Hammerhead KAROO Cycling Computers // Recent Update Round-Up Late 2024

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 69

  • @David-qy6bs
    @David-qy6bs 24 дні тому +8

    After years of having Garmin devices crap out on me and customer service to be every bit as shitty I really enjoyed switching to Hammerhead. Regular updates and enough features and a great map made for a solid experience. But over the years I would just rate the Karoo2 as fine. It does most of what I need. I am not overly dependent on my head-unit.
    However, when Hammerhead decided not to release a phone app that worked with the 2 (only with the 3) I decided that my time as a Hammerhead user has a shelf life. Companies that expect customer loyalty but do not reciprocate need to learn that this business model is a dinosaur. Yes, they want you to upgrade and that makes them bank ... but it is a disservice to your customer base to show them no respect. And that is Hammerhead.
    Probably will try the Coros device next. Looks great.

  • @bikermousefrommarz6739
    @bikermousefrommarz6739 24 дні тому +3

    Great and accurate review. Encouraging to see HH updating the battery modes and CLIMBER features, as well as Field Views. I wish the BEEPER stopped deafening me and the SDK issue was reintroduced. Just odd that HH delayed this feature. Thanks again Shane.

  • @adammcintosh8556
    @adammcintosh8556 23 дні тому +1

    Great update Shane. I recently got a new bike with Force AXS after having a Di2 bike which with a Karoo 2 running KI2 was perfect. The thing I miss most is the audio alert when the front derailleur is going to shift in the Synchro shift modes (sequential in AXS). I asked SRAM who said it’s not available but they will add to wish list. Given Hammerhead is owned by SRAM is disappointing a third party app outdoes them for features at this time. Other than that issue I do like my K2 even with the short battery life..

  • @dominicbritt
    @dominicbritt 24 дні тому

    Nice one Shane… I loved my Karoo 2 but I ended up having to get a 1040 for 2 reasons - battery life and bigger screen.
    If Hammerhead released a version with a bigger footprint and battery , I’d be back on a Karoo in a heartbeat.

  • @fotmheki
    @fotmheki 24 дні тому +6

    So, folks at Hammerhead choose Android as platform for quick and easy development but after 3 full hardware revision haven't yet implemented basic features like drink/eat alert, they released a pretty poor SDK in order to offload their work to indie devs and now have killed it because.... well, no reason we are aware of.
    As a Karoo 2 owner I'm pretty disappointed becasue it had all the potential to be on pair with Garmin, in terms of usability at least, but looks like they don't want/care of users request and don't want to give indie devs the ability to fix their units

  • @jimmyduffer9769
    @jimmyduffer9769 24 дні тому +1

    I like the Karoo 3 I got with my Sram, but no music screen sucks. I didnt realize how much I have gotten use to it on mt Garmin and Wahoo.

  • @altern8tive
    @altern8tive 24 дні тому +5

    To appreciate the data field alignment you'd have to have experienced the update before which they completely omitted any alignment and screwed up the UI. The last hero update was Climber on no route select. Since then the updates have been lacklustre and devoid of independent manufacturer 'uniqueness'.

  • @Cyberjenne
    @Cyberjenne 23 дні тому +1

    I whish the Karoo had a dark mode including a dark (night) map.

  • @richardking6985
    @richardking6985 23 дні тому

    I would like to see the follow up of the IGS800, and a shoot our of some similar priced computers. I had the original karoo, cracked the screen - and unable to repair.... gave up on the Karoo at that point.

  • @fabianmolyneux2308
    @fabianmolyneux2308 24 дні тому

    Doesn’t sound like it’s market optimised to seriously compete against Garmin. I live in hope that some head unit manufacturer will come up with a cellular enabled head unit. It’d be nice to shed the weight of mobile. Great review as usual. Maybe a good idea for Hammerhead to seek your input, prior to market roll out

    • @gplama
      @gplama  24 дні тому

      Karoo units previously had SIM card capability for data connections. eSIM would be the way forward for similar functionality today, although it does then get tricky with regional regulations.

  • @YaniofWigan
    @YaniofWigan 24 дні тому

    Bit spooky, just updated!

  • @ojtamno
    @ojtamno 24 дні тому +4

    5:04: yes, it is what it is. It's called modern engineering. Making shitty design, to save few hours of R&D. That for some reasons leaves this kind of feelings in users.
    Same applies to the 35s screen off timer that is triggered by one button only. What a convenient thing for developers and testers. What a brilliant thing for the manager to report faster project completion with lower budget. Who cares about end user... they will learn to love that!
    Sorry for sad comment but I work in company like this and I it happening everyday.

    • @gplama
      @gplama  24 дні тому

      Reading this comment was good after someone else in the comments was dismissing this video as 'trolling'. Presenting the end-user experience when using some of these features for the first time can be a raw experience. On a related topic - I participate in a number of beta programs. It's very interesting to see some beta groups become too blinkered when it comes to what the competition/industry is doing. That feels like what's happening here with HH.

    • @ojtamno
      @ojtamno 22 дні тому +1

      @@gplama Hm. I know that when looking at the map, Australia may look a bit like "under-the-bride" land but c'mon.... you? A troll? :D
      As far as I'm concerned, you're pointing a clear design flaws and/or bugs. And yes, you do it with style and a bit of humor. But hey, what else is there for us than laugh?
      To me, you operate in really "funny" industry. For reasons I don't understand, all the bike-electronics I own is running the worst quality SW I've ever used. I don't know how "they" do it, but this amount of bugs and bad design choices starts to fascinate me - in professional manner. Till today, my #1 example of requirements engineering failure is Tacx Training App.
      And you, you need to deal with this brilliant design decision every day. To me, you're a hero here, who deals with all that nonsense so that we don't have to... or at least we are prepared for it :D
      Cheers from the North. Winter is coming ;-)

    • @ojtamno
      @ojtamno 22 дні тому +2

      @@gplama OK, last thing, regarding the "first time experience". My view on this is: this is the valuable feedback that R&Ds should learn to use. The thing is: once you play with the device for some time, and get some more-less official help from internet or support who "explain" to you how to use it - you're no longer objective in the test. You don't have a fresh view of the new user who has no clue what to do. It doesn't mean that the product got better. It just you learned how to use it.
      But new users will still have that feeling when starting the device for the first time.
      I learned to value this "first time" experience from my testers. And I value it coming from you.
      Cheers!

    • @leedorney
      @leedorney 22 дні тому

      ​@@gplamaShane, they argue vehemently that theirs a Dev team testing these software changes... 🤔 - but their can't be, because THEY STILL EXIST when released - wtf do I own a Karoo when HH are total jerks! (putting it tightly)

  • @petert8263
    @petert8263 24 дні тому

    I manged to get a good deal on a K3, I mainly use the head unit for navigation. I had a garmin explore 2 but only realise I needed a laptop/desktop to update maps after a few weeks! I’ve got an iPad and work laptop but can’t load garmin express on the work machine. Managed to get a cheap laptop for updates etc. also the Garmin is such a pain to use, layers upon layers of menus. Crashing, bugs etc. perhaps I’m unlucky? Anyway, trying the hammerhead and hoping they develop the app a bit more. They have SRAM behind them so should have the £££ to do it properly.

    • @gplama
      @gplama  24 дні тому +2

      It’s great for them to have the backing of SRAM but Shimano have totally thrown a spanner in the works for them with the messing about with no Di2 function. The “they’re a competitor” line no longer holds water with companies like Magene producing groupsets and GPS bike computes too (that do pair with di2).

    • @petert8263
      @petert8263 24 дні тому

      @ I think I’m spoilt by phone apps. KOMOOT works so well on the phone but just isn’t practical for a whole day on the bike.

  • @jed1mstr
    @jed1mstr 23 дні тому

    Speaking of revisiting devices with updates, have you had a chance to take a look at the Garmin Rally RC and XC200 power meters now that they're on version 4.1.0? I know they said they didn't anticipate fixing your sprint issues until new hardware (or at least suggested as much) the fact that no one else identified the same issues I think warrants a relook with maybe a new unit manufactured more recently than 3 years ago.

    • @gplama
      @gplama  23 дні тому +1

      My Rally XC vs Favero PRO MX video earlier this year was performed with that firmware. Garmin weren't at all interested in following up on this with me in any way. I can confirm Garmin are an extremely difficult company for me to liaise with. This hasn't always been the case, it's a recent change at Garmin HQ.

    • @jed1mstr
      @jed1mstr 23 дні тому +1

      @@gplama oh man, that's disappointing. I'd love a from-factory SPD-SL power pedal option and I know you did your amazing SPD-SL Favero Duo hack, but the q-factor and future durability is not encouraging. If only Favero released a SPD-SL version of their Assioma Pro MX. Otherwise the Garmin's RC's are my only option.

  • @rocstar76
    @rocstar76 24 дні тому

    Due to the lack of SDK and Ki2, I've parked my K3 back in its box and gone back to the K2, which is very disappointing to have to do. I'm now wondering at what point do I sell the K3, but i still live in hope the SDK will be released because i definitely prefer the K3

  • @RossTheNinja
    @RossTheNinja 24 дні тому

    I think a great option would be to have the two fields you normally have at the bottom of the map but the rest of the screen black as a battery save option.

    • @ralfmimoun2826
      @ralfmimoun2826 24 дні тому +1

      The backlight is consuming most of the power, and it must be on to show anything between a single pixel and the whole display. So, you can't save anything by using less screen estate.

    • @RossTheNinja
      @RossTheNinja 12 днів тому

      @ralfmimoun2826 so two back lights needed?

    • @ralfmimoun2826
      @ralfmimoun2826 12 днів тому

      @@RossTheNinja I don't know of any vendor having such a thing in his catalog. Building it in a way that you don't see any gap in "full" mode won't be easy, so that part would be unique and expensive.
      Plus the problem with electronics and code. You need a driver circuit and program code to handle that. Hard to find in the Android ecosystem.
      I don't say that they could not do that. But it would cost.

    • @RossTheNinja
      @RossTheNinja 11 днів тому

      @@ralfmimoun2826 interesting. Thanks

  • @wgthn5103
    @wgthn5103 24 дні тому +1

    Does the screen stay on for the non extreme battery save mode? The Karoo looks like a really good unit and way cheaper than the 1050, interesting to see how the wahoo ace stacks up. Nothing really draws me to a garmin unit for some reason.

    • @leedorney
      @leedorney 22 дні тому

      I can assure you - if the W. Ace shows better, I'll. switch from the k3 in a heartbeat

    • @wgthn5103
      @wgthn5103 22 дні тому

      @ not a fan of the Karoo?

    • @leedorney
      @leedorney 22 дні тому

      @@wgthn5103 I don't mind it like it a lot just the company is pathetic with software development and are rediculous at talking to customers - the forum is a waste of time now

  • @d4nman274
    @d4nman274 23 дні тому

    Any chance youll be putting the new Van Rysel’s D100 smart trainer through the Lama lab test 👀

    • @gplama
      @gplama  23 дні тому

      Yes. But set your expectations low.

    • @d4nman274
      @d4nman274 21 день тому

      ​@@gplama had a feeling since i had not seen it on the channel. Expectations in the gutter.

  • @jamesmckenzie3532
    @jamesmckenzie3532 23 дні тому

    Looking for a replacement for the unsupported Garmin 830. Waiting for Wahoo's newest computer before buying.
    Just as an aside. I had the transmitter for a Garmin HRM completely become unusable. Three of the posts where the screws tighten broke and the fourth screw retention point in the battery cover separated. Of course, the units was four or so years old.

  • @NYGiants4Life
    @NYGiants4Life 7 днів тому

    I’m good with my HH2. I just use it to follow my speed, location, cadence and hills and keep track of all my rides on Strava. I don’t have to charge until at least my 4-5th ride. I go for 20+ miles on the weekend, and 10+ on weekdays sometimes. Best money I ever spent and never had any issues with it.

    • @gplama
      @gplama  7 днів тому +1

      While that's a glowing review, I won't excuse them for pushing updates that clearly weren't user friendly... and they subsequently fixed in the next update.

  • @ralfmimoun2826
    @ralfmimoun2826 24 дні тому +2

    Who would not implement that batterry saving so that a touch will wake up the display? Anything else is just st*pid. Like not having nutrition/hydration reminders or a volume control.

  • @chrisb5824
    @chrisb5824 24 дні тому

    Any new purchasers please note - cracked the screen on my K2 last weekend. Unfortunately the screen is a 'sealed unit' and cannot be replaced (as is the battery too). So any problems outside warranty you're stuffed.
    They, HH, did offer me an 'exceptional' & 'one-off' discount of 15% off a new K3, as long as i bought it from their store - which is more expensive (15%+) than buying it online... Btw - the reason the screen cracked was that the HH - Garmin mount adapter (supplied by HH) failed. And - i dudnt have the lanyard attached...
    A few lessons learnt but importantly - if you break your HH outside warranty its had it! No repairs - unlike Garmin or Wahoo...

  • @jakesiney
    @jakesiney 23 дні тому

    How good is the HH navigation off road? Cant decide if this unit is worth buying.

    • @gplama
      @gplama  23 дні тому

      Following a route or following your nose with just the map? The navigation of a route has always been relatively good for me.

    • @jakesiney
      @jakesiney 23 дні тому

      @ Following a route, normally on the gravel bike. But through fields and unpaved paths.

  • @fardsmobile
    @fardsmobile 23 дні тому

    they still haven't fixed the missing turn by turn audio clues over bt headphones. a launch feature on the k3 that has never worked. Was told it would be coming in the "next build", just after release. still hasn't been done.

  • @leedorney
    @leedorney 22 дні тому

    The ideaology of the Karoo 2/3 is BRILLIANT cept the company is totally inept... the software development is REDICULOUS beyond reason, soo many have sold and moved to other cycle computers.. they got sick of me on their forum and banned me lol

  • @pl.sargento
    @pl.sargento 24 дні тому +6

    Any leaks news about Elemnt Ace? :)

    • @gplama
      @gplama  24 дні тому +1

      Not here. I think RoadCC somehow pulled a 10 minute video on the blurry AF photos of the box posted on Reddit. 😂

    • @morneauh
      @morneauh 23 дні тому +1

      It's coming on December 3rd, it's been announced on the Wahoo Facebook page.

    • @UloPe
      @UloPe 21 день тому +1

      That video was hilarious. Much talk about very little.
      I hope we’ll get a “I’ve been testing this unit for the last x months” here once the embargo lifts

  • @invisiblescout6335
    @invisiblescout6335 24 дні тому +1

    and my regret of going for the edge 840 over the k3 keeps growing...

    • @onezweithree
      @onezweithree 24 дні тому

      got the K3 for 330€ recently. Im actually quite impressed.

  • @SonnyDarvish
    @SonnyDarvish 23 дні тому +1

    I got a ver 2 at 50% price via IPP, didn't have ride type, returned it. Such a simple and silly thing missing in 2024 was astounding.

  • @TheOkinawaBoy
    @TheOkinawaBoy 23 дні тому

    I oved my K2 and now more than happy with K3. I had few routes that took me to the blocked road, but I do not blame HH. I wish interface responce faster and SDK comes out. But for those who complain I'd say go and change it ot Garmin/Wahoo. Why to suffer?

  • @rcuadro
    @rcuadro 23 дні тому

    The fragmentation between the Hammerhead units is comical

  • @stevesmith9082
    @stevesmith9082 21 день тому +1

    Hammerhead has gone backwards IMO with the 3 and they do not listen to their customers as other commenters have said. I will not purchase another Hammerhead unit

  • @testalino
    @testalino 24 дні тому

    The k3 is a great device. The battery life is absolutely fine without any saver modes. Just compare it to the bolt 2, roam 2 or maybe even the 1050 and it will look much different. Bit of a troll video imo.

    • @gplama
      @gplama  24 дні тому +4

      If presenting my experience such as the save mode timeout bug and ride profiles not writing sub_sport information is considered a “troll video” that’s more a reflection on the product than anything else. You’re seeing facts here. I even poked fun at the very concept of the comparison with the 1040 Solar. What we found out is that the battery save modes DO help the K3, a lot.
      Game on with the 1050 comparison. Stay tuned…

    • @testalino
      @testalino 24 дні тому

      @gplama in my opinion the save mode is not even needed. I have no idea why you put your focus on that feature besides trolling of course ;) . Anyway, have fun continuing the saga. Same with the dura, which is obviously your enemy no 1.

    • @gplama
      @gplama  24 дні тому +1

      @@testalino I mention very clearly in the video why I'm looking into the battery save mode. There's a number of end-user UI/UX experience issues shown in this video that HH should seriossly consider reviewing for people to have a better experience with their product. I don't see how this is trolling.

    • @testalino
      @testalino 24 дні тому

      @@gplama well okay, I take the word trolling back then. I just thought that a 'round up' of updates should focus more on the positive things instead of being a 10 minute hammerhead slapping. My experience is rather positive and I wanted to point that out.

    • @gplama
      @gplama  24 дні тому +6

      Thank you. You’ll get those kind of reviews over on the more vendor friendly channels such as GCN, RoadCC, etc.

  • @jamesfearn
    @jamesfearn 23 дні тому +4

    What’s the point of having a bike computer if the screen isn’t showing you data? Tuning the screen off to save battery life should only be a “feature” only used when the battery is less than 20%. Turning the screen of to get to a competitive battery life is dumb when the competitors don’t have to stop showing you data to get there.

  • @RuffRides
    @RuffRides 21 день тому

    Love my Karoo 2 even tho it isn't perfect. Get the jist that you don't like them? Garmin hardware has always been excellent - I just could never go back to them because of the painful, life consuming software than wants to take over and the strava tax. Maybe the software is better now, but they've lost me already.

    • @gplama
      @gplama  21 день тому

      It's not as simple as "I just don't like them".... or as another Karoo owner called this video - trolling. If I didn't like it the device would be returned and I'd actively tell people to avoid it.
      What I'm presenting here is my experience. I'm not going to sugarcoat this as any kind of advertorial for people to buy the device. If anyone thinks the timeout on the screen should occur when USING the device is ok, that's nuts. If HH were to address the issues shown here, all owners would benefit.
      Side note: I did attempt to use the Coros DURA today.... that went straight back in the box when their website was unable to reset my user password.

    • @petert8263
      @petert8263 12 днів тому

      @@gplamaI think the latest update has fixed this? Not tried mine yet to see

  • @NeilLavitt
    @NeilLavitt 24 дні тому

    Left of road countries who drive on the left side of the road:
    Africa
    * Botswana
    * Kenya
    * Lesotho
    * Malawi
    * Mauritius
    * Mozambique
    * Namibia
    * Seychelles
    * South Africa
    * Swaziland
    * Tanzania
    * Uganda
    * Zambia
    * Zimbabwe
    Asia
    * Bangladesh
    * Bhutan
    * Brunei
    * East Timor
    * Hong Kong
    * India
    * Indonesia
    * Japan
    * Macau
    * Malaysia
    * Maldives
    * Nepal
    * Pakistan
    * Singapore
    * Sri Lanka
    * Thailand
    Australia and Oceania
    * Australia
    * Christmas Island
    * Cocos (Keeling) Islands
    * Cook Islands
    * Fiji
    * Kiribati
    * Nauru
    * New Zealand
    * Niue
    * Norfolk Island
    * Papua New Guinea
    * Pitcairn Islands
    * Samoa
    * Solomon Islands
    * Tokelau
    * Tonga
    * Tuvalu
    Caribbean
    * Anguilla
    * Antigua and Barbuda
    * Bahamas
    * Barbados
    * Bermuda
    * British Virgin Islands
    * Cayman Islands
    * Dominica
    * Grenada
    * Guyana
    * Jamaica
    * Montserrat
    * Saint Kitts and Nevis
    * Saint Lucia
    * Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
    * Suriname
    * Trinidad and Tobago
    * Turks and Caicos Islands
    * United States Virgin Islands
    Europe
    * Cyprus
    * Guernsey
    * Ireland
    * Isle of Man
    * Jersey
    * Malta
    * United Kingdom
    South America
    * Guyana
    * Suriname
    * Falkland Islands