These umps this season have a very, a very short fuse. I wish MLB would look into some of these ejections. Like the one that happened with Judge. As far as missed balls and strikes, these umps should have their score card reviewed EVERY month and those who are less then like 90% should be fined. I know that will never happen but these umps will keep running rough shot until someone stops them.
MLB has got to get rid of human umpires. They are completely obsolete now. We have had accurate electronic ball tracking for YEARS and yet the MLB still bows down to these umpires despite some of their bad calls directly impacting the outcome of a game.
There’s a ton of calls that can’t be automated in real time. The only computerized umpiring that we’ll see for the foreseeable future is the strike zone.
@@cooperklips1440 So what? I'm sick and tired of everything stagnating because of "tradition". The MLB is scared of the pitchers union and MLB won't discipline umpires who make themselves main characters in a game.
the most entitled officials of all sports, ejecting someone because they complained of your mistake, they should be suspended for a game without pay too for every bad/wrong call they make
If you were a manager, would you bench your shortstop for every time he made an error or struck out looking? Of course not. The average umpire misses 7-12 pitches per game. If you suspend them 1 game for every pitch they miss, they umpire about 10 games per year. Then you’d have all AAA and AA umpires working MLB games and you’d then regret suspending the MLB umpires.
As bad as the umpires seem, they’re set to have their best year (again) by accuracy %. They keep getting better, as much as fans think they’re getting worse
@@timbailey3846 no the weren't the may look good cause the catcher brings it back over the plate and these dumbass umps keep looking at where the glove is not where the ball crossed the plate. And some of the umps do it cause in their heads the fans are there for them
10:47 When Q got tossed I instantly like him 100 times more. In his first season with KC he seemed kinda ho-hum about the position but 2024 completely changed that for me. Im excited to see where he takes us next year
I wonder how many of these situations involved Angel Hernandez? I'm sure he was involved in the first clip. He was after all the worst umpire in the history of the universe.
Ump takes his mask off in the first clip, not hernandez. Also, angel has a very different strike 3 motion, raising his hand into a fist, then down, and up again. Not sure if these clips are after he retired
Not in real time, it's at the ump's total discretion. They can be disciplined after a game, but they have a VERY strong union that makes it very difficult to discipline them in any meaningful way.
The problem with umpires is the fact that they are not held accountable for their ineptness. Think about it - if a baseball player is having a bad season and doesn't do a good job, they are demoted or released. And if they want to get back to the big leagues, they go home and work on their skills and try to improve. If an umpire has a bad season, they get assigned to a post season series and have no worries about being demoted or fired. And as far as improving their skills during the off-season, they couldn't care less. They go home and, judging by Hunter Wendelstedt and Doug Eddings, they spend the off-season eating doughnuts and cheeseburgers. Bottom line - THE UMPIRES DO NOT CARE HOW CRAPPY THEY ARE BECAUSE THEY CANNOT BE FIRED!!!
That’s BS. Umpiring is a very tough job and no human is perfect. Players get angry and that’s understandable. Happens all the time, it’s part of baseball.
I think sometimes these coaches only defend their players so that they can get thrown out on purpose and then they can go take a dump and get something to eat in the clubhouse, lol
With the AI technology we have now, there should, >Never< be a bad or wrong call by the umpire. When we watch baseball on TV we can see a Strike zone superimposed where the batter stands and can visually see where the pitched ball goes and is repeated many times, after that pitch. I would seem to me that the umpire should also have same view of the strike zone imposed on his face guard, (like pilots have) that tells him if it is a strike or ball and keep this game,, fair.
Those boxes are usually wrong though, they sometimes don't change the height for taller or shorter batters, they're always at an angle because you can't get a straight on view because the pitcher is in the way. The real time estimations are often off and close calls that are identified as wrong are sometimes ruled as correct when the umpire's performance is reviewed by officials after the game. There are of course calls that are clearly wrong, and seeing how far outside some of those calls are does lead some people to want to call for robo umps, but people argue when the call is right and so I don't think the umpires are the issue, I think it's more of a culture thing than a right or wrong issue.
Question. Some of these were close calls on the balls and strikes. I understand the no argue rule. But isn't a strike or ball dependent upon where it crosses the plate, not where the catcher catches the ball? Especially with curves and sliders. It appears to me that these guys feel the ball to be called a strike has to be right down the middle. Doesn't work that way.
The strike zone is defined as this: The area over home plate for horizontal Top of the zone is the midpoint b/w the elbow and the hip Bottom of the zone is the hollow beneath the knee Strike zone is a 3D object, not a 2D box at the front of the plate
First. If you're going to show a strike zone on the screen, put it in the right place. It's from the knees to the letters., not the knees to.the belt. Second. Im.sick.of these stupid announcers whinning because a pitcher gets tossed without a warning. Read the rules. They don't have to give warnings. Third EVERYONE that has ever played knows you dont argue balls and strike or throw your equipment.
They're going to ump themselves out of a job one day. It's bizarre... we literally can see what a strike is, yet they feel so confident they throw people out, lol. One day, they'll realize they forced the league's hand to just use the foolproof method.
I wanna say that taking emotions out of sport is what these umps r trying to do and eblvery single season or game they get it wrong 95% of the time.. Which leads me to ask.. Do umpires have more rules in the rules that specifically says they absolute power over all rules.. And how often are they checked.. Because this is getting ridiculous
Why can’t players challenge pitches the way they do in the minors? Will it interfere with the flow of the game? So what if it does. The umpires need to improve on their calling of balls and strikes. It has been getting worse the last few seasons to include the 2024 season.
Only 21 minutes? Lmao I was expecting this shit to be going for HOURS. Seems like players and managers are getting elected every other day in baseball. For good reason too cause those umps have been absolutely awful this season
I dunno what happened to John Tumpane this year. He went from 94.4% accuracy to like 93%.....one of the worst. He used to be one of the most accurate behind the plate......
The umpires shud be graded, to many bad calls bye, but alot of the players are complaining about pitches that are on the corners and were strikes and the players get bent out of shape when their called. I think players who make a big sciene on a call that was good they should be made to apoligise for their actions as well, seems all of the major sports have become a bunch of whining ball bags.
Umpires are way to soft and take their job to seriously. Players have consequemces and get find for stupid shit and u believe umpires should be fined or have consequences for their actions to
If it was proven - by video evidence - as a player, I'd NEVER pay the fine (for acting out) and would file a grievance - I umpired for 30 years (and worked with some of the bozos you've featured above) and I only had to ask 'someone to leave' on a handful of occasions......I also let someone 'blow off steam' (as long as they didn't make a scene) and it was NEVER on a "ball or strike" call!!!
Such a disrespect für the referees... is worst then in soccer. There may be some bad referees, but this allowed not such behavior from players or training staff.
Use the right grammar when you’re talking about Americas pastime, and don’t ever compare it to a bunch of chickens with their heads cut off running around a field crying, and begging a “referee” to hold up a sheet of paper.
I understand your point of view being from Europe. But they’re different games completely. If you dm me I’d love to take some time to explain the differences. Needless to say it’s going to be a long conversation. Baseball is very different compared to other sports when it comes to the umpire/ player, coach relationship.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Has anyone else noticed that the vast majority of these ejections were the umpire’s fault.
Yes I did terrible umpiring
Yes. However, a player cannot overreact. Umps are humans. Mistakes happen. It’s part of baseball
These umps this season have a very, a very short fuse. I wish MLB would look into some of these ejections. Like the one that happened with Judge. As far as missed balls and strikes, these umps should have their score card reviewed EVERY month and those who are less then like 90% should be fined. I know that will never happen but these umps will keep running rough shot until someone stops them.
I’m pretty sure fining someone for poor performance is just flat out illegal
Yeah, whining because an umpire missed your call is a comedic way to fine someone 😂
打つ方も投げる方も選手達が一球ごとに命をかけて挑んでいる姿に感動する
MLB has got to get rid of human umpires. They are completely obsolete now. We have had accurate electronic ball tracking for YEARS and yet the MLB still bows down to these umpires despite some of their bad calls directly impacting the outcome of a game.
There’s a ton of calls that can’t be automated in real time. The only computerized umpiring that we’ll see for the foreseeable future is the strike zone.
U get rid of the human umpires that takes away from a manager fighting and arguing for his team that can sometimes change the outcome of a game
Umpires are a huge tradition of baseball. Umpires are humans, mistakes happen and it’s the players job to not overreact.
@@cooperklips1440 So what? I'm sick and tired of everything stagnating because of "tradition". The MLB is scared of the pitchers union and MLB won't discipline umpires who make themselves main characters in a game.
@cooperklips1440 by what you’re saying players are humans too. How about stop kissing the umpire’s asses?
the most entitled officials of all sports, ejecting someone because they complained of your mistake, they should be suspended for a game without pay too for every bad/wrong call they make
If you were a manager, would you bench your shortstop for every time he made an error or struck out looking? Of course not. The average umpire misses 7-12 pitches per game. If you suspend them 1 game for every pitch they miss, they umpire about 10 games per year. Then you’d have all AAA and AA umpires working MLB games and you’d then regret suspending the MLB umpires.
i cannot wait until they bring the minor league challenge system into the majors to these umps can get humbled.
Or those players that keep challenging and the umpires get the call right. lol.
The majority of these were correct calls, you get in there and watch 95+ come in at you, not that easy pinhead
As bad as the umpires seem, they’re set to have their best year (again) by accuracy %. They keep getting better, as much as fans think they’re getting worse
@@kevinrorke418 yah man, totally. Statistically.
@@timbailey3846 no the weren't the may look good cause the catcher brings it back over the plate and these dumbass umps keep looking at where the glove is not where the ball crossed the plate. And some of the umps do it cause in their heads the fans are there for them
Where can I get Boone's cute vest?
Aaron judge is the most surprisingly on this 2024 season for the 1st time of his career he ejected
You guys need to import ABS(Automatic Ball-Strike System) from Korea.
We are SO~~~~~~~~ content with that.
I rarely agree with umps except in the case of Manny Machado. He came out of the womb with an attitude.
sloth
Altuve too
10:47 When Q got tossed I instantly like him 100 times more. In his first season with KC he seemed kinda ho-hum about the position but 2024 completely changed that for me. Im excited to see where he takes us next year
Machado always appears in these videos.
A little narrative context woulda gone a long way w this compilation.
Dude cuts to the next clip in the middle of the arguments lol show the whole thing 😔
Worst one was where they threw out the coach for something a fan said
Surprise that there was not more Aaron Boone ejections
Cant wait for umps to get replaced with computers
BS comment
Wow the Yankee coach/ manager got ejected a lot. Gotta feel bad for him.
Vogt got ejected for pretty much no reason bc that ball shit call was the worst
I wonder how many of these situations involved Angel Hernandez? I'm sure he was involved in the first clip. He was after all the worst umpire in the history of the universe.
Ump takes his mask off in the first clip, not hernandez. Also, angel has a very different strike 3 motion, raising his hand into a fist, then down, and up again. Not sure if these clips are after he retired
I can confirm they are after he retired.
And the ejections just keep on coming
So are there any controls over obvious bad calls and early ejections?
Not in real time, it's at the ump's total discretion. They can be disciplined after a game, but they have a VERY strong union that makes it very difficult to discipline them in any meaningful way.
Some of those umpires get real vindictive when someone bruises their egos and they go on a power party.
The problem with umpires is the fact that they are not held accountable for their ineptness. Think about it - if a baseball player is having a bad season and doesn't do a good job, they are demoted or released. And if they want to get back to the big leagues, they go home and work on their skills and try to improve. If an umpire has a bad season, they get assigned to a post season series and have no worries about being demoted or fired. And as far as improving their skills during the off-season, they couldn't care less. They go home and, judging by Hunter Wendelstedt and Doug Eddings, they spend the off-season eating doughnuts and cheeseburgers. Bottom line - THE UMPIRES DO NOT CARE HOW CRAPPY THEY ARE BECAUSE THEY CANNOT BE FIRED!!!
That’s BS. Umpiring is a very tough job and no human is perfect. Players get angry and that’s understandable. Happens all the time, it’s part of baseball.
Pitch challenge system. Immediately. Come on.
I think sometimes these coaches only defend their players so that they can get thrown out on purpose and then they can go take a dump and get something to eat in the clubhouse, lol
With the AI technology we have now, there should, >Never< be a bad or wrong call by the umpire. When we watch baseball on TV we can see a Strike zone superimposed where the batter stands and can visually see where the pitched ball goes and is repeated many times, after that pitch. I would seem to me that the umpire should also have same view of the strike zone imposed on his face guard, (like pilots have) that tells him if it is a strike or ball and keep this game,, fair.
Those boxes are usually wrong though, they sometimes don't change the height for taller or shorter batters, they're always at an angle because you can't get a straight on view because the pitcher is in the way. The real time estimations are often off and close calls that are identified as wrong are sometimes ruled as correct when the umpire's performance is reviewed by officials after the game. There are of course calls that are clearly wrong, and seeing how far outside some of those calls are does lead some people to want to call for robo umps, but people argue when the call is right and so I don't think the umpires are the issue, I think it's more of a culture thing than a right or wrong issue.
Amazing how so many of the comments here come from people who obviously have umpired in the major leagues for years.
0:30 umpires should have to fight one player and one manager per season
Korean abs is god
All these thrike 3 calls shows how bad the umps are. Catchers don't help framing a clear ball that they shape to make the ump make the call
It is simple….. DO NOT ARGUE BALLS and STRIKES
Was that Brett Gartner who threw out Judge?
4:55 2019
So, what happens when an ump puts his hands on a player?
I think a player/manager after getting ejected will either take their time in leaving refuse to leave or assault the umpire
Possible Future Video: Fan Ejections
Jose Altuve getting ejected once in 10 years, and now he’s been ejected like 2 or 3 times this year 😂
A lot of these were strikes
Question. Some of these were close calls on the balls and strikes. I understand the no argue rule. But isn't a strike or ball dependent upon where it crosses the plate, not where the catcher catches the ball?
Especially with curves and sliders. It appears to me that these guys feel the ball to be called a strike has to be right down the middle. Doesn't work that way.
The strike zone is defined as this:
The area over home plate for horizontal
Top of the zone is the midpoint b/w the elbow and the hip
Bottom of the zone is the hollow beneath the knee
Strike zone is a 3D object, not a 2D box at the front of the plate
Wasn't it Ted Williams who said that the strike zone is NOT what the rule book says it is -- it's what that game's plate umpire SAYS it is.
@@Rick-jf6sg that was 70 years ago. Times have changed
@@kevinrorke418 Yes, they have, sadly.
What about the altuve taking off his sock
Need robot to call balls and strikes!!
Just umpires want to be seen as tough guys rather than professional
So pathetic
bs comment. Umpires are humans and mistakes happen. Umps have a HUGE amount of pressure on their shoulders that neither me or you could handle.
Carrapazza and the walking toddler that is Mike Estabrook should be canned
スーパーマリオ3Dワールドムービー エクストラ ベンガルズ 品川CCブルザイズ アウト・フォー・ジャスティス ジョン・フリン監督 アクション/クライム
Yah
these umps need glasses and shouldnt have the power to throw people out with there power trips and can just eject anyone they want
Good morning 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😮😮😮😮❤❤❤😮😮❤😮❤
20:49 BOOM!
We should be able to eject umpires out of the game too
I didn't realize Altuve got ejected TWICE this year after a no-call foul off his foot
First was a bad call and a worse ejection.
First. If you're going to show a strike zone on the screen, put it in the right place. It's from the knees to the letters., not the knees to.the belt. Second. Im.sick.of these stupid announcers whinning because a pitcher gets tossed without a warning. Read the rules. They don't have to give warnings.
Third EVERYONE that has ever played knows you dont argue balls and strike or throw your equipment.
Now I know why the White Sox have the worst record in baseball
Some of these guys have paper thin skin
No wonder Umps wear somany pads
スーパーマリオオデッセイムービー イリュージョン ライオンズ 東京ガスクリエイターズ
They're going to ump themselves out of a job one day. It's bizarre... we literally can see what a strike is, yet they feel so confident they throw people out, lol. One day, they'll realize they forced the league's hand to just use the foolproof method.
Some of these players, are overreacting, most of these pitches were pretty close
It’s time for a high tech solution to completely replace these lousy umpires.
Most of them were strikes
Umps hated me when I played. More than a few never called a game again. The amount of dirt umps have in their closet is always insane
No ump is clean and innocent
@@CaughtSlackin_ No player or manager is, either.
Look like umpires wanna ruin the mlb games
If umpires are ruining baseball for you, it’s time to find a new sport. BS comment
I wanna say that taking emotions out of sport is what these umps r trying to do and eblvery single season or game they get it wrong 95% of the time.. Which leads me to ask.. Do umpires have more rules in the rules that specifically says they absolute power over all rules.. And how often are they checked.. Because this is getting ridiculous
Bruh I hate umpires
메이저리그도 한국처럼 ABS를 도입 해야 한다 매우 공정해서 선수들도 불만이 없다
메이저리그 심판들 오심이 너무나도 많다
지겹다
Why can’t players challenge pitches the way they do in the minors? Will it interfere with the flow of the game? So what if it does. The umpires need to improve on their calling of balls and strikes. It has been getting worse the last few seasons to include the 2024 season.
All of the umpires in this video should be fired and fined their salaries
Especially, you go to the showers.
These umpires sucks
The players reactions sucked wdym. Mistakes happen buddy
Only 21 minutes? Lmao I was expecting this shit to be going for HOURS. Seems like players and managers are getting elected every other day in baseball. For good reason too cause those umps have been absolutely awful this season
You can't throw your equipment in anger. It's against the rules.
The announcers are stupid
Umpires suck and win the players gets mad 🤬🤬🤬🤬
アンパイア態度でかいな。
I dunno what happened to John Tumpane this year. He went from 94.4% accuracy to like 93%.....one of the worst. He used to be one of the most accurate behind the plate......
These umps are beyond terrible
The umpires shud be graded, to many bad calls bye, but alot of the players are complaining about pitches that are on the corners and were strikes and the players get bent out of shape when their called. I think players who make a big sciene on a call that was good they should be made to apoligise for their actions as well, seems all of the major sports have become a bunch of whining ball bags.
Man, MLB is almost as bad as the NBA, everyone is a little bit ch, players, coaches and umps
You cannot go by that 2D box. The plate is 3D, and the strike zone is DIFFERENT for every player...
Umpires are way to soft and take their job to seriously. Players have consequemces and get find for stupid shit and u believe umpires should be fined or have consequences for their actions to
This is why you don’t do DEI hires for umpiring.
Stupid trumper😂
Some white umpires were making bad calls here
What do you think DEI actually is? Do you know or are you just mindlessly repeating right wing propaganda?
If it was proven - by video evidence - as a player, I'd NEVER pay the fine (for acting out) and would file a grievance - I umpired for 30 years (and worked with some of the bozos you've featured above) and I only had to ask 'someone to leave' on a handful of occasions......I also let someone 'blow off steam' (as long as they didn't make a scene) and it was NEVER on a "ball or strike" call!!!
Such a disrespect für the referees... is worst then in soccer. There may be some bad referees, but this allowed not such behavior from players or training staff.
Use the right grammar when you’re talking about Americas pastime, and don’t ever compare it to a bunch of chickens with their heads cut off running around a field crying, and begging a “referee” to hold up a sheet of paper.
@@AppleJuice-eo4ghAre you too ignorant to realize the guy is probably not American or just plain stupid?
I understand your point of view being from Europe. But they’re different games completely. If you dm me I’d love to take some time to explain the differences. Needless to say it’s going to be a long conversation. Baseball is very different compared to other sports when it comes to the umpire/ player, coach relationship.
@@patbruno3049 No sense of talking to a clown like him
@@patbruno3049dude you don’t know a thing about americas pastime soccer is where people cry after getting “hit” by a feather😂
Machado is the worst player in baseball and the biggest over paid cry baby in MLB!!!