Muslim questions origins of Sikhi! #4 Sikhs @ Speakers Corner Hyde Park London
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 жов 2015
- On Sunday 20th Sept, Basics of Sikhi Street Parchar team went to Speakers Corner in Hyde Park London. We spoke to many people of different faiths, including 3 Muslims. Here is the first Muslim debater! Watch till the end!
Basics of Sikhi is a project by Everythings 13, an educational charity dedicated to spreading the wisdom of the Sikh Gurus. Please support our work - bit.ly/1cRKGdz - Whether its £5 a month or £50, all will go towards parchar and NOT building funds.
Vaheguru Simran in the Intro and Outro is how Sikhs chant Gods name. You can download it for free from www.thekdp.com (Jam 2, track 6).
Follow us online
fb page @ everythings13.basicsofsikhi
twitter @everythings_13
Instagram @basicsofsikhi
MP3s www.soundcloud.com/basicsofsikhi
Every Sikh i have ever come across has been a good person, respect to Sikhs.
They very good Doctors magic they dont mess about
...
Jesus Christ is the only hope in this world no other gods will lead you to heaven
There is no security or hope with out Jesus Christ in this world come and repent of all sins today
Today is the day of salvation come to the loving savior Today repent and do not go to hell
Come to Jesus Christ today
Jesus Christ is only way to heaven
Repent and follow him today seek his heart Jesus Christ can fill the emptiness he can fill the void
Heaven and hell is real cone to the loving savior today
Today is the day of salvation tomorrow might be to late come to the loving savior today
Holy Spirit Can give you peace guidance and purpose and the Lord will
John 3:16-21
16 For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. 17 For God sent not his Son into the world to condemn the world; but that the world through him might be saved. 18 He that believeth on him is not condemned: but he that believeth not is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God. 19 And this is the condemnation, that light is come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil. 20 For every one that doeth evil hateth the light, neither cometh to the light, lest his deeds should be reproved. 21 But he that doeth truth cometh to the light, that his deeds may be made manifest, that they are wrought in God.
Mark 1.15
15 And saying, The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God is at hand: repent ye, and believe the gospel.
2 Peter 3:9
The Lord is not slack concerning his promise, as some men count slackness; but is longsuffering to us-ward, not willing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance.
Hebrews 11:6
6 But without faith it is impossible to please him: for he that cometh to God must believe that he is, and that he is a rewarder of them that diligently seek him.
Jesus
Beautiful answer brother. Sikhism is the only religion made for the service of humanity
That's not the main thing , sikhs are here to grow and the service to humanity is to spread the joy of being compassionate and serving others it is very good for the soul and good to encourage others to also share similar values and put them into practice
One thing to remember is Sikhi is not here for people to take for granted because they are a sovereign nation and people must recognize sikhs are amazing people and hindus and muslims need to stand with them
Difference between ideal and reality !?
Sikhs are most rated no 1, as using as drugs ND girl child foticide in India ?
They are designated as kudimaar ?
Wow. Dealing with that guy with a smile. Jagraj Singh was a real warrior 🌸
dude where is he? (later joiner)
@@Singhangteshwer he passed.
Rip to that man
@@hiphophrc This Sikh bro in Video is Jagraj Singh?
How did he passed..what happened?
@@akhere4279 he passed away due to cancer
I would LOVE to watch him debate dr zakir naik, i would pay money for it. He is so good at articulating his answer, remaining respect and no gibberish unlike Dr Zakir.
Arshad Rana This is not true at all, firstly people have converted to Sikhi by their own will.... Not everyone that is a Muslim is educated themselves many are born in Muslim families and out of fear do not look outside of Islams teachings... Kids are beaten by the Mulvi and parents force kids to read the Quran, their is a such a thing called Social conditioning..... also the religion is not important, what is how you connect to God and live a righteous path this can be found in Christianity and Islam but i believe is easier through Sikhism because of the reaching and what is said.
Bunty B zakir nayak cant do debate he can only make fool by set up
@Raja Sameer I have no idea what you are talking about mate.
RIP ❤️🙏
Hahahahaha Debating is bullshit. only energy is sex, if you channelize well it is only truth all other things religion came out of it.
Well, I don't believe in religion of any kind but Sikhism is kind of cool. If I ever did find religion (probably never but who could be sure?) I would definitely consider Sikhism.
Paul what r you waitind for? ,, leave, if , behind , read from holy Guru Granth Saheb , download Gurbani Nirvaan app , or some other app of Gurbani , try to understand sikhi ,in English translation , . , no need to waste time ,, release if from yourself and try to understand truth which is inside you .
@@kulbirlal330 Well, first I'd have to believe in a god of some kind. Then I'd have to be convinced that he was a personal god. Then I'd have to be convinced of the tennents, practices, dogmas or whatever else was involved in Sikhism. I'm not going to believe in something just because I like it or admire it or anything like that. But I think wearing the turban would be cool. But again, that's not a reason to believe in something.
Try to understand the truth inside me? Well, I could be wrong but I think I already did that. I've asked every religious person who wanted a discussion for evidence. I get arguments. Most of which are fallacious. I was raised in a strict southern baptist household and slowly over many years I realized one thing after another after another that didn't add up. If that's not trying to understand the truth inside, what is? Are you sure you considered all the angles? Maybe you haven't yet tried to discover the truth inside. I don't mean to sound accusatory but a lot of religious people are devoted to their belief. Meaning it's not the end result of critical inquiry. It's accepted for other reasons.
@overthehill91 It seem much more appealing than Christianity, Islam and some others though. I feel like I could be pals with a Sikh without crazy religious inspired political opinions getting in the way.
But I hear you.
We need God, not a cool religion, really.
Jesus Christ meets all your needs
@@anuradhakadam7907 He's dead.
I’m not a theologian or an expert and I come from a Christian background.
I have read the Christian Bible and studied much of the Quran and the Vedas and Gita, but all have fallen short for me and left me with so many questions, as there seems to be so many contradictions.
However, Sikhism seems much different and it appeals to me very much.
I like that it is about spirituality and not “religion”.
I like that it is truly about practicing equality and tolerance, as opposed to just preaching it.
I like that it is focused on “works”.
I like that it is monotheistic.
It seems like it is founded wholly on love and spreading love and living it. Love of God and from God. Love of self. And love of others.
May Satguru Nanak Dev Ji Maharaj bless us all with love and wisdom ♥️♥️🙏
YEAH a sikhi is not a religion but a community where the sikh is taught {through shri guru granth sahib} and to sreve for good of people .
@@Simpledays0 hahahahahahhah and hinduism is not a religion too nor is sanatana dharma they are not religions JUST A WAY OF LIFE OR A COMMUNITY JUST LIKE SIKHI
@@tejbirsingh1387 Yeh that's true jain, hindu, sikh and budh are not religion, these are way of life and culture of bharat that's why all of them use dharma after their name . Dharma means Seeker, learner and follow the righteous path. Religion just bind people you have example of Muslim.
But dharma give freedom to people what to choose, what to follow be atheist or not.
@@tejbirsingh1387 Sanatana dharma follow by all of us. Some ways of sanatana dharma follow by sikhs, some ways by jain, some ways by budhism and but many ways by hindu because hindu are so much different from each other.
Thank you brother! The Sikh faith enriches my own understanding of my Christian faith, especially when it comes to contemplation.
I just had to Grab some popcorn before watching this!!!
+The Turbanator This might be a Stupid question, but Did you put Butter on you're Popcorn?
+That Guy There is NO such thing as a "Stupid Question", and YES i did put butter on my Popcorn!!!
+Jai Hind still waiting for the Main Debate
your popcorn will finish but, this stupid stores will not
same place, same moment..one can see A Singh who is so much down to earth besides a person of this world badly trapped in his ego!
it's so rare to see outside of India I'm so happy people like him exist
Veer ji You are doing the bestest thing the sikhs need at this point of time...chardikala bakshaan aap ji nu baba ji
You need to make more speakers corner videos...this is a good message that more people need to hear especially Muslims
As a muslim, I find the Sikh Guy brilliant.
Jakir Nayak chutiya hai
Veer ji, I am so blessed I discovered these videos of yours today.
This guy is enlightened, love his sense of humor:)... and a compassionate soul speaking, don't care much for anything else labels and such.
very impressively handled, however the crowd was too infant to understand reality and hence sikhi
Every one is on their vastaav Guru aap kich lenda!
Bro your words are deep I’m glad I found these videos defo going to be a better Sikh 🙏🏽 thank you
Respect man, you are good carry on being the great person you are. I'm signed up.
amazing as always,
Please upload all the videos from Speakers Corner. WJKK WJKF
He spoke with great humility and patients, may he rest in peace.
Superb explanation....love this guy.
Jagraj veer, You are a reflection of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale.
+Kj Singh Not even a reflection of the dust on their feet unfortunately
+Basics of Sikhi - someone capable of being a reflection of Sant ji would also say something along those lines. :)
+Kj Singh chill lol
You cant compare anyone to Sant Bhindranwale. please think before making such Comments
+Amba Singh - ji, i did not compare, i said *reflection* (of his teachings). Please read carefully Amba ji, no disrespect.
(This comment applies to all 3 of
these debate videos) The people challenging Bhai Jugraj Singh have simply come with
closed minds, despite their illogical arguments against Sikhi being addressed
by Bhai Sahib they continually repeat the same questions and sound like a
broken record, replaying. The people asking the questions are ‘opinionated’
and hence refuse to change their opinions in spite of facts to the contrary.
Often opinionated people refuse to listen to anything that even remotely
contradicts their opinion. Bhai Jugraj knows what he is talking about however his
opponents in the debate are Intransigent but:- “Facts do not cease to exist
because they are ignored.” (Aldous Huxley), Bhai Jugraj
also disengages gracefully. Thank you
Bhai Jugraj for setting the record straight.
God bless you veerji.
bhai sahib bhai Nand lal says.."rasta(dharam) koi vi chun par manzill khuda nu rakhi" je manzil hi tu naked virgins nu rakhi baitha ta..bas fer "Vashna badha ave jaye".
utmost respect for bhai sahib bhai jugraj singh ji.
Sir you are doing great job just carry on ...Hats of you sir I really admire the sikhism.
VJKK VJKF, thank you as always for your great videos. I have a question because I thought that in sikhi there wasn't a concept like hell. I thought that a human being could live as a gurmukh (the highest "level"), as sanmukh o manmukh and then God will decide if you reincarnate or not, of course depending on your actions, but never heard about a concept of hell. It sounds to me like a punishment and I thought there was nothing like that in sikhi. Could you explain a little bit more about it? Thank you so much again. Greetings from Chile.
VJKK VJKF bhenji, punishment can be as a lower life form or in hell.. its a place reserved for people who didn't even deserve a life yet
hell is a temporary place in which a person gos after death, however there are multiple hells. it is dependent on what u did in ur life
This man is a wonderful public speaker. Such a nice demeanour and extremely intelligent 👌
what a stupid question 07:40
ikr
+kawaljeet singh I think that guy was commenting on the Islamic concept of men getting to have countless wives in Jannah (Heaven). That is why they showed the Islamic preacher after his question was asked.
+Zoroastrianism-Islam-Sikhism so they wants to go the heaven just because of girls ? You might be right but i think you didn't heard what he said, when jagraj paaji answered his question he goes "Whats the point of going to the heaven?"
kawaljeet singh When he says "then what's the point of going to heaven" after he hears the response is no he is joking. You can hear the other members of the audience laugh at his joke. In a way I think the man asking the question is trying to show how unrealistic and silly the Islamic view of heaven is.
+kawaljeet singh That guy is a pervert
That guy near the end asking about the afterlife is really rude, damn.
I've just recently found your videos and I love taking time out to listen to the teachings. The concept of hell has always been an interesting topic, so would for eg hitler got to hell ...?
Many Sikhs I met deny the concept of hell. One of Sikh friends told me hell was naar in Sikhism, and a reference he gave me is when Guru Gobind Singh said whoever takes me as God such go to hell. What is hell? Any description? Also, any other references besides this one?
Thank you SM.
what about that person who was constantly trying to grab your attention? you didn't even listen to his question. Is that part yet to be uploaded?
Waheguru Ji, is there a link to #3 Sikhs @ Speakers Corner Hyde Park London. Couldn't find it anywhere.
+INDERJIT SINGH Look in the Street Parchar Playlist or seach on google, its the one about Langar Week
Great Reply...give to them
Bole so nihal sat sri akal,Guru nanak dev ji is great.
Sound of singing prising God, is what maintain the universe, physicist know today that the universe is shaped and maintained by vibration and light =) stay blessed beautiful soul 🌾
Whatever the sikh gentleman said i agree. Sikh gurus were learned scholars and philosophers . They didn't just simply take the good things from other religions and create sikhism
where can I get to listen to this full song which is at the end of this video (waheguru chanting)?
Nanak predates mughal empire by almost 100 years 🤔🤔🤔 definitely a reaction lol
WAHEGURU JI
HIS charisma IS AMAZING
What a great example bhai jagraj has given about guru and akalpurakh..if god is sun guru is a moon who's reflecting light of sun in the dark... wonderful man..//
Excellent!
Nothing but respect to a good human.
No one noticed but as jagraj singh gives the example of the sun. The sun literally brights up waheguru rip veerji
very well spoken
Love you my Sikh brother 🙏
Lovely Sikh man
Where is no 3
I want to get waheguru tune which play before the video. It is quite satisfy.
A question- when people go against you and sikhi, how do you control yourself?
Where is don't recommend channel option UA-cam?
what about the people who existed before guru nank dev ji, they didn't get a chance to get guidance, what would have happened to them in afterlife?
those who didnt get salvation because of good deeds and chanting Gods Name, they get to come back into reincarnation
Yasir Khan they prayed to their origin
They have knowledge before that as well. Guru nanak organised one different path to achieve that ways according to time and fit in kaliyuga. But these all knowledge before that as well and peoples follow it. All the hindu scripture are very old and are from starting of this earth. These all are concept of sanatana dharma which is eternal.
Where can i download the introductory waheguru tune
I don't know why do people compare two Religion or try to convert others it absolutely depends upon individual choices
...because, sometimes people of one faith try to interfere into the faith of other people. Such people must be put right back in their place.
Because you guys blind believe in your books without any proof
@@adilafsar5941 oh so u have quran signed by so called self claimed prophet Muhammad?
so according to this if I come back as a animal or a bird I will be stuck in that form for ever , coz clearly I would have no concept of right or wrong .
someone plz confirm I am right or wrong
+mrsimmerpreetsingh That time as a bird may well be your punishment to learn a lesson, then you move on.
S. Jugraj Singh is living a Thug Life.... Like a boss :)
To the pure, all things are pure, to the base, all things are base.
Just face it there will always be animosity between muslims and sikh till all hell breaks loose.
Beautiful Message
What a bid difference to most Muslims. Calm, respectful rational arguing.... now you can see why nobody says something against Sikhs
PLS reply ihave a question
I request to all my sikh veer plz wstch wstch thid video completr it will clear many misunderstanding
Veer ji tusi himat ni chhadi te guru de teachings de anusar answer dinde gaye...
I like to concept of Sikhism, that you just need to be a good person basically and chant God's name. But in regards to reincarnation, how do they know you turn into an animal or something once you die? Because I dont remember my past life as an animal?
It would seem more logical if you got reincarnated into another human and could have another shot... if some Sikh could explain the above question it would be greatly appreciated, thanks!
+Umar Ali There are a few incidences in which people have remembered their previous lives.
- There are numerous references in Gurbani (Guru's words) regarding Reincarnation to make humans realise that the the Human life is a rare opportunity that we have obtained after a long series of life and birth cycles. So as it is told by the Guru, and we believe in Guru's words. (I can write down some of them if u require)
- For a spiritual person as the state of mind rises, the knowledge of previous lives starts coming up. Not just about your lives but about the creation of GOD. Its Like opening up of Secret door.
+Umar Ali Idea or reincarnation is strictly based on choices and expectations we make in life. We Sikhs see this as Universe's (God's) way of balancing the accounts. If a friend of mine owe me money and i want it so desperately that on me last time all i am thinking about is my money then universe will let me come back and have it (human or non-human way). It is not the money that matters in this case, it is my expectation of happiness from money. That happiness can be in any form. It is not just about money, it could be love of another being, service of society/nation etc.
But human body is best designed to follow the path of God. and if that is what someone wants the most but did not have the level on understanding for it. He/she will get another chance to further acquire the knowledge/understanding to move on the path of God.
Metaphorical reincarnation can be understood as if soul is a software installed on hardware of a body. Every time hardware get damaged software needs to move to another hardware. During the transfer, user data (memories) are zipped because new hardware may not handle it all. Later hardware is further developed with age but software get so involved with other operations and forgets the code to unzip the old data. May be this is why most us do not remember past life. But people who meditate and learn to go deep in mind do remember this.
But obviously there is no direct scientific proof of reincarnation. However there is some evidence and theories for it. A scientific research was done by Canadian psychiatrist Ian Stevenson on this. Also, one of the developing theories of reality, Orch-OR see soul as quantum information and see reincarnation as transfer of information.
***** Its not about caring.
The point is your Past affects your present and your Present actions will affect your future.
I am saying this in reference to all the shabads regarding "purab janam"
I like them analogies, thanks for the information brothers!
+Happs 85 So Kindly Give reference from Gurbani from where you are getting this idea that your past deeds has no value
The Sikhs brothers talks about their beliefs, but they don't talk the origin of their beliefs and why is true and how can we assess it to be true?
Hamad Mutawa watch the video again my Man... Nobody has a proof of what is right or what is wrong or what is true and whats not... If you say how can we accept! Nobody has ever seen God... So noone can tell what's the truth... But what you can do is follow the path what you like or understand more..
Love
👑 DHAN DHAN SRI WAHEGURU JI
DHAN DHAN SAT GURU NANAK DEV Ji👑
WAHEGURU JI BLESS ALL HIS CREATIONS. 🙏
WAHEGURU JI BABA NANAK JI🙏 bless all HIS creations with Simran NAAM JAAP🙏
Heaven is to merge our soul with GOD. Its not a place to enjoy your incomplete lust. Love for sikkim ❤️❤️
Wrong, heaven is also temporary. Their is moksha concept which means union of your soul with god. Like mostly bhramchari used to do.
I've watched a couple of videos of this guy and it's always him that gets asked stupid questions lol
At 0:30, the Muslim Guy finally advocating the Acts of Radical Muslim Rulers(like Aurangzeb).
Just Notice to his tone.
WaheGuru Ji Da Khalsa, WaheGuru Ji Di Fateh🙏
The British public like the beliefs and principles of Sikhi . But will never incorporate them such as Conquering the Panj Vikar .
Find it hard that some Muslims believe in Heavan as a place of lust where there a virgins waiting for men
Vaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa
Vaheguroo Jee Ki Fateh
I am waiting for you now even you are not virgin and even I am Muslim. hahahaha
If you read and understand properly, whom I reply and why? you will not comment on me.
Harprit Lakhan CHAOS
The Qur'an is just a fallacy . Very misleading and devoid of spirituality
Or as a pig !! My god that was so funny to me
Gurfateh and Salutations to Basic of Sikhi and sangat. What BOS is doing is great but let all remember people not to get egotistical when we enter or listen to these debates, because it is the same ego that all of these other religions have adopted and accepted to dominate over others with their mockery and ideology over us.
If you are to learn anything from these video than remember this Singh is showing GYAN of GURMAT, SACH of AKAAL PURAKH and NO FEAR.
With respect,,, is it true that the first guru was a Muslim?,
Also why do sikh not cut hair??
1 no
2 only baptised sikh (khalsa warriors) don’t cut thier hair beacause these kesh give u real look if warrior
Islam is the middle way like you do. But the hand of god always move from heart to heart
ਬਹੁਤ ਕੁੱਝ ਸਿੱਖਣ ਨੂੰ ਮਿਲੀਆ ਇਸ ਨਿਮਾਣੇ ਤੋਂ 🙏
Paji i dont know about afterlife , however if i may /hell and heaven both are on earth . It all depends on how u choose to live life . Heaven is under your parents shadow ,your partners love etc . If you disrespect your elders or insult your younger ones you are as it is living in hell . Nowadays we all live mostly in hell n partially in heaven. Guru ji must have talked about afterlife that most of us are unaware off . Anyhow thanks basics of sikhi , your videos are really helping me understand our religion . Please forgive me if i had said anything disrespectful to u or hurt any ones view .
This Sick man wants to put some poison in Sikhs mind, but the Sikh Bro replied him in an awesome way👍
Prophet Muhammed is mentioned in Gran Saab
rm187loco does that mean islam is the truth?
You're bit confused and making people confuse. I think here you Failed to explain Sikhism and that non sense laughing guy is just disgusting.
i respect this sikh person.geeta is spoken by god shri krishan ji to shri arjun ji. it tells us how can we live our life?,how can we think?what is karma?which karma is best for us?.it is summary of veda and upnishad.it very very deep like ocean.it is not a simple book .in shri bhagwat geeta (book)every slok(word) spoken by god.hindu religion is not only a religion it is way of life.in india many religions have come out from it.
I like it! Well done. Option 1 is actually Christian, I think.
What is the source of 4 options when you die?
My interpretation of Guru Granth Sahib is either union with God or separation from God (reincarnation).
+sukraat You should read Guru Granth Sahib ji more ji, you will see references to all this
If i go to one part of the world and see marvelous buildings and another part of the world and see other marvelous buildings that means that the underlying principles of making the buildings have to be the same. Each culture might have came to understands these principles in a different way but they are still the same. One of those principles is mathematics. God is the common denominator that the universe is built on.
everyone can remain silent to benefit himself, will very rarely correct the mistake because it will make you burn, like the prophet has been lived by
Sikhi is same as Dharma I mean most of
Maulik Dhameliya they’re saint soldiers
Is sach Khand and heaven the same thing?
Judged and get in
+simaran Yes Heaven and Such Khand is the same thing
+simaran With Guru's Blessing, I think Sach khand is the final stage of bliss, which v will be getting from NAAM(meditaion) while we are still alive( Dharam Khand,gyan khand, Saram Khand,Karam Khand and final Sach Khand ) like many saints and GURU's live their life in that BLISS only.............on the other hand after we die and if we got mukti....then we will be in Full Bliss at HEAVEN !!!
+Happs 85 Bro, recommend you read a book called, The Mystical Invisible World. By Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji.
+Happs 85 Gurbani does not reject the existence of heaven and hell only that these destinations are not sought after by the Sikhs because Sikhs strive to get Sachkhand which is much above any of these places.
Hindu dude in red just mad he can't grow hair
I know Sheikh Uthman Ibn Farooq Subhanallah, when will you visit Indonesia again, Subhanallah. Stay healthy, Sheikh, hopefully in the protection of Allah Subhana wa Taala
In the beginning, I feel like the argument was flawed. If a person is is still deep in delusion we don't have to label them a "liar". There could be many spiritual leaders who are world renown, respected, appearing in holy books but at the same time they may have wrong understanding . I wouldn't say they are liars, but rather they are lacking right understanding. What I'm trying to say is criticizing the validity of a person's claims doesn't equate to saying they are a liar.
Jagraj definitely has some sort of grudge or attitude towards Muslims.
By the way rest in peace jugraj Singh.
What's wrong with calling the guru a liar? You can't use "how would you like it if I called your Prophet a liar? Would you like it?" that's got nothing to do with anything.
watvid1 the thing is guru ji never lied, so why should we call him a liar?
@Supreet Virk Truthful Sikh Not even going to ask where you get your info from lol
+R singh - I think you are really exaggerating the situation and have been pretty badly brainwashed to say the least.
Some people are fat minded and do not understand there own religion how could you ask for these things bro you do have very good patients
Just go and have debate about Islam with Muslim profeesor
Haha the Chocolate Story was funny,
Sahabah said" i see the face of muhammad like the moonlight"... Islam is not religion. Islam is the last point of life experience. The truth is truth, when and wherever you find it
Parchar did a great job making the gentlemen realize his inconsiderateness.