I found out Dot Hacker a little late(like... many years later) and got hooked instantly! Then, heard his interviews, I was: OMG! His talking voice is deep and his signing voice is...??? Regarding the hate: I think it's all about extremes. One thing is to dislike, vibes not matching... Hating a lot is another.
It has been almost 40 years they are always making new things and changing their style, two guitarists would be awesome. Of course there would still be the Frusciante’s fanboys always insulting Josh.
I love Josh more than you guys would believe. He’s so sweet and humble. Very talented, as well. I love John almost as much. They’re both amazing. But it really makes me mad when the John fans hate Josh because he doesn’t play just like John. It’s stupid because of course John can play his own style better. It’s his style. And I bet if Josh was the original guitarist, they’d hate John. But I think we should just be unbiased and appreciate them for their differences.
Exactly right. People judged him based on all of Johns attributes which isn’t fair. Admittedly John left some massive shoes to fill but Josh had been their touring guitarist. Should have kept them both to see what they could come up with
I agree!!! I hate to see John fans send so much hate into the world. John would not approve. Josh is an outstanding artist and deserves all the best. I'd love to see them have Josh doing something with keyboards with Chilis.
Klinghoffer is a talented soul. I remember I judged him once, just cause I loved John. I still cringe at the thought of such ignorance of mine. This dude is awesome and would definitely be on the top of my list of people I’d kick it with it.
Josh Klinghoffer is one badass dude. This is like the fourth non-Chili Pepper related song I have heard from him and there is something about the emotions of his tunes that are insanely catchy and hit different to few people. I think that's what he wants, like John, is to be able to influence the lives of a handful of people (even if it is just a few). I wish he received more credit but you definitely have to be one of my favorite musicians.
You should listen then common albums of John Frusciantes and Josh Klinghoffer, those two together is pure magic. I like that better than RHCP :D I was fan of Josh before he was in RHCP.
Heartbreaking and amazing at the same moment. I hope to see you live soon Josh. I'm actually very excited to see you break out on your solo. Much love and support my friend.
From one JF fan to the rest... Stop sending hate for Josh out into the world. John would not approve of all that negative energy. Josh is an outstanding, superbly talented, multi instrument playing musician. He deserves all the best energy sent his way! ❤️
I’d never heard that song, but that was such a great cover! Josh’s voice is strange and delicate and beautiful. He’s gonna be just fine. He’s been playing with world class musicians since about the age of 19, I think.
This may be the very first video on youtube where all the comments are positive towards Josh, it fills me with joy to see such amazing people gathering here to praise his work
I'm a RHCPs fan from day one. I've loved this kiddo right off the bat! Keep on being you Josh, I love you as a guitar player and love hearing from you out front.
Huge Big Thief fan...heard 1 or 2 other covers of 'Not' that really didnt pass muster and didnt expect to like this but got to say he's done a great job here
WOW! I can't believe what I'm hearing. I can honestly say I wasn't really feeling Josh in RHCP but after hearing this it has completely changed my perspective on him. I had no idea he even had any of this in him! WOWWW! Seems to me he was in the wrong band. Josh and RHCP's music just didn't go together as well as John and RHCP. There really isn't a comparison. It's like trying to make something fit when it doesn't belong in there. I'd love to hear more of Josh's music solo or in another band where their music style's can compliment one another. Good stuff Josh!!!!
Have you heard any of Dot Hacker's music? they're a band fronted by Josh which makes very different music to RHCP. I personally think that's by far the best showcase of Josh's talent.
Change is, at times, a good thing. This is one of those times. You’re obviously putting your experience and passion to work, and it’s inspiring. Cheers!
@AJ Kalvelage People don't know what they want... You just enjoy the band...why do u need this drama every time? Josh or Dave or Jhon are great pros and everyone of them took different sounds in the band... i think people will prefer always frusciante because the band became very popular by the time when he was there(Californication above all), and i can understand(it s the reason why i took a guitar in my hand), but i loved the album jhon made alone, so i'm happy of him in the band but more when he did his things alone(it was like i had 2 RHCP) while josh was playing with RHCP and did great things too(I loved "Look Around "simply great)...So my point is people are selfish they only think to their feelings to the band(i love Jhon/Josh) and lose the perspective... it's a good thing to have both them for us motherfuckers ... and if you love josh he's not dead... he ll play with other bands...stop complaining and go hear him with new songs!
I can relate at least a little bit with this. I've always loved josh since I was introduced to the band during his time with them but also was so touched by John's music that I wished he would be back. I think they are great fucking musicians but they definetly appeal to different kinds of people. As much as I'm excited to see what's coming from the Red Hot with John's retun I'm also sad for Josh's departure, I hope he does well.
@@eliotcardoso8089 I DO NOT AGREE...there's no one better than another... There are a lot of things that go in an album production... Every one of them take something different in the band... and one time for all without him Red hot could not go on with the band... The main difference between them is that Frusciante is one of the most experimental guy around, i mean he fucked up success because he wanted to do his experimental music, so i think the difference is not in the guitar tricks but in the mind of them... Pieces like animal bar or wet sand are just incredible... but after all i think that the style of josh was ok for the red hot...of course more in tune than dave navarro that is a clear hard rock/metal guy... this is clear when you compare flea bassline with the dave style and they just don't go in the same direction... even if dave was not good he took a lot in the band...i mean rollercoaster of love is super beautiful... What i wanted to say was stop complaining for one member or another... because there's no one better than another and in the end, you can be sure FRUSCIANTE WILL GO AWAY another time :D is what he does best, create something incredible and then fade away :D like a comet mauahuaha
He oozes passion.
Micah!!!!!!!! ❤❤❤
And he also oozes versatility.
I never understood the people that disliked Josh. I heard him live and his voice is so extremely good
I found out Dot Hacker a little late(like... many years later) and got hooked instantly! Then, heard his interviews, I was: OMG! His talking voice is deep and his signing voice is...???
Regarding the hate: I think it's all about extremes. One thing is to dislike, vibes not matching... Hating a lot is another.
Exactly my point darling.Forget the haters,they will not have change of hearts anyway.Joshy is what we need to focus on 💖💖💖😍
@@raisa_cherry35 Disliking someone doesn't necessarily mean you're a hater... never been a big fan of Josh, but I don't consider myself a hater...
@j77 Did I hurt your feelings? Do you wanna cry? Yeah I mean insulting whoever doesn't share your music taste, a classic when you're 11...
yes,josh is awesome.his voice is best.and he saved chili peppers.
Cant help but feel 2 guitarists could have been a rad thing.
It's been a tradition since 1983 but yeah, I agree with you
i loved when they were both in the band from 2007-2009
my thoughts exactly!
a lot of songs by RHCP have 2 guitars in the studio versions i mean this could work really well live
It has been almost 40 years they are always making new things and changing their style, two guitarists would be awesome. Of course there would still be the Frusciante’s fanboys always insulting Josh.
Josh is AMAZInG and can sound like so many different singers and he plays many different instruments
I love Josh's delicate and soft voice. His voice makes me feel so good. I hope his solo work is successful.RHCPtv1 Thanks for uploading the video!
You should listen then common albums of John Frusciantes and Josh Klinghoffer, those two together is pure magic. I like that better than RHCP :D
@@Andrash88 ‘A Sphere in The Heart of Silence’ is my favorite among the 6 series. Especially ‘My Life’ became my new favorite.😃
I'd like to hear him singing out more too.
lads listen to dot hacker its his band
I love Josh more than you guys would believe. He’s so sweet and humble. Very talented, as well. I love John almost as much. They’re both amazing. But it really makes me mad when the John fans hate Josh because he doesn’t play just like John. It’s stupid because of course John can play his own style better. It’s his style. And I bet if Josh was the original guitarist, they’d hate John. But I think we should just be unbiased and appreciate them for their differences.
melancholy babies true
Exactly right. People judged him based on all of Johns attributes which isn’t fair. Admittedly John left some massive shoes to fill but Josh had been their touring guitarist. Should have kept them both to see what they could come up with
Exactly!
I agree!!! I hate to see John fans send so much hate into the world. John would not approve. Josh is an outstanding artist and deserves all the best. I'd love to see them have Josh doing something with keyboards with Chilis.
as epic as it is to see John rejoining the band, i'd personally rather get more collaborations with John and Josh
Johnsh
Agreed although we always run the possibility of getting both
ataxia was chill
@@cosmosteinhauer226 hopefully. I hope there's no hard feelings between them due to replacing each other in the band
Yes! I love their concerts around 2004 and Josh's work on John's solo albums. They did my favorite music together.
Klinghoffer is a talented soul. I remember I judged him once, just cause I loved John. I still cringe at the thought of such ignorance of mine. This dude is awesome and would definitely be on the top of my list of people I’d kick it with it.
If you haven't already check out his band dot hacker or some of his other stuff or his work with John.
I LOVE JOSH KLINGHOFFER
Crouching there he performs like god and crawls away :)
He is so unique.
He have the most beautiful voice
that I have never seen, it's like a angel
Such a well balanced musician. He’s good at everything.
I wish he would do a studio cover of this song!!!
Josh Klinghoffer is one badass dude. This is like the fourth non-Chili Pepper related song I have heard from him and there is something about the emotions of his tunes that are insanely catchy and hit different to few people. I think that's what he wants, like John, is to be able to influence the lives of a handful of people (even if it is just a few). I wish he received more credit but you definitely have to be one of my favorite musicians.
check out his band dot hacker, you'll love it!
C3POBITCH Thats where I heard his other songs (: especially eye opener.
Dude, enough about John
listen to dot hacker, bicycle thief, and his collab albums with John ("Sphere in the Heart of Silence" and "Shadows Collide with People")
You should listen then common albums of John Frusciantes and Josh Klinghoffer, those two together is pure magic. I like that better than RHCP :D
I was fan of Josh before he was in RHCP.
Heartbreaking and amazing at the same moment. I hope to see you live soon Josh. I'm actually very excited to see you break out on your solo. Much love and support my friend.
Thanks Josh, great to see and hear you again, refreshing during theses stay at home times. Stay healthy !!!
From one JF fan to the rest...
Stop sending hate for Josh out into the world. John would not approve of all that negative energy. Josh is an outstanding, superbly talented, multi instrument playing musician. He deserves all the best energy sent his way! ❤️
I like when new music finds its way to me. I had to listen to more from Big Thief. Thank you Josh.
2:00 is so haunting...❤️
I wanna sit like this man, but I can’t, is painful
the best comment, hahha
I'd die...my knees would cry and then murder me. 😂
Do Yoga
@@mantinizz jajajaja si, empece hace una semana
liked his voice since I first heard him on the track Omission.
Sick Love was a masterpiece from him
Love the guitar on that one.
Love his solo work! Every song he released is great.
This is a cover man
He did not said that is a cover lol
@ that wasnt his intention.
I’d never heard that song, but that was such a great cover! Josh’s voice is strange and delicate and beautiful. He’s gonna be just fine. He’s been playing with world class musicians since about the age of 19, I think.
This may be the very first video on youtube where all the comments are positive towards Josh, it fills me with joy to see such amazing people gathering here to praise his work
Can't stop listening to this.
this guy should still be apart of the band, some keys or effects, vocals. I really enjoyed the two albums he was apart of.
A part
yes, like in the 2007 tour!
check out dot hacker, its his band and theyre really good, definitely recommend
@@oinkooink The two losers posting above me are going to kill themselves one day after realizing they have no friends. Sad but true.
Yaaa like when he was at the Stadium Arcadium era
Hello friends, wow Beautiful song 👏👏👏 very good Josh 👍👍 fantastic artist!! ❤️☘👊😉 Thank a lot for this gem Friends. Like for you. Cheers 😊✌❤
Thank You very Much My Friend Riccardo! I Love You!!!
@@RHCPtv1 Aww thank you very much dears, 🙏🙏❤ I love you too, you are the best! 😘❤❤❤ See you soon 👋😉✌💕🎸
Josh shreds and RIPS on his MUSIC!!!! Nothing but respect for this musician!!!!!!
What a sweet voice he has.
Very awsome Josh..great talent ..love yeah
I like all your music. Grazie Josh ♥️🤘
I'm a RHCPs fan from day one. I've loved this kiddo right off the bat! Keep on being you Josh, I love you as a guitar player and love hearing from you out front.
This guy could easily make his own album...
He did! Two solo albums!
I love Josh's voice and musical talent, his voice gently wraps my heart, his sound of his guitar in the atmosphere makes me mesmerized...
I watched the video and thaught "nice song, underrated musician" suddenly I started to cry and I don't know why I did not cry in 3 years.
Love this video! Just Josh and a guitar is beautiful!
He has a very interesting voice, nice to hear him center stage so to speak. Excited for future music from Josh =)
This is my new favorite video 🥺❤️
I’m fall in love with this cover!
I’ve keep watching this video over and over, day after day. Josh is genius!!
Huge Big Thief fan...heard 1 or 2 other covers of 'Not' that really didnt pass muster and didnt expect to like this but got to say he's done a great job here
Really love that he chosen to play it completely unplugged, you can appreciate his voice, he's great!
we love you josh!
josh klinghoffer yes
Yes
Thank you for sharing. You brought my attention to this band, i love their sound and energy
Thank you Josh. April 21 is my birthday and this song is the best gift 😃
Josh has a wayyyy higher voice than I expected
He sang like a skater kid during the live shows ive seen
I always like him as a guitar player himself, not the RHCP records but his stage persona and playing, his solo work and his covers!
WOW! I can't believe what I'm hearing.
I can honestly say I wasn't really feeling Josh in RHCP but after hearing this it has completely changed my perspective on him.
I had no idea he even had any of this in him! WOWWW!
Seems to me he was in the wrong band.
Josh and RHCP's music just didn't go together as well as John and RHCP. There really isn't a comparison.
It's like trying to make something fit when it doesn't belong in there.
I'd love to hear more of Josh's music solo or in another band where their music style's can compliment one another.
Good stuff Josh!!!!
Have you heard any of Dot Hacker's music? they're a band fronted by Josh which makes very different music to RHCP. I personally think that's by far the best showcase of Josh's talent.
We have some passion here ❤😢
Thanks once again Josh
Amazing
no reason to compare, just stay quiet, relax and enjoy what they gift us
Josh… much respect and love to you young sir . All the best my soul bro
A wonderful musician doing a great bands stuff. I'm glad this flew into his radar. Thanks Josh.
so good❤️❤️
Credits: ua-cam.com/channels/m7N9P8rjiTjh3PCetuytTw.html
(ORG Music and Josh Klinghoffer)
Partner: PortalRHCP (Instagram)
Ainda inconformada como esse cover é bom
Wow
This is art my friend
Thank you so much for share this beauty
Another magic moment with Josh
Best wishes
I love how he picks up the pick and then immediately drops it
Awesome.
So that's his singing voice? Wow, He could sing any Saosin songs
We love you Josh. You did the impossible most thankless job, keep your head up
Love you Josh, wish you all the best ❤️
I love Josh’s voice! Thank you for the upload!
AWSOME 👌👌👍👍💪💪✌✌❤ thanks josh
So nice to hear Josh again. Great cover! Awesome song!
REALLY COOL GUY, Iove his voice and attitude too.
Change is, at times, a good thing. This is one of those times. You’re obviously putting your experience and passion to work, and it’s inspiring. Cheers!
You have such a unique voice!! Keep it coming
we love you josh youre the savior for rhcp
niceee song! thank you Josh for this cover
Exciting guitar player!!!
I LOVE HIM OMG
He's so talented! I'm in love
worlds colliding!! RHCP and Big Thief are my two fav bands :)
Beautiful soul 😍
Josh must lead his path, and be faithful to it.
You're showing the world that you can become a great, successful musician despite having no legs. Such an inspiration.
#handycapable
OMG Josh has no legs!!!!
Lmao
He lost the top of his scalp also.
He's Pewdiepie
They're just stuck in the floor! 😂
What a voice man. You're incredibly talented. Fan from Brazil
Love from Italy!😘
Awesomeness....You do this song justice.
Lovely. You're amazong Josh. Me and my dog admire you
Josh canta HERMOSOOO !!!
Damn you nailed this song!
I'm hooked on this... lol
This song is awesome man. I’ve listened and been playing along thanks for this one
lovely song Josh, best wishes to you X
i watched this video for like 20 times already this week
Love it!
Happy birthday josh 🎊🎊🎊
We love you josh! 😊
Beautiful
This melts my heart.
A sphere in the heart of silence is amazing for those who've never heard it
PEOPLE BEFORE: Oh we miss jhon Frusciante he was a genius!!!; PEOPLE NOW: Oh josh was so good we miss him!!!
@AJ Kalvelage People don't know what they want... You just enjoy the band...why do u need this drama every time? Josh or Dave or Jhon are great pros and everyone of them took different sounds in the band... i think people will prefer always frusciante because the band became very popular by the time when he was there(Californication above all), and i can understand(it s the reason why i took a guitar in my hand), but i loved the album jhon made alone, so i'm happy of him in the band but more when he did his things alone(it was like i had 2 RHCP) while josh was playing with RHCP and did great things too(I loved "Look Around "simply great)...So my point is people are selfish they only think to their feelings to the band(i love Jhon/Josh) and lose the perspective... it's a good thing to have both them for us motherfuckers ... and if you love josh he's not dead... he ll play with other bands...stop complaining and go hear him with new songs!
I can relate at least a little bit with this. I've always loved josh since I was introduced to the band during his time with them but also was so touched by John's music that I wished he would be back. I think they are great fucking musicians but they definetly appeal to different kinds of people. As much as I'm excited to see what's coming from the Red Hot with John's retun I'm also sad for Josh's departure, I hope he does well.
@@gregorisomariva2031 this is so true!
Josh is good but John is better for the red hot I think
@@eliotcardoso8089 I DO NOT AGREE...there's no one better than another... There are a lot of things that go in an album production... Every one of them take something different in the band... and one time for all without him Red hot could not go on with the band... The main difference between them is that Frusciante is one of the most experimental guy around, i mean he fucked up success because he wanted to do his experimental music, so i think the difference is not in the guitar tricks but in the mind of them... Pieces like animal bar or wet sand are just incredible... but after all i think that the style of josh was ok for the red hot...of course more in tune than dave navarro that is a clear hard rock/metal guy... this is clear when you compare flea bassline with the dave style and they just don't go in the same direction... even if dave was not good he took a lot in the band...i mean rollercoaster of love is super beautiful... What i wanted to say was stop complaining for one member or another... because there's no one better than another and in the end, you can be sure FRUSCIANTE WILL GO AWAY another time :D is what he does best, create something incredible and then fade away :D like a comet mauahuaha
That was really fantastic.
2:02 todo inquieto
Y tu
I guess I'm goino listen to this cover 7139+ times
Really would’ve liked to see him cover Waltz 2 by Elliot Smith. I think he’d do a wonderful and lovely job with it 🤘