I already know this didn't happen and I'm 4 seconds in while typing this. Plus, it would be illegal for the Professor to purposely try to target and disprove a student's religion
Then you better tell the professor that because there are professors on Earth that don't believe in the existence of God, yet actually hold a conversation WITH students concerning religion.
well it doesnt mean it wouldnt happen but we dont know what professor it was, what school it was, what student it was, we are meant to believe a student of university would be able at a relatively young age to use einsteins argument at his favor, i guess thats the point of this video, we have to belive that this happened, but he is wrong on 1 thing, death isnt the abcsence of life, you dont call the unborn dead yet they dont have life, death is the end of life as we know it, not the end of energy though
Yeah, this was pretty obviously created by someone who has never set foot in an actual college classroom. The people who make up this garbage about how terrible college is, have obviously never darkened the doorway of an actual merit based institution. Maybe one of those religious indoctrination schools like Liberty or Bob Jones University but not a real school.
Basically what did happen was a professor asked kids if god exists why did he create evil? A student raised his hand and asked if he knew what darkness was,and then he said darkness is only an absence of light,and evil is the absence of god. The student was Albert Einstein
@@rudolfcsampai9549 Actually no he was not. He said that he believes that there has to be a higher force that has created perfection like our world is,look it up!
That was the wrong way to handle that. If the teacher is an atheist fine. If he wants to preach about that, fine, but he shouldn't try to tell students god doesn't exist. I'm not Christian btw. I'm an atheist myself. But it's still the persons choice to follow a religion.
Gumi Swimming true but I’m catholic and think that there has to be some sort of God or creator because even if we evolved from monkeys than where did the monkeys come from??
iiDogeKingii - Roblox and more random letters I guess not but I’m not that good at it. I am working on it. My average is 29 and my personal best is 18. What are yours? I also use a cyclone boys so it’s not smooth.
Rubik's Gaming i am pretty much a beginner. I know intuitive f2l but it slows me down because I need more practice. My best is somewhere between 30 and 40 and my average is like 50. I mainly practice 2x2, but I like big cubes like 6x6
This story is fake. A professor would never debate a student about religion unless the student asked it. Edit: please stop bombarding me with "my teacher did." I now understand that it does happen, I had just never seen it before as teachers aren't allowed to do that in my country.
Yes it is. So are all of these "little christian beating the big bad atheist" videos. This one in the lower level of believable, but it is a little better than most. It;s time to get some real script writers that can give out something that is, at least, in the realms of the believable.
HarmLessBush Gaming and even if they were allowed to, most atheists don't care what you believe in, and teachers want respect from their students, and spontaneously questioning someone's beliefs for no reason isn't a very good way to gain respect.
They left out the part where Albert Einstein rose from the grave, walked in the classroom, handed the student a crisp $100 bill and everyone applauded.
@@kakmaster6945 as a christian, I think most of the bible stories were meant to be metaphors and lessons on life, but I also have the decency to leave a good joke to what it is; a joke
We don't see the conversation, just a lot of writing. We aren't told their names. All we are told is a nice story "proving" a point of view. If it's not made up, it might as well be.
Professor: God is not real. Student: He's real. Professor: How can you say so? Can you see God? Student: No. Professor: Can you touch God? Student: No. Professor: Then he's not real. Student: Can you see your brain? Professor: No. Student: Can you touch you're brain? Professor: No. Student: Then you don't have a brain. It's just a joke please don't do this in your class.
Everyone is talking about how this is obviously fake, but no one is saying why. This "philosophy" professor is the worst philosophy professor I've ever encountered. If this conversation had happened in a class, I would have dropped it in a second. Not because I was offended by the professor's beliefs but because of the professor's lack of knowledge and understanding of philosophy.
To be honest im stuck on this lack of knowledge in biology, and the sciences. What class is this where the teacher knows nothing about philosophy but teaches it, and nothing about biology, but teaches it too.
Biggest wars in the history: Pewdiepie vs T-series Germany vs Poland and France Spinosaurus fanboys vs T. Rex fanboys Flat earthers vs round earthers Christians vs Atheists Please like this
@@Flawlessx69 they can still be killed by something that means that they are not immortal at all , that is so called *death* ...when something stops functioning , dissapears etc , so youre not right , how does your arogance feel now ?
have you seen your own brain? have YOU touched you brain? smelled your brain? tasted your brain? felt your brain? seen your brain? heard your brain? No?? then that means you don't have one
Can we get 2000 subscribers with no videos? idiotic comment lmao we can prove the brain because we know it is there because of proof but god we never saw him we never. felt him you may feel loved but phycology can explain that
@@antonionacionreluya8707 then what do you think is a brain then? By the way do you know who's the student is? They say he's Einstein! Are you brainier than Einstein?
@@troytrillions9125 So is your argument that Einstein was smart, therefore this argument is smart? Stephen Hawking was smart, he didn’t believe in God, so does God therefore not exist? I wouldn’t make that argument myself either, because that’s not something you can use to determine truth.
well cold is absence of kinetic energy of our molecules and it's a lose term something is colder in relation to something like 0 is colder than 1 but 0 I hotter than -1 darkness is just absence of photons human brain one is just stupid and I beliv ein evolution sooo yeah no but we cant also say definitely that god doesnt exist but we also cant be definite in his or her or whatever it is existence so what was wrong in this video other than brain and evolution one
So is it a coincidence that in the Bible god said let there be light, which created the universe. That completely correlates to your belief. Now let me say this, is it possible to take nothing & create a book with Intricate pages & colorful pictures & complex sentences. Is it possible to create a book like that from nothing. No it is not. So what is DNA, DNA is OUR book, full of complex instructions to create us, it’s not possible to create that from nothing which means there has to be a god, & in the Bible it says, “if you seek god you will find him” so if you haven’t yet keep looking because he is there I love you
finally, someone that doesn't post something that they know will make people angry. jeez I mean what is wrong with some of these people just dont post if you dont agree
Well this is not correct, they changed the conversation a little and so the meaning changed by A LOT. It is mostly true until where he stopped talking about cold as absence of heat... See, I will judge this because this is based of a REAL conversion between Einstein and his middle school teacher. You can make up your story but it is not right to change an existing one! What actually was said is that “cold is the absence of heat” and it was applied to the concept of “evil is the absence of good” which Einstein said means “evil is the parts of the universe that are yet untouched by god”. Basically there was no debate on god existence in the first place, the teacher was Christian and made the point that god is evil and that is why Einstein argued with him. The teacher did not pick on him, Einstein just interrupted and said this. Guys, don’t try to change history! Don’t retell it in your ways, the truth will come up eventually!
J Hedgje HE DOES NOT “LET IT HAPPEN” THAT IS SATIN. SATIN DOES THESE HORRIBLE THINGS TO MAKE POEPLE THINK GOD IS MEAN AND DOES EVIL AND HURTS PEOPLE. IT IS ALL SATIN. Why would God purposefully hurt people? You think he just sits back on his chair and watches people die? Really?
Bijan Soularie those are two words made by us to define the variability in numbers (which is another thing we created) and the presence and absence in different objects (and I don't want to mention all of the names science uses to relate to different things in objects according to different theories which is also created by us). So it's a mess of thousands of thousands of theories we say everyday. Technically speaking it is, after science took ages to come to this day.
He talks about dark not existing. Genesis 1:4, God saw that the light was good, and God separated the light from the darkness. One of the most iconic verses counters the students's whole argument.
It's not up to anyone to disprove if God real or not. A believer is making a claim that this particular entity is real, it's up to him/her to prove it. A none believer makes no such claims. They are just asking for testable scientific evidence. Just like if someone comes to you and claims that they saw a dragon, you would ask them for evidence. It would be not up to you to disprove of the dragon.
@@blockbyblock4078 True, but sometimes it's also on the non-believers like me to disprove it, and its simple to disprove the omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent deity by simply questioning someone with the Omnipotent Paradox, Omniscience and Free Will Paradox, and the Problem of Evil argument.
Bentoo So all we would,have to do is tell you that God exists, but you aren't allowed to look at him. Your argument for the existence of the professor's brain are identical to Joseph Smith's argument for the existence of the gold plates of Mormon. They are real, too, but you aren't allowed to see them.
"not allowed" isn't the right word here. (I'm talking about christian religion, because I don't know others rules)christian religion tells us that god created people as free creatures and if there is something that god doesn't allow us, that means it is a lie, so be careful what you write next time and one more thing, there's no need to take my comment seriously, because it was a joke.
Stag Gamers yeah please tell us why your principal broke the law and kicked you out of school for arguing with him about God’s existence or did you mean to say that you left the school because he could not be disproved either way your story would be a lie as long as you lived in America at least.
@@c.yr0623 the point is that u can't prove it, it's kinda based on the simulation theory which indeed could possibly be true as there could have been a much smarter civilization, basically the only way to prove it is for u or a camera to be there but u could still argue that since someone or something is there, it will make a sound then
You see? He contradicted himself in concluding that the professor has no brain. He most likely took it in his biology class that every human has a brain. If the professor has no brain, neither does he.
It's kind of sad that we humans will argue over petty things like what one should believe or not believe in. So person X is an atheist or person Y is a Christian or person Z is a Muslim, so what? Is it that hard for us a species to support one another regardless of our beliefs or lack thereof? At the end of the day, we share the same land and the same sky. (This comment will probably be overlooked, but in all honesty I really hope that it touches and affects each and every one of us.)
@@crazyviolin7954 Um... I don't speak for all atheists, but I only question his existence... and I admit that I can't know for sure if he is real or not. And as long as no one tries to force their religion onto me (in any way), I have no problems with their beliefs
When a sponge has water on it is considered wet, if there is an absence of water it is considered dry and since dry is the opposite of wet I have the right to believe that this entire argument is flawed
@@flynnrider2871 if something didn't create god, god wouldn't exist. And if god existed? There wouldn't be any need for millions of people online using logical fallacies and manipulation tactics to try and convince others to join the "do everything I say, give me 10% of your income and cut your foreskin off" cult.
@@Chronicskillness God wasn’t created. God always existed. God also made time. The creation isn’t above its creator. So if God made time then he isn’t effected by it.
@@flynnrider2871 Here's what you can't do: you can't use logic to try and prove your argument... then when logic is used to falsify your argument... try to use logic by saying "logic doesn't apply to my argument". And include a beyond irrational claim that even if true, doesn't dismiss my point. Like I said: a bunch of logical fallacies in a trenchcoat.
Dark On Me of course, the student keeps telling about the absence of... and her conclusion is 'Faith' but isn't faith the fucking absence of the term 'knowing'
Sjamiell _ is science knowing then? Do people know that the Big Bang is real? If we came from apes then why do we have a tail bone, which scientists explain is “evolution” but apes don’t have tails. But do what ever floats your boat. You don’t believe in religion then okay, let’s not argue anymore, make love not war.
Eric h i don't put any stock into fake vids and had i known this was a Christian propaganda stunt to begin with i wouldn't have bothered but after seeing these fools talk on here i just had to put in MY 2 cents lol
The sad part is that this is such a simple and antiquated outlook on BOTH sides i could've crushed either argument lol seems like Einstein SHOULD have had better sense at a college level but MAYBE his autism didn't really kick in till later in life lol
super AGP. Sure. They can believe what they like but why lie about what non-believers think or say. Makes you wonder how gullible they must be if they think this crap is a real story.
That's no science teacher. That's what a science teacher in a Christian's perfect world would say. In reality, it is common knowledge that cold nor darkness exist, because they are words to describe the absence of heat and light, respectively. We can prove the existence of light and heat through observation and experimentation with the help of the scientific method. Good and evil, however, is completely arbitrary. What heat is to one person is the same to everyone. What light is to one person is the same to everyone. Good is arbitrary. Good is subjective. And evil is not the absence of good. Because you cannot measure good nor evil, you cannot say that evil is the absence of good. And to say that God is good, and to take it one step further and say that evil is the absence of God, would be severely egotistical and misleading.
We don’t just know about god from books we feel him and see know he’s there in are hearts and minds but you will only feel him if you accept him you can’t say people who believe in god are weak if anything there strong there stronger than anyone else as they are feeling even seeing or just believing in something so huge that someone with a weak brain could even understand god you must be open minded willing to accept him and you will feel him you will feel your answers to your questions everything that happens is becuase it’s part of gods plan so don’t say something unless you have s backup to that and you wonder why we have sicknesses and death and disasters it’s all one big trial in gods plan so we can return back to him and live with him and become like him he doesn’t do it to us to make us miserable he does it as s trial to make us prove are sleds to home to prove we will not be tempted by Satan as we did chose god in heaven we all will have 1 major trial in are life and a few small ones and if you can get through those and fight through Satan’s temptations and follow gods path you will live with him now I will not comment on anything else all I haft to say is that’s what I believe
The Jumpy Guitar Gamers read and understood about the Bible. God created humans, and Satan was an angel. There is one commandment that God gives us. And we called it a choice. Are you hear me...... then Satan choice to lie and ask to God to live his life in the dark side and God said ok, because he give us the choice from the beigning. Sorry for my English. Guys learn how to understand the word of God instead of reading without understanding and commenting without knowledge. Which thing has humans created from nothing, you see nothing we can created from nothing. But everything that we created is something from the Gods created things. Look Soil Oil Gas Gold Silver Mettalics Zincs Papers You know we can’t created something from nothing but we can created everything from something from that God createds for us.
We have seen microevolution which is just adaptation, but there has not been any evidence of macroevolution which is when a species turns into another species. Edit: Microevolution doesn't contradict Christianity nor does it condradict biogensis which is a scientific law. Macroevolution contradicts both of those things.
Plenty of evidence in philosophy to say there is a God. That's why in philosophy it's an academic standard to know the argument, and we continue to have this conversation about the exsitance of God.
@@SawkTheFighter13 I don't know of anyone that would not consider philosophical evidence not to be evidence. Evidence is evidence regardless of how you feel about it.
Cold technically isn't the absence of heat. It's when an object or particles absorb energy from it's surroundings (endothermic). And heat is when energy is exerted into the surroundings (exothermic). So basically, cold can be measured by the amount of energy the object absorbs.
Allied Sorry, but you're wrong, Don't mix Heat and Temperature together, they are not the same thing, Cold is a colloquial term in temperature that refers to the slow motion of the particles in a system, and it can't be measured, because when you say that you are going to measure cold, you're actually measuring the amount of energy per particle (Heat). So, sorry but Cold is actually the absence of Heat (energy) and not the opposite of heat.
Eternal Abyss actually, cold is, in fact, is the amount of particles in the air. Get a sponge. Put it in water. Is the water gone? Or is it just in the sponge? How can heat be gone, if it's just in the particles itself?
I just want to say this, the definition of God is that he is supernatural. So when anyone try to measure or find evidence, facts and proofs of God using a scientific method is illogical, how can you proof a supernatural beings using a scientific method? It's like measuring distance with liters or grams, *YOU WILL NEVER GET ANYWHERE WITH THAT METHOD* And also trying to find *direct* proof for God is also out of the question, since we can only go so far as the observable universe, for us to directly observe God that means God has to be within our plain of vision, that means in our universe. If God Is in our universe then he isn't God since he will be effected by time, space and matter: God doesn't get effected by that, so we have to look for indirect evidence
Shadow My life’s a mess this is another concept we human cannot comprehend, we can talk about nothingness, but we can never understand it and it's true. But, think about the claim you made, no one said that God takes on a physical form , we actually believe that God is an essence, so if we said that God has a physical form outside of the universe then it's paradoxical. In addition when I said "not in our universe" I was referring to the realm, we believe that God created 7 heavens and the 7th is the one we live in, maybe the entirety of the 7th heaven is this universe, maybe it's this universe but it contains more than one heavens we don't know the exact details, and when I said God cannot be in our universe I didn't mean it literally I'm sorry for misleading, I meant as in physically. And finally to conclude, you said because God is not in our universe (which was partly my mistake for making it unclear) then he cannot exist, as I explained above not physically but spiritually, then what is our universe expanding into then? If it's complete nothingness how is something becoming nothing?
Shadow My life’s a mess your problem is that you’re thinking that everything that occurs around us has some explanation. If we don’t know the mechanism, we don’t believe in it according to what you’re saying. Then, if you can’t explain it, it’s not true? You simply aren’t intelligent enough to know that you aren’t intelligent. Not everything in this world is explainable, and if you still disagree, it’s just your ego.
Why is everyone hating? If you're not a Christian that's your own business, but don't be going on about something you're not even passionate about. I have been made fun of at school every year for being a Christian, but I still hold onto my Faith. ☺
I think there were answer to the questions the student didnt answer and his answers to the questions he did answer were a bit silly and could have been better answered. If this ever gets to 7 likes, I'll write the answers he should have said on this comment but I dont think it will. We'll see...
@@KARTHIKPANCH97 im having fun with replying to some of the arguments here my favorite is you cant prove hes not real if that applied I could say im a alien from 948757 using advanced spoofle technology to mimic all human things and its true because you cant prove its not
On my father's death bed he knew that I was undecided on this subject because he was dying and God wasn't helping. My dad said people generally dont believe if they can't see it. He asked "do you see the wind?" I said no. He said "God is a feeling as with everything we believe in" I asked why God isn't helping? He replied "was I a good father?" Yes of course I said!!. He replied "life is a test and I've passed son, God needs me". I'm not terribly religious but I do feel there's something greater. We wont know until we are ready I guess.
Mahin Paudel who says God is a he? Who says there is more than one god? As I've said in the past, people think they know the meaning of everything when clearly we dont. You will, we will after we die. Questions will be answered or we realize that what's important down here isnt. Such as the meaning of life. What we have is a gift. Use it and stop with the my my. It's our God. It's not a possession you can have.
Mahin Paudel that's what you believe then that's ok. My statements are just statements and beliefs. I'm not terribly religious myself and not want to be one of those pushy opinionated people. Thanks for your input and thanks for no hostility. I like hearing other opinions because this subject is vast and also very opinionated.
Not to rain on your parade, but wind and God are no where close to the same. We physically feel wind, we can measure and quantify it, and we can explain it scientifically.
Ian Parrish here's a thought. What if God was physical? What if were all wrong. We all see it differently. God looks human? Maybe God is everything. Such as what your standing on or looking at or even better, the wind you feel and we can measure. But, what do I know.......I know nothing until I die and even then it could just be giant pit I'm falling down just like bill and Ted's bogus adventure.
All philosophy professors must know the simple rules of argument. With the argument shown it seems that the professor knows little of philosophy, I know all schools must not allow a person applying to become a professor to be a professor without knowing the basics. When having a stand in your argument you must give facts to make a true conclusion. When given with premises, the conclusion may either be true or valid. VALIDITY AND TRUE ARE NOT THE SAME. Validity is just based on the premises you say which could be your opinions, but a true conclusion is dependent on expanded, correct, and educated observations. This is why doctors carefully check you for them to be able to diagnose you correctly and cure you, but if they look at you and make guesses which they think are correct(opinion) then they may give you the wrong diagnosis and it will be difficult for them to cure you. At this point scientists, philosophers, and even other free thinkers out there are still observing to prove the existence of a god. This is why no conclusions must be made yet without having the facts. Before making a counterargument on this, PLEASE DO A RESEARCH FIRST ON PHILOSOPHY THAN MAKING YOUR OWN PREMISES AND COME UP WITH A CONCLUSION
Student: do u have sense Professor: yes Student: can you feel your sense Professor: no Student: can u taste, see, smell and hear your sense Professor: no Student: then science proves u have no sense
O A S then why did god create him? If he knows everything And he is perfect.he know people are killing each other because of this.then is he such good as I might say he is
@@lissettecastro4742 God created Satan aka. Lucifer as an angel of light, he stood by God because he was very important. God gives everyone freewill including angels. If God didn't give anyone a freewill then Lucifer wouldn't have betrayed God. Lucifer was jealous of God and wanted to be just like him. He took most of the Angels with him. God knows that the Devils days are timed. He is putting us to the test by giving us a freewill to do whatever. If you pass... you will recieve the most greatest gift.... EVERLASTING LIFE. I cause you no harm brother or sister. I am saying the end is near 💖
Queen_ OG Also, because of when Adam sinned, he gave over the earth (which was originally ruled by man) to the devil. So now it’s the devils world which is why bad things happen
@queen Satan did not wanted to be god he was asked by god with the angels to prostrate to adam "the creation of the first human" but he refused claiming that he is better that him therefore god fired him from heaven and promised him hell at the end of time so satan is trying so hard to take with him as many people as he can since we are the reason behind him disobeying the one and only God
I have a sneeeeaaaking suspicion that this is made up because no professor would be as stupid as to say dark exists after that mini rant on the lack of cold. Let's not excuse the shitty production quality with font color fucked up, the same picture in the background the entire video, and the pure cringe of the parentheses. This is completely made up and it seems nobody even watched the video before uploading it to find errors.
Without a classroom or even the classroom floor beneath, this kind of is happening. Check out other threads Debate, conversation and unfortunately arguments have been going on before I've been on planet.
I believe Mr Einstein, may he Rest in Peace and may GOD be with his Family!!! Thank U FATHER for Blessing me with him, also said something about the universe and everything in it is just way too Perfect for it to come together by shear happenstance, therefore there Must be a DIVINE ARCHITECT(not verbatim).
The professor in not a smart atheist, an smart one would know that. Ask these same questions to Neil he would give you the most gracious and mind opening answers!
Facts And Myths true... the professor didnt6 get his degree... obviously.. anyone knows that you can't smell taste see the brain if they're inside a head... you need to remove it first if you want to smell taste and see the brain....
Its a great example the brain to GOD because we can only touch feel see or smell our brain through some processes so is how we can see GOD, knowing that you have a brain without seeing is a mystery but you still have faith that you have brain so is it with the existence of GOD is still a mystery our way of thinking is just limited because we are under sin as i have heard we only use 5% of our brain power so if we overcome sin then GOD opens our minds and unveil the mystery of his existence the same way we do a ct scan or breaking our skull to see if we have a brain
hey im everything Bea Gamboa well your probably wrong. We humans use 100% of our brain. Using 5% is a myth. To keep us alive our brain should 100%. Have you ever heard of subconscious mind? Thats what keeping you alive.
The goddamn evolution argument. ( Disclaimer : Im Christian/agnostic and Im also studying anthropology.) YES YOU CAN SEE EVOLUTION, THERE IS SUCH A THING AS FOSSILS.
susancdwpg Honestly what I dont get is, you can use theories like the Big Bang to say something had to have caused it ( like a god ). But many Christians believe those theories to be poisonous in some way to their ideas. We dont know how quarks and atoms came into being. But personally I dont think anyone can argue that religion is not manmade. Yes there may be a god but its probably not our god, they way we see him. If theres anything that resembles a god, I am one hundred percent sure it is beyond human interpretation.
Look, if there is such a thing as God. A "person" who created all the universe. All the quarks, all the Quantum rules.. I mean, praying and all this is massive bullshit because our planet is definitely not a central of universe and God couldn't care less about us. If you were immortal and all this, and created universe, would you care about some little things praying to bunch of Gods and not even one of them is right?
Ondřej Foltýn that shows your character you care less about ppl or things. I don't see why a powerful God wouldn't care for his creation. it's his. why is it unthinkable for God to care? we humans even with the limited power and life we have ,care for things we create. because God created all things and cares for all things is the reason it makes him so profound and loving according the Christian beliefs. Your sentiment though are expressed in the Bible: what is man that you should care for him. his life is but vapor.
A O Yes but first things first, there are billions of us, it's not fun to listen to everyone just saying how their life is bad (that is praying in a nutshell), second thing, there might be another thousands of earth-like plants with "humans" on it.
My turn now: Once a student asked its professor. How can you tell apart good from bad? The professor says, you use your common sense and do what you think it's good. The student says. Then my common sense tells me to take a gun and kill you. The professor answers: Well ok, what stops you? The student says, it's my religion which teaches us what is good and what is bad. The professor says: If it wasn't that you would've you killed me? The student remained silent. - Think about it, is really religion all it keeps you from doing it? Then the student answered: No, I actually didn't mean it but what if someone wants to do that? What will stop him without religion? -Well, you see son, our instincts and our education will prevent most of the people doing that. But like 1 in a million, there can be such individuals that have the wrong genes and grew up in the wrong conditions. Plus the majority of these do it for a reason not just like that. Those with killer genes won't be stopped by religion anyway.
Asad Ahmed or you could understand them and not tell someone you know nothing about to relive his childhood. Next time, just fuck off and keep your opinion to yourself instead of annoying someone who tried to be funny and a good person to make complete strangers laugh.
If it is your common sense that tells you good from bad, then what if your common sense tells you to shoot someone and kill them would you do it. Yes because that is what my common sense tells me is right. A human can pleasure himself in many ways that includes drugs murder or sex etc. but religion is what tells you you spare the mans life and put the gun down. Religion is what tells you good from bad
The burden of proof is on the believers and frankly their only proof is a book that we dont even have a copy of a copy of the original and a warm fuzzzing feeling they get. seems they might be short of logic. galielo already proved the earth isn't the center of the universe.
@@riveratrackrunner You could argue the same about Darwin's theory of evolution; all science has for proof of his theory is his writings. But believers of Darwin's theory perhaps see it in nature, hypotheses, and scientific debates, just like believers (whether they be Christian, Jewish, or any other group who believes in a Higher Power) might see God's handiwork in science itself, deep serious study of the Bible and/or other religious scripture, and spiritual discussions. It's all rooted in what your personal preference is as far as what you believe to be true, regardless of any/all tangible or intangible "proof" you have in your knowledge or possession. If people want to believe there are leprechauns and a pot of gold at the end of every rainbow, let them think that; it shows they have a vivid imagination. Let them "discover" for themselves whether or not their "theory" is true or false. (Besides, who can say what's truly at the end of every rainbow? Has anyone ever been?) There's no need at attempting to prove people wrong or tear anyone or their beliefs down, since that doesn't accomplish anything whatsoever, unless you get an icky form of pleasure out of it. Plus, some people might view those actions as demeaning and even unintelligent, and no one really wants to look that way. Also, did Galileo ever "prove" the earth was not the center of the universe? Heliocentrism was seen as "absurd and foolish," just like Darwinism is today, by the head of churches past and present. The only way we know the earth revolves around the sun, and not vise versa, is through mathematical calculations, scientific estimations, and eventual confirmations through space travel. And there are still people who believe the earth is flat, despite all this "proof," which is, again, why I say to let people believe what they want to believe. Whatever truth is out there will be found one day, and we will all eventually realize how interconnected everything is on a scientific, philosophical, and, yes, spiritual level. Hopefully, we can all get along in the mean time.
@@manaspajamas5071 yeah galileo did prove it so did other prove that he was correct too.. that's why the church had him killed. Because they are sore losers. But yeah if we put differences aside we would accomplish more as a species. I don't see it happening tho.
@@riveratrackrunner Don't give up on us flawed humans just yet. We may have a ways to go to reach a state of harmony, unity, and peace, but we are (slowly yet surely) heading in the right direction. Thank you for being kind and thoughtful in your reply, even if we might agree to disagree on certain subjects. (Personally, I don't believe the churches themselves are "sore losers," but I do believe the people in them can be, and are, that way to some degree. But hopefully, we are all learning.) That is the beginning of moving forward towards a better tomorrow. Have a lovely, beautiful life! 😊
"It was, of course, a lie what you read about my religious convictions, a lie which is being systematically repeated. I do not believe in a personal God and I have never denied this but have expressed it clearly. If something is in me which can be called religious then it is the unbounded admiration for the structure of the world so far as our science can reveal it." (A.E.)
Kane Clarke explain b this seems flawed to me. If not who created the universe how is it constantly expanding, is there something beyond the universe such as heaven and hell no one knows our entire existence is based off of THEORIES no one actually knows what happened
Kane Clarke if no god or higher up of sort created this universe we have no propose we were put here for a reason we have a point to our living something has to be outside of our universe to let it be expanding although we can’t figure it out it must be there so something made us we didn’t just appear from thin air bc as you know a little pant must have a starting time point as a seed correct, well who planted all the plants? Did they arise from our molten earth? And if so why don’t other planets have plants and animals? Something or someone put us here for an unknown reason maybe just an experiment.
Paul Tillich, the renowned Christian theologian, stated (Dynamics of Faith, 1957) that there is a difference between 'belief' and 'faith'. Belief is based on valid observable, repeatable fact, which is the fundamental basis of all areas of science. On the other hand, faith does not require any form of valid observation or replication of any sort. Faith, using the long held analogy, makes a 'leap of faith' over any need to 'prove' the convictions an individual might hold. I am very glad that I am a scientist. Science can prove what it says!
Thank you for the example, J Will. A near perfect presentation example of the logical fallacy 'Argument from Ignorance' (Latin: 'Argumentum ad Ignorantium'). Further, from the field of psychology, this example provides a serious dose of the 'cognitive bias' well described by the 'Dunning-Kruger Effect.' This PhD, this son of a D.Th. minister, and (especially) this former two-tour multiply decorated combat 'grunt' with the parachute infantry, does indeed experience a limited measure of enjoyment from the 'Schadenfreude' this example has induced as a secondary side-effect. Under normal circumstances I would so enjoy a spirited rational and logical discussion regarding the issue of 'belief' v 'faith. However, it is my long held conviction that one should not encourage individuals who are rationally and logically unarmed.
I've always imagined about time travelling And there are two things in particular I would like to do 1. To check if the history we know now is flawed (or to show people history which their government try to hide from them) 2. To check what actually happened during the time of Jesus
This is SUCH a strawman fallacy. This "conversation" wouldn't actually take place except in the mind of a theist attempting to prove some point. And saying that "science says your god doesn't exists" is not something science would or even could do because science only operates in the physical world and doesn't address that which it cannot test....therefore would never make such a conclusion as "god doesn't exist". And especially when the student starts to question the professor,....this is more of the same. Things like this don't actually happen.....outside a "God's Not Dead" movie. Seriously, this whole video is just an exercise in absurdity.
God created his angels with options and freedom just like us. Satan was Lucifer, and he was an angel. He grew jealous of God, and rebelled. God did not create Satan, he created Lucifer.
I am Muslim and in my college, There's a professor ask me "is GOD are real?" and I said "Yes it is." and more argument and more until I said "If you think you're good enough to think GOD is human,can you prove it?and you asking me why I can't see GOD?I can't feel it,taste it and more. But do you know that GOD is not human and GOD made us. How you live?Why do you live if you're not trust in GOD?If GOD doesn't exist,why do you exist?" then the professor stared at me and he crying. I felt sorry for him bcoz I think I make him feel bad. But I made the professor happy with smile. He forgave me bcoz I have the FAITH to link us between GOD and us.(sorry for my bad English)
Im a christian and i believe in god! Two of my friends are atheist and we still get along very well even tho they dont believe in god we are the best friends! Everyone is allowed to believe in whatever they want to that is my point
now that's a true christian right there... no matter how much verses you memorized, how much of a believer you think you are, when you hate people that have different beliefs, an atheist that loves people no matter what their beliefs are are more of a christian than you are
I think this is an optimistic way of thinking if life, and if someone wants to believe in God, let them. If they don't let them. No matter if there is or isn't, we shouldn't argue about such things, there's no point.
Of course anyone can believe whatever they want, we should never police people's thoughts. But it's valuable to talk about epistemology, and make sure we believe things for good reasons.
@@JC-li8dh dude, stop... I'm trying to be positive and make the world a better place *holds back laughter* I want people to be at peace *bursts into laughter* No seriously, I do
Olive Smash If people stayed in there lane then no one would of heard the good news of Jesus Christ. God Bless you brother, if your confused read the Bible and it will guide your life in the right direction. I would start with John 1. God Bless
Republican States Mapping I just looked it up and he was raised a Jew. Many think he converted to Christianity (including me). His actual beliefs are not and have never been fully proven.
Joel Francis hahah not so fast bro, not exactly...as much as I’d like to believe that, there are the 1000 years of judgement first. When Christ returns we will have 1000 years of Jesus as our ruler before he passes the new kingdom over to our God Yahweh. Not hating but read the bible first aha😅
This... I don't believe in God, but the professor in this story is being disrespectful to religion, something most of us know to respect and honour. Why? Because it teaches smart people. With us being humans, we believe completely different things. If I were to tell someone I believed everyone was a God, who'd stop me? From my point of view, there is no God, but for many others, there is a God or there are many Gods. None of us should be this straight up disrespectful for a persons believes. We can educate, tell someone about our point of view, we shouldn't hate someone or disrespect someone for their believes. People like the teacher, to me, are one of the reasons we have a bad name to some as us 'crushing peoples believes.' No, we're just people that don't agree. While I love talking to people from different believes, I wouldn't dream of pointing out one person and making them answer such guestons as 'If God created everything, he must be evil.' This is not inspiring, to me at least. While the student had clever remarks, it was insulting an older person. A thing not at all inspiring. I don't know, why I watched this, it was recomended to me for some reason. Maybe because Religion is so interesting? The believe in something can be comforting or terrifying, depending on the belief. That makes Christianity among others so interesting.
This isn't real. It is fictional propaganda meant to make atheists look intolerant and college professors look like evil secularists. It's anti-intellectual and the music is really annoying.
David Dyer Maybe, but these is still the fact that if something like this happened, neither would be right in my eyes. No matter, who are the ones fighting.
a lonely spoon Nobody makes stupid points, these were points that you 'see' on the screen, those points from both sides might be invalid (especially from the students side), but of course the professors points seem invalid to someone that believes in God, to me, the points proving God is real were not valid. So? We look at things different ways.
Call me Eko both sides had freakin hillaroous points and we just trying to put the other person in a "lower" position. The argument of the teacher about our inability to see hear etc. god is stupid. Specially for a teacher (im an atheist). You also cant see black holes but at thiz point were almost certain they exist. If this was a real life scenario i thing you could excuse the student for being a lot younger and unwise. Also the teacher started attacking the student and violently tried to make him acknowledge the nonexistence of god which is just inappropriate for a teacher.
People die because they supposed to. It can be a contract they made with God how do we know? We all have our time, our fate, our life our destiny. We are here to learn. To understand what it feels like to have the human physical experience. To learn what no means, what yes means, how it feels to laugh, to cry, to dance, to feel pain physical and emotional. To know love. Unconditional love, forgiveness in many forms. We learn we move on. God tells us in the Bible that he knew us before we were born. So that should tell us there. It does me. I know when I leave this physical body and get back into my spiritual body that’s been prepared for me it going to be awesome. Especially if I passed the tests and karma! Something to look forward too. But the Bible also says we’ll sleep until Jesus comes back and raises the dead. So we won’t know anything until the day he awakens us. So just got to have faith on what happens. I know I have seen a lot in the spiritual realm. It’s something. But it does exists. One day we will all find out! Have faith. As much as a mustard seed! You’ll be fine.
supersuperluigi9 to you. Maybe later in life if you make it to there you will research more. Life’s events tend to steer you in that direction. If not go for it. But do not belittle my beliefs because you have no spiritual experience or beliefs. Misery refunded.
Student: Just ripped a good one. Hey professor did you hear that? Did you smell that ? Did you taste that? Did you happen to see that? Well.. catch that and paint it green. Hahaha
This made me trilled so much. I am an Agnostic, but to me if God exists we need it's prove to us and that could let us to understand the conflict between Science and God. Actually every thinks so Science and Mathematics are opposite of believing God but true is we are finding it's origin in order to claim itself as GOD! Fatih is different thing but originallty is different thing. If God exists it have to show it's reflections in order to prove itself as real. For me God is the purity of Mathematics and Physics this thing also including Philosophy could prove it's existence and for this we will need some thing unexcepted. Einstein to was searching answers of God, he also was in favour to prove god in equation but at last he couldn't.
We don’t just know about god from books we feel him and see know he’s there in are hearts and minds but you will only feel him if you accept him you can’t say people who believe in god are weak if anything there strong there stronger than anyone else as they are feeling even seeing or just believing in something so huge that someone with a weak brain could even understand god you must be open minded willing to accept him and you will feel him you will feel your answers to your questions everything that happens is becuase it’s part of gods plan so don’t say something unless you have s backup to that and you wonder why we have sicknesses and death and disasters it’s all one big trial in gods plan so we can return back to him and live with him and become like him he doesn’t do it to us to make us miserable he does it as s trial to make us prove are sleds to home to prove we will not be tempted by Satan as we did chose god in heaven we all will have 1 major trial in are life and a few small ones and if you can get through those and fight through Satan’s temptations and follow gods path you will live with him now I will not comment on anything else all I haft to say is that’s what I believe
you just put the context of the video, and threw it out the window.... the point was, we belive in things we can't see... and many are true. Plus, who said that the two couldnt co-exist. Science and God could find a way to prove itself with the help of eachother
Ok . If you get annoyed what we Christians believe piss of. It’s just what we believe and I’m gettin really annoyed that some people are getting annoyed for what where saying, so if you don’t like what we’re saying don’t read it. Heck I was talking to someone else in the comments and one guy got pissed for what I was explaining to another person.
I have been raised a Catholic and come from a line of relatives from a relatively Catholic country (Ireland), I attend a Catholic school, and I was always taught God is real. However, in the past few months of my young life, I have concluded God is factually incorrect. Having been taught God created Earth, the universe, etc, and how he made humans. Well I have gathered scientific evidence to prove otherwise. So, according to the bible, God made earth, people, animals, within 7 days. Well, the earth is about 5 billion years old. And the earliest humans, *homo habilis*, were thought to be around 2 million years old. We, as homo sapiens, evolved from a line of the homo species. If god created the world in 7 days, but there is 4.5 billion years between mankind and earth, how could this be in 7 days? Please excuse me if I have made a factual error somewhere, I am only 12.
Darrell Stick Then what proof do you have that god created the universe in 7 days? If you understand light particles (photons) that is the reason you see things, the photons are coming from a light source like the son and are getting reflected and absorbed into your retina so you can see, Photons have a speed limit tho, 300,000m/s, which means when you look far into the night sky the very very faint objects are very old and confirm that the universe is old, if you still don’t believe me than please give me evidence that god exists and he created everything.
Go listen to the UA-cam videos by Dr. Jordan Peterson "Psychological Significance of the Biblical Stories", There are 15 quite long lectures but I know you will take in every word he says - you are an intelligent young man, they are free - enjoy. Also if you have confusion reading the bible get Mr. Dennis Prager's Rational Bible, (Exodus is now available), the insights there will fascinate you because after all they are only stories about how humans have reacted and behaved over the millennia and show how we have worked out what rules and life-style works best for our culture, e.g. The Ten Commandments, and so on. Unfortunately this coming series of 5 books have to be purchased. Perhaps you are confusing science with religion - The way people described things some thousands of years ago tends to be different to how we do it now we have science. Both are necessary, it was through the questioning of God and Religion by those Catholics such as Thomas Aquinas that the Scientific Method was finally born. ("Most men seem to live according to sense rather than reason. St Thomas Aquinas.") Regards.
I would suggest if you want to comprehensively research this subject properly to read on both sides of the subject. I recommend books on philosophy and articles on both interpretations of the world around us. Science is, after all, the human observation of the physical laws of the universe. And we are not known for being always right. Answers in Genesis is a good place to start for the science side of things, and CS Lewis's Mere Christianity, God in the dock, and others are excellent for beginning the philosophical side of inquiry. Here is my advice if you would hear it: do not be leary just because something is old, truth does not change, two and to will always make four. Search for truth. Not Fasion.
Extending the professor argument: if you can't perceive a difference between God and Satan, then the question is not whether God exists, or whether God is Good, or omniscient ---- it's whether he is different from Satan. If God doesn't always help the good, wouldn't satan not always influence the bad??
The thing is that there is such a thing as free will. because God created Satan it does not make him Satan. Satan was created good and then he decided to break away from his original design which made him turn evil and cause evil things to occur. Just because God can do all things does not mean he will. He has given all living beings the ability to make choices on their own, therefore what Satan does is not an extension of God or who he is, it is simply a choice of Satan. God is the cause for all things good without God there is no good. It is however impossible to understand the extension of this argument because unlike God we do not know all things therefore we cannot understand all things. That is why we hold on to our faith if you want to know more then look for God and ask him yourself and maybe you will understand why thousands of years later where still talking about a man who died on a cross.
After realizing this was a fabricated story, for no educated professor would answer 'yes there's cold and dark' and getting up to 5 logical fallacies in the students 'reasoning' I have up on hearing anything truthful from this video whatsoever. bunch of bs.
We don’t just know about god from books we feel him and see know he’s there in are hearts and minds but you will only feel him if you accept him you can’t say people who believe in god are weak if anything there strong there stronger than anyone else as they are feeling even seeing or just believing in something so huge that someone with a weak brain could even understand god you must be open minded willing to accept him and you will feel him you will feel your answers to your questions everything that happens is becuase it’s part of gods plan so don’t say something unless you have s backup to that and you wonder why we have sicknesses and death and disasters it’s all one big trial in gods plan so we can return back to him and live with him and become like him he doesn’t do it to us to make us miserable he does it as s trial to make us prove are sleds to home to prove we will not be tempted by Satan as we did chose god in heaven we all will have 1 major trial in are life and a few small ones and if you can get through those and fight through Satan’s temptations and follow gods path you will live with him now I will not comment on anything else all I haft to say is that’s what I believe
The theoretical professor went wrong by discussing the attributes of the imaginary god before asking for evidence it existed in the first place. Then the rest of the conversation wouldn't have taken place because there is none.
that's a dumb thing to say, if those attributes in this case god's benevolence give him an obligation to act according to them, if he doesn't act according to them, than that disproves his existence
@Benazir Fernandes we didnt pretend that didnt happen... infact, only non muslim geniuses are spread around the world such as albert eisntein, isaac newton, and all that. You pretended that aljabar, a muslim genius who invented algebra, didnt exsist (or at least not taught to kids abt him) so that kids nowadays have a mindset that muslims arent smart
If monkeys evolved to humans why don’t we see the process still happening did the monkeys say one day there are enough humans now so we will just stop evolving
@Dino World If u think life is "just" chemistry u have not studied it very well. Life requires order and information, life only comes from life and that is a scientific law. Darwinian Evolution cannot be observed and therefore cannot be proven it is more religion and faith then it is science. U cannot just throw chemicals together to make life, it just doesn't work that way.
S-Club Holosexual YoYo , and more Well... no really, 1 in 4 people are atheists, and I know maybe you didn’t mean it like that, but this is for all the group of Atheists thinking Christians Don’t Learn anything, We do, There is no IQ difference among us, And if you went to my church (I can’t speak on behalf of all Christians, I’m sure you have been with a bad Christian before, like I have been with Bad Atheists before) The Preacher Teacher us Morals, Safety, Healthy relationships, Timing, and so many positive Lessons, We actually know that some things in the bible we can’t rely on, We don’t Try and act good so we can go to Heaven, Being a good person is who you should be, Humanity was born with Sin, Sex is apparently a sin, although that statement is inaccurate, it was a mistranslation, Taking this path in life actually helped me, Science was basically the grandson of Religion Anyway, without religion to start, There is no science, no morals, nothing, I cannot say for certain but the world would be too different without it
I greatly respect both this professor and this student. They listened to and respected each other. So many debates go haywire and heated, but these men remained calm. Wouldn't it be nice if all participants in all debates controlled themselves like this?
Another fake student/teacher description. It was fake when people used little Einstein for this, and the new versions are still fake and bad as arguments: www.snopes.com/religion/einstein.asp The argument contradicts the Bible: " I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the Lord do all these things." - Isaiah 45:7 If you don't believe that the verse is true, then it's not that important. The opposite of cold is not heat, is hot. Hot and cold is a degree of heat: low temperatures are cold, high temperatures are hot. If you assume that a value of a measured temperature is the same as hotness, it's trivial to measure the coldness, especially if there are a minimum and maximum temperatures. All you have to do is invert the value. The opposite of darkness is not light, it's brightness. A similar argument used for cold and hot applies here. Does the lack of heat exist? Does the lack of light exist? Yes. Aren't you convinced? Does the absolute zero temperature exist? Do dark holes (absolute darkness) temperature? Yeap. It becomes very weird to say that those things don't exist when you can observe it. Saying that darkness doesn't exist means that there's brightness everywhere, or that the existence of light is senseless. You could say that darkness doesn't *really* exist, in some metaphysical opinion (it's just a measurement, not the real thing), but that also applies to brightness. That would be same as saying that words don't *really* exist because they only exist in the sense that imagination (the opposite of real) exists. That seems something that naturalists and materialists agree. Ancient Greeks found out that the Earth was not flat by observing the shape of the Earth. Later, without leaving Earth, it was found that the Earth is not the center of the Universe without. Nobody ever observed directly, for instance, photons. Science is hypothetical-deductive. We can reason what is expected or not expected to happen if something is true or false. It seems that most people, especially creationists, conflate common sense with science, but they're very different ways thinking. I suppose Philosophy teacher wouldn't make a similar mistake about science, especially taking into account that I learned that subject in the first month of the first year of Philosophy in High school. Not even New Atheists would use the "Philosophy teacher" argument. The argument from the video is a straw man. You people don't really think through about what you say. If you want to read Christian arguments and literature, choose the intelligent ones and also read the criticism.
Does God create evil as it says in King James Bible - Isaiah 45:7 and Amos 3:6? Isaiah 45:7 and Amos 3:6 (Isaiah 45:7, KJV) - "I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the LORD do all these things." (Amos 3:6) - "Shall a trumpet be blown in the city, and the people not be afraid? shall there be evil in a city, and the LORD hath not done it?" Is God really the one who created evil? To answer the question we must first look at how the word for evil, rah, is used in the Bible, examine the context of the Isaiah 45:7 passage, and look at other passages on the same subject. First of all, the Hebrew word for evil, rah, is used in many different ways in the Bible. In the KJV Bible it occurs 663 times. 431 times it is translated as evil. The other 232 times it is translated as wicked, bad, hurt, harm, ill, sorrow, mischief, displeased, adversity, affliction, trouble, calamity, grievous, misery, and trouble. So we can see that the word does not require that it be translated as evil. This is why different Bibles translate this verse differently. It is translated as calamity by the NASB and NKJV; disaster by the NIV; and woe by the RSV. Second, the context of the verse is speaking of natural phenomena. "I am the Lord, and there is no other; Besides Me there is no God. I will gird you, though you have not known Me; 6 That men may know from the rising to the setting of the sun That there is no one besides Me. I am the Lord, and there is no other, 7 The One forming light and creating darkness, Causing well-being and creating calamity; I am the Lord who does all these," (Isaiah 45:5-7). Notice that the context of the verse is dealing with who God is, that it is God who speaks of natural phenomena (sun, light, dark), and it is God who is able to cause "well-being" as well as "calamity." Contextually, this verse is dealing with natural disasters and human comfort issues. It is not speaking of moral evil; rather, it is dealing with calamity, distress, etc. This is consistent with other scriptures. For example, "And the Lord said to him, "Who has made man’s mouth? Or who makes him dumb or deaf, or seeing or blind? Is it not I, the Lord?" (Exodus 4:11). "Shall a trumpet be blown in the city, and the people not be afraid? shall there be evil in a city, and the LORD hath not done it?" (Amos 3:6). Also, take note that Isaiah is presenting contrasts. He speaks of "light" and "darkness," "well being" and "calamity." The word "well-being" in the Hebrew is the word for 'peace,' "Shalome." So, in the context, we are seeing two sets of opposites: Light and dark, peace and non-peace, or well being and calamity. The "evil" that is spoken of is not ontological evil, but the evil experienced by people in the form of calamity. From the above two verses (Exodus 4:11; Amos 3:6) we can see that the Lord is involved in calamity and problems in the earthly realm. Exodus 4:11 is speaking of human frailty and Amos 3:6 is speaking of woes in a city. It is not a moral evil that God brings, but calamity and distress upon people. Of course, this raises other questions of why God would do such a thing, which I won't cover here. But, we can trust that whatever God does is just and is used for teaching, guiding, and disciplining His people. Third, there are other verses that clearly show that God is pure and that He cannot approve of evil. “The Rock! His work is perfect, For all His ways are just; a God of faithfulness and without injustice, righteous and upright is He," (Deut. 32:4). "Thine eyes are too pure to approve evil, and Thou canst not look on wickedness with favor," (Hab. 1:13). We can see that the Bible teaches that God is pure and does not approve of evil, that the word rah (evil) in Hebrew can mean many things, and that contextually the verse is speaking of calamity and distress. Therefore, God does not create evil in the moral sense, but in the sense of disaster or calamity.
An aitheist is sinner who does not have the Spirit of God, therefore cannot understand the Bible. So we recommend you to stop quoting the Holy Scriptures.... it will confuse you even more. Just discuss about the topic regarding the existence of the Creator VS Evolution first....
Bright people who can understand virtually anything else are often quickly perplexed when they read the Bible. The reason is that spiritual things “are spiritually discerned” (1 Corinthians 2:13, 14). The deep things of the Word will never be understood by a worldly mind, no matter how brilliant. Unless one honestly seeks an experience with God, he or she cannot understand the things of God. The Holy Spirit, who explains the Bible (John 16:13; 14:26), is not understood by the secular mind. On the other hand, the humble, even uneducated, seeker who studies the Bible receives amazing understanding from the Holy Spirit (Matthew 11:25; 1 Corinthians 2:9, 10).
1 Corinthians 2:14 - But the natural man receiveth not the things of the Spirit of God: for they are foolishness unto him: neither can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned.
You're using text from a book in an attempt to prove the accuracy of the book. That's like trying to prove Gandalf and Bilbo Baggins exist using excerpts from the Lord of the Rings.
Christianity was created by powerful people long ago to keep people in menial jobs in line. If they do not act as the powerful people believe, then they will be eternally punished. However, if they continue to work hard, avoid suicide, and obey the powerful people rules, then they will live in heaven forever. It's pretty easy to see. A king wanted to change the rules of Catholism so he could divorce, which created Anglican Church.
Caden Henderson Ah well. Powerful people. From year 33 to year 313 christians have had to live hidden in the darkness and have been slayed by the romans. Powerful people I must say.
While religion does this, we can't assume that's the origin of it. But yeah, it's a possibility for sure. By the way the King was Henry VIII of England.
@@Manifoldboss67 If you crack open a skull right now (human), you'll see a brain. I'm sure you have seen images on the internet of the brain, heart, intestines, and other organs on the inside of our bodies. Those photos and drawings are from actual proof. If you cut open your leg to the bone right now, you will see a big bone called the femur. Tell me, what can you cut open to see or feel your god? Nothing. God is a concept, just like the concept of infinity. It does not exist, but we have a representation of it.
The issue is that the boy says you can’t observe evolution when you can... ever heard of a fruitfly. They mature in like a few hours of birth you can evolve things into them. Have you even seen a dog? How did a big bad wolf become a chuwawa?
Everyone is debating the existence of God, but I'm wondering why the teacher in the background is writing maths equations in a philosophy lesson 👌
only the Doctor would pick up something like that. Oh sorry, I meant *John Smith*
Max Dwiar shhhhh
John Smith 🤐
( ͡° ʖ̯ ͡°)
Perhaps because maths is the only universal language we have. The numbers stand over us all, like sentinels.......or maybe God.
The problem is that the student can't prove the existence of god. and the teacher can't prove the none existence of god.
Simon Bigras ye
You cannot prove that "God" doesn't exist because that's a negative claim. You can't prove a negative claim.
Simon Bigras God created every thing so no one can show that God does not exist.
Dharmraj Singh yeah, that was my point. Have a nice day!
People weak from mind stay with the belief that god exists
Time to read the arguments and quarrels in the comment section!
Yep..
I'll get the popcorn
Yes it is
why do I like this, have I become netizen now?
Quarrel quarrel rage argue argue
I already know this didn't happen and I'm 4 seconds in while typing this. Plus, it would be illegal for the Professor to purposely try to target and disprove a student's religion
Then you better tell the professor that because there are professors on Earth that don't believe in the existence of God, yet actually hold a conversation WITH students concerning religion.
AMR Animations
There are professors who do that.
Im fairly sure they can have a conversation about it, so long as its judt a conversation or something like that
well it doesnt mean it wouldnt happen but we dont know what professor it was, what school it was, what student it was, we are meant to believe a student of university would be able at a relatively young age to use einsteins argument at his favor, i guess thats the point of this video, we have to belive that this happened, but he is wrong on 1 thing, death isnt the abcsence of life, you dont call the unborn dead yet they dont have life, death is the end of life as we know it, not the end of energy though
Yeah, this was pretty obviously created by someone who has never set foot in an actual college classroom. The people who make up this garbage about how terrible college is, have obviously never darkened the doorway of an actual merit based institution. Maybe one of those religious indoctrination schools like Liberty or Bob Jones University but not a real school.
Did this happen ?
23% no
77% no
Mindless Parrot
Basically what did happen was a professor asked kids if god exists why did he create evil? A student raised his hand and asked if he knew what darkness was,and then he said darkness is only an absence of light,and evil is the absence of god. The student was Albert Einstein
@@Helioo11
albert einstein was an atheist lol
@@rudolfcsampai9549 Actually no he was not. He said that he believes that there has to be a higher force that has created perfection like our world is,look it up!
Precisely he was a pantheistic believer in spinochas god
That was the wrong way to handle that. If the teacher is an atheist fine. If he wants to preach about that, fine, but he shouldn't try to tell students god doesn't exist. I'm not Christian btw. I'm an atheist myself. But it's still the persons choice to follow a religion.
Gumi Swimming true but I’m catholic and think that there has to be some sort of God or creator because even if we evolved from monkeys than where did the monkeys come from??
Gumi Swimming at least you understand
Rubik's Gaming IM NOT THE ONLY CUBER WATCHING THIS!!!!!
iiDogeKingii - Roblox and more random letters I guess not but I’m not that good at it. I am working on it. My average is 29 and my personal best is 18. What are yours? I also use a cyclone boys so it’s not smooth.
Rubik's Gaming i am pretty much a beginner. I know intuitive f2l but it slows me down because I need more practice. My best is somewhere between 30 and 40 and my average is like 50. I mainly practice 2x2, but I like big cubes like 6x6
This story is fake. A professor would never debate a student about religion unless the student asked it.
Edit: please stop bombarding me with "my teacher did." I now understand that it does happen, I had just never seen it before as teachers aren't allowed to do that in my country.
Yes it is. So are all of these "little christian beating the big bad atheist" videos. This one in the lower level of believable, but it is a little better than most.
It;s time to get some real script writers that can give out something that is, at least, in the realms of the believable.
grumpy sod agreed. This is one of the weakest arguments I have ever seen for a god.
Kieran Nolan 1) it's an example smart ass 2) yes he would (or she)
HarmLessBush Gaming have you ever had that happen to you? I'm pretty sure teachers aren't allowed to do that in my country.
HarmLessBush Gaming and even if they were allowed to, most atheists don't care what you believe in, and teachers want respect from their students, and spontaneously questioning someone's beliefs for no reason isn't a very good way to gain respect.
They left out the part where Albert Einstein rose from the grave, walked in the classroom, handed the student a crisp $100 bill and everyone applauded.
Yea trust me that wouldn't have happened...
@@kakmaster6945 that, sir, is the point of the joke
@@joemama425 That's why Christianity is also a joke
@dont be negative You're right, it wouldn't have, because you would have to be bat shit crazy to believe the students irrelevant argument.
@@kakmaster6945 as a christian, I think most of the bible stories were meant to be metaphors and lessons on life, but I also have the decency to leave a good joke to what it is; a joke
the comment section is in a worse war then any war before
True that bro true that
Your almost at 5k subs
Why do people use Then instead of Than? Stay in school!
U hit 5k
Can we get 5000 subscribers with no videos? Deus vult infidel
Im just surprised how the professor doesn’t know that cold and darkness are the absences of heat and light
yup i learn that in like year 7?
He must not have a brain then.
oh fudge :/
Five bucks says this story is just made up
We don't see the conversation, just a lot of writing. We aren't told their names. All we are told is a nice story "proving" a point of view. If it's not made up, it might as well be.
Professor: God is not real.
Student: He's real.
Professor: How can you say so? Can you see God?
Student: No.
Professor: Can you touch God?
Student: No.
Professor: Then he's not real.
Student: Can you see your brain?
Professor: No.
Student: Can you touch you're brain?
Professor: No.
Student: Then you don't have a brain.
It's just a joke please don't do this in your class.
Unknown Person
Professor:but when i die someone can touch my brain proving that my brain exist
can you see god in a CT scan?
Unknown Person I saw this at insta
Unknown Person
Professor: If you knew what a brain is u could.
Unknown Person well well unknown person if we crack the professors head we will be able to see and touch it can u do the same with god ?
Everyone is talking about how this is obviously fake, but no one is saying why. This "philosophy" professor is the worst philosophy professor I've ever encountered. If this conversation had happened in a class, I would have dropped it in a second. Not because I was offended by the professor's beliefs but because of the professor's lack of knowledge and understanding of philosophy.
How dafuq did he become a philosophy professor?
God is Good coping and cheating and etc...
@@gigachad-jh1dh Hahahah...
Thank you!!!!
To be honest im stuck on this lack of knowledge in biology, and the sciences. What class is this where the teacher knows nothing about philosophy but teaches it, and nothing about biology, but teaches it too.
Biggest wars in the history:
Pewdiepie vs T-series
Germany vs Poland and France
Spinosaurus fanboys vs T. Rex fanboys
Flat earthers vs round earthers
Christians vs Atheists
Please like this
Actually Christians vs muslims
@@TheNinthGeneration1
Not rlly
@@TheNinthGeneration1 Muslims don't rlly argue like that
@@TheNinthGeneration1 We are like brothers, never! Atheists vs Christians
PrincessQueen Aisha what about the crusades? And the conquests for what is currently Spain? Among many other battles and wars through history?
If there is no evil
There is no good
If there is no death
There is no life
If there is no evil then there is no evil. If there is no death then there is no death.
It's fun to play with words.
Joey Crimson sort of. Those practically immortal organisms can continue to reproduce but at some point each singular cell will die
Nothing is true.
Everything is permitted
OK now let's go stab random people with blades hidden in our arms.
Wouldn't make sense to die before you live
@@Flawlessx69 they can still be killed by something that means that they are not immortal at all , that is so called *death* ...when something stops functioning , dissapears etc , so youre not right , how does your arogance feel now ?
have you seen your own brain? have YOU touched you brain?
smelled your brain?
tasted your brain?
felt your brain?
seen your brain?
heard your brain?
No?? then that means you don't have one
Can we get 2000 subscribers with no videos? idiotic comment lmao we can prove the brain because we know it is there because of proof but god we never saw him we never. felt him you may feel loved but phycology can explain that
*cough* *cough* it was a joke *cough* *cough*
I've seen a brain....
Can we get 5000 subscribers with no videos? SOME PEOPLE HAVE BRAINS AND SOME PEOPLE EVEN SAW BRAINS
Can we get 5000 subscribers with no videos? hahahahah
It is truly a wonder seeing so many fallacies and equivalence errors in one short video. Whats even more sad is that anyone is convinced by this.
Not everyone, friend. I want to take the brain of the student and put it in a jar labelled "THIS IS NOT A BRAIN".
@@antonionacionreluya8707 then what do you think is a brain then? By the way do you know who's the student is? They say he's Einstein! Are you brainier than Einstein?
@@troytrillions9125 So is your argument that Einstein was smart, therefore this argument is smart? Stephen Hawking was smart, he didn’t believe in God, so does God therefore not exist? I wouldn’t make that argument myself either, because that’s not something you can use to determine truth.
well cold is absence of kinetic energy of our molecules and it's a lose term something is colder in relation to something like 0 is colder than 1 but 0 I hotter than -1 darkness is just absence of photons human brain one is just stupid and I beliv ein evolution sooo yeah no but we cant also say definitely that god doesnt exist but we also cant be definite in his or her or whatever it is existence so what was wrong in this video other than brain and evolution one
You forgot that everyone has their own belief. I personally belive in the big bang theory but I have full respect to people who belive in God.
agent Δ• Sn6 •Δ this is a good man right here.
Now no swearing please
H E C K
No u
Wrong meme sorry
So is it a coincidence that in the Bible god said let there be light, which created the universe. That completely correlates to your belief.
Now let me say this, is it possible to take nothing & create a book with Intricate pages & colorful pictures & complex sentences. Is it possible to create a book like that from nothing. No it is not.
So what is DNA, DNA is OUR book, full of complex instructions to create us, it’s not possible to create that from nothing which means there has to be a god, & in the Bible it says, “if you seek god you will find him” so if you haven’t yet keep looking because he is there
I love you
finally, someone that doesn't post something that they know will make people angry. jeez I mean what is wrong with some of these people just dont post if you dont agree
agent Δ• Sn6 •Δ May god bless you
agent Δ• Sn6 •Δ i belive in both
Well this is not correct, they changed the conversation a little and so the meaning changed by A LOT. It is mostly true until where he stopped talking about cold as absence of heat...
See, I will judge this because this is based of a REAL conversion between Einstein and his middle school teacher. You can make up your story but it is not right to change an existing one!
What actually was said is that “cold is the absence of heat” and it was applied to the concept of “evil is the absence of good” which Einstein said means “evil is the parts of the universe that are yet untouched by god”.
Basically there was no debate on god existence in the first place, the teacher was Christian and made the point that god is evil and that is why Einstein argued with him. The teacher did not pick on him, Einstein just interrupted and said this.
Guys, don’t try to change history! Don’t retell it in your ways, the truth will come up eventually!
LOL Science no God let Evil happen I don’t know why but he let it happen God doesn’t create evil that’s the problem here he lets it happen
J Hedgje HE DOES NOT “LET IT HAPPEN” THAT IS SATIN. SATIN DOES THESE HORRIBLE THINGS TO MAKE POEPLE THINK GOD IS MEAN AND DOES EVIL AND HURTS PEOPLE. IT IS ALL SATIN. Why would God purposefully hurt people? You think he just sits back on his chair and watches people die? Really?
LOL Science I agree
Craft Slime Company he doesn’t do it on purpose of course not he’s a loving God and kind and forgiving God
Craft Slime Company I agree. God is still trying to fight off Saitan and things.
So "off" is not the opposite of "on". It's simply the ABSENCE of "on". 😂😂
Bijan Soularie those are two words made by us to define the variability in numbers (which is another thing we created) and the presence and absence in different objects (and I don't want to mention all of the names science uses to relate to different things in objects according to different theories which is also created by us). So it's a mess of thousands of thousands of theories we say everyday. Technically speaking it is, after science took ages to come to this day.
Bijan Soularie 😒 Have you not learned about english, that there is some words in absence of something
That's deep
He talks about dark not existing. Genesis 1:4, God saw that the light was good, and God separated the light from the darkness. One of the most iconic verses counters the students's whole argument.
in fact there isn't such a thing a the opposite 😊
It's not up to anyone to disprove if God real or not. A believer is making a claim that this particular entity is real, it's up to him/her to prove it. A none believer makes no such claims. They are just asking for testable scientific evidence. Just like if someone comes to you and claims that they saw a dragon, you would ask them for evidence. It would be not up to you to disprove of the dragon.
Spot on
The burden of proof should always be on the one who claims that he/she have seen God 🤷 it's pretty simple
@@blockbyblock4078 True, but sometimes it's also on the non-believers like me to disprove it, and its simple to disprove the omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent deity by simply questioning someone with the Omnipotent Paradox, Omniscience and Free Will Paradox, and the Problem of Evil argument.
God loves all of you.. Amen
@@johmierosales9168 no he doesn't
C'mon ... We all know we CAN touch feel and smell the professors brain, it's just illegal ))
Bentoo
So all we would,have to do is tell you that God exists, but you aren't allowed to look at him.
Your argument for the existence of the professor's brain are identical to Joseph Smith's argument for the existence of the gold plates of Mormon. They are real, too, but you aren't allowed to see them.
"not allowed" isn't the right word here. (I'm talking about christian religion, because I don't know others rules)christian religion tells us that god created people as free creatures and if there is something that god doesn't allow us, that means it is a lie, so be careful what you write next time and one more thing, there's no need to take my comment seriously, because it was a joke.
I touched my professor’s brain day one.......he didn’t come back.
Bentoo 😂😂😂😂
Lol
I tried this with my principal now I'm searching for another school XD
do tell...
Stag Gamers yeah please tell us why your principal broke the law and kicked you out of school for arguing with him about God’s existence or did you mean to say that you left the school because he could not be disproved either way your story would be a lie as long as you lived in America at least.
@@David12754 oh god did u saw that XD after my sentence....That was just sarcasm...
LoL👌🤣
Good! God has a new, better place for you! God is good!
"If a tree falls in a forest with nobody around to hear it, does it still make a sound?" 😶💭
Alex Duncan it’s a stupid riddle. no shit it does, that’s like saying “if you turn a lamp on and nobody is around, is it really on?”
@@c.yr0623 the point is that u can't prove it, it's kinda based on the simulation theory which indeed could possibly be true as there could have been a much smarter civilization, basically the only way to prove it is for u or a camera to be there but u could still argue that since someone or something is there, it will make a sound then
Slav King oh wow...I am..wow thank you that is mind lifting also, another atheist I see? Agreeee
People are actually dumb if they don’t think that a tree doesn’t make a sound of someone is around it
Artist In Music someone has to be around to turn a lamp chap. But sometimes trees fall all by themselves.
I laughed my head off at the part where the student said that the professor had no brain.
You see? He contradicted himself in concluding that the professor has no brain. He most likely took it in his biology class that every human has a brain. If the professor has no brain, neither does he.
teacher:
how DARE you USE MY words AGAINST me?!
This actually happened tho. I was there. Right after it all went down they started making out. It was beautiful really.
I know that didn't happen but
WTH
You have such amaizing imagination
😂
BOSS Potter I like you. You seem very nice.
You wasnt there if you didnt live when einstein did
Ruutui pelailee uhhhhhhh. Yeah I did
Ruutui pelailee yeah where is your proof he wasn't there
It's kind of sad that we humans will argue over petty things like what one should believe or not believe in. So person X is an atheist or person Y is a Christian or person Z is a Muslim, so what? Is it that hard for us a species to support one another regardless of our beliefs or lack thereof? At the end of the day, we share the same land and the same sky.
(This comment will probably be overlooked, but in all honesty I really hope that it touches and affects each and every one of us.)
Well I don't think that is part of our DNA, haha
No, atheist try to get Christians to say God is not real. Christian's are trying to show them love, and the way to Hevan.
@@crazyviolin7954 Um... I don't speak for all atheists, but I only question his existence... and I admit that I can't know for sure if he is real or not. And as long as no one tries to force their religion onto me (in any way), I have no problems with their beliefs
Justin Y's Disciple it wasn’t overlooked by me my friend
Ok
Professor :Who create Evil?😈
I : human beings 😇
Parasites. Did humans create those?
Wrong
Isaiah 45:7 (KJV) I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the LORD do all these things.
Who created human beings your all powerful god there fore god created evil
If god is real and all forgiving then why does he need hell to punish his ascenders no Christian in the world could prove that
Fuck off
When a sponge has water on it is considered wet, if there is an absence of water it is considered dry and since dry is the opposite of wet I have the right to believe that this entire argument is flawed
You cracked religion wide open. It's a pile of logical fallacies in trenchcoat pretending to be Intelligent and rational.
@@Chronicskillness If God doesn’t exist then why does ANYTHING exist?
@@flynnrider2871 if something didn't create god, god wouldn't exist.
And if god existed?
There wouldn't be any need for millions of people online using logical fallacies and manipulation tactics to try and convince others to join the "do everything I say, give me 10% of your income and cut your foreskin off" cult.
@@Chronicskillness God wasn’t created. God always existed. God also made time. The creation isn’t above its creator. So if God made time then he isn’t effected by it.
@@flynnrider2871 Here's what you can't do: you can't use logic to try and prove your argument... then when logic is used to falsify your argument...
try to use logic by saying "logic doesn't apply to my argument".
And include a beyond irrational claim that even if true, doesn't dismiss my point.
Like I said: a bunch of logical fallacies in a trenchcoat.
Faith, the ABSENCE of knowing?
hehehhe for real?
Dark On Me of course, the student keeps telling about the absence of... and her conclusion is 'Faith' but isn't faith the fucking absence of the term 'knowing'
Sjamiell _ is science knowing then? Do people know that the Big Bang is real? If we came from apes then why do we have a tail bone, which scientists explain is “evolution” but apes don’t have tails. But do what ever floats your boat. You don’t believe in religion then okay, let’s not argue anymore, make love not war.
HI I'm a perso Amen
Technically it’s true. If you believe in something you don’t actually know it exists. you just believe so.
Whoever made up this silly little anecdote has obviously never attended a philosophy class or spoken to a real atheist.
Eric h i don't put any stock into fake vids and had i known this was a Christian propaganda stunt to begin with i wouldn't have bothered but after seeing these fools talk on here i just had to put in MY 2 cents lol
The sad part is that this is such a simple and antiquated outlook on BOTH sides i could've crushed either argument lol seems like Einstein SHOULD have had better sense at a college level but MAYBE his autism didn't really kick in till later in life lol
Eric Henderson, I myself am an atheist and I believe people have the right to a religion
super AGP. Sure. They can believe what they like but why lie about what non-believers think or say. Makes you wonder how gullible they must be if they think this crap is a real story.
Eric Henderson yes, I 100% agree with you, I woukd personaly never confront someone just because of their religion
I was super mad at the teacher in the backround even though it wasnt him
@@TaterVG Yeah you are right
SAME
Why were you all mad?
No I wasn't mad now that I think about it, but he looked like he was being asked the same question 20 times
Lol 😂😂
Professer:Have you seen GOD
Me:Have you seen air?
Exoposed
Air can be understood, detected and observed in a multitude of different ways, and even bottled. You can't do anything like that with any gods.
Then who created universe? Aliens.
johmie rosales haha
@@Maksie0 faith.
air can be felt dumbass
That's no science teacher. That's what a science teacher in a Christian's perfect world would say. In reality, it is common knowledge that cold nor darkness exist, because they are words to describe the absence of heat and light, respectively. We can prove the existence of light and heat through observation and experimentation with the help of the scientific method. Good and evil, however, is completely arbitrary. What heat is to one person is the same to everyone. What light is to one person is the same to everyone. Good is arbitrary. Good is subjective. And evil is not the absence of good. Because you cannot measure good nor evil, you cannot say that evil is the absence of good. And to say that God is good, and to take it one step further and say that evil is the absence of God, would be severely egotistical and misleading.
We don’t just know about god from books we feel him and see know he’s there in are hearts and minds but you will only feel him if you accept him you can’t say people who believe in god are weak if anything there strong there stronger than anyone else as they are feeling even seeing or just believing in something so huge that someone with a weak brain could even understand god you must be open minded willing to accept him and you will feel him you will feel your answers to your questions everything that happens is becuase it’s part of gods plan so don’t say something unless you have s backup to that and you wonder why we have sicknesses and death and disasters it’s all one big trial in gods plan so we can return back to him and live with him and become like him he doesn’t do it to us to make us miserable he does it as s trial to make us prove are sleds to home to prove we will not be tempted by Satan as we did chose god in heaven we all will have 1 major trial in are life and a few small ones and if you can get through those and fight through Satan’s temptations and follow gods path you will live with him now I will not comment on anything else all I haft to say is that’s what I believe
It said philosophy not science
The Jumpy Guitar Gamers read and understood about the Bible. God created humans, and Satan was an angel. There is one commandment that God gives us. And we called it a choice. Are you hear me...... then Satan choice to lie and ask to God to live his life in the dark side and God said ok, because he give us the choice from the beigning. Sorry for my English. Guys learn how to understand the word of God instead of reading without understanding and commenting without knowledge.
Which thing has humans created from nothing, you see nothing we can created from nothing. But everything that we created is something from the Gods created things.
Look
Soil
Oil
Gas
Gold
Silver
Mettalics
Zincs
Papers
You know we can’t created something from nothing but we can created everything from something from that God createds for us.
@@mstirfqri4468 god doesint exist to atheists your argument is mute
It was a philosophy professor, per the video.
*when you know essays are going to be written in the comment section over science and god*
The student said we havent observed evolution, but we have wtf is he talking about
edit he said seen evolution but it doesnt make it false
so you saw one species become another?
We have seen microevolution which is just adaptation, but there has not been any evidence of macroevolution which is when a species turns into another species. Edit: Microevolution doesn't contradict Christianity nor does it condradict biogensis which is a scientific law. Macroevolution contradicts both of those things.
@@Gamerboy365ify thanks for youre comment ill research more next time, btw i dont have anyithing agains cristianity but this video is just a fake deep
The difference is that the professor can prove the existence of his brain, while the student can't prove the existence of God
Plenty of evidence in philosophy to say there is a God. That's why in philosophy it's an academic standard to know the argument, and we continue to have this conversation about the exsitance of God.
@@souzajustin19d you call that evidence HAHAHAHAHA
@@SawkTheFighter13 I don't know of anyone that would not consider philosophical evidence not to be evidence. Evidence is evidence regardless of how you feel about it.
@@souzajustin19d Lol, there is no evidence god exists. Thinking god exists is dogshit evidence, regardless of how you feel about it
@@SawkTheFighter13 alright, denying basic philosophy. Not very wise, but do you boo.
I'm a Christian and i'm proud to be one.🙌 I believe in God and i do have faith.
But the Christian god isnt good, his son represents good, he is god, therefor he must be nuetral
You can use common sense to prove god doesn't exist.
Do you believe in science, or do you think your little "faith" is better than facts and knowledge
Cold technically isn't the absence of heat. It's when an object or particles absorb energy from it's surroundings (endothermic). And heat is when energy is exerted into the surroundings (exothermic). So basically, cold can be measured by the amount of energy the object absorbs.
It actually is, I sorry if I come of rude or something, but that is what it is defined as. It just exerts less heat.
Its like a meter of sorts, you cant go into the negatives, cold, but you can go higher and get progressively lower, heat
NeVa PuRe cold is not the opposite of heat its the opposite of hot.
Allied Sorry, but you're wrong, Don't mix Heat and Temperature together, they are not the same thing, Cold is a colloquial term in temperature that refers to the slow motion of the particles in a system, and it can't be measured, because when you say that you are going to measure cold, you're actually measuring the amount of energy per particle (Heat).
So, sorry but Cold is actually the absence of Heat (energy) and not the opposite of heat.
Eternal Abyss actually, cold is, in fact, is the amount of particles in the air. Get a sponge. Put it in water. Is the water gone? Or is it just in the sponge? How can heat be gone, if it's just in the particles itself?
I just want to say this, the definition of God is that he is supernatural. So when anyone try to measure or find evidence, facts and proofs of God using a scientific method is illogical, how can you proof a supernatural beings using a scientific method?
It's like measuring distance with liters or grams, *YOU WILL NEVER GET ANYWHERE WITH THAT METHOD*
And also trying to find *direct* proof for God is also out of the question, since we can only go so far as the observable universe, for us to directly observe God that means God has to be within our plain of vision, that means in our universe.
If God Is in our universe then he isn't God since he will be effected by time, space and matter: God doesn't get effected by that, so we have to look for indirect evidence
Zyad AL-otaibe Someone who understands. Thank You
Zyad AL-otaibe so god doesnt exist in this universe? The only universe that has been proven to exist? So logically speaking your god doesnt exist
Shadow My life’s a mess this is another concept we human cannot comprehend, we can talk about nothingness, but we can never understand it and it's true.
But, think about the claim you made, no one said that God takes on a physical form , we actually believe that God is an essence, so if we said that God has a physical form outside of the universe then it's paradoxical.
In addition when I said "not in our universe" I was referring to the realm, we believe that God created 7 heavens and the 7th is the one we live in, maybe the entirety of the 7th heaven is this universe, maybe it's this universe but it contains more than one heavens we don't know the exact details, and when I said God cannot be in our universe I didn't mean it literally I'm sorry for misleading, I meant as in physically.
And finally to conclude, you said because God is not in our universe (which was partly my mistake for making it unclear) then he cannot exist, as I explained above not physically but spiritually, then what is our universe expanding into then? If it's complete nothingness how is something becoming nothing?
Shadow My life’s a mess your problem is that you’re thinking that everything that occurs around us has some explanation. If we don’t know the mechanism, we don’t believe in it according to what you’re saying. Then, if you can’t explain it, it’s not true? You simply aren’t intelligent enough to know that you aren’t intelligent. Not everything in this world is explainable, and if you still disagree, it’s just your ego.
And again a proof that religion is a massive mental disease.
Why is everyone hating? If you're not a Christian that's your own business, but don't be going on about something you're not even passionate about. I have been made fun of at school every year for being a Christian, but I still hold onto my Faith. ☺
I think there were answer to the questions the student didnt answer and his answers to the questions he did answer were a bit silly and could have been better answered. If this ever gets to 7 likes, I'll write the answers he should have said on this comment but I dont think it will.
We'll see...
Rumple 7 write your answers
This comment section is so sad lmao
Ryu Kek xD
At least most of the arguments are really really funny
+Max Eidemiller some
are funny indeed but more than funny they are stupid and nonsense. though some are sensible
@@KARTHIKPANCH97 im having fun with replying to some of the arguments here my favorite is you cant prove hes not real if that applied I could say im a alien from 948757 using advanced spoofle technology to mimic all human things and its true because you cant prove its not
On my father's death bed he knew that I was undecided on this subject because he was dying and God wasn't helping. My dad said people generally dont believe if they can't see it. He asked "do you see the wind?" I said no. He said "God is a feeling as with everything we believe in" I asked why God isn't helping? He replied "was I a good father?" Yes of course I said!!. He replied "life is a test and I've passed son, God needs me".
I'm not terribly religious but I do feel there's something greater. We wont know until we are ready I guess.
Mahin Paudel who says God is a he? Who says there is more than one god? As I've said in the past, people think they know the meaning of everything when clearly we dont. You will, we will after we die. Questions will be answered or we realize that what's important down here isnt. Such as the meaning of life. What we have is a gift. Use it and stop with the my my. It's our God. It's not a possession you can have.
Mahin Paudel that's what you believe then that's ok. My statements are just statements and beliefs. I'm not terribly religious myself and not want to be one of those pushy opinionated people. Thanks for your input and thanks for no hostility. I like hearing other opinions because this subject is vast and also very opinionated.
Not to rain on your parade, but wind and God are no where close to the same. We physically feel wind, we can measure and quantify it, and we can explain it scientifically.
Ian Parrish yes itd very obvious and well done for understanding physics ian. Really, you diddnt have to explain considering.
Ian Parrish here's a thought. What if God was physical? What if were all wrong. We all see it differently. God looks human? Maybe God is everything. Such as what your standing on or looking at or even better, the wind you feel and we can measure. But, what do I know.......I know nothing until I die and even then it could just be giant pit I'm falling down just like bill and Ted's bogus adventure.
All philosophy professors must know the simple rules of argument. With the argument shown it seems that the professor knows little of philosophy, I know all schools must not allow a person applying to become a professor to be a professor without knowing the basics. When having a stand in your argument you must give facts to make a true conclusion. When given with premises, the conclusion may either be true or valid. VALIDITY AND TRUE ARE NOT THE SAME. Validity is just based on the premises you say which could be your opinions, but a true conclusion is dependent on expanded, correct, and educated observations. This is why doctors carefully check you for them to be able to diagnose you correctly and cure you, but if they look at you and make guesses which they think are correct(opinion) then they may give you the wrong diagnosis and it will be difficult for them to cure you. At this point scientists, philosophers, and even other free thinkers out there are still observing to prove the existence of a god. This is why no conclusions must be made yet without having the facts.
Before making a counterargument on this, PLEASE DO A RESEARCH FIRST ON PHILOSOPHY THAN MAKING YOUR OWN PREMISES AND COME UP WITH A CONCLUSION
Student: do u have sense
Professor: yes
Student: can you feel your sense
Professor: no
Student: can u taste, see, smell and hear your sense
Professor: no
Student: then science proves u have no sense
Rehman Shahzad Lmbo thats from a african comedy
Marshi melon which African comedy..... tell me about...... what's the channel called
Rehman Shahzad I forgot but its so funny xD
Marshi melon find it out and do tell me I really wanna watch it
Rehman Shahzad Got it! Its Mark Angel Comedy
Satan is a former Angeles who betrayed GOD and heaven.
O A S then why did god create him? If he knows everything And he is perfect.he know people are killing each other because of this.then is he such good as I might say he is
@@lissettecastro4742 God created Satan aka. Lucifer as an angel of light, he stood by God because he was very important. God gives everyone freewill including angels. If God didn't give anyone a freewill then Lucifer wouldn't have betrayed God. Lucifer was jealous of God and wanted to be just like him. He took most of the Angels with him. God knows that the Devils days are timed. He is putting us to the test by giving us a freewill to do whatever. If you pass... you will recieve the most greatest gift.... EVERLASTING LIFE. I cause you no harm brother or sister. I am saying the end is near 💖
Queen_ OG Also, because of when Adam sinned, he gave over the earth (which was originally ruled by man) to the devil. So now it’s the devils world which is why bad things happen
@queen Satan did not wanted to be god he was asked by god with the angels to prostrate to adam "the creation of the first human" but he refused claiming that he is better that him therefore god fired him from heaven and promised him hell at the end of time so satan is trying so hard to take with him as many people as he can since we are the reason behind him disobeying the one and only God
Satan is a character they invented to scare people back into church, many years ago.
I have a sneeeeaaaking suspicion that this is made up because no professor would be as stupid as to say dark exists after that mini rant on the lack of cold. Let's not excuse the shitty production quality with font color fucked up, the same picture in the background the entire video, and the pure cringe of the parentheses. This is completely made up and it seems nobody even watched the video before uploading it to find errors.
No professor would let the kid carry on after his stupid point.
This turned out to be a never ending debate
If only this happened
jason-katsune Yes it did. Albert Einstein said this.
Henry Espanola No he didn't there is no proof of that, either way I did like it, it just wasn't einstein.
It's Einstein! But more simple arguement .. this is improved too much
Without a classroom or even the classroom floor beneath, this kind of is happening. Check out other threads Debate, conversation and unfortunately arguments have been going on before I've been on planet.
I believe Mr Einstein, may he Rest in Peace and may GOD be with his Family!!! Thank U FATHER for Blessing me with him, also said something about the universe and everything in it is just way too Perfect for it to come together by shear happenstance, therefore there Must be a DIVINE ARCHITECT(not verbatim).
The professor in not a smart atheist, an smart one would know that. Ask these same questions to Neil he would give you the most gracious and mind opening answers!
Which is irrelevant because he would still be wrong.
Tim Rohrbach how
Niel Degras Tyson is awesome
*an smart one*
We scan brain we can smell it if we'll remove and even taste it
Facts And Myths true... the professor didnt6 get his degree... obviously.. anyone knows that you can't smell taste see the brain if they're inside a head... you need to remove it first if you want to smell taste and see the brain....
Its a great example the brain to GOD because we can only touch feel see or smell our brain through some processes so is how we can see GOD, knowing that you have a brain without seeing is a mystery but you still have faith that you have brain so is it with the existence of GOD is still a mystery our way of thinking is just limited because we are under sin as i have heard we only use 5% of our brain power so if we overcome sin then GOD opens our minds and unveil the mystery of his existence the same way we do a ct scan or breaking our skull to see if we have a brain
hey im everything Bea Gamboa well your probably wrong. We humans use 100% of our brain.
Using 5% is a myth. To keep us alive our brain should 100%. Have you ever heard of subconscious mind?
Thats what keeping you alive.
We can feel the presence of GOD by praying or worshipping him
King Dragon someone else can tho
Nothing Spontaneously Erupts , that is a scientific absolute, therefore There is A Creator. Energy is never destroyed merely changed.
Ever heard of a spontaneous reaction? You should have learned about it in high school chemistry
@@anonymouswombat2354 that depends on the school whether they teach it or not. Different countries means different curriculums. Don't blame him/her.
Carol Selfridge “Nothing Spontaneously Erupts” “There is a Creator”
Why does the creator get to spontaneously erupt while the universe doesn’t,
There's no absolute in science, as everything is uncertain, hence why we keep updating old theories.
The goddamn evolution argument. ( Disclaimer : Im Christian/agnostic and Im also studying anthropology.) YES YOU CAN SEE EVOLUTION, THERE IS SUCH A THING AS FOSSILS.
susancdwpg Honestly what I dont get is, you can use theories like the Big Bang to say something had to have caused it ( like a god ). But many Christians believe those theories to be poisonous in some way to their ideas. We dont know how quarks and atoms came into being. But personally I dont think anyone can argue that religion is not manmade. Yes there may be a god but its probably not our god, they way we see him. If theres anything that resembles a god, I am one hundred percent sure it is beyond human interpretation.
Forest Trees It is almost certainly an unimaginably powerful being that couldnt care less what we fucking do tbh
Look, if there is such a thing as God. A "person" who created all the universe. All the quarks, all the Quantum rules.. I mean, praying and all this is massive bullshit because our planet is definitely not a central of universe and God couldn't care less about us. If you were immortal and all this, and created universe, would you care about some little things praying to bunch of Gods and not even one of them is right?
Ondřej Foltýn that shows your character you care less about ppl or things. I don't see why a powerful God wouldn't care for his creation. it's his. why is it unthinkable for God to care? we humans even with the limited power and life we have ,care for things we create. because God created all things and cares for all things is the reason it makes him so profound and loving according the Christian beliefs. Your sentiment though are expressed in the Bible: what is man that you should care for him. his life is but vapor.
A O Yes but first things first, there are billions of us, it's not fun to listen to everyone just saying how their life is bad (that is praying in a nutshell), second thing, there might be another thousands of earth-like plants with "humans" on it.
A video about religion and science? Gotta get my popcorn and watch the comment section
dont forget the drinks
My turn now:
Once a student asked its professor. How can you tell apart good from bad? The professor says, you use your common sense and do what you think it's good. The student says. Then my common sense tells me to take a gun and kill you. The professor answers: Well ok, what stops you? The student says, it's my religion which teaches us what is good and what is bad. The professor says: If it wasn't that you would've you killed me? The student remained silent.
- Think about it, is really religion all it keeps you from doing it? Then the student answered: No, I actually didn't mean it but what if someone wants to do that? What will stop him without religion?
-Well, you see son, our instincts and our education will prevent most of the people doing that. But like 1 in a million, there can be such individuals that have the wrong genes and grew up in the wrong conditions. Plus the majority of these do it for a reason not just like that. Those with killer genes won't be stopped by religion anyway.
Asad Ahmed wrong our parents teach us that cause if we would we get our ass beat
Asad Ahmed bitch do you undestand humor
Asad Ahmed or you could understand them and not tell someone you know nothing about to relive his childhood. Next time, just fuck off and keep your opinion to yourself instead of annoying someone who tried to be funny and a good person to make complete strangers laugh.
Asad Ahmed I do! But please understand this kind of humor next time please!
If it is your common sense that tells you good from bad, then what if your common sense tells you to shoot someone and kill them would you do it.
Yes because that is what my common sense tells me is right.
A human can pleasure himself in many ways that includes drugs murder or sex etc. but religion is what tells you you spare the mans life and put the gun down. Religion is what tells you good from bad
"Can you prove the flying spaghetti monster doesn't exist?No. So therefore he exists."
That is literally the logic here
The burden of proof is on the believers and frankly their only proof is a book that we dont even have a copy of a copy of the original and a warm fuzzzing feeling they get. seems they might be short of logic. galielo already proved the earth isn't the center of the universe.
@@riveratrackrunner You could argue the same about Darwin's theory of evolution; all science has for proof of his theory is his writings. But believers of Darwin's theory perhaps see it in nature, hypotheses, and scientific debates, just like believers (whether they be Christian, Jewish, or any other group who believes in a Higher Power) might see God's handiwork in science itself, deep serious study of the Bible and/or other religious scripture, and spiritual discussions. It's all rooted in what your personal preference is as far as what you believe to be true, regardless of any/all tangible or intangible "proof" you have in your knowledge or possession.
If people want to believe there are leprechauns and a pot of gold at the end of every rainbow, let them think that; it shows they have a vivid imagination. Let them "discover" for themselves whether or not their "theory" is true or false. (Besides, who can say what's truly at the end of every rainbow? Has anyone ever been?) There's no need at attempting to prove people wrong or tear anyone or their beliefs down, since that doesn't accomplish anything whatsoever, unless you get an icky form of pleasure out of it. Plus, some people might view those actions as demeaning and even unintelligent, and no one really wants to look that way.
Also, did Galileo ever "prove" the earth was not the center of the universe? Heliocentrism was seen as "absurd and foolish," just like Darwinism is today, by the head of churches past and present. The only way we know the earth revolves around the sun, and not vise versa, is through mathematical calculations, scientific estimations, and eventual confirmations through space travel. And there are still people who believe the earth is flat, despite all this "proof," which is, again, why I say to let people believe what they want to believe. Whatever truth is out there will be found one day, and we will all eventually realize how interconnected everything is on a scientific, philosophical, and, yes, spiritual level. Hopefully, we can all get along in the mean time.
@@manaspajamas5071 yeah galileo did prove it so did other prove that he was correct too.. that's why the church had him killed. Because they are sore losers. But yeah if we put differences aside we would accomplish more as a species. I don't see it happening tho.
@@riveratrackrunner Don't give up on us flawed humans just yet. We may have a ways to go to reach a state of harmony, unity, and peace, but we are (slowly yet surely) heading in the right direction.
Thank you for being kind and thoughtful in your reply, even if we might agree to disagree on certain subjects. (Personally, I don't believe the churches themselves are "sore losers," but I do believe the people in them can be, and are, that way to some degree. But hopefully, we are all learning.) That is the beginning of moving forward towards a better tomorrow. Have a lovely, beautiful life! 😊
*CAN YOU SMELL YOUR GOD*
Lmao
Matt A. Thats not funny wtf stop
Default Skin Said By The TrashNite Player
Dat Random Dude Trashnite? Dude your watching a fake video that isnt even real and commenting a joke that isnt even funny.
Matt A. I can smell a bible 😂
im sorry you had to read this while you were on your period i didnt mean to get an innocent 9 year old triggered
Albert Einstein
Carl TGA CONFIRM
No that's actually just religious propaganda to make people believe it
That was not Einstein, he was not a deist.
Carl TGA Actually albert believed in god.
"It was, of course, a lie what you read about my religious convictions, a lie which is being systematically repeated. I do not believe in a personal God and I have never denied this but have expressed it clearly. If something is in me which can be called religious then it is the unbounded admiration for the structure of the world so far as our science can reveal it."
(A.E.)
Give this student claps for that answer 👏👏
Worst answer ever, that happens when people debate with scientists
Of course there is something called cold
The concept of God actually being real still isn’t plausible.
Kane Clarke explain b this seems flawed to me. If not who created the universe how is it constantly expanding, is there something beyond the universe such as heaven and hell no one knows our entire existence is based off of THEORIES no one actually knows what happened
Phobic Rapter exactly, but just because it is unexplainable doesn’t automatically mean that a god created all of this. It just is what it is.
Kane Clarke if no god or higher up of sort created this universe we have no propose we were put here for a reason we have a point to our living something has to be outside of our universe to let it be expanding although we can’t figure it out it must be there so something made us we didn’t just appear from thin air bc as you know a little pant must have a starting time point as a seed correct, well who planted all the plants? Did they arise from our molten earth? And if so why don’t other planets have plants and animals? Something or someone put us here for an unknown reason maybe just an experiment.
That's because you aren't too smart
Steelers Superfan who me?
Paul Tillich, the renowned Christian theologian, stated (Dynamics of Faith, 1957) that there is a difference between 'belief' and 'faith'. Belief is based on valid observable, repeatable fact, which is the fundamental basis of all areas of science. On the other hand, faith does not require any form of valid observation or replication of any sort. Faith, using the long held analogy, makes a 'leap of faith' over any need to 'prove' the convictions an individual might hold. I am very glad that I am a scientist. Science can prove what it says!
Thank you for the example, J Will. A near perfect presentation example of the logical fallacy 'Argument from Ignorance' (Latin: 'Argumentum ad Ignorantium'). Further, from the field of psychology, this example provides a serious dose of the 'cognitive bias' well described by the 'Dunning-Kruger Effect.' This PhD, this son of a D.Th. minister, and (especially) this former two-tour multiply decorated combat 'grunt' with the parachute infantry, does indeed experience a limited measure of enjoyment from the 'Schadenfreude' this example has induced as a secondary side-effect. Under normal circumstances I would so enjoy a spirited rational and logical discussion regarding the issue of 'belief' v 'faith. However, it is my long held conviction that one should not encourage individuals who are rationally and logically unarmed.
James Smith prove logic exists using empirical evidence
I've always imagined about time travelling
And there are two things in particular I would like to do
1. To check if the history we know now is flawed (or to show people history which their government try to hide from them)
2. To check what actually happened during the time of Jesus
You would probably see a lot of differences in true history and you would probably see that Jesus was just a sand rat that made a lot of shit up
At the time of jesus, there Was another timetraver, who used to make prak Videos... like turning water to wine
@@theonesithtorulethemall And in the time of Moses there was an 11th commandment that said "Just kidding!" but Moses dropped it
This is SUCH a strawman fallacy. This "conversation" wouldn't actually take place except in the mind of a theist attempting to prove some point. And saying that "science says your god doesn't exists" is not something science would or even could do because science only operates in the physical world and doesn't address that which it cannot test....therefore would never make such a conclusion as "god doesn't exist".
And especially when the student starts to question the professor,....this is more of the same. Things like this don't actually happen.....outside a "God's Not Dead" movie.
Seriously, this whole video is just an exercise in absurdity.
God created his angels with options and freedom just like us. Satan was Lucifer, and he was an angel. He grew jealous of God, and rebelled. God did not create Satan, he created Lucifer.
I am Muslim and in my college, There's a professor ask me "is GOD are real?" and I said "Yes it is." and more argument and more until I said "If you think you're good enough to think GOD is human,can you prove it?and you asking me why I can't see GOD?I can't feel it,taste it and more. But do you know that GOD is not human and GOD made us. How you live?Why do you live if you're not trust in GOD?If GOD doesn't exist,why do you exist?" then the professor stared at me and he crying. I felt sorry for him bcoz I think I make him feel bad. But I made the professor happy with smile. He forgave me bcoz I have the FAITH to link us between GOD and us.(sorry for my bad English)
wow this never happened
Im a christian and i believe in god! Two of my friends are atheist and we still get along very well even tho they dont believe in god we are the best friends! Everyone is allowed to believe in whatever they want to that is my point
Solar Gaming God seems mean
DAN THE VELOCIRAPTOR VAN ok....
im christian too!
now that's a true christian right there... no matter how much verses you memorized, how much of a believer you think you are, when you hate people that have different beliefs, an atheist that loves people no matter what their beliefs are are more of a christian than you are
I think this is an optimistic way of thinking if life, and if someone wants to believe in God, let them. If they don't let them. No matter if there is or isn't, we shouldn't argue about such things, there's no point.
i think we found a pure one... purer than this comment section
Of course anyone can believe whatever they want, we should never police people's thoughts. But it's valuable to talk about epistemology, and make sure we believe things for good reasons.
@@knight2489 Pure? Me? Not really, I just believe in stuff like this..
Rory Gallo yes there is
@@JC-li8dh dude, stop... I'm trying to be positive and make the world a better place *holds back laughter* I want people to be at peace *bursts into laughter* No seriously, I do
When you accidentally "smELT yoUr gOD" in ur Minecraft Furnace, how much coal does it take btw?
I'm now conflicted with all these comments. 😿 You guys really need to stay in your lane rather than to convince others you know.
Olive Smash If people stayed in there lane then no one would of heard the good news of Jesus Christ. God Bless you brother, if your confused read the Bible and it will guide your life in the right direction. I would start with John 1. God Bless
Down Town thanks but what I meant is just believe what you believe in case you didn't understand.
Olive Smash nah man, you should read Isaiah 13:18
Olive smash if everyone stayed in their own lane there would be no teachers and so would everyone be dumb in that case? Yes yes they would
tinker bee 1. Do your research. There is evidence. 2. God wanted us to trust him. He never should have needed to make evidence.
That guy was actually Albert Einstein
American Bro einstein was a juddaist
Republican States Mapping Jews believe in God too.
American Bro not our god. He said a christian student
Republican States Mapping I just looked it up and he was raised a Jew. Many think he converted to Christianity (including me). His actual beliefs are not and have never been fully proven.
American Bro oh ok, interesting
Does anyone know what's the title of the background music 😍😗?
try shazam app and maybe you can find it. :)
Cuộc Sống Mới Ok thanks
SJ V Eminem
GOD is real and he is coming very soon...to take the true believers to heaven with Him
Joel Francis Amen to that.
🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
Joel Francis hahah not so fast bro, not exactly...as much as I’d like to believe that, there are the 1000 years of judgement first. When Christ returns we will have 1000 years of Jesus as our ruler before he passes the new kingdom over to our God Yahweh. Not hating but read the bible first aha😅
“God is coming soon “
-Christians for 1000+ years
And the loving god will eternally torture at least 90% of the other people...
Yep god is 100% good and just
This... I don't believe in God, but the professor in this story is being disrespectful to religion, something most of us know to respect and honour. Why? Because it teaches smart people. With us being humans, we believe completely different things. If I were to tell someone I believed everyone was a God, who'd stop me? From my point of view, there is no God, but for many others, there is a God or there are many Gods. None of us should be this straight up disrespectful for a persons believes. We can educate, tell someone about our point of view, we shouldn't hate someone or disrespect someone for their believes. People like the teacher, to me, are one of the reasons we have a bad name to some as us 'crushing peoples believes.' No, we're just people that don't agree. While I love talking to people from different believes, I wouldn't dream of pointing out one person and making them answer such guestons as 'If God created everything, he must be evil.' This is not inspiring, to me at least. While the student had clever remarks, it was insulting an older person. A thing not at all inspiring. I don't know, why I watched this, it was recomended to me for some reason. Maybe because Religion is so interesting? The believe in something can be comforting or terrifying, depending on the belief. That makes Christianity among others so interesting.
This isn't real. It is fictional propaganda meant to make atheists look intolerant and college professors look like evil secularists. It's anti-intellectual and the music is really annoying.
David Dyer
Maybe, but these is still the fact that if something like this happened, neither would be right in my eyes. No matter, who are the ones fighting.
David Dyer the professor's points were fcking stupid.
a lonely spoon
Nobody makes stupid points, these were points that you 'see' on the screen, those points from both sides might be invalid (especially from the students side), but of course the professors points seem invalid to someone that believes in God, to me, the points proving God is real were not valid. So? We look at things different ways.
Call me Eko both sides had freakin hillaroous points and we just trying to put the other person in a "lower" position. The argument of the teacher about our inability to see hear etc. god is stupid. Specially for a teacher (im an atheist). You also cant see black holes but at thiz point were almost certain they exist. If this was a real life scenario i thing you could excuse the student for being a lot younger and unwise. Also the teacher started attacking the student and violently tried to make him acknowledge the nonexistence of god which is just inappropriate for a teacher.
People die because they supposed to. It can be a contract they made with God how do we know? We all have our time, our fate, our life our destiny. We are here to learn.
To understand what it feels like to have the human physical experience.
To learn what no means, what yes means, how it feels to laugh, to cry, to dance, to feel pain physical and emotional. To know love. Unconditional love, forgiveness in many forms. We learn we move on.
God tells us in the Bible that he knew us before we were born. So that should tell us there. It does me. I know when I leave this physical body and get back into my spiritual body that’s been prepared for me it going to be awesome. Especially if I passed the tests and karma! Something to look forward too. But the Bible also says we’ll sleep until Jesus comes back and raises the dead. So we won’t know anything until the day he awakens us. So just got to have faith on what happens.
I know I have seen a lot in the spiritual realm. It’s something. But it does exists. One day we will all find out! Have faith. As much as a mustard seed! You’ll be fine.
faith is a nonsensical word for people who believe something is real for the sake of believing it.
saying "have faith in the magic ghost frog" does not prove the magic ghost frog exists.
David Teer The Backyard Ufologist I am so thankful for stuff like this
supersuperluigi9 well hope your right! Once you take the last breath it will be over. If you are ok with that go for it! Sad.
supersuperluigi9 to you. Maybe later in life if you make it to there you will research more. Life’s events tend to steer you in that direction. If not go for it. But do not belittle my beliefs because you have no spiritual experience or beliefs.
Misery refunded.
On the board there is Science that contains physics and he is a philosophy teacher
And the argument is not even philosophically sound. One word for this video is *IRRATIONALITY*
Still science
This is a great discussion.
It really isnt
2:12 this sounds dirty
Well the first bit hahah
10/10 kinkist shit on the internet
12:14*
Strawberry Flavored Clorox Bleach still true tho
Teacher was absolutely correct and right👍
The kid was actually correct
i could absolutely see someone's brain through x ray
Who else came here just for the music?
I came here cause I don't know the name of the music 😁
Student: Just ripped a good one.
Hey professor did you hear that?
Did you smell that ?
Did you taste that?
Did you happen to see that?
Well.. catch that and paint it green. Hahaha
This made me trilled so much. I am an Agnostic, but to me if God exists we need it's prove to us and that could let us to understand the conflict between Science and God. Actually every thinks so Science and Mathematics are opposite of believing God but true is we are finding it's origin in order to claim itself as GOD! Fatih is different thing but originallty is different thing. If God exists it have to show it's reflections in order to prove itself as real. For me God is the purity of Mathematics and Physics this thing also including Philosophy could prove it's existence and for this we will need some thing unexcepted. Einstein to was searching answers of God, he also was in favour to prove god in equation but at last he couldn't.
We don’t just know about god from books we feel him and see know he’s there in are hearts and minds but you will only feel him if you accept him you can’t say people who believe in god are weak if anything there strong there stronger than anyone else as they are feeling even seeing or just believing in something so huge that someone with a weak brain could even understand god you must be open minded willing to accept him and you will feel him you will feel your answers to your questions everything that happens is becuase it’s part of gods plan so don’t say something unless you have s backup to that and you wonder why we have sicknesses and death and disasters it’s all one big trial in gods plan so we can return back to him and live with him and become like him he doesn’t do it to us to make us miserable he does it as s trial to make us prove are sleds to home to prove we will not be tempted by Satan as we did chose god in heaven we all will have 1 major trial in are life and a few small ones and if you can get through those and fight through Satan’s temptations and follow gods path you will live with him now I will not comment on anything else all I haft to say is that’s what I believe
you just put the context of the video, and threw it out the window.... the point was, we belive in things we can't see... and many are true. Plus, who said that the two couldnt co-exist. Science and God could find a way to prove itself with the help of eachother
Ok . If you get annoyed what we Christians believe piss of. It’s just what we believe and I’m gettin really annoyed that some people are getting annoyed for what where saying, so if you don’t like what we’re saying don’t read it. Heck I was talking to someone else in the comments and one guy got pissed for what I was explaining to another person.
Shame your God never taught you how to spell and punctuate correctly . . .
I have been raised a Catholic and come from a line of relatives from a relatively Catholic country (Ireland), I attend a Catholic school, and I was always taught God is real. However, in the past few months of my young life, I have concluded God is factually incorrect.
Having been taught God created Earth, the universe, etc, and how he made humans. Well I have gathered scientific evidence to prove otherwise.
So, according to the bible, God made earth, people, animals, within 7 days. Well, the earth is about 5 billion years old. And the earliest humans, *homo habilis*, were thought to be around 2 million years old. We, as homo sapiens, evolved from a line of the homo species. If god created the world in 7 days, but there is 4.5 billion years between mankind and earth, how could this be in 7 days?
Please excuse me if I have made a factual error somewhere, I am only 12.
I agree with you.
Darrell Stick Then what proof do you have that god created the universe in 7 days? If you understand light particles (photons) that is the reason you see things, the photons are coming from a light source like the son and are getting reflected and absorbed into your retina so you can see, Photons have a speed limit tho, 300,000m/s, which means when you look far into the night sky the very very faint objects are very old and confirm that the universe is old, if you still don’t believe me than please give me evidence that god exists and he created everything.
Go listen to the UA-cam videos by Dr. Jordan Peterson "Psychological Significance of the Biblical Stories", There are 15 quite long lectures but I know you will take in every word he says - you are an intelligent young man, they are free - enjoy.
Also if you have confusion reading the bible get Mr. Dennis Prager's Rational Bible, (Exodus is now available), the insights there will fascinate you because after all they are only stories about how humans have reacted and behaved over the millennia and show how we have worked out what rules and life-style works best for our culture, e.g. The Ten Commandments, and so on. Unfortunately this coming series of 5 books have to be purchased.
Perhaps you are confusing science with religion - The way people described things some thousands of years ago tends to be different to how we do it now we have science. Both are necessary, it was through the questioning of God and Religion by those Catholics such as Thomas Aquinas that the Scientific Method was finally born. ("Most men seem to live according to sense rather than reason. St Thomas Aquinas.") Regards.
I would suggest if you want to comprehensively research this subject properly to read on both sides of the subject. I recommend books on philosophy and articles on both interpretations of the world around us. Science is, after all, the human observation of the physical laws of the universe. And we are not known for being always right. Answers in Genesis is a good place to start for the science side of things, and CS Lewis's Mere Christianity, God in the dock, and others are excellent for beginning the philosophical side of inquiry. Here is my advice if you would hear it: do not be leary just because something is old, truth does not change, two and to will always make four. Search for truth. Not Fasion.
You mean God Himself or your ideas about God are incorrect?
Extending the professor argument: if you can't perceive a difference between God and Satan, then the question is not whether God exists, or whether God is Good, or omniscient ---- it's whether he is different from Satan. If God doesn't always help the good, wouldn't satan not always influence the bad??
Satan influences good people to make them bad
The thing is that there is such a thing as free will. because God created Satan it does not make him Satan. Satan was created good and then he decided to break away from his original design which made him turn evil and cause evil things to occur. Just because God can do all things does not mean he will. He has given all living beings the ability to make choices on their own, therefore what Satan does is not an extension of God or who he is, it is simply a choice of Satan. God is the cause for all things good without God there is no good. It is however impossible to understand the extension of this argument because unlike God we do not know all things therefore we cannot understand all things. That is why we hold on to our faith if you want to know more then look for God and ask him yourself and maybe you will understand why thousands of years later where still talking about a man who died on a cross.
After realizing this was a fabricated story, for no educated professor would answer 'yes there's cold and dark' and getting up to 5 logical fallacies in the students 'reasoning' I have up on hearing anything truthful from this video whatsoever. bunch of bs.
You're right, this video is a source of Blessed Salvation.
We don’t just know about god from books we feel him and see know he’s there in are hearts and minds but you will only feel him if you accept him you can’t say people who believe in god are weak if anything there strong there stronger than anyone else as they are feeling even seeing or just believing in something so huge that someone with a weak brain could even understand god you must be open minded willing to accept him and you will feel him you will feel your answers to your questions everything that happens is becuase it’s part of gods plan so don’t say something unless you have s backup to that and you wonder why we have sicknesses and death and disasters it’s all one big trial in gods plan so we can return back to him and live with him and become like him he doesn’t do it to us to make us miserable he does it as s trial to make us prove are sleds to home to prove we will not be tempted by Satan as we did chose god in heaven we all will have 1 major trial in are life and a few small ones and if you can get through those and fight through Satan’s temptations and follow gods path you will live with him now I will not comment on anything else all I haft to say is that’s what I believe
But he can feel his brain
Omni King Godpad recorder Yeah, that means he thinks he's smart but he's not ? 😂
U can scan a brain
Ok lemme know when u stick ur hand in ur head,cuz that’s the only way.If u feel ur Brain hitting ur skull most likely ur not ina good health state :)
His body can not him
Let's just say that chuck Norris popped us out. Ok are we all done now?
The theoretical professor went wrong by discussing the attributes of the imaginary god before asking for evidence it existed in the first place.
Then the rest of the conversation wouldn't have taken place because there is none.
that's a dumb thing to say, if those attributes in this case god's benevolence give him an obligation to act according to them, if he doesn't act according to them, than that disproves his existence
Yeah Christian's argument always win epicly when theyre the creator
And is not the opposite so?
@Benazir Fernandes we didnt pretend that didnt happen... infact, only non muslim geniuses are spread around the world such as albert eisntein, isaac newton, and all that. You pretended that aljabar, a muslim genius who invented algebra, didnt exsist (or at least not taught to kids abt him) so that kids nowadays have a mindset that muslims arent smart
@Benazir Fernandes then looks like our arguments are even
@Benazir Fernandes aight u too
Well we observe evolution everyday and we can take evidence from the past animals and present animals and see where they changed and why.
Scientist dont say that. You must be superior 🤣🤣🤣
you full of nonsense.
....and we can observe Proffesor's brain with ultra sound!
....and we can observe Proffesor's brain with ultra sound!
If monkeys evolved to humans why don’t we see the process still happening did the monkeys say one day there are enough humans now so we will just stop evolving
Teaching evolution isn't preaching faith, it's conveying factual information based on hard scientific evidence.
Evidence that we came from meteors
@@spig8842 what is your evidence suggesting we came from meteors?
But science can only be used to provide proof to show God exists. Which is what science teachers teach is science provides proof.
Actually that isn't true. Darwinian evolution has never been observed and is impossible to prove. U must rely on faith, faith in a natural process.
@Dino World If u think life is "just" chemistry u have not studied it very well. Life requires order and information, life only comes from life and that is a scientific law. Darwinian Evolution cannot be observed and therefore cannot be proven it is more religion and faith then it is science. U cannot just throw chemicals together to make life, it just doesn't work that way.
faith is the absence of knowing...
Facts
Absolutely right!!
I didn't know that there are really a lot of people that are atheists.
JadeKook 97 I'm pretty sure most of the world actually is. Now that Science is easier to get access too, more knowledge is brought to people.
S-Club Holosexual YoYo , and more
I'm not used to it since that my country is a religious. I'm shooken
S-Club Holosexual YoYo , and more Well... no really, 1 in 4 people are atheists, and I know maybe you didn’t mean it like that, but this is for all the group of Atheists thinking Christians Don’t Learn anything, We do, There is no IQ difference among us, And if you went to my church (I can’t speak on behalf of all Christians, I’m sure you have been with a bad Christian before, like I have been with Bad Atheists before) The Preacher Teacher us Morals, Safety, Healthy relationships, Timing, and so many positive Lessons, We actually know that some things in the bible we can’t rely on, We don’t Try and act good so we can go to Heaven, Being a good person is who you should be, Humanity was born with Sin, Sex is apparently a sin, although that statement is inaccurate, it was a mistranslation, Taking this path in life actually helped me, Science was basically the grandson of Religion Anyway, without religion to start, There is no science, no morals, nothing, I cannot say for certain but the world would be too different without it
S-Club Holosexual YoYo , and more 84% of the world is religious
I’m an atheist
I greatly respect both this professor and this student. They listened to and respected each other. So many debates go haywire and heated, but these men remained calm. Wouldn't it be nice if all participants in all debates controlled themselves like this?
You do Get that this is made up right?
Another fake student/teacher description.
It was fake when people used little Einstein for this, and the new versions are still fake and bad as arguments: www.snopes.com/religion/einstein.asp
The argument contradicts the Bible:
" I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the Lord do all these things." - Isaiah 45:7
If you don't believe that the verse is true, then it's not that important.
The opposite of cold is not heat, is hot. Hot and cold is a degree of heat: low temperatures are cold, high temperatures are hot. If you assume that a value of a measured temperature is the same as hotness, it's trivial to measure the coldness, especially if there are a minimum and maximum temperatures. All you have to do is invert the value.
The opposite of darkness is not light, it's brightness. A similar argument used for cold and hot applies here.
Does the lack of heat exist? Does the lack of light exist? Yes.
Aren't you convinced?
Does the absolute zero temperature exist?
Do dark holes (absolute darkness) temperature?
Yeap. It becomes very weird to say that those things don't exist when you can observe it.
Saying that darkness doesn't exist means that there's brightness everywhere, or that the existence of light is senseless.
You could say that darkness doesn't *really* exist, in some metaphysical opinion (it's just a measurement, not the real thing), but that also applies to brightness. That would be same as saying that words don't *really* exist because they only exist in the sense that imagination (the opposite of real) exists. That seems something that naturalists and materialists agree.
Ancient Greeks found out that the Earth was not flat by observing the shape of the Earth. Later, without leaving Earth, it was found that the Earth is not the center of the Universe without. Nobody ever observed directly, for instance, photons. Science is hypothetical-deductive. We can reason what is expected or not expected to happen if something is true or false.
It seems that most people, especially creationists, conflate common sense with science, but they're very different ways thinking. I suppose Philosophy teacher wouldn't make a similar mistake about science, especially taking into account that I learned that subject in the first month of the first year of Philosophy in High school. Not even New Atheists would use the "Philosophy teacher" argument. The argument from the video is a straw man.
You people don't really think through about what you say. If you want to read Christian arguments and literature, choose the intelligent ones and also read the criticism.
Does God create evil as it says in King James Bible - Isaiah 45:7 and Amos 3:6?
Isaiah 45:7 and Amos 3:6
(Isaiah 45:7, KJV) - "I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the LORD do all these things."
(Amos 3:6) - "Shall a trumpet be blown in the city, and the people not be afraid? shall there be evil in a city, and the LORD hath not done it?"
Is God really the one who created evil? To answer the question we must first look at how the word for evil, rah, is used in the Bible, examine the context of the Isaiah 45:7 passage, and look at other passages on the same subject.
First of all, the Hebrew word for evil, rah, is used in many different ways in the Bible. In the KJV Bible it occurs 663 times. 431 times it is translated as evil. The other 232 times it is translated as wicked, bad, hurt, harm, ill, sorrow, mischief, displeased, adversity, affliction, trouble, calamity, grievous, misery, and trouble. So we can see that the word does not require that it be translated as evil. This is why different Bibles translate this verse differently. It is translated as calamity by the NASB and NKJV; disaster by the NIV; and woe by the RSV.
Second, the context of the verse is speaking of natural phenomena.
"I am the Lord, and there is no other; Besides Me there is no God. I will gird you, though you have not known Me; 6 That men may know from the rising to the setting of the sun That there is no one besides Me. I am the Lord, and there is no other, 7 The One forming light and creating darkness, Causing well-being and creating calamity; I am the Lord who does all these," (Isaiah 45:5-7).
Notice that the context of the verse is dealing with who God is, that it is God who speaks of natural phenomena (sun, light, dark), and it is God who is able to cause "well-being" as well as "calamity." Contextually, this verse is dealing with natural disasters and human comfort issues. It is not speaking of moral evil; rather, it is dealing with calamity, distress, etc. This is consistent with other scriptures. For example,
"And the Lord said to him, "Who has made man’s mouth? Or who makes him dumb or deaf, or seeing or blind? Is it not I, the Lord?" (Exodus 4:11).
"Shall a trumpet be blown in the city, and the people not be afraid? shall there be evil in a city, and the LORD hath not done it?" (Amos 3:6).
Also, take note that Isaiah is presenting contrasts. He speaks of "light" and "darkness," "well being" and "calamity." The word "well-being" in the Hebrew is the word for 'peace,' "Shalome." So, in the context, we are seeing two sets of opposites: Light and dark, peace and non-peace, or well being and calamity. The "evil" that is spoken of is not ontological evil, but the evil experienced by people in the form of calamity.
From the above two verses (Exodus 4:11; Amos 3:6) we can see that the Lord is involved in calamity and problems in the earthly realm. Exodus 4:11 is speaking of human frailty and Amos 3:6 is speaking of woes in a city. It is not a moral evil that God brings, but calamity and distress upon people.
Of course, this raises other questions of why God would do such a thing, which I won't cover here. But, we can trust that whatever God does is just and is used for teaching, guiding, and disciplining His people.
Third, there are other verses that clearly show that God is pure and that He cannot approve of evil.
“The Rock! His work is perfect, For all His ways are just; a God of faithfulness and without injustice, righteous and upright is He," (Deut. 32:4).
"Thine eyes are too pure to approve evil, and Thou canst not look on wickedness with favor," (Hab. 1:13).
We can see that the Bible teaches that God is pure and does not approve of evil, that the word rah (evil) in Hebrew can mean many things, and that contextually the verse is speaking of calamity and distress. Therefore, God does not create evil in the moral sense, but in the sense of disaster or calamity.
An aitheist is sinner who does not have the Spirit of God, therefore cannot understand the Bible. So we recommend you to stop quoting the Holy Scriptures.... it will confuse you even more. Just discuss about the topic regarding the existence of the Creator VS Evolution first....
Bright people who can understand virtually anything else are often quickly perplexed when they read the Bible. The reason is that spiritual things “are spiritually discerned” (1 Corinthians 2:13, 14). The deep things of the Word will never be understood by a worldly mind, no matter how brilliant. Unless one honestly seeks an experience with God, he or she cannot understand the things of God. The Holy Spirit, who explains the Bible (John 16:13; 14:26), is not understood by the secular mind. On the other hand, the humble, even uneducated, seeker who studies the Bible receives amazing understanding from the Holy Spirit (Matthew 11:25; 1 Corinthians 2:9, 10).
1 Corinthians 2:14 - But the natural man receiveth not the things of the Spirit of God: for they are foolishness unto him: neither can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned.
You're using text from a book in an attempt to prove the accuracy of the book. That's like trying to prove Gandalf and Bilbo Baggins exist using excerpts from the Lord of the Rings.
I've felt God but I think that is for believers to experience and for non believers to deny.
Can you explain how he felt?
How have you „felt” god?
Do you have any evidence on that? I felt a dragon, it’s real.
ive felt a mermaid, yes, its true. but i think thats for believers to experience and for non believers to deny 😜😎😍😏😏🤑😏😏
People can make their own choices, and that’s not gods decision.
Well you choose to follow gods path or not, but once you make that decision, he has another one for you ;3
If God would control people, sin wouldn't exist. The Bible says God gives people the choice to be a Christian or to be devil's slave.
Twin Rhyme Doesn't he have a huge plan or something? Therefore there is no freewill if we use this logic, it's all contradictory.
Tim Rasputkov he also killed a lot of animals and people
Wellll, it's complex but if you R E A D the bible maybe you'll understand :3
Christianity was created by powerful people long ago to keep people in menial jobs in line. If they do not act as the powerful people believe, then they will be eternally punished. However, if they continue to work hard, avoid suicide, and obey the powerful people rules, then they will live in heaven forever. It's pretty easy to see. A king wanted to change the rules of Catholism so he could divorce, which created Anglican Church.
That's the most fucking stupid thing I've ever heard. What information do you have to back it up
Caden Henderson
Ah well. Powerful people. From year 33 to year 313 christians have had to live hidden in the darkness and have been slayed by the romans. Powerful people I must say.
Night Shade Then why have many wars been started because of Christianity, and persecution of religious deviants, and scientists.
While religion does this, we can't assume that's the origin of it. But yeah, it's a possibility for sure. By the way the King was Henry VIII of England.
You might have confused Anglican Christian with Protestant Reformation m8
6:14 couldn't he have told that I can see my brain if I take a CT scan............
no. You can see an IMAGE of your brain, not your brain
Yeah............he needs proof if his brain exists p
I'm sorry......that's what I meant but I wrote it wrong
@@Manifoldboss67 what's the difference
@@Manifoldboss67 If you crack open a skull right now (human), you'll see a brain. I'm sure you have seen images on the internet of the brain, heart, intestines, and other organs on the inside of our bodies. Those photos and drawings are from actual proof. If you cut open your leg to the bone right now, you will see a big bone called the femur. Tell me, what can you cut open to see or feel your god? Nothing. God is a concept, just like the concept of infinity. It does not exist, but we have a representation of it.
You have Photo of Jesus though..
The issue is that the boy says you can’t observe evolution when you can... ever heard of a fruitfly. They mature in like a few hours of birth you can evolve things into them. Have you even seen a dog? How did a big bad wolf become a chuwawa?