Should Managers Automate Their Plays?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 191

  • @sbzguadafoc
    @sbzguadafoc Рік тому +192

    you have one of the best approaches to explaining tactics in football. Combining animations with real football situations helps to cement the idea and gives a clear understanding of the tactic being used. Thanks for sharing and keep it up!

  • @condimentofmassdestruction9114
    @condimentofmassdestruction9114 Рік тому +73

    Manager like De Zerbi and Sarri are so amazing, the way that their teams play football is so mathematical and it works. It’s also beautiful to watch .

    • @RetroFootballFC
      @RetroFootballFC Рік тому +9

      Sarriball at its best is amazing, beautiful team plays and goals

  • @superslayerguy
    @superslayerguy Рік тому +24

    This is fantastic man. I'm a stupid American I've been watching for 5 years and still don't really understand tactics as much as I want to(absolutely love the sport though). This video really helped me a lot thank you, most other channels just run through all the numbers and expect you to know everything.

  • @chrislock677
    @chrislock677 Рік тому +14

    Personally I enjoy watching football with a blend of coded movements and creativity
    More coded movement in build up and protecting goal and creativity everywhere else

  • @alistairwilliams9074
    @alistairwilliams9074 Рік тому +36

    Very interesting video & I definitely learned a lot. This does give me certain moments to look when analyzing a game. Thank you for making this video.
    I do like a share a "scripting" story that could be probably different or same to the one that is explain in the video.
    Chris Ramsey, former youth coach at Tottenham & I believe he's currently at QPR, shared a story from Harry Kane's days in the academy. It's not about Kane, but on one or more games, he would tell Kane to let the opposition's center backs to launch long balls from the back. This is so Ramsey could see how the team's own center backs deal with long balls. Maybe after that, Ramsey could then see how the team build attacks, escape from opposition's pressure, etc.
    Thank you again for the video & have a nice week 👍

  • @alexmusic5013
    @alexmusic5013 Рік тому +22

    Been in amateur football management for 5 years. This video was a greatly detailed and meticulous breakdown. Liked, subscribed and commented.

  • @DaveS688
    @DaveS688 Рік тому +8

    Brilliant video, thank you. I would love to see you expand on the scripted/coded aspects beyond the examples shown here. Perhaps a series of videos each tackling a typical phase scenario and you then cover the top 5 highest percentage/ most effective scripted patterns that typically occur in that scenario with the videos then moving through the game model phases in logical sequence much like when watching a brilliant team goal starting from the keeper and build up and then moving through the thirds to a finish but broken into separate videos bite sized chunks and with lots of variations. This would help me become better/faster at recognising typical scripted plays a team is using or noticing they are doing something different than typical and so perhaps working unscripted. I hope that makes sense, it could become a really good and useful series!

  • @WillGerardus
    @WillGerardus Рік тому +5

    For me this is the best and most complete explanation of how football works. I've shown it to my inexperienced team mates and they understaind football much better now. Thank you!

  • @nikitapower947
    @nikitapower947 Рік тому +21

    Love your channel, keep it up!

  • @mikhail8068
    @mikhail8068 Рік тому +332

    Thanks bro I'm gonna dominate school football by using this

    • @dead-tp6pn
      @dead-tp6pn Рік тому +2

      Facts

    • @carlosandresilvaaleixo8341
      @carlosandresilvaaleixo8341 Рік тому +28

      You didn’t watch the video did you? Literally says at the end that during development this is discouraged as it removes decision making which is vital to learn at an early age

    • @smnwlsh
      @smnwlsh Рік тому +38

      For school football, I recommend that you strive for humiliation instead of domination

    • @wespicedmemes
      @wespicedmemes Рік тому

      @@carlosandresilvaaleixo8341maybe bad for development but bro tryna win games. He not an academy coach💀

    • @wespicedmemes
      @wespicedmemes Рік тому +1

      @@smnwlshwhat’s the difference

  • @nharikrishna7818
    @nharikrishna7818 Рік тому +7

    This is what we needed. Pure tactical kind of things..

  • @manwhoasked5942
    @manwhoasked5942 Рік тому +12

    The way Ancelotti's Real Madrid breaks out of the defensive phase is very interesting, and different to Mourinho's a decade ago. The players bond with each other so well that they improvise on the spot. The first leg against Chelsea saw some great transitions. Now that there's Bellingham, Fran and Guler, it's gonna get better.

  • @abdallahmire8656
    @abdallahmire8656 Рік тому +3

    simple and effective, I now understand and can analyse a football game

  • @TheJester524
    @TheJester524 Рік тому +4

    Amazing video! Probably one of the best you made, in my opinion.

  • @RyanKlarc
    @RyanKlarc Рік тому +4

    Quality content! You've earned yourself a new sub. Keep up the good work

  • @ohimats
    @ohimats Рік тому +1

    Speaking of improving the content, the small audio effects on the board play is just the thing that was missing from your presentations. Really great stuff.

  • @condimentofmassdestruction9114

    Circuit based football or scripted play has it’s limits. Sarri tried it at Juventus and Chelsea he didn’t worked like it worked at Napoli or Lazio. However it’s one of the most beautiful style of football in my opinion.

    • @W_Abany
      @W_Abany Рік тому

      His Chelsea were successful no?

  • @damien_lebrave
    @damien_lebrave Рік тому +8

    Very interesting and good explanation too

  • @losgauchosfutbolclub
    @losgauchosfutbolclub Рік тому +3

    The correct wording if you are using Cognitive Science as a mental model is "automatism". Automating actions rely on knowledge stored in long-term memory, pattern recognition (which is limitless). Automatisms reduce the cognitive load players experience when trying to "think" and use "decision-making" during an extremely demanding series of actions (a match). In matches, "thinking" is slow. Pattern recognitions and the accompanying practiced responses within a game model is what makes certain teams very successful when implementation certain models such as juego de posicion and juego de fases

    • @losgauchosfutbolclub
      @losgauchosfutbolclub Рік тому

      Your comment: "however should be
      10:14
      avoided as much as possible during
      10:16
      development and in youth teams as the
      10:18
      main priority during these stages of
      10:20
      development is to increase decision
      10:21
      making and speed of though"
      .. has no scientific backing in the field of cognitive science research. The myth of "let them figure it out" is counter-productive for beginners (non-expert learners).

    • @JuliGS10
      @JuliGS10 Рік тому +1

      @@losgauchosfutbolclub interesting. I fully believe you but could you share some sources for the "the myth let them figure it out is counter productive for beginners" part? I would like to educate myself further! Thank you

  • @shuyaochen2249
    @shuyaochen2249 Рік тому

    Best and clearest video to show how football analytics work in professional way

  • @maximoyer
    @maximoyer Рік тому

    Wow, the whole thing of breaking down plays into bite-sized chunks makes this so much easier!! Wow!! Amazing Video!

  • @nnamdiejiofor3985
    @nnamdiejiofor3985 Рік тому

    This video to me is the most revolutionary video about modern football made. I now understand better. I've been longing to understand how coaches arrange their training and how they think. Thanks bro

  • @Ackz89
    @Ackz89 Рік тому +2

    In regards to youth not adopting a more structured approach to improve decision making. I feel it's important to have alignment between the youth team and the first team in the philosophy that you adopt. If the youth team plays in the same manor as the first team, transitioning up would be seamless.

  • @andrew_j_weber
    @andrew_j_weber Рік тому +2

    Really really great job man. you’ve broken down principles and training in such a clear way, fantastic.

  • @aleking0076
    @aleking0076 Рік тому +3

    Love these videos! They are really informative, I love the addition of the training segment, many of us here are managers or aspiring managers and more of those would help us a ton! Love the videos, keep up the great work!

    • @FootballMeta
      @FootballMeta  Рік тому +1

      Thanks man, I plan on starting a new series interviewing coaches and getting them to explain their thought process behind certain exercises, so hopefully something you guys can engage with

    • @aleking0076
      @aleking0076 Рік тому

      @@FootballMeta I think we would all enjoy that, I will be waiting for it!

  • @AchuZ8
    @AchuZ8 Рік тому +2

    you are inspiring and teaching me a lot of things that will help me achieve my dream as a manager :)

  • @Tizou007
    @Tizou007 Рік тому

    This was explained brilliantly. I’m talking better than coaching courses. And you explained it in 10 min within a video. Fantastic information and very easy to understand.

  • @amanvalodia3669
    @amanvalodia3669 Рік тому +1

    Another awesome videos. Keep it up

  • @S1mple0bserver
    @S1mple0bserver Рік тому

    Wow!
    This was an amazing video!
    Keep these coming.
    Love you animations too! 👏👏👏

  • @nerdifymusic7322
    @nerdifymusic7322 Рік тому

    Adam clearly of 442 mentioned something like this when talking about England's new footballing philosophy. Already figured it out and translated it in Football Manager. However, Thanks for expanding it better and now I'm excited to try it on FM

  • @fillipe4700
    @fillipe4700 Рік тому +4

    Manager career better watch out... anyway, thanks for the content!

  • @davidemozzi10
    @davidemozzi10 10 місяців тому

    thank you my friend amazing channel, the best football tactics channel in YT

  • @bruh8285
    @bruh8285 Рік тому

    Amazing work, my favourite football channel by far👍👏

  • @eFootballtactician10
    @eFootballtactician10 Рік тому

    Another brilliant video. Noted evrything important stuff and hope to do so with the rest of ur videos. EDUCATIONAL

  • @jogobonito1234
    @jogobonito1234 Рік тому +2

    In my opinion, managers should teach "macro-principles" and then let the players interpret them freely. See Wenger's Arsenal or Ancelotti's Madrid, or even more Diniz's Fluminense. If you automate too much, you get sterile after a while.

  • @remacimohamed5474
    @remacimohamed5474 Рік тому +1

    great channel i love your content🤩

  • @omkarbarve1974
    @omkarbarve1974 Рік тому

    Quality content. You convert instincts which players/managers/watchers feel into terms & ideas. SUBLIME video concepts!

  • @yasuotop1348
    @yasuotop1348 Рік тому +1

    Great vid ⚡️

  • @elefteriosmouratidis
    @elefteriosmouratidis Рік тому

    This was really well done. Bravo

  • @JS-fz4et
    @JS-fz4et Рік тому

    Dang this is great content for coaching. Thanks! Keep it up!!!

  • @hassanbadruwasswa4585
    @hassanbadruwasswa4585 9 місяців тому

    I am in Uganda Africa, I really like your illustrations. I am learning a lot. Thanks 👍👍👍👍👍

  • @T54321
    @T54321 11 місяців тому

    An excellent analysis video! Keep it up!

  • @akachiedoggy5711
    @akachiedoggy5711 Рік тому

    Wow, this is a high level tutorial of football tactics. I love your channel

  • @olatdopemu3162
    @olatdopemu3162 Рік тому

    Love this! Very well put together.

  • @faridelkarfa8857
    @faridelkarfa8857 Рік тому

    Excellent 8lin depth analysis....very enjoyable. ...keep up the very good work...

  • @sunsuu
    @sunsuu Рік тому

    This was a very high level video. I know that I alone only have so much of an opinion, but I really do believe that you should make more videos expanding on this. For example, learning about the 4 phases was really interesting.

    • @sunsuu
      @sunsuu Рік тому

      At the end you stated that younger teams should not rely on scripting. It would be nice to see your ideas that could be supplementary for like a high school team, or something to that effect.

  • @Thefootynutritionist
    @Thefootynutritionist Рік тому

    Love this video! Do you have a video showing any other ideas for principles coaches use in attack/defense that relate to game models?

  • @eswarrao688
    @eswarrao688 11 місяців тому

    Awesome 3rd man ball movement explained ❤

  • @HIM-lk6of
    @HIM-lk6of Рік тому

    Great stuff mate!

  • @khalidalbadr1329
    @khalidalbadr1329 10 місяців тому

    Thanks for the well detailed information that will make it easy to understand the basics to train for best performance. I only think due to changing situations to the complexities of the game it is better to name the goal of training adaptability rather than scripted .good luck

  • @MrBobo2709
    @MrBobo2709 Рік тому

    love your content! keep it up

  • @alexpena1853
    @alexpena1853 Рік тому +1

    Thank you and congratulations on your videos, they progressively get better! I would stay with your comment warning youth levels not to become scripted/coded. Although I do agree, I wonder if coding the youth player, SPECIFICALLY in the US, could have a more positive than negative effect on their development. As far as the Pro level, I believe both approaches should be utilized, in a fluid manner from the players perspective, and a strategic manner from the coaching perspective. Players would have the liberty to be creative but can fall back on "muscle memory" when needed; and, coaches can flip the script to deceive the opposing team tactics.

  • @marcomonini4126
    @marcomonini4126 Рік тому

    From which software are you getting your clip videos? Well done!

  • @johannesheld6107
    @johannesheld6107 Рік тому

    Great video. 👍My game model looks a bit different, when I classify the sub-phases. But overall quite similar. When I did my A-License in Germany, I can remember that we discussed this topic during the course. And the overall result was, that the defensive behavior during the defensive phases of the game is much more scripted, while offensive behavior relies much more on creative solutions and the ability to take own decisions especially if we talk about the final third, when it comes to creating chances and breaking through. Of course it is a multifaceted topic and it depends on different factors. At the end there are different ways to be successful, which makes the game so interesting in the end. 😊

  • @williammiles5363
    @williammiles5363 6 місяців тому

    You got one sub... Thought I understand football all this while.

  • @estebantheshark547
    @estebantheshark547 Рік тому +2

    can you guys make a video on ball playing center backs it would mean a lot

    • @FootballMeta
      @FootballMeta  Рік тому

      Working on it, will be out next week thanks for the suggestion 🙌🏻

  • @colealexander9556
    @colealexander9556 Рік тому

    Very infotmative.thanks.would love a breakdwon like this on dezerbis tactics

  • @AnantaAkash.Podder
    @AnantaAkash.Podder Рік тому +1

    A lot of informative video man... I learned a Lot.... Specially your explanation about the Developing Training Session for Build Up was amazing... As a lover lf Football really appreciate your Efforts... Huge Fan❤️❤️❤️

  • @Micahel..
    @Micahel.. 6 місяців тому +1

    Hello sir. Your videos helps alot. Im a field hockey coach. U12 - U17. I applies your tactics in game and really helps alot. I want to ask something ..how can we connect sir. Keep up the good work.

  • @DiegoGaona
    @DiegoGaona Рік тому

    Congratulations! Which program do you use for animations on the tactical board? Thanks

  • @noblesleem1077
    @noblesleem1077 Рік тому

    Shall we assign numbers based on tradition? It helps understanding the players at play in every phase of the game

  • @andreaninosajdak3475
    @andreaninosajdak3475 Рік тому

    Great video 🔥

  • @MTLDYLAN
    @MTLDYLAN Рік тому

    Clear & concise

  • @Quazzi
    @Quazzi Рік тому +1

    Watch the FA cup game between United and Brighton and you'll see why autonomy can be nullified by not engaging in any ways you've prepared to counter, almost like a tailor made counter to the exact patterns. A definite drawback for this approach, good managers can counter them.

  • @footballphilosophy2023
    @footballphilosophy2023 Рік тому

    First time I've seen your channel. But love the video I've just watched. It's really interesting and hoping I can take some things from it into my coaching of kids

  • @EdwinAmeka
    @EdwinAmeka Рік тому

    This is a real talk bro I will try to emulate

  • @ottor2580
    @ottor2580 Рік тому

    Excellent video. I learn so lot.

  • @KisakyeEmmygrace
    @KisakyeEmmygrace Рік тому

    Thanks so much for the breakdown

  • @mainelettuce9040
    @mainelettuce9040 Рік тому +3

    When I here the word "scripting", FIFA Games come to mind.

  • @charlesmbuya2604
    @charlesmbuya2604 Рік тому

    Woow this jst made me look football in different way keep it up mamen u light will shine👏

  • @zionikoroha
    @zionikoroha Рік тому +2

    Who paused it at 03:56

  • @Goofy8907
    @Goofy8907 Рік тому

    Great video!

  • @dishantdalvi
    @dishantdalvi 11 місяців тому

    Great insight 💯

  • @Fgd231
    @Fgd231 Рік тому

    Great video. Interesting how Brighton and Man City are both automated teams but Brightons system is great to watch whereas city’s is very boring

  • @seanmccarthy8860
    @seanmccarthy8860 Рік тому +1

    Brilliant and simple

  • @ArdaUnhail
    @ArdaUnhail Рік тому +1

    I think scripted football can achieve many things but i am not in football industry and not a pro making a life out of it, so i like players showing initiative and tactical approaches looking like more chaotic time to time better. I am not a good example tho, i find Bundesliga or La Liga mid table matches more entertaining than CL last 16 and up.

  • @bleezyMadust
    @bleezyMadust Рік тому

    Great video I m definitely gonna apply this in my fifa gameplay

  • @romanquane5742
    @romanquane5742 Рік тому +1

    Could you do a video on ‘Le Marcature Preventive’ - in English I think the translation is counter marking. Might be a bit niche but it’s good to look at with transitions rest defence etc.

    • @FootballMeta
      @FootballMeta  Рік тому

      I kind of covered it at the end of this video ua-cam.com/video/KXZaP0niM3g/v-deo.html it's a topic I've wanted to cover but it's hard to make interesting haha

  • @adarsh3693
    @adarsh3693 Рік тому

    Good explanation ❤

  • @jan.kowalski
    @jan.kowalski Рік тому +1

    Yeah, please do a material about modern center backs principles...

    • @silvioferraro5165
      @silvioferraro5165 Рік тому

      Too scripted, running the risk of copying American football. At the professional level and for the big money those players earn, shouldn’t they be able to resolve most situations themselves by mental or athletic means? One of the aspects of the beautiful game is creativity generated from athletic skills or soccer IQ…. why jeopardize these qualities?

    • @jan.kowalski
      @jan.kowalski Рік тому

      @@silvioferraro5165 Statistics. 1 of 20 players is capable of creativity, the rest is not. People are not equal in their potential. In such cases you need a creativity from manager, to let him create rules to follow for those "dumber", yet fast or athletic, players.

  • @Deepaksoccercoach
    @Deepaksoccercoach Рік тому

    Thank brother this is very useful 👌

  • @alialjnabi2353
    @alialjnabi2353 Рік тому

    Brilliant video ❤❤

  • @alwymitch2980
    @alwymitch2980 Рік тому

    I loved this video🔥🔥🔥

  • @wasswahassanbukenya6086
    @wasswahassanbukenya6086 Рік тому

    Greatly appreciated

  • @maximedehogbe7566
    @maximedehogbe7566 Рік тому

    Could you analyze the New tactic of Luis Enrique at PSG? Thanks

  • @leonardtupamahu32
    @leonardtupamahu32 Рік тому

    Thanks for sharing bro

  • @jeremiahgumani6280
    @jeremiahgumani6280 Рік тому

    Brilliant video

  • @rabbarabbi4575
    @rabbarabbi4575 Рік тому

    Well done bro

  • @footbal147
    @footbal147 Рік тому +1

    I have a question. What is the difference between left/right midfielder and left/right winger. Pls reply

    • @FootballMeta
      @FootballMeta  Рік тому

      Winger is much more attacking minded, used mostly in the final third, while midfielder would have more defensive responsibility... However it's a role that is rarely seen in the modern game

    • @footbal147
      @footbal147 Рік тому

      @@FootballMetaIn 4-2-3-1 the two wide players on both sides of the CAM(Central attacking midfielders) are wingers or midfielder?

  • @hgpsale7605
    @hgpsale7605 Рік тому

    Is there any training drills for Scripting I really like to know, thank you

  • @niclas8265
    @niclas8265 Рік тому

    Great video

  • @mohamedabdelkader8665
    @mohamedabdelkader8665 Рік тому

    Absolutely Awesomeness and joy isn't?

  • @theswaysquad4162
    @theswaysquad4162 Рік тому

    I want to become a coach but I’m still in high school I really don’t know what to do😕

  • @19Arian
    @19Arian Рік тому

    I like how de zerbi organize players for build up

  • @christopherwp5705
    @christopherwp5705 Рік тому

    Can you please explain in detail about sarriball?

  • @adampatel1727
    @adampatel1727 Рік тому

    Thanks bro, now I can peruse my dream of being Liverpools manager 👍🏼

  • @tfmbatha
    @tfmbatha Рік тому

    What do you think about Mamelodi Sundowns?

  • @adarshsatyam-un6dg
    @adarshsatyam-un6dg Рік тому

    Make a video on 532 formation.

  • @wiri7109
    @wiri7109 Рік тому

    I disagree with your last comment. Decision making and speed of thought are the priorities of development and youth teams, and scripting is a great way to facilitate that process. As long as you make sure to tell them none of the scripted movements are hard and fast rules, these default actions provide a great foundation for players to add to their repotoire. After all, how can they develop sound decision making skills if you don’t give them options to decide from and explain that some options are better than others.

  • @Gaaei
    @Gaaei Рік тому +1

    #RDZ #ACMilan #Pioli