Vow... I have never seen Hoodbhoy that much helpless and out of his wit. Ghamidi sahab is way way head of everybody. His logic, content and delivery, just mind blowing. I consider him the fifth Imaam of our time.
@@rightwingtrollslayer Idiots without knowledge can only call/abuse a learned scholar the way you did. Just go thru the sites having Ahmed Javed's wisdom and knowledge. May Almighty and the Most Merciful Allah guide you.
Javed ghamadi is just love it allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti day all time great for me I don't think any other better prayer than this prayer allah qabool farmaey aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤
نہایت ہی علمی ڈسکشن ۔ عباسی کو تو صرف سیٹ فل کرنے کیلئے بٹھایا ہوا ہے ۔ ہود بھائی نے اچھے سوالات کئے ۔ غامدی اور احمد جاوید صاحب واقعی علم کے پہاڑ ہے ۔ عقلی دلائل سے زبردست جوابات دئے ۔ ماشاء اللہ
@1:01:40 Aik jumla hi kafi hai Ahmad Javed sb ka. What a wonderful personality Ghamidi sb And Javed sb has. Parvez sb, no doubt is master although in his field but reason cannot dominate revelation
I am myself science student and I also study Quran and other religious books and I am very convinced that Quran e pak is words of Allah. Quran has very unique detail about creation of earth and the humans that science discovered recently. Some scientist won noble prizes based on Quranic Ayats in which Dr Keith moore and Dr Shawn are prominent. I think pervaiz hud is totally missing the point here, Darwin theory itself is a theory and if it is proven then it should not be called theory anymore it should be facts. In history Newton provided ona theory that was believed in science for many years and then it was rejected by Enstien recently. So in science nothing is permanent and it keep on changing. Tomorrow we might have new theory who knows. But Quran words are same since then time of revealation. In the end I found Javed Ahmed Ghamidi sahab arguments very logical and conviencing. May Allah reward him
Quran ke ilm se tau yahan koi bhi ashna nahin hai hehe, ye log tau bahir ki theories Quran se sabit kerne ke chakkar mein hain na keh Quran ke ander sey koi nayi theory nikal rahay hain lol
ہر ایک کا اپنا میدان ہے ۔ فلسفے کی دنیا کا آفتاب احمد جاوید صاحب اور غامدی صاحب مذہبی فکر کے نمائندہ ہیں ۔۔۔ سائنس کی دنیا کے شہسوار پرویز ہود بھائی کا۔مذپبی مکالمہ بہت بودہ اور سطحی تھا ۔ انہیں بہت کچھ سیکھنے کی ضرورت ہے ۔ احمد جاوید صاحب میرے نذدیک Wisdom کی سب سے بڑی آواز ہیں اس خطے کی۔۔۔ سجآد ث
Next level discussion. Ghamidi sahab and javaid sahab emerged as clear Victors. Nevertheless Itnay muhazzabana andaaz mai do mukhtalif nazariat ki guftugoo sun kr maza aa gaya
I have never seen Perez sahab failing so miserably in an argument.. I m myself a medical doctor and phd scholar in genetics and I can say Ghamidi sahab was way ahead in this discussion. Darwin’s theory has lost its credibility in recent era just like Newtonian physics is thing of past post Einstein era.
Hmm interesting. I'm a doctor as well, currently in my surgical residency. Mujhe shaq hai k Hoodbhoy mulhid hai that's why he tends to have a very skeptical position which is fair and he has a right to his opinion but anyways I have a sincere question. Why do you say that about darwin's theory?
Ghamdi Sahib'd arguments are very strong and totally childish points of Pervez Hoodboy. I have lots of respect for Pervez Hoodboy but here I have to say that here Ghamdi Sahb has huge status before those scientists.
I don't believe that you are a PhD, because either you don't know much about the theory of evolution or you are lying, because the theory of evolution hasn't lost credibility, on the contrary it is a fact.
watching a couple of years later, but enjoyed the discussion. questions are good and responses are equally logical by both Ghamidi sb and Ahmed Javed sb.. in love with arguments and the words chosen for this...
Ufhhhh....ak se badh kar ak personality.... Religion, science, philosophy, meta physics are at peak in this debate.... This discussion is asset and gift to us and all coming generations
*کیا آپ اکثریت کے پیچھے چل رہے ہیں؟* ایک بار حضرت عمر رضى الله بازار میں چل رہے تھے، وہ ایک شخص کے پاس سے گزرے جو دعاء کر رہا تھا، *"اے الله مجھے اپنے چند لوگوں میں شامل کر، اے الله! مجھے اپنے چند لوگوں میں شامل کر"* حضرت عمر رضى الله نے اُس سے پوچھا، یہ دعا تم نے کہاں سے سیکھی؟ وہ بولا، الله کی کتاب سے، الله نے قرآن میں فرمایا ہے: *"اور میرے بندوں میں صرف چند ہی شکر گزار ہیں۔"* *(القرآن **34:13**)* حضرت عمر رضي الله عنه یہ سُن کر رو پڑے اور اپنے آپ کو نصیحت کرتے ہوئے بولے، "اے عمر ! لوگ تم سے زیادہ علم والے ہیں، اے الله مجھے بھی اپنے اُن چند لوگوں میں شامل کر۔" ہم دیکھتے ہیں کہ جب ہم کسی شخص سے کوئی گناہ کا کام چھوڑنے کا کہتے ہیں تو وہ کہتا ہے کہ یہ اکثر لوگ کرتے ہیں۔ میں کوئی اکیلا تو نہیں۔ اگر آپ قرآن پاک میں *"اکثر لوگ"* سرچ کریں تو "اکثر لوگ" *"اكثر لوگ نہیں جانتے"(**7:18**7)* *"اكثر لوگ شکر ادا نہیں کرتے"(**2:24**3)* *"اكثر لوگ ایمان نہیں لائے"(**11:17**)* اگر آپ *"زیادہ تر"* کو سرچ کریں، تو آپ کو ملے گا کہ زیادہ تر لوگ، *"زیادہ تر شدید نافرمان ہیں"۔ (**5:59**)* *"زیادہ ترجاہل ہیں" (**6:11**1)* *"زیادہ تر راہ راست سے ہٹ جانے والے ہیں۔" (**21:24**)* *"زیادہ ترسوچتے نہیں۔" (**29:23**)* *"زیادہ تر سنتے نہیں" (**8:23**)* تو اپنے آپ کو *چند لوگوں* میں ڈالو جن کے بارے میں الله نے فرمایاِ، *"میرے تھوڑے ہی بندے شکر گزار ہیں"(**34:13**)* *"اور کوئی ایمان نہیں لایا سوائے چند کے"(**11:40**)* *"مزے کے باغات میں پچھلوں میں زیادہ هيں اور بعد والوں میں تھوڑے" (**56:12**-14)* چند لوگوں میں اپنے آپ کو شامل کریں اور اس کی پرواہ نہ کریں کہ اورکوئی اس راستے میں نہیں اور آپ اکیلے ہیں. كتاب الزھد: احمد بن حنبل رحمة الله المُصنف: ابن ابى شيبة رحمة الله
Ahmed Javaid Saab raised a very important point about theory of evolution. What a deep thought. Although I may not agree with that creation theory and evolution theory can not coexist. I believe it can.
Ghamidi shb is a very clever man he was slowly taking the poor scientists to his strong zone i.e talking about religion and philosophy and beats them so badly that they don't even remember that what was the topic of debate😂 They should had been talking about their strong zone i.e science and discoveries that challenges the belief systems through out the history then it'll be a worth watching debate
I am the student of Zoology. I feel it disgusting when a professor of physics (Parwaiz sahab), without having background knowledge of Darwinism, discusses biological evolution in a very confusing way. Host is asking irrelevant questions from irrelevant person.
Hudbhoy had no clue about what he was asking and giving refs of, especially Quran that he seemed absolutely devoid of its content and spirit. Ahmed Javed is another enlightened scholar who speaks with almost absolute depth of knowledge, logic and references. Javed Ghamidi indeed is a precious pearl in whom I see a 21st century renaissance. Having known both Javeds, it is rather imperative for the state (of Pakistan) to give them charge of the construction or reconstruction of the religious thought in Islam. Having given the true picture and face of Islam - above all Fiqh, sects and factions/fractions - I positively hope millions would convert as Muslims - hundreds of millions of Daleits, western whites, the Yellow and Black races. Besides, the existing 1.7 billion Muslims are also likely to correct their following/direction towards Islam (Deen e Ibrahimi).
Ghamidi sahab is saying such a simple logical thing. How come an apparently intelligent scientist like Dr Hoodbhoi cannot get his point. Ghamidi sahab is saying one thing while Dr Hoodbhoi negated him using a completely different point. Ghamidi sahab tried to explain by using an example of poultry farm. He never said that the whole universe was made only for humans but Dr Doodbhoi misunderstood his words & kept on debating that universe was not made only for humans. Ghamidi sahab is saying ع while Dr Hoodbhoi is saying غ
Javed Ahmed Ghamidi outclassed them all, Ghamidi sahab is a genius... And Pseudo Scientists do not know there are school of thoughts in science as First Newtonian, then Relativity than String Theory.... Hahaha how stupid scientists have been made to sit there....
He may not be a stupid scientist but he's addicted to poke his nose in the issues he has got no knowledge, specially philosophy and religion. He should better keep learning and teaching physics.
Dont ever make assumptions of "outclass" or "absolutism". Religion like science evolves hence Islam says "Aur aqal walon ke liay nishaniyaan hain [and there are signs ie explore ie to experiment[]". I dont not think Ghamidi sahab or like of Ahmed Javed sahab were dissing Prof's Abassi and Hoodbouy but merely finding a common ground. While you are hell bound about one biased notion that THEY ARE WRONG and WE are RIGHT and Ghamidi/Ahmed sahibaan made it. That us just your thought, not a fact. Abbasi told in his first statement tbat Galileo was shunned by church, today hes is accepted so its apart of evolution, and Ghamidi sahab very eloquently stated that its a difference of philosophy (ir thought process- Ghamidi;s majors are philosophy) and hence very debatable but not in respect of religion. You, very respectfully, simply missed the point of the discussion!
اگر زمین میں موجود چیزیں انسان کی خدمت کے لئے نہیں ہیں تو پھر تیل گیس سونا چاندی لوہا تانبا وغیرہ اور دیگر معدنیات کس کے لئے ہیں۔ صرف انسان ہی ان سے نفع اٹھانا اور ان تک رسائی حاصل کرنا جانتا ہے۔
احمد جاوید صاحب علم کی کہکشاں ہیں اللّه توفیقات میں اضافہ کرے
Ahmed Javed clearly won. He is the most articulate, and logical.
Every word or lines of Ahmed javed shb is literally a quote or lesson to remember.
Gamadi shb is also good.
Ghamidi sahab makes the most sense. He is so clear & logical & systematic. And he explains in easy way.
Vow... I have never seen Hoodbhoy that much helpless and out of his wit. Ghamidi sahab is way way head of everybody. His logic, content and delivery, just mind blowing. I consider him the fifth Imaam of our time.
My heartfelt dream to once meet Javed Ahmed Ghamidi Saahab, my idol, He is the true representer of Islam
Sabeer akram. Idol or ideal???
Same..if u get a chance let me know as well.
WHAT A MAN HE IS.AHMAD JAVEED.BRILLIANT MAN
he was the only one I'd call an idiot, and probably uninformed in this debate.
@@rightwingtrollslayer why do you say that
@@rightwingtrollslayer Idiots without knowledge can only call/abuse a learned scholar the way you did. Just go thru the sites having Ahmed Javed's wisdom and knowledge. May Almighty and the Most Merciful Allah guide you.
غامدی صاحب کے علم کو سلام ہے
Javid ghamidi sab explained beautifully. He is dynamic personality May Allah bless him and bring joy and happiness in his life
آیتہ الکرسی اور سورہ العصر کا علم انسانی عقل کو درست راہ فراہم کرنے میں مددگار ہے۔
بہت کامل بات کی آپ نے۔۔۔ جزاک اللہ
غامدی صاحب اور جاوید صاحب کے سامنے تمام شرکا کا علم بہت سطحی اور محدود ہے۔
Love u Ghamidi sb.. Allah aap jeise bohot scholars peida kare. Ameen
Javed ghamadi is just love it allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti day all time great for me I don't think any other better prayer than this prayer allah qabool farmaey aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤
ghamdi is great scholar 'what a mind , huge knowledge
نہایت ہی علمی ڈسکشن ۔ عباسی کو تو صرف سیٹ فل کرنے کیلئے بٹھایا ہوا ہے ۔ ہود بھائی نے اچھے سوالات کئے ۔ غامدی اور احمد جاوید صاحب واقعی علم کے پہاڑ ہے ۔ عقلی دلائل سے زبردست جوابات دئے ۔ ماشاء اللہ
gamidi ek dorrr ka name hei
great man
The debate shows the debth of ghamdi sir knowledge .we should promote him as much as we can because he presents the real Islam
Ghamidi sb has deep knowledge and full of etiquette
یقین عقل کی آرزو ہے جو دل کے ہاتھوں پوری ہوتی ہے
احمد جاوید صاحب
Very informative Debate. Love for Mountains of Knowledge Javed Ahmed Ghamidi and Ahmad Javed Sahib. The highbrowed Personalities
I really apreciate such a debate l really am inspired by Ghamidi the way he presents lslam in a great logical way
جاوید غامدی صاحب اللہ کی ایک نعمت ہیں.. آفتاب عالم خان بینکاک
اایک انتہائی شاندار مباحثہ جس کا مزہ اور بھی دوبالا ہو جاتا اگر آخر کے پانچ منٹ آواز کا معیار ٹھیک ہوتا
ghamdy is super hero
NO
@@justpurs2306 ,yes he is legen of the era
عباسی صاحب کے اٹھائے گئے سوالات آج کے دور میں بہت سطحی معلوم ہوتے ہیں۔
@1:01:40 Aik jumla hi kafi hai Ahmad Javed sb ka. What a wonderful personality Ghamidi sb And Javed sb has. Parvez sb, no doubt is master although in his field but reason cannot dominate revelation
imaan taza hogaya
may Allah bless all these people
I am myself science student and I also study Quran and other religious books and I am very convinced that Quran e pak is words of Allah. Quran has very unique detail about creation of earth and the humans that science discovered recently. Some scientist won noble prizes based on Quranic Ayats in which Dr Keith moore and Dr Shawn are prominent. I think pervaiz hud is totally missing the point here, Darwin theory itself is a theory and if it is proven then it should not be called theory anymore it should be facts. In history Newton provided ona theory that was believed in science for many years and then it was rejected by Enstien recently. So in science nothing is permanent and it keep on changing. Tomorrow we might have new theory who knows. But Quran words are same since then time of revealation.
In the end I found Javed Ahmed Ghamidi sahab arguments very logical and conviencing. May Allah reward him
You are wrong dear, Darwin theory is not a theory it's a fact just like gravitional theory is theory but gravity is a fact
good job bro beshak
ywgjg
Quran ke ilm se tau yahan koi bhi ashna nahin hai hehe, ye log tau bahir ki theories Quran se sabit kerne ke chakkar mein hain na keh Quran ke ander sey koi nayi theory nikal rahay hain lol
Ahmed Javed sahib the great is the actual scholar! MaashaaAllah
Ghamidi sab in another level ❤️
Knowledgeful discussion! Ghamidi sb ko dhwron salam!
Javeed ghamdi nailed it
Ahmad javed is best.
ہر ایک کا اپنا میدان ہے ۔ فلسفے کی دنیا کا آفتاب احمد جاوید صاحب اور غامدی صاحب مذہبی فکر کے نمائندہ ہیں ۔۔۔
سائنس کی دنیا کے شہسوار پرویز ہود بھائی کا۔مذپبی مکالمہ بہت بودہ اور سطحی تھا ۔
انہیں بہت کچھ سیکھنے کی ضرورت ہے ۔
احمد جاوید صاحب میرے نذدیک Wisdom کی سب سے بڑی آواز ہیں اس خطے کی۔۔۔
سجآد ث
bhot behtreen program
@1:01:43 Ahmed Javed sent Hoodbhoy running for cover
Ahmed sb hit the nail on the head
Javed Ahmed Ghamidi Sir, ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️Allah aapko jannat naseeb farmaaye
MashaAllah great Ghamidi sahib
Next level discussion. Ghamidi sahab and javaid sahab emerged as clear Victors. Nevertheless Itnay muhazzabana andaaz mai do mukhtalif nazariat ki guftugoo sun kr maza aa gaya
good job ghamidi sir
ywgjg
Both pervez hudboy and ghamdi are really good respectful speakers
Ahmed javed is a sign of perfection
2 best minds in Pak. Javed sir and other MIT professor.
ہم بہت خوش نصیب ہیں کہ ہم دور غامدی میں جی رہے ہیں
قران مجید تدبر تفکر پر بہت زور دیتا ھے۔۔۔ سائنسی فکر عطا کرتا ھے۔
یہ بکواسات خالص ھیں
I have never seen Perez sahab failing so miserably in an argument.. I m myself a medical doctor and phd scholar in genetics and I can say Ghamidi sahab was way ahead in this discussion. Darwin’s theory has lost its credibility in recent era just like Newtonian physics is thing of past post Einstein era.
Hmm interesting. I'm a doctor as well, currently in my surgical residency. Mujhe shaq hai k Hoodbhoy mulhid hai that's why he tends to have a very skeptical position which is fair and he has a right to his opinion but anyways I have a sincere question. Why do you say that about darwin's theory?
True.
A.A Khan Bangkok
Ghamdi Sahib'd arguments are very strong and totally childish points of Pervez Hoodboy. I have lots of respect for Pervez Hoodboy but here I have to say that here Ghamdi Sahb has huge status before those scientists.
Jhola chap doct. Hoga Tum.100percent
I don't believe that you are a PhD, because either you don't know much about the theory of evolution or you are lying, because the theory of evolution hasn't lost credibility, on the contrary it is a fact.
watching a couple of years later, but enjoyed the discussion. questions are good and responses are equally logical by both Ghamidi sb and Ahmed Javed sb.. in love with arguments and the words chosen for this...
Ahmed Javed is just exceptionally advanced
Ufhhhh....ak se badh kar ak personality....
Religion, science, philosophy, meta physics are at peak in this debate....
This discussion is asset and gift to us and all coming generations
Javed gamidhi great scholar.
Well explained
No body among contestants are parallel to Javed Ahmed Ahmed sahab.
Ghamidi sahib is a Legand ❤
Ghamdi sahab live long
I am amazed and annoyed to see ignorant like Mr.Sarmad in such a wonderful debate.he is a big Zero in front of Ghamdi and Javed sb.
Wo jab mo khol raha tha bas science , experiment yahi chilla raha tha
Ghamdi sahb Great scholar
دونوں حضرات قابل تعریف ہیں دونوں جلیل القدر عالم ہیں۔
Ahmed javid sahib and javid ahmed ghamidi are knwoledgeable persons with convincing arguments.......impressive
Ahmed javed sb,the greatest personality
ahmad javaid sb is the most scholar man of all
*کیا آپ اکثریت کے پیچھے چل رہے ہیں؟*
ایک بار حضرت عمر رضى الله بازار میں چل رہے تھے، وہ ایک شخص کے پاس سے گزرے جو دعاء کر رہا تھا،
*"اے الله مجھے اپنے چند لوگوں میں شامل کر، اے الله! مجھے اپنے چند لوگوں میں شامل کر"*
حضرت عمر رضى الله نے اُس سے پوچھا، یہ دعا تم نے کہاں سے سیکھی؟ وہ بولا، الله کی کتاب سے،
الله نے قرآن میں فرمایا ہے:
*"اور میرے بندوں میں صرف چند ہی شکر گزار ہیں۔"*
*(القرآن **34:13**)*
حضرت عمر رضي الله عنه یہ سُن کر رو پڑے اور اپنے آپ کو نصیحت کرتے ہوئے بولے،
"اے عمر ! لوگ تم سے زیادہ علم والے ہیں، اے الله مجھے بھی اپنے اُن چند لوگوں میں شامل کر۔"
ہم دیکھتے ہیں کہ جب ہم کسی شخص سے کوئی گناہ کا کام چھوڑنے کا کہتے ہیں تو وہ کہتا ہے کہ یہ اکثر لوگ کرتے ہیں۔ میں کوئی اکیلا تو نہیں۔
اگر آپ قرآن پاک میں *"اکثر لوگ"* سرچ کریں تو "اکثر لوگ"
*"اكثر لوگ نہیں جانتے"(**7:18**7)*
*"اكثر لوگ شکر ادا نہیں کرتے"(**2:24**3)*
*"اكثر لوگ ایمان نہیں لائے"(**11:17**)*
اگر آپ *"زیادہ تر"* کو سرچ کریں، تو آپ کو ملے گا کہ زیادہ تر لوگ،
*"زیادہ تر شدید نافرمان ہیں"۔ (**5:59**)*
*"زیادہ ترجاہل ہیں" (**6:11**1)*
*"زیادہ تر راہ راست سے ہٹ جانے والے ہیں۔" (**21:24**)*
*"زیادہ ترسوچتے نہیں۔" (**29:23**)*
*"زیادہ تر سنتے نہیں" (**8:23**)*
تو اپنے آپ کو *چند لوگوں* میں ڈالو جن کے بارے میں الله نے فرمایاِ،
*"میرے تھوڑے ہی بندے شکر گزار ہیں"(**34:13**)*
*"اور کوئی ایمان نہیں لایا سوائے چند کے"(**11:40**)*
*"مزے کے باغات میں پچھلوں میں زیادہ هيں اور بعد والوں میں تھوڑے" (**56:12**-14)*
چند لوگوں میں اپنے آپ کو شامل کریں اور اس کی پرواہ نہ کریں کہ اورکوئی اس راستے میں نہیں اور آپ اکیلے ہیں.
كتاب الزھد: احمد بن حنبل رحمة الله
المُصنف: ابن ابى شيبة رحمة الله
بہت عمدہ.
Good and useful debate between opposing opinions and ideas.
Good and Informative Deabate...!!
What a healthy discussion🙏🙏 Much needed Now
ڈاکٹر عقیل الغروی کے بغیر تمام گفتگو ادھوری ہے
Ahmed Javaid Saab raised a very important point about theory of evolution. What a deep thought. Although I may not agree with that creation theory and evolution theory can not coexist. I believe it can.
This program very good
Evolution Designed and Implemented by Allah S.W.T the way he wants is the Answer to the 1st part. Javed Ahmed Ghamidi sahb Explained it very well
Ghamidi as always is very impressive
Ghamdi sahab given reasonable answers
ghamdi is the hero of islam ocean of knowlege infront of gamdi other peopel are drop of water knowledge
VERY TRUE
You really dont know
Very good conference
Ghamdi sab is the most geniuses man in this sitting
Ghamidi :what a legend!
Ahmad javed sb the great
increasing my faith
شاندار!!!!
Ghamidi shb is a very clever man he was slowly taking the poor scientists to his strong zone i.e talking about religion and philosophy and beats them so badly that they don't even remember that what was the topic of debate😂
They should had been talking about their strong zone i.e science and discoveries that challenges the belief systems through out the history then it'll be a worth watching debate
Hood bhy sb it is Darwinian Theory. It's still only a theory not a Law. We can reject, amend or replace a scientific theory .
I am the student of Zoology. I feel it disgusting when a professor of physics (Parwaiz sahab), without having background knowledge of Darwinism, discusses biological evolution in a very confusing way. Host is asking irrelevant questions from irrelevant person.
بالکل میں نے بھی یہی محسوس کیا
ہود صاحب کے پاس کسی قسم کا کوئی متعلقہ نالج نہیں ہے۔وہ تو بس اسلام کے خلاف ہے تاکہ وہ اپنے آپکو زبردستی کا لبرل دکھا سکے۔
Hudbhoy had no clue about what he was asking and giving refs of, especially Quran that he seemed absolutely devoid of its content and spirit. Ahmed Javed is another enlightened scholar who speaks with almost absolute depth of knowledge, logic and references. Javed Ghamidi indeed is a precious pearl in whom I see a 21st century renaissance. Having known both Javeds, it is rather imperative for the state (of Pakistan) to give them charge of the construction or reconstruction of the religious thought in Islam. Having given the true picture and face of Islam - above all Fiqh, sects and factions/fractions - I positively hope millions would convert as Muslims - hundreds of millions of Daleits, western whites, the Yellow and Black races. Besides, the existing 1.7 billion Muslims are also likely to correct their following/direction towards Islam (Deen e Ibrahimi).
no parallel to ghamdi sb , , , , , , , simply
واااہ غامدی صاحب۔
ڈاکٹر ھود صاحب اپ بھی سائنس کے ماہر ہیں۔
در حقیقت گفتگو کا موضوع اتنا وسیع اور گفتگو کا وقت کم۔
بہر حال دلچسپ!
I wanted to listen Ahmad Javed sb but not enough time was given to him.
Ghamidi sahab is saying such a simple logical thing. How come an apparently intelligent scientist like Dr Hoodbhoi cannot get his point. Ghamidi sahab is saying one thing while Dr Hoodbhoi negated him using a completely different point. Ghamidi sahab tried to explain by using an example of poultry farm. He never said that the whole universe was made only for humans but Dr Doodbhoi misunderstood his words & kept on debating that universe was not made only for humans.
Ghamidi sahab is saying ع while Dr Hoodbhoi is saying غ
Javed Ahmed Ghamidi outclassed them all, Ghamidi sahab is a genius...
And Pseudo Scientists do not know there are school of thoughts in science as First Newtonian, then Relativity than String Theory.... Hahaha how stupid scientists have been made to sit there....
He may not be a stupid scientist but he's addicted to poke his nose in the issues he has got no knowledge, specially philosophy and religion. He should better keep learning and teaching physics.
Dont ever make assumptions of "outclass" or "absolutism". Religion like science evolves hence Islam says "Aur aqal walon ke liay nishaniyaan hain [and there are signs ie explore ie to experiment[]". I dont not think Ghamidi sahab or like of Ahmed Javed sahab were dissing Prof's Abassi and Hoodbouy but merely finding a common ground. While you are hell bound about one biased notion that THEY ARE WRONG and WE are RIGHT and Ghamidi/Ahmed sahibaan made it. That us just your thought, not a fact. Abbasi told in his first statement tbat Galileo was shunned by church, today hes is accepted so its apart of evolution, and Ghamidi sahab very eloquently stated that its a difference of philosophy (ir thought process- Ghamidi;s majors are philosophy) and hence very debatable but not in respect of religion.
You, very respectfully, simply missed the point of the discussion!
Do we have a better version of the video? The last few minutes can hardly be followed when Javed Ghamidi was answering a crucial question. Thanks!
Yes its available on youtube
Can you please provide the link Brother Sufyan?
@@sufyanahmad7218 link please
Plz someone share the link of any video of this program in which last 10 minutes have clear sound
اگر زمین میں موجود چیزیں انسان کی خدمت کے لئے نہیں ہیں تو پھر تیل گیس سونا چاندی لوہا تانبا وغیرہ اور دیگر معدنیات کس کے لئے ہیں۔ صرف انسان ہی ان سے نفع اٹھانا اور ان تک رسائی حاصل کرنا جانتا ہے۔
😂😂😂
فرقے تو رحمت ہیں ۔۔۔ جیسے سائنسی دبستان بھی مختلف ہیں۔
i wish you could have clear voice at the end part of the program for at least last 15 minutes.
10000 biologosts deny the theory of Darwinism
Inshallah, a time will come when the last ten minutes of this debate will b rectified with the help of IA
Ghamidi is on another level no match what so ever.
There is an error in the last few mins. Please uplaod the good quality video.
ghamidi is best .super hero
Yr plz do upload last 10 minutes video
Javed Ahmad Ghamdi Sahib aur Ahmad Javed Sahib sy bohat kuch seekhny ko mila aur baqi do to bachy hain deen to kya science bhe nahi janty hain.....
علماء عام آدمی سے يقيناً برتر ھيں۔ جاويد احمد غامدی صاحب کے جوابات دلائل پر مبنی ھيں۔
What has been happening in this video ending? question
Ghamdi sahb the great
i feel that ghamidi sb is imam e waqet.
زیادہ ہو گیا بھائی صاحب یہ
@@MohiyoDeenجی۔ بہت ہی زیادہ ہو گیا
I agree