Constantius .Constantius 1. just communicate and get by really but they all speak Spanish or at least understand it for the most part so I don't think there would be any problem even for conversation. if you do run into an older person you'll still be able to converse but slowly. 2.Mexicans and Puerto Ricans can definitely understand spanish in spain unless they are uneducated and speak with a really thick accent.
goodfella21f My friend's wife is Mexican. She was born there and moved to the US when she was five. Her parents never learned English so she always spoke Spanish at home but didn't know much outside of the home setting. She went to Spain on vacation for a couple weeks and had a very hard time understanding people especially outside of the major cities.
Im from Chile, I moved to the US when I was 8. There, i knew Puerto ricans, mexicans, colombians, peruvians, ecuatorians, argentinians, etc etc.. And i understood them perfectly... but when I returned to Chile, after 10 years, i realized we speak like shit ! We speak fast, we dont pronounce the last words, we swear alot and we use TOO MUCH SLANG (only understandable in chile) ... so yeah, i get your point.
Catalan league: First Round: FC Barcelona - Espanyol, Second Round: FC Barcelona - Espanyol Third Round: FC Barcelona - Espanyol Fourth Round .........
FC Andorra are an Andorran club, but continue to take part in the Spanish league system. Currently in the Primera Catalana, (the regional Catalan division in the fifth level of the Spanish football league system) FC Andorra are permitted to play outside of their own country’s national football league because they are registered with the RFEF (since 1948).
M'encanta la llengua catalana. Estic feliç de parlar-ho tots els dies, encara que molt lentament, però el català és realment en el meu cor. Sóc québécois i estimo a Catalunya.
Pathetic to see muslims being dragged into poisonous nationalism, ethnicity, race bullshits. There are only two kind of people in broader terms, Muslim and Kafir. And amongst Muslim, there are Practising and non-practising Muslims.
Lol. That's not even a comparison. Catalans are not a different race. They are Spanish, if they like it or not. These indepence movements in Spain are sponsored by Soros and the Anglosax elites. Their worst nightmare is for the entire Hispanic countries to reunite. If all Latin American countries and Spain reunite, they become the world power they once were. That's why they sponsor these movements. Guardiola is just a brainwashed tool. Luckily the Spanish are becoming smarter. Both in the Basque country as in Catalunya they celebrated the Spanish Eurocup victory like never before. And the same is happening in the South American countries. They supported Spain, wore Spanish shirts and celebrated the victory. Last week a representative of Puerto Rico went to the United nations to demand for Puerto Rico to become part of Spain again.
sure, we have a total different cultural and linguistic meaning from the spanish one, that's why a lot of us fon't feel identified with spanish culture. Our culture is nothing about "flamecno", sevillanas or bull fighting for example. We have a lot of history so different from spain. For example we have sardanas, castellers, modernism (Gaudí), totaly different expresions and way of thinking... we're just different. I wish I could express this better but my english level is so limited.
Spain is a CRIMINAL TERRORIST state - Spain is NOT sustainable - Spain can only continue to exist with laws imposed by CRIMINAL TERRORIST Franco to hide the truth about the Spanish HOLOCAUST against Catalonia. Open a full disclosure and investigation about the Castilian TERRORIST CRIMINAL chiringuito and Spain will disappear. Castilians are the only that suport Serbians. Tell the truth about your Castilian Criminal Terrorist Spain and Europe will impose Holocaust reparations for all Catalan families destroyed by 80 years of Castilian fascist repression still going on today. NOBODY stands with CRIMINAL TERRORIST Spain
@@joanberenguer4410 Spain is a CRIMINAL TERRORIST state - Spain is NOT sustainable - Spain can only continue to exist with laws imposed by CRIMINAL TERRORIST Franco to hide the truth about the Spanish HOLOCAUST against Catalonia. Open a full disclosure and investigation about the Castilian TERRORIST CRIMINAL chiringuito and Spain will disappear. Castilians are the only that suport Serbians. Tell the truth about your Castilian Criminal Terrorist Spain and Europe will impose Holocaust reparations for all Catalan families destroyed by 80 years of Castilian fascist repression still going on today. NOBODY stands with CRIMINAL TERRORIST Spain
As a Kurd, I know exactly how he feels! No matter the effort at assimilation, forced integration or even ethnic cleansing. YOU are what you are! And be bloody proud of it!
Bro I'm kurd as well and I know exactly how it feels like i have to be grateful that I was born in the independent iraqi Kurdistan region. Where we had freedom and our own political leaders and parliament where I was able to express my nationality and to speak Kurdish with absolutely no controversy and consequences and where I had my all education in Kurdish. I wish one day the rest of the Kurdish children in Iran, Turkey Syria will have the same childhood as I had.
@@shianzekri7629 You definitely have been lucky, though really it should be nothing more than a birthright to live and be free. I was born in Kirkuk, spent most of my childhood in Slemani and then 2-3 years in Hawler where my parents worked as surgeons. In the late 80's, we were forced to sing the Iraqi national anthem in school, weren't really allowed to say anything remotely pro Kurdish, weren't allowed to be taught in Kurdish and then of course we had the horrible experience of having to escape to the border in the middle of the night during the uprising. We were lucky in that we had cars and lorries and food but we had to literally live by the side of the road for weeks upon weeks before being able to return to slemani. Even in that difficult time, the Iranians were horrible. A girl was shot by an Iranian soldier as she tried to climb the lorry for bread handouts, and one of our neighbour's sons died after being mauled by a bear whilst he was out collecting wood to keep us warm. We have certainly come a long way.
Anayasamızın 3. maddesi: TÜRKİYE Devleti, ülkesi ve milliyetiyle BÖLÜNEMEZ bir bütündür. Dili türkçedir. Beğenmeyen arap yarım adasına cehennem olup gidebilir. Catalanlar ülkesine yararlı, okumuş ve zeki insanlar. Siz kürtler gibi ülkenin dört bir yanında terör estirip, töre adı altında kadınları öldürüp, hor görmüyorlar. Her yıl bağlı oldukları ülkenin askerlerini şehit etmiyorlar. Ülkenin güzel her şeyini kullanıp vergi kaçırmıyorlar, kızları taciz ve tecavüz vakalarının en çok görüldüğü yer de catalanların yaşadığı yer değil ama siz kürtlerin yaşadığı yer. 20 tane çocuk doğurup ülkenin ekonomisine işsiz bireyler katmıyorlar. Cumhuriyetimizin 100. Yılında dilediğin şeylere dikkat et. Sen şuan bu ülkede barınabiliyorsan Ulu Önder Mustafa Kemal Atatürk sayesinde yaşıyorsun, barınıyorsun.
I remember my ex girlfriend from BCN saying that Catalonia is not Spain, and after winning a football match against Germany, she was yelling "Espanyaaa!" (or was it even "Españaaa!"?)... Catalonia is maybe a bit parsimonious and I wonder whether they wanted to be independent too if they were not the richest but the poorest region in Spain. Don't get me wrong, I love Catalonia a lot and I do respect Pep Guardiola, but some things appear like total hypocrisy to me. Moreover, as a German with historical awareness, I am saying with utter conviction that any kind of hyper-nationalism is no good at all. Everyone can keep their identity, their customs and also their language, but do we really need new nations while trying to get rid of borders? Visca el Barça!
Face it, Catalonia has been part of Spain for so long now, you're spanish. Tell me, in concrete example, how does your culture differ so much from Spanish culture? That's an argument I heard so often in Quebec from separatists (culture) yet you couldn't tell an average Canadian and average French Canadian apart if they don't say a word. Dress the same, listen to the same type of music, bitch about the same issues.. So on and so forth.
Firstly , the Generalitat owes Spain 1.890 million Euros it has lent it to support its expenditures. 60 % of its exports are to Spain, and the rest to the EU. Catalonia has Splain as its craddle but it s a piece of shit hole without Spain
Dave Kent exactly, i grimaced when i read that. the idea of eroding borders as though humans are a theoretical idea that can be solved through simple measures, overlooking our innate complexities. ridiculous.
No es una simple cuestión de lenguas: las identidades nacionales se construyen a partir de ciertas particularidades culturales, las que sean, y si no fíjate en Irlanda: la práctica totalidad de los irlandeses tienen como lengua materna el inglés pero no por ello dejan de sentirse irlandeses (en su caso la singularidad cultural con la que se identifican como país es la religión ya que más del 90% de los irlandeses son católicos en contraste con los ingleses, de amplia mayoría protestante).
Los irlandeses en efecto son celtas y católicos frente a los anglosajones protestantes. Fueron explotados y masacrados por ingleses. NO tiene nada que ver con la historia de catalanes y el resto de españoles, que es una historia en común y en colaboración, salvo momentos puntuales (1640; Guerra de Sucesión) desde Hispania Tarraconensis y todos los siglos de la Reconquista. Y que no nombren el 36 porque había catalanes en ambos bandos como en el resto, y Madrid cayó después que Barcelona y sufrió igual de represión.
@@Josep_Hernandez_Lujan que "una llengua una nació" és més fals que una moneda de tres euros Una llengua pot tenir moltes nacions, una nació pot tenir moltes llengües
Danke Pep, für all deine Leidenschaft die du auch in München gezeigt hast, so kennen dich alle. Ich wünsche dass auch dieser Traum eines Tages in erfüllung gehen kann. Deine Heimat Katalonien ist wunderschön und Barcelona ist für mich die schönste Stadt Europas!
I am writing an assignment about Catalonias fight for independence, and would like to use a couple of quotes from this Guardiola interview. Do you remember which TV-station conducted the second interview (Guardiolo in red shirt) and perhaps what year it was? Thank you in advance
Another option would be to have our own federation, as is the case of Andorra, which has the Football Federation of Andorra. Therefore, Andorra has a football League and the team that wins it can represent the country at the European Cup. But it has a club called “Futbol Club Andorra” which plays in the Catalan League despite being a national team. If it were better it could even play in the “Copa del Rey”.
And Catalonia wouldn´t have risen those catalonian players without the spanish La Liga. If my grandma were green and flat she wouldn´t be my grandma, but a crocodile... Please, grow up.
Das stimmt. Ohne Bayern und Baden Württemberg, Deutschland würde nicht so reich sein. Aber ich muss sagen, Bayrisch und Schwäbisch verstehe ich überhaupt nicht lol.
MENTIRA. De 23 jugadores que fueron al Mundial, sólo 7 eran catalanes (Puyol, Piqué, Busquets, Fábregas, Capdevila, Víctor Valdés y Xavi), de los cuales sólo 5 eran titulares (Puyol, Piqué, Busquets, Capdevila y Xavi), y de esos 5 sólo 4 eran del Barça (los que hemos dicho menos Capdevila). Por lo tanto de 11 jugadores que salen al campo 6 eran no catalanes. Los jugadores más importantes de la Selección española en ese Mundial fueron Villa, Casillas y Xavi: Villa por los goles (que fueron casi todos suyos), Casillas por las paradas en momentos clave (penalti a Paraguay en Cuartos, dos mano a mano con Robben en la Final...) y Xavi por ser el cerebro de cada jugada de ataque. Mención aparte para Iniesta y Puyol, que fueron muy importantes en momentos delicados. En ese momento el Barcelona estaba en auge y era el mejor equipo de Europa, sin duda. Pero decir que España ganó el Mundial gracias al Barcelona o gracias a los jugadores catalanes es ser muy ignorante. Los mismos jugadores catalanes o del Barsa lo han dicho más de una vez: esa generación fue un cúmulo de muchas cosas, no de una sóla.
En mexico se hablan 67 lenguas autoctonas, pero no por eso existen igual numero de paises,talvez la cultura catalana sea unica pero son españa y no significa q sean basallos. Segun e leido españa esta constituida como nacion de nacionalidades. K pasaria si en lugar del castellano fuese el catalan mas hablado, pe.sarian lo mismo
@@gianmedley Pues el mexicano con faltas de ortografía ha hecho una observación acertada, déjese usted la soberbia porque él tiene razón y México se lo muestra. Una lengua no significa una nación, una nación no significa una única lengua.
Sure, I'm not disagreeing with you in any way, but I still previously posted line-up overclasses any other line-up in the world. The only weak link in that team is Arbeloa and perhaps not enough balance on the midfield due to two attacking midfielders.
I respect Pep's feelings. I lived in Barcelona for three years and I speak Catalan. However, we should be thinking of uniting and cooperating, and not just among the various nationalities in Spain, but even accross continents, everywhere. The future is union, not separation. Respecto els sentiments d'en Pep. Vaig viure tres anys a Barcelona i parlo català. Però crec que hauríem de pensar en unir-nos i cooperar, i no només entre les diversas nacionalitats d'Espanya, sinó fins i tot entre continents, i arreu del món. El futur és unió, no separació. Respeto los sentimientos de Pep. Viví en Barcelona durante tres años y hablo catalán. Pero creo que deberíamos pensar en unirnos y cooperar, y no solo entre las diferentes nacionalidades de España, sino también entre continentes y todo el mundo. El futuro es unión, no separación.
Partially you're right. Before 2010 the separatist option never exceeded the 35% of catalan population but the economic crisis is NOT the only reason. It's more a combination of ofensive decisions of various spanish institutions, including the Government and the Constitional Court, to the legitims reclaims of the catalan institutions with the support of the majority of catalan citizens.
Lies. Mass boycott ensued in the 2017 vote. Of those who did (43%), 2,044,038 (90.18%) voted for separation and 177,547 (7.83%) voted against. Separatists won 90% on a 43% Turnout. About 39%. 5️⃣7️⃣% BOYCOTTED.
Serbia, Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina and Montenegro we just have different religion. Serbs are Orthodox, Croats are Catholics, Bosniaks are Muslims, Montenegrins are Orthodox like Serbs becaus they are Serbs. Serbian tribe. But language is the same!!! 99,99% words is same. But each nations calls the language by itself: Serbian, Croatian, Bosnian, Montenegrin language. It is the craziest in Bosnia. Bosniaks (muslims) the language called BOSNIAN (like Bosnia). But in Bosnia lives and Serbs and Croats and he speak Serbian and Croatian. I’m Bosnian Serbs and i speak Serbian language not Bosnian. Slovenian and Macedonian have some difrent dialect. Crazy House!!! 😂 Yugoslavia.
For example, Barcelona Football Club may ask the English Premier to play there. Then we’d have to see what the English League thought of that, but as a club we can certainly do it. In fact, we could do this today. The important thing is that we, the members, have it clear in our minds what we actually want; it’s up to us to decide where we would like to play. The ultimate objective is to be able to decide and I’m convinced that we will decide.
Catalonia is Spain, it has always been Spain. If you do not like your own country, go to Quatar, where you love it, with so many liberties and equalty. Liar.
What has quatar got to do with spain/catalonia ? you can't force people to embrace any sort of identity , they're free in their choices , the irony is that you talk about freedom whilst not allowing people to have any freedom in their choices
Amazing football coach. A nefarious public figure. A model of how decades-long social engineering in Spain can polarize in such a crazy way. In that respect a guinea pig, the poor like many others
The RFEF’s current rules state that, in order to compete in Spain, “a team must be affiliated to the RFEF and integrated into it, other than the Federation of Autonomous Communities that are members.” In other words, if Catalonia leaves the RFEF, the Catalan teams will be excluded from any national competition.
if catalonia does become independant, would barcelona leave the spanish league? and would many catalona born players, have to stop playing for spain? how will it work
. Cultura australiana és generalment una barreja de cultures angleses i europees i és molt similar a tot el país. Som molt afortunats a Austràlia per tenir una economia forta i un baix atur, però la meva ciutat natal, Perth és una de les ciutats més cares del món per viure! Tinc la intenció de traslladar-se a Catalunya o València quan em retiri com puc viure còmodament allà al meu ingrés Pension australiana gaudir de la vida en el seu bell país.
@@viewit9833 no he dicho que no sea un idioma pero lo que no es es un idioma suyo propio con copyright como te quieren hacer creer. Es un idioma que se habla en muchas partes.
Ceuta y Melilla ya eran plazas españolas hace 500 años, mucho antes de que Marruecos estuviera constituido; si no te agrada la integridad nacional del país que estás habitando amigo, eres libre de irte al maravilloso estado marroquí, con vuestro maravilloso rey, que vive en Francia por algún motivo.
We should not forget that Guardiola has personal interests in this: his sister has had as a first job an 80k role as a general director of Foreign Affairs (relaciones exteriores) in the Puigdemont governement (year 2015). She's now an "ambassador" of CT in Denmark. We do not know how much does she perceives, as the CT government does not clarify how much these "ambassadors" earn. The only thing we know is that the department she works with spends 1,6M to pay 19 people like her...
Imagine the Spanish national team without Xavi, Busquets, Alba, Piqué and Fabregas. The end of an era. There would be no more trophies for the RFEF, if the Spaniards suddenly had to assemble a creative midfield of their own.
Els Catalans sempre diuen "Tenim la nostra propia llengua!" Any Spanish person can understand this sentence so it's not really a separate language like Welsh is from English, for example.
Hello professor, Catalan is a Western Romance language derived from Vulgar Latin and named after the medieval Principality of Catalonia... You're welcome.
DocStrange0123 it still sounds like Spanish. I'm not even spanish nor a native speaker of it but I would say I understand at least 70% of said Catalan. Catalans look like spaniards, speak like spaniards and for me as a foreigner they are just Spanish special snowflakes wanna be. I might be wrong but they aren't that different from other autonomous communities of Spain who also have their own specific culture and language like the Basque Country for example, but still are rather distinctly, of Spanish and Iberian culture.
You're a Catalan, from Spain! Just like every other Catalan is also from Spain! Just like the Basque and the Valencianos and the Madristas! Look at your passport!
i understand Pep and his feelings for Catalonia.but what bothers me the most,why did he ever play for Spain at the first place since he clearly does not want to represent it and feels that is not his country?
there are accusations by team mates that he only played for spain for the money but i doubt thats the reason. alot of footballers tend to play for a nation and to have their names recognised nationally
Because he's a money-hungry machoman perhaps? He could be North African more like and always very secretive about his private life mmm mmm imagine all the fun in the changing rooms . . .
Where would Barcelona football club play if Catalonia became an independent State? I think wherever it wished. Obviously, Catalonia would need to have its own League as federations make it compulsory, so a state structure for sports would have to be created. However, Barcelona Football Club, as a private club can theoretically play wherever it wants to.
Make no mistake: We don't have, for example, own Treasury and it's a great chain in our relation with Spain. Because without own Treasury we can't measure own government spending and we can't have catalan government budgets adequate to our needs as Spain invests more than 40% of catalan revenues outside Catalonia... It's a nonsense.
But this could affect the income of the club... Obviously, already today, what brings in the money is the European Cup, and we expect that Barcelona will play in the competition. Cause-effect scenarios will take place, but they will quickly be readdressed. At the moment, we must understand sport as a matter of state; therefore, it will be solved as a matter of state.
Pero si tu as sido un poco mas gracias a haber jugado en la seleccion...si no hubieses sido uno mas de tantos jugadores que con el tiempo se olvidan....SI TAN INDEPENDENTISTA ERES PORQUE AS JUGADO EN LA SELECCION.......
Oh really? Catalonia isn't Spain then why you play for Spain You could just refuse to play International football like Paul Scholes (2007-10 ) Totally BS
I would guess that Barcelona will still be in La Liga. Maybe similar to AS Monaco, where they are not part of France, but play in the French league. As to the national team, I would say the Catalan players are going to want to play for Catalunya rather than Spain.
Arent catalán people the same tribal/ethnicity as the spaniards ? isn't there Names and language truly the same? or are they different people group that have been assimilated?
Tribaly, the same ethnicity as in all east and south Spain: Iberians. That's going to prerroman times. But not going so far in time, there is only on ethnicity in the whole iberian peninsula. If you study History of Spain, you will see that Catalans were not assimilated, but an integral part of the foundation of the nowadays' Spain (the Casal Reial d'Aragó, and de Barcelona, the Crown of Aragon, the Hispanic Monarchy through the dynastic union of Castile and Aragon, etc...) In the iberian Christian kingdoms there was a long project of reunification after the muslim conquest (with conflicts in between among different Christian kingdoms, of course) in which Catalonia played a fundamental role. I mean, there is a reason why there were so extremely long celebrations in Barcelona (ten whole days with their nights) on the occasion of the conquest of Granada. You can check the Dietaris de la Generalitat de Catalunya if you want to see It by yourself. And that was that the so long desired unity of the Iberian Peninsula had being recovered (later came the conquest of Navarra by both Castile and Aragon, and remember that Catalonia was a part of the Crown of Aragon, also Portugal was expected to unite with the rest of Crowns and Kingdoms through marriage politics). So Catalonia was not assimilated, but played one of the protagonist roles in the formation and unification of Spain.
@@DavidNilo-ss8gq i really much appreciate this comment you made for me brother, One more quesiton if you don't mind? are you implying that the portuguese people and the spainiards are the same ethnic group/tribal from back in the day aswell?
@@endritbajrami8795 I would say they are the same ethnic group, yes, and in fact Portugal indeed formed also part of the Hispanic Monarchy. But they also had their own nobility and rulers (and even in a same ethnicity politics also play a big role), that's why they are no longer in a union with the rest of Iberian Peninsula (remember that we speak of a time when families and the power of families, nobility in this case, was more important than ethnicities and nations). With Catalonia is not the same, cause the King of Spain (short way of stating all his titles associeted to Spain) IS the Count of Barcelona as he descends by legitimate succesion from the old Counts of Barcelona of the Casal de Barcelona of the deep middle ages when not even Aragon and the Catalan Counties had yet made an union. But all I said as our common past is a reason why we both Spaniards and Portuguese feel ourselves as brothers.
‘Every Peoples and Nation has the right to manage themselves even prior to the application of any fundamental Human right’ 607-A(VII) UN’s Resolution Pep Guardiola is right! FREEDOM FOR CATALONIA
I don’t think its fair for nations who have fought to defend their borders for centuries i.e.: Scottish, Welsh, and English to be compared to a region of Spain. (as the Catalans tend to do).
Even more unfair is to compare Catalonia to the Irish, which are indeed a nation and were oppressed (and almost starved to death) by England for centuries, while Catolonia is not a nation, but a spanish nationality, the second richest part of Spain and one of the most developed alongside Madrid and the Basque Lands
but language isn't the only condition for our nationhood, we've got a totally different culture, values, expresions... a history as a country so different from the rest of spain.
I don't despise you for Catalonia I think it's good that what makes Spain amazing too many people. Im galician and i know galicia and Spain has different parts about each other (like Cata) but it what makes Spain. I know you Catalans don't want this and that but I just think it's funny. I love all parts of Spain really and right now we all need to work together for a better place. I know that some spanish people said bad things about Catalonia but really just Ignore it it's just bullcrap.
Espania once controlled Portugal too but it was always Portugal. Catalonia is its own country and one day will be free again. Now for u imbecile go read a history book to educate your simple self.
Trying to relieve the explanation of littlegirljuststoned catalans have a way of thinking and make thinks more european than the rest of Spain. Our character isn't tipically Mediterranean, it's more north-central-european and this is reflected, for example, at work, in the way we do bussiness, in the way that people relate, etc...
One's entitlement to a sense of political sovereignty is based purely on cultural unity and relative alienation, not on how much blood has been spilled in the name of the country. That is the kind of tripe falange spouted off earlier in the 1900s. Catalonia is a unique sense of identity vis a vis their language, political ideology, and customs, and, as such, should very much be considered as having its own nationality and, by extension, something of an autonomous polity.
Em vaig sentir molt benvingut quan jo hi era. Tots els que visiten Catalunya sembla caure en amor amb ell pel que ha d'estar fent alguna cosa bé :) All the best to you and your family and friends. Viva Catalunya!
Querido Guardiola, si no eres español por qué sigues hablando en castellano? Dado que es tu lengua, habla catalán y deja el español a los "verdaderos" españoles.
a lo mejor la entrevista era en español? *Zi ERES EZPANIOl XQ AVLAS INGLES JAJAJAJA SOI LISTO* Bueno,seguramente no sepas ni inglés,pero Olé por ti campeón
Ese discursito de Español=España y todo lo demás sobra es una tontería. España es un país con más de una lengua, y cuál es el problema? Porque no aceptarlo, asumirlo y usarlo como una arma de publicidad más? Es que los españolistas tan duritos sois una ruína con el tema indepe, Intentemos mejorar el tema y las relaciones en vez de tanta discusión tonta.
multiple countries speak multiple languages... in canada half the country speaks english and the other half speak french... its still one country... what will catalans gain from independence? they are already free
Crec que viure al costat del mar prop de Barcelona seria el millor. Probablement vaig a viatjar per tot Europa i el Regne Unit una mica. Tinc moltes ganes de veure molt més de Catalunya i Espanya quan torni en uns dos anys. Fins ara no he vist molt de Barcelona, el museu Dalí a Figueres, la casa de Dalí a Port Lligat, i Cadacqes. La proximitat de Catalunya amb la frontera francesa és un avantatge ja que el sud de França és tan bonic.
but it is the truth. I do not feel Spanish. You should not take offence on that. I feel fine with other people feeling Spanish and I have many Spanish friends. But I feel Catalan. We have to respect each other
+tomiwa jobi Galicia también. Y el País Vasco. Y Baleares. Y Valencia. Y qué? España es una nación muy rica en cultura, siempre ha sido así y siempre lo será.
+lombingo +lombingo valencia no quiere independencia de España. ellos son gente que vienen de ascendencia catalana pero ellos son orgulloso de ser españoles
Gràcies pel teu suport i pel teu interès per Catalunya, la seva llengua i cultura. Parles molt bé el Català! :) Benvingut sempre que vulguis venir a Catalunya. A Austràlia Occidental també hi ha gent que vol la independència? Teniu diferències culturals o lingüístiques amb la resta d'Austràlia? Perdona si em faig pesat però és molt interessant i no conec gaire la situació. Salut
I think Catalunya has everything pretty well, i mean there are other countries with worse problems.. Catalunya has just been lucky to have succesfull athletes(football players for all i know) and they speak their own language.. and sure differences in culture and stye but thats normal i mean in Andalucia people are totally different than Madrid but they dont want to be other country? I think Catalunyan people just think they're somehow "too good" for Spain and thats just pathetic!
Ojalá algún año estos catalanes tengan lo que quieren lo que ocurre es que su mayor problema lo tienen en su propio pais cataluña ya que no todo el mundo quiere esa independencia que otros añoran tanto. En cualquier caso sería estupendo que el barça solo compitiera en su liga catalana o quizás para esto si que se encuentran a gusto.
I speak Spanish and this is easier for me to understand than Chilean Spanish.
Constantius .Constantius 1. just communicate and get by really but they all speak Spanish or at least understand it for the most part so I don't think there would be any problem even for conversation. if you do run into an older person you'll still be able to converse but slowly.
2.Mexicans and Puerto Ricans can definitely understand spanish in spain unless they are uneducated and speak with a really thick accent.
goodfella21f
My friend's wife is Mexican. She was born there and moved to the US when she was five. Her parents never learned English so she always spoke Spanish at home but didn't know much outside of the home setting. She went to Spain on vacation for a couple weeks and had a very hard time understanding people especially outside of the major cities.
Constantius .Constantius
She was in a few different places. I think she was fin in Madrid but had a hard time in more rural areas.
BigSirZebras Becuase castilian spanish was the only language who was spoken by the spaniard invaders in america.
Im from Chile, I moved to the US when I was 8. There, i knew Puerto ricans, mexicans, colombians, peruvians, ecuatorians, argentinians, etc etc.. And i understood them perfectly... but when I returned to Chile, after 10 years, i realized we speak like shit ! We speak fast, we dont pronounce the last words, we swear alot and we use TOO MUCH SLANG (only understandable in chile) ... so yeah, i get your point.
One can't betray what he feels
loves*
Special one could…
Occasionally…
Pep had hair wow
He looked different
Catalan league: First Round: FC Barcelona - Espanyol, Second Round: FC Barcelona - Espanyol Third Round: FC Barcelona - Espanyol Fourth Round .........
Girona , Barcelona, espanyol , levante
@@UmarKhanlodhi-jc9qz levante is valencia
@@basti6643 sorry my bad I got confused in the flag Catalan and Valencian flag
@@UmarKhanlodhi-jc9qz Paisos catalans is valencia too and islas baleares
FC Andorra are an Andorran club, but continue to take part in the Spanish league system. Currently in the Primera Catalana, (the regional Catalan division in the fifth level of the Spanish football league system) FC Andorra are permitted to play outside of their own country’s national football league because they are registered with the RFEF (since 1948).
M'encanta la llengua catalana. Estic feliç de parlar-ho tots els dies, encara que molt lentament, però el català és realment en el meu cor. Sóc québécois i estimo a Catalunya.
A mira un español como yo
Barcelona into europa league 🤣🤣
@@AK_AVFC la teva mare xucla la polla anglesa
Que vergüenza das
As a Kurd I support Barcelona and Catalonia, the feeling is terrible not having a country, vista Barca vista catalunya!
Pathetic to see muslims being dragged into poisonous nationalism, ethnicity, race bullshits. There are only two kind of people in broader terms, Muslim and Kafir. And amongst Muslim, there are Practising and non-practising Muslims.
@@asfiraihan2073kurds are nearly 40 millions like any other nations they deserve a country
Lol. That's not even a comparison. Catalans are not a different race. They are Spanish, if they like it or not. These indepence movements in Spain are sponsored by Soros and the Anglosax elites. Their worst nightmare is for the entire Hispanic countries to reunite. If all Latin American countries and Spain reunite, they become the world power they once were. That's why they sponsor these movements. Guardiola is just a brainwashed tool. Luckily the Spanish are becoming smarter. Both in the Basque country as in Catalunya they celebrated the Spanish Eurocup victory like never before. And the same is happening in the South American countries. They supported Spain, wore Spanish shirts and celebrated the victory. Last week a representative of Puerto Rico went to the United nations to demand for Puerto Rico to become part of Spain again.
@@Rawenhappy The difference IS that they are already living in they Country they also founded and constructed: Spain
sure, we have a total different cultural and linguistic meaning from the spanish one, that's why a lot of us fon't feel identified with spanish culture. Our culture is nothing about "flamecno", sevillanas or bull fighting for example. We have a lot of history so different from spain. For example we have sardanas, castellers, modernism (Gaudí), totaly different expresions and way of thinking... we're just different. I wish I could express this better but my english level is so limited.
Modernismo existe en todo lados. Gili
@@infolibertad_1 pq insultas
So Spanish language originate fron where?
Spain is a CRIMINAL TERRORIST state - Spain is NOT sustainable - Spain can only continue to exist with laws imposed by CRIMINAL TERRORIST Franco to hide the truth about the Spanish HOLOCAUST against Catalonia. Open a full disclosure and investigation about the Castilian TERRORIST CRIMINAL chiringuito and Spain will disappear. Castilians are the only that suport Serbians. Tell the truth about your Castilian Criminal Terrorist Spain and Europe will impose Holocaust reparations for all Catalan families destroyed by 80 years of Castilian fascist repression still going on today. NOBODY stands with CRIMINAL TERRORIST Spain
@@joanberenguer4410 Spain is a CRIMINAL TERRORIST state - Spain is NOT sustainable - Spain can only continue to exist with laws imposed by CRIMINAL TERRORIST Franco to hide the truth about the Spanish HOLOCAUST against Catalonia. Open a full disclosure and investigation about the Castilian TERRORIST CRIMINAL chiringuito and Spain will disappear. Castilians are the only that suport Serbians. Tell the truth about your Castilian Criminal Terrorist Spain and Europe will impose Holocaust reparations for all Catalan families destroyed by 80 years of Castilian fascist repression still going on today. NOBODY stands with CRIMINAL TERRORIST Spain
As a Kurd, I know exactly how he feels! No matter the effort at assimilation, forced integration or even ethnic cleansing. YOU are what you are! And be bloody proud of it!
Bro I'm kurd as well and I know exactly how it feels like i have to be grateful that I was born in the independent iraqi Kurdistan region. Where we had freedom and our own political leaders and parliament where I was able to express my nationality and to speak Kurdish with absolutely no controversy and consequences and where I had my all education in Kurdish. I wish one day the rest of the Kurdish children in Iran, Turkey Syria will have the same childhood as I had.
@@shianzekri7629 You definitely have been lucky, though really it should be nothing more than a birthright to live and be free.
I was born in Kirkuk, spent most of my childhood in Slemani and then 2-3 years in Hawler where my parents worked as surgeons. In the late 80's, we were forced to sing the Iraqi national anthem in school, weren't really allowed to say anything remotely pro Kurdish, weren't allowed to be taught in Kurdish and then of course we had the horrible experience of having to escape to the border in the middle of the night during the uprising. We were lucky in that we had cars and lorries and food but we had to literally live by the side of the road for weeks upon weeks before being able to return to slemani. Even in that difficult time, the Iranians were horrible. A girl was shot by an Iranian soldier as she tried to climb the lorry for bread handouts, and one of our neighbour's sons died after being mauled by a bear whilst he was out collecting wood to keep us warm. We have certainly come a long way.
@@shianzekri7629 I am a Kurd living in Turkey and I don't want to live with Middle Easterners. We are a whole as the Republic of Turkey. 🇹🇷
Anayasamızın 3. maddesi: TÜRKİYE Devleti, ülkesi ve milliyetiyle BÖLÜNEMEZ bir bütündür. Dili türkçedir. Beğenmeyen arap yarım adasına cehennem olup gidebilir. Catalanlar ülkesine yararlı, okumuş ve zeki insanlar. Siz kürtler gibi ülkenin dört bir yanında terör estirip, töre adı altında kadınları öldürüp, hor görmüyorlar. Her yıl bağlı oldukları ülkenin askerlerini şehit etmiyorlar. Ülkenin güzel her şeyini kullanıp vergi kaçırmıyorlar, kızları taciz ve tecavüz vakalarının en çok görüldüğü yer de catalanların yaşadığı yer değil ama siz kürtlerin yaşadığı yer. 20 tane çocuk doğurup ülkenin ekonomisine işsiz bireyler katmıyorlar. Cumhuriyetimizin 100. Yılında dilediğin şeylere dikkat et. Sen şuan bu ülkede barınabiliyorsan Ulu Önder Mustafa Kemal Atatürk sayesinde yaşıyorsun, barınıyorsun.
Shut up K.rd
Hi there! I need help translating a letter from English into Catalan.
Can someone help me? I don't trust Google Translate... thank you!
I could try
Google translator work very well
I remember my ex girlfriend from BCN saying that Catalonia is not Spain, and after winning a football match against Germany, she was yelling "Espanyaaa!" (or was it even "Españaaa!"?)...
Catalonia is maybe a bit parsimonious and I wonder whether they wanted to be independent too if they were not the richest but the poorest region in Spain.
Don't get me wrong, I love Catalonia a lot and I do respect Pep Guardiola, but some things appear like total hypocrisy to me.
Moreover, as a German with historical awareness, I am saying with utter conviction that any kind of hyper-nationalism is no good at all. Everyone can keep their identity, their customs and also their language, but do we really need new nations while trying to get rid of borders?
Visca el Barça!
maybe you're trying to get rid of borders
how's your country working out for you, historically aware German?
Face it, Catalonia has been part of Spain for so long now, you're spanish. Tell me, in concrete example, how does your culture differ so much from Spanish culture? That's an argument I heard so often in Quebec from separatists (culture) yet you couldn't tell an average Canadian and average French Canadian apart if they don't say a word. Dress the same, listen to the same type of music, bitch about the same issues.. So on and so forth.
Almogàver there was no catalonia and never will only spain will stay!
Firstly , the Generalitat owes Spain 1.890 million Euros it has lent it to support its expenditures. 60 % of its exports are to Spain, and the rest to the EU. Catalonia has Splain as its craddle but it s a piece of shit hole without Spain
Dave Kent exactly, i grimaced when i read that. the idea of eroding borders as though humans are a theoretical idea that can be solved through simple measures, overlooking our innate complexities. ridiculous.
No es una simple cuestión de lenguas: las identidades nacionales se construyen a partir de ciertas particularidades culturales, las que sean, y si no fíjate en Irlanda: la práctica totalidad de los irlandeses tienen como lengua materna el inglés pero no por ello dejan de sentirse irlandeses (en su caso la singularidad cultural con la que se identifican como país es la religión ya que más del 90% de los irlandeses son católicos en contraste con los ingleses, de amplia mayoría protestante).
I què?
Los irlandeses en efecto son celtas y católicos frente a los anglosajones protestantes. Fueron explotados y masacrados por ingleses. NO tiene nada que ver con la historia de catalanes y el resto de españoles, que es una historia en común y en colaboración, salvo momentos puntuales (1640; Guerra de Sucesión) desde Hispania Tarraconensis y todos los siglos de la Reconquista. Y que no nombren el 36 porque había catalanes en ambos bandos como en el resto, y Madrid cayó después que Barcelona y sufrió igual de represión.
@@Josep_Hernandez_Lujan que "una llengua una nació" és més fals que una moneda de tres euros
Una llengua pot tenir moltes nacions, una nació pot tenir moltes llengües
This man was positive
Danke Pep, für all deine Leidenschaft die du auch in München gezeigt hast, so kennen dich alle. Ich wünsche dass auch dieser Traum eines Tages in erfüllung gehen kann. Deine Heimat Katalonien ist wunderschön und Barcelona ist für mich die schönste Stadt Europas!
España es su pais, España descubridora del mundo
Ich freue mich sehr, das zu lesen, vielen Dank aus Katalonien!
M'alegra molt llegir això, moltes gràcies des de Catalunya!
da stimme ich dir zu, Barca ist wirklich die schönste Stadt in Europa
Thank you , you are always welcome to visit
Gràcies, PEP!!!
I am writing an assignment about Catalonias fight for independence, and would like to use a couple of quotes from this Guardiola interview. Do you remember which TV-station conducted the second interview (Guardiolo in red shirt) and perhaps what year it was?
Thank you in advance
Que viva españa
@@robertcuevas3602fuck Spain
Oui, Visca Catalunya i visca l'Espanya
Only allowed by Spain to play friendly matches, once a year.
If catalonia becomes independent, will it mean that, they will have their own national team? And will barcelona play in the french league?
Another option would be to have our own federation, as is the case of Andorra, which has the Football Federation of Andorra. Therefore, Andorra has a football League and the team that wins it can represent the country at the European Cup. But it has a club called “Futbol Club Andorra” which plays in the Catalan League despite being a national team. If it were better it could even play in the “Copa del Rey”.
Spain would never have won any of it's recent trophies without Catalonia.
And Catalonia wouldn´t have risen those catalonian players without the spanish La Liga. If my grandma were green and flat she wouldn´t be my grandma, but a crocodile... Please, grow up.
Das stimmt. Ohne Bayern und Baden Württemberg, Deutschland würde nicht so reich sein. Aber ich muss sagen, Bayrisch und Schwäbisch verstehe ich überhaupt nicht lol.
reza michael that is stupid, the best players of spanish national selection and fc barcelona are from others partes of Spain, not from Catalonia
+seed86💁 yes, it is, have been, and will be along aaall your life😁 kisses😘👋
MENTIRA. De 23 jugadores que fueron al Mundial, sólo 7 eran catalanes (Puyol, Piqué, Busquets, Fábregas, Capdevila, Víctor Valdés y Xavi), de los cuales sólo 5 eran titulares (Puyol, Piqué, Busquets, Capdevila y Xavi), y de esos 5 sólo 4 eran del Barça (los que hemos dicho menos Capdevila). Por lo tanto de 11 jugadores que salen al campo 6 eran no catalanes. Los jugadores más importantes de la Selección española en ese Mundial fueron Villa, Casillas y Xavi: Villa por los goles (que fueron casi todos suyos), Casillas por las paradas en momentos clave (penalti a Paraguay en Cuartos, dos mano a mano con Robben en la Final...) y Xavi por ser el cerebro de cada jugada de ataque. Mención aparte para Iniesta y Puyol, que fueron muy importantes en momentos delicados.
En ese momento el Barcelona estaba en auge y era el mejor equipo de Europa, sin duda. Pero decir que España ganó el Mundial gracias al Barcelona o gracias a los jugadores catalanes es ser muy ignorante. Los mismos jugadores catalanes o del Barsa lo han dicho más de una vez: esa generación fue un cúmulo de muchas cosas, no de una sóla.
¿En qué año fue esa entrevista?.
Can you tell me what did he said please?
En mexico se hablan 67 lenguas autoctonas, pero no por eso existen igual numero de paises,talvez la cultura catalana sea unica pero son españa y no significa q sean basallos. Segun e leido españa esta constituida como nacion de nacionalidades. K pasaria si en lugar del castellano fuese el catalan mas hablado, pe.sarian lo mismo
un mexicano va a dar clases sin tener ni idea si. Cataluña es un país. busca la definición
@@gianmedleyCataluña nunca ha sido un país.
@@gianmedley Pues el mexicano con faltas de ortografía ha hecho una observación acertada, déjese usted la soberbia porque él tiene razón y México se lo muestra. Una lengua no significa una nación, una nación no significa una única lengua.
You can find it in the wikipedia searching for "catalan language".
gran pep! ets un mestre!
Sure, I'm not disagreeing with you in any way, but I still previously posted line-up overclasses any other line-up in the world. The only weak link in that team is Arbeloa and perhaps not enough balance on the midfield due to two attacking midfielders.
I respect Pep's feelings. I lived in Barcelona for three years and I speak Catalan. However, we should be thinking of uniting and cooperating, and not just among the various nationalities in Spain, but even accross continents, everywhere. The future is union, not separation.
Respecto els sentiments d'en Pep. Vaig viure tres anys a Barcelona i parlo català. Però crec que hauríem de pensar en unir-nos i cooperar, i no només entre les diversas nacionalitats d'Espanya, sinó fins i tot entre continents, i arreu del món. El futur és unió, no separació.
Respeto los sentimientos de Pep. Viví en Barcelona durante tres años y hablo catalán. Pero creo que deberíamos pensar en unirnos y cooperar, y no solo entre las diferentes nacionalidades de España, sino también entre continentes y todo el mundo. El futuro es unión, no separación.
why Spanish rules the Catalan and not the Catalan rules Spanish? This is just imperialist bullshit. Catalans should be free
@@KochariAsgar you don’t know shit, talk first about the Azeri genocide on the Armenians.
De cap manera. No incloure. Catalunya per als catalans
@@liqiz1755 Armenians commite gencide on Azeri.
@@Josep_Hernandez_Lujan ¿Qué pensarían tus ancestros andaluces o murcianos de lo que escribes?
Then why did he play for Spain, almost 50 times? It's contradictory.
Partially you're right. Before 2010 the separatist option never exceeded the 35% of catalan population but the economic crisis is NOT the only reason. It's more a combination of ofensive decisions of various spanish institutions, including the Government and the Constitional Court, to the legitims reclaims of the catalan institutions with the support of the majority of catalan citizens.
Lies. Mass boycott ensued in the 2017 vote. Of those who did (43%), 2,044,038 (90.18%) voted for separation and 177,547 (7.83%) voted against. Separatists won 90% on a 43% Turnout.
About 39%.
5️⃣7️⃣% BOYCOTTED.
ok, imma check it out
a TRUE BARCELONA LEGEND for a reason
What's up with the constant head shaking?
Serbia, Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina and Montenegro we just have different religion.
Serbs are Orthodox, Croats are Catholics, Bosniaks are Muslims, Montenegrins are Orthodox like Serbs becaus they are Serbs. Serbian tribe.
But language is the same!!! 99,99% words is same.
But each nations calls the language by itself: Serbian, Croatian, Bosnian, Montenegrin language.
It is the craziest in Bosnia.
Bosniaks (muslims) the language called BOSNIAN (like Bosnia). But in Bosnia lives and Serbs and Croats and he speak Serbian and Croatian.
I’m Bosnian Serbs and i speak Serbian language not Bosnian.
Slovenian and Macedonian have some difrent dialect.
Crazy House!!! 😂
Yugoslavia.
For example, Barcelona Football Club may ask the English Premier to play there. Then we’d have to see what the English League thought of that, but as a club we can certainly do it. In fact, we could do this today. The important thing is that we, the members, have it clear in our minds what we actually want; it’s up to us to decide where we would like to play. The ultimate objective is to be able to decide and I’m convinced that we will decide.
like in mainland China people speak Mandarin, but I am from Hong Kong, I speak Cantonese, it's also different as Spanish and Catalan
The difference between Mandarin and Cantonese is way way bigger than the difference between Castilian and Catalan
Catalonia is Spain, it has always been Spain. If you do not like your own country, go to Quatar, where you love it, with so many liberties and equalty. Liar.
What has quatar got to do with spain/catalonia ? you can't force people to embrace any sort of identity , they're free in their choices , the irony is that you talk about freedom whilst not allowing people to have any freedom in their choices
Why Catalonia wants to leave Spain. ..Spain is a beautiful country as I saw?
ȘΘɴ Θʃ τħε ɖεȘεરτ it’s a matter of identity and independence
@@gaiusmarius4112
It is a matter of money disguised
Most Catalans don`t want to leave Spain. All this is movement is funded; it`s the divide and conquer policy of the Soros gang. Like in Kosovo.
@@gaiusmarius4112
A matter of money and corrupt politicians
Amazing football coach.
A nefarious public figure.
A model of how decades-long social engineering in Spain can polarize in such a crazy way.
In that respect a guinea pig, the poor like many others
The RFEF’s current rules state that, in order to compete in Spain, “a team must be affiliated to the RFEF and integrated into it, other than the Federation of Autonomous Communities that are members.” In other words, if Catalonia leaves the RFEF, the Catalan teams will be excluded from any national competition.
Of course every country have their own league. Barcelona should be making own league .
Lol he doesnt wanna pay tax
cheers from Amazigh of Libya to Catalonia ^^..Tanimirt(thanks)
if catalonia does become independant, would barcelona leave the spanish league? and would many catalona born players, have to stop playing for spain? how will it work
Yea it'll be catalonia league they won't get champions League spot. Barca out forever
Freedom for Valle de Aran! Stop catalonian oppressing them!
@Perry Manso
Freedom for Tabarnia!
@Perry Manso
ua-cam.com/video/v2bZ4b5ucqY/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/v2bZ4b5ucqY/v-deo.html
Fuck Spain, cut it into pieces, worthless country anyways.
Absolutely!
. Cultura australiana és generalment una barreja de cultures angleses i europees i és molt similar a tot el país.
Som molt afortunats a Austràlia per tenir una economia forta i un baix atur, però la meva ciutat natal, Perth és una de les ciutats més cares del món per viure!
Tinc la intenció de traslladar-se a Catalunya o València quan em retiri com puc viure còmodament allà al meu ingrés Pension australiana gaudir de la vida en el seu bell país.
A subir precio de pisos y alquileres, para k vosotros viváis bien...
"own language"?
Bro, Catalan / catalan dialetcs is also spoken in Valencia, Balear Islands, and in other countries like Andorra or Italy.
You missed the point completely. Holy shit
Igual que el castellano, se habla en USA, Argentina, Mexico etc etc... es un dialecto or language?....
@@viewit9833 no he dicho que no sea un idioma pero lo que no es es un idioma suyo propio con copyright como te quieren hacer creer. Es un idioma que se habla en muchas partes.
@@jbo4547I think you are the one who missed his point
As a proud Moroccan i understand what you feel about the oppression, we live the same with ceuta Melilla
Y no hablas de la opresión de vuestro rey?
What about the berbers of the rif ?
What do you think of the moroccan occupied west africa？
Ceuta y Melilla ya eran plazas españolas hace 500 años, mucho antes de que Marruecos estuviera constituido; si no te agrada la integridad nacional del país que estás habitando amigo, eres libre de irte al maravilloso estado marroquí, con vuestro maravilloso rey, que vive en Francia por algún motivo.
We should not forget that Guardiola has personal interests in this: his sister has had as a first job an 80k role as a general director of Foreign Affairs (relaciones exteriores) in the Puigdemont governement (year 2015). She's now an "ambassador" of CT in Denmark. We do not know how much does she perceives, as the CT government does not clarify how much these "ambassadors" earn. The only thing we know is that the department she works with spends 1,6M to pay 19 people like her...
Imagine the Spanish national team without Xavi, Busquets, Alba, Piqué and Fabregas. The end of an era. There would be no more trophies for the RFEF, if the Spaniards suddenly had to assemble a creative midfield of their own.
Els Catalans sempre diuen "Tenim la nostra propia llengua!" Any Spanish person can understand this sentence so it's not really a separate language like Welsh is from English, for example.
Hello professor, Catalan is a Western Romance language derived from Vulgar Latin and named after the medieval Principality of Catalonia... You're welcome.
DocStrange0123 it still sounds like Spanish. I'm not even spanish nor a native speaker of it but I would say I understand at least 70% of said Catalan. Catalans look like spaniards, speak like spaniards and for me as a foreigner they are just Spanish special snowflakes wanna be. I might be wrong but they aren't that different from other autonomous communities of Spain who also have their own specific culture and language like the Basque Country for example, but still are rather distinctly, of Spanish and Iberian culture.
You're a Catalan, from Spain! Just like every other Catalan is also from Spain! Just like the Basque and the Valencianos and the Madristas! Look at your passport!
xbenjemimax no
@@2277ize No, what?
i understand Pep and his feelings for Catalonia.but what bothers me the most,why did he ever play for Spain at the first place since he clearly does not want to represent it and feels that is not his country?
there are accusations by team mates that he only played for spain for the money but i doubt thats the reason. alot of footballers tend to play for a nation and to have their names recognised nationally
Panos Stamoulis Because he isn't stupid
Because he's a money-hungry machoman perhaps? He could be North African more like and always very secretive about his private life mmm mmm imagine all the fun in the changing rooms . . .
he's smart, your words won't be heard if you're not in high position.
+Panos Stamoulis He had to.
Qué gran cosmopaleto
Where would Barcelona football club play if Catalonia became an independent State?
I think wherever it wished. Obviously, Catalonia would need to have its own League as federations make it compulsory, so a state structure for sports would have to be created. However, Barcelona Football Club, as a private club can theoretically play wherever it wants to.
Scotland, Wales & N Ireland have teams that can play in international competition. Why not Catalonia?
Because it's not a country lol
hope the language and the culture never dies regardless of sovereignty
ok sir I m a fan of spanish empire, I state that catalan is a dialect, not a language, all small dialects must be banned to make spain great again
Catalan is a language literally search it up... educate yourself
Make no mistake: We don't have, for example, own Treasury and it's a great chain in our relation with Spain. Because without own Treasury we can't measure own government spending and we can't have catalan government budgets adequate to our needs as Spain invests more than 40% of catalan revenues outside Catalonia... It's a nonsense.
So latin america adopted spanish culture or catalonian culture??
Mainly Spanish
But this could affect the income of the club...
Obviously, already today, what brings in the money is the European Cup, and we expect that Barcelona will play in the competition. Cause-effect scenarios will take place, but they will quickly be readdressed. At the moment, we must understand sport as a matter of state; therefore, it will be solved as a matter of state.
Pero si tu as sido un poco mas gracias a haber jugado en la seleccion...si no hubieses sido uno mas de tantos jugadores que con el tiempo se olvidan....SI TAN INDEPENDENTISTA ERES PORQUE AS JUGADO EN LA SELECCION.......
Oh really? Catalonia isn't Spain then why you play for Spain You could just refuse to play International football like Paul Scholes (2007-10 )
Totally BS
Its not really free when most of its money is being taken away from it and sent to the government while its language is banned from many schools.
Catalonia is not spain
Basque is not spain
Kachin is not myanmar too
I'm support from kachin country
Yes, is a region of Spain
Tabarnia is not Catalonia.
es clar que sí, coi!!
I would guess that Barcelona will still be in La Liga. Maybe similar to AS Monaco, where they are not part of France, but play in the French league. As to the national team, I would say the Catalan players are going to want to play for Catalunya rather than Spain.
Good i respect your opinion i think others will also not impose their opinions on you .Anyway
Arent catalán people the same tribal/ethnicity as the spaniards ? isn't there Names and language truly the same? or are they different people group that have been assimilated?
Tribaly, the same ethnicity as in all east and south Spain: Iberians. That's going to prerroman times.
But not going so far in time, there is only on ethnicity in the whole iberian peninsula.
If you study History of Spain, you will see that Catalans were not assimilated, but an integral part of the foundation of the nowadays' Spain (the Casal Reial d'Aragó, and de Barcelona, the Crown of Aragon, the Hispanic Monarchy through the dynastic union of Castile and Aragon, etc...)
In the iberian Christian kingdoms there was a long project of reunification after the muslim conquest (with conflicts in between among different Christian kingdoms, of course) in which Catalonia played a fundamental role. I mean, there is a reason why there were so extremely long celebrations in Barcelona (ten whole days with their nights) on the occasion of the conquest of Granada. You can check the Dietaris de la Generalitat de Catalunya if you want to see It by yourself. And that was that the so long desired unity of the Iberian Peninsula had being recovered (later came the conquest of Navarra by both Castile and Aragon, and remember that Catalonia was a part of the Crown of Aragon, also Portugal was expected to unite with the rest of Crowns and Kingdoms through marriage politics).
So Catalonia was not assimilated, but played one of the protagonist roles in the formation and unification of Spain.
@@DavidNilo-ss8gq i really much appreciate this comment you made for me brother, One more quesiton if you don't mind? are you implying that the portuguese people and the spainiards are the same ethnic group/tribal from back in the day aswell?
@@endritbajrami8795 I would say they are the same ethnic group, yes, and in fact Portugal indeed formed also part of the Hispanic Monarchy. But they also had their own nobility and rulers (and even in a same ethnicity politics also play a big role), that's why they are no longer in a union with the rest of Iberian Peninsula (remember that we speak of a time when families and the power of families, nobility in this case, was more important than ethnicities and nations). With Catalonia is not the same, cause the King of Spain (short way of stating all his titles associeted to Spain) IS the Count of Barcelona as he descends by legitimate succesion from the old Counts of Barcelona of the Casal de Barcelona of the deep middle ages when not even Aragon and the Catalan Counties had yet made an union.
But all I said as our common past is a reason why we both Spaniards and Portuguese feel ourselves as brothers.
If Catalonia is not Spain then Northern Ireland is not Britain too
‘Every Peoples and Nation has the right to manage themselves even prior to the application of any fundamental Human right’ 607-A(VII) UN’s Resolution
Pep Guardiola is right!
FREEDOM FOR CATALONIA
Catalonia us not a country it's a region within the country of Spain, Pep saying it's a country does not make it so.
👀
I don’t think its fair for nations who have fought to defend their borders for centuries i.e.: Scottish, Welsh, and English to be compared to a region of Spain. (as the Catalans tend to do).
Even more unfair is to compare Catalonia to the Irish, which are indeed a nation and were oppressed (and almost starved to death) by England for centuries, while Catolonia is not a nation, but a spanish nationality, the second richest part of Spain and one of the most developed alongside Madrid and the Basque Lands
but language isn't the only condition for our nationhood, we've got a totally different culture, values, expresions... a history as a country so different from the rest of spain.
Que viva españa
I don't despise you for Catalonia I think it's good that what makes Spain amazing too many people. Im galician and i know galicia and Spain has different parts about each other (like Cata) but it what makes Spain. I know you Catalans don't want this and that but I just think it's funny. I love all parts of Spain really and right now we all need to work together for a better place. I know that some spanish people said bad things about Catalonia but really just Ignore it it's just bullcrap.
Go ahead with the Europe of Regions ...
Yes, and later on the Europe of cities and towns.
Catalonia is Spain
Is a region of Spain
Espania once controlled Portugal too but it was always Portugal. Catalonia is its own country and one day will be free again. Now for u imbecile go read a history book to educate your simple self.
@@TheReddevil821 You are probably the dumbest person i have ever seen in my entire life
Partition always affect any country
Example: Russia , India
Partition didn't affect India
We are free and fine now.
@Perry Manso
Being part of Catalonia also affects Tabarnia. The rural Catalonia worsens Tabarnia's economy.
Trying to relieve the explanation of littlegirljuststoned catalans have a way of thinking and make thinks more european than the rest of Spain. Our character isn't tipically Mediterranean, it's more north-central-european and this is reflected, for example, at work, in the way we do bussiness, in the way that people relate, etc...
Que viva españa
i can never take it serious when someone says catalonia is a country
Eventually Catalan Football League has FC Barcelona and mighty teams like Espanyol, Girona.... 😂
Catalonia is Spain's part.
¡Abrazafarolas!
7 años después y aún la tienes hasta la tráquea
Joer abuelito tomate tus pastillas por favor
Why does he not look Spanish?
Russell Richards HAHAHAHAHAHAH he looks like Spanish wtf
One's entitlement to a sense of political sovereignty is based purely on cultural unity and relative alienation, not on how much blood has been spilled in the name of the country. That is the kind of tripe falange spouted off earlier in the 1900s.
Catalonia is a unique sense of identity vis a vis their language, political ideology, and customs, and, as such, should very much be considered as having its own nationality and, by extension, something of an autonomous polity.
I see, so refering a catalan as a spanish is like refering a hongkongers as a mainland chinese, both catalan and hongkongers will get pissed off lol
Yea like you hating its going to change somthing
Em vaig sentir molt benvingut quan jo hi era. Tots els que visiten Catalunya sembla caure en amor amb ell pel que ha d'estar fent alguna cosa bé :)
All the best to you and your family and friends.
Viva Catalunya!
*Visca la Catalunya!
Querido Guardiola, si no eres español por qué sigues hablando en castellano? Dado que es tu lengua, habla catalán y deja el español a los "verdaderos" españoles.
a lo mejor la entrevista era en español? *Zi ERES EZPANIOl XQ AVLAS INGLES JAJAJAJA SOI LISTO* Bueno,seguramente no sepas ni inglés,pero Olé por ti campeón
Se inglés, español e italiano campeón!
Ese discursito de Español=España y todo lo demás sobra es una tontería. España es un país con más de una lengua, y cuál es el problema? Porque no aceptarlo, asumirlo y usarlo como una arma de publicidad más? Es que los españolistas tan duritos sois una ruína con el tema indepe, Intentemos mejorar el tema y las relaciones en vez de tanta discusión tonta.
¿Y por qué hablas Inglés y/o Italiano si no eres de los "verdaderos" Ingleses o Italianos?
multiple countries speak multiple languages... in canada half the country speaks english and the other half speak french... its still one country... what will catalans gain from independence? they are already free
Crec que viure al costat del mar prop de Barcelona seria el millor. Probablement vaig a viatjar per tot Europa i el Regne Unit una mica. Tinc moltes ganes de veure molt més de
Catalunya i Espanya quan torni en uns dos anys. Fins ara no he vist molt de Barcelona, el museu Dalí a Figueres, la casa de Dalí a Port Lligat, i Cadacqes.
La proximitat de Catalunya amb la frontera francesa és un avantatge ja que el sud de França és tan bonic.
but it is the truth. I do not feel Spanish. You should not take offence on that. I feel fine with other people feeling Spanish and I have many Spanish friends. But I feel Catalan. We have to respect each other
Guardiola is not Barça
***** Yes I am from BCN.
Cataluña debe obtener la independencia. Ellos hablan un idioma diferente que es catalán y son todavía parte de España
+tomiwa jobi Galicia también. Y el País Vasco. Y Baleares. Y Valencia. Y qué? España es una nación muy rica en cultura, siempre ha sido así y siempre lo será.
+lombingo el valenciano,el balear y el catalan es el mismo idioma,pero son diferentes dialectos
+lombingo
+lombingo valencia no quiere independencia de España. ellos son gente que vienen de ascendencia catalana pero ellos son orgulloso de ser españoles
Gràcies pel teu suport i pel teu interès per Catalunya, la seva llengua i cultura. Parles molt bé el Català! :)
Benvingut sempre que vulguis venir a Catalunya.
A Austràlia Occidental també hi ha gent que vol la independència? Teniu diferències culturals o lingüístiques amb la resta d'Austràlia?
Perdona si em faig pesat però és molt interessant i no conec gaire la situació.
Salut
🇪🇦🇪🇦🇪🇦🇪🇦🇪🇦
what about it? It's part of canada
Canada?
Catalonia is one of the places which made what we call Spain together Spain is stronger with Catalonia
So if someone feels Spanish I do not dislike them. Why do you despise me for feeling Catalan??
I think Catalunya has everything pretty well, i mean there are other countries with worse problems.. Catalunya has just been lucky to have succesfull athletes(football players for all i know) and they speak their own language.. and sure differences in culture and stye but thats normal i mean in Andalucia people are totally different than Madrid but they dont want to be other country? I think Catalunyan people just think they're somehow "too good" for Spain and thats just pathetic!
Are you serious
Porque la selección catalana no puede jugar competiciones internacionales, ¿es que no has visto el vídeo o tienes problemas de comprensión?
No, he will never. But maybe when Catalonia has a National Team he will coach for us. Seriously have you watched the video?
Ojalá algún año estos catalanes tengan lo que quieren lo que ocurre es que su mayor problema lo tienen en su propio pais cataluña ya que no todo el mundo quiere esa independencia que otros añoran tanto. En cualquier caso sería estupendo que el barça solo compitiera en su liga catalana o quizás para esto si que se encuentran a gusto.