This was a very useful video ! 🤗 I do all my Coach shopping online, and to see size comparison and the other factors you mention is "worth it's weight in gold" , although videos don't weigh anything, 😉 I'm sure you understand what I mean... 👛🤗👜
Love this review, excellent comparisons. I have the chalk, black, and red cassie 19s because I just love the way the bag is set up inside with separate compartments to aid in organization. They both look good on you and I prefer a wide strap because it’s more comfortable like you said.
Both bags are nice and very comparable to each other in terms of capacity. My favorite is the Cassie 19 but I’m biased because I own two of them. 😊💖 Thank you for sharing!
Your videos are very helpful. I like the soft tabby in leather but the leather is so easy to scratch🤤, so I’m opting for the willow saddle bag! Can’t sait
I love the soft tabby :-). The willow is a very nice bag… I like how they did the rolled leather edges unlike the Cassy 19… Congratulations on your new bag - thank you so much for watching!
The Willow Saddle has the vintage Coach look & I like it better. It also looks much softer than the Cassie. Could be more of a throwback to vintage Coach leather and that would affect the price. Thanks for sharing!
I think the Cassie is actually softer, believe it or not:). The rolled edges, better leather strap & webbed strap may be the price difference...🥰. I think the leather on the Willow feels thinner on the back pocket especially:(.
Thanks for the comparison. 😘 You sure work fast! I like the rolled edges that Coach has recently put out again, like on the Cary crossbody and this Willow saddle. Contrasting glazing doesn’t really appeal to me. I like the shapelier form of the Willow as well.
It's like depending on if you're going to a formal event or casual event, the strap you use changes the feel of the bags. Great options and love the looks of these beautiful bags. Thanks for showing the comparisons. 💗🤍
Interesting comparison!! Remember in school when we had to do compare and contrast papers? If the topic had been on bags it would have been so much more fun!! 💖🌸
@@myluxurycloset529 lol, I must have been to excited to get one. thx, if Macy's have the purse you feature just link it anyways, sale or not. I'll be happy to support your channel.
I have the Cassie handbag in black and I would love to purchase a web strap. How can I go about purchase a web strap? The Saddle bag is to die for! I love that handbag!
This was very helpful! The Willow is on Black Friday sale currently for $230 in Canada, while I have yet to see the Cassie go on sale to that level in the couple months I've been watching their prices. I also like the wide strap on the Willow - I know the thin Cassie strap would always bother me.
Thank you so much for the review!! I actually wanted to know more about the willow but I think I like the Cassie bag. It’s more versatile and classy. How is the color chalk is it more white? I’m a shortie will Cassie work for me too? Thank you 😊
Wonderful video!! I love the color pink but I’m gonna wait to see if the Cassie 19 will come in that beautiful pink. I love the way you dressed up your purses.
I don’t have either. I do have my eye on the Cassie 19. I didn’t see the Willow Saddle Bag available on the Coach retail site anymore. Is it no longer available?
I really would like to purchase with pink and green strap combo but as per usual, we don't get the colour I want in australia. Every colour available but this one.
This is such a good comparison video! I really like the willow saddle - find it sits so nice on the body and I love the strap options. I’m in Canada and there is an army green one willow saddle I like at Bloomingdale’s that I want to order. I’ve never ordered from there and I’m wondering what your experiences have been ordering from there? Is it a hit or miss place for quality of deliveries? They don’t have free returns for Canadian customers so I don’t want to have issues. I could also order from 24S who has free returns but it’s not as good of a deal. Thanks 😊
@@myluxurycloset529 oh wow ok. I’m most worried about that strap and how it can come damaged if it was pulled off of a shelf and it’s showing low stock…hmm decisions, decisions…
Hi Erin - I am subscriber that has a question on the willow. I like the way that the willow forms to my hip moreso than the cassie 19 - however I would like to find some type of shoulder bag strap to go with the black willow. Do you have any good recomendations?
I didn’t realize we are the same height! Did you order the black pebbled coach novelty strap I told you about? I would be curious to see what length you got, if you did! Interestingly this strap is way longer than the one in chalk I got about a year ago. Maybe 4-6” longer than the other one even on the shortest setting! I’m debating returning it because it just doesn’t bring the bag up as high as I want it. I wonder if the one I got was fabricated incorrectly or if they are just making them longer now. ..
It's not the lining that is causing the back pocket to show indentations. It's how tight the back pocket is sewn. You can pull the back pocket on the Cassie open wider than you can on the Willow. the willow has a tighter pocket.
Which is your favorite???
This was a very useful video ! 🤗 I do all my Coach shopping online, and to see size comparison and the other factors you mention is "worth it's weight in gold" , although videos don't weigh anything, 😉 I'm sure you understand what I mean... 👛🤗👜
Yes!!! Thanks so much🥰🥰🥰
Love this review, excellent comparisons. I have the chalk, black, and red cassie 19s because I just love the way the bag is set up inside with separate compartments to aid in organization. They both look good on you and I prefer a wide strap because it’s more comfortable like you said.
thanks and yes it's a great alternative for sure 🥰🥰🥰
I like how you mix & match.Give more options.Thank you for sharing.
of course!!!♥️
love the strap on the cassie 19! thank you for the great idea!!
of course!!!🩷
Loved the thorough comparison. 😊
I'm so glad you found it helpful! 😊
I was so confused about which bag to choose and your detailed video helped. Ordered the willow saddle bag in Chalk. Will order the chain too. ❤
yay!!! congrats🥰🥰🥰
Dillards has the Cassie 19 in grey for $177. Still available as of 6/13.
ty!!! ♥️
Both bags are nice and very comparable to each other in terms of capacity. My favorite is the Cassie 19 but I’m biased because I own two of them. 😊💖 Thank you for sharing!
Thank you!!!🥰🥰🥰
i am just in the process of deciding which of the two bags it will be for me. Perfect video! thank you
yay - glad to help🥰
I like the Cassie. It's so cute and classy.
It really is!!!💙
Great video I wish coach would sale the thicker straps separate from the camera bags.
me too!!!
Your videos are very helpful. I like the soft tabby in leather but the leather is so easy to scratch🤤, so I’m opting for the willow saddle bag! Can’t sait
I love the soft tabby :-). The willow is a very nice bag… I like how they did the rolled leather edges unlike the Cassy 19… Congratulations on your new bag - thank you so much for watching!
The Willow Saddle has the vintage Coach look & I like it better. It also looks much softer than the Cassie. Could be more of a throwback to vintage Coach leather and that would affect the price. Thanks for sharing!
I think the Cassie is actually softer, believe it or not:). The rolled edges, better leather strap & webbed strap may be the price difference...🥰.
I think the leather on the Willow feels thinner on the back pocket especially:(.
Thanks for the comparison. 😘 You sure work fast!
I like the rolled edges that Coach has recently put out again, like on the Cary crossbody and this Willow saddle. Contrasting glazing doesn’t really appeal to me. I like the shapelier form of the Willow as well.
It has a lot of advantages!!🥰🥰🥰
It's like depending on if you're going to a formal event or casual event, the strap you use changes the feel of the bags. Great options and love the looks of these beautiful bags. Thanks for showing the comparisons. 💗🤍
Of course - thanks so much!!!🥰
Interesting comparison!! Remember in school when we had to do compare and contrast papers? If the topic had been on bags it would have been so much more fun!! 💖🌸
thanks and YES that would have been fantastic!!!
The Willow saddle bag is beautiful in that bright pink! ❤😊
Petunia is a beautiful shade for sure 🥰🥰🥰
Can you please do a what's in my bag video for the saddle. I just bought one at Macy's, can't wait to get it.
I kinda did already!!! This video shows what's inside🥰🥰🥰.
@@myluxurycloset529 lol, I must have been to excited to get one. thx, if Macy's have the purse you feature just link it anyways, sale or not. I'll be happy to support your channel.
It's linked!!🥰. thx so much
great video! lots of work! Thanks!
thanks🥰🥰🥰
I love the organization of the Cassie bag
It's sooo good🥰🥰🥰
I have the 19 and the regular size
@@ladym0290 me too🥰♥️🥰
I have the Cassie handbag in black and I would love to purchase a web strap. How can I go about purchase a web strap? The Saddle bag is to die for! I love that handbag!
you just have to buy a bag that has one or go to cthrupurses.com and use my HBHW30 code for 30% off😉♥️🥰. Thank you!
Absolutely Willow! I returned my Coach Cassie 19 and now have two Willow saddlebags.
they are great bags!!!🥰
Hi!! Where did you buy coach❤cassie 19?
you can get them from Coach and 24S - I link them in the box when I discuss in a video:)
I think I like the cassie, but the willow with the piped is so nice
yes it's a hard choice!🥰
The review I needed 🥴🤣🤣🤣!
Every time I say I’m not gonna watch (my debit card gets worried 😟), boom another great review/ video!
awe so glad to help!!!🥰
Great comparison video, I bought both and love them. 😊
thanks and yes they are great!!!🥰
Such a good comparison.
ty🥰🥰🥰
This was very helpful! The Willow is on Black Friday sale currently for $230 in Canada, while I have yet to see the Cassie go on sale to that level in the couple months I've been watching their prices. I also like the wide strap on the Willow - I know the thin Cassie strap would always bother me.
thanks! good luck finding your deal🥰
Thank you so much for the review!! I actually wanted to know more about the willow but I think I like the Cassie bag. It’s more versatile and classy. How is the color chalk is it more white? I’m a shortie will Cassie work for me too? Thank you 😊
You are so welcome! I don't have either anymore, but it prob would work! It's a very light cream:). Ty so much♥️
I had cassie 19, camera bag, and thinkin' to buy saddle bag too because of the strap (unfortunatelly my camera bag didn't come with 2 straps)
I prefer the Cassie & the Camera, but the Willow does have some fabulous straps!♥️
Wonderful video!! I love the color pink but I’m gonna wait to see if the Cassie 19 will come in that beautiful pink. I love the way you dressed up your purses.
awe thanks so much!!!🥰
Great comparison video! I'd choose the Cassie. TFS ❤️
I think I would too🥰🥰🥰
I don’t have either. I do have my eye on the Cassie 19. I didn’t see the Willow Saddle Bag available on the Coach retail site anymore. Is it no longer available?
I linked the willow on my community page recently - several colors available but not on Coach. I love the Cassie 19🥰
Love this bag!
me too 🥰🥰🥰
I ordered the willow saddlebag in black last night! Half price, $187 can’t beat the price!
yay!!!
Thx, just ordered mine
@@nancywheeler8359 yay such a great deal!
Hi , may I ask do you still have the name of the thick metal strap you ordered from Amazon for the Willow saddle bag ? Thanks
Did you check the description box?
My Cassie 19 straps keep coming off. I have tried everybodies comments aboutnswitching around the hooka. Did not work. May have to return it.
Awe that stinks. Maybe try it with just one or two straps instead of all three???
I really would like to purchase with pink and green strap combo but as per usual, we don't get the colour I want in australia. Every colour available but this one.
i'm sorry:(😓
@@myluxurycloset529 it's alright, I've been waiting for a few months for this one, there's always another bag that will catch my eye. 😊
This is such a good comparison video! I really like the willow saddle - find it sits so nice on the body and I love the strap options. I’m in Canada and there is an army green one willow saddle I like at Bloomingdale’s that I want to order. I’ve never ordered from there and I’m wondering what your experiences have been ordering from there? Is it a hit or miss place for quality of deliveries? They don’t have free returns for Canadian customers so I don’t want to have issues. I could also order from 24S who has free returns but it’s not as good of a deal. Thanks 😊
Bloomingdale's is hit or miss with how much care they take in packaging, But this bag is a pretty durable one so it will probably be fine :-).
@@myluxurycloset529 yes I find the same with Macy’s…thanks :)
It's the same company 🥰
@@myluxurycloset529 oh wow ok. I’m most worried about that strap and how it can come damaged if it was pulled off of a shelf and it’s showing low stock…hmm decisions, decisions…
i got the saddle today for 50% off on Black Friday. no discount for Cassie 19 which i actually prefer.😃
that's a great deal! I prefer the Cassie too♥️
Hi Erin - I am subscriber that has a question on the willow. I like the way that the willow forms to my hip moreso than the cassie 19 - however I would like to find some type of shoulder bag strap to go with the black willow. Do you have any good recomendations?
like a chain strap???🥰
@@myluxurycloset529 Thank you - I'm sorry I mean more along the lines of a leather style.
@@heidifris4880 I don't...the hardware won't match on every option I can think of...
@@myluxurycloset529 No worries - I just know you are the strap woman! ha ha. Thank you for the response anyway.
no problem - I'd put a chunky chain with it myself 🥰
I didn’t realize we are the same height! Did you order the black pebbled coach novelty strap I told you about? I would be curious to see what length you got, if you did! Interestingly this strap is way longer than the one in chalk I got about a year ago. Maybe 4-6” longer than the other one even on the shortest setting! I’m debating returning it because it just doesn’t bring the bag up as high as I want it. I wonder if the one I got was fabricated incorrectly or if they are just making them longer now. ..
I didn't - I think the one you got is from the men's line:). I looked at it, but decided not to order because I have so many straps ha ha😂♥️🥰.
@@myluxurycloset529 I had no idea! That would make sense!! I will have to look at the listing again. Shoot
Where can I get a Cassie 19 ??
go.magik.ly/ml/1njxy/ or go.magik.ly/ml/1njxz/ (affiliate links - on the second one, use code FIRST15 for 15% off:))
I am selling my lilac signature and cherries - message me if u are interested:)
cassie because of the top handle
🥰🥰🥰
Do you see a lot of difference between Coach’s Petunia color and the Watermelon color?
Yes - the watermelon goes with a LOT more stuff in my wardrobe with its coral undertones...♥️
Love the new saddle bag but No top handle is a deal breaker for me. :-( still love Cassie! ❤️
I hear you - what about a short chain???♥️
Cassie 19
yes, girl!!!!♥️
Coach inside sale with take25 is 25% off everything that I see as I scroll through the Coach website
most things, not everything...I posted some of the things on my community page😍
It's not the lining that is causing the back pocket to show indentations.
It's how tight the back pocket is sewn. You can pull the back pocket on the Cassie open wider than you can on the Willow. the willow has a tighter pocket.
True. I also think the leather is thinner, though🥰
@@myluxurycloset529 yeah that too. ☺️