Javed Akhtar vs. team Animal
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 жов 2024
- Writer Javed Akhtar described what he thinks is a good hero. But team “Animal” disagreed.
Brut India is the fastest-growing digital video publisher in the country. We're a young, independent platform producing compelling journalism in new formats.
You can also find us here:
Facebook: / brutindia
Instagram: / brut.india
Twitter: / brutindia
Snapchat: Brut India
Snapchat: Brut India Stories
It's sad that people aren't getting his point. He's not bashing the movie or its makers, he's talking about the audience giving such praise to the movie and its content.
Leave it bro...people are getting dumber and dumber by every generation.
So all the Mumbai Don movies which glorified the likes of Dawood proved that India was a country who loved criminals.....
yes
@@dharmeshsingh3440 it needed to be said again and again😊
Animal is dangerous for society, but movies like Ugly Aur Pagli are perfectly fine. SIMP, Gynocentric society.
It's ironic that Animal promotes the concept of alpha males, yet in reality, the ppl behind the film behave like snowflakes, getting offended by people's comments about their film and responding with immaturity.. lol
Well, What are they supposed to do then? Internet is just a place like that, why not criticise the movie in real life infront of them, and see how it goes😊?
@@Rudra-rf5cnwhy are you di*k riding this movie so much. You are everywhere in this comment section
@@Rudra-rf5cnasli ID se aao vanga
@@vikingk1725 What's vanga, bhai🤣?
@@Rudra-rf5cn Well he is speaking publicly, so not really a difference
A bad person being bad in a movie is not wrong, but showing as if the bad persons actions are okay and there is nothing wrong with it, that’s what makes it wrong. And that’s what animal did, they made it seem like it was ‘normal’ and ‘okay’ to abuse someone
Good point
You are completely wrong.
Here nothing is good or bad. *Javed Akhtar Questioned the character saying "how come that character can do such things ???? So based on the Storyline, Animal team gave a reply to javed akhtar saying "her love was fake and actually she wanted to trap Ranvijay and his father,,,,so after knowing this Ranbir Kapoor's character asked her to lick his boot"* . Also they added that javed akhtar wouldn't have Questioned the same thing when a woman says to a man to lick her boot if he cheats her.
‼️‼️ I just want to know,
Why all Alpha - Sigma Man, always needs a Women to prove him Alpha beta Gama sigma Whatever male..🤬
Why Alpha never become Alpha without humilating women .?
@@s.z3717 because he is an *"Alpha MALE"* ,,,,,not an *"Alpha HUMAN"* .
Got it ?????
Stupid assessment. Good bad kahaan se aagaya! Tumhara dimag tumhe bol raha hai ye good hai,wo bad hai.
In the film most of the male characters are grey in shades.
Also the director himself said that Ranvijay is neither a good guy nor all of his actions are morally correct.
Watch his interview on galatta plus.
This is such a PERFECT speech. Much respect to the way he has put his thoughts across.
‼️‼️ I just want to know,
Why all Alpha - Sigma Man, always needs a Women to prove him Alpha beta Gama sigma Whatever male..🤬
@s.z3717 Haha, seriously, because there's hardly any other way to dump their male ego I guess.
You didn't have problem with nudity and sex in this film ?😂
@ahmedzakikhan7639 You do realize I'm also supporting somebody who's AGAINST the film? And no, my problem is more with cheating / male dominance / no importance or voice of female characters/ extreme and disgusting violence, all of these are worse than nudity.
@@AB-ur9rq very true
Nowadays villains are portrayed as hero and heroes are portrayed as villains.
Ako mirzapur pasand aayi thi
Nhi gangs of wasseypur 😅
Yes gangs of wasseypur aur iska ,shezadeka produced mirzapur tho ,maha kavya hai....
100 chuhe Kai billi hajj ko jaye
Ranbir wasn't the hero, he was the protagonist (main character) 🤦♂️
He's absolutely right, people especially young people have always been fantasized by Bollywood movies and they tend to mimic them. If a movie spreads a wrong message to the society and it is implemented in real life then it will be a problem not only to that person but to the society too
Did you think about his own movies, where women were objectified as well. This Islamist bigot has to stop.
Bhai ye toh fir feminist movies ko bhi ban kardo, ya fir movies all together hi ban kardo, it will encourage people to fight ten guys at once, na?
@@adityasakalekar5175 Ha bhai, ye bhi sahi baat bole ho...
For those, whom watch movies of different genres and industries, "Animal" is neither a violent nor immoral. Cause there are a lot of scenes in different movies which are more disturbing than Animal. But for mass Indian audience its new. Thats why people are criticizing it.
Furthermore, many people started criticizing it without even watching it.
@@Rudra-rf5cnBollywood ko hi ban kar do 🤣🤣
Totally respect Javed Akhtar for voicing what millions of us painfully feel about our society 😢😢
Just leave the country no pain y'all will suffer
You overestimate the effect of movies
इन्होंने Animal देखी ही नही है ना ही कबीर सिंह देखी है ये एक Animal का संवाद बता रहे है दूसरा कबीर सिंह मूवी पर निर्देशक का रियल लाइफ बयान बता रहे है वो भी आधा ये है आज की परेशानी कोई एक समाज का घोषित ज्ञानी या बड़ा आदमी है उसे जब कोई समाज पर राय रखने को बोला जाता है तो वो सिर्फ अपने पॉइंट्स को अपने Sabdo को अपनी बातो को अच्छा सुंदर और सभ्य घोषित करने के लिए ऐसे ऐसे Example देता है जिनको इन्होंने ना तो सही से जाना है ना पहचाना है ना अध्यन किया है बस सुनी सुनाई बातो पर ज्ञान पेल रहे है Animal में Jutte चाटने का बोलने पर कही से भी लड़की का अपमान नही है वो एक दोखरबाज इंसान को बोला गया है क्यो की वो बोला में अब वफादार बन गया हु तब उसे परखने के लिए रणविजय ने ऐसा बोला जब वो ऐसा करने लगती है वो हट जाता है क्या उसने Jutta चटवाया दूसरा कबीर सिंह में साहिद का पात्र अपनी प्रेमिका की सगाई में आ जाता है उसकी मर्जी के खिलाफ सादी हो रही है वो वहा हंगामा करता है गुस्से में होता है उसकी प्रेमिका उसे रोकती है समझाती है बार बार वो गुस्से में पागल हो रखा होता है और वो प्रेमिका को एक थपड़ मार देता है इसपर बवाल होने पर Director Reddy Saheb ने बोला था की अगर कोई लड़का लड़की गंभीर प्रेम संबंध में है और किसी वजह से दोनो Mese एक भयंकर गुस्से में है और उसका पार्टनर उसे रोक रहा है बार बार तो ऐसे रिश्ते में हाथ चलना कोई असंभव बात नही चाहे लड़का हो या लड़की हाथ चला सकता है और ऐसा हर जगह होता आया है होता रहेगा अगर प्रेमी प्रेमिका को किसी वजह से गुस्से में एक थपड़ मार भी देता है तो क्या इस से दुनिया खतरे में आ जाएगी क्या लड़कियों का जीवन खतरे में आ जाएगा क्या कोई संकट आ जाएगा क्या ये सब समाज में होता नही क्या हा हर प्रेमी या हर प्रेमिका ऐसा नही कर सकते लेकिन कबीर सिंह जिस तरह का पात्र है जिस तरह का उसे दिखाया है High Temper और लापरवाह तो क्या वो ऐसा नही कर सकता लेकिन वो दिल का साफ है दिल से मन से वफादार है ईमानदार है वही अगर वही पात्र कोई दोखेबाज होता बेइमान होता और उसे थपड़ मारते दिखाते तब बात गलत होती तब डायरेक्टर ने बोला और जावेद साहेब ने सुनी सुनाई बाते यहां बोल के खुद को ज्ञानी साबित करने के चक्कर में खुद का मजाक उड़ा लिया जावेद साहेब जेसे की सबसे बड़ी Problem है खुद Sandeep Reddy तभी दोनो संवाद का उदाहरण उन्होंने सिर्फ Reddy साहेब पर दिए क्यो की अब इन्हे लग रहा है की एक South से आया हुआ आदमी तेलगु से आया आदमी हिंदी में 2 मूवी बनाता है और दोनो All Time Blockbuster और Jisme Animal तो 2023 की सबसे बड़ी हिट और जिस तरह की उन्होंने दोनो फिल्म बनाई जिस तरह की Writting थी फिल्म की जिस तरह की पटकथा थी वैसा आजतक हिंदी सिनेमा में कोई लेखक कर ही नही पाया ये जावेद साहेब भी नही सलीम साहेब भी नही तब इन्हे गुस्सा आ रहा है खुद को असुरक्षित Feel कर रहे है तब लगा हुआ है 80% Bollywood Reddy Saheb को Target करने में उन्हें बदनाम करने में उन्हें नीचा दिखाने में और उन पर मानसिक दबाव डालने में ताकि वो एग्रेसिव हो और अगली फिल्म में इन सब बातो को वो दिमाग में रखे और अगली फिल्म में वो कोई बड़ी गलती करे Esbaar वो Perfect Film ना बना पाए और एक Director और Writter का ऐसा होता है वो अगर एकबार सिर्फ एक फिल्म में भी Fail हो गए तो वो Legend नही कहलाएंगे और Public उन पर इतना भरोसा फिर नही कर पायेगी एक हीरो Star चाहे 5/7 Film में Fail हो जाए उस पे भरोसा रहता है लेकिन एक Director Writter को हर बार सफल होना होता है अगर उन्हे बेस्ट और Legend बने रहना है तो जेसे अगर राजामौली साहेब आज भारत के बेस्ट और नामी Director है आज Public उन पे आंख बंद कर के भरोसा करती है क्यो की उन्होंने आजतक 12 लगातार सफल फिल्म दी है जिसमे 5 Atbb 3bb 3superhit 1hit Esa Track Kisi का नही तो अगर उनकी Next Film अच्छी ना बने और Flop हो जाए भगवान ना करे तो उस आदमी के Share समझो तुरंत 50% Down हो जाएंगे और एक असफल फिल्म से उनके Carrier पर दाग लग जाएगा और वो भरोसा नही रहेगा Jese हिरानी साहेब का हुआ 5 Atbb दी लगातार भारत के दूसरे सबसे अच्छे Director थे लेकिन एक Dunki में Fail क्या हुए सभी ने उनसे मूंह मोड़ लिया आज कोई उनपे वो भरोसा नही करता जो पहले करता था तो बात ये है Reddy साहेब को दिमाग पे असर डाल के उन्हे असफल करवाने का ये पूरा Sadyantra है Bollywood का Bhagwan करे Reddy Saheb ये अच्छे से समझ जाए और अगली फिल्म इसी तरह अपने विजन से अपनी बुद्धि से बिना किसी 1% दबाव के किसी 1% डर के बनाए और सफल हो भारत को और हमे ऐसे सच्चे ईमानदार विजनरी ज्ञानी और मेहनती Film Maker की सख्त जरूरत है
Don't watch mirzapur 3 😡😡😡😡😡
Millions. Nobody thinking about she came to cheet the guy and going to kill whole family. Millions of men are suffering from girls who is cheating them
I cannot believe that Animal's team chose to respond in such an immature fashion, talking like insecure alpha dudes on the internet and going with the absurd argument of 'if a woman did this, you would have called it feminism'. The point is, the movie is not just an unbiased story with no gender playing part in it. They've glorified the alpha male trope, yet again. That's the problem and they just can't seem to understand it.
Very well said! But that been said let's not forget that they have also shown it's disadvantages as the character proceeds in the story (losing it all) leaving us (the audience) to think on our own.
Yup seriously lol, sounds like 17 year old kid, wtf animal is a total fantasy movie, no guy in real life could talk to women like that😂.
The movie is made by immature people, so it's not surprising that they responded this way
But you can't really refute their point...There are a lot of feminist movies too, all they and their supporters ask is why the one sided biasness and hypocrisy?
@@Rudra-rf5cn in India how many feminist movies? Even if someone make how many watch it? lol kuchbi bolneka. West ko india se compare mat kar. Kal aise chapri ladke Teri behn aur maa ko bolenge tabi dekhte he kya karega.
The only sane voice in film industry today…Respect and Salute 🫡
Vikran messy in 12th fail is real hero and best story . Inspirational movie .
Abey to kya sabhi ias ban jatey hai kya
Phir bhi ladki ka chakkar babu bhaiya
Nah wasn’t the best story tbh but still far better from animal
Poverty P**n hai 12th fail . Aur Animal glorification of misogyny and toxic masculinity hidden with over the top violence & mission to save father . Even though the father with all his money could've had the best security.
Coaching mafia propoganda
Sandeep Vanga is the type of guy who gets inspiration from Andrew Tate reels and decides to make a film about it
accurate. I wouldnt be surprised if hes a andrew tate fan
I believe this 👍
Speculation much?
Andrew Tate will become Sandeep Vanga‘s fan now.. 🤣
Andrew Tate is facing trial in Romania charged with rape, human trafficking and forming an organised crime group to sexually exploit women.
This is what Hollywood and Bollywood people does majority of them, it’s been 15 years I have ever watched Bollywood movie in theaters.most of them are involved in children trafficking &all sorts of evil.Spend your money for something meaningful.
Old people had higher morals and a moral compass. Mad respect for them.
Ummm no??? There were wars and they seized whole countries. Every generation has problems
I'm not sure about that.
But JA had a valid point
Bus assaults against women nowadays are caused mainly by these oldies. There are more to these old communities than u see.
Really? Said who?
Its not just old people, but our generation as well. It’s just there are way too many vocal Alpha males and misogynists
I can't believe animal team would disrespect a senior writer like Javed Akhtar. He is a legend and an experienced writer who has written about betrayal in beautiful and realistic manner. Today's generation is losing its sanskaars.
Everyone knows he is a ghost writer, it is an open secret in moviegoers.
Chamcho ki barat nikli hai...😂😂😂😂 You can do Puja of Javed . Take him to you home
Oooo who cares about the oldy she did not even get the film nor did chapris like you
Javed is a pure opportunist , he does have some skills on writing , but has lost all respect.
@@AmitKpradhan that's TRUE. He has written many immoral characters and story. A film is a film, let's treat it that way. I like films which has apocalyptic background, that does not mean I like to those things real life.
Bravery in public is as rare as unicorn nowadays in India. Salute to Sir Javed.
saying "if a woman had said that then you guys would have celebrated it by calling it feminism." is a assumption. if you make your statement based on an assumption, i don't think your argument is well grounded.
exactly even from an unbiased pov his argument is weak. With that director I am starting to see a pattern at this point. first Kabir Singh and then this. His liking to portray violence against women is one thing but defending abusive actions irl is not good at all.
yeah even if any woman criticise the movies like Animal or Kabir Singh, people don't think that they are giving their opinion as individual person but rather think that they are saying this out of Feminism and just bcz their gender is woman or something, now some will say its just movie and its for entertainment, i agree but justifying it even off screen by Director is wrong from my perspective
Strawman Fallacy
His statement is absolutely true because no one questioned the killing of hundreds of men in the film, but all they are talking about is a lick my shoe line which he did not even let her do it even though she came to get his family killed. Biased ppl as usual
@@Uehehdjdjshya a woman will only talk about a specific topic and it's his characters that his wish wtf are you ppl on 😂 what did he justify can you pls elaborate, don't argue about the slap because slap in common in sex that's just illiterate to think it hurt you because ppl died in his films 😂, now where's the equality
I like how unafraid he is. I guess a few things get easier with age. While most of the Bollywood supported the movie finally someone points out the problem. Rosamun Pike in Gone Girl isn't glorified,she gets away with it but it's clearly shown something is very off with her. Barry Keoghan in Saltburn wasn't glorified either but the story is a psychological thriller with a twisted antagonist/protagonist's aspirations..no one in anyway justifies it. But team Animal won't budge to justify their protagonist's heroics at any given chance.
Exactly! Deflecting important questions pertaining to social, mental awareness makes me wonder if the filmaker, director and it's 'hero' of that movie are irresponsible and/or morally not sound. Which makes this movie's success even more daunting for the society.
He is unafraid because he is still very powerful. You can google 'Salim-Javed'. I completely agree with the rest of your point.
What abt wolf of the wall streets? In animal,when are his actions justified again? He pays the consequence for everything. He murders ppl for his father but same father gonna die at the end nmw. He cheats, his wife leaves him. Idk if u noticed but when confronts his wife abt cheating he is guilty remember that he is the same guy who scolded his cousins for cheating on thier wives.
It's interesting to know that people only pinpoint the wrong things with Rosamund Pike's character and fail to realise Ben Affleck's character also had some serious flaws in Gone Girl, ultimately it depends on the audience how they interpret and validate a character's role.A mature audience would have definitely understood there were some incorrect elements in Animal movie.
@@adityachauhan4873right the mature audience knows the shoe scene is not the only wrong thing in the movie. it’s not a movie with high moral ground . The hero has done other horrible things too .
And about Gone girl , sure Ben’s character wasn’t exactly the husband of the year , but did he deserve that ?
Javed Akhtar is the pinnacle of the highest standards for many decades. His depths can't be reached by shallow-minded S.R. Vanga and his Animal team. Javed Akhtar's craft and literature are studied in universities. The movie 'Animal' was a tiny blip in Bollywood history; people are already starting to forget about it.
💯👌
He was the one who started portraying smuggler as hero.
Started glorifying underworld.
@ShakDMC sadly he couldn't pass his values to his kids. His daughter said its woman's choice to have sex outside of marriage, this is the definition of women empowerment in terms of these elite kids....
Could not expect a better response from animal team. Looks like they themselves are kind of animal too😂
They explain about alpha males they themselves are sheep.easily offended
Mummy kha phone vapas deydho chotu
@@SenseiSaitama21tere paas phn bhi nhi hona chahiye
@@lorddBobby ooo comedy
It shows the confidence of vanga and his alpha nature to give a befitting reply to any criticism.
Animal is by far the most pathetic film. Huge respect and very much agree with Javed Akhtar sir.
Its a grt film. Only feminist will get offended. Dont worry if you become normal woman, you will not be treated like that.
@@avishekmukhopadhyay6086 it is a bad influence, only those who have no ethics or morality would like that bullshit film. No film should be allowed to dehumanize a group or gender. Patriarchy and misogyny is a real life thing and it needs to be cured, not idolized.
@@avishekmukhopadhyay6086
‼️‼️ I just want to know,
Why all Alpha - Sigma Man, always needs a Women to prove him Alpha beta Gama sigma Whatever male..🤬
Why Alpha never become Alpha without humilating women .? saale Farzi.🤬🤬🤬
@@avishekmukhopadhyay6086dumb meninist
@@s.z3717point to be noted, like andrew tate ko daikh lo, uski hr baat women are..., women have, sy start hoti hai
Chapri bewakoof nomaanay haen sab
If the roles were reversed then there would be a huge backlash bcz women are hated and insulted for much lesser. Also, this ABSTRACT "role reversal" angle is used more so as an excuse to normalise REAL male psychopathy. The director is not just seeing this as a fictional story but a real possibility, its seems so from the way he is defending it and responding to it.
yes. this. exactly this. women actors are facing backlash and death threats even for their clothes in movies. and here they are talking about glorifying degrading behavior of such level. people would eat the women alive if something like these were portrayed in the name of feminism in movies.
‼️‼️ I just want to know,
Why all Alpha - Sigma Man, always needs a Women to prove him Alpha beta Gama sigma Whatever male..🤬
Why Alpha never become Alpha without humilating women .?🤔🤔🤬
Great observation and insight. The director seems to highlight the possiblity of how the movie reflects real life. It is daunting for our society that this movie is supposedly a success.
@@oshing9 The movie clearly IS a box office hit, and that is terrifying as it reflects what kind of society we are living in.
Absolutely. Four more shots, I haven't even seen this movie or even heard of it yet I know it's labelled as 'feminist' movie and hated for it. The discrepancy is insane.
Javed akhtars single lyric is better than the entire animal film
I agree
Ek larki ko dekha Jo eysa laga ....
Breathless
Sandese aate hai,
Radha kaise na jale and so on....
I don't think the Animal team is getting the issue here, either they really can't understand or they are deliberately trying to misunderstand. The problem is not gender any gender telling to lick the shoe or the betrayal being glorified or slapped is the issue here. The messaging is wrong, irrespective of which gender is doing it.
Message? So ppl are skipping school and are getting educated by films, why don't ppl use the same logic and become a topper and a caring husband like ranvijay who doesn't hesitate to touch his wife's feet or help her deliver the baby by himself, but na you are smart so you won't be manipulated but the others will only handpick the bad stuff right ✌️ keep going dude you are a certified citizen of our nation
@Shortshortsssssss But after release of 3 idiots movie, did number of suicides among students decreased? Even after release of 3 idiot movie, students are still committing suicide.
@Shortshortsssssss ya after watching 3 idiots all are becoming toppers and instead of curing a patient we are chanting All is well ✌️
@Shortshortsssssss a film can inspire dude but film is never the only source of knowledge and information, you just called Animal a sh*t film, just say you did not like it chill 😂, ooo 3 idiots inspired the youth all are amazed by it and stuff is for Chapris, because one film will never save a person's life you ppl are just biased on Animal 😂
@Shortshortsssssss and what's with the biased replies just address my whole comment dude 😂, that's what you ppl always do ie selective justice
I have seen kabir singh and I feel like it was an entertaining movie except some of the scenes. I was more eager to watch Animal after all the controversy and the deflecting opinions by the audience. But somewhere I saw a clip of the director saying something like irrespective of your gender if you can’t even slap your partner then it’s not love and I was like hell no dude…. A person with a mentality like that should not be encouraged no matter how good his work is.
F o
this guy never slapped asscheeks . ok virgin
@@samratyadav9268🐑
Venga needs help
Just got my shoes licked - in this country, daily, millions pick up 💩 poop entering into manhole. Javed Saheb is reflecting on the character of a society based on this movie. The reality, where in India, millions face violence, rape, and humiliation based on caste, color, economic status, and education. It's the same society that elects leaders based on their criminality, toxicity, and harm. inflicted on vulnerable individuals.
Just shows how today's actors , directors and writers can stoop to any level. Only goal is to make money. Atleast we as audience need to do better by rejecting films like animal.
Complete respect for Javed Akhtar sir
This is true! It’s sad that Animal kind of movies becomes a hit. Vanga once said that just because he watched gangster movies in his childhood, he didn’t become a gangster. But he did become a nasty film director, thanks to those movies. If only highly educated people like doctors & engineers were to watch a movie then probably a movie like Animal won’t make a dent in the society but unfortunately most of the movie goers in India are uneducated or illiterate, who have a little to no knowledge about right or wrong. Such movies plays with their mind sadly and then a heinous crime like Rape happens. Movies plays a big part in shaping the society. It’s important that film makers takes a responsibility.
Don't care. You don't watch if you don't like it. There are 100s of rabid feminist and male bashing films. Ban those first.
Lol most of the movie goers are educated most of them with degrees and high paying job why would a illiterate pay a 300-400 for a ticket if he doesn't even has a job
@@KuchBhi-xs5oe so Animal arranged for them too, selling tickets now at 100 rupees, kuchh bhi kar k 1000 cr kamana hai,..har jaga tatti kr k bhi q na ho
@@KuchBhi-xs5oe just 100/- enough to watch this flim come to Lila cinema hall in my city
@@KuchBhi-xs5oeyou do realise that movies and web series can be easily downloaded from telegram or pirated websites just after one day of it’s release. Hope you are not living under a rock:)
You are a true Artist.
Criminals who made Animal
Fools who acted in Animal l
Morons who appreciated Animal
Animals who liked Animal.
Javed Sir 🙏 You are a true Artist.
You forgot to add one more point.
I'm a snowflake who can't handle movies.
The subtle take on consumerism and capitalism is one of the best articulation ever.
Ok beta what else, what Modi said is right gendu generation, at least understand the film dude
@@Ok99012 I am not even talking about the film here. I don't know what you're talking about par Modiji ne kaha he to sahi hi kaha hoga..
@@uravshukla hm but chapri is even jugding the ppl who liked a particular film and that's concerning
@@Ok99012 concerning toh he hi na bhai.. cinema is the mirror of society..
@@uravshukla I usually don't buy the communist arguments but dangers of consumerism is inevitable. If we see around the world, all the attempts to stop consumerism are almost failed. Its a reality. The only subtle way to tackle it is consumer ethics. If you don't like a movie or say product, don't buy it.
In countries like India movie or cricket heroes are worshipped and followed religiously. So it is important for directors or actors think well before portraying any character on screen. Social responsibility should be part and parcel of everyone
So glad he expressed this publicly!
Each and every word of Javed ji is 10000000% true I completely agree its fault of audience who supports this kind of worst vulgar movies where there is no sense to watch.. Father son emotion and we can't watch with our father what a shame... Never give hype to these vulgar directors they spoil our coming generations
@@ananthansreekanth7988 Aur zinda wapis aagye? 😂
You could have comment same for Dhoom movies. What they are teaching.
I was like whatever🙂until I saw that clip of this director saying it’s not true love if we don’t have the liberty of slapping each other💀
He said that😂😂😂
This Vanga guy is crazy shit...oh god...i don't need to slap anyone to show my love, care and affection and vice versa(irrespective of gender)... period!!
That's a pathetic statement from him!
@@Pritipatil22 Didi ask any doctor couples slap eachother during a sexual intercourse what do you mean
Yeah.. same!!
Huge Respect for Javed Sir ✨🫡
Why ????
Problem is that javed akhtar like Buddhas can't see a film as a film.
It is just a movie, no need to question the character.
@@ankitSharma43825 there was case in Australia where a indian man harassed a Austrian women..when she sued him at the court.."he replied he learnt it from Govinda movie "
Yeh india ha..baki duniya ma film samjh k ayena dekhati ha..india main log film dekh ke apna samjh ka Aina banata ha..after the movie tere naam kidnapping of girl after refusal increase by double..there is many examples..
Is desh main log ek WhatsApp main fake message verify nhi kar sakta film or reality ko kya hi separate karenge..
@@ankitSharma43825 Character of the movie?
@@dreamer9375 Questioning the character.
@@dreamer9375You mean which character. The girl who came to cheat the hero family?
Very true Javed ji can't agree more...film makers and actors need to more responsible before making a film or doing a role,given the impact of cinema on people and the kind of soft power that these senseless celebrities enjoy in our country....
The fact that films like animal esrning crores hints at the real mentality of our population, javed sir, U r no wrong 🙏🏻
Always great to listen to Javed Sir. I think Animal movie's team did not see the entire speech of Javed sir and just responded on a single thing immaturely. He is litterally putting the onus on the viewers and not on a film maker alone. Well as they say 'Common sense is a rare commodity'...😂
Oh am sure they saw javed sir's entire speech. They're deflecting from taking resposibility of the moral impact of the film on our society using 'straw man fallacy'. It's is immature to say the least and narcissistic to say the most.
Javed Akhtar ❤️💕
It's like when you're in an argument and mid argument u realise you're wrong but you're too stubborn to accept you're wrong so you'll die everything but accept that you're wrong like question Javed Akhtar's work lol...
True
Going from ancient india where ma sita had the right to chose her own groom and noble brave indian women like laxmibai to animal being a superhit. Really tells you why india was sone ki chiriya and now it isn't.
Edit- PLEASE READ THIS. If you don't know, major reason for india being sone ki chiriya was the freedom it provided to women. Example, the holy texts of vedas which are considered to be the oldest texts were written by a lot of women.
India had temples based around sex and even had texts like kamasutra which normalised sex for both men and women.
FUN FACT- A lot of people say that women showing skin is not indian culture. Actually concept of 'Parda' was introduced by the mughals and was not hindu culture. So much for our society being Hindu centric but all we are following are mughals.
I still do believe in the women of our country.
Wait what?? What does that have to do with this? By that logic, why don't you compare today's women with the women in those times? Uss samay ye Ander ka bhoot kaha chala jata hai🤣?
Also, fun fact: Mata Sita didn't choose her Groom, it was Earned by lord ram who lifted the shiv dhanush, that's basic knowledge you fatherless feminists 🤣
He means to be conscious while promoting a message....
Neither did you read Kamasutra, vedas, but go around preaching like an Idiot about how it promotes nudity blah blah🤣....
@@Rudra-rf5cn Bro what I'm saying is if you read some ancient texts.You can read some stories of shivaji maharaj. He never let anti women art to be propogated when he was fighting the mughals. Mughals through art and culture corrupted our culture. And their starting point was anti women sentiments through literature and art. We cannot let that happen again when our nation is finally rising.
When has it become a fashion to portray people with mental problems as heroes! Both the director and the character has some serious issues. Anger taking over one's senses and unnatural obsession/love are considered mental issues.
Avg Twitter warriors who said he is a hero .
Exactly. I was always confused what to call vanga's characters. Media call them toxic. I feel something else. Self obsession and lack of emotional control belongs to mental health categories. Definitely if one has them beyond a level, such people had problem. It would be better if the character really shown as a mental illness sufferer. But, they show such traits as if they were super heroic. People who can acknowledge them had no problem. But, the problem with people who can't differentiate and try to imply.
@@bindu6515 I feel, using the words such as 'Toxic masculinity' is actually misleading and dangerous since it has a positive connotation from at least one perspective, which could be appealing for people who lack the ability to comprehend the actual psychology of such behaviour.
The whole point of this movie was for us to look at it as a society that "respects women" and say that it's bad. Instead we help it make millions. Then we wonder why life is miserable.
It seems that the society doesnt respect women, otherwise they wont enjoy and make it a super hit. Good thing is that it can help filter out and highlight the type of men to avoid.
respect has no gender
The response from the movie team is actually absurd Talking like a true twitter user lmao
Oh this UA-cam user is such a smart and matured guy
Oh wow such a mature comment in the comments section
I bet Vanga wrote it himself.
Wheres thw lie tho? I bet feminists would have cheered on in the movie theatres while watching such a scene. I saw it as a movie , what did you see it as?
@@d_pratik1if some women would've cheered for such a scene then they're wrong. Why play the kiddy blame game
Slapping and abuse is smtg always portrayed in Indian cinema. It's disgusting. I always ask my husband why there's always that casual slapping of characters like it's normal. Gory, gangsters and extreme violence.
Because they exist in real life too.
@@curious_one1156 yes, they should be portrayed, because those exist in real lives too, unfortunately. But in no way, those should be glorified.
Societal violence can be portrayed but physical abuse should be avoided as it gets glorified by default and then everyone wants to ape it on the weaker gender in the society that only nourishes further violence in society
Those 'fing ering and sha gging' on Gangs of Wasseypur and Mirzapur are feeling annoyed seeing 1% of same things shown in ANIMAL. 😂
Very true and eye opening speech. Loved how he explained it all, such simplicity yet courageous personality is needed in todays generation.
Surprisingly Rocky and rani was the only film that promoted love peace friendship equality and focused on some very important subjects in India it was also culturally apt and was not trying to follow violence terrorism and Hate
12 th fail.
@@gouranggehlot4896Yeah 12th fail is also a inspiring movie with great acting. Wheareas Rocky and Rani also was a reall nice family friendly movie with values and love towards family members even and overcoming acceptance towards their indiffrences. Both are good movies but are of different genre.
A converted muskin Javed who is not even musIeem according to arabs should show mirror to his son Farhan for making Mirzapur that has worst scenes of 'women abu ses' in any OTT series.
Very true said by great contemporary lyricist 😊❤. It's time for audience to decide which type of movies seen by them instead of complaining to makers. Today's the youth is the major driving factor or attractive lure for such misogynist or any anti social media which can affect mind of their without using their own mindset they rely completely on just 2 hrs movies.
I'm curious why you are assuming that you are smart?
‼️‼️ I just want to know,
Why all Alpha - Sigma Man, always needs a Women to prove him Alpha beta Gama sigma Whatever male..🤬
Why Alpha never become Alpha without humilating women .?🤔🤔🤬
@@s.z3717 absolutely right 👍
@@SenseiSaitama21 dear sir what do u want to prove !
@@Y.kyadav65 dear mam forget it, I'm done with biased chapris
Agree 100% with Javed Akhtar. It’s a shame that a movie like Animal was a superhit! 😢
The Legendary , Iconic Writer and Lyricist Javed Saab has a Valid Point. 👌👌
zyada dimag nahi lagane kaa ,torrent se download karne ka, ranvir ko gaali dene ka ,movie delete kardena ka shimmmmmpleeee😂😂
I watched the movie because it was ironically funny for me. _Especially_ the "alpha male" scenes lmao. Also, when a movie is more about appealing to the largest audience possible instead of the writers expressing their actual ideas, only then does the movie start to go bad.
The problem is that people in general (regardless of gender) take movies way too literal. Violence and abuse should not be encouraged or showcased regardless of the gender. Writers and directors do have responsibility. Just like how majority of Indian men were highly offended by the movie Darling that’s how women feel about Animal. Whether people like it or not movies like Kabir and Animal are problematic period.
Then again, in Darling, the women had a very solid reason of getting back at the man like that, he kept them terrified, abused for years, ruining all their dreams and any chance of a happy and fulfilled lives. But here in Animal, the character of Ranbir Kapoor is just toxic towards women for no apparent reason, he just controls, abuses and breaks their trust for no fault of the women. So, I think, comparing that joke in the name of movie with movies like Darling, Bulbul etc. is a dire insult to justice. And, really I don't know why that movie was named as animals, because that is an insult to the animals too.
@@user-bw8yn3zr1sAgree...❤
I totally agree with your point. Darling definitely showed how the wife was being abused for so long but what I was saying was there was such a huge issue regarding that movie and now that women are speaking out on animal there have been such lame arguments and justification, and I am not comparing the two but I hope you understand what I am getting at.
@@user-bw8yn3zr1s
Javed Akhtar is 10x experienced than whole Animal team. If he is disappointed, then there really is a problem. The Animal team must understand it.
One day, This Vanga guy will end up like RGV
That will be a great honour for Vanga.
All these critics and commenters didn't really understand the movie.Everyone seems to miss the fact that the title is not "sanskari" but "Animal" that means the main protagonist is irrational, emotional and illogical, it is a story of such an animalistic man and nothing more.
Everyone on the internet assumed that viewers are immature and wont know difference btw a hero and victim, but Sandeep vanga believed his audience to have that basic intelligence.
@@vinaybandi4470 do you agree on his statement of Slapping partner? he said that off screen btw
@@Uehehdjdjsh are you aware that couples slap each other during sexual intercourse? And coming to Animal where is the concept of equality, why is no one mentioning the deaths of hundreds of men what's with all these chappri arguments 😂
@@Uehehdjdjsh Is it Okay if a women slaps a man? (PS: just asking. I am strictly a verbal person.)
@@Uehehdjdjsh hm is it ok to show killing scenes of men in films? And aren't there a few slaps in sex?
Ye feminism khtm kahe ni hota be.. Abey itna seriously kon leta hai movie ko. It just a movie. Ek movie ko dekhkr life ni chlti. Sabke apni apni problems hai life m. Tumhe gyan dene ka moka ni mila kya bhaut Dino se. 😂😂
It's funny to see how the feminists and simps are getting melted down in the commen section to the response of Animal's team.
People wont criticise adultry showing in web series instead justify saying its her choice. But if similar maniac story is in favour of men then everyone takes up mic .
It's 2024, the lead of the film doesn't need to play good adarsh guy anymore. Filmmakers are exploring grey characters more, audience need to be mature enough not to follow any movie character.
Then they should be mature enough to take all the criticism which will come along with it and not acting like a narcissist.
Well said kush.
@@R_t-99then you should be mature enough to judge movies on the basis of movies not on your morality
@@Misyognitic-king anyone can judge anything . If you want freedom of speech then don't expect it to be only for yourself.
@@R_t-99 I mean forcing your own morality and sense of righteousness to someone else and acting just as angry to that person when that person don't really buy your self righteousness in such a way people don't stop talking bout it doesn't make both sides exactly good.
Why are all these people against Animal..let the public decide
The Animal team got down to a new level of absurdity and narrow mindset with such comment to such a lagend writer..if you are making an "art" , you also must be graceful enough to take all kind of criticism..n Javed sir is not bashing the "movie" (seriously can't even call that piece of garbage a real movie) , but no one can deny how much the indian audience are influenced by cinema..so yes this kind movie can really be damaging for the youth..
His each and every word has lot off depth and precious and i believe to understand the depth of these words one should have deeper understanding of their surroundings and the elements that are essential for a balanced and prosperous society.
Yes I totally agree with him...as a woman and mother od girl child..I feel insecure and its a disturbing trend..all smoking drinking alcohol, just from trailer I felt so negetive that have not seen the movie..wrong message to men..yes I have seen Sam Bahadur movie..very good message how to he treats his wife
If people are not getting his point of view then they are ‘ sick’!
What about the sensor board. Should the responsibility not lie on the sensor board?
Censor board exists to only see if the ruling govt is shown in a bad light!
censor board should not exist for movie releases. who are they to decide what art is or not. Hating or loving the movie should lie with the audience
@morijin5568 grow up. Don't forget cinema is a major platform that can impact average human being in many ways and every art form can be used in both positive and negative ways, to create imbalance In society or to empower the society.
@@morijin5568wht are you talking about! Censor board exists to monitor the cultural, moral, political, psychological impact of movies on the society, our communities and in turn our nation. Mindless clones won't understand this. The success of this movie is a reflection of how mentally/morally/psychologically sick our society is.
He's a knowledgeable man .
I don't understand why people make fun of him
People shouldn't idolize this type of film & characters,grow up,in our culture women is Beloved Mother,Respected sister,Caring Wife,Loving daughter,This type of wanna be cool trends of Alpha characters can destroy our cultural values 🙏
Animal movie's last 4 seconds scene is for Javed types. 😂
Totally Agree with Javad sa. about movie Animal
Where is Censor Board in today's society 👎🏼
PRASOON JOSHI Sa.(Chairman) Are you really in your chair...!!!
Wake up Prasoon ji...
Janta remember's your "Tare zameen par"
It's amazing that in a movie where men are killed in the most violent way every 10 minutes people are complaining about an insult a woman faced!
@user-rw1pb5rp3l The women getting insulted is a spy sent to kill him, what are you even talking about! How would you treat someone who tried to kill you?
Also are you okay if Ranbir's character made women who are not a significant part of the movie to lick his boots? Of course not. Please understand you're biased. Self reflection is good it is not good to project always
@user-rw1pb5rp3l Let me get this straight, men getting killed is okay but insulting a woman who tried to kill you is fine?
He is absolutely right, this kind of film being super hit only reflects the mindset of the society we live in
Sandeep Reddy vanga The fire....ANIMAL 👌👌👌👌
The pause this guy gives and waits for the claps... is this paid????
Okay SO FIRSTLY I WANNA ASK A Q. HOW MANY OF YOU HAVE WATCHED ANIMAL MOVIE? Secondly, Applause to him for what he said this is what we always discuss at home but now a days its like a compitition between director about whose movie can create bigger controversy. Every single movie releasing they are including something which can create a debate and this is what NEGATIVE PUBLICITY/PROMOTION is. People know that movie is having bad scenes but they want to see it themselves just to troll it later. Because of this movie breaks record and the makers gets their profit why will they care what msg they are giving to society its only about money.
THERE IS A LOT OF DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ARJUN REDDY AND ANIMAL
Javed akhtar is right ❤
Says a man who cheated on his wife. If you can disrespect your wife and mother of your two kids, you dont get to be mad at a fictional character meant to be watched by adult audiences. Animal is a typical movie promoting a toxic , mentally unstable man as the " alpha". However, men who pretend to be feminists and then cause such pain to their wife and children should refrain from an opinion. Also if his current wife had said this, i would say the same about her. Best if celebrities refrain from commenting on anything normal. Their disconnect from reality is mind-boggling.
True although I hv not seen the movie because of the review I got. One shouldn't promote morally incorrect things and degrading woman is the worst that can be done to society. It's our responsibility to boycott such movies, as an audience.
His son was the producer of Mirzapur. And yet we didn't see him criticising anything about it. The series contained vulgar language, extreme violence, inappropriate display of relationship etc etc!!!!!
ANIMAL team's Perfect response to those evil hypocrites who follow a cuIt book that is destroying the world to this day instead of reforming their book, virtue signal others on certain scenes.😂
Says the one whose son produced mirzapur
I totally agree with Javed sahab words on this specific matter.
this is why the name of the movie is Animal and he has shown how is he an Animal from his characters.
To all the comment section and viewers. The last 3 seconds of Animal credit scene was enough. 😂
Fact to all ANIMAL haters: @kooalabeats5388 hey haIaIa putra, concept of puja dates back to Ramayan and even Satyuga. Bhagwan Shri Ram ji made Shiv Lingam to do puja, it is known as Rameshwaram today. Don't glorify your invading community mughaIs/musIeims to toe your agenda.
If films like Animal and Kabir Singh continue to become blockbusters in Indian cinema then it is sure that the maximum percentage of India's youth and movie-watchers are doomed. The main problem is that Sandeep Reddy Vanga has always been glorifying wrong deeds in his film which it definitely wrong. Salute to Mr. Javed Akhtar for such a wonderful speech!
If you don't like something, just remember you're not even their target audience.
As per your logic , there won't be any good or bad movie.
I think he is just making comments what he found on internet /SM..n yet has not watched the film. Rannvijay Singh is not an hero, first of all. He is an anti-hero. Noone is idolizing that character. The movie is hit because of the performances ( thanks to marketing/PR) . People are watching it for Ranbir.
Javed Akhtar vs. team Animal both have their right to voice their opinion and either parties should respect. If we are biased we should stop calling ourselves a democracy, In a democracy everyone has their right to voice their opinion and artistic freedom freely.
The audacity to say "writers of your calibre" to Javed Akhtar lmao baitho beta....
"Society" never understands what is right and what is wrong. In times when life was simple, it was because they did not have sources of information, and storytellers could get away with simple films.
Javed sahab you're getting old..not only physically but mentally 😢
If you don't want any negative comments stop making movies. Animal team are narcissist, just take it as review and move on.
It's their film, dude. Of course they are going to react. Remember, the genuine ones are always the ones who get pissed.
I mean your statement apply more on the so called 'reviewers'. They are the ones who took a movie so seriously that they had to put on a social white knight complex to show off their cheap virtue signalling.
This is a message from someone whose son produced Mirzapur 😂
Most of the public has zero awareness, they follow the hype watch the movie, come out with hyped reviews. There is a herd mentality which controls people. Just because Ranbir Kapoor and Bobby Deol who look a certain way are playing deep down sick characters it is applauded by viewers who have no innate ability to discern and see what is being done.
Ranvijay-Assaulting a woman's dignity and betraying his wife and call himself SIGMA
Shri RAM-Respecting even the shadow of a woman and fighting Mighty Ravan for his beloved wife.
CHOOSE YOUR IDOLS WISELY!...
Bollywood is showing more insecurity and resistance towards Directors who dare to do different. Especially if they are from South. Javed Ji may please do a webseries on movies that have regressive themes and depictions originated in Bollywood. The censor board has cleared this movie and he must respect that. Several movies like DON must also face similar scrutiny.
Selective feminism and selective justice by these wokes
exactly.. they never spoke about rape scenes, catcalling in their movies n now they have problem.. thing is sandeep is overtaking Bollywood.. also what abouut ssr case n deugs n casting couch😂😂
The problem with this movie is they wanted to make it some artistic piece and ended up mixing it with cheap masala to get big ammount in return and now all this chaos
I think both side are right to certain extent with Javed Akhtar being the better.
The main part people missed was the context. The character doesn't ask this to a random women or his wife but to a woman who came with the intention of killing him, and now is saying that she loves him.
Absolutely right sir❤️🙏
My non existent respect for makers of Animal movie has now become negatively non existent..if that's a thing😂
I completely agree with him. The fact that pathetic and sick movies like Animal are becoming super hit reveals character of people these days. Even Kabir Singh was just like Animal, mindless violence and obsession with lust. And it is so unfortunate to see good movies not getting acknowledgment.
What about your daughters lust stories sir? The fault isn’t just of audience but also the makers. Na rahegi baaz na bajegi baansuri