@manjsher3094 You can borrow books for 2 weeks for free. You just have to apply for a library card. Every town or city in the United States has them. There are others like High Schools or Colleges and Universities that have them too. But you must be a student there th borrow the books.
@manjsher3094 I don't know if my last reply went through. A public library is a place where you can borrow books to read. They are quite common in the United States. Every city and town has at least one.
I concur with the thread creator. I have "A brief history of Black Holes" and am enjoying to read it. Dr. Becky packs it full of information in a way that is not a trudge but a joy to read. I love it too.
Good for you, enjoying some time in the Pacific Northwest! I kind of wish it had been a working vacation for you because I would have loved to see you do a lecture while you were here.
Hello, Dr.Becky, so yesterday, after only about two years, the UA-cam Gods decided to finally show me an episode of Joe Marler's podcast with you as a guest. I must say that you were absolutely wonderful and I loved every minute of the show. The question I wanted to ask is whether you've had a chance to have that coffee with Roger Penrose since then? Have a great day. Sending love from the Czech Republic.
The Rockies (Cascades, Sierras, et al) are majestic but I have to tell you I totally, completely fell in love with the Highlands. It's beauty is second to none. And there are some serious dark skies available.
The Scottish Highlands or some place else? I'd agree with you about Scotland. This English sasonach loved the Scottish Highlands, dark skies and daylight beauties. Particulary liked looking down on loch Ness and loch Lomond. Brother lived in Inverness at the time, so took the opportunity to do it. ❤
Hey, from Washington State, hope you had a good visit. My high school astronomy class really appreciates your videos and I enjoyed listening to your book this past summer.
Love your Smokey the Bear shirt. Bummed I didn't get to meet you in-person, so you'll have to come out to Washington again! I speak for everyone here, and they all feel the same way.
How mesmerizing our solar system is, when realizing the sense of incredible depth witnessing a comet near the sun, and our moon. Floating in space, worlds, real and tangible, just beyond our reach, but there.
I was able to stare long enough in C\2023's location and notice that is "twinkled" every now and then. I'm glad I was able to image it. =) Good memories for a long time.
Thank you for being someone we can live vicariously through about physics without all the hard work in the education system 😆 and for being, well, really lovely too 😍
What I find odd is that astrophysicists, used to coldly observe and analyze the Universe where you can find "quite a few" strange things every day, are surprised to find something different from the usual. You are really kids, surprised by the new things and the new toys they have in their hands....... that's great. Keep it on.
Big Bang theory says 96% of the universe is unobservable "dark" stuff and only 4% is real. Consequently, about 96% of observations will be surprising to cosmologists, because the universe is 100% real.
We are so happy your plan with Kris made your hike a breeze and helped you to not have any joint pains!🤩You are killing it! Thank you so much for sharing trainwell.
I got some great photos of the comet last night, with the full moon shining very brightly. I hope to go out again on Saturday night, before the moon rises.
Great video Becky. Always nice to get a well researched dose of space news. As a physicist myself, I was very disappointed by the Nobel price selections. AI? Really? Must be the most overhyped tech of our time.
That's how I imagine the very early universe; chaotic, some mass but almost all energy, and what mass does form is quickly energized again by... I imagine stars that supernovae in seconds(maybe minutes), not years, massive primordial black holes forming, gorging, growing.
Not related to astronomy or astrophysics, but as someone who used to spend summers at my Grandmother's house in Capitan, NM where the Smoky Bear museum and historical park are, near the Capitan Mountains where an actual bear cub was found in the aftermath of a forest fire was named after the character, I definitely approve of the shirt!
Sweet! I just saw that comment. I live in Southern Indiana. The sun had just went down but it was still bright out. No visual aids needed🔥🔥👀 thanks for letting me know about it ✌️
So I don't know how valid this is, I didn't see it personally... But my sisters who live in rhode island said they got pictures of aurora happening... so that's pretty cool
All the best scientific discoveries tend to be preceded by the phrase "Huh, that's weird." So, I'm certainly looking forward to what comes from this weird glowing galaxy observation :)
That massive OIII spike immediately makes me think of two of the more notable citizen discoveries from Galaxy Zoo: green pea galaxies and quasar ionization echoes. Both seem to be included as possible explanations in the graphic from the paper. I’d be interested in a more detailed comparison between these object classes and how unusual this object is compared to them!
I saw the comet tonight at around 7:45pm-8pm in Michigan with 7x binoculars pretty easily (it isn't absolutely clear, but it is absolutely noticeable with binoculars). It did take a bit to find, but it's almost exactly opposite the moon, twice as high in the sky. (although the moon will have moved tomorrow night - it will be lower and to the left.) The skies will be clear again tomorrow night, so, sweet!
Living on the Colorado front range, my stargazing is a tad limited. Anything low on the western horizon ends up behind the notoriously opaque Rocky Mountains.
Dr. Becky, I love this channel; I really do. As someone who lives in the State of Washington, I am sorry I missed you when you passed through my state and county. I must say that I have never heard of Mt. Renée, so I am assuming you meant (@ 6:43) Mount Rainier. Which name looks like it might be pronounced like the comparative form of 'rainy', but which we pronounce like 'ray-near', not to be confused with your pre-eminent bushcrafter, Ray Mears. The indigenous name is 'Tacoma' or 'Tahoma', but rather than ask, Captain George Vancouver of the Royal Navy decided to name it after his good friend, Rear Admiral Peter Ranier, Jr. I, myself, have often thought that the word looks French and ought to be pronounced in accord with their rules, so I get it, but such is not the case. Did you summit?
I admit I had a bit of a mood swing between the point you mentioned that NASA might not send the Europa Clipper up and then your future self correction saying that they had successfully sent it up. I am very excited about this mission, though I don't wanna wait until 2030 to start discovering neat stuff about Europa!!! Thank you so much for this awesome video. Just a question, will you do any more episodes on code/Python/Fortran usage in Astrophysics? I am also curious is Julia is catching on (the language that is).
Neural networks for physics is a borderline part, but at the same time it could be a useful tool for physics and might be useful to analyze a lot of data to reveal new possible correlations.
Dr Becky. Please check Landauer Limit using Hawking Temp for a 1KM black hole. Verify against gravity per Planck area from GR. It’s the same value, same order of magnitude too .724, almost RMS. Gravity is an expression of a particle’s causal uncertainty. When the uncertainty is resolved, the info is encoded back into spin. A’s counterfactual turns into a wormhole to make A and B local, when they are the uncertainty is resolved. Maxwell’s demon causes one unit of gravity to be emitted for each spin entangled pair. Gravity is a bit of negative energy to account for a particle containing positive energy being out of causal contact. Gravity is the coin for spooky action at a distance. Please check Landauer to GR per Planck Area. GR 1.261 x 10^-30J Landauer at a Hawking T 1.74 x 10^-30J! Do you see the significance?
Cool, I like your videos. Its like space-news, however you can say that .) Im still waiting for the z30 to be found, it will cause some trouble explaining .)
I love the 'toe-nail' moon phase, when the shadowed part of the moon is illuminated by sunlight reflected from planet Earth - with planets in the view a 3-d perspective is possible.
4:15 If you miss Mercury, be comforted by the thought that Tycho Brahe, the astronomer with the golden nose, never managed to watch Mercury either, which he even lamented on his deathbed.
Yay! I live 15 miles due south of Mt Rainier in Packwood. Wonderful areas all around to hike, outside of the Park too., Goat Rocks and Mt Adams wilderness areas.
@14:30 Minor oopsie: 2.9 billion km, not million. I wanted to watch the Clipper launch live, but sadly the delay meant I was at work. Did see the Starship launch and catch though. That was amazing! Cheers! 👍
I kind of agree with you, that it doesn't seem like that big a thing that this asteroid will momentarily 'encircle' the Earth. But the term "capture" seems inappropriate to me. When we say we think that Mars' gravitational field captured Deimos and Phobos, that seems entirely appropriate; they have remained in orbit around the planet for a long time and we know that one of them, at least, will die there in the astronomically near future. 2024 PT5, however, can only be described as temporarily detained before moving on. It will be showing its metaphorical travel documents and then be allowed to go on its way. This is just a layover on a through flight, so to speak. If we were truly capturing it, on the other hand, that would be very exciting, because we could then study it in much more detail and far more conveniently and economically that can be done with any other asteroid at present. Long term in-orbit missions as well as sample return missions lasting mere months instead of years could be done, not to mention the possibility of manned missions (not to land on but to have a close-up, real-time viewer to enhance investigation) in the very near future. And, of course, there would be a new little light in the sky, at night.
Silly o'clock in the morning is my favourite time of day. I was a baker, then a wildlife surveyor, then I done night-time site security and the whole time (till my knees gave out and I went to sit down in the back rooms of a museum updating the records of minerals and insects for a few years.) I'm a cyclist for fun who twigged that 3-6 am is the cleanest air, lowest traffic volume and most interesting skies you can get in any given 24-hour period.. the wee hours grow on ya.. lol.
dr. Becky, it’s been a pleasure viewing your videos. I’ve learned a great deal from you. I have a question. Hypothetically, if for some reason, our solar system was thrown out of the galaxy. Would it be able to survive on its own? thank you.
Why wouldn't it? Assuming the planetary orbits were not disrupted by whatever caused the Sun to be ejected from the galaxy, what would stop them from staying in those orbits later?
I just found your book in the public library in Fredericksburg, Virginia USA. It was an amazing read.
What's a public library?
@manjsher3094 You can borrow books for 2 weeks for free. You just have to apply for a library card. Every town or city in the United States has them. There are others like High Schools or Colleges and Universities that have them too. But you must be a student there th borrow the books.
@manjsher3094 I don't know if my last reply went through. A public library is a place where you can borrow books to read. They are quite common in the United States. Every city and town has at least one.
I'm a librarian in Fairfax, I have her books in for order. Thanks for being a reader!
I concur with the thread creator. I have "A brief history of Black Holes" and am enjoying to read it. Dr. Becky packs it full of information in a way that is not a trudge but a joy to read. I love it too.
I am using ‘silly o clock’ forever now! And I appreciate you using my image as one of the images you featured in this video!
Haha it’s one of my favourite phrases! That image was beautiful thanks again for sending in
@@DrBecky you are welcome!!
"Silly O'clock in the morning"
🤣 I'm going to steal that one!
So am I
Or the military equivalent: "Zero Dark-thirty" ("0:Dark-thirty")
@@atlasisshrugging when I did my time that ment dawn....
I usually use stupid o’clock but my granddaughters don’t like me using that word so it’s silly from now on.
@@LeftCoastStephen nice 👍
"silly o' clock" is the best time of the day my dear doctor. =)
Good for you, enjoying some time in the Pacific Northwest! I kind of wish it had been a working vacation for you because I would have loved to see you do a lecture while you were here.
Glad you had a nice time here in the Northwest of the US.
Hello, Dr.Becky,
so yesterday, after only about two years, the UA-cam Gods decided to finally show me an episode of Joe Marler's podcast with you as a guest.
I must say that you were absolutely wonderful and I loved every minute of the show.
The question I wanted to ask is whether you've had a chance to have that coffee with Roger Penrose since then?
Have a great day.
Sending love from the Czech Republic.
20:51 pretty cool when you get real news „from the office“ (- not like everyone else in the world just getting gossip from their workplace)
The Rockies (Cascades, Sierras, et al) are majestic but I have to tell you I totally, completely fell in love with the Highlands. It's beauty is second to none. And there are some serious dark skies available.
Somebody doesn’t like forests.
The Scottish Highlands or some place else? I'd agree with you about Scotland. This English sasonach loved the Scottish Highlands, dark skies and daylight beauties. Particulary liked looking down on loch Ness and loch Lomond. Brother lived in Inverness at the time, so took the opportunity to do it. ❤
@@noelstarchild - Yes, the Scotland Highlands.
Hey, from Washington State, hope you had a good visit. My high school astronomy class really appreciates your videos and I enjoyed listening to your book this past summer.
Love your Smokey the Bear shirt. Bummed I didn't get to meet you in-person, so you'll have to come out to Washington again! I speak for everyone here, and they all feel the same way.
Impressed you mentioned Sylvia Plath. Thank you for the video.
How mesmerizing our solar system is, when realizing the sense of incredible depth witnessing a comet near the sun, and our moon. Floating in space, worlds, real and tangible, just beyond our reach, but there.
Thanks, dr. Becky! 😊
But yeah, it's spring here in Brazil... But really rainy. 😢
Anyway, stay safe there with your family! 🖖😊
So glad you had such a great time hiking here in my beloved Washington state!
Just realized I wasn’t subscribed and I apologize. I love your monthly chats and look forward to them. Like and subscribed, finally.
I was able to stare long enough in C\2023's location and notice that is "twinkled" every now and then. I'm glad I was able to image it. =) Good memories for a long time.
Thank you for being someone we can live vicariously through about physics without all the hard work in the education system 😆 and for being, well, really lovely too 😍
Glad to hear you enjoyed our beautiful Pacific Northwest. 🗻
What I find odd is that astrophysicists, used to coldly observe and analyze the Universe where you can find "quite a few" strange things every day, are surprised to find something different from the usual.
You are really kids, surprised by the new things and the new toys they have in their hands....... that's great. Keep it on.
Big Bang theory says 96% of the universe is unobservable "dark" stuff and only 4% is real. Consequently, about 96% of observations will be surprising to cosmologists, because the universe is 100% real.
We are so happy your plan with Kris made your hike a breeze and helped you to not have any joint pains!🤩You are killing it! Thank you so much for sharing trainwell.
I got some great photos of the comet last night, with the full moon shining very brightly. I hope to go out again on Saturday night, before the moon rises.
That comet reminds me of McNaught 2007.. what a sight. I saw Haley's comet in 85, McNaught wiped the floor with it.
Great video Becky. Always nice to get a well researched dose of space news.
As a physicist myself, I was very disappointed by the Nobel price selections. AI? Really? Must be the most overhyped tech of our time.
I wish they would stop calling it artificial intelligence. It would be better termed inductive statistics.
@@Carusus1 I call it 'received wisdom'.
The Comet, draw a line from Arcturus to Venus, the Comet is halve way, use a bino to see it..
Wurmp’s visibility in Times Square shows its potential! I’m all in!
Absolutely like your every videos and the facts and news 😊
Thank you for explaining HERA, everyone was mentioning "it is needed" without clear-cut concise summary, now I understand.
I love the space grade zip tie at 14:48
"@ silly o'clock in the morning."😆
That's how I imagine the very early universe; chaotic, some mass but almost all energy, and what mass does form is quickly energized again by... I imagine stars that supernovae in seconds(maybe minutes), not years, massive primordial black holes forming, gorging, growing.
Not related to astronomy or astrophysics, but as someone who used to spend summers at my Grandmother's house in Capitan, NM where the Smoky Bear museum and historical park are, near the Capitan Mountains where an actual bear cub was found in the aftermath of a forest fire was named after the character, I definitely approve of the shirt!
Sweet! I just saw that comment. I live in Southern Indiana. The sun had just went down but it was still bright out. No visual aids needed🔥🔥👀 thanks for letting me know about it ✌️
@Dr Becky I don't know if you will see this but it would be really cool to get your opinion on the show 3 Body Problem! Thanks!
I saw aurora and a comet in the past week, its been awesome!
Thank You, Dr Becky
The near full moon sure reduced the visibility of C/2023 A3. But I helped a bunch of people see it on the 14th & 15th. Very fun to see
I was on, I think perhaps, that exact same trail in August.
I was watching the piece about the DART mission and wondered did changing the orbit of Didymos also affect the path of Dimorphos?
3:12 "Handileee" 😂❤
It's another great video. Becky looks beautiful. She's the No.1 UA-camr science educator / Astrophysicist. Brains and beauty A perfect combination ❤😊
Any plans to do a video on the Euclid telescope observation sample?
So I don't know how valid this is, I didn't see it personally... But my sisters who live in rhode island said they got pictures of aurora happening... so that's pretty cool
Don't forget to feed the cat! That's important.
It's amazing that our Sun bends that comet's trajectory basically like a horseshoe
Psychology is just biology
Biology is just chemistry
Chemistry is just physics
Physics is just math
Math is just...logic?
Great stuff as always. Thank you. Was wondering what the latest is on the OSIRIS-REx mission is. Have they examined the material collected yet?
Love this kind of news!! Thanks
All the best scientific discoveries tend to be preceded by the phrase "Huh, that's weird." So, I'm certainly looking forward to what comes from this weird glowing galaxy observation :)
That massive OIII spike immediately makes me think of two of the more notable citizen discoveries from Galaxy Zoo: green pea galaxies and quasar ionization echoes. Both seem to be included as possible explanations in the graphic from the paper. I’d be interested in a more detailed comparison between these object classes and how unusual this object is compared to them!
12:45 Made me think of XKCD 435: Purity
I've had gas all day, can't see anything. I think my eyeballs are melting. Love you
I saw the comet tonight at around 7:45pm-8pm in Michigan with 7x binoculars pretty easily (it isn't absolutely clear, but it is absolutely noticeable with binoculars).
It did take a bit to find, but it's almost exactly opposite the moon, twice as high in the sky. (although the moon will have moved tomorrow night - it will be lower and to the left.)
The skies will be clear again tomorrow night, so, sweet!
Love Smokey. Cool sweatshirt.
Trainwell is pretty solid. I’m at 45 days.
See you in two years Didymos! ☄🛰
I just missed A3 earlier this evening
Wild AF that the gas falling into that AGN could vastly outshined the gas that had coalesced into stars in this galaxy.
Living on the Colorado front range, my stargazing is a tad limited. Anything low on the western horizon ends up behind the notoriously opaque Rocky Mountains.
I adore your enthusiasm. Really the only place I come for cosmology, astrophysical tidbits anymore
20:56 could it be an active Galactic nuclei having jetted into some giant gas cloud? Could this be another Hanny’s voorwerp?
Saw the comet, one evening, last Monday, ...naturally we got clouds the rest of the week... Took some pictures and put them on my youtube channel :)
I am buying a telescope for xmas. Thank you!
Dr. Becky, I love this channel; I really do. As someone who lives in the State of Washington, I am sorry I missed you when you passed through my state and county. I must say that I have never heard of Mt. Renée, so I am assuming you meant (@ 6:43) Mount Rainier. Which name looks like it might be pronounced like the comparative form of 'rainy', but which we pronounce like 'ray-near', not to be confused with your pre-eminent bushcrafter, Ray Mears. The indigenous name is 'Tacoma' or 'Tahoma', but rather than ask, Captain George Vancouver of the Royal Navy decided to name it after his good friend, Rear Admiral Peter Ranier, Jr.
I, myself, have often thought that the word looks French and ought to be pronounced in accord with their rules, so I get it, but such is not the case.
Did you summit?
She said Rainier in her somewhat non-rhotic accent.
Brits tend to use the original French pronunciation whereas USAians tend to use Slavic pronunciation.
Over here in Pune we have had cloudy skies for last couple of days making comet sighting impossible.
I admit I had a bit of a mood swing between the point you mentioned that NASA might not send the Europa Clipper up and then your future self correction saying that they had successfully sent it up. I am very excited about this mission, though I don't wanna wait until 2030 to start discovering neat stuff about Europa!!! Thank you so much for this awesome video.
Just a question, will you do any more episodes on code/Python/Fortran usage in Astrophysics? I am also curious is Julia is catching on (the language that is).
Heck. A person would be crazy to get up at “silly o’clock” LOL
This video goes nicely as a chaser after HyperspacePirate's latest DIY heat pump video.
I can't believe you came to the Cascades and didn't call me! LOL
Seeing Wurmp in Times Square proves this meme coin is a rising star!
When will we get a new show called ESA: CSI?
European Space Agency: Crash Scene Investigation
I love the shirt. Smokey the bear
Neural networks for physics is a borderline part, but at the same time it could be a useful tool for physics and might be useful to analyze a lot of data to reveal new possible correlations.
Dr Becky. Please check Landauer Limit using Hawking Temp for a 1KM black hole. Verify against gravity per Planck area from GR. It’s the same value, same order of magnitude too .724, almost RMS. Gravity is an expression of a particle’s causal uncertainty. When the uncertainty is resolved, the info is encoded back into spin. A’s counterfactual turns into a wormhole to make A and B local, when they are the uncertainty is resolved. Maxwell’s demon causes one unit of gravity to be emitted for each spin entangled pair. Gravity is a bit of negative energy to account for a particle containing positive energy being out of causal contact. Gravity is the coin for spooky action at a distance. Please check Landauer to
GR per Planck Area. GR 1.261 x 10^-30J
Landauer at a Hawking T 1.74 x 10^-30J! Do you see the significance?
Cool, I like your videos. Its like space-news, however you can say that .) Im still waiting for the z30 to be found, it will cause some trouble explaining .)
“Because physics is everything”. Oops wrong channel 😂
Weekly banger is here
I love the 'toe-nail' moon phase, when the shadowed part of the moon is illuminated by sunlight reflected from planet Earth - with planets in the view a 3-d perspective is possible.
😂.. ok well your definitely a fan. ..
I'd love to have lunch,see how far our normal chats could be out of this worldly.interesting pics..nice to spend time with you xo
You shine lady🤩
You have a few Australian followers here, any chance of showing some sky news for us.
4:15 If you miss Mercury, be comforted by the thought that Tycho Brahe, the astronomer with the golden nose, never managed to watch Mercury either, which he even lamented on his deathbed.
Yay! I live 15 miles due south of Mt Rainier in Packwood. Wonderful areas all around to hike, outside of the Park too., Goat Rocks and Mt Adams wilderness areas.
@14:30 Minor oopsie: 2.9 billion km, not million. I wanted to watch the Clipper launch live, but sadly the delay meant I was at work. Did see the Starship launch and catch though. That was amazing! Cheers! 👍
I think you should say "The DART mission was a HIT" eh? Get it?
Love your shirt
I kind of agree with you, that it doesn't seem like that big a thing that this asteroid will momentarily 'encircle' the Earth. But the term "capture" seems inappropriate to me. When we say we think that Mars' gravitational field captured Deimos and Phobos, that seems entirely appropriate; they have remained in orbit around the planet for a long time and we know that one of them, at least, will die there in the astronomically near future. 2024 PT5, however, can only be described as temporarily detained before moving on. It will be showing its metaphorical travel documents and then be allowed to go on its way. This is just a layover on a through flight, so to speak.
If we were truly capturing it, on the other hand, that would be very exciting, because we could then study it in much more detail and far more conveniently and economically that can be done with any other asteroid at present. Long term in-orbit missions as well as sample return missions lasting mere months instead of years could be done, not to mention the possibility of manned missions (not to land on but to have a close-up, real-time viewer to enhance investigation) in the very near future. And, of course, there would be a new little light in the sky, at night.
Unusually hot stars in the early universe? Could this finally be Population 3 stars?
I am waiting to see how many of the bloopers involve her explaining the concept of a neural network.
In regards to my subscriptions she got the scoop on this one. 😜☠️😜
Silly o'clock in the morning is my favourite time of day. I was a baker, then a wildlife surveyor, then I done night-time site security and the whole time (till my knees gave out and I went to sit down in the back rooms of a museum updating the records of minerals and insects for a few years.) I'm a cyclist for fun who twigged that 3-6 am is the cleanest air, lowest traffic volume and most interesting skies you can get in any given 24-hour period.. the wee hours grow on ya.. lol.
I saw the comet from California 😊
Fog/dust obscures light in space despite gravity... crazy
I love Night Sky News!!
Didymus literally means "twin"
2:30 awesome sight considering its once in a lifetime. (80,000 years is a long time)
dr. Becky, it’s been a pleasure viewing your videos. I’ve learned a great deal from you. I have a question. Hypothetically, if for some reason, our solar system was thrown out of the galaxy. Would it be able to survive on its own? thank you.
Why wouldn't it? Assuming the planetary orbits were not disrupted by whatever caused the Sun to be ejected from the galaxy, what would stop them from staying in those orbits later?
Thanks!!
A second moon? Steven Fry and Alan Davies will be apoplectic! 😁😁
My thoughts exactly.
I prefer “fingernail moon.” My toenails are usually hidden beneath sox and inside footwear.
As an Elder Scrolls fan I concur.
far less audience for that on OnlyMoons
maybe you could have fingernail moons for new moon crescents, and toenail moons for the waning crescent moon ?
Even after they are cut/when you're cutting them?
Where they belong :)