I feel she was saying no, no, no for 47 seconds because he was carrying her towards the balcony. And he had mentioned chucking her off, so of course she was terrified. Him saying he would let her go home except she's been a bad girl, tells me everything. He could have opened the hallway door and put her out there, but he chose the balcony for a reason.
@@samsngdevice5103 No you wouldn't, because that would make you a murderer unlike him. He was found NOT guilty by a jury of his peers in a court of law. If the court got this decision wrong, then everyone who has ever been found guilty should be innocent then. Also it wasn't kidnap, she went to his house voluntarily as shown on the cctv..
The evidence proves: 1. he is absolutely not the best guy 2. she is a super entitled, annoying b*tch 3. he didnt push her off the balcony Justice is not a popularity contest. Being a terrible, narcisistic womanizer doesnt make you a murderer automatically. The facts are the facts.
She was screaming bc he was dragging her to the balcony…he told her to “let go” bc she was hanging on to something inside, she BEGGED for him to let her leave…he is a psychopath and WILL kill again! Please please do an update! This poor girl
@@stevekoolie1977 he was found not guilty he could literally walk into the police station and say he murdered her and there is nothing they can do about it, you cant retry someone again after that.
Um, she tried to clobber him with a metal pole. Didn't you hear that? He was telling her to let go of the weapon she was using to hurt him. I guess you missed the part where he said, did you think it was like the movies, where you hit someone and they drop?
When that girl stated, "I just want to go home" and he replied "No, you have been a bad girl". At that very moment he was holding her against her will.
After knowing she fell or pushing her, he showed no remorse or empathy, he went downstairs, saw the cops, took off, got a pizza and went to sleep. Regardless if he was guilty or not the guy is an absolute psychopath.
@@littleangel18 Yeah and that would actually make him less guilty EINSTEIN... Even as a normal person it would be pretty hard to feel for somebody behaving THAT moronical, like she did.... What should he have empathy for? A girl that punched and kicked him repeatedly even after asking her to stop? Of course he had no empathy for her, a person without personality disorder woudlnt either after this experience.... I have ZERO empathy for her, after the recordings she seemed to be a disgusting human being.. When you want to argue that, you are lying to yourself sry...you also wouldnt have wanted to be around her for sure!
I can’t imagine being her family and listening to this 😭 it disturbed me deeply and I’m just a stranger and not only that but a desensitized true crime fan to boot.
The fact that he was found not guilty after the recording explicitly reveals that Warriena begged to just "let [her] go home" and Gable straight up replies with, "I *would*, but you've been a bad girl." How on Earth could they think he was innocent!? He chose to trap and lock her out on a 14 story balcony instead of letting her go home like she begged multiple times! Unbelievable! Not to even mention that he audibly physically assaulted her while she apologized and asked to go home. I'm glad his full name and psycho face were broadcasted so that women can avoid this psychopath. The dude even had the audacity and presence of mind to stomach eating some freaking pizza after everything that happened. Pure insanity on so many levels.
Even the other members of his beloved body building forum called him on his shit. He's the very definition of a toxic male that believes women are just tools that are responsible for building his ego. This is t0he kind of man that makes it dangerous for women to casually date, makes it easier for like-minded men to justify using/hating women, and makes it monumentally harder for decent men to earn any kind of trust from women. Ugh this entire story grinds the F out of my gears.
I'm so glad the law isn't decided by emotions. Even if one agrees with every point- she apologized and then begged to go home and he wouldn't let her. Up until he puts her outside and closes the door you think everything he did was wrong and everything she did was pure altruism- what then? Once she is alone outside on the balcony she has choices; wait even more than 27 seconds and maybe he will let her back in. Call out to other tenants or to people on the street- 17 floors is not impossible to hear. Grab a table or chair and threaten to smash the door. No. Instead she chooses to climb up and over a SAFETY RAIL 17 floors in the air and attempt to Nathan Drake her way to another balcony!? Gabe didn't force her to be drunk and he didn't force her very rash decision on that balcony. You want him to go to jail because he was "mean", that's one thing, you might also get a kidnapping charge to stick, though she was not out there long at all and she was throwing rocks and swinging a telescope piece- if she's not fully dressed and if she still has stuff to find but she's behaving like a lunatic, perhaps the idea was to let her cool off for a moment. It's not the worst idea. People keep citing the begging and "no!" repetition, but you never take into account that she switched over from aggressive, rude and threatening while actively assaulting to playing the complete victim. How does he know she won't just continue on the same if he puts her down? He chose to put a barrier between them- not a bad idea. It's his choice of barrier that is questionable, but any room in the apartment would Almost certainly qualify as kidnapping and throwing her into the hall would have interrupted neighbors and made a scene, so he thought "outside in fresh air"
The fact that his downstairs neighbor heard similar sounds coming from his place before tells you everything you need to know. This stuff always happens to you because you're the problem, mate.
if he slept with 270 women in there surely there was plenty of screaming. its not great evidence of anything if noone called the police and/or no girls ever reported it.
I think she screamed so long because he was putting her over the balcony, that’s why she kept saying “no” left her hanging there and waited for her to inevitably fall.
As soon as he told his father “I didn’t push her or anything” I knew he pushed her. After a divorce from a lying ex who would give away her guilt by telling me exactly what I didn’t ask is how I know she did. Don’t volunteer information without being asked. You’ve just told on yourself.
I’m not defending him or anything but the girl fell from the balcony, it was obvious for him to say that. Sometimes we panic and say things that are not needed not because we wanted to, and that’s what could have happened there if he’s innocent.
@@sohamchakraborty900I agree in general terms because I have anxiety and always over explain but I think in THIS particular case it is him telling on himself because I absolutely believe he did
He was just itching to throw someone off his balcony. His log about trying to pick up one of his tinder dates and carry them back into the apartment prior to her running home and blocking him gave an insanely weird impression. But his saying "you're lucky i haven't thrown you off my balcony" after having tried to get her out there every time she said anything disrespectful made his murderous intentions blindingly obvious. Definitely premeditated
Omfg, terrifying thought isn't it, to think people are actually plotting or fantasising about this crap. Scary stuff. 😔 This world is full of the depraved & thankfully, also the good.
@@janelizabeth8680 Im just amazed at the people on here defending him, or justifying what he did, or victim blaming her for going home with a stranger. Bad choices don't ",justify" murder in any, single, solitary way!
That was the most terrifyingly, spine chilling thing I have ever heard. She was murdered. I think that all the time she was screaming no, was because he was forcing her out the door onto the balcony and over the railing. How after hearing that recording, could he be found not guilty?
this recording is cut down. in the full recording you hear her screaming, him closing the door seemingly panting from the physical exhaustion AND THEN her distant, muffled screams. He wasn't near her when she fell so it isnt technically murder. Though i do wonder how he wasnt charged for involuntary manslaughter at the very minimum
Nah he didn't throw her over. When u listen to it all & in order u can hear he didn't. He's disgusting, sexually aggressive & an asshole, he should've carried her out of the apartment & not out to the balcony. She was so scared on the balcony & I believe tried to climb to another balcony to escape him. He is responsible for her death by his actions, even with her violent episodes.
He was twice her size, a bodybuilder, possibly on steroids. She was not beating him up and he didn't let her leave when she wanted to. He also plied her with strong alcohol when she was already drunk. He orchestrated her death and the fact that he walked away Scott free is quite frankly astonishing
Hes 100% going to kill again. When she stated I wanna go home and he said “No You’ve been a very bad girl” made my stomach flip. That alone states he’s holding her against her will. Must be nice to have mommy and daddy’s money and a good lawyer.
Yes, I know this case. He is very much guilty and has been enabled his whole life. Terrible parents. And now his belief that he's untouchable has been validated. Tha makes him dangerous. Stay FAR away from this creep folks!
There was 100% malice in his voice when he replied to her asking to go home. " I would have but you've been a bad girl". Like many other have said he could have just tossed her out the front door and shut it. How did a jury find him not guilty?
He illegally imprisoned her. Had he let her leave sh would be alive today. How he didn't get charged with other crimes he committed if not murder s beyond me.
@@RaphaelDawkinsCombatRadio It's a relief to read a man understand the situation instead of pulling the mysogynistic card to humiliate the woman. You're a rarity right now.
It's the brightest red flag of red flags. For her to swipe right on AND go out with that nutcase she must've really been down bad. When a dude's first message is sexual you know to that guy you're literally a human sex toy.
I was thinking thr same thing! I don't know how they possibly could have found him not guilty after listening to his own recording! The other person who should be ashamed of themselves is Gable's father! The fact that he never sounded shocked, surprised or even alarmed during their call speaks volumes about what Gable has done in the past. Also, his father picking him up and bringing him home, knowing everything that just happened is astounding! There's absolutely no way that my mom would have taken me anywhere but back to the scene to talk to the officers! With this kind of enabling, it's no wonder that Gable is the entitled little bully he is!!
for what?? They had no evidence to prove him guilty of murder, sure he was guilty of other things like negligence and harassment but not murder, there just isn't evidence to prove he killed her
@@jakesherman8080 You don’t HAVE to have definitive evidence to convict as a jury. Yes that is the law and they can tell you that you need to convict based on the law and that the burden of proof is on the prosecutor but you don’t actually have to do that. If the jury decides to convict without “definitive” evidence that is legal. That may not have been enough evidence for the law but it’s enough for me if I was on the jury. The same goes the other way if there is video of a guy shooting someone and the evidence is clear, but I personally feel it was justified because the guy he shot hurt his child in the past, then I would not agree to a guilty verdict if I was on the jury
@@sillyravis1340 the jury can rule whatever they want to rule, again I am saying there is no evidence to support the theory that he killed her, all there is suggests he threw her outside onto his balcony, that is all that we know and can infer
@@jakesherman8080homeboy killed her. He had a chance to kick her out but instead she’s taken outside into the porch- the only place where she could die. At the very least it’s manslaughter. She screams and pleads with him to let her go home. He replies with harsh coldness “I would but you’ve been a bad girl.” Jeezus
It's very clear by the audio that he killed her. He was saying things like let go and yet you can hear him strangling her. He was saying things to make it SEEM like he was defending himself. Really putting on a show. It was SO obvious. He knew he was recording things.
Exactly, anyone with more than two brain cells to rub together should be able to figure that out. Absolutely appalling that he got away with it. Where was this-Australia? Idk how their legal system works, but the jury (if they do that) must’ve been made up of cretins, or the judge.
Yes. He beat her up and thought he might get in trouble for her injuries, so he threw her over! That way her injuries would be thought to have come from her fall. Sadly he has lots of admirers. In the jury and in public. I even bet a young female jury member contacted him later to hook up! This is just the way the world is!! We are what we area!!
The neighbors didn't want to call the police with all the noise, as they didn't want to get a pretty boy in trouble! Good looking people are the 💣 They get away with murder.....they really do!
If he wanted her out of his apartment so badly, why not throw her out the front door rather than the balcony? I can not fathom how the investigation lead to a not guilty verdict; an absolute injustice was done. How horrifying for Warriena and her loved ones.
Exactly. You've got to consider if someone's in his pocket. This isn't how tbe justice system works with so much incriminating evidence. This corruption has been enabled by those in that court and NZ has blood on its hands.
Two things chill me to the bone: a) his tone when he insults her b) she would have been completely aware of the danger but unable to react, because of the shit he brewed up for her. What a monster. He should NEVER be allowed back into society again
This man is a monster. The audio is absolutely horrifying. That poor girl. He recorded the entire thing. The absolute arrogance and lack of empathy is astounding. An absolute monster. How could he possibly be exonerated?
@@stacyjjk-hv8ty He created the monster by plying her with incredibly strong home brewed liquor when she was already drunk. He also refused to let her leave. Which is a criminal offence, that's unlawful imprisonment. So had he let her go, she would have still been alive today. But he plied her with alcohol and illegally imprisoned her. He should be charged for that. And if he's found guilty of illegal imprisonment then he must be found culpable in her death.
Well maybe because she was so drunk she tried to cimb over the balcony. If he was inside and locked the door because she was acting crazy maybe on drugs she lost her footing drunk abusive women are. highly dangerous.
@@MsDrunkendave maybe instead of choking or overpowering a girl twice your size, grab her and put her out. He didn’t have to hide her phone, keep her from leaving or lock her outside.
@@MsDrunkendave it's not okay for anyone to assault anyone, but it's also not your right to shame this victim because of your personal worldview or hangups.
@@MsDrunkendave No one deserves to be suffocated, just because they cannot handle their liquor, and conssequently becomes a stupid violent drunk. He was much bigger and could have just put out the front door and locked it.
This is the third case I heard where a woman falls to her death in Australia, and the man in the house says it was suicide.😒 And some of these men get away with it.
I'm from Australia and this case was ALL over the news when it happened, it was so blindingly obvious that he was guilty. The national outrage was palpable. There were also multiple women who had met him/gone on dates previously with him, who came forward, all of their stories were eerily similar. It should also be noted that he had Warriena's phone in his pocket the whole time - he *finds* it while on the phone to his father afterwards. Violence against women in this country is not treated seriously at all, offenders are given so many chances - even just this week a 21 year old woman was stabbed to death in front of her 3 year old son, by yet another deranged man who had already shown so many red flags. They just don't care about us here. RIP Warriena
@@picklesmccoy7796 Sorry but it's the same in EVERY COUNTRY, including America. So many men like this are all over the world. Especially with these sites like Tinder that a lot of men use for casual sex. Violence against women is nothing new globally. Australia is no different to any other western country in that regard. The original commenter must not have traveled much to say something like that.
I agree. The laws there are sad. Murderers barely ever get life. If it was in the USA depending on the state he would've got the death penalty. Which he deserves
The only thing that I know leaded to this incident was her screaming..because if you scream ..that alarms every person's mind even if they are innocent ..because louder noises makes you innocent instantly and other one one guilty ..so don't scream ..because no one wants to go jail without actually doing anything
Edit; “For the people who are saying she jumped by her own, go listen to the tape again ,she was begging him to let her go home and he replied I would BUT YOU WERE A BAD GIRL, if she jumped by her own as he claimed why he could not help her not to do so ???????” *It’s heartbreaking to listen to the lady screaming No No No as she’s knowing it was her end, I can’t imagine how horrific was to fall from that balcony 😢 What a cruel cold blood murderer He could simply let her go home I wish karma will get him soon since justice was deaf and blind in this case. May she R.I.P
@@Metadeth1997 he tossed her onto the balcony and closed the door, she then in a drunken state tried to clump to the lower level how is that his fault.
@@nervoussips2622 Well we werent there were we? Listening too the tapes is enough too understand what happened. Why would a woman climb down a building thats several stories tall, knowing its a death sentence?
He was definitely trying to throw her over when she was screaming “No no no no no!!” and he kept telling her to let go because she was gripping the railing. The terror in her screams is definitely that of somebody who thinks they’re about to die. That’s why she was facing outwards. Nobody trying to get down from a FOURTEENTH FLOOR balcony is going to do so facing outwards. Period! He got her over and she was gripping the railing and he just left her like that because he knew she’d fall. Not only did he actually mention throwing her off the balcony, but he tried several times to get her to look for her phone out there. He was TRYING to get her out on the balcony. Did police ever investigate the phone situation? Did they find her phone? He knew exactly what was going to happen and it’s exactly what he wanted. He didn’t even bother to look over. Anyone, I don’t care if they’re getting along or not, anyone would freak out at somebody falling 14 stories to their death right in front of them. He didn’t even do much as flinch, didn’t bother calling police or ambulance, and actually ate f*cking pizza. Again, nobody normal would have an appetite after that sh*t. He’s clearly sick! And the fact that the neighbor said they had heard screams just like hers weeks before….. he probably tried it then with another girl. He gets extremely aggressive sexually and it freaks girls out and they probably fear that they’re going to be r*ped so they try to leave and it pisses him off. He’s a straight up weirdo! It broke my heart to hear her screams. Those could only be described as the screams of somebody who KNEW they were going to die. And her saying “I just want to go home! I just want to go home!” is even more heart breaking.
He didn't do anything wrong, aside from inviting a girl with clear mental issues into his home. She tried to climb out of his building and fell. That's very obvious.
@@scottandrews947 Exactly. We can clearly hear in the recording that she was a drunk, violent mess. He was probably trying to drag her out to the balcony so she could cool down and she was holding onto something, like the leg of a table. He was probably gonna leave her out there while he found her phone and then send her on her way.
both you guys are sick if you think his not to blame and even if she was drunk would u lock a drunk person out on your balcony! no you wouldn’t because it’s dangerous at 14 floors high, instead you would call the police or kick her out the FRONT DOOR and make her go home like she kept on saying she wants to go home.
"why does this keep happening to me?" That phone call was so sketch. He just assumed she jumped cause cops are around his apartment?? Yeah right dude. He also says he thinks she must have thought it was a joke. It couldn't have been that bad if she could reasonably expect him to think she was joking
WRONG. You have obviously never met a drunk Kiwi girl. And neither had he by the sounds of it. They get drunk and proceed to bash and belittle their man and don't stop until physically stopped. THEY ARE EXHAUSTING Don't get me wrong this guy is an imbecile and only had to push her out his front door instead of his patio door 🙄. She was saying no, no as he was pushing her out the door and she had realised that she had gone to far. He could of stopped and told her to leave again and she may have actually left voluntarily at that point but the Moron probably wanted to punish her for all the crap she had done to him. And then she decided to climb around to the next unit but fell. And yes he needs to go to prison for it. Just my two cents worth. From the land down under 🇦🇺 🇦🇺🇦🇺
I’m just gonna put this out there for the Aussie ladies in the comments - first of all, he was found not guilty but second he’s back on tinder under the name Eric Thomas. He’s also had other similar incidents with women and his balcony.
Well he was lying to his dad and it didn't seem scripted at all. And they edited out the parts where the father responded. Are you being intentionally dense?
I know one thing, I never want to hear that audio again, chilled me to my core. I feel like he dangled her over the balcony edge hence her screaming "NO" so many times and left her there to fall. Terrifying.
That was horrifying to listen to. I'm legit shaking. What a horrible horrible man. He has no business being free. He could've put her out the door, but like he said when she begged him to let her go home, " I would but you've been a bad girl". He knew she was never going home. How is he free?
To me when he locked her out he knew her being so drunk and in terror that only bad things could happen. He should have been responsible for at least a Man slaughter charge.
Let's conveniently forget all the times she verbally berated him; Let's face it, she HAD indeed been a bad girl. The bitch couldn't handle her liquor, becoming a bad drunk, like happens to a number of people when under the influence. She did in fact become a psycho bitch after one too many.
Agree that he should have put her out in the hallway, locked his door, and called the police. She assaulted him. Problem solved. He's free because convicting a person of murder required evidence in support of a conviction. There was no such evidence. He was definitely a creep, but a murderer? We'll never know.
I'd be horribly embarrassed if my kids grew up to think fornication was acceptable. (And no, this is not virtue signaling, or whatever crap woke people think it is.)
This was one of the worst recordings I've ever heard, you can hear how scared and confused she is and the malice in his voice. The gaslighting is the worst part. I can't believe he got free, I have no doubt he's done this before
Of course he killed her. If he had wanted her out of his apartment why didnt he push her out of the door into the hallway. Then shut the door behind her. Im sure the front door is a more secure door than the balcony door. He got away with murder. If she were my daughter i would swing for him.
That doesn’t fit the definition of murder in the least! I love these arguments people have- so she’s drunk and not to blame for throwing rocks, he is drunk, getting hit by rocks and is supposed to assume if he puts her outside, she will jump! Was she even dressed? So he should throw an half dressed, wildly unreasonable woman into the hallway of his apartment building at that hour? I’m not saying he’s a good guy- he seems to be slime, but what he did was not beyond reason. She was behaving poorly and doing damage to the apartment - and I don’t care what size you are, rocks hurt. She also grab a piece of a telescope to hit him. So he put her outside to cool down. She wasn’t out there for even a minute and it wasn’t freezing, so why she chose to go directly over the rail is insane. It’s tragic. He didn’t make the best choices, but in no way did he cause her to climb over that rail and try some Uncharted move. In the end, he is SO LUCKY he had that recording because even with the evidence, people want to assume the worst of him and the best of her.
@@tylerskiss I'm not saying he did or didn't murder her but I also don't think u can definitively state he didn't. She's screaming NO so many times n for so long how do you know that when he was forcing her onto the balcony he didn't pick her up and act/physically insinuate or actually begin to physically force her over that railing? That's why with just the audio, I won't make a judgement on murder. If she climbed over to try n climb down, I don't believe her feet would've been facing out but rather toward the building.
@@tylerskiss I'm curious why he only chose to record audio. Seems like your average person who wanted to document the wild things happening around them would opt for recording video more than those who would opt for only audio. Definitely wouldn't be my first instinct. I guess he was trying to conceal it, maybe? But at that point it seemed like she was drunk enough to probably not even notice the phone as much as if she was sober. His past also leaves me with some bias as well. They were both insanely drunk as well so nothing good could have really come out of it aside from her just leaving.
@@tylerskiss How many times did he say about throwing her off the balcony. So as you say she was beating him up. This guy outweighed her & towered over her. Had already dominated her in his flat. Why did he push her onto the balcony & not into the hallway outside of his flat? If he wanted to be rid of her or for her to calm down he should have put her into the hallway. He wanted her to go off the balcony.
@cyril lmfao yo people really think like you? She asked to go home and he taunted her. Her body was facing away from the balcony as she fell. Rocks ? Lol little baby rocks ? I have had a woman throw literally fist at me and hot coffee in my own home and I never laird my hands on her or any other woman for that matter. He murdered her lol 😂 you’re absolutely deranged like the judge who let this man go free.
She said she wanted to go home and he refused saying, "I would but you've been a bad girl." Her death is a direct result of his actions. He should have at least been convicted on manslaughter.
Murder as he thought about it first as his statements about him saying "she was lucky he didn't chuck her off the balcony" NO one puts a drunk person on a balcony to cool off. A bunch of bull crap. He tried to drop her while she was facing forward so she couldn't grab anything when he let go, but she still managed to grab on, if even for a bit. Thepeople who let him go free are idiots, and I hope their reading this too. She probably wasn't even used to that hard liquor and it makes some people mean, but even if she was mean, he should have just waited for her to sober up, and if she got to be too much put her out the front door and lock it. He will kill again someday, and next time he will be even more sneaky about it. All thanks to the losers in the courtroom.
@@murdermysterymissing8044 He was inside, you can tell by the recording. You hear her on the other side of the balcony door. He never hung her off the balcony. She thought she could climb down below. She's obviously the abusive, defiant type. I've been there. Numerous times. I know her type all too well. My question is, why didn't that guy grab her when she was hanging on? He said he could touch her.
You hear her on the outside in the recording. So he didn't throw her off. But you don't put an abusive, defiant drunk girl on a balcony and lick the door. Im pretty sure she thought she could climb down below. She slipped.
@@jeffcampbell2710 Just because he was inside when she ultimately fell doesn’t mean he didn’t throw her off. Watch the end of the video. It’s very plausible that he could have tried pushing her over facing out, which would have occurred during her screaming No over and over, she grabs onto the railing to stop the fall. He walks inside leaving her there, slams the door and locks it. You would still hear him inside and her muffled yells for help outside, then her ultimate fall. It’s the prevailing theory for those that believe he’s guilty. Also, there’s no way the dude could have reacted quickly enough to grab her unless he was a superhero. He wasn’t on the floor beneath her, he was two floors down. She had already passed the balcony directly below, and was picking up momentum as she rocketed passed the next balcony, even if reacted in that split second and reached out in an attempt to grab onto her, there’s no way he could have gained enough grip to hault the pull of gravity, and move her onto his balcony to safety. Even if he did grab on or get an arm stuck onto her in that split second, the force of her body falling would have probably pulled him off the balcony to his death as well. Dudes an extreme weirdo loser. I bet every single woman left him completely unsatisfied and creeped out beyond belief, which is why he could never have a girlfriend.
@@GenerationDown you can hear her up against the glass. If she was over the railing, you wouldn't have heard her. She was talking loud, she wasn't screaming bloody murder. Big difference.
This dude recorded himself choking and muffling her face while saying the PERFECT things to paint the story he wanted… and you can tell when he’s cursing at her, he’s totally getting off to degrading and threatening her. The fact that he’s out there now is terrifying.
@@anthonycampos8057 He may not have pushed her, but he told his Dad, “I saw her climbing over his rail” Um he could have done so much different like kick her out into the hallway but that’s not what he wanted he “had” to punish her for being “a bad girl” seriously he’s the reason she fell, so damn right he killed her. At the very least murder 2nd degree, this guy walked out not guilty” but that doesn’t make him innocent
@@michellefucile7426 well I'm talking by the letter of the law. And i gotta be honest, I think a not guilty verdict would've occurred in the US as well.
How could her saying "JUST LET ME GO HOME” and him saying “I CANT YOUVE BEEN A BAD GIRL” not be enough to prove he’s guilty?!?! That recording was chilling. He was getting off on abusing her like that.
It’s unbelievable how such a monster like him got off with this,his parents were as much to blame for letting him off with what he did and paying for his freedom they’re all sick,sad,mentally I’ll individuals
Well because someone can't pick and choose which part of it to believe or not depending on their agenda. Using your own logic and Placing so much importance on Words. On the recording he had also told her to get her stuff and get out and to leave, On the recording It was very clear she Had admitted to Assaulting him more than once. Once being with Something used as a weapon. I've listened to it 3 times At this point, There is something definitely off about him. But without a doubt The same goes for her.
@@teelitek9275 She was drunk and he muffled her. He was Smothering her, You could hear the snorting hardcore. You can totally tell he killed her on that tape.
I believe he carried her to the balcony and put her over it, she grabbed onto the railing and he left her dangling. This explains the 47 seconds of her screaming no repeatedly. She was terrified.
Yeah if her feet were away from the building that means she was facing away, holding onto the railing from behind her. She was probably stuck and too drunk to work out how to get back over, and too scared to go back over the railing because he was probably still there basically refusing to let her get back. So she keeps saying no like no leave me alone just let me go home. It also explains why the neighbors couldn't figure out what they were seeing. Because if her feet were facing the building it's be obvious she was falling off and needed help. But facing the other way would mean she's stupidly trying to get down the wrong way
He, knowing how drunk she was, probably picked her up and placed her on the other side of the balcony knowing she wouldn’t have the strength to climb back up. He already choked her out and her screams at the end shows she was terrified. So sad.
I wouldn’t fuck with a kiwi those guys are huge this guy is lucky she died and the police took him or her cousins would of came and f$&@ed him up. As a kiwi myself if anyone spoke to my family the way he is speaking to her I’d break his f$&@ing legs and arms
The several times he said, in a menacing tone 'You don't understand do you....' He knew he was recording himself so he was careful with his words. But the meaning behind it was 'you don't understand how dangerous I am. What I'm capable of' ... A normal man does not threaten to throw someone of the balcony (twice). Her cries of No were haunting. I grew up going to Surfers on holidays etc., and have family that live nearby so was interested in this case. I also know that tradie / aussie tone and the meaning behind it, so I stand by my interpretation. I fully believe he should still be in jail for murder. It is incomprehensible he is free.
Yes, let that be a lesson to us all. You never truly know how dangerous anyone is or what triggers rage, aggression etc. What past trauma or pain someone has lived with may come boiling to the surface in an unstoppable explosion. And what is a normal man/woman? Everyone is capable of anything if you push “their” right button. “You’ll never know the psychopath sitting next to you” -twenty one pilots
@@la2alaska336 Another lesson can go for the Aussie court system. Dont reward these little cowards proclaimed to be sociopaths, throw them in prison where they can attempt that intimidation shit on real men.
I agree with you that when he was repeating to her, "You don't understand do you", he was degrading her as a stupid idiot and garbage in his own mind, because in his mind, she was an idiot because she did not understand or even suspect what was going to happen to her. to justify killing her in his own mind, he had to reduce her as an idiot who did not even deserve to live. Is other statement, "This is bull shit" and"this is more than enough" were all means of justifying himself killing her. What I am sure is the reason he killed her was for the thrill, and his reason for recording this is because he wanted the thrill of reliving murdering her by listening to the recording. It is very rare to encounter a man that make people experience such degree of disgust and repulsion, like this fucking piece of shit. Every thing possible must be done to deny this coward, any opportunity to hide himself. Anyone and everyone that come any where near to him, must be made aware that he is in fact, a disgusting monster. Absolutely every woman that might happen to come anywhere near to him, must be informed of what he did and what he is. I did not believe in the death penalty, but I have now changed my mind. I now believe that monster like him should and must be put to death, and I can't help but feel that hanging or electric chair or lethal injection is not good enough, he should be put to death by being thrown off the roof of a high rise building.
or you don't understand that you're about to die, do you. I have an imeasurable amount of true crime stories, this one disturbed me the most. That recording is the worst thing I've ever heard and spews evil like I've never heard, even more than the guy who takes his girlfriend up the elevator then throws her over the balcony. I can't
Absolutely 100% guilty. How on earth did he get away with that. He was clearly strangling her, you could hear her struggling to breathe. It sounds to me like he forced her out onto the balcony, her feet were facing away from the balcony which indicated he hung her over the edge and then let her go. This is murder for sure. 😡
Amanda, I see it The same way. How do they know he wasn't close to her on the balcony? If she were that drunk how is she going to climb over away from the railing? With her arms behind her? No way! He was holding her over facing away from the building. It's the only thing that makes ANY sense. I don't know anyone(from experience- I used to climb balconies to get down), who would climb down that way! Impossible unless you're trying to off yourself.
Let me elaborate it please, You are with a girl in room having all that ..she is super drunk ..beating destroying your place ..and when it's more than enough for you and you forcefully stop her , then she realises her position that she is in strangers apartment with with a complete stranger person and minds starts showing all trapped girl movies ..(aka GOAT SENSES are activated) .. next thing you know she starts screaming with a complete strange behaviour ..so stop drinking if you can't handle ..and get married with a single person ..I mean you guys are also humans 'right!! ..stop behaving like animals like fu*king whenever you guys are horny no matter who.
Exactly correct. He has a choice to put her out the apartment building but why outside the balcony. Obviously he is a psychopath and he enjoy punishing those poor girls that slept with him. Imagine in bed with 200 girls just almost in 2 years.
@@joycelow2667 Hey, that's 270 girls/daddy issue skanks, not 200. No roofies, just straight up game. Give him props for his game. Or for his lays' easiness.
@@oldmandoinghighkicksonlyin1368 Please share with me your story of having immense brain damage and being stuck inside the personality of a 14 year old boy
She was clearly very intoxicated and clearly terrified. Her screams of “no!” were utterly chilling. I reckon he was dangling her over by her arms. After all, she couldn’t go home because she was a “bad girl”. This man was a monster.
I also think he was dangling her by her arms that's why she kept yelling NO! NO! Since he's a bodybuilder then finally just dropped her. This was so sick and sad story 😞
So you were there and saw what happened? Unless you were, you really shouldn’t jump to conclusions. Making “jump” was a poor choice of words, but you know what I mean.
@@lovinglife4327 He was ACQUITTED, after a long trial and all the evidence had been presented. But she knows what happened because, well it’s HER opinion, and you know what they say about opinions don’t you?
Dude made mostly every woman he came across uncomfortable. He was not charming nor did he have a way with words. I believe he felt emasculated from not being in control of the situation. To have a women fight him not only angered him but made him feel weak. Dude always made himself the victim in every situation ("why does stuff like this always happen to me"). He didn't throw her into the hall, call her a Uber, call the police, he kept her in the apartment and I believe he didn't attend to let her go until he felt he had gotten "even".
@@MrSloppySausage he actually doesn't seem charming at all, he seems like a little pig. I think most women just looked at them and thought he was hot and that's why he was with so many women
He couldn't have made that many women feel Uncomfortable, 200 plus of them slept with him. Why the narrator makes it sound like men, or at least just this guy is the only bad one BECAUSE he goes out trolling for sex. He wouldn't get any of there weren't women looking for no strings attached one nighters. Maybe ALL these women should stop going home with strangers. Is Tindr NOT known for specifically being an app for meeting up for......well, not long lasting relationships? Granted this guy is a major douche, but don't forget, it's Tnder & as long as he's good looking, it's AMAZING what women will ignore. Stop teaching young women it's OK to go with any dude, bc after all "men do it". Men & women are not the same, it's biological. Maybe if men are taught to better respect women and women are taught to respect themselves, you wouldn't have an absolute loser like this guy getting over 200 broads to go home with him. 🤷♀️ As a female, it's embarrassing really. I'm just grateful my mom taught me to respect myself & to not go home W random men and that women are not as strong as men physically.
WOW that was really hard to listen too. I've heard about this case over and over on different channels but I've never heard that's recording before and I never want to hear it again. It has me literally crying for her and my daughter, and granddaughters just thinking that could have been one of them. He's a literal piece of 💩!!!!! And we'll be hearing about him again I don't doubt that for a minute. He already had a big head about himself and now getting away with murder he thinks he's invincible... Stay safe everyone
HE has constantly been in trouble with police ever since. Changed his name. Just days ago he was found naked and passed out in his car then evaded police
I think he placed her on the other side of the railing, knowing she would eventually lose grip and fall, and he could claim he was nowhere near her when it happened. Immediately before he slams the door, she lets out a louder, longer, more panicked and pleading scream. I think it was the moment she realized this wasn’t just some kind of sadistic joke, and that he was actually leaving her there and walking away.
The neighbors would've heard that sort of commotion and said they heard a male voice fighting with a woman. The struggle obviously happened inside the apartment. In her drunken state, she tried to climb over the railing and down to the floor below.
This is what I wondered too. He took her out, put her down on the wrong side of the railing and then left her knowing she wouldn’t be able to get back to the right side but that it would give him time to get inside and away from her before she fell so he could show he was nowhere near her and honestly be able to say he didn’t push her or throw her off but he’s still 100% responsible for her falling. There was no way she was getting back to the balcony without falling even if she was sober and facing the building instead of backwards!
@@pinkfluffydino8217 why wouldn't she be able to get to the other side? I've been plenty drunk before but I was still capable of climbing over the edge of a balcony...
Do they have no justice in Australia? If it weren't for the recording I'd say it was iffy but the recording clearly shows what happened. Can't believe he walked away
It's disgraceful isn't it 😡 When it comes to violence against your intimate partner Australia treats victims like shyt 😡😠 Something seriously needs to change 😡😠 RIP to all the victims, men and women, of domestic violence across Australia 🇦🇺 and world wide.
It took 46 seconds because she was resisting him in a fight for her life, as he dragged her to the balcony, held her over the side and eventually let her go! I don’t think she was out there by herself at all, and the audio does not prove that he wasn’t with her. He could have simply set the phone down.
His dad is a lawyer, he called his dad then left the building. Since he got off for this crime, he's been back on tinder and also been arrested for drugs and driving while under the influence of alcohol both of which he got off because of his dad. Money can get you off a murder charge.
That was one of the most infuriating “not guilty” verdicts that I have ever heard of in my years of consuming true crime stories. There is zero chance that he didn’t murder this woman. I’m in shock and disbelief that he got away with it considering the damning recordings. She said she would leave and even begged him to let her go home. All he had to do was get her out the door. He had something to prove. Locking her out while she was standing in the balcony would have been forgivable and cause reasonable doubt, but we can clearly hear that isn’t what happened.
@@andresweinman9995 Amen 🙏 to that, that’s why he made that homemade Vodka, I’m sure. Alcohol is usually one ☝️ of the guilty parties. Devils brew for sure 👍
He didn't get away with murder. Yes you hear him restrain her, but in this audio you can clearly hear her outside while he came back in the apartment from the balcony. This proves she was still on the balcony while he came back in. At the very least this was manslaughter. This is why he was found not guilty.
You can tell everything in the tone of his voice. He is saying all the right things, but in the most relaxed tone ever. If an innocent human being went through what he described, they would be hysterical. I've noticed thats where a lot of guilty criminals mess up. They think that being calm makes them appear innocent, when in reality its the exact opposite. Innocent people freak out, and raise their voice and ask the police questions if they're being interrogated. I've watched enough true crime to know that the calm ones are usually guilty.
I mean she wanted it rough and wanted to dominate someone , all the money talk was about this . and when things got rough she just decided she is in danger and jumped off the balcony , its such a simple case.He is a psyco but she was crazy too hah
@@Tetrathegod Bro 🤦♀️ She was drunk because he was plowing her with booze all night while he stayed sober. Why was he recording it to begin with? Why did he threaten with throwing her off the balcony? He took her phone and she got upset& he used that to his advantage. Don't be foolish dude.
@@jillybean9563 wdym he was plowing her with booze? XD she is an adult and knew what she was taking . and the guy is a complete retard maybe it was just games and just being playful . She was just your typical wanna be dominant woman and when you take away her power as he did by pushing her and choking her .. anyways just 2 wrong people in 1 room . Maybe he needed bit of prison so he can grow up .
@@Tetrathegod He was giving her alcohol, but not drinking any himself. You can hear in her voice how plastered she is. She sounds really, really, really intoxicated. Not saying that's an excuse to get violent, but what I think happened is he was doing things to piss her off, taking her phone, you can hear hitting& objects being thrown, (and we don't really know who was doing what, we just have his word and I'll take that with a grain of salt) Who knows what else he was doing to make her mad so that he had an excuse to push her off the balcony. Unfortunately we only have audio and no visuals, we can hear him saying things like "I should never have given you so much to drink. Im injured and you don't have a scratch on you. This is bullshit. You're lucky I haven't chucked you off my balcony." He got her drunk, and then made remarks to make it sound like she was being violent on the recordings and then threw her off the balcony. She screams "No, I'll leave" and he still continues to drag her onto the balcony. Why didn't he just let her leave? I think he knew exactly what he was doing. 7 years later and he has more allegations. Dude is a creep.
She was saying " let me go home". She did NOT jump. He dangled her off the balcony & let her fall to her death in a disgusting fit of rage. He had just replied "too late for that" when she said just let me go home. He didn't even see her as a person, like all the women he "dated". There's a reason all those women at his apt. & in the clubs got such a creepy vibe off him . Unfortunately Wareena was so drunk that it was too late when she realized who she was with was a monster
Exactly! Plus you don’t hear her bang on the balcony door because she had no time. No body had time to save her because she was dangling when he left her. This guy tried to choke her, she would’ve gone to the police.
@@MsJoey2121 Exactly! And he started the whole thing, he stole her phone, she wanted it back so she could leave. He WANTED to get into it with her & then kill her 😡 . I swear she should have run out his front door screaming for help, in whatever she had on, purse or no purse. Sometimes you are fighting for your very life & it's all that matters. And her phone was in his pocket the whole time, is what he told the police he "found it in his pocket"! He killed her intentionally. I heard that he did it again too.
You don't hear a struggle on the balcony. I also thought first he killed her but probably he didn''t and just locked her on the balcony, she was afraid to go back and started climbing. But it's strange that she faced forward. If there was a sound of a struggle I would immediately agree.
@@alexthedeal1827 Screaming "no, no, no" & he says "let go" because she was clinging to him for dear life isnt a struggle? She's struggling to hang on to him because she knows he's going to toss her. Your misogyny is showing, Alex!
@@elizabethjarvie4472 listening to it more times I think you're right. I was confused because first it started on the bed or so where he pinned her down and grabbed a flashlight or so. Then she starts with no and it seams dramatic but then you can her hear continuing to say no when they're on the balcony so there it's probably no don't kill me. But what is 100% proof, no guessing, is that the hairdressers underneath see her dangling while she is saying things that he recorded before he clearly closes the balcony door. So when yoi combine these 2 things it's 100% and he should have been convicted, don't understand hiw they did not reenact simultaniously what they heard/ what he recorded, crazy.
How in the hell was he found not guilty… just getting her that drunk should have been a crime…. I cannot believe he got away with murder… he 100% was trying to “Chuck her off the balcony” like said… smh RIP baby girl
The part where she said let me go home, and he said no… that’s where he should have been given at least some form of punishment for causing the circumstances of her death, even if she fell.
@@HumbleConfidenceESagreed I don’t think it was murder but defo had a part to play…she was ridiculously drunk and slightly nuts but he enjoyed toying with her and by locking her on the balcony probably had hoped she would do something stupid
@@juliexx1980 he shouldn’t have been going tit for tat with a drunk emotional woman, should have tried to reason with her more, but he was drunk himself so… but yeah… letting her get on that balcony was very strange and spiteful. Just very sad how it ended. As a judge I’d probably have given him at least 2-4 years.
@@HumbleConfidenceESI don’t support the guy but one thing I’ll stand by is people as hammered as she was can’t be reasoned with. That much alcohol makes it pretty much impossible
@@dk9102 true, unsure if you drink yourself, but in Islam alcohol is called the mother of all evils (it leads to numerous harmful actions to one’s self and society)
My son was out recently and he saw him, some guy had his phone in his face recording him yelling it’s gable the murderer......he’s still on dating sites and prowling around clubs 🤢
Yea, I agree. I live in S.E. Queensland and was bombarded with this case, however I heard and learned more about tostie and the case on this channel than I have heard before. He truly is a nut job this grub. Typical of Queensland justice system, he should already have been in prison prior to this heinous crime. We will hear about this grub again in the future, I can feel it in my water ! 🇦🇺xoxox🇦🇺
This was horrifying to listen to. Aside from this terribly sad story I just want to say that this video was really well made and you are quickly growing into my favorite true crime UA-camr. I love the narration and the originality. The stories are also told so clearly. Thank you for your work!
He clearly records his dates so he can manipulate who ever listens after he's done something horrible. It's all scripted nonsense from him . Absolute Psycho
This case has always pissed me off and after the first time watching it I never wanted to really hear about it again. But it is almost 3 AM and I can’t find anything new to watch and I love this channel so therefore I will support it by watching it again. 😊 thank you for creating such great content from these horrible cases. Every time I get a notification from y’all I am extremely happy
Just from the recording, it should be obvious for anyone with half a brain , what really happened. When she said NO for 47 second, he was carrying her toward the balcony , had her by the hands and she was trying not to get over the railing with her legs getting clingy. After 47 seconds he got her legs over the railing and put her hands on the railing , knowing she will cling to it , all this time she was with the back facing the building. Then he went inside and after 30 seconds she couldnt hold on anymore. That is why, he wasnt with her at the time of the fall . Prosecution was trully incompetent or really stupid. I cant believe this is possible, quite outrageous
This is the most accurate statement I’ve read on this horrific incident. If her hands were on the very top of the railing, rounded metal, she could’ve held on and climbed back over. The problem is, her hands were gripping the cement part of the terrace which is much lower. It was only a matter of time she would lose that grip. The only part that I’m completely confused about is your comment reiterating that her back was facing the building. That’s incorrect. Her back was facing the street. In the graphic image from the neighbors terrace 1 floor below, you can see the front of her feet dangling off the terrace, which means her back is not facing the building. What am I missing ? Thanks
@@FOXAMG63 they said eyewitnesses were saying that, that was not correct. The ones who witnessed it said she actually had her back towards the building.
@@FOXAMG63 this video explains that the photo with legs dangling facing the building was from a recreation, and was incorrectly circulated by media. From eye witness accounts, her back was to the building.
For some reason I was always on the understanding that he was innocent..... But after listening to this (obviously the same audio) I’ve changed my mind. He obviously was doing something to her whilst he was talking so calmly. And this is not his first ‘altercation’. He’s a deeply deranged person.
@Thou Swell Yeah. And his story that he told his dad absolutely reeks of lies and bullshit. Terrifying that he's still out there and 100% going to harm women again after getting away with murder.
@@SarahLBanks lol there's a reason he decided to narrate the most important parts of the audio through his suggestive perception instead of letting it play for itself, he only plays the parts that would seem the most incriminating if they were cut from the rest of the audio This is why "you were always understanding he was innocent FOR SOME REASON" , that reason being, YOU ACTUALLY LISTENED TO THE FULL RECORDING prior to her fall, that's what made it clear he was innocent , fear files made sure to cut it out and narrate it instead. From the start he wasn't being objective at all, at every step he put made "innocent" but very suggestive questions or comments taking you by the hand it order to lead you to the conclusion he wants you to reach So yes, most ppl who watched this that hadn't known this case very well would end up being led astray like you were . You should make your own decision, not just let some skewed representation of things decide things for u Toastee had several hobbies caring for animals he had rescued, I don't remember the name but you can find it, however he was presented as a pure predatory criminal "TOWERING X height Y pound" compared to the "timid,small frame, x pound and y height" Anyway if you want another channel that stays neutral and doesn't manipulate the evidence, there's betters that stay objective on this case All this to say if things had happened as the fear files is trying to portray, there would have been an unanimous decision to find him guilty of murder
The fact he recorded everything shows how a psycho he is. He is the type that enjoys being feared and being the master. From her voice, you can say she was choked or she had something on her mouth/face. He is so evil he said the perfect things for the police to hear later😢 He was enjoying every bit that happened in that room
Why would anyone lock another person who is inebriated out on a balcony 14 stories up?! When she begged to go home, why didn’t he bring her home or call her a cab? He’s guilty of murder, in my opinion.
How this creep wasn’t held responsible for her death is unbelievable and beyond comprehension. The prosecutor must be feeble minded if he doesn’t understand that he placed her on the outside of the balcony railing. There’s even a god damn audio recording!
@@crispyandclean1446 so she deserved to be murdered? Talk about blaming the victim...this guy is sll sorts of sick that you would never imagine....now I am thinking what's up with you?
He clearly wasn’t in fear for his live he could have called the cops at anytime! The recording is chilling. When he wouldn’t let her leave because she was a “bad girl” made me feel physically ill. He definitely gave her too much alcohol on purpose to take advantage of her and then kicked her in the balcony while highly highly intoxicated and terrified clearly so terrified she felt she needed to climb off the balcony.
It probably didn't help her fear level that she'd only just met him off Tinder. I wouldn't have to be drunk to be terrified that someone didn't shove me out the front door and instead locked me on a balcony, after not letting me leave. I probably would have tried climbing down the balcony as well in that situation. He obviously wasn't terrified of her or he would have let her leave or tossed her out of the door.
Right how is that one statement or the you’re lucky I haven’t thrown you off the balcony yet how were those not enough to at least give him manslaughter or something. He definitely needs to be in jail. This was gonna happen sooner or later by the way he talks about women
So it would have been fine if he tossed her half undressed out into the hall of the apartment building at that hour? She was throwing rocks! And other stuff. I’m not defending his choice, but given the circumstances he wasn’t way out of line. Had she been out there for more than six whole seconds before deciding to climb over the rail…! And you would do the same? God help us all. Tragic? Yes. Best choice on his part? No. His fault? Not at all.
@@tylerskiss Yes. It would have been a lot smarter to toss her out the front door, along with her clothes and things.. versus putting a highly intoxicated person on a balcony of a high rise.
Thus one has always bothered me _"She was drunk and beating me up so I put her on the varanda"_ ? What? Not in a bathroom, a bedroom, A closet, or just quite simply kicking her out of the apartment and calling her a taxi? It's just an unbelievable concept.
Just because she appeared to be a mean drunk doesn’t mean you have to kill her You would think that the thought of calling a cab or security to remove her from your apartment would have crossed his mind at some point in those 3 hours says a lot to me about his intentions He did not sound drunk to me at all and had full control of the situation he seemed rehearsed like he was acting, no mumbling or stumbling over words but clear and precise I don’t know what happened in the first of the recording but the last says it all, he killed her
She was a complete psycho couldn't hold her drink started abusing him both physically n verbally he didn't know what to do n she jumped off the balcony herself...
That'll happen when you kick,punch, and throw things at someone for hours for no reason. Just because someone is bigger and stronger than you doesn't obligate them to put up with your abuse. Being restrained is a very lenient response to a violent psycho.
@@ilovehotmoms5804abuse IS, however, choking and retaining someone and making them fear for their life, and then throwing them off the balcony which I believe is what happened and she managed to grab on for a moment. Actually no wait-that’s murder. Straight up murder. So what if she was annoying? He could’ve and should’ve just let her go home-but that’s not what he wanted to do, he wanted to kill her. Being annoying isn’t an f’ing death sentence. It’s not even a crime. But it looks like the tiny 🍆 misogynist trolls are showing up in here 🙄 btw this isn’t aimed at you I’m agreeing with you
The only thing I needed to hear in this case was the recording. If he was actually worried about himself he’d leave his apartment and call the cops. This guy was a freak from the beginning and the recording is so hard to listen to. 😓
Why didn't he just call the police, and keep his balcony door locked? Even if he didn't murder her, he facilitated her death when she was incredibly vulnerable. Dangerous man!
The simple fact that this creep feels the need to record his encounters with women in the first place speaks volumes to me. And when he asked his dad, “Why does this keep happening to me?” I’d like to know what he meant by that 🤔 seems to me he’s been a monster before this girl met his wrath. Poor girl.. she just wanted to go home. Why he couldn’t have thrown her out into the hall and locked the door is beyond me. Even if he didn’t physically throw her over, he did absolutely nothing to stop her or help her once she was dangling. That right there should be a charge of some sort.
he hid her phone and purse so she couldn’t leave and when she got irritated and started throwing the pebble ornaments he got mad, what a psycho he knew exactly what he was going to do to her that’s why he recorded it trying to make it sound like it was all on her i’m also disgusted with the neighbours how can you hear a woman screaming no no no i want to go home and not call the police 😪 shame on them
What??? I thought she had just lost her phone.... I didn't know he had hidden it .. idk if you know Anna Oop but she made a video sticking up for the girl and everyone is DRAGGGING HER. But then I see this video and everyone is sticking up for Warriena and not Gable? I guess it depends which details you hear. I think he'd guilty. Aside from causing her death he should've at LEAST been charged with negligence or manslaughter.
I feel she was saying no, no, no for 47 seconds because he was carrying her towards the balcony. And he had mentioned chucking her off, so of course she was terrified. Him saying he would let her go home except she's been a bad girl, tells me everything. He could have opened the hallway door and put her out there, but he chose the balcony for a reason.
In America that's called kidnapping. And also in America, if the kidnapping results in death it is murder regardless of intentions.
Exactlyyyyy Emil Ur spot on
@@IwasBlueb4
he is a monster for what he did. If this was anyone I knew, I would personally seek re venge and get it.
@@samsngdevice5103 No you wouldn't, because that would make you a murderer unlike him. He was found NOT guilty by a jury of his peers in a court of law. If the court got this decision wrong, then everyone who has ever been found guilty should be innocent then. Also it wasn't kidnap, she went to his house voluntarily as shown on the cctv..
Yes exactly!!!! That's exactly what I pictured as I heard it. He was carrying her to over the balcony. He dropped her off it!!! 😢
i'll never understand how people can meet up with someone on a social media site and just go to their house without knowing the person.
People have been hooking up at bars forever. It's not crazy. Lol
@Ellen dingler. Exactly!! That was what I was thinking also, it's crazy how people do that
Yeah this woman is not exactly sympathy-inspiring. This falls under the banner "play stupid games, win stupid prizes".
@@scottandrews947 I agree
@@iamimi92 so dangerous for men or women
She says "Just let me go home" he says "I would but you've been a bad girl" and STILL gets away with it. Mind Blowing.
Cause he was innocent
The evidence proves:
1. he is absolutely not the best guy
2. she is a super entitled, annoying b*tch
3. he didnt push her off the balcony
Justice is not a popularity contest. Being a terrible, narcisistic womanizer doesnt make you a murderer automatically. The facts are the facts.
@@smartyjonez5470 na, you’re just an incel who hates women so you never hold other males accountable for their violence
@@smartyjonez5470 when you force someone drunk onto a balcony you're anything but innocent.
Dude that part chilled my bones
She was screaming bc he was dragging her to the balcony…he told her to “let go” bc she was hanging on to something inside, she BEGGED for him to let her leave…he is a psychopath and WILL kill again! Please please do an update! This poor girl
This story does need a bigger audience and to be reopened
Ooouuu I bet you’re right! She was holding onto something! I didn’t even think of that. I figured she was holding something to throw at him
@@stevekoolie1977 he was found not guilty he could literally walk into the police station and say he murdered her and there is nothing they can do about it, you cant retry someone again after that.
@@JB-kg1zvIf there's New evidence 🧾 they can reopen the case and set a new trial date.
Um, she tried to clobber him with a metal pole. Didn't you hear that? He was telling her to let go of the weapon she was using to hurt him. I guess you missed the part where he said, did you think it was like the movies, where you hit someone and they drop?
When that girl stated, "I just want to go home" and he replied "No, you have been a bad girl". At that very moment he was holding her against her will.
Where did he say that?
@@rebukesatan8166 in the recording
@@rebukesatan8166 25:49 on the video
@@Butterfly_47 you are all imagining things.
@@rebukesatan8166 you okay mate??? it's literally part of the recording, right before she starts screaming "no" several times.
After knowing she fell or pushing her, he showed no remorse or empathy, he went downstairs, saw the cops, took off, got a pizza and went to sleep. Regardless if he was guilty or not the guy is an absolute psychopath.
he did have a personality disorder which could definitely make his reactions abnormal
@@zionix15432 yeah anti social personality disorder lol 😂 aka psychopath
@@littleangel18 Yeah and that would actually make him less guilty EINSTEIN... Even as a normal person it would be pretty hard to feel for somebody behaving THAT moronical, like she did....
What should he have empathy for?
A girl that punched and kicked him repeatedly even after asking her to stop?
Of course he had no empathy for her, a person without personality disorder woudlnt either after this experience....
I have ZERO empathy for her, after the recordings she seemed to be a disgusting human being..
When you want to argue that, you are lying to yourself sry...you also wouldnt have wanted to be around her for sure!
@@peterschroeder3087 SIMP
@@toidIllorTAmI doesnt make any sense whatsoever...
Lifetime ban from 3 huge clubs bc he was "creeping them out" says EVERYTHING
Ikr. And new clubs banned him before he even had a drink 🤣
I mean she had enough warning signs. Women need to be smarter. Stop being dumb for sex
@@kelseywelsey2924 He's tall and good-looking. This is all women care about these days. Red flags be damned.
@@kelseywelsey2924 I know the way he was talking with her on the phone should have told her that's not the guy for her to be messing around with.
Those places don't ban just cuz a woman complains. Any exGF could do that. They had to know the guy was no good!
This poor girl. This was beyond disturbing to listen to. My deepest condolences to her family and friends. Rest in peace😔
I can’t imagine being her family and listening to this 😭 it disturbed me deeply and I’m just a stranger and not only that but a desensitized true crime fan to boot.
Her poor family hearing that recording. My heart breaks
The fact that he was found not guilty after the recording explicitly reveals that Warriena begged to just "let [her] go home" and Gable straight up replies with, "I *would*, but you've been a bad girl." How on Earth could they think he was innocent!? He chose to trap and lock her out on a 14 story balcony instead of letting her go home like she begged multiple times! Unbelievable! Not to even mention that he audibly physically assaulted her while she apologized and asked to go home. I'm glad his full name and psycho face were broadcasted so that women can avoid this psychopath. The dude even had the audacity and presence of mind to stomach eating some freaking pizza after everything that happened. Pure insanity on so many levels.
Even the other members of his beloved body building forum called him on his shit. He's the very definition of a toxic male that believes women are just tools that are responsible for building his ego. This is t0he kind of man that makes it dangerous for women to casually date, makes it easier for like-minded men to justify using/hating women, and makes it monumentally harder for decent men to earn any kind of trust from women. Ugh this entire story grinds the F out of my gears.
@@oliviabenson9425 gogo feminism, smh
No way shocked the law is an ass
Someone was paid off pretty well.
I'm so glad the law isn't decided by emotions. Even if one agrees with every point- she apologized and then begged to go home and he wouldn't let her. Up until he puts her outside and closes the door you think everything he did was wrong and everything she did was pure altruism- what then? Once she is alone outside on the balcony she has choices; wait even more than 27 seconds and maybe he will let her back in. Call out to other tenants or to people on the street- 17 floors is not impossible to hear. Grab a table or chair and threaten to smash the door.
No. Instead she chooses to climb up and over a SAFETY RAIL 17 floors in the air and attempt to Nathan Drake her way to another balcony!? Gabe didn't force her to be drunk and he didn't force her very rash decision on that balcony. You want him to go to jail because he was "mean", that's one thing, you might also get a kidnapping charge to stick, though she was not out there long at all and she was throwing rocks and swinging a telescope piece- if she's not fully dressed and if she still has stuff to find but she's behaving like a lunatic, perhaps the idea was to let her cool off for a moment. It's not the worst idea.
People keep citing the begging and "no!" repetition, but you never take into account that she switched over from aggressive, rude and threatening while actively assaulting to playing the complete victim. How does he know she won't just continue on the same if he puts her down? He chose to put a barrier between them- not a bad idea. It's his choice of barrier that is questionable, but any room in the apartment would Almost certainly qualify as kidnapping and throwing her into the hall would have interrupted neighbors and made a scene, so he thought "outside in fresh air"
The fact that his downstairs neighbor heard similar sounds coming from his place before tells you everything you need to know. This stuff always happens to you because you're the problem, mate.
And none of them called the police
if he slept with 270 women in there surely there was plenty of screaming. its not great evidence of anything if noone called the police and/or no girls ever reported it.
He recently did the same thing with another woman. She got saved from jumping
Exactly, people trying to claim this thug is innocent and not the problem.
Nasty dirty dude
I think she screamed so long because he was putting her over the balcony, that’s why she kept saying “no” left her hanging there and waited for her to inevitably fall.
As soon as he told his father “I didn’t push her or anything” I knew he pushed her. After a divorce from a lying ex who would give away her guilt by telling me exactly what I didn’t ask is how I know she did. Don’t volunteer information without being asked. You’ve just told on yourself.
I’m not defending him or anything but the girl fell from the balcony, it was obvious for him to say that. Sometimes we panic and say things that are not needed not because we wanted to, and that’s what could have happened there if he’s innocent.
@@sohamchakraborty900 Just because he didn't toss her, doesn't mean he's "innocent" of causing her death.
yep, we would call that manslaughter in these parts. @@joez.2794
@@sohamchakraborty900I agree in general terms because I have anxiety and always over explain but I think in THIS particular case it is him telling on himself because I absolutely believe he did
Yep.
He was just itching to throw someone off his balcony. His log about trying to pick up one of his tinder dates and carry them back into the apartment prior to her running home and blocking him gave an insanely weird impression. But his saying "you're lucky i haven't thrown you off my balcony" after having tried to get her out there every time she said anything disrespectful made his murderous intentions blindingly obvious. Definitely premeditated
Omfg, terrifying thought isn't it, to think people are actually plotting or fantasising about this crap. Scary stuff. 😔
This world is full of the depraved & thankfully, also the good.
@@janelizabeth8680
Im just amazed at the people on here defending him, or justifying what he did, or victim blaming her for going home with a stranger. Bad choices don't ",justify" murder in any, single, solitary way!
I can not believe he was found not guilty
What about when she was looking for her cell phone and he mentioned multiple times that it might be on the balcony 🤔
Premeditated but he's free.
That was the most terrifyingly, spine chilling thing I have ever heard. She was murdered. I think that all the time she was screaming no, was because he was forcing her out the door onto the balcony and over the railing. How after hearing that recording, could he be found not guilty?
Absolutely he murdered her but im not surprised that our judicial system let him go 🤬
@@AFDM007 what about Singapore
@@AFDM007 you can't even chew gum in Singapore lol
@@ItsMeSienna this is here in Australia yeah? Cause yes the courts her suck ass.
this recording is cut down. in the full recording you hear her screaming, him closing the door seemingly panting from the physical exhaustion AND THEN her distant, muffled screams. He wasn't near her when she fell so it isnt technically murder. Though i do wonder how he wasnt charged for involuntary manslaughter at the very minimum
"Just let me go home"
"I would, but you've been a bad girl."
Guilty. Guilty as fuck.
And that’s when he decided where “home” would be for her.
Omg yes! I can’t believe it.
Nah he didn't throw her over. When u listen to it all & in order u can hear he didn't. He's disgusting, sexually aggressive & an asshole, he should've carried her out of the apartment & not out to the balcony. She was so scared on the balcony & I believe tried to climb to another balcony to escape him.
He is responsible for her death by his actions, even with her violent episodes.
Amen.
The abusers always seem to play the 'victim' card. I see it every day.
He was twice her size, a bodybuilder, possibly on steroids. She was not beating him up and he didn't let her leave when she wanted to. He also plied her with strong alcohol when she was already drunk. He orchestrated her death and the fact that he walked away Scott free is quite frankly astonishing
Keep kissing until happens to you, oh sorry
Looks like you like guys
Mate I’m fairly large and I still have issues with trauma from my ma beating me as a little kid. I don’t particularly enjoy being hit by women
Well, criminals, get away with crime all The Time look at Tyson fury😂😂😂😂
Yes his home made cider.
apparently he dated 270 women, think he's at least severly autistic, why do you think nothing happened all these times before?
Hes 100% going to kill again. When she stated I wanna go home and he said “No You’ve been a very bad girl” made my stomach flip. That alone states he’s holding her against her will. Must be nice to have mommy and daddy’s money and a good lawyer.
A jury saw all the evidence, not you or I.
They found him not guilty.
Clearly the jury felt the girl was more to blame than he was.
Yes, I know this case. He is very much guilty and has been enabled his whole life. Terrible parents. And now his belief that he's untouchable has been validated. Tha makes him dangerous. Stay FAR away from this creep folks!
It must of been a jury l of his peers then!!!
She was being crazy to begin with....i bet he locked her on the balcony. She being drunk tried climbing down
@@jacobsaks5891 Yeah, buddy... You don't victim blame without coming off as a creep yourself.
There was 100% malice in his voice when he replied to her asking to go home. " I would have but you've been a bad girl". Like many other have said he could have just tossed her out the front door and shut it. How did a jury find him not guilty?
Because people are pathetic sheep and think every trial needs to be like on Law & Order no one uses their brains
No
This man repulsive 🤢
He illegally imprisoned her. Had he let her leave sh would be alive today. How he didn't get charged with other crimes he committed if not murder s beyond me.
@@RaphaelDawkinsCombatRadio It's a relief to read a man understand the situation instead of pulling the mysogynistic card to humiliate the woman. You're a rarity right now.
That message he sent her after that swipe right was the BIGGEST RED FLAG EVER.
apparently not to her
@DvidTheGnome was that response even necessary, considering what we just watched? 😳🤦♀️ lol
It's the brightest red flag of red flags. For her to swipe right on AND go out with that nutcase she must've really been down bad. When a dude's first message is sexual you know to that guy you're literally a human sex toy.
@@doucheberry I mean they both seem like awful people.
@@DvidTheGnome Well, only one is dead. What a peach of an outlook. God...
The jury in this case should be ashamed of themselves
I was thinking thr same thing! I don't know how they possibly could have found him not guilty after listening to his own recording!
The other person who should be ashamed of themselves is Gable's father! The fact that he never sounded shocked, surprised or even alarmed during their call speaks volumes about what Gable has done in the past. Also, his father picking him up and bringing him home, knowing everything that just happened is astounding! There's absolutely no way that my mom would have taken me anywhere but back to the scene to talk to the officers! With this kind of enabling, it's no wonder that Gable is the entitled little bully he is!!
for what?? They had no evidence to prove him guilty of murder, sure he was guilty of other things like negligence and harassment but not murder, there just isn't evidence to prove he killed her
@@jakesherman8080 You don’t HAVE to have definitive evidence to convict as a jury. Yes that is the law and they can tell you that you need to convict based on the law and that the burden of proof is on the prosecutor but you don’t actually have to do that. If the jury decides to convict without “definitive” evidence that is legal. That may not have been enough evidence for the law but it’s enough for me if I was on the jury. The same goes the other way if there is video of a guy shooting someone and the evidence is clear, but I personally feel it was justified because the guy he shot hurt his child in the past, then I would not agree to a guilty verdict if I was on the jury
@@sillyravis1340 the jury can rule whatever they want to rule, again I am saying there is no evidence to support the theory that he killed her, all there is suggests he threw her outside onto his balcony, that is all that we know and can infer
@@jakesherman8080homeboy killed her. He had a chance to kick her out but instead she’s taken outside into the porch- the only place where she could die. At the very least it’s manslaughter.
She screams and pleads with him to let her go home.
He replies with harsh coldness “I would but you’ve been a bad girl.”
Jeezus
It's very clear by the audio that he killed her. He was saying things like let go and yet you can hear him strangling her. He was saying things to make it SEEM like he was defending himself. Really putting on a show. It was SO obvious. He knew he was recording things.
Exactly, anyone with more than two brain cells to rub together should be able to figure that out. Absolutely appalling that he got away with it. Where was this-Australia? Idk how their legal system works, but the jury (if they do that) must’ve been made up of cretins, or the judge.
And I think that this was the ONLY one of his recordings that was ONLY audio instead of video, how convenient.
Yes. He beat her up and thought he might get in trouble for her injuries, so he threw her over! That way her injuries would be thought to have come from her fall.
Sadly he has lots of admirers. In the jury and in public. I even bet a young female jury member contacted him later to hook up! This is just the way the world is!! We are what we area!!
The neighbors didn't want to call the police with all the noise, as they didn't want to get a pretty boy in trouble! Good looking people are the 💣
They get away with murder.....they really do!
autopsy per the examiner that there was no strangulation
The sense of calming in his voice tells me this dude is a crazy bastard.
If he wanted her out of his apartment so badly, why not throw her out the front door rather than the balcony? I can not fathom how the investigation lead to a not guilty verdict; an absolute injustice was done. How horrifying for Warriena and her loved ones.
Same reason she tried to climb down a building. Both drunk, both acting like complete morons and neither able to think straight.
@@freebirddee2620 absolutely that, and i think most people are too dumb to really understand what a murder is....lmao
Exactly. You've got to consider if someone's in his pocket. This isn't how tbe justice system works with so much incriminating evidence. This corruption has been enabled by those in that court and NZ has blood on its hands.
@@peterschroeder3087 Spot on. People see an unfortunate circumstance and instantly conclude murder, not even understanding its actual definition.
Idk how the jury and judge heard her suffering, her gasps her plea for help. And decided he was innocent...
Two things chill me to the bone: a) his tone when he insults her b) she would have been completely aware of the danger but unable to react, because of the shit he brewed up for her. What a monster. He should NEVER be allowed back into society again
The home made cider he plied her with.
This man is a monster. The audio is absolutely horrifying. That poor girl. He recorded the entire thing. The absolute arrogance and lack of empathy is astounding. An absolute monster.
How could he possibly be exonerated?
No she was a crazy bitch
Money. That’s how
The girl climbed off the railing after he left her in the balcony for throwing rock at him and being violent.
@@stacyjjk-hv8ty He created the monster by plying her with incredibly strong home brewed liquor when she was already drunk. He also refused to let her leave. Which is a criminal offence, that's unlawful imprisonment.
So had he let her go, she would have still been alive today.
But he plied her with alcohol and illegally imprisoned her.
He should be charged for that. And if he's found guilty of illegal imprisonment then he must be found culpable in her death.
Well maybe because she was so drunk she tried to cimb over the balcony. If he was inside and locked the door because she was acting crazy maybe on drugs she lost her footing drunk abusive women are. highly dangerous.
With all this amount of evidence of rage and abuse, how is he not guilty? This is so sad!
Pathetic to say the least!!!
It's absolutely chilling to hear him say "that's enough" and "it's over" while shes clearly struggling to breathe. Poor girl.
Because he's subduing her so that she stops attacking him? Yes. poor girl.
@@MsDrunkendave maybe instead of choking or overpowering a girl twice your size, grab her and put her out. He didn’t have to hide her phone, keep her from leaving or lock her outside.
@@MsDrunkendave it's not okay for anyone to assault anyone, but it's also not your right to shame this victim because of your personal worldview or hangups.
@@MsDrunkendave No one deserves to be suffocated, just because they cannot handle their liquor, and conssequently becomes a stupid violent drunk. He was much bigger and could have just put out the front door and locked it.
@@mags2847 how do you know he hid her phone? She's drunk. She probably misplaced it.
This is the third case I heard where a woman falls to her death in Australia, and the man in the house says it was suicide.😒 And some of these men get away with it.
I'm from Australia and this case was ALL over the news when it happened, it was so blindingly obvious that he was guilty. The national outrage was palpable. There were also multiple women who had met him/gone on dates previously with him, who came forward, all of their stories were eerily similar. It should also be noted that he had Warriena's phone in his pocket the whole time - he *finds* it while on the phone to his father afterwards. Violence against women in this country is not treated seriously at all, offenders are given so many chances - even just this week a 21 year old woman was stabbed to death in front of her 3 year old son, by yet another deranged man who had already shown so many red flags. They just don't care about us here. RIP Warriena
I'm sorry to hear that 🥺 this world is so cruel against women and children
Sounds like women where you are need to learn to exercise a little street justice.
@@picklesmccoy7796 Sorry but it's the same in EVERY COUNTRY, including America. So many men like this are all over the world. Especially with these sites like Tinder that a lot of men use for casual sex. Violence against women is nothing new globally. Australia is no different to any other western country in that regard. The original commenter must not have traveled much to say something like that.
I agree. The laws there are sad. Murderers barely ever get life. If it was in the USA depending on the state he would've got the death penalty. Which he deserves
@@picklesmccoy7796 that would be ideal .... Except we'd be thrown in jail like cyntoia brown. Another idea - how about men just stop killing us?
The fact that he kept insisting to his dad that he didn’t push her off the balcony was proof enough for me. 🤷♀️
He obviously intended to kill her.
The only thing that I know leaded to this incident was her screaming..because if you scream ..that alarms every person's mind even if they are innocent ..because louder noises makes you innocent instantly and other one one guilty ..so don't scream ..because no one wants to go jail without actually doing anything
Also I'm not on that murderers side ...
Exactly , how tf did he get away with this murder smh
@@Uzi16_29 I have no idea
Edit;
“For the people who are saying she jumped by her own, go listen to the tape again ,she was begging him to let her go home and he replied I would BUT YOU WERE A BAD GIRL, if she jumped by her own as he claimed why he could not help her not to do so ???????”
*It’s heartbreaking to listen to the lady screaming No No No as she’s knowing it was her end, I can’t imagine how horrific was to fall from that balcony 😢
What a cruel cold blood murderer
He could simply let her go home
I wish karma will get him soon since justice was deaf and blind in this case.
May she R.I.P
It's Austaltia. The worst country in thw world. They are more corrupt then America. This guy's daddy paid for his freedom.
She jumped how is that his fault?
@@nervoussips2622 But she didnt, listen too the entire tape. HE tossed her out
@@Metadeth1997 he tossed her onto the balcony and closed the door, she then in a drunken state tried to clump to the lower level how is that his fault.
@@nervoussips2622 Well we werent there were we? Listening too the tapes is enough too understand what happened. Why would a woman climb down a building thats several stories tall, knowing its a death sentence?
You can literally hear the enjoyment in his voice as he's holding her down. He's almost moaning in pleasure. This is beyond sick.
He was definitely trying to throw her over when she was screaming “No no no no no!!” and he kept telling her to let go because she was gripping the railing. The terror in her screams is definitely that of somebody who thinks they’re about to die. That’s why she was facing outwards. Nobody trying to get down from a FOURTEENTH FLOOR balcony is going to do so facing outwards. Period! He got her over and she was gripping the railing and he just left her like that because he knew she’d fall. Not only did he actually mention throwing her off the balcony, but he tried several times to get her to look for her phone out there. He was TRYING to get her out on the balcony. Did police ever investigate the phone situation? Did they find her phone? He knew exactly what was going to happen and it’s exactly what he wanted. He didn’t even bother to look over. Anyone, I don’t care if they’re getting along or not, anyone would freak out at somebody falling 14 stories to their death right in front of them. He didn’t even do much as flinch, didn’t bother calling police or ambulance, and actually ate f*cking pizza. Again, nobody normal would have an appetite after that sh*t. He’s clearly sick! And the fact that the neighbor said they had heard screams just like hers weeks before….. he probably tried it then with another girl. He gets extremely aggressive sexually and it freaks girls out and they probably fear that they’re going to be r*ped so they try to leave and it pisses him off. He’s a straight up weirdo! It broke my heart to hear her screams. Those could only be described as the screams of somebody who KNEW they were going to die. And her saying “I just want to go home! I just want to go home!” is even more heart breaking.
He didn't do anything wrong, aside from inviting a girl with clear mental issues into his home. She tried to climb out of his building and fell. That's very obvious.
@@scottandrews947 Exactly. We can clearly hear in the recording that she was a drunk, violent mess. He was probably trying to drag her out to the balcony so she could cool down and she was holding onto something, like the leg of a table. He was probably gonna leave her out there while he found her phone and then send her on her way.
both you guys are sick if you think his not to blame and even if she was drunk would u lock a drunk person out on your balcony! no you wouldn’t because it’s dangerous at 14 floors high, instead you would call the police or kick her out the FRONT DOOR and make her go home like she kept on saying she wants to go home.
@@candycane7434 he was drunk too . doubt he was thinking logically . he sounded high as a kite like her
@@mauraodonoghue4115 He sounded completly normal while talking to bis dead
"why does this keep happening to me?" That phone call was so sketch. He just assumed she jumped cause cops are around his apartment?? Yeah right dude. He also says he thinks she must have thought it was a joke. It couldn't have been that bad if she could reasonably expect him to think she was joking
That dude is super weird
WRONG.
You have obviously never met a drunk Kiwi girl. And neither had he by the sounds of it.
They get drunk and proceed to bash and belittle their man and don't stop until physically stopped.
THEY ARE EXHAUSTING
Don't get me wrong this guy is an imbecile and only had to push her out his front door instead of his patio door 🙄. She was saying no, no as he was pushing her out the door and she had realised that she had gone to far. He could of stopped and told her to leave again and she may have actually left voluntarily at that point but the Moron probably wanted to punish her for all the crap she had done to him. And then she decided to climb around to the next unit but fell. And yes he needs to go to prison for it.
Just my two cents worth.
From the land down under 🇦🇺 🇦🇺🇦🇺
@@kumaralockwood3172 sexist
You hook up with almost 300 easy, low self-esteem people and you question "why does drama find me?"
@@kumaralockwood3172 lol right on, man. It's like Haka dancing. It's never ending.
I’m just gonna put this out there for the Aussie ladies in the comments - first of all, he was found not guilty but second he’s back on tinder under the name Eric Thomas. He’s also had other similar incidents with women and his balcony.
Unreal!!!! Unbelievable!!!!!!
Yeah right.
That is HORRIFYING. He's sadistic and well on his way to being a serial killer. What a psycho!
That man should not be free. He is a danger to women. Probably men too but he clearly has a target.
This needs to be pinned.
"Whys this always happen to me" famous words of a narcissis. Everything is some one else's fault. Privilege
Malignant narcissist, most likely (ASPD + NPD)
Wow this is crazy. Dudes narrated this situation in his head thousands of times with how calm and sick he sounds. Evil.
Well he was lying to his dad and it didn't seem scripted at all. And they edited out the parts where the father responded. Are you being intentionally dense?
RIGHT......
Does anyone know the best place to get a panzerotti in Kalamazoo?
No one forced her to jump off the balcony.
She murdered herself.
Get YOUR facts STRAIGHT..
@@troyounce3295 Didn't sound scripted? Are you joking?
I know one thing, I never want to hear that audio again, chilled me to my core. I feel like he dangled her over the balcony edge hence her screaming "NO" so many times and left her there to fall. Terrifying.
I feel the same . She knew. What a sick piece of crap
I thought the same thing! She was facing outwards,he was holding her by her arms dangling her over the edge. Then her screaming NO over an over.
I agree. You can hear they were outside and he was holding her over the edge. What an absolute psychopath.
I hope she rests in peace. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
thats EXACTLY what he did
That was horrifying to listen to. I'm legit shaking. What a horrible horrible man. He has no business being free. He could've put her out the door, but like he said when she begged him to let her go home, " I would but you've been a bad girl". He knew she was never going home. How is he free?
To me when he locked her out he knew her being so drunk and in terror that only bad things could happen. He should have been responsible for at least a Man slaughter charge.
Let's conveniently forget all the times she verbally berated him; Let's face it, she HAD indeed been a bad girl. The bitch couldn't handle her liquor, becoming a bad drunk, like happens to a number of people when under the influence. She did in fact become a psycho bitch after one too many.
@@noelnewlon I hate what happened to her. She did flip out. I wonder if the toxicology report showed.
Now that he got away with it and felt his rush, he will probably become a serial killer and improve his methods.
Agree that he should have put her out in the hallway, locked his door, and called the police. She assaulted him. Problem solved.
He's free because convicting a person of murder required evidence in support of a conviction. There was no such evidence.
He was definitely a creep, but a murderer? We'll never know.
Imagine being her parents having to listen to this audio of their daughter's last moments. This is a nightmare
😢
Raise your daughters not to be easy. Very important conversation at a young age.
I'd be horribly embarrassed if my kids grew up to think fornication was acceptable. (And no, this is not virtue signaling, or whatever crap woke people think it is.)
The recording DOES NOT prove he wasn’t near her when she fell. It literally only proves his phone wasn’t near her when she fell.
That's what i heard, too!!!!
It's horrific, right?😔
Hi from Austria 🇦🇹
Exactly what I thought. I think he put her over the balcony and she eventually fell after he came back into the room.
@@mcshaunable yessss!
Her drunk ass fell on her own
@@dantauche7917 yo is this toasty’s sock account
This was one of the worst recordings I've ever heard, you can hear how scared and confused she is and the malice in his voice. The gaslighting is the worst part. I can't believe he got free, I have no doubt he's done this before
Exactly just never got caught.
You're just saying that because you know what the outcome is in this situation.
Unfortunately he will do it again…. And hopefully this time he will be found guilty
i totally agree...ND HES EVIL
Glad he got free that crazy b got what she deserves
This is incredible, unbelievable and the most cruel thing. How did he get away with murdering this young woman?!?
Shit
Of course he killed her. If he had wanted her out of his apartment why didnt he push her out of the door into the hallway. Then shut the door behind her. Im sure the front door is a more secure door than the balcony door. He got away with murder. If she were my daughter i would swing for him.
That doesn’t fit the definition of murder in the least!
I love these arguments people have- so she’s drunk and not to blame for throwing rocks, he is drunk, getting hit by rocks and is supposed to assume if he puts her outside, she will jump! Was she even dressed? So he should throw an half dressed, wildly unreasonable woman into the hallway of his apartment building at that hour?
I’m not saying he’s a good guy- he seems to be slime, but what he did was not beyond reason. She was behaving poorly and doing damage to the apartment - and I don’t care what size you are, rocks hurt. She also grab a piece of a telescope to hit him. So he put her outside to cool down. She wasn’t out there for even a minute and it wasn’t freezing, so why she chose to go directly over the rail is insane.
It’s tragic. He didn’t make the best choices, but in no way did he cause her to climb over that rail and try some Uncharted move.
In the end, he is SO LUCKY he had that recording because even with the evidence, people want to assume the worst of him and the best of her.
@@tylerskiss I'm not saying he did or didn't murder her but I also don't think u can definitively state he didn't. She's screaming NO so many times n for so long how do you know that when he was forcing her onto the balcony he didn't pick her up and act/physically insinuate or actually begin to physically force her over that railing? That's why with just the audio, I won't make a judgement on murder. If she climbed over to try n climb down, I don't believe her feet would've been facing out but rather toward the building.
@@tylerskiss I'm curious why he only chose to record audio. Seems like your average person who wanted to document the wild things happening around them would opt for recording video more than those who would opt for only audio. Definitely wouldn't be my first instinct. I guess he was trying to conceal it, maybe? But at that point it seemed like she was drunk enough to probably not even notice the phone as much as if she was sober. His past also leaves me with some bias as well. They were both insanely drunk as well so nothing good could have really come out of it aside from her just leaving.
@@tylerskiss How many times did he say about throwing her off the balcony. So as you say she was beating him up. This guy outweighed her & towered over her. Had already dominated her in his flat. Why did he push her onto the balcony & not into the hallway outside of his flat? If he wanted to be rid of her or for her to calm down he should have put her into the hallway. He wanted her to go off the balcony.
@cyril lmfao yo people really think like you? She asked to go home and he taunted her. Her body was facing away from the balcony as she fell. Rocks ? Lol little baby rocks ? I have had a woman throw literally fist at me and hot coffee in my own home and I never laird my hands on her or any other woman for that matter. He murdered her lol 😂 you’re absolutely deranged like the judge who let this man go free.
Chilling when she said "I just want to go home" and he replied "No, you have been a bad girl".
🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼
Right!?! Says so much about his mind frame
Yes! That part gave me the chills!
Oh, i felt that. It's chilling.
Hi from Austria 🇦🇹
He was clearly getting off when he was overpowering her and taking pleasure in tormenting her. Disgusting.
She said she wanted to go home and he refused saying, "I would but you've been a bad girl." Her death is a direct result of his actions. He should have at least been convicted on manslaughter.
Murder as he thought about it first as his statements about him saying "she was lucky he didn't chuck her off the balcony" NO one puts a drunk person on a balcony to cool off. A bunch of bull crap. He tried to drop her while she was facing forward so she couldn't grab anything when he let go, but she still managed to grab on, if even for a bit. Thepeople who let him go free are idiots, and I hope their reading this too. She probably wasn't even used to that hard liquor and it makes some people mean, but even if she was mean, he should have just waited for her to sober up, and if she got to be too much put her out the front door and lock it. He will kill again someday, and next time he will be even more sneaky about it. All thanks to the losers in the courtroom.
@@murdermysterymissing8044 He was inside, you can tell by the recording. You hear her on the other side of the balcony door. He never hung her off the balcony. She thought she could climb down below. She's obviously the abusive, defiant type. I've been there. Numerous times. I know her type all too well.
My question is, why didn't that guy grab her when she was hanging on? He said he could touch her.
You hear her on the outside in the recording. So he didn't throw her off. But you don't put an abusive, defiant drunk girl on a balcony and lick the door. Im pretty sure she thought she could climb down below. She slipped.
@@jeffcampbell2710 Just because he was inside when she ultimately fell doesn’t mean he didn’t throw her off. Watch the end of the video. It’s very plausible that he could have tried pushing her over facing out, which would have occurred during her screaming No over and over, she grabs onto the railing to stop the fall. He walks inside leaving her there, slams the door and locks it. You would still hear him inside and her muffled yells for help outside, then her ultimate fall. It’s the prevailing theory for those that believe he’s guilty. Also, there’s no way the dude could have reacted quickly enough to grab her unless he was a superhero. He wasn’t on the floor beneath her, he was two floors down. She had already passed the balcony directly below, and was picking up momentum as she rocketed passed the next balcony, even if reacted in that split second and reached out in an attempt to grab onto her, there’s no way he could have gained enough grip to hault the pull of gravity, and move her onto his balcony to safety. Even if he did grab on or get an arm stuck onto her in that split second, the force of her body falling would have probably pulled him off the balcony to his death as well. Dudes an extreme weirdo loser. I bet every single woman left him completely unsatisfied and creeped out beyond belief, which is why he could never have a girlfriend.
@@GenerationDown you can hear her up against the glass. If she was over the railing, you wouldn't have heard her. She was talking loud, she wasn't screaming bloody murder. Big difference.
"Why does this shit KEEP happening to me?" told me all I need to know.
This dude recorded himself choking and muffling her face while saying the PERFECT things to paint the story he wanted… and you can tell when he’s cursing at her, he’s totally getting off to degrading and threatening her. The fact that he’s out there now is terrifying.
But the question is, did he kill her?
Absolutely terrifying my God we know what he’s capable right? Sick Twists like this Narcissist NEVER change Period!!!!!
@@anthonycampos8057 He may not have pushed her, but he told his Dad, “I saw her climbing over his rail” Um he could have done so much different like kick her out into the hallway but that’s not what he wanted he “had” to punish her for being “a bad girl” seriously he’s the reason she fell, so damn right he killed her. At the very least murder 2nd degree, this guy walked out not guilty” but that doesn’t make him innocent
@@michellefucile7426 well I'm talking by the letter of the law. And i gotta be honest, I think a not guilty verdict would've occurred in the US as well.
@@anthonycampos8057 Do you seriously believe that?
How could her saying "JUST LET ME GO HOME” and him saying “I CANT YOUVE BEEN A BAD GIRL” not be enough to prove he’s guilty?!?! That recording was chilling. He was getting off on abusing her like that.
It’s unbelievable how such a monster like him got off with this,his parents were as much to blame for letting him off with what he did and paying for his freedom they’re all sick,sad,mentally I’ll individuals
Well no that's not enough
I was about to ask the exact same question.
Well because someone can't pick and choose which part of it to believe or not depending on their agenda. Using your own logic and Placing so much importance on Words. On the recording he had also told her to get her stuff and get out and to leave, On the recording It was very clear she Had admitted to Assaulting him more than once. Once being with Something used as a weapon. I've listened to it 3 times At this point, There is something definitely off about him.
But without a doubt The same goes for her.
@@teelitek9275 She was drunk and he muffled her. He was Smothering her, You could hear the snorting hardcore. You can totally tell he killed her on that tape.
I believe he carried her to the balcony and put her over it, she grabbed onto the railing and he left her dangling. This explains the 47 seconds of her screaming no repeatedly. She was terrified.
Yeah if her feet were away from the building that means she was facing away, holding onto the railing from behind her. She was probably stuck and too drunk to work out how to get back over, and too scared to go back over the railing because he was probably still there basically refusing to let her get back. So she keeps saying no like no leave me alone just let me go home. It also explains why the neighbors couldn't figure out what they were seeing. Because if her feet were facing the building it's be obvious she was falling off and needed help. But facing the other way would mean she's stupidly trying to get down the wrong way
Yes!!!!!!
Yep, that would explain it......
Yes he placed her there thinking he could scare her, torture her more, then let her go! A very sick evil psycho!
Yup, any idiot could figure this out in 2 seconds, exept cops. Either his father owns them, or they are really dumb.
That recording. Chills. How chilling is it to hear someone screaming for their life right before they die.
He, knowing how drunk she was, probably picked her up and placed her on the other side of the balcony knowing she wouldn’t have the strength to climb back up. He already choked her out and her screams at the end shows she was terrified. So sad.
That was one of the most gut wrenching stories I've ever heard, heartbreaking. I couldn't sleep last night. What a disgusting human being!
If I were her parents - this guy would also “accidentally” fall from that balcony!
100% he'd have 6 hitmen
I wouldn’t fuck with a kiwi those guys are huge this guy is lucky she died and the police took him or her cousins would of came and f$&@ed him up. As a kiwi myself if anyone spoke to my family the way he is speaking to her I’d break his f$&@ing legs and arms
He mentioned several times that he stated this type of thing always happens to him I wonder how many other women he's murdered and gotten away with
The several times he said, in a menacing tone 'You don't understand do you....' He knew he was recording himself so he was careful with his words. But the meaning behind it was 'you don't understand how dangerous I am. What I'm capable of' ... A normal man does not threaten to throw someone of the balcony (twice). Her cries of No were haunting. I grew up going to Surfers on holidays etc., and have family that live nearby so was interested in this case. I also know that tradie / aussie tone and the meaning behind it, so I stand by my interpretation. I fully believe he should still be in jail for murder. It is incomprehensible he is free.
Yes, let that be a lesson to us all. You never truly know how dangerous anyone is or what triggers rage, aggression etc. What past trauma or pain someone has lived with may come boiling to the surface in an unstoppable explosion. And what is a normal man/woman? Everyone is capable of anything if you push “their” right button. “You’ll never know the psychopath sitting next to you” -twenty one pilots
@@la2alaska336 Another lesson can go for the Aussie court system. Dont reward these little cowards proclaimed to be sociopaths, throw them in prison where they can attempt that intimidation shit on real men.
I agree with you that when he was repeating to her, "You don't understand do you", he was degrading her as a stupid idiot and garbage in his own mind, because in his mind, she was an idiot because she did not understand or even suspect what was going to happen to her. to justify killing her in his own mind, he had to reduce her as an idiot who did not even deserve to live. Is other statement, "This is bull shit" and"this is more than enough" were all means of justifying himself killing her. What I am sure is the reason he killed her was for the thrill, and his reason for recording this is because he wanted the thrill of reliving murdering her by listening to the recording. It is very rare to encounter a man that make people experience such degree of disgust and repulsion, like this fucking piece of shit. Every thing possible must be done to deny this coward, any opportunity to hide himself. Anyone and everyone that come any where near to him, must be made aware that he is in fact, a disgusting monster. Absolutely every woman that might happen to come anywhere near to him, must be informed of what he did and what he is. I did not believe in the death penalty, but I have now changed my mind. I now believe that monster like him should and must be put to death, and I can't help but feel that hanging or electric chair or lethal injection is not good enough, he should be put to death by being thrown off the roof of a high rise building.
or you don't understand that you're about to die, do you. I have an imeasurable amount of true crime stories, this one disturbed me the most. That recording is the worst thing I've ever heard and spews evil like I've never heard, even more than the guy who takes his girlfriend up the elevator then throws her over the balcony. I can't
Absolutely 100% guilty. How on earth did he get away with that. He was clearly strangling her, you could hear her struggling to breathe. It sounds to me like he forced her out onto the balcony, her feet were facing away from the balcony which indicated he hung her over the edge and then let her go. This is murder for sure. 😡
Amanda, I see it The same way. How do they know he wasn't close to her on the balcony? If she were that drunk how is she going to climb over away from the railing? With her arms behind her? No way! He was holding her over facing away from the building. It's the only thing that makes ANY sense. I don't know anyone(from experience- I used to climb balconies to get down), who would climb down that way! Impossible unless you're trying to off yourself.
You're exactly right! He must have dangled her over the railing, and she was screaming "no, no, no" at the top of her lungs!
She may have fakes it. To many half heart yells for help. Didn't add up.
How did OJ get away? The answer, good lawyers.
Let me elaborate it please,
You are with a girl in room having all that ..she is super drunk ..beating destroying your place ..and when it's more than enough for you and you forcefully stop her , then she realises her position that she is in strangers apartment with with a complete stranger person and minds starts showing all trapped girl movies ..(aka GOAT SENSES are activated) .. next thing you know she starts screaming with a complete strange behaviour ..so stop drinking if you can't handle ..and get married with a single person ..I mean you guys are also humans 'right!! ..stop behaving like animals like fu*king whenever you guys are horny no matter who.
Im 99% sure iv heard this story, but not from an angle this immersive
The 60 Miniutes Australia coverage was pretty good.
He actually said to his dad 'why does this shit keep happening to me?' Exactly how many women have 'accidentally' died around him?
At no point in his own recording does he even tell her to leave. He could have shoved her out into the hallway and locked the door
Exactly correct. He has a choice to put her out the apartment building but why outside the balcony. Obviously he is a psychopath and he enjoy punishing those poor girls that slept with him. Imagine in bed with 200 girls just almost in 2 years.
True. She could've called for help on his balcony instead of thinking climbing down was an option.
There are two idiots in this situation.
@@joycelow2667 Hey, that's 270 girls/daddy issue skanks, not 200. No roofies, just straight up game. Give him props for his game. Or for his lays' easiness.
@@oldmandoinghighkicksonlyin1368 Please share with me your story of having immense brain damage and being stuck inside the personality of a 14 year old boy
@@SugarGliderTribe witness testimony. Which I am sure was further scrutinised.
She was clearly very intoxicated and clearly terrified. Her screams of “no!” were utterly chilling. I reckon he was dangling her over by her arms. After all, she couldn’t go home because she was a “bad girl”. This man was a monster.
I also think he was dangling her by her arms that's why she kept yelling NO! NO! Since he's a bodybuilder then finally just dropped her. This was so sick and sad story 😞
So you were there and saw what happened?
Unless you were, you really shouldn’t jump to conclusions.
Making “jump” was a poor choice of words, but you know what I mean.
@@sylviamoreno687
So you were there and witnessed everything that happened personally?
Maybe you should have testified..
@@travelwithtony5767 why are you so triggered over an opinion bro? It's just what she thinks happened, the dude got off clean anyways.
@@lovinglife4327
He was ACQUITTED, after a long trial and all the evidence had been presented.
But she knows what happened because, well it’s HER opinion, and you know what they say about opinions don’t you?
Dude made mostly every woman he came across uncomfortable. He was not charming nor did he have a way with words.
I believe he felt emasculated from not being in control of the situation. To have a women fight him not only angered him but made him feel weak. Dude always made himself the victim in every situation ("why does stuff like this always happen to me"). He didn't throw her into the hall, call her a Uber, call the police, he kept her in the apartment and I believe he didn't attend to let her go until he felt he had gotten "even".
He could have just as easily as he pushed her onto the balcony left the apt himself and called the police to remove her.
He was clearly charming. He had sex with tons of girls. He had no substance under that charm though.
@@MrSloppySausage he actually doesn't seem charming at all, he seems like a little pig. I think most women just looked at them and thought he was hot and that's why he was with so many women
@@ThimbleFox350 Exactly
He couldn't have made that many women feel Uncomfortable, 200 plus of them slept with him. Why the narrator makes it sound like men, or at least just this guy is the only bad one BECAUSE he goes out trolling for sex. He wouldn't get any of there weren't women looking for no strings attached one nighters. Maybe ALL these women should stop going home with strangers. Is Tindr NOT known for specifically being an app for meeting up for......well, not long lasting relationships?
Granted this guy is a major douche, but don't forget, it's Tnder & as long as he's good looking, it's AMAZING what women will ignore. Stop teaching young women it's OK to go with any dude, bc after all "men do it". Men & women are not the same, it's biological. Maybe if men are taught to better respect women and women are taught to respect themselves, you wouldn't have an absolute loser like this guy getting over 200 broads to go home with him. 🤷♀️ As a female, it's embarrassing really. I'm just grateful my mom taught me to respect myself & to not go home W random men and that women are not as strong as men physically.
This is INSANE, he literally recorded himself murdering someone.
😢
WOW that was really hard to listen too. I've heard about this case over and over on different channels but I've never heard that's recording before and I never want to hear it again. It has me literally crying for her and my daughter, and granddaughters just thinking that could have been one of them. He's a literal piece of 💩!!!!! And we'll be hearing about him again I don't doubt that for a minute. He already had a big head about himself and now getting away with murder he thinks he's invincible...
Stay safe everyone
@@GiantsWS OK big tough guy. Like to see you try!
HE has constantly been in trouble with police ever since. Changed his name. Just days ago he was found naked and passed out in his car then evaded police
Whaaatttt???? Damnnnn
He needs to be locked up.
Even before
@@ADetailedHouse He changed his name even before he changed his name?
This guy will never get a date again. He will end up committing suicide
I think he placed her on the other side of the railing, knowing she would eventually lose grip and fall, and he could claim he was nowhere near her when it happened. Immediately before he slams the door, she lets out a louder, longer, more panicked and pleading scream. I think it was the moment she realized this wasn’t just some kind of sadistic joke, and that he was actually leaving her there and walking away.
I think that's a really sound hypothesis. That would fit in with her screaming for so long even though he only had to drag her a little ways.
The neighbors would've heard that sort of commotion and said they heard a male voice fighting with a woman. The struggle obviously happened inside the apartment. In her drunken state, she tried to climb over the railing and down to the floor below.
@@Bubba__Sawyer I see u on this thread defending the dude way too much, ur definitely a creep just like him
This is what I wondered too. He took her out, put her down on the wrong side of the railing and then left her knowing she wouldn’t be able to get back to the right side but that it would give him time to get inside and away from her before she fell so he could show he was nowhere near her and honestly be able to say he didn’t push her or throw her off but he’s still 100% responsible for her falling. There was no way she was getting back to the balcony without falling even if she was sober and facing the building instead of backwards!
@@pinkfluffydino8217 why wouldn't she be able to get to the other side? I've been plenty drunk before but I was still capable of climbing over the edge of a balcony...
Do they have no justice in Australia? If it weren't for the recording I'd say it was iffy but the recording clearly shows what happened. Can't believe he walked away
It's disgraceful isn't it 😡 When it comes to violence against your intimate partner Australia treats victims like shyt 😡😠 Something seriously needs to change 😡😠 RIP to all the victims, men and women, of domestic violence across Australia 🇦🇺 and world wide.
It took 46 seconds because she was resisting him in a fight for her life, as he dragged her to the balcony, held her over the side and eventually let her go! I don’t think she was out there by herself at all, and the audio does not prove that he wasn’t with her. He could have simply set the phone down.
@@droberts8703 Not by being thrown off the balcony
That's exactly what he did. Sit the phone down
His dad is a lawyer, he called his dad then left the building. Since he got off for this crime, he's been back on tinder and also been arrested for drugs and driving while under the influence of alcohol both of which he got off because of his dad. Money can get you off a murder charge.
Him and OJ are really winning
cute that you think that.
@@rickjames5998 lol its true tho its who you know and how much money you have do you live under a rock?
His dad was a carpet layer right? He was working for him. The lawyer didn’t response when he called him. At least that’s what understood.
@@rickjames5998 Ignorant much?
That was one of the most infuriating “not guilty” verdicts that I have ever heard of in my years of consuming true crime stories. There is zero chance that he didn’t murder this woman. I’m in shock and disbelief that he got away with it considering the damning recordings. She said she would leave and even begged him to let her go home. All he had to do was get her out the door. He had something to prove. Locking her out while she was standing in the balcony would have been forgivable and cause reasonable doubt, but we can clearly hear that isn’t what happened.
The alcohol 🍸 is guilty 😬
Just goes to show, if your good looking and rich 🤑, you can still get away with obvious murder!!!
@@andresweinman9995 Amen 🙏 to that, that’s why he made that homemade Vodka, I’m sure. Alcohol is usually one ☝️ of the guilty parties. Devils brew for sure 👍
Sad that he got away with murder.
Just terrible
He didn't get away with murder. Yes you hear him restrain her, but in this audio you can clearly hear her outside while he came back in the apartment from the balcony. This proves she was still on the balcony while he came back in. At the very least this was manslaughter. This is why he was found not guilty.
He’s absolutely guilty of her murder. Giving her that much alcohol was extremely irresponsible. He’s disgusting!
You can tell everything in the tone of his voice. He is saying all the right things, but in the most relaxed tone ever. If an innocent human being went through what he described, they would be hysterical. I've noticed thats where a lot of guilty criminals mess up. They think that being calm makes them appear innocent, when in reality its the exact opposite. Innocent people freak out, and raise their voice and ask the police questions if they're being interrogated. I've watched enough true crime to know that the calm ones are usually guilty.
So true
I mean she wanted it rough and wanted to dominate someone , all the money talk was about this . and when things got rough she just decided she is in danger and jumped off the balcony , its such a simple case.He is a psyco but she was crazy too hah
@@Tetrathegod Bro 🤦♀️ She was drunk because he was plowing her with booze all night while he stayed sober. Why was he recording it to begin with? Why did he threaten with throwing her off the balcony? He took her phone and she got upset& he used that to his advantage. Don't be foolish dude.
@@jillybean9563 wdym he was plowing her with booze? XD she is an adult and knew what she was taking . and the guy is a complete retard maybe it was just games and just being playful . She was just your typical wanna be dominant woman and when you take away her power as he did by pushing her and choking her .. anyways just 2 wrong people in 1 room . Maybe he needed bit of prison so he can grow up .
@@Tetrathegod He was giving her alcohol, but not drinking any himself. You can hear in her voice how plastered she is. She sounds really, really, really intoxicated. Not saying that's an excuse to get violent, but what I think happened is he was doing things to piss her off, taking her phone, you can hear hitting& objects being thrown, (and we don't really know who was doing what, we just have his word and I'll take that with a grain of salt) Who knows what else he was doing to make her mad so that he had an excuse to push her off the balcony. Unfortunately we only have audio and no visuals, we can hear him saying things like "I should never have given you so much to drink. Im injured and you don't have a scratch on you. This is bullshit. You're lucky I haven't chucked you off my balcony." He got her drunk, and then made remarks to make it sound like she was being violent on the recordings and then threw her off the balcony. She screams "No, I'll leave" and he still continues to drag her onto the balcony. Why didn't he just let her leave? I think he knew exactly what he was doing. 7 years later and he has more allegations. Dude is a creep.
what a trash guy. I don't know if he killed her but his attitude towards women was still terrifying.
She was saying " let me go home". She did NOT jump. He dangled her off the balcony & let her fall to her death in a disgusting fit of rage. He had just replied "too late for that" when she said just let me go home. He didn't even see her as a person, like all the women he "dated". There's a reason all those women at his apt. & in the clubs got such a creepy vibe off him . Unfortunately Wareena was so drunk that it was too late when she realized who she was with was a monster
Exactly! Plus you don’t hear her bang on the balcony door because she had no time. No body had time to save her because she was dangling when he left her. This guy tried to choke her, she would’ve gone to the police.
@@MsJoey2121
Exactly!
And he started the whole thing, he stole her phone, she wanted it back so she could leave. He WANTED to get into it with her & then kill her 😡 . I swear she should have run out his front door screaming for help, in whatever she had on, purse or no purse. Sometimes you are fighting for your very life & it's all that matters. And her phone was in his pocket the whole time, is what he told the police he "found it in his pocket"! He killed her intentionally. I heard that he did it again too.
You don't hear a struggle on the balcony. I also thought first he killed her but probably he didn''t and just locked her on the balcony, she was afraid to go back and started climbing. But it's strange that she faced forward. If there was a sound of a struggle I would immediately agree.
@@alexthedeal1827
Screaming "no, no, no" & he says "let go" because she was clinging to him for dear life isnt a struggle? She's struggling to hang on to him because she knows he's going to toss her.
Your misogyny is showing, Alex!
@@elizabethjarvie4472 listening to it more times I think you're right. I was confused because first it started on the bed or so where he pinned her down and grabbed a flashlight or so. Then she starts with no and it seams dramatic but then you can her hear continuing to say no when they're on the balcony so there it's probably no don't kill me. But what is 100% proof, no guessing, is that the hairdressers underneath see her dangling while she is saying things that he recorded before he clearly closes the balcony door. So when yoi combine these 2 things it's 100% and he should have been convicted, don't understand hiw they did not reenact simultaniously what they heard/ what he recorded, crazy.
How in the hell was he found not guilty… just getting her that drunk should have been a crime…. I cannot believe he got away with murder… he 100% was trying to “Chuck her off the balcony” like said… smh RIP baby girl
The part where she said let me go home, and he said no… that’s where he should have been given at least some form of punishment for causing the circumstances of her death, even if she fell.
@@HumbleConfidenceESagreed I don’t think it was murder but defo had a part to play…she was ridiculously drunk and slightly nuts but he enjoyed toying with her and by locking her on the balcony probably had hoped she would do something stupid
@@juliexx1980 he shouldn’t have been going tit for tat with a drunk emotional woman, should have tried to reason with her more, but he was drunk himself so… but yeah… letting her get on that balcony was very strange and spiteful. Just very sad how it ended. As a judge I’d probably have given him at least 2-4 years.
@@HumbleConfidenceESI don’t support the guy but one thing I’ll stand by is people as hammered as she was can’t be reasoned with. That much alcohol makes it pretty much impossible
@@dk9102 true, unsure if you drink yourself, but in Islam alcohol is called the mother of all evils (it leads to numerous harmful actions to one’s self and society)
My son was out recently and he saw him, some guy had his phone in his face recording him yelling it’s gable the murderer......he’s still on dating sites and prowling around clubs 🤢
Really? What was he like?
He can't be here in the US he might get beat up on the street
@@cineefrank1733 lol!
@@jackieclan815 he was just standing there taking it
@@ghosttheaussiehusky9378 pause...!
I am so angry after watching this, justice wasn't served. He caused her death. Rest in peace Warina.
@@Lavonne1 doesnt warrant killing her
@@davidca96 kenneth is a gable in the making. I can sense it
@@Lavonne1 I think you mean “they slept together on the first night”.
Me toooo like I’m so mad right now
Kenneth has deleted his comment, or its been reported I can't see it, which is good cause it was irrelevant anyway.
Seen this douchebag's story on several different outlets now, and this was by far the most detailed and thorough version yet. Great job imo 👏
I thought so too. He does it so well. A lot of details are new to me since they were not available from other channels.
Absolutely
@John M dude GREAT comment 🤣🤣🤣
Yea, I agree. I live in S.E. Queensland and was bombarded with this case, however I heard and learned more about tostie and the case on this channel than I have heard before. He truly is a nut job this grub. Typical of Queensland justice system, he should already have been in prison prior to this heinous crime. We will hear about this grub again in the future, I can feel it in my water ! 🇦🇺xoxox🇦🇺
@John M ~~ why ? Truth hurt much ?
The fact he mentioned throwing her off the balcony & that's her cause of death....But he's NOT GUILTY?!
This was horrifying to listen to. Aside from this terribly sad story I just want to say that this video was really well made and you are quickly growing into my favorite true crime UA-camr. I love the narration and the originality. The stories are also told so clearly. Thank you for your work!
except for the stupid, incorrect subtitles.
And the fact that there’s girls that act like this
@@finc4164 at least this video HAS subtitles. Take your complaints to someone who cares lol
@@rustyshackleford2808 says a lot about you bud
@@seinfields says a lot about society always taking the woman’s side.
So many different ways this could have turned out. He could've called police to escort her out, or the building management etc.
could've just stayed the hell off of tinder
@@Hermitelder 👍 👍
He was mad he let his anger get to him he wasn't thinking rationally, he is definitely guilty
No this guy wanted to teach her a lesson. Show her you was in control.
Another psycho.
@@lilithst2340 or the woman lost control. Hindsight is great but almost always useless as it is after the fact.
He clearly records his dates so he can manipulate who ever listens after he's done something horrible. It's all scripted nonsense from him . Absolute Psycho
This case has always pissed me off and after the first time watching it I never wanted to really hear about it again. But it is almost 3 AM and I can’t find anything new to watch and I love this channel so therefore I will support it by watching it again. 😊 thank you for creating such great content from these horrible cases. Every time I get a notification from y’all I am extremely happy
Also rest in peace Warriena Wright 😢
Just from the recording, it should be obvious for anyone with half a brain , what really happened. When she said NO for 47 second, he was carrying her toward the balcony , had her by the hands and she was trying not to get over the railing with her legs getting clingy. After 47 seconds he got her legs over the railing and put her hands on the railing , knowing she will cling to it , all this time she was with the back facing the building. Then he went inside and after 30 seconds she couldnt hold on anymore. That is why, he wasnt with her at the time of the fall . Prosecution was trully incompetent or really stupid. I cant believe this is possible, quite outrageous
Absolutely. No justice
This is the most accurate statement I’ve read on this horrific incident. If her hands were on the very top of the railing, rounded metal, she could’ve held on and climbed back over. The problem is, her hands were gripping the cement part of the terrace which is much lower. It was only a matter of time she would lose that grip.
The only part that I’m completely confused about is your comment reiterating that her back was facing the building. That’s incorrect. Her back was facing the street. In the graphic image from the neighbors terrace 1 floor below, you can see the front of her feet dangling off the terrace, which means her back is not facing the building. What am I missing ? Thanks
@@FOXAMG63 they said eyewitnesses were saying that, that was not correct. The ones who witnessed it said she actually had her back towards the building.
Quite a possibility!
@@FOXAMG63 this video explains that the photo with legs dangling facing the building was from a recreation, and was incorrectly circulated by media. From eye witness accounts, her back was to the building.
For some reason I was always on the understanding that he was innocent.....
But after listening to this (obviously the same audio) I’ve changed my mind. He obviously was doing something to her whilst he was talking so calmly. And this is not his first ‘altercation’.
He’s a deeply deranged person.
@Thou Swell Yeah. And his story that he told his dad absolutely reeks of lies and bullshit. Terrifying that he's still out there and 100% going to harm women again after getting away with murder.
lol y'all really let the narrator convince you through his suggestions
@@mamadounjooi220 oh shit I have haven’t I? Crikey I thought I was strong minded too.
@@SarahLBanks lol there's a reason he decided to narrate the most important parts of the audio through his suggestive perception instead of letting it play for itself, he only plays the parts that would seem the most incriminating if they were cut from the rest of the audio
This is why "you were always understanding he was innocent FOR SOME REASON" , that reason being, YOU ACTUALLY LISTENED TO THE FULL RECORDING prior to her fall, that's what made it clear he was innocent , fear files made sure to cut it out and narrate it instead.
From the start he wasn't being objective at all, at every step he put made "innocent" but very suggestive questions or comments taking you by the hand it order to lead you to the conclusion he wants you to reach
So yes, most ppl who watched this that hadn't known this case very well would end up being led astray like you were . You should make your own decision, not just let some skewed representation of things decide things for u
Toastee had several hobbies caring for animals he had rescued, I don't remember the name but you can find it, however he was presented as a pure predatory criminal "TOWERING X height Y pound" compared to the "timid,small frame, x pound and y height"
Anyway if you want another channel that stays neutral and doesn't manipulate the evidence, there's betters that stay objective on this case
All this to say if things had happened as the fear files is trying to portray, there would have been an unanimous decision to find him guilty of murder
His explanation is like his alibi…
21:54 : "You're lucky I haven't chucked you out of the balcony".
Magically, she is chucked out of the balcony.
The fact he recorded everything shows how a psycho he is. He is the type that enjoys being feared and being the master. From her voice, you can say she was choked or she had something on her mouth/face. He is so evil he said the perfect things for the police to hear later😢
He was enjoying every bit that happened in that room
I agree. This man was enjoying this. He had so many options to get that woman out of his apartment if he wanted to.
Why would anyone lock another person who is inebriated out on a balcony 14 stories up?! When she begged to go home, why didn’t he bring her home or call her a cab? He’s guilty of murder, in my opinion.
Sounds like he was holding her over the edge hence why she screamed no so many times.
Lucky you aren’t a judge then.
Bring her home? Do you not comprehend how stupid that sounds?
He definitely killed her
@@Basedtv800 lucky girl the murderer
How this creep wasn’t held responsible for her death is unbelievable and beyond comprehension. The prosecutor must be feeble minded if he doesn’t understand that he placed her on the outside of the balcony railing. There’s even a god damn audio recording!
Can’t believe he was found not guilty. I feel he was responsible for her death.
This. I don’t think he ever intended to kill her but he still played a huge part in her fate.
I wonder if her family and friends can hold him liable in a civil suit. Not sure about the laws in Australia.
Definitely her fault what happened. Don't go home with someone you met 15 minutes before
He will paid dearly later on this life time or next life for sure .
@@crispyandclean1446 so she deserved to be murdered? Talk about blaming the victim...this guy is sll sorts of sick that you would never imagine....now I am thinking what's up with you?
That's hard to listen too, I'd love to get ahold of this guy
He clearly wasn’t in fear for his live he could have called the cops at anytime! The recording is chilling. When he wouldn’t let her leave because she was a “bad girl” made me feel physically ill. He definitely gave her too much alcohol on purpose to take advantage of her and then kicked her in the balcony while highly highly intoxicated and terrified clearly so terrified she felt she needed to climb off the balcony.
It probably didn't help her fear level that she'd only just met him off Tinder. I wouldn't have to be drunk to be terrified that someone didn't shove me out the front door and instead locked me on a balcony, after not letting me leave. I probably would have tried climbing down the balcony as well in that situation. He obviously wasn't terrified of her or he would have let her leave or tossed her out of the door.
Right how is that one statement or the you’re lucky I haven’t thrown you off the balcony yet how were those not enough to at least give him manslaughter or something. He definitely needs to be in jail. This was gonna happen sooner or later by the way he talks about women
So it would have been fine if he tossed her half undressed out into the hall of the apartment building at that hour? She was throwing rocks! And other stuff. I’m not defending his choice, but given the circumstances he wasn’t way out of line.
Had she been out there for more than six whole seconds before deciding to climb over the rail…! And you would do the same? God help us all.
Tragic? Yes. Best choice on his part? No. His fault? Not at all.
@@tylerskiss because throwing her out in the hallway wasn’t an option? Did he plan this? No but did he prevent this? Again no. He’s at fault 100%.
@@tylerskiss Yes. It would have been a lot smarter to toss her out the front door, along with her clothes and things.. versus putting a highly intoxicated person on a balcony of a high rise.
Holy shit... That was incredibly disturbing hearing that poor girl😢
Thus one has always bothered me _"She was drunk and beating me up so I put her on the varanda"_ ? What?
Not in a bathroom, a bedroom, A closet, or just quite simply kicking her out of the apartment and calling her a taxi? It's just an unbelievable concept.
Unbelievable and unacceptable!!!!
this was the excuse for his father, media and police but nobody believe that....but as he s crazy he though it"s normal to act this way.
Just because she appeared to be a mean drunk doesn’t mean you have to kill her
You would think that the thought of calling a cab or security to remove her from your apartment would have crossed his mind at some point in those 3 hours says a lot to me about his intentions
He did not sound drunk to me at all and had full control of the situation he seemed rehearsed like he was acting, no mumbling or stumbling over words but clear and precise
I don’t know what happened in the first of the recording but the last says it all, he killed her
Even though I've already seen a lot of these stories I watch your videos because I enjoy the way you narrate them
Lol, no shit that's the point
@@adampalermo6203 not quite, the point is to learn a lesson from it, enjoyment lasts for a while but lesson lasts life time.
Gives me Forensic Files vibes
That’s what they all say
@@socialmedia2674 the point is u need help.. professional help..
She was terrified for her life after he had tried to suffocate and restrain her multiple times. She had no other means of escape. God bless her soul.
She was a complete psycho couldn't hold her drink started abusing him both physically n verbally he didn't know what to do n she jumped off the balcony herself...
That'll happen when you kick,punch, and throw things at someone for hours for no reason. Just because someone is bigger and stronger than you doesn't obligate them to put up with your abuse. Being restrained is a very lenient response to a violent psycho.
@@stewpitt8388abuse isn’t throwing tiny pebbles at someone once you little creep.
I see the basement dwelling incels are showing out in this thread 🙄
@@ilovehotmoms5804abuse IS, however, choking and retaining someone and making them fear for their life, and then throwing them off the balcony which I believe is what happened and she managed to grab on for a moment. Actually no wait-that’s murder. Straight up murder. So what if she was annoying? He could’ve and should’ve just let her go home-but that’s not what he wanted to do, he wanted to kill her. Being annoying isn’t an f’ing death sentence. It’s not even a crime. But it looks like the tiny 🍆 misogynist trolls are showing up in here 🙄 btw this isn’t aimed at you I’m agreeing with you
The only thing I needed to hear in this case was the recording. If he was actually worried about himself he’d leave his apartment and call the cops. This guy was a freak from the beginning and the recording is so hard to listen to. 😓
Why didn't he just call the police, and keep his balcony door locked? Even if he didn't murder her, he facilitated her death when she was incredibly vulnerable. Dangerous man!
He set her up
The simple fact that this creep feels the need to record his encounters with women in the first place speaks volumes to me. And when he asked his dad, “Why does this keep happening to me?” I’d like to know what he meant by that 🤔 seems to me he’s been a monster before this girl met his wrath. Poor girl.. she just wanted to go home. Why he couldn’t have thrown her out into the hall and locked the door is beyond me. Even if he didn’t physically throw her over, he did absolutely nothing to stop her or help her once she was dangling. That right there should be a charge of some sort.
he hid her phone and purse so she couldn’t leave and when she got irritated and started throwing the pebble ornaments he got mad, what a psycho he knew exactly what he was going to do to her that’s why he recorded it trying to make it sound like it was all on her i’m also disgusted with the neighbours how can you hear a woman screaming no no no i want to go home and not call the police 😪 shame on them
What??? I thought she had just lost her phone.... I didn't know he had hidden it
.. idk if you know Anna Oop but she made a video sticking up for the girl and everyone is DRAGGGING HER. But then I see this video and everyone is sticking up for Warriena and not Gable?
I guess it depends which details you hear. I think he'd guilty. Aside from causing her death he should've at LEAST been charged with negligence or manslaughter.
Did the investigation ever determine whether he had the phone or she lost it? I’m honestly curious, because either seems very feasible.
@@llhannah9297 thanks
I wish she had left without it. she could have never known this would happen
@@rrpostalagain in the audio he finds it in his pocket and acts like he does not know how it got there.