How Big Is The Sun?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 кві 2015
  • Thanks to www.squarespace.com/minutephysics for sponsoring this video!
    MinutePhysics is on Google+ - bit.ly/qzEwc6
    And facebook - / minutephysics
    And twitter - @minutephysics
    Minute Physics provides an energetic and entertaining view of old and new problems in physics -- all in a minute!
    Music by Nathaniel Schroeder / drschroeder
    Thanks to the following Subbable subscribers for making MinutePhysics possible:
    Gina and Jeff Ross
    Bobby Ross
    Gracie Ross
    Gwen Stacy Spider Cat
    Annie Shutelock
    EZ8-D
    Tobias Kallehauge
    Casper Kristensen
    Stephen Petty Valenzuela
    alertthemedic
    QuantumRealityProject.com
    Ian Gallagher
    Kathy Whalen
    Pablo Soares
    Jenny Katzer
    tuseroni
    ElwoodsChannel
    / elwoodschannel
    @JessieBakes
    David McCamey
    @jiveforceone
    @DEVORE
    Peta Cuttell
    Zoe Reidinger
    Chris Ronderos, Dallas, TX
    Mike Cannizzaro
    Robyn King
    Ryan Schauer
    Simon Francis Max Bild-Enkin
    Frysann
    Damien Bargiacchi
    Douglas Heanssler
    coldarrow
    / thesimplescientist
    Wim Pierson
    @terinjokes
    Antoniu Stefan
    Caryn Pavlak: carynpavlak
    Marcus Bolmstedt
    Kathryn
    @TBSkyen
    @KnowledgePLists www.KnowledgePlaylists.com
    iylanna
    Steven Klurfeld
    John Harman (from Dayton,OH)!
    Mason R Norris @masonrnorris
    alkemann
    Gustav Delius
    This video made possible by the following Patreon Supporters:
    Mark
    Wes Brown
    John Green
    Florian Philipp
    Rens van der Heijden
    Bob Bolch
    Daniel Ametsreiter
    Joël Quenneville
    Richard Pearson
    David Dailey
    Steven Mulder
    Karim
    Ethi Raj
    Ryan Kyle
    William Ricketts
    Collin Mandris
    Matt
    Jonathan Foster
    Siddharth Sadanand
    Maarten Daalder
    Robby Olivam
    Alan Browning
    Jonathan Piersa
    Julia Person
    James Craver
    Sarah Chavis
    Yonatan Bisk
    Richard Campbell
    Chris Barrett
    Jan A
    Christopher Coleman
    Daniel “YoureDown” Breger
    Hendrik Payer
    Daniel Yip
    Matt K
    William Pearson
    Kevin Lynch
    Nick Ward
    Kevin
    john eriksson
    Allan Farrell
    Tobias Olesen
    Chris Chapin
    Michael Keefe
    Jon Mann
    Bert Goethals
    Joji Wata
    Adam Naber
    Rob Ibsen
    Jacob Gumpert
    Peter Collier
    Andi Davis
    Aarthy
    Raymond Cason
    Evan Gale
    Paul
    Tori McClanahan
    Andrew Stobie
    Dominik Steenken
    Danilo Metzger
    Christian Altenhofen
    Ezra Lee
    Roy Morgan
    Olivia Darroch
    Amber Ciarvella
    ryan horlacher
    Keith Chang
    Milokot
    Janel Christensen
    Will Scherer
    Mike Fulcher
    Larom Lancaster
    Liam Callaway
    John Harman
    Christos Papandreou
    Fernando Pazin
    Johnathon Kinville
    Jason Medrano
    Andrew Barnett
    Katharina Schuchmann
    John Gietzen
    Michael Tardibuono
    Matthew Hebert
    Christy Filipich
    Pierre-Louis Bourgeois
    Genevieve Lawrence
    Brian D’Agostini
    Chris
    Dominik Menzi
    Ryan A. Schauer
    Daniel Johnson
    Nico Houbraken
    Michael Carr
    Ragnhild
    Elizabeth Meisterling
    Lysann Schlegel
    Magnus Krokstad
    Chase Turner
    Owain Blackwood
    Russ Arrell
    Brenden Bullock
    Asaf Gartner
    Mark Samberg
    Tina Johnston
    Mike Cochrane
    Tom Murphy
    Peter L
    Jeff
    Erica Pratt
    David
    Artur Szczypta
    David Drueding
    Nicklas Ulvnäs
    Nigel W
    James Nelson
    Mary Foster-Smith
    Clayton Neff
    Michael Merino
    Jason and Gayle Corfman
    Mihaly Barasz
    Steven Klurfeld
    Richard Bairwell
    Tamas Bartal
    Erven
    Justin Prahl
    Michael Maitlen
    John Harman
    Hans van Staveren
    Kasey
    Karlin Nazario
    M K
    Jacques LABBÉ
    Geralyn Byers
    jason black
    Candice Blodgett
    Daniel Gibbs
    Henry Berthelsen
    Andy Kittner
    Steve Hall
    Erdumas
    Rob Snyder
    John Kelly
    Jessica Rosenstein
    Bill Tomiyasu
    Vasco Simões
    Eoin
    Simon Hammersley
    iain
    Holger
    Alexis Carpenter
    Jay Goodman
    Joseph Perry
    Mark Govea
    Eduardo Rampelotto Gatto Created by Henry Reich
  • Наука та технологія

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,8 тис.

  • @enoraskye6020
    @enoraskye6020 8 років тому +124

    In 8th grade, I did a scale model of the solar system. This included scale distance. In order to keep all the planets within school grounds, I had to make my sun the size of a tennis ball, and all my planets were nothing more than a speck of sand (or smaller). Mercury, Venus and Earth were in the Auditorium, where my sun was. Mars, Jupiter, Saturn and Uranus were in the Hall. Neptune in the Gym, and Pluto (which was still a planet when I was a kid) was placed just barely on school grounds, in the baseball field). I haven't done the math recently, but I want to say it was just around 1000 feet from my scale sun. My science teacher said it was the coolest solar system model she had ever seen.

    • @ericgolightly8450
      @ericgolightly8450 Рік тому +3

      That's so cool! I wanna do that

    • @zixiany
      @zixiany 11 місяців тому +3

      the scale model of anything in the universe is the hardest thing ever. the nearest star would be about 1500 km (900 miles) away

  • @neilmcmahon
    @neilmcmahon 9 років тому +99

    It's so big that it's own gravitational field is keeping it alive.

  • @JasonWMorningwood
    @JasonWMorningwood 9 років тому +664

    Here is my script for this video:
    INTRO
    "So how big is the sun?"
    "Huge"
    OUTRO

    • @22NightWing
      @22NightWing 9 років тому +9

      Jason W. Morningwood My jimmies have been educated.

    • @Ragnarockalypse
      @Ragnarockalypse 9 років тому +3

      Jason W. Morningwood What about *VY Canis Majoris?*

    • @JasonWMorningwood
      @JasonWMorningwood 9 років тому +8

      Ragnarockalypse
      INTRO
      "So how big is VY Canis Majoris"
      "Ludicrously humongous multiplied by a factor of 6.9"
      Outro

    • @Ragnarockalypse
      @Ragnarockalypse 9 років тому +2

      Jason W. Morningwood Excellent! Though I just made a search and found out that UY Scuti is even bigger than that. The Universe is OP.

    • @JasonWMorningwood
      @JasonWMorningwood 9 років тому

      Ragnarockalypse At that point you just change the multiplier accordingly ;)

  • @iidirectxii7545
    @iidirectxii7545 8 років тому +150

    How big is the Sun ? Answer - fucking huge.

    • @GnawedChan
      @GnawedChan 8 років тому +5

      +II DIRECTx II look up VY Canis Majoris

    • @iidirectxii7545
      @iidirectxii7545 8 років тому +2

      Beef Master Just blows your mind how big some of the stars are out there and how far away they are. Considering how big they are we still can't see them without high powered telescopes, this just gives us a tiny idea how huge our galaxy is, nevermind how big the universe is. Simply amazing.

    • @GnawedChan
      @GnawedChan 8 років тому +3

      II DIRECTx II Yeah watching some of those videos which compare star sizes with our own Sun literally scare me and fascinate me, theres so much out there we don't know about .

    • @anshulkatare
      @anshulkatare 8 років тому +1

      +II DIRECTx II yuuuuuge!!!

    • @thepileofcrates7104
      @thepileofcrates7104 8 років тому

      13333333337 meters tall

  • @454ffv
    @454ffv 9 років тому +301

    wait so how bigs the sun

    • @almightyshippo1197
      @almightyshippo1197 9 років тому +15

      454ffv Mass: 1.989E30 kg
      Radius: 695,800 km (1 R☉)

    • @Dimitar997
      @Dimitar997 9 років тому

      454ffv well if its radius is 10x of that of Jupiter, then it's about 1000 times bigger than Jupiter.

    • @Dimitar997
      @Dimitar997 9 років тому

      Shakih Sokamer maybe

    • @zool201975
      @zool201975 9 років тому

      454ffv i think we just cant really scale these things mentally anyway. we can understand the immensity but like lets say we can picture a meter we cant picture a million meters. so its really impossible for any of us to really scale of a continent let alone something even bigger.
      still i reckon we could get closer to really picturing it if wed use virtual reality and tinker with things like the distance between the earth and the sun reduced to the distance of the moon. how does the sky and horizon look then.

    • @CheCheDaWaff
      @CheCheDaWaff 9 років тому +5

      ***** Actually you _can_ just cube it!
      If you scale up any object x times in 3D space it's volume will go up x^3 times.
      If you don't believe me try this:
      Volume of Jupiter is: (4/3)* pi* (R^3) [where R is radius of Jupiter]
      The Sun has 10 times the radius, which is 10*R
      Therefore the volume of the Sun is: (4/3)* pi* (10*R)^3
      Which is: (4/3)* pi* (R^3)* (10^3)
      You can see that this is just 10^3 times the volume of Jupiter!

  • @mgsquared5204
    @mgsquared5204 8 років тому +140

    Wait so if I put a pie in the sky about 30 ft. Up IT WILL HAVE THE SAME TIDAL FORCES OF THE MOON?!?!?!

    • @BoomBrush
      @BoomBrush 8 років тому +16

      +Michael Guiliano this is the best comment ive seen all day

    • @hazardeur
      @hazardeur 8 років тому +18

      not sure but i think you're missing this one: "In fact, any two objects of ROUGHLY THE SAME DENSITY...."

    • @jonedwards5953
      @jonedwards5953 8 років тому +7

      +Hazardeur stone ball then

    • @justtemporaryreally4086
      @justtemporaryreally4086 8 років тому +6

      Yeah the identical apparent size and identical pull seem to be unrelated in reality. The gravitational force of an object is supposed to be proportional to its mass, regardless of size, and also, given the same density, mass is NOT proportional to size, it goes up exponentially (that and a hydrogen based star is definitely not dense compared to a chunk of rock.).
      The fact the moon has the same gravitational pull as the sun has nothing to do with its identical apparent size but only a combination of mass and distance, and could be explained by saying the only "stable" orbital distance where the moon could settle was with equal pull from the sun and earth.
      However, calling the identical apparent size of the sun and moon a mere coincidence sounds to me at best like lazy science. Some scientists just don't like admitting they don't know something like it was something to be ashamed of.

    • @jonedwards5953
      @jonedwards5953 8 років тому +1

      EXACTLY

  • @amshermansen
    @amshermansen 9 років тому +243

    How Big Is The Sun?
    Second Answer: Like, Big. Really big.

    • @alfredomarquez1916
      @alfredomarquez1916 9 років тому +34

      Mansen I'm partial to 'Pretty fucking big'.

    • @HiItsSalty
      @HiItsSalty 9 років тому

      Alfredo Marquez unfortunately in a family friendly video i wouldnt say that even though i probably swear way more that you

    • @terryflopycow2231
      @terryflopycow2231 9 років тому +5

      Mansen Nothin on this beast!!!
      i.imgur.com/7aYbwwY.png

    • @TheRealSkeletor
      @TheRealSkeletor 9 років тому +6

      Mansen "Space," says the introduction to The Hitchhiker's Guide, "is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is," and so on.

    • @amshermansen
      @amshermansen 9 років тому +1

      Skeletor Jopko Good times, good...times.

  • @ultravidz
    @ultravidz 9 років тому +24

    Now THIS is the kinda MinutePhysics I remember!

  • @homegirl44
    @homegirl44 9 років тому +386

    Me after the quick scientific calculations towards the end of the video:
    ".........what?"

    • @VEE727
      @VEE727 9 років тому +34

      Yeah he's rushing through the videos now. I don't understand why

    • @juvasaditya6384
      @juvasaditya6384 9 років тому +1

      True

    • @deamon6681
      @deamon6681 9 років тому +52

      VEE727 Wait what? As far as I remember that was the concept about minutephysics.

    • @LightningSonic
      @LightningSonic 9 років тому +2

      VEE727 To fully grasp or commit all the information to heart, it sometimes requires many multiple viewings and note-taking. But I get the gist of what he's saying in this video. He said that if two planets (in this case the sun and the moon) appear to have the same size, their radii divided by their distances (from earth to the respective planet) are roughly equivalent between the two.So, (and I looked up the data to calculate this) the one is 0.0045186952235024 and the other is 0.0046366666666667. Basically, they're the same. That's the result of dividing the radius of the moon with the distance from earth to it, and then the same with the sun.
      It's a factoid. It doesn't provide much use, but is interesting.

    • @zolikoff
      @zolikoff 9 років тому +17

      VEE727 Didn't rush that part. He showed the formula for the gravitational tidal force to demonstrate that it is, in fact, proportional to (r/d)^3.
      It's just simple math that doesn't need explanation; anyone who knows the formula will understand it, and anyone who doesn't know the formula won't understand any explanation given for it unless he reads up on it. For such a person, it is enough for the purpose of the video to just state that the tidal force *is* proportional to that formula, without any further explanation.

  • @dryued6874
    @dryued6874 9 років тому +30

    Curiosity photographs martian solar eclipses?
    It's even more awesome than I thought.

  • @jeffdazle
    @jeffdazle 9 років тому +86

    Make video on the biggest star in our galaxy

    • @sratra1
      @sratra1 9 років тому +4

      Jeff Pierre I think that would be fun to watch too but I dont think he would do it because people would say its unoriginal. There's tons of videos that are already out there on UA-cam for this.

    • @zolikoff
      @zolikoff 9 років тому +1

      sratra1 Perhaps it would be fun to explain how all those videos are wrong because they depict smooth spherical objects for those stars, when in reality they'd be uneven, swelling globs of a very low density gas.

    • @zolikoff
      @zolikoff 9 років тому

      Chillbro Swaggins Nope. At its outer edges it's much closer to vacuum than to the density of air.

    • @Mar184
      @Mar184 9 років тому +1

      ***** Haha, nice one! :D

    • @VedavyasMunugoor
      @VedavyasMunugoor 9 років тому

      Does anyone know what the biggest star in the galaxy is? I know it's VY Canis Majoris in terms of the universe (at least out of our known stars) but I'm not sure what the biggest star is in our own galaxy.

  • @isuckatstarcraft96
    @isuckatstarcraft96 9 років тому +375

    so how big is it

    • @rekr6381
      @rekr6381 9 років тому +48

      really big

    • @almightyshippo1197
      @almightyshippo1197 9 років тому +11

      Jamal l'Friedchicken Mass: 1.989E30 kg
      Radius: 695,800 km (1 R☉)

    • @isuckatstarcraft96
      @isuckatstarcraft96 9 років тому +4

      Almighty Shippo That's a big star

    • @almightyshippo1197
      @almightyshippo1197 9 років тому +4

      Jamal l'Friedchicken It's certainly bigger than my house. :P
      Although, our sun is actually tiny compared to some of the other stars out there.
      For example, UY Scuti is roughly 1,708 Solar Radii (1 Solar Radii = 1 of our Sun, so ~1,700 times the radius of the Sun, or 1,708 x 695,600km... tiny really).

    • @almightyshippo1197
      @almightyshippo1197 8 років тому +3

      The Sun UY Scuti threatened to supernova all over my house if I didn't brag about him... sorry, I didn't have a choice. Please don't burn my skin, sir.

  • @josh11735
    @josh11735 9 років тому +163

    Wow, I always underestimate how far away the moon really is... Awesome explanation MinutePhysics! :D

    • @Rythaze
      @Rythaze 9 років тому +28

      Imagining the moon's distance, and thinking about the Apollo missions, really gets you thinking that it certainly was an amazing feat for its time.

    • @josh11735
      @josh11735 9 років тому +9

      Rythaze Next stop, Mars? ;)

    • @Rythaze
      @Rythaze 9 років тому +14

      josh11735 see you there. :)

    • @neilstilin2224
      @neilstilin2224 9 років тому +16

      josh11735 Another example I like is that you could fit all the other planets (lined up in a row) between the Earth and the moon

    • @josh11735
      @josh11735 9 років тому +1

      Neil Stilin That's amazing! :D

  • @TheScholesie09
    @TheScholesie09 9 років тому +216

    I'd never even considered that the sun affects tides. I feel stupid.

    • @ricksmith4201
      @ricksmith4201 9 років тому +12

      It's responsible for the highest and lowest tides of the month(along with other stuff) but that's just kinda cool. There called spring and neap tides

    • @UnashamedlyHentai
      @UnashamedlyHentai 9 років тому +1

      TheScholesie09 It's why we have two high tides and two low tides per day.

    • @OniNekomon
      @OniNekomon 9 років тому +4

      ***** No tides here in Lithuania

    • @felixlogographic2802
      @felixlogographic2802 9 років тому +3

      SketrickTV No potato either.

    • @Dante_Eydel
      @Dante_Eydel 9 років тому +10

      ***** Mother Russia says no need for tides, can't make wodka out of them.

  • @RoScFan
    @RoScFan 9 років тому +5

    The thing that amazes me more than anything out of all these things is how far away the moon is. The Earth and Moon seem much closer to each other.

  • @Akadius1776
    @Akadius1776 9 років тому +9

    'Looks about the same size in the sky', that's some gud sciencing right thur! 1:22

  • @electronicsNmore
    @electronicsNmore 9 років тому +20

    Good Video! Brings back the days when I spent many hours looking through my homemade 12" Newtonian.

    • @coquimapping8680
      @coquimapping8680 3 роки тому +2

      It’s been five years since you commented and you got one like. Two when I like it.

    • @SimonOpsi
      @SimonOpsi 3 роки тому

      @@coquimapping8680 and number four from me

    • @user-dh8oi2mk4f
      @user-dh8oi2mk4f 3 роки тому

      @@SimonOpsi bruh, now it’s 9

    • @siyacer
      @siyacer 3 місяці тому

      hm?

    • @siyacer
      @siyacer 3 місяці тому

      ​@@user-dh8oi2mk4ftime travellers

  • @s7one_479
    @s7one_479 9 років тому +4

    I LOVE your channel. Every video gives me goose bumps and pushes me to peruse my goal of engineering science. Keep it up!

  • @SirDailydose
    @SirDailydose 9 років тому +3

    I've been waiting for this kind of video for a long time from MinutePhysics.
    Finally!

  • @eldizo_
    @eldizo_ 9 років тому +60

    Imagine living on a planet with the same surface area of a star, it would be pretty dope having all that land, yet the Internet would be a weird place with all the lag from opposite sides.

    • @Gh0stClown
      @Gh0stClown 9 років тому +65

      Borikuaedu3991 The gravity would kill you. You'd be crushed under the weight of your own eyebrows.

    • @neeneko
      @neeneko 9 років тому +14

      Floobs Hrm. I wonder if any synthetic materials and configuration could produce a sphere the size of the sun but surface gravity of the earth.

    • @YouHolli
      @YouHolli 9 років тому +10

      Floobs Not if said object is hollow and you are living on the inside ;)

    • @gol.drodger5261
      @gol.drodger5261 9 років тому +6

      Well we'd assume the beings their could withstand the gravity.

    • @Gh0stClown
      @Gh0stClown 9 років тому +5

      neeneko To have the mass of the Earth (about 6x10^27 grams) and the volume of the sun (1.41x10^33 cubic cm) You'd need a material that has a density of about 4x10^-6 gcm^-3, or about 0.0004% the density of polystyrene. No way a planet made of a material like that won't crumble under it's own gravity

  • @CrispyChicken44
    @CrispyChicken44 9 років тому +4

    FINALLY. Some space things again!

  • @Ubeogesh
    @Ubeogesh 9 років тому +3

    Nice video, totally worth to watch in full screen!

  • @CookieMonsterNoVeggi
    @CookieMonsterNoVeggi 9 років тому +2

    I have wanted to see a comparison of relative sizes like this for a while now. Loved the video, Henry!

  • @randallkelley3599
    @randallkelley3599 9 років тому +1

    Just luv your vids, the pics and the voice overs. Info. is very interesting!. Space/universe is so mind blowing!

  • @RawringAtYouNoobs
    @RawringAtYouNoobs 9 років тому +7

    Ah equations! Lovely!

  • @tranngankim
    @tranngankim 8 років тому +18

    I lost you at about 1 minute

  • @erocicTheGreat
    @erocicTheGreat 9 років тому +1

    Great video, full screen definitely needed!

  • @paulahuerto4899
    @paulahuerto4899 8 років тому

    Just found this Channel .. And i'm loving it.

  • @freedomwarrior7734
    @freedomwarrior7734 9 років тому +46

    Wow the sun is BIG. It's amazing to think that it took only one week for God to create it 6000 years ago.
    I caught you.

    • @averagebritishgirl6616
      @averagebritishgirl6616 9 років тому

      AnonymousIntellectual lo ur such a troll!

    • @johnkat4391
      @johnkat4391 9 років тому +3

      The sun was created before earth days existed, so a, "day" would be a block of time.

    • @averagebritishgirl6616
      @averagebritishgirl6616 9 років тому

      John Kat lemon

    • @IronicTB
      @IronicTB 9 років тому

      AnonymousIntellectual I would choose the word "incredible" over amazing, myself.

    • @carultch
      @carultch 9 років тому +1

      AnonymousIntellectual Here's an interesting thought experiment for you:
      Suppose that it really did take God 3 days to create the Earth, as the bible prescribes.
      Now suppose that kilogram for kilogram, God creates the sun, the moon and the stars at the same rate.
      How long does it take God to create the Moon? 18 minutes
      How long does it take God to create the Sun? 1.8 million days (5000 years)
      How long does it take God to create the stars, neglecting those outside our own galaxy? 1 quintillion days (2.7 quadrillion years)

  • @joshhooper4147
    @joshhooper4147 9 років тому +45

    If you think the Sun is big, listen to this: The biggest star in the Observable Universe is 1708 times bigger than the Sun!

    • @TheMigulis
      @TheMigulis 9 років тому +6

      Josh Hooper UY Scuti has around 1708 times bigger radius than our sun...

    • @chitranchakrabortty
      @chitranchakrabortty 9 років тому +5

      Josh Hooper correction, in the ''Observable'' Universe.

    • @joeblow966
      @joeblow966 9 років тому +26

      Josh Hooper Well, the biggest one we've found so far. My moneys on the fact that there's some bigger shit out there.

    • @ammettheyellingfrog1
      @ammettheyellingfrog1 9 років тому +15

      That makes no sense, stars are just pin pricks in the blanket that is the sky, how can one be bigger that the sun? Idiot

    • @joshhooper4147
      @joshhooper4147 9 років тому +9

      ammettheyellingfrog1 are you serious?!

  • @mridulatirumala3065
    @mridulatirumala3065 7 років тому

    I just love watching these videos

  • @TheGpsm
    @TheGpsm 9 років тому +2

    Please, could you make a video about the Lagrange Points? Thanks! I love this channel.

  • @stellarfirefly
    @stellarfirefly 9 років тому +16

    Huh, I always heard that the sun's effect on tides is roughly half that of the moon's. Are they actually close to equal?

    • @JessperC
      @JessperC 9 років тому +9

      stellarfirefly When dealing with big numbers scientist generally fall into a scale that deals with magnitudes. If something isn't 10x or 1/10th as much it's pretty close, this can be a bit confusing to everyone else.

    • @Insertnamesz
      @Insertnamesz 9 років тому +3

      ***** I calculated this last semester in my mechanics class. The sun accounts for about 40% while the moon accounts for about 60% of the total tidal strength. They may be even more like 47% and 53%, but I can't exactly remember. Will need to go digging through my notes ;P

    • @kobewankenobi8926
      @kobewankenobi8926 9 років тому +1

      i calculated it last year too and i got like 63 and 37

    • @DanielLCarrier
      @DanielLCarrier 9 років тому +8

      stellarfirefly Half is close to equal if you're doing a Fermi calculation.

    • @bobbyharper8710
      @bobbyharper8710 9 років тому +4

      stellarfirefly The video is wrong although they supplied the correct formula.The difference in the pull of the moon is 2.20 x 10^-6 The difference in the pull of the sun is 1.01 x 10^-6 Which is .457 or roughly 1/2.

  • @iAmAbrahamster
    @iAmAbrahamster 9 років тому +82

    Tide goes in, tide goes out. You can't explain that.

    • @ricksmith4201
      @ricksmith4201 9 років тому +4

      Lol yea you can

    • @TheCavemonk
      @TheCavemonk 9 років тому +8

      Rick Smith For anyone not knowing, it's an infamous Bill O'Reilly quote from an interview with David Silverman, an atheist. That interview birthed a few other quotes and memes, it's worth checking out.

    • @joeblow966
      @joeblow966 9 років тому +2

      Rick Smith Then explain it to Bill O'Riley

    • @TheGoldFencer
      @TheGoldFencer 9 років тому

      iAmAbrahamster Ha nice reference :P

    • @Kabitu1
      @Kabitu1 9 років тому +2

      iAmAbrahamster Sun goes up, sun goes down. Coincidence? I think not!

  • @douglasbaiense
    @douglasbaiense 9 років тому

    Love this kind if evocative content. Thx a lot

  • @ghandiesel
    @ghandiesel 9 років тому

    the density of this information is blowing my mind! I have to watch this 5 more times

  • @Jeonsaryu
    @Jeonsaryu 8 років тому +8

    I have a question then! If I hold a marble out so that it covers the sun, would that marble have the same gravitational influence on me as the moon does?

    • @rsrikri5hna
      @rsrikri5hna 8 років тому

      +Aaron Park gravitational force is directly proportional to m/d^2, so they wont have the same gravitational force on you. But i don't think gravitational force formula is applicable for such short distances

    • @Jeonsaryu
      @Jeonsaryu 8 років тому

      That was a sarcastic joke, Vegeta.
      Marble + Arm's Length:
      0.003 kg /(0.655 m)^2 = 0.00699259
      Moon + Distance from Earth to Moon:
      7.342 x 10^22 kg /(384400000 m)^2 = 496875

    • @theunknownblock5942
      @theunknownblock5942 8 років тому

      well hi there fellow- oh crap they're doing math! mayday! mayday!

    • @williamhesford1363
      @williamhesford1363 8 років тому

      Sri Krishna Chaitanya as of lately with all the fuss on the reality of gravity which I believe is all in the mind, I think that formula might be full of black holes. Actually that formula is probably full of money. Backed by the richest with an agenda. Anything associated with gravity especially math equations are becoming very suspect. If gravity does not exist or proven its shouldnt be used as a variable in math. I am sure nasa put together bogus pages long math equations that had gravity formulas being used. Well since its failed to be proven then all those particular math problems using a gravity formula must be wrong.

    • @Jeonsaryu
      @Jeonsaryu 8 років тому

      William Hesford Please... just go back to wearing your tinfoil hat, and flipping the bird at the surveillance cameras operated by "lizard men".
      If gravity didn't exist, no force would be keeping the satellites in orbit around the earth. No GPS, no satellite TV, no accurate weather reports, no accurate map imaging, and god damn overview images of Area 51.

  • @geometric2083
    @geometric2083 5 років тому +4

    Physics and geometry= makes my brain SEPARATED TO MY HEAD..😅😅

  • @MrCrackerjack121
    @MrCrackerjack121 9 років тому

    KEEP MAKING VIDEOS YOU GUYS ARE AWESOME

  • @isacc2838
    @isacc2838 3 роки тому

    Thank you of your sharing

  • @DanFrederiksen
    @DanFrederiksen 9 років тому +4

    Hmm, I wouldn't have thought that the sun tidal force is as great as the moon.
    Makes me wonder why we aren't tidal locked.

    • @blackSUAAAVE
      @blackSUAAAVE 2 роки тому

      We aren't tidally locked because the Earth is so far away from the sun.
      We are 93 million miles away from the sun.
      Oh, btw. The sun is so much bigger than the moon it ain't even funny.

  • @rosybrown3833
    @rosybrown3833 4 роки тому +3

    so overall how big is the sun

  • @ImAlexGoodwin
    @ImAlexGoodwin 9 років тому

    I'm a new subscriber and I gotta say I love your videos and also that the background music reminds me of Blues Clues whenever Steve would draw in his handy-dandy notebook. lol

  • @k.biswas4873
    @k.biswas4873 6 років тому

    It's good and I never knew about this fact before. It's helpful

  • @Teth47
    @Teth47 9 років тому +11

    But... Isn't the sun's effect on the tides much smaller than the moon's? If memory serves, it's about 50% lower...

    • @Teth47
      @Teth47 9 років тому +8

      ***** The video also clearly states that the sun's effect on tides is roughly equal to the moon's. Henry misspoke, or missed a point of research.

    • @zolikoff
      @zolikoff 9 років тому +7

      Teth47 Well, in astronomical terms, being within the same order of magnitude can be said to be "roughly equal". Seeing as how things that aren't "roughly equal" tend to differ by factors of millions.

    • @Teth47
      @Teth47 9 років тому +6

      zolikoff That really, really depends who you talk to, and how much we've tested to know. Being accurate to an order of magnitude when the data is far more granular is poor form. You are now being an apologist, don't do that.

    • @zolikoff
      @zolikoff 9 років тому +2

      Teth47 Wasn't apologizing or defending anything, I obviously didn't mean to say the difference doesn't matter scientifically.
      What I meant to say is it isn't that important *colloquially*. This is a simplified informational video, not a scientific one. I wouldn't expect it to bog down at such details that don't really matter to the video at hand.

    • @Teth47
      @Teth47 9 років тому +1

      zolikoff You literally apologized for the mistake, twice >_> Anyway, this is a condensed scientific video, it should be accurate. If you're going to educate, educate. Do your research, don't be wrong, because you're teaching people things, and they are trusting that you're teaching them correct things.

  • @TheAres1999
    @TheAres1999 8 років тому +5

    Man, the moon is far away.

  • @BadKnightLv01
    @BadKnightLv01 9 років тому

    That was an extremely cool visualization

  • @ChaosShadow00x
    @ChaosShadow00x 9 років тому

    Excellent perspective!

  • @ronnqvist_
    @ronnqvist_ 9 років тому +4

    The moon affects the tides more than twice as much as the sun.

  • @EpicSpence
    @EpicSpence 9 років тому +4

    The sun is 400 times bigger than the moon.
    Would it not be better to say the diameter of the sun is 400 times that of the moon? Just to save any confusion of volume comparisons.

    • @ansarizeeshan5808
      @ansarizeeshan5808 6 років тому

      Will the sun is too much bigger than moon it's just it's diameter but considered it's volume compared to moon I think you can fit 64.3 millions moon into the sun means you can fit 6 crore 30 lakh moon

  • @midgetfriendodog
    @midgetfriendodog 9 років тому

    This was my favourite episode of minute physics i've seen in along time!

  • @escraftTH
    @escraftTH 9 років тому

    I really love your vid. the simple explanations are really good for noob nerd and the complex equations are also good for pro nerd.

  • @AnimeVideoEditor
    @AnimeVideoEditor 9 років тому +133

    coincidence? i think not

  • @2nmingo
    @2nmingo 8 років тому +9

    one word : Outer space is fucking scary

    • @Stevethe11th
      @Stevethe11th 8 років тому +6

      that's five...

    • @Monochromicornicopia
      @Monochromicornicopia 8 років тому +4

      +Stevethe11th
      Count again

    • @Stevethe11th
      @Stevethe11th 8 років тому +4

      +Monochromicornicopia ooohhh, I see now. thanks

    • @Monochromicornicopia
      @Monochromicornicopia 8 років тому

      Stevethe11th
      Wow my Jedi powers are growing faster than I thought..

    • @Stevethe11th
      @Stevethe11th 8 років тому

      +Monochromicornicopia lol, the force is strong with this one

  • @darpanpatel8023
    @darpanpatel8023 9 років тому

    Just awesome...love it...go on.....

  • @randallkelley3599
    @randallkelley3599 9 років тому

    I didn't think of the sun as a tidal factor! The universe is so complex, so hugh, and is so amazing. cool vid.

  • @BellaBehindAKidBehindACamera
    @BellaBehindAKidBehindACamera 8 років тому +4

    NOT AS BIG AS MY... Ok I'll stop

  • @ExploreRealms
    @ExploreRealms 9 років тому +9

    speed of light is *fast* but I'd expect the fasting thing in the *universe* to be much faster.. Kinda disappointing..

    • @ExploreRealms
      @ExploreRealms 9 років тому +1

      ItsDumi Tried convincing myself but.. Still Disappointed..

    • @saltaloncreative
      @saltaloncreative 9 років тому

      ItsDumi Well any faster than that & you're travelling through a WHOLE different medium...

    • @arendvanderrande850
      @arendvanderrande850 9 років тому +1

      Learning Curve According to Einsteins Relativity Formula, you would have a sqrt(

    • @saltaloncreative
      @saltaloncreative 9 років тому

      Arend van der Rande Is time not considered a medium? My apologies, Arend.

    • @VeggieBond
      @VeggieBond 9 років тому

      ItsDumi Hopefully there is something much faster than that.

  • @nadirbaitsaleem7270
    @nadirbaitsaleem7270 7 років тому

    This is AMAZING!

  • @TheInimicus
    @TheInimicus 9 років тому

    the video editing in this one is just marvelous! big plus from me!!!

    • @TheInimicus
      @TheInimicus 9 років тому

      SimplyExplain I will defenetly try them in my free time! thanks:)

  • @eljono1
    @eljono1 8 років тому +11

    "coincidence"

  • @staas1737
    @staas1737 7 років тому +4

    "Coincidence"

  • @daedra40
    @daedra40 9 років тому

    Knowledge has never been so viscerally mouthwatering

  • @maximatron1159
    @maximatron1159 9 років тому

    Great video!

  • @barbiewawa09
    @barbiewawa09 8 років тому +5

    Tbh this video is really not that great. Seriously? How big is the sun? geez

  • @michaelnew1962
    @michaelnew1962 9 років тому +18

    It's no coincidence.

  • @arasanmark818
    @arasanmark818 8 років тому

    I like watching these kinds of videos even though I don't understand much of the maths involved

    • @theunknownblock5942
      @theunknownblock5942 8 років тому +1

      Maths? What country are you in? I'm in America, so I just say math.

  • @boingyfly007
    @boingyfly007 9 років тому

    If Henry was a lecturer he'd do a whole year's worth of physics in one lecture. Damn. By the time their next video's out, I'll just have finished picking apart this one.

  • @adriancarpio7536
    @adriancarpio7536 7 років тому +6

    You didn't answer the question. I came to see how big the sun is, not for solar eclipses and coincidences and tidal forces and other things....
    Don't worry, I haven't subbed yet but still
    Disliked
    Reported

  • @benjaminjosephmyers
    @benjaminjosephmyers 9 років тому +96

    You have all of this evidence, yet don't suspect that this might be God's intention.

    • @lereff1382
      @lereff1382 9 років тому +293

      Benjamin Myers Here we go... *_*grabs popcorn_****

    • @Kascaded
      @Kascaded 9 років тому +123

      Bait

    • @AnaloguePixelOfficial
      @AnaloguePixelOfficial 9 років тому +32

      Benjamin Myers What the hell does this have to do with a deity that SOME people believe in?

    • @SuperLusername
      @SuperLusername 9 років тому +14

      Benjamin Myers img0.joyreactor.cc/pics/comment/%D0%BA%D0%BE%D1%82%D1%8D-%D0%BD%D0%B5%D0%B4%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%BB%D0%B5%D0%BD-NO-190136.jpeg?hc_location=ufi?hc_location=ufi

    • @TheSuperNick1134
      @TheSuperNick1134 9 років тому +57

      Quinten Messemaker Humanity created religion. You should have lost faith in Humanity a long time ago.

  • @anmoljain365
    @anmoljain365 8 років тому

    I'm such a big fan of your channel.
    I've got 1 ques
    'Why orbits of massive objects are elliptical?'

    • @Nilguiri
      @Nilguiri 8 років тому +1

      +Anmol Jain
      All orbits are elliptical.

  • @user-pj5vw6xl5u
    @user-pj5vw6xl5u 9 місяців тому

    Nice explanation of planets

  • @Saikanix
    @Saikanix 9 років тому +10

    This is amazing, God is truly great.

    • @kickandblock
      @kickandblock 9 років тому +13

      God didn't do any of this lmao.

    • @supernova3992
      @supernova3992 9 років тому +9

      Nathan Mabie 2000 people died in an earthquake in Nepal recently. Isn't god great?

    • @AsquareM
      @AsquareM 9 років тому +1

      Super Nova Yes. Yes he is.

    • @kickandblock
      @kickandblock 9 років тому +5

      AsquareM Productions you're an embarrassment to humanity

    • @AsquareM
      @AsquareM 9 років тому

      ***** Thank you.
      If I am an embarrassment in your views to humanity for believing in God and having faith then OK

  • @iota-09
    @iota-09 9 років тому +3

    i can tell by a fact though, that you have lots of saliva in your mouth when talking.
    gee, i keep hearing that "splash" "shlip" "plup" constantly when you talk, especially during the last segment of the video.

    • @klisar23
      @klisar23 9 років тому +3

      iota-09 I cant stop hearing it now, damn you

  • @colecoopermma
    @colecoopermma 9 років тому

    wish this was a little longer, still amazing though :)

  • @uditkumar2460
    @uditkumar2460 7 років тому

    Amazing video

  • @thepropolys
    @thepropolys 9 років тому +11

    It's not really a coincidence because God designed them to appear the same size in the night sky.

    • @MindLaboratory
      @MindLaboratory 9 років тому +9

      Andrew White Yes, you're right - no coincidence at all! Praise be to Apollo!

    • @JoachimTumanowicz
      @JoachimTumanowicz 9 років тому +3

      Andrew White I know, right? I'm so furious that people don't believe in Helios anymore. I mean, the proof is right there in the sky. A very old book says that Helios travels from east to west in his flaming chariot. Well, there you have it.
      And the thunderstorms? Totally Zeus.

    • @DanielLCarrier
      @DanielLCarrier 9 років тому

      Andrew White Why would God do that? If you can't predict beforehand which coincidences God would cause, and you can't figure out how common coincidences should be by chance, then you can't use coincidences as evidence regarding God.

    • @thepropolys
      @thepropolys 9 років тому +1

      Daniel Carrier God made the two main lights in the sky, the sun to rule the day, and the moon to rule the night (read Genesis chapter 1). The fact is that God made the universe; therefore, the sun and moon appearing the same size in the sky is a design by God. All of creation is evidence for God, and all know that God created it.

    • @JoachimTumanowicz
      @JoachimTumanowicz 9 років тому +6

      Andrew White Flying Spaghetti Monster created pirates and then people. You don't really see any pirates these days but there are lots of people. Therefore a man is Flying Spaghetti Monster's design, not Jehowa's

  • @isaacpalmer3917
    @isaacpalmer3917 9 років тому

    So cool!

  • @dubstepboy3409
    @dubstepboy3409 8 років тому

    keep the good work

  • @davidk1308
    @davidk1308 9 років тому

    You need to do more videos please!

  • @etiennea-d-s5345
    @etiennea-d-s5345 7 років тому

    Thanks for the french subtitles :)

  • @koentjeklomp
    @koentjeklomp 7 років тому

    great vid man

  • @EricFaucon
    @EricFaucon 9 років тому

    What about density of objects ? A black hole is super tiny (singularity) but has quite an effect on tides, don't you think ?

  • @TF8ase
    @TF8ase 9 років тому

    Wow, fascinating.

  • @Glooberloob
    @Glooberloob 9 років тому

    minutephysics episodes never disappoint

  • @TechnoStickmen
    @TechnoStickmen 8 років тому

    Very good!

  • @itsdenn9704
    @itsdenn9704 9 років тому

    At 1:26 isnt the formule for Fg = G*Mm/r^2. Instead of dividing by d^2 you should divide by r^2.

  • @cavereric
    @cavereric 9 років тому

    More!! :-)

  • @Owen_loves_Butters
    @Owen_loves_Butters 2 роки тому +2

    Except the moon and sun aren't the same density, the moon is 3x denser, so as a result has 3x greater effect on the tides

  • @kalewidman3291
    @kalewidman3291 8 років тому +2

    I knew that the sun was massive, but that video made me astonished on how garagntuan it is, especially compared to the earth. Then, it even discombobulates me more to know that the sun is smaller than most of the stars in the universe!
    Amazing!!!

    • @_Insert_Username
      @_Insert_Username 6 місяців тому

      who saidbsun is one of the smallest?
      It is an average size star

  • @cagedtigersteve
    @cagedtigersteve 9 років тому

    So when calculating gravitational forces which objects should I consider? Earth, the moon, the Sun, Jupiter? Saturn?

  • @radithyajoenan4640
    @radithyajoenan4640 9 років тому +1

    Another fun facts :
    UY Scuti is a bright red hypergiant and pulsating variable star in the constellation Scutum. It is currently the largest known star by radius and is also one of the most luminous of its kind. It has an estimated average median radius of 1,708 solar radii, or a diameter of 2.4 billion km (1.5 billion mi; 15.9 AU); thus a volume 5 billion times that of the Sun. If placed at the center of the Solar system, its photosphere would engulf the orbit of Jupiter, and the radius is about the same size as the orbit of Saturn.

  • @pavel00995
    @pavel00995 8 років тому

    Awesoooooome video!

  • @theholyschois7477
    @theholyschois7477 9 років тому +1

    This video was awesome, made me feel really tiny and insignificant in some ways...However, I don't think its called an "eclipse" when Phobos blocks part of the sun from the Martian surface, I think its called a "Transit" due to the size. I could be wrong though.

    • @thiccityd9773
      @thiccityd9773 9 років тому

      It counts as an eclipse because it is a moon that blocks out most of the sun.

  • @billyrayhoscheit1775
    @billyrayhoscheit1775 9 років тому

    Huh, what? Thanks, I needed that. Mind shatter.

  • @MJFAN666
    @MJFAN666 9 років тому

    AWESOME

  • @prox16plasma28
    @prox16plasma28 6 років тому

    Minutephysics your sound looks good

  • @constcarry
    @constcarry 9 років тому +1

    Thank you, Almighty Lucky Chance! How benevolent you were to luckily have this occur!

  • @xomp
    @xomp 9 років тому

    I love how MinutePhysics has become a thinly veiled advertisement campaign now. 1 minute of content followed by 45 seconds of advertising. GG

  • @darksider7791
    @darksider7791 9 років тому

    I would like longer videos from MinutePhysics. As soon as I finished watching the video, I will forget some of the information I absorbed. I know I could play it back but how many time will I have to do that.