Would you trust a Temu 80A electrical connector?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 тра 2024
- Without full metallurgy tests it's hard to say exactly what alloy this electrical connector is made of. The attraction of a strong neodymium magnet was very slight, even with the outer plating and nearby steel screws removed. I'll guess a brass alloy with a nickel plating.
A subsequent test on random brass plumbing fittings also showed a very slight attraction of the same magnet.
Brass is technically an alloy of copper and zinc, with the colour being affected by the ratio. With the cost of copper these days, it's no surprise that it looked a light golden colour, suggesting more zinc than copper. Then again, I'm sure there are probably cheap alloys being made that look like brass to cut costs.
In this application the chunkiness and very close vicinity of the coupled wires is probably a benefit for the application of acting as a single pole power distribution block.
China has a huge manufacturing industry, so it's no surprise that they have a lot of machine components at fairly low prices. This block cost £3 which compared favourably with a similar distribution block from a UK seller at £12.
I'd consider this block for personal panel projects, but not for an industrial application where the cost of machine down-time makes the use of prominent brand items more important.
If you enjoy these videos you can help support the channel with a dollar for coffee, cookies and random gadgets for disassembly at:- www.bigclive.com/coffee.htm
This also keeps the channel independent of UA-cam's algorithm quirks, allowing it to be a bit more dangerous and naughty.
#ElectronicsCreators - Наука та технологія
All I read was "would you trust a temu" and instant said no.
Same. Not even an option.
Same
Precisely 😊
All my homies don't trust no temu
I was about to make this exact comment.
You should hand it off to PhotonicInduction to test the 80A claim
Well he'd probably start with 80 kA just for fun. ("Oops looks like I've misread that")
@@PapaLurts "Oops, popped it!"
I'm sure Andy is doing great (I sure hope so), but we are all missing out on some great potential collaborations. I would so much like a coop between Clive, Andy, Mehdi and lets throw in Techmoan and 8-Bit-Guy for the memes.
How is he still alive?
Or just save on the shipping and test it with an 80-120Ah car battery
tin is paramagnetic, so it'll be slightly attracted to a magnet.
a nickel plating would make it more attractive... and more expensive.
As for the "brass"...
954 aluminium bronze "looks" like brass and has about 5% iron, which will make it slightly magnetic. It's a common alloy for plumbing fittings.
It's considerably cheaper than brass.
it's also has like 4x as much electrical resistance.
Best way to tell the difference is to drill it.
Brass drills easily
954 is harder to drill and is very "grabby".
Quality of plastics is always a good sign of decent products.
Hahahaha China:)
I opine that poor plastics are bad, and better plastic is meh.
Legos are made of good quality ABS. We could fool a lot of people into expecting better quality by using more ABS plastic in things.
@@markiangooley Yes but its expensive and verry accurate too.
@@markiangooleyit depends on the use case. And bad abs exists. Abs is not oil resistant, it doesn’t even work with vegetable oil. Btdt.
Iron is very poorly soluble in both the alpha and beta phases of brass, so it precipitates as a ferromagnetic secondary phase, which could explain the slight attraction to a magnet. As for the naming, the Chinese term for brass is literally yellow copper, so it often gets mistranslated as just copper (or more likely "mistranslated", if you catch my drift).
I think the screws are made from steel and he did not removed them as he tested it, so they are this what was ferromagnetic, not the brass itself.
@@mikropower01 That must be some incredible powerful magnet, if it still attracts anything a good few centimeters away from a ferromagnetic material.
It looks to be nickel plated, and nickel is ferromagnetic.
nickel is magnetic...
@@kosir1234 - There is a big steel screw within a distance of 3mm of the Neodym magnet.
With such a quality connection this would make, at 80A you may also find it doubles as a space heater. I can imagine the fun, melty goodness that could come from something like this when running at 80A!
My home lightning arrestor claims to handle 100,000 amps. Funny there don't seem to be any cables large enough connected to it. Maybe they count the bolts that pass it by.
>"bottom out"
>"i shall grind this bottom"
the innuendo. 😳😳😳
I'm pretty sure this is why Big Clive content *always* leaves me with a warm feeling inside... ❤🔥🏳🌈🍾😉
@@dieseldragon6756 you dirty wee man!😂
If the plating is nickel it would explain the slight magnetic effect. I wonder of it is still magnetic when all the screws are removed and the plating ground off.
yep came here to say that, thick nickel plate is certainly magnetic
“I shall grind the bottom here” slip of the tongue, ooh err.
@@TheChipmunk2008 Likewise - Great minds and all that!
I removed the plating and screws and it still had a very slight attraction. I also tested the magnet on a couple of brass plumbing fittings and it had a similar light attraction.
@@bigclivedotcom interesting
My eyes were looking at the end of the title for the obligatory "With Schematic"... now that would have been an interesting view!
Here's the schematic for anyone interested:
┌o-o-o-o┐
└-O-O-O-┘
I've seen that silvery "brass" alloy in many cheap electrical devices, it's always super brittle with huge grains in the metal. I always figured it was basically pot metal from whatever scrap they had on hand, as they don't seem to be too picky about meeting specifications.
yep. If you torque to spec, it just bursts.
Chinesium can be pretty hit and miss, they have a saying that basically goes "you get what you pay for" and if you try buying for cheap without proper connections you'll definitely get scammed.
White brass like this is pretty common in other places, like taps and the likes. It is absolutely the wrong kind of brass to use for electrical connections. White brass is not intended or remotely a good idea for situations where any plastic deformation is required.
You'd have to be _on_ pot 🚽 to trust that any alloy coming from Temu is anything close to the claims made in the listing... 🍁😉
The main thing I would be concerned about is if they always send the same item when ordering from the listing. No guarantee that they don't swap out what they're selling at some point for something much sketchier.
Exactly what I thought. Temu could easily throw out _Good enough_ product up to the point several high-profile UA-camrs review it, and *then* start shipping out the _real_ Chinesium... ⚠
@@dieseldragon6756 I was thinking more likely that they would open up shop running at a loss to build a customer base and reputation before cutting costs right down to the bone, but accumulating UA-cam reviews is definitely a possibility as well
Yeah, that’s the problem with TEMU and the like. You might get something perfectly adequate, but you just don’t know. That’s what reputation is for: to have confidence that you can trust the product.
That's almost certainly nickel-plated brass.
In regards to the 80A rating, I reckon it could probably take 80A fairly well - It looks thick enough. I'm surprised that a Temu product is actually fairly legitimate.
Yeah, in that case the CE sign one could spot on it might actually be genuine
I agree and I've seen stuff we pay a lot more for and completely cut down to the bone. Looks ok to me.
its not like Temu actually manufacture anything. This is just like any other chinese product, sold without any accountability through a large company. To me the question often is, would it actually make financial sense to produce a really bad version of a product? The market of people you can essentially scam with niche industrial parts is probably not worth it, so you're probably better off producing something actually usable.
Repeatability is a real problem. You don't know if the next order came from the same factory
I agree - here in Aus, a Weidmuller block is $95 vs plenty of variations of the Temu item at $10-15. Many of the cheapo ones have certifications stamped on them, but who knows if they're genuine. Anyhow, I'd happily use this block for projects, just not in my house electrical box where a fire started by such a thing would void insurance.
Flame 🔥 test on the plastic would possibly be interesting.
Its pretty easy to make it retardant I'd imagine it is ignition protected. But only one way to find out....
.. and check if you can carbonate it, please. For science.
😂😂😂@@Tuning3434
Our electrical material heavily relies on PVC, so i always believed it to be highly flammable. Isn't it?
But if you order it again, will you get the same thing?
That's always an unknown variable from China.
I've used them for battery systems. - work well and don't heat up at the rated load. I've mostly screwed them to the enclosure backplate but have put them on DIN rail in the past. Just make sure you properly tighten the hex screws.
These look absolutely spot on for earthing blocks in camper conversions
Dunno if I'd trust _anything_ from Temu for CPC purposes, especially after seeing some of the fault currents you can get flowing through PME links as demonstrated in other videos on this platform... ⚡🔌🌍😳
Finding the density of the block would help. Take out the screws first, weigh it and then use a measuring cup to see how much water it displaces. Worst case with something like that block, measure it accurately and make allowances for the holes to figure out its volume.
I use density this way to separate out Zamak scrap from aluminium for melting and casting.
Eureka!
such a sophisticated measurement tool
Love this type of content! Happy you made it over 1 million followers, I was in around the 300k mark.
I would trust it to 30-35 amps for personal projects.
brave man
@mattsan70 why it's less than half of the rated amperage
@@stevetobias4890 Well the clamping system to begin with. It is garbage at making great conduct with the wire (not bad for like 6A applications), which at 80A is crucial. It is the same single screw you find on the cheap terminal strips, it should be at least 2 screws per wire at 32+A and preferaby with a clamp, not just a screw, so the wire is making contact through its entire surface. And at these current ratings, i better see plated copper, both for heat and for conductivity. Plus it is temu, this one is brass, the next is inox steel, the other is made from scrap metal with chrome spray paint.
Yeah, my concern is also less with the block itself and more with the quality of clamping - If your block starts to melt, it won't be because not enough copper, it will be because your contact resistance is shit.
Yeah, that checks out with my experience
The contact screws being made of steel, is the weak link.
They didn't spend the extra for brass screws.
Nice that you have tested it.
I would trust it about as much as Gary Glitter in a kids home .
Looks pretty good !
"Eriflex" is the brand we use at work. We use them with 480 for small power distribution.
I designed an earthquake simulation lab apparatus that used 460VAC power to pump massive amounts of water thru a very small and cramped lab. I kept asking for water ingress-protected enclosures and controls but they're expensive... so eventually when the dean, dept chair, and two visiting grant program managers came to witness a demonstration I had our usual safety brief and said, "and as always I cannot stress how dangerous this side of the room is; please just do not come over here, look at, and especially do not touch anything. These circuit breakers are here to protect the building from fire and will not activate if you become part of the circuit."
The next day I had my capital expense approval for a whole new electrical cabinet. With name-brand parts!
They are great and modular with a connection clip on the side. I have used them up to 300A
Before deciding to trust this device by looking at it:
Look up the lug torque specification of a similar device of a reputable seller. Tighten the lugs of the Temu device to the reputable device's specified torque specification.
Now you're ready to decide whether or not to trust that Temu device.
looks like a copy of the Erico UD-80A, so bottom connections = 3.5 Nm top connections = 1.2 Nm
It seems good enough for hobby projects, but for actual installations I would not risk it and get components from a reputable seller. Just to make sure.
Are your hoppy 80A different from domestic supply ? Assuming the cheap plastic is still there holding it off the metalwork.
Three ports on the 6 mm side, so can do 3-phase leads in one of those! Brilliant design.
I've just started to embrace DIN-rail stuff at the observatory. Not for power distribution, but organizing our motion-controller cabinet. I had previously thought that DIN-rail stuff was expensive, but in general, that's not the case. Soooo, coming up with ways of mounting "weird things" to the DIN rails we're putting inside the enclosure. Mostly based on generic circuit-board mounting brackets for DIN rails--they can be adapted for other uses with the addition of off-the-shelf angle brackets and the like.
There's a metric crap-tonnne of "custom DIN-rail mount for " on Thingiverse. If we had a decent 3D printer...
for mounting PCBs on a DIN-Rail we use brackets from Phoenix Contact or Weidmüller... they sell a plastic profile that can be cut to the desired length and end/mid brackets for mounting
YES! I would! But only up to ten amps.
The slight magnetism was probably the steel screws. Zinc will vaporise well below the melting point of iron so a zinc, copper, iron alloy would be very difficult to make. I suppose the silver coating could be Nickel which would make it slightly magnetic. If it's Nickel coated brass then it is pretty scookem.
Perfect for use in DIY lightning conductors 🌩
Considering you can run about 80 amps continuously down 8ga wire, I'd say there's probably enough material there for 80 amps to flow through. Gotta get a TIG/Stick welder to generate 80 amps for testing purposes. lol.
I agree, there is enough material there. It is the quality of the connections that is probably the biggest issue. You need a very high quality connection to put 80A through it safely. This looked like it should be capable of forming good connections, but that is what I would have tested.
Naval and architectural brass have quite a bit of iron in the alloy and are mildly magnetic.
The brass alloy is probably an alloy with a low (50% or slightly less) copper content. Saves them on materials costs. Bulk conductivity wouldn't be as good as alloys with more copper in them, also somewhat more brittle than a higher-copper brass alloy.
My estimation would be 0,5% Copper, 2,5% Nickel, 77% Aluminium, and 21% _„finest“_ Chinesium... 😉
Innuendo bingo:
“I’ll go deeper”
“Let’s bottom this”
His content _always_ leaves me with a warm feeling inside... ❤🔥🍾😉
It has the BC seal of approval.
I use that kind of thing all the time at my day job. Automation Dircect has good prices. Not sponsored, we buy their stuff all the time.
when Hell freezes over, but it never will with products like this adding to the heat. :-)
Check hardness.... just a quick test with a springloaded centerpunch will probably show this to be cartridge brass, which is gummy and kind of horrible to work with but very popular among the Chinese manufacturers. Likely fine for the application where you're not screwing those screws in and out all the time but not a good plan if there is a lot of reconfiguring going on.
A couple of these will be Handy for distributing 12vDC round the shed
UKK... Urho Kalevi Kekkonen.
Kekkonen, Kekkonen, Kekkonen, Kekkonen, Kekkonen.
There would also be a "red brass" alloy that has a very coppery hue to it, but I wouldn't trust the stuff with threading screw holes into it or at least significantly torquing said screws. It is common in trinketry and belt buckles etc, usually plated with a dull silvery coating that may be further stained. The coating will wear off and reveal the coppery color when brushing against clothing long enough, and the stuff will also sometimes develop greenish-greyish tarnish when exposed to skin secretions.
When PEX water pipes came in, the Chinese brass had 15% zinc in it that caused problems. Then mixer taps (brass) had some lead content over the permissible levels. Don't know if UK enforces import standards, but different countries seem to get different product. Perhaps it would be a hoot to have a UK metal machinist too up a drop in , identical magnesium connector block.
At least there is no head on the screws.
Could we maybe have a Resistance test of the alloy material?
Maybe not for 80 A permanently in a hidden spot. 30 to 40 A where you can look once in a while or have easy access: yes.
I like the fact that they clearly marked the cable sizes for in and out!
About the material: the "brass" is very pale. So I tend to say it's something between brass and "Neusilber" (new or fake silver). They probably reduced the copper percentage of the alloy and replaced it with nickel.
Advantage: firmer material.
Disadvantage: more brittle and higher electrical resistance.
So: under certain circumstances usable.
the brass is a lie, as usual
@@marcogenovesi8570 How do you know?
Did you visit clive, took the connector from him and made an analysis? Maybe you can present us the exact composition as you claim to know it.
I still haven't bought anything from temu, I'm still alive! 😄
I guess it can be cupronickel, some types of industrial quality PCB mounting terminal blocks and connectors are made of it too.
Absolutely! I'd trust it completely. (Wait. Did you mean as an electrical connector?)
Silvery magnetic plating means nickel, very common for brass to be nickel plated. Some IEC60309 plugs also have nickel plated brass prongs
Strong magnets can empirically demonstrate electrical conductivity via diamagnetic repulsion.
In Australia, trust Middendorp Electrical stores.
looks surprisingly decent for £3, would probably be ok for 40 maybe even 60Amps, although i am immediately drawn to the case trying to think of another use for it.
Well brass is an alloy of copper and zinc. The pale color implies it has more zinc than what we usually see. Too much zinc will make it brittle.
I continue to be surprised by the fact I haven’t been dissatisfied with anything I’ve bought off Temu yet. And I’ve bought a lot! 😂
I have not bought anything of Temu.
And I won't ever.
That's a useful function as I was wondering how the hell is he going to measure the hole depth using that.
You can get brass alloys that have a touch of iron and other metals in the recipe, most brass is 70 copper and 30 zinc, for acetylene gas components I think they use more zinc in the mix to prevent copper acetylide forming which can be explosive.
Gaz Yorkshire.
It's probably a leaded brass alloy, the RoHS brass is more of a reddish colour. (Naval brass- bronze)
would 25mm^ (73A) or 35mm^ (90A) actually fit in the holes ?
You might just about get the 25 in there, though i wouldn't trust it for 80A, i would like to see double screwed connections.
In a panel running for long periods with the cover closed and no supervision: hell no not even for personal use.
In the open for a quick test setup while I’m watching it: I’m feeling more comfortable going past the rating with this than with the UL listed name brand ones. If it fails it’s not expensive to replace.
Those UKK Terminals exist already far longer then Temu. I am using them for years and as they fit on DIN-Rails, they are very practical. The bigger brothers like the 125A versions I do use as Main Busses in a Powerwall where currents go up to 95A regularly. Much bigger issues are for example the Chines breakers. Those fail on me frequently.
Sure I'd trust it at 80mA
80mA seems a bit much to trust a Temu product with. 80µA _might_ be OK...But *only* if you tighten those screws down really, _really_ tight... 😉
its fine id use those all day
Clive, are you squirmy about dremels ? I mean with grit paper I'm not that afraid of it, but with saws, them going at 12000 rpm is kinda scary... While I cut some stuff in the past some blades flew past me shattering on every wall, luckly I was not in their way... maybe they were cheap blades, they were the ones that came in the same set as the ones I bought from LIDL.
have something in front of the eyes. you can get like saw/router bits that are just like a router bit though they tend to not snap like cutting wheels. really with the drum sandpaper things you can cut a bunch of plastic too it really eats through stuff(and doesn't shrapnel same way).
I always have my plastic lensed glasses on, but also position myself out of the direct path of a shattering blade.
Speaking of electrical panel fires, and I know this is more aimed at domestic CUs, but any thoughts on the EnviroBurst Automatic Fire Suppression System tubes??
I'm guessing it's only rated at 80A to imply a limit of 20A on each of the "outlets". Probably the first thing to break down with higher currents, which the block could easily handle, would be the cheap plastic melting. I used a similarly cheap knockoff DIN mount double pole isolator on my small solar input circuit, maximum 20A at 45V is never going to worry it. The branded item Schneider is ~$130 Aussie bucks and the knockoff was $8 shipped.
I can't be alone in the "Buy three of them, test one to failure, and then use the other two at half the rating" mental thinking? Especially for prototype stuff where I just want some isolation/organization, and not really going to push it to the absolute limit.
Testing just a single item to failure doesn’t inform one of very much. It’s possible to have an outlier as the test item (either as a poor quality junk or an example of how good the product may be). A small test sample with an odd number of items, starting with at least three, would be better. Using two samples one is not able to identify the outlier if the results of one are significantly out of line with the other. (Having an even number of samples in general allows for a situation in which all results fall within two groups evenly.)
Ideally, if one is concerned about the quality of a product such as this, it would be wise to test every component at the promised maximum performance guarantee for at least a short time period and perform a longer test a value that is a bit higher than the expected load it will be under in daily use. This way if the item is unable to meet the job requirements one should find out early on. (I did say should find and I’m not promising parts won’t fail later on.)
Well initially it was a hard no, but on review, it doesn't look as bad as I first thought.
Its AMAZING the conductive differences between pure copper, brass, and anything else. GOOD brass only has about 1/4 the conductivity of copper! Chinese who knows what brass...less.
Whipping out the single entendres there.
It should be sent to JW for a load test. Problem with Temu, is you might not get identical items, if you order it again
Interesting but what about the protection for the smaller cables?? or are the smaller cables inputs??
nice video, but i wanted to see Flames! 😀
Help me out here, what are you looking for with the magnet? Is magnetism a good sign for electrical conductors or would you prefer something non-magnetic? I also enjoyed how you demonstrated three separate ways to use a pair of calipers, I just learned it is a depth gauge as well 👍
I was looking to see if it was plated steel.
If you'd like to see this tested for it's resistance let me know, I'd be happy to put between 600-800 amps through this and do a little video on how low resistance testing of terminations is done.
for a distro block on some 3d printer build, meh, sure I would if they had these at the 20 baht store. very least you get a bunch of grub screws.
The shiny plating looks great, but nothing like copper. Brass has a relatively higher resistance. When it comes to ohms, it is little, but even that little has major effects, like too much heating when it comes to high currents like the 80 amps mentioned and especially using AC. My answer is no, I would not use it.
I actually have some similar looking units in service at work but the front plastic cover is a baby blue. Maybe if i remember i will report back what brand those are. I wonder if they're made in the same place or if this is a clone made by temu based off the original. Not sure why this has 3 inputs in the top though. As i recall the ones we use at work have a single large input at the top and 6 outputs from the bottom.
Weigh it, do an Archimedes to determine the volume (without the screws, natch) and you could compute the density. That might let you figure out what kind of brass it is. It's probably one of the standard alloys.
This is a copy of a TE Entrelec DBL80 distributor. Considering they are about $10 each for the genuine UL listed EU made part I don't know why you would risk anywhere near 80 amps through the Chinese knock off.
Amen!
“I shall grind the bottom here” - I did grin.
I feel like such a boss because I've got the same skookum £5 ebay special vernier calipers as Clive
There's a video showing the construction and insides of them.
Could it be an aluminium-brass alloy? I think the light colour made it hard to tell, it looked like plain old aluminium to me.
A simple test of the weight and volume (take the screws out and dunk it in a graduated cylinder of water) will enable one to calculate the average density, that might yield some more clues to the composition. Copper is pretty dense so if it feels heavy that's a good sign.
Sure they could have smuggled some lead in but I'm guessing that's unlikely.
Hi Clive. It looks like you may have a fungal infection ( like athletes foot) on your left hand. I sometimes get similar from sweaty hands in work gloves that don't get dried out properly. I have found that use of a generic athletes foot spray on the affected area clears it up in a few days.
I trusted those 240v 10a relays, and the contacts fused after 10 circles.
that's a lot of amps
@@marcogenovesi8570 i "only" put about 4 amps thrpugh it, but i as a novice i didnt know about inrush current. Welp now i know what to look for in relays.
A lot of materials at low cost uses metal that has been recycled and may not be pure. Unsurprising that a brass which should be just copper and zinc is magnetic. That indicates that iron has contaminated the mix. Pure copper is just getting more and more expensive. I find the same contamination issue with solder that won't flow as well as high quality versions.
Honestly, I think it would probably outlast any cable that you could fit into it
It looks like it's based on the ELIT UD80A/ERICO UD80A. With a cheaper plastic for the mold, necessitating a spring based DIN mechanism.
Looks okay. The bottom plate looks a little narrow. It looks like a din Henley.
Pop it in the oven at 65 degrees for an hour and see how well the shell holds up
Well, its a solid metal block so obviously it can handle 80A. As long as it is plated the brass is fine. The question is primarily one of screw retention / the wire interface. It looks quite reasonable as long as the screws aren't easily stripped out.
I would definitely use ferrules for any wiring (yes, those would be some huge ferrules), but it will improve the copper/tin interface, the retention, and provide a bit of protection as well as reduce excessive bending of strands as they leave the holes.
A good litmus test, actually, is to determine the largest ferrule that fits into those holes, that it reaches across the screw cross-hole, with the ferrule's plastic shield fitted into the hole, partially fitted, or outside the hole (three different sized ferrules for each size hole). If you get a good fit there is basically zero chance of having electrical issues.
-Matt
Considering that a 20A rated WAGO 221 using only a small piece of metal holds 120A before destroying itself , I suspect that this 80A chunk piece of metal would actually handle 250A with ease.
Oh no, another video without schematics! ;-)
I would. Only if I were using someone else’s CC information to order it.
It trust it on 80A. Don’t forget the fine print. 8.0A
Ideal test object for an Omicron CPC-100 and FLIR C3-X. Test at 80A for 1 hour, then 160A for 30 minutes...... Not sure if the 200A test leads will fit on both sides of the connector (large holes).
Looks more like some form of aluminium bronze. The fact that its slightly magnetic suggests that it is containing iron, unless the tin plate is iron plate.
Nothing to it but to do it Clive.
Ah... *Now* that Big Clive ❤🔥 has bought and reviewed it, Temu will drop the quality down _considerably_ to maximise profit at minimum outlay while people are buying on the back of Clives findings. I wouldn't touch Temu with Mr. Sunaks' barge-pole...But if I went on there now and bought the same thing, I wouldn't be at all surprised if the one I received was 100% aluminium or worse. 🔌⚡🔥⚠
What would be fun is if this was passed on to PhotonicInduction to see just how much current it could withstand in practice. Think my bet would be on 80A *For
Agreed ,i'm an electrician and your tear down as always was spot on