Should you buy a Canon R5 in 2024 | How the R5 may be better for you over the R5 Mark II

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 110

  • @rezzoc91
    @rezzoc91 2 місяці тому +57

    The best part of the R5II is getting the R5 greatly discounted

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  2 місяці тому +3

      Haha. That’s one way to look at it!

    • @chasingframes
      @chasingframes 2 місяці тому +3

      Absolutely currently saving for a R5 will be a huge jump from my 5dmklll which I will not be getting rid of

    • @joelmanrique5914
      @joelmanrique5914 Місяць тому +2

      i can agree because I am planning on getting one. 😂

    •  14 днів тому +1

      not in my country... even used is very expensive.

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  14 днів тому +1

      yea, the used market is all over the place globally.

  • @jer48888
    @jer48888 Місяць тому +15

    I love that more people realize that there is no perfect camera but a camera like the R5 should never be deemed irrelevant overnight. Kudos brother it’s an excellent camera.

  • @thelensmanphotography
    @thelensmanphotography 2 дні тому +1

    Been shooting with the R5 for years, bought the R5II to shoot action photography, wildlife, (birds in flight) keeping R5 for landscape & portrait photography.

  • @Hakku1403
    @Hakku1403 3 місяці тому +22

    I will stick with my R5 for many years to come. It´s a beast and the love of life

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  3 місяці тому +2

      Sure is! Thanks for watching!

    • @mikem6796
      @mikem6796 2 місяці тому

      ​​@@TonyMellinger Does the r5 still overheat? I heard the battery life was terrible. True? Should I get r5c if I'm getting into video but mostly do stills?

    • @Devdattab
      @Devdattab 2 місяці тому +1

      I am buying a new R5 this week. Its a beast and is enough for me.

    • @Hakku1403
      @Hakku1403 2 місяці тому

      @@Devdattab You have chosen wisely, bro

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  2 місяці тому

      @@Devdattab It is truly a beast.

  • @steeleman74
    @steeleman74 2 місяці тому +13

    I just ordered the R5 and it's ready for pick up! I cannot wait because I know it will do all I need and more!

  • @Drmikekuna
    @Drmikekuna 2 місяці тому +6

    How many times over the last twenty years have I bought an upgraded camera because influencers or others have "told me" that the dynamic range, focusing, or whatever was 100% better than what I had, only to find out that the new camera was only marginally better (at best) and that I already had enough camera with my old gear? Professional photographers were making pro-level prints using cameras like the 12 MP D3 in the day. That camera had fantastic autofocus and beautiful images. Obviously, cameras have advanced since then, but older cameras could certainly do the job. I remember talking to a wedding photographer (at a wedding) who was shooting with an original 5D and a 5DII when the 5D IV had been out for years. He had no need to upgrade because he knew what he was doing and how to get the most out of cameras. Clients care about the image. They couldn't care less what camera was used. Of course, some elite photographers need every advantage. I take pretty nice photos, but I'm nowhere near elite level, so all is good with my older gear.

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  2 місяці тому

      True words. Thanks for watching! Not a single couple at a wedding had said “oh… you’re shooting on that outdated camera!?”

  • @budchristman2849
    @budchristman2849 Місяць тому +1

    Bought an R5 and I have a number of EF Lens that work well. I just ordered a RF 200-800 for wildlife and am excited to get the reach. This camera is as you say a beast. I have it with me and I take everywhere I go. I know this camera will do me a great job.

  • @KathySierraVideo
    @KathySierraVideo 3 місяці тому +7

    I love my R5. Does everything I need in such a small, light camera. I’ve never had an overheat either, and I shoot 4K 60 fps in Clog3. The recording limit is rarely an issue but occasionally a pain. Like you, I’ve never felt I needed *more* dynamic range, and I’m always impressed with how forgiving it is for exposure challenges. But I’m not a pro, so 🤷🏼‍♀️.

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  3 місяці тому +1

      Thanks so much for watching and the comment! I totally agree with you, the record limit is the biggest pain point I’ve encountered. Thanks again for watching and keep creating amazing content with that R5!

  • @JosiahAdriel
    @JosiahAdriel 3 місяці тому +6

    I just got my R5 last Friday and love it

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  2 місяці тому +1

      Love it! You’ll create all sorts of amazing things.

  • @garrywatters1140
    @garrywatters1140 14 днів тому +1

    I have an R5 and an old 1dx mk1. I will be using both and not upgrading for a lot of years yet.

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  13 днів тому +1

      The 1dx was such a legend. Hard to get rid of it!

  • @ralphguppy
    @ralphguppy 2 місяці тому +2

    My R6 MkII gives me the pre-capture, which is indeed a valuable wildlife feature. I’m looking for an R5 for the resolution increase only to make cropping easier.

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  2 місяці тому

      Yea, the pre-capture is amazing! That would be really helpful for event coverage too.

    • @jonowebster
      @jonowebster 2 місяці тому +1

      Feels like something they could have added to the R5 via a firmware upgrade

    • @ralphguppy
      @ralphguppy 2 місяці тому

      @@jonowebster absolutely could have!

  • @gregorydobson4307
    @gregorydobson4307 2 місяці тому +2

    Great video, iam just about to upgrade from my 6d to the r5. Your definitely true about the small increments a new model has to the last one.

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  2 місяці тому

      Love the r5! Shot on it all weekend. It’s such a great camera. That’s a huge step from a 6D. You’re going to absolutely love it!

    • @fi_lines
      @fi_lines 2 місяці тому

      I currently have the 6D and am thinking about the R5. You’ll have to let me know if you love it and if I should just go for it.

  • @josephmurad1134
    @josephmurad1134 3 місяці тому +1

    I have a R6 MK1 and It does everything I need as a stills photographer. I considered picking up a refurbished R5, but decided against it and would rather invest in better glass. 45 mp is nice though.

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  2 місяці тому

      I did love my r6. So many amazing photos with that camera! It’s such a great balance of speed and quality

  • @ElBoyoElectronico
    @ElBoyoElectronico 3 місяці тому +1

    I will definitely stick with my R5! Besides not having the money for an upgrade, I really, really do not want to also have to sell and rebuy my batteries, the cage system, the battery grip and other stuff. Imo those costs are also something that people tend to for forget

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  3 місяці тому +1

      Yea, there’s lots that go into it. I know canon is trying to push their battery technology, but having to update batteries every camera is kind of rough.

  • @John-Shutterlyphotos
    @John-Shutterlyphotos 2 місяці тому +4

    What I noticed is the R5 no longer has auto focus and the colors suck the day the R5 ii came out not mention DSLR's no longer work, lol. I love my 5D Mark IV, still my studio camera, love my R6 still works after the R6 ii came out and love my R5. No plans to upgrade to the R5 ii even though I would love it also

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  2 місяці тому +1

      🤣 you’ve got quite a kit there! The 5D4 was an exceptional photo camera. I’ve got lots of memories with that body.

    • @John-Shutterlyphotos
      @John-Shutterlyphotos 2 місяці тому +1

      @@TonyMellinger Thanks, it all started with a Kodak 110 instamatic around 1979.

    • @Windsurfingaddict
      @Windsurfingaddict 2 місяці тому

      @@John-Shutterlyphotos
      My mum had one that I used lol 😂

    • @5foto5
      @5foto5 11 днів тому

      I also still use the 5D IV and the R6. Now I’m planning to buy the R5. It is heavily discounted.
      I do most work with my 5D IV unless it’s action. If and when the R3 comes down in price, that will my future camera. 😀
      Never again the latest camera.

    • @John-Shutterlyphotos
      @John-Shutterlyphotos 11 днів тому +1

      @5foto5 The R5 is a great camera, especially now that the R5 ii has come out and the R5 price has dropped substantially. I still find myself using the 5D IV a lot, maybe more than my R6 & R5. IBIS and eye detection is superior on both the R6 & R5, but the quality and versatility of the 5D IV is second to none.

  • @marcosuozzi
    @marcosuozzi 3 місяці тому +5

    Just got a brand new R5 here in Switzerland for 2300Usd 🥰 Don‘t need more.

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  3 місяці тому

      What a steal! Gosh. That’s a lot of camera for $2300

    • @marcosuozzi
      @marcosuozzi 3 місяці тому

      @@TonyMellinger yes it is. I mean the R52 is the better camera… no question… but not double the price better at the moment. For now I‘m happy with my R5c and R5 combo 🥰🤗

  • @DroseMr
    @DroseMr 3 місяці тому +4

    My buddies use the r5 for there tv show. Im fully invested in Lumix. Great show.Thank You

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  3 місяці тому +1

      Very nice! Thanks for watching!! Once you get in an ecosystem, you’re invested for sure!

  • @3-piece129
    @3-piece129 Місяць тому +1

    Yes, I love my R5ii so much, even with the extra noise it produces, that I chunked my R5 out my car window.

  • @drewkwabs
    @drewkwabs 2 місяці тому +2

    Saving up for a used r5

  • @adude394
    @adude394 13 днів тому

    I got the R5 instead of the R5 Mk II myself. The newer model is clearly a powerhouse, but the R5 is more than enough for anything I like to do, not to mention a fair amount less expensive!

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  9 днів тому +1

      Right. It’s super cheap right now. I saw a Black Friday deal for like 2500 bucks!

  • @philcupper
    @philcupper 3 місяці тому

    Timely video. Been on my R6 for awhile and looking to pick up another body to replace my older EOS R as a backup/second body. Honestly think the original R5 is going to be plenty for me instead of the R5mkII. (Wedding hybrid coverage).

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  3 місяці тому +1

      Glad I could help! The r5 has done wonders for me in the wedding industry. Glad I could help, thank you for watching!

    • @Hakku1403
      @Hakku1403 3 місяці тому +1

      The R5 is til today and for many years to come a beast of a camera

  • @alexfournier9956
    @alexfournier9956 Місяць тому +2

    Good steal i gotta here today toorder a R5 , R5 II not great upgrades indeed !!

  • @yusufcem1840
    @yusufcem1840 20 днів тому

    Brother canon r5 enough or better to buy R5 mark ii? Thank you

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  19 днів тому

      All depends on what you need. If you have the money, spend it. The R5 can create amazing content for the price though!

  • @rudradavesar6755
    @rudradavesar6755 29 днів тому +1

    i own r7 i will buy r5 next year when the price gets to $1500 to make a kit of $2000 of r5 with a great lens

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  28 днів тому

      It’s dropping fast!! That’ll be a great kit

  • @BasilVKfilms2018
    @BasilVKfilms2018 3 місяці тому +1

    I am in a dilemma to buy R5 or R5 II. I mainly do wedding photo / video and and maternity photoshoot and commercial video ad for small companies. Could you please tell me do you find difficult to edit video from R5. Codec related

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  3 місяці тому

      I don’t have any trouble with the R5 codec. I do have a new MacBook Pro M3pro though. If you have an Apple with an M processor, you should be fine. I’m not sure about PCs

    • @BasilVKfilms2018
      @BasilVKfilms2018 3 місяці тому

      @@TonyMellinger I have m2 pro 1 tb 32gb model.

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  3 місяці тому +1

      @@BasilVKfilms2018 oh you shouldn’t have any trouble at all

    • @jassyelise1594
      @jassyelise1594 27 днів тому

      For someone like me who only uses camera not video do you suggest I go for the R6 in that case ?

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  27 днів тому

      @ maybe! It depends if you want the high resolution images for cropping. The r6 is a great camera for photos though. And honestly, much easier files to work with because you can transfer them so much faster. And they are smaller files to work with on your computer and iPad. 24mp is still a huge image

  • @shaileshprasad1308
    @shaileshprasad1308 2 місяці тому

    Is sticking to R6 better than going for R5 since R5 is discounted right now because of the mark ii coming out

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  2 місяці тому

      There are great deals on the R5 right now. It’s a great camera. Honestly though, if the R6 works for you, no need to upgrade!

  • @hypnoraythompson5824
    @hypnoraythompson5824 3 місяці тому

    Well said mate.

  • @gokugotop
    @gokugotop 4 дні тому

    Does anybody know why the c log 3 on my canon r5 keeps making my reds look pink? I cannot find anything online about it. In Cinema gamut c log 3 my reds always or sometimes turn pink when i convert it to rec 709 i am starting to regret my purchase it’s extremely annoying

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  3 дні тому

      I’m not sure I’ve quite noticed what you’re talking by about but can’t you just move your magenta slider more green and it fixes it? I think this camera colors beautifully

  • @Tsoprano27
    @Tsoprano27 Місяць тому

    I'm still holding on to my 5D3 in 2024 😆

  • @nubscrub
    @nubscrub 3 місяці тому

    You’re the only person I’ve seen or heard mention anything about the R5 now being trash. No one is saying that?

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  3 місяці тому +2

      You must not have watched much of the video hehe

  • @lonnygraham54
    @lonnygraham54 25 днів тому

    I love the r5

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  23 дні тому

      It’s a beast! Glad you’re enjoying it. Thanks for watching!

  • @roynewport5397
    @roynewport5397 4 дні тому

    Got a new R5 yesterday , I think the iso above 3200 is poor and no better than my 5d mk4

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  3 дні тому +1

      Interesting… I was just shooting at 12,800 and have usable content. I really struggled with the noise in the 5d4.
      Especially with video.

  • @hugomouteira7015
    @hugomouteira7015 21 день тому

    Fun Fact: R5II has less Dynamic Range at 6400 ISO in stills vs R5

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  21 день тому +1

      I keep hearing that. I don’t kind the DR on my R5.

  • @blackimp4987
    @blackimp4987 Місяць тому +2

    Actually R5mkII has lower dynamic range. I appreciate your advise. I still have a 6Dmk II that I never loved after having a 5d and a eos 3 I still own. I want a decent dynamic range camera capable of 4k video at 120 frames thou 80% of the time I'm going to shoot pictures - portraits landscape and some sport or rc airplanes -. I' ve learnt well it's absurd spending too much for instruments I don't exploit thou I 've learnt as well a product too much oriented to consumers in hobby I really love might stop me from using it - that's what happened to me with my 6DmkII. I'd really love to use again an eye-control af as I have on my eos 3 that is very useful even in portraits session but the price of R5mk II and the lower dynamics make me be more realistic. I just wait for the R6 mk III, test it in my hands with the R5 and then I'm.going to decide.
    Thank you for encouraging not falling for the last and more expensive products when they are actually not needed and the older ones can do a decent job for much less money

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  Місяць тому

      Interesting comments about the lower dynamic range. Is that in photo or video? I hadn’t heard that yet

    • @blackimp4987
      @blackimp4987 Місяць тому +1

      @@TonyMellinger I saw in many reviews that in photos at higher iso R5 are cleaner than R5mk II and many reviewers complain about that and this results in slightly lower dynamic as well. It's after all the logical consequence of adopting a stacked sensor as the added electronic layer produces thermal noise. I don't know if in compressed video formats it's visible.
      Moreover: a stacked sensor has a great meaning for reducing the twist of objects moving fast when shooting with the electronic shutter but from what I saw in R5mk II images of sports where you swing quickly a tool like a racket it still results a little twisted. This is because the only true solution would be a parallel acquisition of all the pixels. I think Sony just made a camera that implements that acquisition system. Otherwise it's better having a normal CMOS and shooting with mechanical shutter in my opinion

  • @23ironchatarra
    @23ironchatarra 17 днів тому

    nice

  • @jeffmanser2883
    @jeffmanser2883 3 місяці тому

    What the hell is an R5 OG????? There’s an R5 and a R5II shaking my head

    • @hawaiifreespeechnews
      @hawaiifreespeechnews 3 місяці тому

      OG = Original Gangster

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  3 місяці тому

      🤣

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  3 місяці тому

      Ther’s also an R5C haha

    • @hawaiifreespeechnews
      @hawaiifreespeechnews 3 місяці тому

      @@TonyMellinger which supposedly still has a better video image than the R5ii. I’m holding out for the R1 and C400 even though I have to wait longer for them

  • @richardperry5538
    @richardperry5538 Місяць тому

    And if they bring out the Canon Mk3 the Mk2 will be trash......and it goes on and on 🤔 The fact they are sticking to calling it an R5 tells you the original is great.

    • @TonyMellinger
      @TonyMellinger  Місяць тому

      Yep! The R5 set the bar high, it’s an incredible camera!

  • @maniharlaishram1823
    @maniharlaishram1823 2 місяці тому

    Praise Resion Say Just now

  • @maniharlaishram1823
    @maniharlaishram1823 2 місяці тому

    Sar, Praise Give me

  • @lonniesfilmmaking333
    @lonniesfilmmaking333 3 місяці тому

    You’re contradicting yourself

  • @s.gharavi1614
    @s.gharavi1614 2 місяці тому +1

    This is so useless

  • @Mamunrashid-ym6ot
    @Mamunrashid-ym6ot 4 дні тому

    I just ordered the R5 and it's ready for pick up! I cannot wait because I know it will do all I need and more!