Doctor Who: Best First Doctor Stories
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 сер 2024
- Today I countdown my all time favourite William Hartnell stories! These are purely my opinions, and what I enjoy most.
Let me know what your favourites are in the comments below!
Social:
Twitter: @josh_snares
Instagram: @joshsnares
Facebook: JoshuaSnares/
Doctor Who clips are owned by the BBC, and music licensed from Artlist
Thanks for watching! - Фільми й анімація
Sorry but being the nerd I am, you said The War Machines was his penultimiate story when obviously The Smugglers is
Yeah, I mean who would forget about a masterpiece like the Smugglers?
omg i am the worst fan, i'm cancelling myself
Why isn't the BBC hiring him to DO THESE for the actual releases?
Mind boggling the mentality of the BBC.
@@JoshSnares I mean I dont blame you because The Smugglers is one of the worst stories ever
you spelt 'best' wrong
Keys of Marinus is one of my favourite first Doctor adventures. Love the format of it, having each episode it’s own little sub-Adventure in a different style, brining it all together in the end.
That's actually the FIRST William Hartnell story I ever watched! Loved it and have been a fan of his Doctor ever since! 😂😂😂😂
ye, I love it too, my 2nd favourite
The Keys of Marinus - it's an epic and really feels like it's 6 mini stories packed in. Also it's full of adventure that none of the adventurers actually want to be in, they all want to return to the TARDIS and leave.
The Rescue and The Romans - Packaged together on VHS and because of that I think of them always being together. I love in the Rescue it shows illustrates the Doctor having had unseen adventures before Babs and Ian joined them.
I agree with you on The War Machines and The Time Meddler.
The Daleks' Master Plan seems like it should be a season all on its own like the Key to Time, it's epic in ways that we don't ever see again except maybe during the Moff years of the interconnected story arcs.
Honourable mentions: the other Dalek stories; Daleks. Invasion and Chase. They've all got flaws, mostly from padding, but all have epic senses of scale, coverage and contribution to the universe.
One of my favourites.
7:49 soooo, you love the Gunfighters so much that you accidentally mentioned it for a second time 😂
Please make more of these for all the Doctor's! Your such a good youtuber, and I'd love to hear your thoughts on the other Doctors eras!
I like that The Gunfighters gets a placing AND an honourable mention too, it's just that good! Another great vid Josh, lovely to see your appreciation for this era, it's easily my favourite. Agree heartily with all your choices. Every one a classic. Choosing favs is impossible I love them all, however..
1. The Myth Makers
2. The Smugglers
3. The Keys of Marinus
4. The Reign of Terror
5. The Crusade
6. The Space Museum
Someone needs to descent from the skies baring a wheelbarrow with all the missing episodes in. We need more missing ep recoveries in my life time.
The Chase is definitely up there with the great adventures.
Bless you, sir! Hartnell is a delight! My fondest wish is a beautiful animation of Marco Polo someday.
We can all dream!
The Time Meddler is wonderful. I'm surprised my DVD isn't worn out from all the re-watching. Its such a shame we couldn't get Marco Polo in colour because those costumes were gorgeous, and it would have been nice to see them in all their glory. I'm hard pressed to pick my favourite stories because, just like every incarnation of the Doctor, they all have great moments. If I had to choose, I think:
1. The Time Meddler
2. The Dalek Invasion of Earth
3. The Savages (where's my animation of this, BBC? C'mon, get your bloody act together!)
4. The Tenth Planet
5. The Celestial Toymaker
6. The War Machines
Great choices, glad to see Marco Polo getting some much-deserved appreciation - it's the story I'd most like to see returned. My favourite first Doctor story is The Daleks. Sure, it's not perfect, but it's the perfect way to establish the Daleks, and it ensured the future of the programme.
My absolute favourite is "The Massacre of St. Bartholomew's Eve". Hartnell gets to play the bad guy (and play him well). Steven absolutely shines as he carries this story. The themes of religious persecution and politics are not dumbed-down for the audience and the guest characters (and actors) are absolutely brilliant. The icing on the cake is the Doctor's speech to himself when he's finally alone in the TARDIS.
Splendid work as always, young man! Hmm mm! Indeed. Yes, indeed!
To offer another ranking into the mix:
6. The Edge of Destruction
5. The Crusade
4. The Dalek Invasion of Earth
3. The Aztecs
2. The War Machines
1. The Time Meddler
Great video. My favourites are:
1 - The Daleks
2 - The Tenth Planet
3 - The Time Meddler
4 - The Dalek Invasion of Earth
5 - The Keys of Marinus
6 - The Aztecs
Special mention to the first episode of An Unearthly Child - possibly one of the best episodes of Doctor Who in the entire series.
A fantastic review of some very interesting Hartnell stories. My top five would have to be
1. Daleks Master plan
2. An Ubearthly Child (All four episodes )
3. Dalek Invasion of earth
4. The Web Planet
5. The Aztecs
It's just so good to see William Hartnell getting so much respect these days as we owe him so much. 👍😎
Some of my favorite 1st Doctor stories were The Time Meddler, The Dalek Invasion of Earth, The Tenth Planet, The Daleks, and the Reign of Terror.
Mine would be:
6. Mission To The Unknown
5. The Dalek Invasion Of Earth
4. The Romans
3. The Time Meddler
2. The Daleks Master plan
1. The Aztecs
Mission to the unknown is good, but it is not, top tier for me, why do you like about it?
@@sampletext8229 isnt mission to the unknown th one where the doctor doesn't appear? No idea why I ranked it 6th best
Superb choices! I adore Hartnell's era.
Another fantastic video Josh!! To be honest Hartnell ranks somewhere in the middle for me as "best doctor"..but there are some stellar stories.
My top 5:
#5- The Gun fighters - I have to agree with you about this one...it's silly but it's comedy moments make want to watch this one over and over again. Plus Steven and Dodo playing that song is enough to make me burst out laughing.
4. The Space Museum - Overall this isn't that great a story...but I feel that episode 1 is possibly the greatest episode of any Doctor Who story..the cliff hanger is brilliant. .too bad the rest of the story isn't as strong.
#3 - The Keys of Marinas - number 3 was a toss up between Marco Polo and this story...but the reason I like this one better is because the way the story is written. ..it's like you get 4 separate story adventures in one ..while I believe Marco Polo is fantastic and is the one story I'd love to see found again. ..Keys keeps my attention through the whole story.
#2 - The Dalek Invasion of Earth- This is classic Who..the Doctor vs the Daleks. .what more could you want...plus the departure of Susan is heart breaking. ..and has always left a question in my head...when will they finally write a new Doctor Who story where he/she returns to Earth to visit Susan...after all he says he will return.
#1 - The Daleks - The introductory story of the Daleks has always been my favorite story from the Hartnell era...so many things happening here. ..the introduction of the Thalls. .you get Hartnell's first showing of his greedy side as he lies about the mercury switch...Barbra and Ian are still bitter about being kidnapped. ..all this within a brilliant Daleks story.
Oh and by the way my favorite Doctor is #2 .
Why does everyone prefer Dalek invasion of Earth to The Dalek's Master Plan?
I agree on Episode 1 of The Space Museum! It's amazing! Then... episodes 2-4.... :( :( :( Just dreadful.
Since no ones talking about it (I know it had a lot of problems) I just wanna say I love The Keys Of Marinus.
Plus, Master plan features the Brigadier before he was the Brigadier. Yes, Nicolas Courtney was in a First Doctor story.
If we do ever get a recovery or animation, it would have to be like Gone With the Wind, the Invasion or the War Games. Split in half over two discs.
What you do is brilliant Josh. Keep it going and thanks.
60s Doctor Who is my favourite television ever! My top 5 First Doctor Stories is
1 Marco Polo
2 The Aztecs
3 The Daleks
4 The Tenth planet
5 The Daleks Master plan
Marco Polo is literally one the best things ever made.
Matthew JH 60s who is the best
it is also the one lost story we have no hope of recovering cause nitwits in the bbc burnt it, so unless some one else has it, its gone for good!
Daleks' Masterplan is brilliant. The story does meander and it is slightly uneven, but the concept, acting, direction...its just brilliant. The Daleks are the most ruthless they had ever been, along with great voice modulation and even having sinister, sneaky personalities. The delegates each having their own unique alien qualities (remember when they were clapping backwards, and Chen's long fingers and odd writing style). Its attention to detail the show had never seen before. The stakes were so high and the cost of winning was heartbreaking. I'm sure the Time Destructor was responsible for that Doctor's body wearing a bit thin. It was a very dark era in the story terms
Great review Josh ! You picked my favourite top 5 exactly 😊😊
Great video this, love listening to other people’s opinions. My favourite doctor is Troughton. Love him so much 😀
To be honest The Web Planet is my favourite Hartnell story. I've seen quite a decent amount of his episodes and for whatever reason this engaged me the most. I wasn't bored for a second. I quite like the idea of the story, the ridiculous looking creatures are charming to me and it has a lovely surreal feeling to it. It's just fun.
We've all got a favourite!
Lovely reviews, thanks Josh.
Perfect timing, I'm coming toward the end of yet another Hartnell watch through.
He’s my favourite doctor too .... I can still remember watching the first episode at the age of 7, mind blowing concepts ... time travel, spatial weirdness .... then the DALEKS!! I can remember going back to school on the Monday after the DALEKS reveal, all the kids running round shouting EXTERMINATE!! I have a soft spot for the Voords as a “monster”, they scared me more than the DALEKS
Wow! Your taste exactly matches mine! Thank you for your incredible videos that highlight this era of Dr. Who! Bill Hartnell will always be #1 for me and these episodes really demonstrate why.
I too love The Gunfighters. Even the bad singing. And how the Doctor rolls the dice on wild western dentistry. I'd've hit the randomiser on the TARDIS and hoped for the best.
Some great choices there! I am encouraged to watch some of these serials again very soon. Love The War Machines - agree there should have been more contemporary Hartnell tales - this has the feel of Adam Adamant Lives about it. The Time Meddler has been a favourite of mine since I first saw it in 1992 when BBC2 began the first major repeat season of Who since 1984. The Romans is a sublime piece of TV. The joke about the fridge is a classic. Did you upgrade your choice of The Gunfighters? You give it a place on the list and then say it gets an honourable mention? You make a very convincing argument for each story and your obvious love of the First Doctor shines through. Great video, Josh!
Definitely DMP, it was ahead of its time. Two companions die, returning characters of the Monk and Daleks, and it’s just epic with the conclusion using the time destructor.
I have to congratulate you young man on your research and videos on the first doctor. These videos are priceless and such a refreshing sight from other Dr items on UA-cam. I can't agree with your selection but that's OK it's subjective. Oh yes I watched these when they were first screened. That makes me as old as the doctor
I love the gunfighters. Its a fun light hearted episode with some great comedy in it.
"Doc?"
"yes?"
Holiday?"
"I suppose so."
You sure chose some fun ones... mine seem so serious now ;)
1) The Daleks' Master Plan
2) Marco Polo
3) The Crusade
4) The Aztecs
5) The Daleks
6) The Massacre
Thanks again for all your great work!
Very good choices. The Gunfighters is okay for what it is, and I do agree that it's fun. The Romans is also a pretty fun story and is wildly underrated.
Just know you have to do one of these for each of the Doctors now.
OK the opening 'Space helmet for a cow' just made me spit tea all over my macbook. Nice one.
it's the best line in history! haha
What a wonderful list! It's so cool to hear what you think about your favorite doctor, and I'm glad Hartnell has fans representing him!
For me:
7. The Edge of Destruction
6. The Time Meddler
5. The Aztecs
4. The Space Museum (so underrated)
3. The Daleks' Masterplan
2. The Tenth Planet
1. The Dalek Invasion of Earth
Another brilliant video!
Wonderful video, Josh. Hartnell is also my favorite Doctor, and your list is very similar to my own. But my favorite story is "Marco Polo".
Im so happy you put Daleks master plan as number one, same here. I love the narrated audio release!
the gunfighters is so good it made the list and the honourable mentions!
Top 6 in no particular order: The Daleks, Keys of Marinus, Web Planet, Romans, Dalek Invasion of Earth and Time Meddler.
Honourable mention to Space Museum (1).
I am lucky to have only missed seeing one episode of Dr Who ever on first broadcast and that was the last episode of The Chase although at least I had the Century 21 mini album of the episode.
So many good stories to choose from, I have a soft spot for The War Machines as it was the first Hartnell story I ever owned.
God I love the 60s Doctor Who so much!
My absolute favourite Hartnell story is the Tenth Planet. Will you do make these for all of the Doctor's?
Well, here goes nothing!
The Aztecs (#1 - Yeah, I know, it's cliche to say that this is your favourite Hartnell but when I was watching it on Twitch, I was quite honestly blown away with how good it was. I haven't watched most of era, so thank you to Twitch for allowing me to watch stories I've never seen)
The Edge of Destruction (#2 - Could we please get more TARDIS-focused stories in the new series? All we have is The Doctor's Wife and the focus for that was on Idris, and not the paranoia inside the TARDIS. Imagine that but with Jodie's TARDIS team, it would be awesome!)
The Time Meddler (#3 - Great fun, great villain, great cast, great ending, it is fantastic. I love the addition of Steven from the previous story, and he already works well with Hartnell. This is a fantastic TARDIS team and it is a shame that we don't have much of their stories in the archive)
The Rescue (#4 - I love this story. I love it a lot. I love the costume design on the villain of the story, still freaky to this day. Vicki is just fantastic and it's a great opener for the new TARDIS team. That scene where the Doctor asks Susan to open the door is heartbreaking)
The Chase (#5 - 60's Who boiled down into the most fun adventure that they could ever have. The first two stories are weak because of those fish people, but as soon as they leave that planet, the Chase kicks off! There is so much to love in this story)
Honourable Mention: The Space Muesum (Like I said, I haven't watched much, but I actually enjoyed this story when it was shown on Twitch. Not as bad as everyone said it was)
You forgot about Journey to the Center of the TARDIS.
Ender We’re all trying to forget that one.
If Edge of Destruction was basically the Midnight of the classic series it might have been one of the very best of all time
Yeaaaaa a new Shares video
*puts it in watch later*.
Shall enjoy this later. Save BEST for last. Thank you Mr. Snares for all the hard work. Your fans appreciate your dedication and respect you show Hartnell and Troughton.
Dear Mr. Snares thank you for the heart but it's true.
I've been a fan since the late 80s but yourself, a newbie (as you revealed in that video about how you became a fan?),
does fantastic magical videos full of love and passion for Doctor Who? I feel less of a fan. I intend to be better from now on.
UA-camrs/Fans like yourself have not only re ignited my Whovian flame but help each week to make my depression less worse than it might've been. Thank you. Means a lot. NEVER let anyone tell you can't because you're gay or any other reason.
Have a wonderful day and Peace.
I heartily agree that THE DALEKS' MASTERPLAN is one of the best ever stories and that it should be animated. Something else we can agree on is Billy Hartnell - had the Doctor been a real person and not a fictional character, he would have been Billy for sure. :)
Here my top 6 (from what I’ve seen):
6. An Unearthly Child
5. The Space Museum
4. The Dalek Invasion Of Earth
3. Keys Of Marinus
2. The Aztecs
1. The War Machines
Great stuff Josh, can we have your top Troughton stories next please?😀
"The War Machine" with the doctor standing there, walking slowly and triumphantly closer to the War Machine while everyone else cowers. That is one of the first greatest "doctor" moment.
And the Gunfighters is AMAZING. Even with the terrible American accent.
1) Daleks Masterplan
2) Time Meddler
3) Reign of Terror
4) Gunfighters
5) War Machines
6) Savages
7) The sensorites
Really wanted to out in the Daleks or Planet of the giants and Marco Polo or the Massacre. All really great stories.
You gave the Gunfighters an honourable mention despite it already having a place on the list
excellent list
Damn, The Gunfighters made the list AND the honourable mentions? You must really love that story :P
so nice, i mention it twice
And to answer the question, my top five, unorthodox I know...
the keys of marinus
The daleks master plan
The dead planet
The web planet
The chase
I'm a huge fan of TKoM for same reason as Josh mentions 're TDMP. That it's so wide ranging, a vast story. KOM is one of the few times where the story based on an alien planet isn't confined to one tiny area. Instead different regions of marinus are shown. :)
agree 100% about keys or marinus
I love All of the first doctor story from the William Hartnell
Great video! I think of all the stories to be returned to the archives 'Marco Polo' would be my top pick (though 'The abominable snowmen' and 'Fury from the Deep' would also be high on the list).
I LOVE The War Machines - it really shakes things up - it sets the template for all the wonderful unit stories.
Well, you've definitely got my support for no.1
I can remember on Twitter, someone who had done the animation for 'The Macra Terror' had put up a chart of what they look for when they want to animate a lost episode or story. The main one is how many characters are in it, and if it's over a certain amount, the BBC won't do it. So unfortunately, that means 'Marco Polo' and 'The Daleks' Master Plan' won't get the animation treatment.
Never say never...
Bill Hartnell is my favorite Doctor too, and Season Three was brilliant.
nice choice of episodes :) first doctor is defiantly an interesting one.
A lot of people seem to fixate on Hartnell being this old and cranky version of The Doctor, but a lot of my favourite moments of the 1st Doctor are when he was being cheeky and childish. People seem to forget how funny he could be. I always loved it when one of the companions came up with the idea to save the day, only for The Doctor to turn around and say "yes, I'm glad I thought of that". Fans who perhaps never really watched the classic series probably have a view of him similar to that of "Twice Upon A Time" which is so wrong. He could be grumpy, but he was more often than not the mischievous grandfather figure going on wild adventures.
The Massacre is a Doctor who story a must see favorite about Steven being confused as The Doctor is The Aboot or the Aboot looks identical to his friend IF! I just the whole will WILL survive completely and return in the archives to it's glory and seeing THE LIGHT OF DAY!
William hartnell is definitely a favorite of mine
I love that you love him
And I agree time meddler is amazing
GUNFIGHTERS! Just the dentist office scene is worthy of a Hugo.
I like the dark man but my son keeps on telling me it doesn't count.
You said "The Gunfighters" as an honorable mention, however it was already #5 on your list haha! A nice little ranking video, to which I somewhat agree with! :)
fun list. Hartnell is my second fav also.
Time Meddler was the 1st Hartnell story I saw, during the 1993 BBC repeat run so it has always been one of my favourites too.
for honorable mentions, you said The Gunfighters...
You’re absolutely right, Time Meddler is currently my favourite First Doctor story.
Although I do have a fondness for Keys of Marinus, Tenth Planet, and War Machines.
Daleks master plan needs to be animated
Ah, Hartnell's a favourite of mine too. There really hasn't been a Doctor like him since. Even the oldest actor to portray the Doctor, Peter Capaldi, didn't give in anyway similar performance.
The Tenth Planet is all kinds of awesome. The Mondasian Cybermen are genuinely unnerving.
I am so here for Gunfighters love. And honestly, every single one of your choices would be on my list too. I think that your comments on the War Machines and the companions are really interesting.
The Gunfighters is so much fun!
@@JoshSnares I'm of that generation that was always told "Celestial Toymaker is a classic; The Gunfighters is awful", so I was blown away when I saw the latter. So much fun, so joyful.
I'd have to say The Time Meddler is my favourite. I can't go past all the other historicals. Aztec, Romans and Gunfighters are all amazing... I would definitely love to see Marco Polo, Myth Makers and the other half of The Crusade returned to the archives. Great video review. Thank you.
But why is this literally the best channel?
😍😍
For me, The War Machines is the best, but to be fair, I never watched Daleks' Masterplan. Hopefully I'll be able to one day. The Time Meddler is a close second for me, while The Sensorites (underrated!) is the third.
The First Doctor is my favourite as well, take five! ✋🏼
Josh: onarable mentions go to: the gunfighters...
Me: W A H T !
The Time Meddler and The Romans would definitely be on my list. Would also have An Unearthly Child and The Aztecs too.
My favorites
I do love the Romans. Proving Doctor Who can be farce. I also love the bit of "Ian, Barbara's calling you"
Massacre - It is such a strong story. Tragic. Also a strong Steven story that he takes center stage
Also I do feel the Ark needs a mention due to it being one of the few stories that really used the travel part as we rarely see the Doctor return and see the effect of what they did.
I love The Time Meddler. A real ground-breaking episode. I love the moment the recording of the monks singing slows down. Peter Butterworth is great as The Monk.
would you mind looking into cliffhangers and how they are significant both to doctor who as a show and the look into lost episodes?
I love it when you put a bit more personality into these videos
I think I'm gonna need to rewatch the Gunfighters now.
Do it!!
glad am not only one love gunfighters thank you josh, : smile happy face
You are right Josh, the daleks master plan should be animated next!
The Gunfighters...? I'd love to know your least favourite Hartnell stories... 😉 think I'd have to switch it out with The Aztecs. Top list, nice vid, thanks.
It is a crime that The Daleks isn't even an honourable mention.
I didn't know William Hartnell is your favorite doctor not hard to guess though your channel is what encouraged me to watch more of the black and white era outside of admittedly only 2 parts I had an interest in because of how important they are ( unearthly child and the 10th planet) Daleks master plan is the newest I'm not done with yet but have been enjoying your animations and the surviving 3 episodes I've heard a lot about marc polo assuming loss cannons stuff would be the best bet for watching it. he's not a personal preference in terms of personality traits I like in the doctor but he gave us the show and has great stories I have genuinely enjoyed it so far.
No surprises that the Daleks Marterplan is number one. Hopefully it will be animated one day.
The Gunfighters came in number 4, and was also in the honorable mentions. Other than than, very nice video.
In descending order
1 - The Unearthly Child (episode 1 only - the studio bound "cavemen trying to start a fire" episodes bore me)
2 - The Daleks
3 - The Web Planet (a guilty pleasure - so much ambition on a "High school Drama club" budget.)
4 - Daleks Master Plan (except the silly "Feast of Steven" for its ballsy killing off of characters.)
5 - The Ark (rare use in early Who of time travel within the story)
6 - Marco Polo - Best of the pure historicals.
Sold me on The Keys of Marinus. Purchased it after this.
OK, Josh. Here's my top six:
1) The Time Meddler
2) The Crusade
3) The War Machines
4) The Daleks
5) The Aztecs
6) The Web Planet
I've only seen the existent three episodes of DMP, so I'm going to just give it an honorable mention.
I too love The Gunfighters, and I'm not ashamed to say it!
yeehaw!