tp the video seconds too

    • @cskye6529
      @cskye6529 Рік тому

      @@skie6282 Probably because it is a clock and ticks every half second.

  • @depwater12
    @depwater12 5 років тому +104

    5w40 provides better protection against heat. Especially in turbo cars and high horsepower cars in the summer

    • @aa7h911
      @aa7h911 4 роки тому +4

      @Samuel Fita 5W40 is better than 5W30 as above for summer and cars that produce a lot of power/turbo etc. Now 0W40 will protect better during startup in cold better than 5W40 due to its viscosity. Of course you need to look into spec sheets etc to compare, but generally first number (0 or 5) is for the cold and the second number (30 or 40) for when the oil is up to running temps.

    • @bmbl80
      @bmbl80 4 роки тому +12

      5 is winter grade and 30/40 is summer grade, so 5w30 or 5w40 will be the same in winter. 40 is definitly better in summer

    • @MeBallerman
      @MeBallerman 3 роки тому +40

      @@bmbl80 No. FORGET "summer" - the 30/40 refer to the oil's viscosity within it's operating temperature, which is between 100ºC and 120ºC . So 5W40 means it has a "5" viscosity rating at winter temperature (-17.8ºC or 0ºF) before you start the engine (cold start in winter) The 40 has NOTHING to do with summer, as many people think. It refers to the oil's viscosity rating at operating temperature (which is set to 100ºC or 212ºF)
      40 is better for cars with a tonne of HP, as it has a thicker, more protecting oil film.
      W stands for winter, yes - but there's no S for summer - is there? Nope. Because it refers to the engine oil's viscosity rating at operating temperature summer AND winter. BAM. So many people get this wrong.

    • @tomorrowcomestoday1621
      @tomorrowcomestoday1621 3 роки тому +1

      @@MeBallerman sir, I hope you can help me with this. I have a 2007 5.4L v8 triton and I've been using 5 w 30 synthetic blend as the manufacturer recommend here in my country and my users manual. But my question is.. I send my truck for oil changes every 5k and they have always use the oil filter FL-820S. In my users manual says that's the one my engine needs, but yesterday when I picked up the truck and I was at my garage checking everything underneath I saw a different filter they used, the model is MFL-2099 and it says " oil filter, long life" and motorcraft brand, but it has a different shape as the 820s my truck had before. Now I am confused and not sure why they did that and I just don't have the time to take it tomorrow again because I need to travel for work. Would you help me to understand if this new filter they used could damage my engine? I've never seen that model and in motorcraft web page I couldn't find anything about it nor it's specifications. Thanks.

    • @MeBallerman
      @MeBallerman 3 роки тому +2

      @@tomorrowcomestoday1621 I wouldn't worry too much - maybe the mech guy thought "this is a very good filter for your motor" or something. But if you feel insecure about it, have him change it to the one you know. But I'm sure it will be fine, if there are no leaks, and the oil lamp doesn't light up. I mean, either it fits on, or it doesn't, it's just a filter, it doesn't contain explosives or stuff.

  • @rogeriosartori555
    @rogeriosartori555 6 місяців тому +3

    Nice. Now repeat that with both at 100⁰C

  • @kanime59
    @kanime59  Рік тому +16

    Thank you for your comment. Toyota's 2ZR is a high-precision engine, but recommending 5w-30 is the claim of the manufacturer, which prioritizes fuel efficiency. Considering the outside temperature, I think that around 10W40 is fine. I'm an oil professional, but I don't think it's necessary to stick to 5w-30.

    • @siccolindsay610
      @siccolindsay610 Рік тому +1

      Sir what oil weight should I use for the Mercedes M103 engine? I live in Indonesia, tropical, 20-35 Celcius outside.

    • @radiocontrolled9181
      @radiocontrolled9181 10 місяців тому

      ​@@siccolindsay61010W40 is fine.

    • @ilir4429
      @ilir4429 6 місяців тому +1

      I am not a professional, but as much as I researched, use the recommended, especially if turbo charged engine 5w30,4w40

  • @robertolouth7468
    @robertolouth7468 Рік тому +3

    I liked very much your bottle test 👍🏼
    I drive a Toyota 2.5 A25A engine, I live in the tropic with temperatures of between 10 to 35 centigrade and use the recommended by Toyota oil, 0w16. So far very good my driving is mostly short city. Not an ounce of oil lost between changes. I have use 5w30 for when I couldn’t find 0w16, and engine is a bit noisier with ticker oil. But same mileage with both oils.

  • @DomoKuchikan
    @DomoKuchikan 3 роки тому +5

    About to add 1l 5w30 to the current 3l of 5w40 in my 20 years old Polo. The engine has never burned/used any oil and hopefully won't start now...

  • @ppiilloottee
    @ppiilloottee 2 роки тому +2

    Thank you 👍

  • @TheCameraRs
    @TheCameraRs Рік тому +1

    i have a audi 2008 model: A3 2.0t what do u reccomend p.s its winter time rn if that means anything -shrugs- appreciate any suggestions

  • @rango1195
    @rango1195 5 місяців тому +3

    Wath about this, if car can heave 7liters of oil, to add 3,5l of 5w40 and 3,5l of 5w 30 , that is in the end 5w 35😅

  • @iXoTreX
    @iXoTreX 5 років тому +18

    5w30 perfect for the winter saison :)

  • @mariabuligan892
    @mariabuligan892 3 роки тому +5

    Nice Vid. Sir, Whats the ambient temp?

  • @janekbrat
    @janekbrat Рік тому +3

    Awesome

  • @sussertheoriginal
    @sussertheoriginal 10 місяців тому

    The temperature of the oils is this test is a vital factor. We need to know what it was, as has been said.

  • @whiteskull5362
    @whiteskull5362 3 роки тому +21

    thing is like this : If you change the oil every 10.000 km then it dosent matter if you use 5w30 or 5w40 ,its really dosen't matter,some people say that 5w40 offer better protection if you drive fast ...but who the fuck drive fast all day , i don't think that when you start the car you drive aggresive all time ,so for me 5w30 is better because of my driving style ,i have also a tuned audi s5 V6, 440 Hp and is not a problem using 5w30 , i use Ravenol RSP 5w30 is a full synthetic oil. the thing is that you must change the oil every 10k

    • @whiteskull5362
      @whiteskull5362 3 роки тому

      @Pawan kohad my car have 130.000 km

    • @oxy6233
      @oxy6233 3 роки тому

      Respect for your choice in vehicle. I have the exact same car :)

    • @cmte.brazinazzo2061
      @cmte.brazinazzo2061 2 роки тому

      But you use Ravenol RSP, a high ester base oil... try that in a Group III oil.

    • @barrymantei7795
      @barrymantei7795 Рік тому

      It's not if you drive fast if you do heavy towing 5w40 offers better protection

  • @kanime59
    @kanime59  Рік тому +1

    Your choice of oil will change depending on the country you live in and the outside temperature. In the case of Audi, there is a strong tendency for the engine oil to decrease, so I think it would be better to choose a slightly harder oil.

    • @jfloyo11
      @jfloyo11 Рік тому +1

      I have an audi that goes through oil...so I should use the 5w40?

    • @whaleblue
      @whaleblue Рік тому

      @@jfloyo11 if the weather is hot, i think the answer is YES!

    • @jfloyo11
      @jfloyo11 Рік тому +1

      @@whaleblue yeah Im in Southern US where its hot a lot

    • @VanquishMediaDE
      @VanquishMediaDE Рік тому +1

      @@jfloyo11 Turbo engines tend to consume more oil than naturally aspirated engines. 1/2 a quart or 1 qt of oil loss in-between oil changes on a Turbo engine is normal.
      Change the oil and filter every 3,500 miles

  • @NNA-r5d
    @NNA-r5d 9 місяців тому

    Car pump is powered well to push oil all over the system. If you live in a tropical country 5w40 is best. If moderate 5w30 if in very cold 0w30 ..

  • @precisepan9385
    @precisepan9385 3 роки тому +2

    I changing every 5.000 km.used 5w-40 cauze car km 200.000 already

  •  2 роки тому +1

    Geilooo👍

  • @rossinisantos4740
    @rossinisantos4740 2 роки тому +3

    Da uma força aí chefe

  • @tahaanwar7555
    @tahaanwar7555 Рік тому +1

    I have a toyota with 2ZR-FE engine, that's a 1.8L four cylinder engine, which produces hp upto 140 and torque of 170nm, where I live the temperature in summer goes upto 48°C, face a lot of traffic jams and idling, I really floor the pedal sometimes and operate my vehicle at high rpms, manufacturer recommends 5w30 (but it says that you can use a higher viscosity oil depending upon conditions) and I'm currently using fully synthetic 5w30, do you think that I should switch to fully synthetic 5w40 given my driving conditions and style as my car has already done 38000 miles or should I stick to the same 5w30?? Please guide, I'm coming across different opinion and am really confused, the dealership here is suggesting a 5w50 but that's a big no for me.

    • @Yogi231faza
      @Yogi231faza Рік тому

      Spokojnie 5w40...a nawet 50

    • @awaisiqbal8934
      @awaisiqbal8934 Рік тому +2

      @Taha Anwar I would definitely recommend 5w40 to minimize Toyota vvti rattle in summer because it does make a difference with respect to engine noise and film thickness. A part from that, If you do not exceed 3000 RPM quite often / 90 C coolant temperature under load you can opt to use 5w30 unless you hear vvti rattle, hydraulic lifters or timing chain tensioner etc sounds in engine. Don't go for 5w50 it won't serve the purpose because its viscosity is too thick to provide enough lubrication under load and worsen fuel economy also. I am an Engineer by profession and cars enthusiast

    • @Mm.2112
      @Mm.2112 Рік тому +1

      I have the same engine in a 2009 Toyota Corolla I use a 5w40 fully synthetic all year round and I change the oil every 4500 to 5000 km the car currently has done 450,000 km

    • @radiocontrolled9181
      @radiocontrolled9181 10 місяців тому

      ​@@Mm.21125000km is much too early to change the oil. It can easily take 8K or 10K with no problems. In reality fully synthetic oils can take much more than that. But 5000km oil change us waaaayyyy too frequent. Waste of money, time and detrimental to the environment.

  • @mirola73
    @mirola73 Рік тому +4

    Yes...and ?
    We all know 40 is thicker than 30.

  • @clbe26
    @clbe26 Рік тому +3

    I live in 10°c coldest
    39°c hottest
    I use 5w40 is it correct?

  • @DJEvoIX
    @DJEvoIX 4 роки тому +6

    ok, and now what...
    i have e350 cdi om642 DPF
    Benz recommended 229.51 oil its 5w30, but i find some oil with specs 229.51 5w40, i use my car every day ( in winter - 20°C , and summer its 30/40°C ).
    I want 5w40 but i drive more agressively ( for turbo etc i think its better ), but... in winter? Its better to but 5w30 or 5w40?
    I dont want destroy my engine, but 5w30 its not good in high temperature ( my think )... iam like crazy now.. :D

    • @oqhr
      @oqhr 4 роки тому +1

      If you live in a cold area, just keep using 5w30 all the time

    • @charafelectroful
      @charafelectroful 3 роки тому

      0w40 better

    • @s0ulkiller
      @s0ulkiller 3 роки тому

      For diesel 5W30 is OK, I would have doubts about more powerful petrol engines, different story. 5W30 for diesel and in -20*C is OK.

    • @nAN3ftw
      @nAN3ftw 2 роки тому

      Both gradations will perform good. As long as it meets the required mb spec. Keep in mind you have a dpf and you have to meet the 229.51 spec. Using 229.5 will damage the dpf. In your case, consdiering the temperature difference in winter-summer i would recommend using 0w40 oil, if not go for 5w30.

    • @bofor7493
      @bofor7493 2 роки тому

      @@s0ulkiller for -25 Is 0w30 oil better!

  • @dm6877
    @dm6877 Рік тому

    That should be done on 0 c temeperature

  • @ostoja2004
    @ostoja2004 2 роки тому +5

    Nic tu wielkiego nie ma , zrób test w temperaturze +5C a potem sprawdź film smarny przy +100C

  • @EB720S
    @EB720S 4 роки тому +8

    I used 5w40 oil on my car and the recommended oil was 5w30 is this normal or it's bad for the engin????and should I always use 5w30 no matter the condition considering that the temperature can goore than 40° in the summer where I live ????

    • @roysterben863
      @roysterben863 3 роки тому +11

      Since you said the temperature is 40°C in summer where you live, 5W‐40 might be the better choice because the oil is more viscous at high temperature than 5W-30. As long as you didn't go lower than the recommended grade you'll be fine, changing to a higher grade oil won't do damage to the engine but a lower grade than what is recommended will damage the engine

    • @EB720S
      @EB720S 3 роки тому

      @@roysterben863 thanks bro

    • @sanfransoho
      @sanfransoho 3 роки тому +13

      @@EB720S
      The first number refers to to cold condition ambient. Viscosity W - winter cold motor starting ambient condition
      Examples
      SAE 0W−40 °C
      SAE 5W−35 °C
      SAE 10W−30 °C
      SAE 15W−25 °C
      SAE 20W−20 °C
      SAE 25W−15 °C
      The second number is equal important.
      How the oil behave under engine operating temperature, not ambient temperature!!! That's important to understand.
      How does the oil behave in a 100 C temperature ambient. (Viscosity 100 C)
      Examples
      SAE 16 5,6 mm²/s to 6,9 mm²/s
      SAE 20 6,9 mm²/s to 9,3 mm²/s
      SAE 30 9,3 mm²/s to 12,5 mm²/s
      SAE 40 12,5 mm²/s to 16,3 mm²/s
      SAE 50 16,3 mm²/s to 21,9 mm²/s
      SAE 60 21,9 mm²/s and higher
      Depends what your motor need under operating temperature.
      The high ambient temperature are not important.

    • @EB720S
      @EB720S 3 роки тому

      @@sanfransoho thnx bro now i understood

    • @sanfransoho
      @sanfransoho 3 роки тому +3

      @@EB720S
      Note
      You should use the viscosity, api rating... as from manufacturer or engine producer recommended.
      Tiny changes form 5w30 to 5w40 is not per se a problem.
      More important.
      Read your car, truck, tractor handbook. Or the engine operating manual, for further oil instruction.
      you can also look up the oil instructions for special ambient temperature or severe usage of your vehicle / motor.

  • @ahmetakinci9033
    @ahmetakinci9033 Рік тому

    Bu test sadece 5w40 ın 5w30 dan daha az akışkan olduğunu gösteriyor. Ve bunu zatdn biliyoruz.

  • @wija33
    @wija33 4 роки тому +2

    5W30 IS BETTER?

    • @bofor7493
      @bofor7493 2 роки тому +1

      For specification VW 505.01 maybe better 5w40,but I used oil Shell Helix hx7 5w30!

  • @shahinir
    @shahinir 5 років тому +8

    5W30 is better!

    • @TheRealiBl4de
      @TheRealiBl4de 4 роки тому +7

      wrong :D

    • @jibrahil7532
      @jibrahil7532 4 роки тому +1

      For bmw

    • @boggsty
      @boggsty 4 роки тому +2

      jib rahil for bmw it’s worse, especialy for the 6 cylinder engines because it is not as stable as the w40 under heat. That’s also why the piston rod bearings wear prematurely

    • @bofor7493
      @bofor7493 2 роки тому +1

      For specification VW 504/507.00 not exist oil 5w40!
      Only 5w30 and 0w30!
      Ende!

    • @user-ch9cx1mb9n
      @user-ch9cx1mb9n Рік тому

      На тёплом и гоячем моторе отличне масло. Если не подделка. Я про масло 5-40 роботает даже -45 мотор не стродет и в летню жару. А 5-30. ЖИТКОЕ . Сам с севера

  • @user-rt6lp7rc3j
    @user-rt6lp7rc3j 9 місяців тому

    手、邪魔。

  • @maximo-imp
    @maximo-imp 10 місяців тому

    Do the same but at 80 degrees Celsius...