WILL NON MUSLIMS GO HELL FOREVER? - ATHEIST CONVINCED
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 жов 2024
- #ATHEIST #HELL #ISLAM
Check our sponsors, Nature’s Blends, producers of premium Ethiopian Black Seed products.
Discount code: salam10
Website: www.naturesble...
Instagram: @naturesblends
FULL DISCUSSION WITH TONY ON SALAM CHANNEL: ua-cam.com/video/iE7DTG2oZeU/v-deo.html
Just show them Israel terrorising Palestine and they will be convinced. If they’re not, then they deserve it too.
Assalamualaikum
So glad to write the second reply on your comment. Alhamdulillah 🙌
@@unclegardener 🤣🤣😭😭
@@goodboi4007 I mean it’s true 😂😂
@@unclegardener please pray for ppl of palistain😭😭
The fact he said "im 10% moved."
Means that he's actually closing in on Islam, he seems like a genuine guy who hasn't heard the message before yet he is asking proper questions and getting answers. Let's pray for this guy.
May Allah guide him...and to all... Aameen
@@mohammadzubair7020 ameen
@EveryIsnaad IsFabricated wow.. Every historian...really? sorry to say but It's ur own loss if u die with this much ignorance... Try to read more with an open mind.
@EveryIsnaad IsFabricated you comment on so many videos. Yet no one listens or cares what you have to say.
@@AntiAtheismIsUnstoppable you are confused my friend. It's your scriptures that contains lies, inconsistencies and fabricated stories from unknown authors that confuses people while the Quran has been preserved well.
Edit: i read the Quran in both arabic and my own language. It has been an amazing journey of a read.
Very respectful guy. This is how these conversations should always be
@@barisandmoos348 shush
Islam is false
@Bless Well you’re not making much sense are you? You think the only reason one would watch videos about a religion that he doesn’t believe in is him not being fully convinced by his religion? Does that apply to muslim scholars and debaters that study the bible? No, they do it for the sake of knowledge and to improve their argumentative skills, some do it out of curiosity.
@Bless And that makes him somehow not convinced by christianity? If u addressed his comment stating the same things you replied to me with, then your comment would be more credible.
@@BibliayFe Your idea about Islam is wrong.
No doubt,Islam is the only complete code of life.
"And if you were to live on billion trillion years, God knows you would go back to the same sin" that was a wonderful argument Ali, very precise
@@barisandmoos348 ?
@@barisandmoos348 u putting thus everywhere isnt gonna do anything. Stop spreading hate and stop spreading lies
going back to sin is fine, the prophet peace be upon him said:Every son of Adam is a sinner And the best of sinners are those who Repent .
But what Ali Dawah is saying is they will never believe
@@allahm-ast3mnlywlatstbdlny164 That’s true. People feel bad for sinning after promising God they will never commit the sin again, and give up. A true muslim keeps praying and keeps asking Allah for help. Why? Because Allah is All-Merciful. He is Greatest.
This was a nuclear ☢️ argument !
Make sense to both sides.
from this discussion alone has opened so many perspective about Allah's mercy to us, thank you brother Ali Dawah
Islam is fake
@@BibliayFe if Islam is “fake” so is Christianity you fool
@@AD4MANTIUM2166 just islam and Muhammad, the children lover
@@BibliayFe prove it.
@@Fatimah262 the quran is full of lies
Atheists: Doesn't believe in Heaven and Hell
Also Atheist: Gets triggered when a believer says they will go to hell
lol true never thought about that
😂
Mufti menk has a video on that,
Take my lunch money 😂🤣
@Sage of Synergism
Because it is loooool
And the verse u cited doesn't speak about terrorism, be honest and stop this 💀
Very great conversation..very respectful guy, he was searching for the truth may Allah guide him insha Allah, may Allah guide all of us...
Ameen
Ameen
ameen
Alevi kardesim wahabilerden uzak hak. 12 imamin yolu git shiilerin yolu
🚫 *ALI DAWAH IS A MUNAFIQ WORKING FOR IBLIS THATS WHY HIS DAWAH IS FILLED WITH IGNORANCE AND MISGUIDANCE AND FITNAH AND DEBATES AND DRAMA AND DISTRACTIONS. HE IS A HUMAN SHAYTAN. HE IS HERE TO MISGUIDE* 🚫🚫🚫🚫
And not to forget, Mohammed (pbu) his wish that will save everyone with even an atom of faith in their hearts from the hellfire.
In this life also:
When we do a good deed, It will be written down as 10 good deeds up to 700 depending on the deed.
When we sin, it wil be written down as one sin.
When we want to commit a sin, but don’t commit it, it wil be written down as one good deed.
When we want to do a good deed but end up not doing it, it wil be written down as one good deed.
When we commit a sin, and repend for it, it will be written down as a good deed.
And that’s why Allah is the all Merciful.
He gave us so many chances, and still people will end up in hell because of how evil and disobedient they were.
Well said brother. May Allah protect us from the hellfire.
I like when a debate is going both people lash out on each other, but I like it more when people debate in a respectful manner where both party have a change to speak and to answer
Mashallah! Ali's extremely solid at debating with intellectuals! May Allah protect him
🚫 *ALI DAWAH IS A MUNAFIQ WORKING FOR IBLIS THATS WHY HIS DAWAH IS FILLED WITH IGNORANCE AND MISGUIDANCE AND FITNAH AND DEBATES AND DRAMA AND DISTRACTIONS. HE IS A HUMAN SHAYTAN. HE IS HERE TO MISGUIDE* 🚫🚫🚫🚫
@@barisandmoos348 get outta here troll
@@barisandmoos348 still fearlessly calling people to Islam. How much dawah have u done publicly . Allah Knows Best. And Allah Will Judge . Not you
This didn’t age well
May Allah help the Muslims all over the globe and the oppressed
Ameen
Aameen
Ameen
Ameen
Ameen you too ameen 🙏
This guy seems smart and open minded and i hope he will accept islam. The problem is that he doesn't know Allah and the wisdom behind his actions.
@@barisandmoos348 get a life
Please go do something productive
@@barisandmoos348 and what are you doing or have done? let me guess, nothing...
@@barisandmoos348 if he's a munafiq then thats upto God and him himself
@@barisandmoos348 Oh shut up!!
Love this kind of debate where both parties get to speak and listen to each other, also Brother Ali clearly explaining things in a no nonsense matter which tony seemed to apreciate too well done both for such a lovely debate worthy of a million likes.👍🏻😊👍🏻
🚫 *ALI DAWAH IS A MUNAFIQ WORKING FOR IBLIS THATS WHY HIS DAWAH IS FILLED WITH IGNORANCE AND MISGUIDANCE AND FITNAH AND DEBATES AND DRAMA AND DISTRACTIONS. HE IS A HUMAN SHAYTAN. HE IS HERE TO MISGUIDE* 🚫🚫🚫🚫
@@barisandmoos348 just shut up
@@youman5079 islam is false
@@BibliayFe you mean Christianity ?
@@youman5079 no. I meant islam, do you understand English?
That was a good argument by Ali. That if Allah knows that this person even if they lived billions of years would keep on transgressing, then they deserve hellfire for eternity
Makes sense as in the quran,it does say that people will say that let us have a second chance but Allah know if he does they'll do the same things again and again
Nah it wasn’t a good argument, cause that doesn’t make allah just or forgiving. Cause that means he made a person to be that way and not have a choice to able to change. That is like making a car missing 2 wheels and because of that you keep on kicking the car for being unable to drive.
What happend to free choice? Or is that also a myth? Because if so then we nothing more that humans in a matrix powering god with prayers ;).
@@r-ex2945 unfortunately for you you won’t be able to understand but I’ll still say it .firstly Allah has given each and everyone of us free-will that’s the ability to do whatever we want, secondly eternal hell is not a place that Allah would put just about anyone that is meant for the worst of worst like Pharaoh who claimed he was God himself even after God sent him so many signs and yet denied them.
Respectfully educate yourself or atleast don’t comment with little or no knowledge about Islam
@@r-ex2945 People have the ability to choose to do right or wrong. Allah has given people reason and logic, to look at his signs and think. To choose to be better, and choose to believe. If you haven't received the message then you are not going to be judged on faith but on your actions alone.
The chance to believe was given to the pharaoh. He was given a chance to change his ways but he was arrogant.In the quran it says whenever it was said to them there is no god worthy of worship except Allah, they acted arrogantly. Allah didn't say to musa (as) that forget him he's a lost cause. He didn't, he told him to go talk to him, give him the message. Yes he's an oppressor but maybe he'll ponder, think and reason.
When yunus (as) thought that his people had no hope. They acted arrogantly, worshiped idols, and were quite elitist. He warned but to no avail. He got so disheartened, that he left in anger. He sees the clouds forming and he leaves thinking the punishment of Allah is coming. He left giving up on his people, without Allah's permission But once he has left, they look onto the clouds, ponder and seek forgiveness from Allah. They turn back to him. Another proofs of Allah's mercy. Allah says that he doesn't just destroy a people, but gives them chance after chance and loads of time to change. Yunus as came back from facing a trail due to his actions and sees his people praying and awaiting guidance.
The story was told to Muhammad (saw) to keep firm and not give up on the people. We have companions in islam like khalid ibn walid who were enemy's of Islam before they believed and seemed forgiveness. I can't remember which companion but one of them killed many Muslims and tried to kill the prophet too, and he was worried that how would Allah forgive him, he's done horrible things but the prophet told him that if you are to convert, all your previous sins are ti be forgiven. You start afresh.
Allah judges based on what you have done, every soul will face the consequences of what it had done. so if all your life, you have transgressed, did horrible things to people. And also the guidance came to you, u were told don't this- stop. You were warned but you still persisted then you are blameworthy. You showed no signs of change whatsoever.
Even if you have made the worst of mistakes, you ask forgiveness from Allah and he forgives. There is no week long fast you have to keep, or climb up some mountain. You just ask and he will forgive. He says that a person will tire from asking for forgiveness before he stops giving it.
ua-cam.com/video/7CvVWsfDKZk/v-deo.html
@@hootho_1007 Dude do you even read what I wrote? You come with a judgement that I don't know the Islam like you know me...
Again Why would god make a person in a way that the person will not change in a billions years... Cause if he did than why punish that person for acting like that cause he was made that way without being able to change...
Think about it. Again its a wrong example. Cause where in the Quran is it written that god made people who will sins for billions of years and never be able to do good?
We have free choice to make mistakes or do good. But Free choice also means that we are able to do both and switch from 1 to the other. saying that someone would do evil for billions of years and isnt able to change is like absurd...
i like that the Atheist is being honest by asking questions in his mind to learn.
He's obviously helping himself by opening up. May he get the clarity and receive Hidayah. Ameen.
Nothing wrong with Atheists, everything wrong with religious faith.
@@FactStorm uhh no you're wrong
@@Meleeman69 You think dedicating your life to supernatural hypotheses without evidence is a good way to live life? It's dishonest and pitiful. There's a reason they rely on faith, its called such because its not knowledge
@@FactStorm good job on outing yourself as someone who knows nothing about islam lol, it's 100% about evidences
This guy was really trying to understand. I hope Allah guides him
Jai Shri Ram!🇮🇳
@@mrsingh3136 how's river Ganges?
@Alok Vyas your point is faltered because if you put that into different context then it would be morally wrong and currently against the law. According to evolution humans killed for food. Now that would be illegal. Anyone could call all current humans murderers for their past which is wrong as its a complete different set of people
@Alok Vyas 6:109 “Do not abuse those whom they worship besides Allah”
4:60 "O ye who believe! obey Allah, and obey His Messenger and those who are in authority over you"
These explicitly tell Muslims to respect other religions and respect the law
@Alok Vyas also you may bring up that we Muslims follow the actions of Muhammed SAW which we do but no where does it say that he is perfect and has never committed a sin. Humans make mistakes and it is acknowledged on the Quran. Please think before you post your comments
Etrenel hell is a punishment for a crime (rejecting your creator )
So the crime doesn't take as long as the time of the punishment ..
Eg: athiest opinion , if someone kills someone and it took him 3 mins to kill him .. they prison him for hole life in jail , and they believe there is no going to be another life for him ..
Eg: if someone slaps a police officer he will be sentenced for 3 years .
So the punishment doesn't take time as the crime ...
if you see knew the punishment of disbelieve and rejection of your creator is hell and he told you ... then its stupid to reject God while he gave you the information of the punishment of that crime (rejection our creator).
Jazakullah Khairan
As salam u alaikum very good angle also. It’s the one the sins being committed against.
@@AliDawah thank you for the reply :)
@@ibrahimibikunle9797 you too bro
It's ethanol.
You can tell he is a really genuine person. May Allah Azawajal guide and open his heart to islam.
Islam is fake
@@BibliayFe May Allah open your heart to the truth.
@@smallhabitsbigchanges4379 same to you, so you can save your soul
May you give a lap dance to Satan like lil nas x
@@HamdiGlenn ?
Disobedience to an infinite being makes the eternal punishment proportional.
I don't see where that makes sense?
@@thebestvieweryoullneverfor7745 If you kill a cockroach you wont get any punishment. If you kill a cat you might go to jail for a few days. If you kill a random pedestrian you usually get a couple of years/tens of years in prison. If you kill a law officer you are highly likely to spend your life in prison. If you kill the president of the united states you will probably be sentenced to death or get multiple life sentences without parole.
What i explained here is that punishment is proportional with the severity of who the crime is commited to. (in this case murder, but in islam shirk is even worse than murder). SO if you dont obey the laws of this INFINITE being (by comitting shirk), and you take into acount the proportionality of punishment , then a infinitely big punishment is proportional.
@@AmazonFinds.2k that's an amazing insight, never looked at it that way, jazakallah well put.
@@AmazonFinds.2k Thanks it helped a lot :)
Proportional is your opinion.
god must be really arrogant and egoistic and sadistic to do such things.
There is no eternal hell, it doesn’t make sense.
If muslims want to get back to his old tradition. He must go back to the Quran.(Allama Ikbal)
One day in the hereafter is like 1000 years of our time.. so basically even one day in hell fire is like eternity if you think about it. The day of judgement itself will be like 50000years long.. May Allah protect us from His punishment.
Ameen.
Wait is it said anywhere how long the judgement day will be?
@usersif
تَعْرُجُ الْمَلَائِكَةُ وَالرُّوحُ إِلَيْهِ فِي يَوْمٍ كَانَ ""مِقْدَارُهُ خَمْسِينَ أَلْفَ سَنَةٍ
"The angels and the Spirit [i.e., Gabriel] will ascend to Him during a Day the extent of which is fifty thousand years."
Chapter 70 verse 4
@@lolr.9575 Allahu akbar
@@ua7234 lets sew what u will say on day of judgment
The guy asked a really really important question, something I think about a lot as well. I feel really bad for all my non believer friends to think that they could be in hellfire forever, I question if that's fair. Usually to resolve this i say to myself that Allah is the most just and maybe this is a test, a way shaitan creates doubt in my head. Even though we do not fully understand but we have to believe that Allah's decision will be just as it is said in the Quran that after Allah has given His judgement no one will question it, no one will feel they have been treated unjustly.
وما ربك بظلام للعبيد
and never does God do the least wrong to His creatures. [41:46]
You are indoctrinated.
@@FactStorm You’re indoctrinated to think others that hold a different worldview contrary to yours are indoctrinated.
@@IlmQuarter Lol, what a pathetic comment.
@@FactStorm originally I was going to agree with you because I thought indoctrinated meant "taught to accept a set of beliefs", but then I googled it and turns out the meaning is "taught to accept a set of beliefs uncritically", now there I don't agree. I guess to put it simply I as a Muslim believe the Quran is the authentic unchanged word of God and I believe so until proven otherwise by proof of any faults in the Quran. And since so far there hasn't been a convincing argument proving the Quran wrong then I continue to believe what is in it thus I believe that God's judgement will be just.
This is also an important point, a lot of people are atheist because they have a fear of believing.
Theyre just scared, and it's no reason to make fun of them. If you show those who are willing to listen & be around you the path of Islam (the way of life) and the religious aspect of Islam (worship). Then they'll end up realizing they had no need to be so scared/afraid then they will welcome Islam wholeheartedly.
I warn you against watching such anime and I advise you to remove that picture
@@Ahmed-pl2gb no, and no.
Youre not Allah, you have no idea what kind of Muslim I am. So instead of judging and acting like an imam or scholar I would advise you to stop and revalute yourself.
@@dragonbane001 @The Storm ? What are you talking about bro? are we that arrogant that we can't take advise you could just humbly take it and research the matter? D you feel offended that your muslim brother was looking out for you? Your response to this advise may reflect your bad character but I assum you don't have bad character
Subhan'Allah
as muslims we enjoin good and forbid evil
This anime uses the term God very loosley with different characters and has music
And on top of that drawn pictures as well and I assume you know the ruling on that .
May Allah guide us
I as your muslim brother am looking out for you
@@Ahmed-pl2gb nah, you're not humble and I can see through that.
@@Ahmed-pl2gb why should he remove that picture and why can't he watch anime?
Ali dawah said: when we smile it's like charity
Atheist: you guys got all the good things
🤣🤣🤣
If people can go to heaven forever it is only logical people can go to hell forever too otherwise the test of life wouldn't be fair is all you had to say
Lot of muslims do also loose hope forgetting how much Allah merciful is and will continue sining by thinking : oh i’m lost, i’m going anyways in hell… (btw, you should do a video about this brother Ali, you will help a lot of muslim who fall into this Shaytans trap). thank you a lot for this discussion, it’s also a reminder for us muslims to repent and keep living and trying our best to satisfy our Lord. May Allah bless you all my brothers and sisters
From Canada 🇨🇦 but honestly one day I wanna just come to the UK 🇬🇧 just to see these discussions live
Prob the best, civilised discussion in Speakers corner. We need more people like these. Great job Ali. May Allah guide him.
🚫ALI DAWAH IS A MUNAFIQ WORKING FOR IBLIS THATS WHY HIS DAWAH IS FILLED WITH IGNORANCE AND MISGUIDANCE AND FITNAH AND DRAMA AND DISTRACTIONS. HE IS A HUMAN SHAYTAN. HE IS HERE TO MISGUIDE 🚫🚫🚫🚫
@@barisandmoos348 bri chill. What happen, u dont look so good
@@barisandmoos348 I guess you are playing in iblis’s game how are you doing. Are you winning
God bless you Ali, this man is clearly an agnostic and your high morals have a much stronger influence than words may Allah reward you and all our Muslim brothers who call people to Islam
Allah is the honour of the heaven. So, he can decide whom to enter his paradise. Like, if you build a house you put criteria to whom to enter your home.
He asked a question why Allah punish infinity to non belivers. Brother this world is a test. So, if you doesn't have the simple criteria of believing him although islam is the religion which answer you. Still you are ignoring it. As a example if you study well after that you gets a good job until you retire. Same way if you believe in Allah and do righteous deeds. You will enjoy next life. Or else worshipping wood and statue and going to pub and brotels you won't enter to paradise.
Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said, "Everyone of my Ummah will enter Jannah except those who refuse". He was asked: "Who will refuse?" He (ﷺ) said, "Whoever obeys me, shall enter Jannah, and whosoever disobeys me, refuses to (enter Jannah)".
[Al- Bukhari].
The guy came with an open mind and looking to learn. Respect
it so satisfying to talk to people like this guy. so respectful and open minded
I kid you not, I was literally thinking about this yesterday. I was literally thinking about the whole finite-infinite thing and you’ve answered my question.
As a Christian, this is a question I have also wrestled with. One of the best analogies ive heard is from pastor Mike Winger;
The punishment for a crime is determined not just but what the criminal act is, but also to whom the act was committed against.
Say I was found guilty of punching someone, wouldn't you expect me to recieve a greater punishment for hitting a policeman, as opposed to a stranger? Or say a hit a President or a King, wouldn't my punishment be even greater still?
How much more authority then does God have. And since our sinful rebellion is ultimately made against Him, how much more serious should we expect the just punishment be.
I for one, am very glad that Justice and Mercy are God's alone!
Hell is Eternal but because of how merciful Allah is, He included "unless your Lord may will otherwise" in Surah 11:107 and Surah 6:128.
So we keep discovering Allah's unlimited mercy every second of our lives, MashaaAllah.
Keep up the good work brother from your brother from Canada. Love these types of videos, Where your out in public, doing social experiments or giving Dawah to people. That you have been doing recently.
Reminds me of a famous saying.
"Get to paradise first"
Masha Allah, lovely explanation brother!
Amazing intellectual debate MashAllah
🚫 *ALI DAWAH IS A MUNAFIQ WORKING FOR IBLIS THATS WHY HIS DAWAH IS FILLED WITH IGNORANCE AND MISGUIDANCE AND FITNAH AND DEBATES AND DRAMA AND DISTRACTIONS. HE IS A HUMAN SHAYTAN. HE IS HERE TO MISGUIDE* 🚫🚫🚫🚫
@@barisandmoos348 shutup jahil
Nothing intellectual in religion, it relies on faith and not evidence. Please grow up..it's embarrassing that you religious people are so naive.
@@FactStorm mind defining evidence? What evidence empirical evidence?
@@omaribnalahmed5967 Yes, if its empirical then it wouldn't require faith, belief, prayers etc.
Ngl even as a muslim this question popped up into my head once. How can somebody be punished for eternity if they only sinned for a few decades. The answer in this video makes a lot of sense.
I think the same. It doesn’t make a lot of sense, let me tell you why. I do agree that some sins may be greater than others but even when someone says they have sinned against God, The Eternal Being therefore it is only proportionate forget that God is free of all needs. He’s high above humans and therefore their sins do not have any impact on Him. Another thing is if they were gonna be disbelieving for eternity then what is the point of creating them in the first place? Even us cannot understand eternity, sometimes even a few days seem like a lot so I let you imagine how scary the idea is. May God protect us all.
@@thehourglassfan3515 I guess we’re all born with a clean slate, we know nothing at all when we’re born. We grow up, learn, form our own opinions, an ethical code and moral compass. So we are all actually given a chance to seek the truth and accept it. That would mean people aren’t born predisposed to disbelieve for eternity, it’s each individual who reaches that state themselves.
@@thehourglassfan3515 It seems if I get past one hurdle on my life, in terms of extremely depressing thoughts, there is a new wave, if you like, of demotivation and sadness, and right now, it is the eternal nature of Hell. How can I be expected to believe, with my limited knowledge that Allah is indeed the most merciful if he will cause people to be eternally humiliated, burnt, tortured, mocked and immersed in regret and grief, no matter what they have done. Yes, there is no denial from me that there are people who deserve punishment and justice should be served for the people who have been oppressed, yes evil individuals who have done evil things do exist, no doubt, but eternal, never ending punishment seems like a whole, different level of cruelty. By the way, there is no doubt in my mind, that Islam is the truth from Allah, too many things just seem to 'click', I believe this to be the truth, which is a reason as to why I cannot possibly justify or understand eternal hell. Allah can see me typing this, so Allah please, forgive me for saying this, but I would really love there to be justice, but not eternal humiliation and regret.
@@dhussss14 same thing goes for me.I can't even bear a needle going into my arms and to think that some people are going to get burned for eternity seem really depressing.
Love it how two well mannered people are discussing …… nice civil manner …. Learning from each other ….benefiting each other …. More like these please
Ali you did a great job. MashAllah TabarakAllah!
This is the most genuine person I have come across. I wish him all the best!
May Allah Accept your works, and make it a means of acceptance and Guidance for the Ummah!
I love how your camera quality has gone so much better , jazakum Allah Khairan
Atheist: I don't believe in God, hell and heaven.
Atheist when facing death: God please save me or God please don't let me die right now.
No lol
@@bagaskarapangestu7873 deep down in your heart you cry out to Allah when your in danger. Unless your insane every one calls out to Allah in desperate need. Don’t fool yourself
@@lmivha3275 prove it
@@bagaskarapangestu7873 if your in a near death experience or less you will call out to GOD you can deny it or go with it,it dose not change anything
@@vitamine8105 Just because you say it doesn't mean it's true. Until you can prove your assertion it will remain invalid.
There's also mention of a man who killed 99 people who entered paradise because he believed in Allah and wanted to make tauba.
@Sage of Synergism You're so funny, funny funny funny
I am convinced these anti Islam commemts are from bots, ignore and report them as spam.
@EveryIsnaad IsFabricated All those books are not in their original form. You say Jesus is God but he never said that I'm God, We believe in Jesus as messanger of Allah Almighty.
@EveryIsnaad IsFabricated Dude, just give up already.
ماشاء الله bro
That was beautifully explained. If only all atheist came with this sort of mindset.
salam brother keep it up from your brother in australia and biggest fan and im 16 years old and i look up yo you
I love how the sun shined it's rays of light upon you both around 6 mins during Ali's explanation.
We don’t know who’s going to hell or heaven only Allah knows 💗 inshallah the best for us all
Excellent answer 👌🌹🌹 I've never heard it before 🤔
May Allah SWT reward brother Ali❤️🌷🌷
1st from Bangladesh 🇧🇩✌🏻💕
Mectoo
I just wanted to add that God is not only merciful but also JUST, the most just! You can't expect those who intentionally and abusively commit the worst of sins to just enjoy heaven! They deserve to be punished. And people who were treated unfairly in this life are thirsty for justice in the life after.
Even if u do the most evil things in the dunya, Allah SWT will still forgive you! He is the most merciful, Allah says in the Qur'an that you should never doubt his mercy. So if u ask for forgiveness for no matter what you have done Allah will forgive u insha'Allah. u said ppl who do rllly bad things can't just enjoy heaven, well as I said before, Allah will forgive them if they asked for forgiveness. And also in jannah you will always live peacefully. No negativity will happen there at all. So I'm jannah you will not get punished, but Allah will question whom he wills about what they have some in judgement day. We shouldn't care about dunya because we should always strive for jannah. you'll always be in peace In Jannah, you'll never be sad there nor angry, you'll never be hungry or become fat, and everyone will be the same age in jannah (33) you get to wish for anything to Allah in jannah
Bring him back and discuss islam with him again he will revert some day.
What if he doesn’t? He has every right not to be convinced, don’t you think? You don’t choose what to believe, either you do or you don’t. Christians genuinely believe in their books and so do the people belonging to other faiths. 🙂
@@thehourglassfan3515 He has every right to form his own opinion and come to his own conclusions. That is the definition of how a personal faithay be made and or strengthened
@@jona7200 And God will accept him inshAllah no matter what.
@@thehourglassfan3515 well, if he doesnt believe in Islam after being represented with it, he becomes an unbeliever & denier of the truth ( in Islams point of view). Still God is the all merciful and only he knows. Islam is only the straight path.
@@jona7200 How come? Him not accepting the religion just means he’s not convinced, that is it.
Thank you for the upload,it was very enlightening to learn about the way you explained finite life and infinite hell or paradise.
That’s crazy you just posted I just wanted to watch one of your videos 😂
This person is respectful and smart. I as a Muslim have this question why hell fire for eternity? if we know the person is going to keep sining then just shut him down. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ No need for that person to exist.
Now that title says it all. About who judge's.
I like that guy. Very respectful man . May Allah guide him.
Y are atheists so worried about the akhirah when they don’t even believe in it🤣🤣🤣
Deep down in their hearts they believe it, but out of their arragance they do not want to submit to it.
@@bilals1279 word😂
It's more that it is offensive when somebody says we are going to hell, it's like that person is saying they want us to be tortured because we do not believe in the same thing as them.
@@bilals1279 Do you have any proof backing up that claim?
@@b.ballooon9225 I honestly don’t understand this concept. Someone is free to believe what they are convinced of. Atheists have reached a specific conclusion not out of disrespect for God but because the circumstances of their lives led them to believe as such.
"What would Allah do with your punishment if you are grateful and believe? And ever is Allah Appreciative and Knowing." َ An-Nisaa 4:147
He is truly an open minded person no doubt.
this tony guy seems like such a nice bloke, awesome video
01:03 "the orthodox position..." it sounds weird to call us normal muslims "orthodox". we are the average, we are in the middle path
Mashallah, this was one of the more civil debates at Speakers Corner I’ve watched. It’s nice to see people put their arrogance to one side and discuss Islam and their own views in this manner. May Allah guide Tony towards Islam as the man seems intelligent and modest enough to strive within our religion and community.
~some sins can't be forgiven~
*imagine denying your father by saying you are not my father and going to someone else and acknowledges him as your father*
*inviting everyone to learn about Islam*
That's what a Christian would argue
Hes a very kind and open minded man I like people like this
Tony is a cool guy
Islam is fake
@@BibliayFe Christianity is fake
@@BibliayFe jeses is the son of God and jesus is God dafaq is that meant to mean
@@BibliayFe It's as if your cult is any different lmao.
It's always hilarious when one Abrahamic cult member criticizes another!
You're all deluded, indoctrinated saps! Too gullible for your own good, what a disgusting mentality!
@@aotgoat3267 he is the Son ans He is divine
Mash'Allah Ali is inspired! What a great and wise answer. These are the discussions that bring people forward. Respectful and we don't have to agree. But human dignity is preserved.
Trying to scare an atheist with “hell”, is like telling a kid he won’t get presents from Santa.
Also Ali, stop raising your voice when you know your loosing 🤣
Wow, what a nice civil discussion. No shouting, no biased opinions but instead just a pure and intelligent discussion between open-minded people.
Ali: „No other religion has this“
Jehovah: „And this good news of the Kingdom will be preached in all the inhabited earth for a witness to all the nations, and then the end will come.“ -Mathew 24:14
“He will render judgment among the nations And set matters straight respecting many peoples”- Isaiah 2:4
“I will safeguard you and give you as a covenant for the people And as a light of the nations”- Isaiah 42:6
„Declare his glory among the nations, His wonderful works among all the peoples. Jehovah is great and most worthy of praise“ - Psalm 96:3
Nice try ❤️
Respectful guy. May Allah bless his heart with the noor of emaan. InShaaAllah
Read the Quran, Allah speaks to u.
Say Sala, 5 times a day, U speak to Allah.
🚫 *ALI DAWAH IS A MUNAFIQ WORKING FOR IBLIS THATS WHY HIS DAWAH IS FILLED WITH IGNORANCE AND MISGUIDANCE AND FITNAH AND DEBATES AND DRAMA AND DISTRACTIONS. HE IS A HUMAN SHAYTAN. HE IS HERE TO MISGUIDE* 🚫🚫🚫🚫
@@barisandmoos348 shutup munafiq
You provided a very well balanced answer Ali, Masha'Allah
What about a good guy who live his life doing only good but didnt accept Islam Is it fair he would burn in hellfire forever?
I also dont understand this
Mashallah,hope this men Allahmadulillah become Muslim and later Sheikh for future generation. Jazak Allah Khair for Muslim guy having Patience .
May Allah open his heart and guide him to the Islamic path.. 💫
There is zero proof of God. Use your brain, abstain from belief.
the universe was intelligently designed and thats a fact
This man is open minded and friendly 👌
*islam is the best religion*
*who want to learn about islam can come* 🖤😀
MashaAllah wonderful discussion
Ali Dawah may ALLAH reward you
Hellfire 😂🤦🏽♂️
please be respectful bro
Why should people then expect infinite reward of heaven for finite actions of goodness? It's OK to believe that God is loving, generous and merciful when it suits people it seems.
Alhamdilelah for the blessing of Islam. Good job brother Ali answering his questions.
What a well mannered man. May Allah guide him.
Ali ,my greetings to you from a new Muslim,you’re videos are the best along with uthman in San Diego,hijab,and Dr Zanik,thank you.
The idea of punishment is connected to the idea of justice. Is brother Tony aware of the deeds that deserve punishment? I always thought justice is something very important for atheist. Another thing is that there are many small deeds with reward and the reward of good deed is immediately written whereas punishment is delayed. Good thoughts are rewarded, bad thoughts are left unjudged. This is what Ali meant: God by his mercy and his will to make us enter paradise has made the way to paradise easier. He is the most merciful but also the most just. I would not want a God that has become blind by his mercy and has no rules of justice.
A simple example to give brother Ali is, why is it just to give a life sentence for the killing of a human being that lasts less than a minute? Should we put the killer in jail for a minute as well?
This is the kind of conversation that I want to see, respectful and beneficial.
Sometimes, when you had this kind of discussion you just don't others point of view... But it helps us to review back what we understanding by explain to others...
A temporary hellfire can also be equally argued for Islamically as did Ibn Taymiyyah and Ibn Qayyim did. They brought several interesting arguments which most don't consider but is quite valid in addition to the philosophical argument
I like this guy.
He is very respectful
Ali maybe you should’ve told him also that the infinite punishment or pleasure concept is due to the fact that it doesn’t have a measurement of time like we do here etc, it’s beyond those laws and worldly physics etc
Gentle guy who listens and understand. Not just got his own perspective fixed permanently.
Min 5 to 6 what a beautiful answer wow , Allah is all knowing and all just. May God reward you ali
Very interesting arrangement.
May Allah guide us all
I am a righteous person or at least I think I am so.And I am Orthodox ☦️☦️☦️.I think that a non righteous muslim doesnt deserve heaven more than me.God told us that the most important thing is just being kind and nice to people