Backyard Beekeeping Q&A 290 Purple Martins AND Bees? Good or Bad?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 110

  • @Adam.Holmes.
    @Adam.Holmes. 9 днів тому +3

    1) Is a double queen hive more productive than a single queen hive with a double-deep? 4:16
    2) I'm trying to liquify some honey, but part of it remains crystalized, what can I do? 9:27
    3) I would like to build a Purple Martin House and add it to my backyard. Should I be concerned that they will reduce my bee population? 13:12
    4) A two queen system can be a lot to handle, not recommended for new keepers. 22:38
    5) With a two-queen system, if one queen dies on one side will they just spread their pheromone through both brood boxes? 34:58
    6) I had to replace my queen and chose VSH stock, are they smaller than other bee stock and will they require new queen excluders? 42:03

    • @kennith.
      @kennith. 8 днів тому

      Thank you Adam

  • @Highland_Honey
    @Highland_Honey 9 днів тому +7

    A Great BIG CONGRATULATIONS to Quinn!!! That's 'The Way To Bee', Quinn!!!🐝💛

  • @brianbennett4374
    @brianbennett4374 9 днів тому +3

    Looking forward to watching you with keeper's Hive 😊. Thanks Fred 😊

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому

      I just hope my grandson doesn't claim that hive as his own... he's a little shifty, and I find his name on random bee equipment (';')( ';').... it's going to ge a fun year in my opinion :)

  • @georgegarcia5052
    @georgegarcia5052 8 днів тому +1

    Wonderful discussion on purple martins!

  • @marobroski2286
    @marobroski2286 8 днів тому +1

    Dziękujemy.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  7 днів тому

      Thank you, as always, for your kind generosity. :)

  • @ronlogreco876
    @ronlogreco876 7 днів тому +1

    Fred, to decrystallize my small jar honey (1-3 ibs.) I submerge the jars in a crock pot of water set on warm. The water temperature is about 100 degrees if you leave the lid off the crock pot. Overnight is all that's necessary for 1 lb jars. Sometimes I need to invert the quart jars of fall honey for additional 8 hours. I have a different method in mind for my 1-3 gallon jars.

  • @lambbrookfarm4528
    @lambbrookfarm4528 9 днів тому +2

    Quinn, you are the man! ...I have Phoebes and Wood Peewees, both members of the flycatcher family of birds... they hang out on the bee yard electric fence and eat bees...

  • @tasmedic
    @tasmedic 8 днів тому +2

    Here in Tasmania our locally adapted honey bees are small, dark and feisty. I find the flow super a real Godsend, because if I'm in any of my hives for more than a few minutes, they get fed up with me and start trying to drive me away. They also tend to congregate on top of the frames, and aren't particulary bothered by my smoker, either. Trying not to squish them when reassembling the hive after an inspection can be very challenging. One thing I found helpful was to gently brush them off the top of the frames, down the front of the hive, towards the entrance. This sometimes causes less upset than trying to smoke them, which you might find surprising! Local colleagues keep offering me queens to replace my feisty genetics, but I do love my grumpy girls, and they are very productive.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому +1

      Wow, I'm just impressed that you live in such a unique part of the world! :) Thank you so much for sharing where you are and what you do.

  • @DerekCampbellIS
    @DerekCampbellIS 6 днів тому +1

    Hilarious Fred! Enjoyed the "destroyer of your labor pool" by overpayment claim. Grandma must not be watching this! LOL.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  6 днів тому

      I have one grandson who's 5. When we all go out to pick up firewood kindling, he stops in front of every little stick "grandfather, how much if I pick this one up" (';')( ';')... this is what I'm up against. How about you get to be warmed by a nice fire. "well I'm not picking up any sticks then".

  • @redfish440
    @redfish440 9 днів тому +1

    Congratulations Quinn, thanks Fred for another informative and entertaining stream, have a great weekend!

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому +1

      You are very welcome, and Quinn is an over achiever for sure. :)

  • @davidpotts3844
    @davidpotts3844 8 днів тому +1

    Totally like the intro

  • @NKYHoneyBees
    @NKYHoneyBees 5 днів тому +1

    Aren't dragonflies great for mosquitos? I say we leave them all alone :) Nature has a way of working itself out.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  5 днів тому +1

      Everyone will make their own decisions. The Question was about Purple Martins specifically, and if they eat bees. I think we're ok overall :)

  • @markbasinger6015
    @markbasinger6015 9 днів тому +1

    Love Purple Martins.
    Was awesome to meet you and your wife at NAHBE 25!

  • @Highland_Honey
    @Highland_Honey 9 днів тому +2

    My great uncle always kept bees, and had purple martin houses set up for his garden. He said it was a trade-off, just like the rat snake that would visit his chicken house. He believed the occasional occasional bee and the occasional egg were a small price to pay for quality pest control.

  • @maureenjais-mick8114
    @maureenjais-mick8114 8 днів тому +1

    Love the deer seemingly attracted to the noisemaker! Looked like she was trying to find the product number. Maybe a different frequency would be more threatening? Re purple martins, I don't have them in my Maryland yard, but the catbirds like to sit by the colonies and grab a few bees as they fly in or out. I am happy to see them and they don't do much damage - fun to watch.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому

      That deer was more stubborn than the others. There were five of them. That last one finally stopped coming, but you're right, it was annoying... she only stayed 20 seconds. :) Before the noise-makers, they would remain for 30 minutes or more at a time. :)

  • @rosswagner9083
    @rosswagner9083 9 днів тому +1

    Thank you for answering my question! I think I'm going to get a double queen keepers hive.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому

      That's great news Ross. I'm looking forward to this year of beekeeping... lots of new ground for me to cover :)

  • @saintjohncoleman8602
    @saintjohncoleman8602 9 днів тому +2

    When I had 2 queens in one hive, a mother and her daughter, and both were laying. It was an 8 frame Langstroth with a medium honey super and a flow super. This Flow super was my first most successfully filled flow unit. So many bees!

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому

      That sounds like a perfect recipe for high production and cooperation without separation!

  • @SIBEEMAN
    @SIBEEMAN 9 днів тому +1

    Great job Quinn! Great job granddad on passing down such high intelligence too!
    Fred, quick question. I see towards the end of your video. You have a hive that’s elevated on top of a Beesmart hive instead of it sitting directly on it. What is the reason?
    Thank you

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому

      That's just to get the entrance out of skunk range. The beesmart stands are too short unless I shim the legs, or add a spacer/booster. :)

  • @tommychew6544
    @tommychew6544 9 днів тому +2

    I like your take on Purple Martins, survival of the fittest is really important! I had a large colony of Purple Martins several years ago and waged war on European house sparrows and starlings using traps and my marksmanship skills, both invasive species ignorantly introduced to North America in the 1890's and 1920's (starlings in the 1890s and European house sparrows in the 1920's)! Those two have done more to take out our native songbirds than any other combination that has ever happened in North America, they aggressively take over nesting cavities, I've witnessed it myself. I'd love to say more but, I'll stop my comment here, just true observations and having read the history of them.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому +1

      Watching bird lovers provide housing for House Sparrows and boost their numbers is a source of frustration for me. My own sister in law allowed House Sparrows to take over her entire Purple Martin Hotel. We've had house sparrows peck Bluebirds to death on their nest. It's a grizzly behavior. I wish more people understood why house sparrows are all that you see in suburbia and cities, becuase they have pushed nearly all of the native song birds. I understand, it's hard for some people to act against any bird species. I wish they knew more about the issue.

    • @glennsnaturalhoney4571
      @glennsnaturalhoney4571 8 днів тому +1

      ​@FrederickDunn I agree, but what can you do about sparrows? I put bird feed out, mostly sunflowers and 90% goes to sparrows. Enough cardinals, titmice, etc to keep me putting it out. Glenn

    • @tommychew6544
      @tommychew6544 8 днів тому

      @@glennsnaturalhoney4571 Usually it's only millet in my area that attracts the house sparrows. The European house sparrows don't have beak power to crack open black oil sunflower seed like Cardinals, Grosbeaks, and other woodpeckers that manage to get past the shell. Those European house sparrows are easily mistaken for our own native sparrows, especially on the female side of things. Only the adult male has that distinctive black patch on their chests. The juvenile male and female birds are look so close to our native sparrows that it is nearly impossible to tell them apart at the short glance they give us.

  • @sonofthunder.
    @sonofthunder. 9 днів тому +1

    Got fondant on about 15 or so colonies and even packed down 2 ,that needed less space ,going to bee cold,so we were lucky to get to 56°f yesterday,snows pretty much gone ,made me happy to get a peak at them

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому +1

      We could have used a warm spot like that around here :)

  • @davidoligny1051
    @davidoligny1051 7 днів тому +1

    Summer of 2023 we had a pair of Cardinals that would snag bees as they left and returned to our hive. Last summer they left the bees alone.
    What did Quinn do to win his award? Congratulations to him.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  7 днів тому

      It's kind of a good citizen award. Great with teachers, follows rules, looks out for other students and helps out. :)

    • @davidoligny1051
      @davidoligny1051 7 днів тому

      Good for him. We need more good citizens.

  • @TheKeepersHive
    @TheKeepersHive 8 днів тому +1

    Fred, never had one side of a Keeper's Hive turn into a laying worker. Yes, if you kill the queen on one side they will make emergency cells but if that emergency queen does not result in a new laying queen they do not develop into laying workers... all the bees just eventually work the other brood box and you are left with a one queen hive.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  7 днів тому

      Oh, that's great information! Very interesting, even though some say they do get laying workers when one queen fails. Sounds like a healthy dabate is on the horizon. Does the Keeper's Hive configuration aid in preventing the laying worker issue if one side loses their queen?

    • @TheKeepersHive
      @TheKeepersHive 7 днів тому

      Welcome healthy debates. Appreciate your public service announcement of the dangers of keeping two queen hives. It is hard to fully appreciate what it is like to have a colony with over 100,000 bees. What makes the Keeper's Hive design nice is you dont have to tear it all apart to do the brood inspection.. Thankfully! Weighing supers is not advised until you shake off all the bees and get the boxes into the honey house or you will be running for the forest.

  • @kushytooshybees
    @kushytooshybees 9 днів тому +1

    We keep Purple Martins, but only keep a 4 gourd pole. We DO have a dragon fly problem in the fall. Maybe we need more grouds.

  • @NKYHoneyBees
    @NKYHoneyBees 5 днів тому +1

    Hi Fred, you had a website where you can see which fields around were sprayed with pesticide. Would you mind sharing that?

  • @seanrichardson881
    @seanrichardson881 8 днів тому +1

    Well fred, the deer are hungry! You should plant a big strip of turnips and radishes for them to dig up in the winter. Ever find shed antlers laying out there?

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому +1

      Antlers in the woods... there is plenty of forage out there :) I'm not planting anything to bring them in. In the past, they ate my holly bushed down to twigs (';')...

  • @davidhorsley4657
    @davidhorsley4657 9 днів тому +1

    I love purple martins and miss them a lot. We had beaucoups of them in Houston, but have failed utterly to attract them here in the Panhandle. Our western kingbirds (flycatcher family) eat a few bees daily but don't make a dent in a strong hive.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому +1

      Maybe you'll be able to bring them back? I had not idea how dependent they are upon old men (';')( ';').... we have flycatchers too :)

  • @darwinuyaguari1778
    @darwinuyaguari1778 9 днів тому +1

    Thanks for all information you share. How do you remove the dead bees from an apimaye hive and how do you apply the oxalic acid vaporizer? Thanks

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому +1

      For Apimaye, I pull the bottom tray and dump it out. I wish they had a difference entrance that would permit dead bee removal at the entrance. This is how I do OA in an Apimaye: ua-cam.com/video/yYpnqrjK_xg/v-deo.htmlsi=BwaDDiClS6liZhwU

    • @darwinuyaguari1778
      @darwinuyaguari1778 8 днів тому

      Thank you, this is my firts year and I have apimaye hives. Thanks for all information

  • @Rhams3y
    @Rhams3y 6 днів тому +1

    I have a bunch if opossums on my property and I've never seen them show interest in my hives. They usually truck along between them eating ticks. Is this a winter behavior?

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  5 днів тому

      They eat dead and living bugs mostly on the ground. Hard to resist frozen bees on a landing board when you consider that those bees also may have honey remnants in their abdomens. I consider them to be low, to no, stress on a bee colony.

  • @michaelshelnutt3534
    @michaelshelnutt3534 8 днів тому +1

    Maybe you need a motorized scarecrow that’s connected to your alarms to add some motion to scare away the critters not affected by the noise and lights.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  7 днів тому

      Hi Michael, they did finally walk away, but deer are a challenge once they know something worth eating is there. It's fun to figure out deterrents :)

  • @saintjohncoleman8602
    @saintjohncoleman8602 9 днів тому +1

    I used to be concerned about predators like assassin bugs, jumping spiders, dragonflies, praying mantises, etc, but I made some observations “did the calculus”and realized that at least in my area of SE coastal VA, predation is no big deal mathematically, except when queen rearing, where one eaten queen can ruin your day. I don’t have purple martins though, so made no purple Martin observations.

  • @davidpotts3844
    @davidpotts3844 8 днів тому +1

    Fred you rock

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому

      Thanks, David :)

    • @davidpotts3844
      @davidpotts3844 8 днів тому

      @@FrederickDunn I have 8 hives over wintering in Ky near Nashville may lose
      1 hive but that's okay. I can still make 30 hives through the season using double screen boards

    • @davidpotts3844
      @davidpotts3844 8 днів тому

      I figured to lose 6 of 30 in my factors

  • @LuckyCrownHoney
    @LuckyCrownHoney 9 днів тому +1

    Ayyyye Fred! Love the intro, as always!

    • @LuckyCrownHoney
      @LuckyCrownHoney 9 днів тому +1

      1:36 Congrats Supervisor Quinn!

    • @LuckyCrownHoney
      @LuckyCrownHoney 9 днів тому

      10:14 😂

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  9 днів тому +1

      I am so glad :) So nice to see your comment as always :)

    • @LuckyCrownHoney
      @LuckyCrownHoney 9 днів тому

      31:08 Something to be aware of is legal consequences of “warning” signs on your property. I have been told that if you have “Beware of Dog” or other “Caution” signs, that it can possibly be read legally that you were “aware of danger.” That your dog, or in this case, bees, were dangerous, and therefore if they bite, or sting, you are responsible for any injuries acquired on your property by such subject. Even if the injured party is trespassing illegally, including with “no trespassing signs.” This is probably a state by state thing though, but here in MD, it’s definitely a possibility. The signs around my apiary just state “honeybees hard at work.”

  • @1turf32
    @1turf32 9 днів тому +1

    Congratulations to Quinn

  • @gigihenderson8567
    @gigihenderson8567 9 днів тому +1

    Congrats to Quinn! Try to stay warm, I saw they are predicting a polar vortex coming in soon. (I’m in Northern CA, so not going to get too cold).

  • @robertlewis3336
    @robertlewis3336 9 днів тому +1

    Martins are awesome mosquito catchers.

  • @jasonseaward8506
    @jasonseaward8506 9 днів тому +1

    I just heard about Tung oil, do you have any experience with it?

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому

      Requires frequent refreshing and takes quite a while to set. I've used it back in the 80's but not my choice for bee hive boxes.

    • @jasonseaward8506
      @jasonseaward8506 5 днів тому

      @FrederickDunn thank you. I had just learned of it and was curious

  • @DerekCampbellIS
    @DerekCampbellIS 6 днів тому +1

    maybe for a little quicker reaction to the warning siren...we add a sound file similar to what Kevin used on Home Alone...a tommy gun...guessing that's one that will frighten them away quickly.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  6 днів тому

      They eventually stopped coming. It was a slow-deterrent, but finally worked. :)

  • @joejackson9214
    @joejackson9214 9 днів тому +1

    Fred,
    Is it true that glass jars won’t crystallize as fast as plastic?

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому +1

      I can't make that connection at all. When you consider how and why honey crystalizes, a glass or plastic container shouldn't alter that. I only use glass for my honey.

    • @joejackson9214
      @joejackson9214 8 днів тому +1

      @ I have bottled in glass and plastic the same day, and the plastic has crystallized, but the glass has not. I did some research online and that’s what I found out.

    • @joejackson9214
      @joejackson9214 8 днів тому +1

      @ I am transitioning to all glass this year

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому

      @ Please share any studies you have. I can't find any scientific resource that supports crystallization based on plastic vs glass. www.thepharmajournal.com/special-issue?year=2021&vol=10&issue=5S&ArticleId=6213

  • @jamesbarron1202
    @jamesbarron1202 9 днів тому +1

    Dragonfly’s are the #1 predator of adult mosquitoes and martins love dragonfly’s and that’s why I backed out of putting up marten houses and went with a huge bat house instead. I have both bats and dragonfly’s to eat mosquitos. Dragonfly’s eat much more mosquitoes than martens from my research. The dragonfly’s aren’t flying much when the bats are active. Maybe just 30 minutes at dusk when my bats leave their house to feed.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому

      Since the mosquitoes are most active just after dark, how are the Purple Martins finding them? We have bats here also. Hummingbirds also eat mosquitos, and they hunt them in the woods. All very interesting, thanks for sharing.

  • @claudesully
    @claudesully 8 днів тому +1

    🦌🦌🦌🦌🦌🦌🦌

  • @PYehl1
    @PYehl1 8 днів тому +1

    I stand on being a stat against what you stated. We purchased the Elevator sparrow trap and got rid of 95 house sparrows this year. Not for the faint of heart tho. Ya feel like crap but we don’t keep purple martins (yet) but we do have blue bird and tree swallow nesting boxes in our pasture which the invasive English House Sparrows will invade and kill the nesting native birds. With the trap you do have to make sure a native sparrow doesn’t get in there by mistake. A few times we had to rescue a tree or white crowned sparrow. So you have to know your birds if trapping to dispatch them.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому

      I'm not sure what you mean by a "stat against what you stated"? What are you against? ua-cam.com/video/oUhrXfiXTUA/v-deo.htmlsi=VsQIvsp-WxxkQMl2

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому

      Oh, you mean what the PurpleMartinSociety put out regarding most women not being willing to dispatch sparrows and other predators of Purple Martins. journals.lww.com/coas/fulltext/2019/17030/resisting_extinction__purple_martins,_death,_and.1.aspx

    • @PYehl1
      @PYehl1 8 днів тому +1

      @ just meant when you said women don’t take care of the house sparrows.. we dispatched them- 2 women.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому +1

      @@PYehl1 Yes, I was surprised that they said that. I've included the link/source. My sister-in-law falls into the category of not defending her Purple Martins. I'm glad you are someone who does :)

  • @jasonseaward8506
    @jasonseaward8506 8 днів тому +1

    At this moment, it's raining and 2°c (melting the snow) and as the day goes by, its going to cool off to -10°c today, and the next cpl days its lowering even cooler to -20°c. Normally my winters stay around freezing, with minimal snow but go and figure, the winter i start keeping bees, i have a horrible winter lol 😅

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому

      In spite of all of those weather challenges, I'm glad you are able to winter your bees :)

    • @jasonseaward8506
      @jasonseaward8506 5 днів тому

      @FrederickDunn so far so good 🤞🏻

  • @davidpotts3844
    @davidpotts3844 8 днів тому +1

    Fred, you got 2 . 2 k views

  • @raymschmidt6032
    @raymschmidt6032 9 днів тому +1

    Good job sup!

  • @ronsmith2946
    @ronsmith2946 8 днів тому +1

    I had to remove my Purple Martin houses as I could not get virgin queens mated and returned to the hive.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  7 днів тому

      I'm curious how you knew that it was the Purple Martins that nabbed your virgin queens? What time of year to the Purple Martins show up? Would it be possible to do your mating/splits earlier than the Martin gathering? Just tossing out thoughts here. Thanks for sharing.

    • @ronsmith2946
      @ronsmith2946 7 днів тому

      @@FrederickDunn After I removed the martin boxes I have not had any trouble getting mated queens back. You could sit out and watch the martins dive bomb the hives about 30 to 50 ft. above them.

    • @ronsmith2946
      @ronsmith2946 7 днів тому

      @@FrederickDunn Martins scouts show up here the end of February or first of March

  • @kennith.
    @kennith. 9 днів тому +1

    Thank you, Fred. Congrats to Quinn. Similar to the others, I can't wait till spring so I can follow the series on the keeper's hive / flow frames combo.

  • @mrw2403
    @mrw2403 9 днів тому +1

    Never heard of a purple martin till now. I see they are apparently in my area( eastern KY). Have yet to notice any. Are they pretty loud or any distinct sound?

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому

      You can google purple martin sounds and listen to their chatter... their nests are high up. I hear tree swallows quite a bit. I haven't had a Purple Martin Hotel...

  • @saintjohncoleman8602
    @saintjohncoleman8602 9 днів тому +2

    PS: I feed house sparrows to my snakes..

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому

      I approve this message... (">

    • @PYehl1
      @PYehl1 8 днів тому +1

      Great use for them!!!

  • @bthyme
    @bthyme 8 днів тому +1

    Poor hungry things...

  • @gigihenderson8567
    @gigihenderson8567 9 днів тому +1

    I am trying ti find someone around me who has wax dipping equipment. I’d love to get all my wooden ware dipped. I saw Randy Oliver’s “Current Research” session where he shared his observation of wax-dipped wood.

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn  8 днів тому

      I think there are two phases.... the first hot-dip isn't bees wax, I think it's a paraffin mix so it can be raised to higher temps to displace any moisture in the wood. Then there is a final coating of beeswax.

    • @gigihenderson8567
      @gigihenderson8567 8 днів тому +1

      yeah, Randy’s research was to evaluate different wax mixes for efficacy. His year-long experiment showed that pure microcrystalline wax held up the best over time.