Thoughts on Thursday #5. Peterson Elizabethan vs Sutliff match Victorian

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 48

  • @Mak-Talon90
    @Mak-Talon90 Місяць тому +1

    I really enjoy your videos, thank you!

  • @s.m.r.1202
    @s.m.r.1202 Місяць тому +1

    Thanks Garrett and Katie! Enjoyed the video. Safe travels to you both. 😊

  • @WillBill1966
    @WillBill1966 Місяць тому +1

    Thanks for the review! Be careful on the trip. Have fun! ✌️😎👍

  • @ParsimoniousPiper
    @ParsimoniousPiper 28 днів тому +1

    Y’all make me grin from beginning to end 😂

  • @CentralCalPiper
    @CentralCalPiper 10 днів тому +1

    Hi Guys! Great video! Thanks for the comparison :)

  • @TheLeagueOfTheKeeprsOfTheBriar
    @TheLeagueOfTheKeeprsOfTheBriar Місяць тому +1

    I like the Sutliff Matches; they do a decent job, safe travels

  • @jespiping
    @jespiping 27 днів тому +1

    Hope ya had a great time at MM.
    Elizabethan is fantastic in my opinion. One of my favs! So smooth and not perique heavy.
    Interested to hear thought of smoking the rev.Calabash Cob!
    Take care you two!😊💨💨

  • @StDavidpipes
    @StDavidpipes Місяць тому +1

    Good review, thanks.

  • @yusufsayed1583
    @yusufsayed1583 Місяць тому +1

    Good Evening 😊 Awesome Video👌🏽 Beautiful Pipes 😍Thanks For The Comparison 👏🏼 No , Red Blood Moon is The Best 😉 Hiccups From Tobacco 😂 You Guys Have a Fabulous Day 🤗 Love ❤ Hugs 🤗 Blessings 🙏🏽 Greetings 🤝🏽 From South Africa 🇿🇦

  • @StandswithafistPiper
    @StandswithafistPiper 29 днів тому +1

    Good to see you Garret and Katie - hope the long drive went well - in the trusty red 4x4 ?

    • @SmokeSnacks
      @SmokeSnacks  23 дні тому

      no in our little commuter car- much cheaper.

  • @carolinarose704
    @carolinarose704 Місяць тому +1

    Such a sweet pup! You two! Go to your own corners!

  • @TheNorthGAPiper
    @TheNorthGAPiper Місяць тому +1

    Beautiful pup! I love some Elizabethan mixture! I got two tins a while ago and smoked one in only a week and a half. I’m holding onto the second to age and need to get more to smoke. I would love to try the Dunhill version. You can get deep stewed fruits from VaPer’s. I got one pound of clearance HH Burley Flake for $43! Great review! My favorite VaPer is Stokabee LBF. Safe travels!

    • @SmokeSnacks
      @SmokeSnacks  23 дні тому

      i recently tried the six pence and it smelled like catfish when i opened it, is that normal?

    • @TheNorthGAPiper
      @TheNorthGAPiper 23 дні тому

      @@SmokeSnacks 😂 that’s a new one. I would say it’s the periques musk that you’re smelling with the smokiness of the Kentucky. Definitely has a musty characteristic that fits the tin description pretty well, but tastes GREAT!

  • @OldUncleMike
    @OldUncleMike 29 днів тому +1

    Some people say new meerschaums have an odd taste for the first few smokes & new cobs have a distinct taste on the first few but I have never experienced that on any of mine. 👍😃☀️🌵

    • @SmokeSnacks
      @SmokeSnacks  23 дні тому

      i have seen that with both but it didnt last long.

  • @PiperX1X
    @PiperX1X 26 днів тому +1

    Good afternoon guys, just trying to get caught up. I’ve never tried the Elizabethan mixture as yet. I agree with Katie there, I don’t mind paying more if it’s something I really enjoy but I’ll sip it and try and make it last.
    That dog is so cute, I bet you can’t resist those eyes when it’s wanting something even if it’s just a good rub.

    • @SmokeSnacks
      @SmokeSnacks  23 дні тому

      she gets whatever attention she can, she loves to cuddle.

    • @PiperX1X
      @PiperX1X 22 дні тому +1

      @@SmokeSnacks My two are the same and I had a couch I’m sure my two would be sneaking up for a cuddle too.

  • @LifeWithAPipe
    @LifeWithAPipe Місяць тому +1

    I have a tin of Elizabethan Mixture I have yet to open. Looking forward to trying it more now. Thanks for your thoughts on these!

  • @BenCase88
    @BenCase88 4 дні тому +1

    I think if you want a VaPer that's great for a really good price I have to go with PS Luxury Navy Flake. Aged Escudo is my absolute favorite if money was no factor.

    • @SmokeSnacks
      @SmokeSnacks  4 дні тому +1

      im a Big Bayou Morning guy but those are good ones for sure.

  • @BillKeechPiperRacingPhotog
    @BillKeechPiperRacingPhotog Місяць тому +1

    Great comparison, I’ve only had the Peterson Elizabethan which I don’t mind but I don’t go to it very often

  • @PaladinPiper
    @PaladinPiper Місяць тому +1

    I didn’t care for Elizabethan so I never cared to try the match. Great job though guys!

  • @MillennialCodger
    @MillennialCodger Місяць тому +1

    😂😂 I love these comparison videos! I had a similar reaction as Katie to the sutliff prince (duke) albert match. Weird chemical and cardboard tastes and lot of bite, it wasn't my pipes fault though, tried it in several. I wanted to try some of their dunhill matches, but not so much now.

    • @SmokeSnacks
      @SmokeSnacks  23 дні тому +1

      i think the difference might be with the palate of the blender.

  • @MadArmyVet
    @MadArmyVet Місяць тому +1

    Yall should drop south on your way back and meet up with Zach and I. You know you want to do a San Antonio stop.

    • @SmokeSnacks
      @SmokeSnacks  23 дні тому

      yeah no that would have been a massive detour.

  • @BlakesPipes
    @BlakesPipes Місяць тому +1

    Blake was here. Going to bed!

  • @Wentz789
    @Wentz789 Місяць тому +1

    I tried sutliff equivalent to early morning pipe by Peterson and sutliff equivalent to Peterson's nightcap and sutliff does not match up to the Peterson for me