Commenters here really think hes criticizing Jaun Alia, in this very interview he said two person were even better than iqbal in Urdu Dani "Piyare Mian" & "Jaun Alia". But you need to watch his full video on Jaun Alia to understand his point of view and you will agree with him afterwards.
اقبال کے ہاں عربی اور فارسی الفاظ کی بہتات ہے،،، جبکہ جون ایلیا کے ہاں ارود دانی اور ردھم کا الگ تصور ہے جس میں عام فہم الفاظ مضمون باندھتے نظر آتے ہیں۔
شاعر کا ہر مصرع انتہائی زبردست کبھی بھی نہیں ہوتا کچھ ہی مواد کمال کے درجے پر ہوتے ہیں لہٰذا جون ایلیا صاحب کی بھی ایسی شاعری ہے جو لاجواب سمجھا جاسکتا ہے
I totally disagree with Mr. Ahmed Javed. He spewed unbelievable hatred , disrespect and vitriol against a person who is not even in this world. Whatever he said in this clip tells a lot about him and his narrow mind. Jon was an exceptional thinker. A man who was brutally honest in accepting his weaknesses. A man who would openly share his feelings which require a lot of courage. It's one thing to disagree with the philosophy of a poet and the other to humiliate him. Jon has millions of followers. People love him and relate to his writing. It's a fact whether Mr. Javed likes it or not. The interviewer was just happy to have Mr. Javed as a guest.
I agree with Dr Ahmed Javed , June alia was overrated and presented himself as fake Majzoob his Only fame was that he was the brother of Raees Amrohi his wife Hina was more educated than him.
Mujhay nahi pata aap kia kehna chah rahein hein. I assume that you do not want to write what you think about me. That happens when you judge people without knowing them. So again , please let me know who I am. I sincerely wish you the best in life.
Aik taraf ahmed javed sahab ka kehna hy k jaun ki assal shayari woh thi jo mushairo me nahi parhi gyi. Dusri janib kehte hen k woh koi barra shayar nahi. Goya usne behter shayari bhi ki lekin woh barra shayar bhi nahi. Javed sahab ki apni baat k andar tazaad hy. P.S. ahbab se guzarish hy k jon ki nazmein mulahiza kijiey. maslan "darakht e zard" , "so fusta سو فسطا" , "sheher aashob"
Joun was very high class and very clever intellectual see his writing suspence digest and aalmi digest some time what he said was very bravely which no other intellectual said Any way he naver care any critic on his mind or intellectuality he was very open minded person
@@fawazbashar uper video mean koi ALIM DUSRON ke pagri uchal Raha hay or neechy comment section mean koi us ka MADDAAAHH logon say BEHS kar Raha hay??? agar JHON ealiya acha poet nahi to KON SA POET BACHY GA???? sharam na ho to akal say kaam chal jaata hay. Akal na ho to sharam say kaam chal jaata hay. MASLA TAB HOTA HAY JAB NA AKAL HO OOR NA HE SHARAM✌️
Ahmad javed sahab Iqbal ,Ghalib , Hafiz ,Attar ,Meer , Bedil ,Goite , Shakespeare parhny waly insan han unhen zahir hy jaun elia kaha pasand ain gy.Jaun elia ne sirf khala pur ki ha shairi me koi nai shaiiri nai ki koi naya mazmoon nai diya .Aur ye log jo bol rahy inhu ne instagram reels aur tiktok ki had tak shaiiri suni ha aur matric fail kisi larki se muhabat larai ha aur jaun ko relate kr sakty apny sath bus is liye jaun inhen samajh ata ha ab in k samny ap bedil iqbal ya ghalib parho ye log itny satahi soch k malik han in k bus ki baat e nai ha unhen parhna
Ek fursat - e - gunah mili wo bhi char din Dekhien hein hum nay hoslay parwardigar kay Faiz Ahmed Faiz. The couplet above is so against the values and beliefs of Mr. Ahmed Javed. I am sure it gives much anticipated and desired license to this puratanical group to start insulting Faiz. So people critical of Jon not respectful of religious beliefs, here is another target by the name of Faiz Ahmed Faiz.
No doubt Jaun Alia was an excellent soul and a great poet lot of highly educated people love him I cant understand Why Ahmed Javed Sahib criticizing him even pointing (He don't know what he was saying) refer to his drinking habit, people already hate majority of so called Religious scholars kindly (ISS QUAM PAI RAHM KUREEN) Regards
جون ایلیاء اگر اتنے ہی غیر اہم شاعر تھے تو موصوف کو مقبولیت پانے کے لئے ان پہ لگ بھگ دو گھنٹے کیوں بات کرنا پڑی۔۔۔ وہ بھی بے سروپا گفتگو ۔۔۔ مولوی صاحب کو اپنے دائرہ علم میں رہ کر باات کرنا چاہئے
The number of ignorant entities in the comment section is really mind blowing! Haha It's no wonder that people of this stature hardly know men, the stature of Ahmad Javaid. They can carry on with their mockery as it's not going to take away anything from the loftiness of this towering literary critic , Ahmad Javaid. Their ignorance is also demonstrated by the fact that their measuring stick has the criterion of fame! How ridiculous! Just commoner things!
"JO GUZARI NA JA SAKI HUM SAY" "HUM NAY WO ZINGDAGI GUZARI HAY" (JHON)🌹✌🏻 JHON KO PATA HE NAHI THA KAY WO KYA KEH RAHY THAY😅 O BASS KARO BABA JE. dhari sufead hay ap ke warna ap ka sirf bolny ka ANDAAZ deak kay samjh aa gaye hay kay ap khud kitny bary JAHIL ho😅✌🏻🕳️
@@AbuZar-k1ye sahar jo kabhi imroz hai kabhi fardaan nahi maloom hoti hai kahase paida wo sahar jisse larazta hai shabistaan e wajood hoti hai banda-e-moumin ki azaan se paidaa..
To all the haters of Jon Aeliya, I would like to share a quote from Amjad Islam Amjad. " Jon Aeliya was a poet ahead of his time." Logical conclusion for the people spewing hatred and nastiness against Aeliya is that they believe Amjad Islam Amjad was wrong and obviously Mr. Ahmed Javed and only them know more about Urdu adab and Shairi. To me, this platform is to utter vitriol to feel better. So petty and ordinary.
Aisey saada aur qabliyat se labraiz loug UA-cam par sun-nay ko kam hi multay hain.
Bohot mehzooz hua enki adabi guftugoo se.
Love from Karachi ❤
واہ واہ مزا آگیا
Commenters here really think hes criticizing Jaun Alia, in this very interview he said two person were even better than iqbal in Urdu Dani "Piyare Mian" & "Jaun Alia". But you need to watch his full video on Jaun Alia to understand his point of view and you will agree with him afterwards.
He is nowhere close to Iqbal, even Javaid knows that
@jax9574 thats what jawaid said, nowhere near iqbal, but urdu dani is something entirely different.
@@wajeehhasan4860 Javaid doesn't rate Elia that high he did a whole video on him before too
اقبال کے ہاں عربی اور فارسی الفاظ کی بہتات ہے،،، جبکہ جون ایلیا کے ہاں ارود دانی اور ردھم کا الگ تصور ہے جس میں عام فہم الفاظ مضمون باندھتے نظر آتے ہیں۔
شاعر کا ہر مصرع انتہائی زبردست کبھی بھی نہیں ہوتا
کچھ ہی مواد کمال کے درجے پر ہوتے ہیں
لہٰذا جون ایلیا صاحب کی بھی ایسی شاعری ہے جو لاجواب سمجھا جاسکتا ہے
I agree with respected Javed Ahmad sb
It's takes humility to recognize someone's true worth. Great will be great, call it whatever you may.
A good rather learnful discourse..
Luv it
Get thjs man again with some more to tell
Jo guzari na ja saki hum say
Hum nay wo ZINDAGI guzari hay
(JHON)✌️🌹
ہم ہیں رسوا کنِ دلّی و لکھنؤ, اپنی کیا زندگی اپنی کیا آبرُو
I totally disagree with Mr. Ahmed Javed. He spewed unbelievable hatred , disrespect and vitriol against a person who is not even in this world. Whatever he said in this clip tells a lot about him and his narrow mind. Jon was an exceptional thinker. A man who was brutally honest in accepting his weaknesses. A man who would openly share his feelings which require a lot of courage. It's one thing to disagree with the philosophy of a poet and the other to humiliate him. Jon has millions of followers. People love him and relate to his writing. It's a fact whether Mr. Javed likes it or not. The interviewer was just happy to have Mr. Javed as a guest.
Apkay Naam say he apka taasub zaahir ho gaya
Acha aap nay mujh ko meray naam say pehchan lia. Zabardast. Zara bataein mein kon hun ?
I agree with Dr Ahmed Javed , June alia was overrated and presented himself as fake Majzoob his Only fame was that he was the brother of Raees Amrohi his wife Hina was more educated than him.
@@alinaqvi9455 ap uppar comment likhnay walay Hain ..aur Jo mein nay pehchana woh apko bhi pata hay Keh kia pehchana
Mujhay nahi pata aap kia kehna chah rahein hein. I assume that you do not want to write what you think about me. That happens when you judge people without knowing them. So again , please let me know who I am. I sincerely wish you the best in life.
Aik taraf ahmed javed sahab ka kehna hy k jaun ki assal shayari woh thi jo mushairo me nahi parhi gyi.
Dusri janib kehte hen k woh koi barra shayar nahi.
Goya usne behter shayari bhi ki lekin woh barra shayar bhi nahi. Javed sahab ki apni baat k andar tazaad hy.
P.S. ahbab se guzarish hy k jon ki nazmein mulahiza kijiey. maslan "darakht e zard" , "so fusta سو فسطا" , "sheher aashob"
Joun was very high class and very clever intellectual see his writing suspence digest and aalmi digest some time what he said was very bravely which no other intellectual said
Any way he naver care any critic on his mind or intellectuality he was very open minded person
میں جو ہوں جون ایلیا ہوں جناب
اسکا بیحد لحاظ کیجیے گا!
مکمل انٹرویو کہاں سے ملے گا جناب
جی شیئر کرتا ہوں
1:32 Jaun se ek lrrki muhabbat karti thi, unko khat bhi bheja karti thi. Jab kisi ki zindagi ka pata hi, to phir tanqeed kyun?
aapko jaun ne ye baat kaan me batai thi
Main jo hoon jaun Elia hoon janab
Iska behad lihaz kijiyega
استاد محترم کی شان میں گستاخی ہوگی
جون کی کتاب "شاید" کا دیباچہ بہت سے مصنفوں کے کتابوں سے عظیم ہے ہر لحاظ سے۔
Agreed
Yaani JHON ko pata he nahi tha Kay wo Kya keh RAHY thay😅
In BABA JE ko pata hay Kay wo Kya keh RAHY hean??😅😅😂✌️
آپ پہلے یہ معلوم کیجئے کہ احمد جاوید صاحب کون ہیں.
Upr video me Allimo ka sukoot dekha neeche Jahilo ki wahwaahi.
@@fawazbashar uper video mean koi ALIM DUSRON ke pagri uchal Raha hay or neechy comment section mean koi us ka MADDAAAHH logon say BEHS kar Raha hay???
agar JHON ealiya acha poet nahi to KON SA POET BACHY GA????
sharam na ho to akal say kaam chal jaata hay.
Akal na ho to sharam say kaam chal jaata hay.
MASLA TAB HOTA HAY JAB NA AKAL HO OOR NA HE SHARAM✌️
@@educare6878 JE mujhy pata hay Kay ye Kon hay.
AB AP PATA KEJEYE Kay JHON kon hean✌️💪
@@Mi3940 jaun is a cringe poet and mostly cringe and low class people appreciate him
Ahmad javed sahab Iqbal ,Ghalib , Hafiz ,Attar ,Meer , Bedil ,Goite , Shakespeare parhny waly insan han unhen zahir hy jaun elia kaha pasand ain gy.Jaun elia ne sirf khala pur ki ha shairi me koi nai shaiiri nai ki koi naya mazmoon nai diya .Aur ye log jo bol rahy inhu ne instagram reels aur tiktok ki had tak shaiiri suni ha aur matric fail kisi larki se muhabat larai ha aur jaun ko relate kr sakty apny sath bus is liye jaun inhen samajh ata ha ab in k samny ap bedil iqbal ya ghalib parho ye log itny satahi soch k malik han in k bus ki baat e nai ha unhen parhna
Baba g nu rest di zrurat ay...
Rest in peace Ziada behtr rway ga
Iftekhar arif and peerzada qasim peerzada qasim ilm aur shakhsiyat me inse kahi zyada hai wo bta denge kaun h jaun elia
ترے آنے کی خبر کون ومکاں سے آئی.!!!
Ek fursat - e - gunah mili wo bhi char din
Dekhien hein hum nay hoslay parwardigar kay
Faiz Ahmed Faiz.
The couplet above is so against the values and beliefs of Mr. Ahmed Javed. I am sure it gives much anticipated and desired license to this puratanical group to start insulting Faiz. So people critical of Jon not respectful of religious beliefs, here is another target by the name of Faiz Ahmed Faiz.
No doubt Jaun Alia was an excellent soul and a great poet lot of highly educated people love him I cant understand Why Ahmed Javed Sahib criticizing him even pointing (He don't know what he was saying) refer to his drinking habit, people already hate majority of so called Religious scholars kindly (ISS QUAM PAI RAHM KUREEN) Regards
What is liabanese?
@@shirazmahdi I think not very sure he was western intellectual
Leibniz, the german philosopher
@@owaisnajam5165 thanks for your kind information dear
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz
Mathematician cum Philosopher@@owaisnajam5165
ایک انتہائی عامیانہ شاعر تھے۔
Han mayar thourra dheela tha magar adaigi performance say log inspired thay...wo achhi thi
جون کی شاعری ہر ایسے غیرے کے سمجھنے کی بات نہیں۔۔ PHD لیول کے لوگ ہی اسے سمجھ سکتے ہیں۔۔
@@syedn8580 PhD..jahalat Mai?
@@mariaali2192
مثلاً معیار میں کیا کمی تھی؟
Disagree ❌
😊
Jitnay afrad afraid n.chaha miyan ko naam se jantay hen us se kahin zyada hazrat e jon k.chappal uthanay waley mil jaingay.
😂
جون ایلیاء اگر اتنے ہی غیر اہم شاعر تھے تو موصوف کو مقبولیت پانے کے لئے ان پہ لگ بھگ دو گھنٹے کیوں بات کرنا پڑی۔۔۔ وہ بھی بے سروپا گفتگو ۔۔۔ مولوی صاحب کو اپنے دائرہ علم میں رہ کر باات کرنا چاہئے
Sir Ahmad Javed sb is really great.
Adab ka buniyadi usool hai keh woh tanqeed se bach nahi sakta...
مجھے لگتا ہے،
احمد صاحب نے صائب کا فارسی شعر غلط پڑھا ہے.
اپنا قد اونچا کرنے کے لئے جون کا نام لے رہا ہے یہ بڈھا
اِس آدمی کو کوئی نہیں جانتا۔ جسکے اپنی کوئی حیثیت نہیں وہ ایک نامور شاعر پر انگلی اٹھا کر اپنا نام ایسے بنا رہا ہے کہ بد نام ہونگے تو کیا نام نہ ہوگا۔
Totally agreed with Javee Sb june was overrated and presented himself as Majzoob but it was all fake.
See who is talking about Syed Jaun Oliyaaa... Inka adab se koi taluq b hai?
do you even know who he is?
🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
کیا منہ ہے ارسطو کا جو کرے چوں مرے آگے۔ اک طفل دبستاں یے افلاطوں مرے آگے
Ahmad javaid isa controvertial person.
Sagher sadique top ka poet guzra hy pori earth py.
is naam ka koi poet paida hi nhi hua
@SadiqueKhan449 sagher sadique. Log Dil mein jaga keisy bana lety Hein sagher. Ham to apna Naam us ki zubaa'n tak na la saky.
John was an intellectual person. Ackerman & guest both have no idea about John Aleiya.
The number of ignorant entities in the comment section is really mind blowing! Haha
It's no wonder that people of this stature hardly know men, the stature of Ahmad Javaid.
They can carry on with their mockery as it's not going to take away anything from the loftiness of this towering literary critic , Ahmad Javaid.
Their ignorance is also demonstrated by the fact that their measuring stick has the criterion of fame! How ridiculous!
Just commoner things!
Ab mai kuch boluga to vivad ho jaayega
jalne walon ko jalne do
"JO GUZARI NA JA SAKI HUM SAY"
"HUM NAY WO ZINGDAGI GUZARI HAY"
(JHON)🌹✌🏻
JHON KO PATA HE NAHI THA KAY WO KYA KEH RAHY THAY😅
O BASS KARO BABA JE.
dhari sufead hay ap ke warna ap ka sirf bolny ka ANDAAZ deak kay samjh aa gaye hay kay ap khud kitny bary JAHIL ho😅✌🏻🕳️
Jahilo ke sardar ye kun hai tunhe koi andaza hai? pakistan ke top ke danishwar awr adab shanas shakhseyat mahan javed sahib
Ab ek darhi wala aur jaun 🤷♂️
🤣
Ajeeb bay tukki baat hai... jo mushaerey mein parha, us sey jo nahin parha us ki ehmiyat kaise kam hogayee?
He is an extremely overrated poet.
Kabhi padhiye bhaijaan aap 😊
Itni garam joshi, aur is qadar, kia baat?
mujhse koi shikayat hai? Nhi to.
-Jaun
i suggest you to read Dr. Iqbal's poetry@@ansarialiasgar7192
@@AbuZar-k1ye sahar jo kabhi imroz hai kabhi fardaan
nahi maloom hoti hai kahase paida
wo sahar jisse larazta hai shabistaan e wajood
hoti hai banda-e-moumin ki azaan se paidaa..
@@d.Boi-ii umdaa qalam hai
To all the haters of Jon Aeliya, I would like to share a quote from Amjad Islam Amjad. " Jon Aeliya was a poet ahead of his time." Logical conclusion for the people spewing hatred and nastiness against Aeliya is that they believe Amjad Islam Amjad was wrong and obviously Mr. Ahmed Javed and only them know more about Urdu adab and Shairi. To me, this platform is to utter vitriol to feel better. So petty and ordinary.
@@alinaqvi9455 I do not hate Jaun. Why would I? The poor man is dead. But I do believe that he is overhyped and overrated.
Yes you can believe that he is overrated. Amjad Islam doesn't. I am with Amjad Islam Amjad on that.
amjad sahab shayar thay
javed sahab critic hain
I hope aapko pata hoga dono me carq
John Elia hain zanab ehtram kijiye
Darhi
بڑے شاعر کیا ہوتا ہے۔ مسلمان ہو کر شراب اور شباب پر شعر کہنا سوائے بہودگی کے کچھ نہہ
baba g ko na koi janta h na shayad inko b kisi orat ne munh lgaya hoga .... bs interview k liye kuch b bol dia .... 🤣🤣🤣
Bhai aapko pata hai ye kon hain?
Kabhi inky bary mai parha h k ye kon hain?
یہ معروف شاعر اور اسکالر ہیں۔
jaun bhai asal id sy ao 😂
Itne maroof hotay to kbhi nazar m aa hi jatay. Shayad Mars p hnge maroof 😂
جاھل بد بخت نشئ عامیانہ کلام
ان حضرت کا اپنا کیا معیار ہے؟ یہ خود ہر رنگ میں جاھل مرکب ثابت ہوئے ہیں ۔۔۔
3sry drjy k entehai low level shair-go. Jhon elia