Schwarber going off and the brewers nodding along… should have been a sign to probably do some investigating Honorable mention joe west thinking he’s bigger than the game itself Ladies and gentlemen…. We got him
Kyle's rant was an all timer...and no one more deserving than Angel Hernandez...how in the hell does he keep his job? Who does he have pictures of? Torre? Manfred? The two of them together??
Hernandez just does this s**t on purpose at this point. He knows because he’s a minority and protected by the union, there will never be consequences for him sucking at his job. He definitely gets off on this s**t.
I’ve never endorsed violence until I started watching Angel Hernandez videos. I refuse to believe no one has decked that smug face during his entire career.
I told someone the other day that some hero needs to take a lifetime ban for blasting Angel in the face, and I was told I'm a psycho. But I stand by it. It's the only way some of these ump bullies will learn.
That called 3rd strike Schwarbs got ejected on was a strike and within the margin of error for the ABS (automatic balls strikes) system. A roboump would have called that a strike as well... I mean the umpires were pretty lenient with Schwarber letting him remain in the dugout AFTER he was ejected. I'm pretty sure the only missed ball/strike call that game by Angel was on McCutch. It's easy for anybody at home with a TrackMan box on their screen to see those pitches are outside of a box, but the tech has a margin of error and most of those "missed calls" were within that margin.
Schwarber going after Hernandez will remain one of my very favorite baseball moments of all time. Then having the camera cut to Cutch and have him standing there with a look that says “yeah. He’s awful.”
The Major League Baseball Umpires Association is the single best reason why Umpires are allowed to be as consistently bad as they are with zero repercussions
Me and every Nationals fan are firm believers that those final 3 calls went against us intentionally. I have never seen another team get called for that ever
Padres fan here, y'all got absolutely ROBBED with those calls. Some of those umps probably owed someone a lot of money and needed to fix the games to pay it off
I'll agree with Davey Martinez that the rule needs to be fixed if its not being called consistently. That call at home was terrible. The plays at first it looked like Turner and Myers took the same path to first.
I am not a Nationals fan, but being a fan of a team that was cheated against playing the Astros (Yankees 2019) I will confirm that the Nationals were absolutely robbed in that series by the Umps doing the cheating for Houston. Houston cant win any clean, they can only win with cheating or bad calls.
I’m probably gonna get made fun of because of what team I go for but that doesn’t matter but as an Angels fan I have to agree with every nationals fan and Dave Martinez like wtf is going on with the umpires nowadays and it’s always the nationals who get screwed over with the base running like how isn’t the commissioner seeing this like it’s just absurd 😂, I recently got into baseball last year and I’ve never loved a sport this much and I have to agree with my brother because my brother loved baseball way more than me but now he hates it cause of the umpires and I totally agree with my brother because If baseball stays like this then it’s gonna be bad for the future of baseball.
I still think the Dodgers-Giants Check swing series was crazy and hilarious at the same time. They got the first one wrong and wait for the worst time for the Giants to balance it 😂
Dodger fans lose their mind over the Ruf check swing but if you look at the whole at bat it was a make up call for calling a pitch 6 inches off the plate a strike earlier in the AB.
I watched the game live, and man, I could tell Schwarber was going to explode after that 6th inning strikeout. I'm glad he did. Made a fan out of me and put the spotlight deservedly on Angel's horrible officiating during that game. Also imo showed Joe Girardi in a bad light. Kyle gets THAT heated, and the opposing team was even agreeing with him, and all he does is walk out with his hands in his pockets for a casual talk? I'm glad we got rid of him after that.
I think Angel has thrown Girardi out the most outta any umpire, or Atleast he’s close. Everyone is sick of Angel, Joe knew he wasn’t gonna get through to him
@@aleclovejoy8636 As a Giants fan the wind screwed you guys in Game 3 on the Lux flyout that should have gone out and tied it and gave us the win and in that one game the ump screwed you guys out of the division on the check swing so it kinda just worked out itself out tbh
LMAO I feel so bad for Washington's manager Davey Martinez. Not only did he get shafted on both sides of a weird call (one in Game 6 of the World Series mind you), every bad call just made no sense and were actually comical
You say that as if broadcasters are the most knowlegeable baseball people in the world. There are several who are quite good, but the vast majority know about half what you think they do and about 5% of what THEY think they do. Color men in particular think just because they played, they know how to officiate.
I’m not from America but I am getting into baseball, i think it’s cause the umpires have all the power whereas in any other sport, there’s a whole system/association beyond the referees
The difference between baseball umpires and cricket umpires is night and day. Cricket umpires will ask for a review if they are not sure, but baseball umpires refuse to accept they are wrong.
@@MimesAgainstHunmanityBaseball (although it would make the game slower) should adopt the cricket approach but umpires don’t give a fuck because they’re protected by the Union
@@jacobcorn7758 The thing is, eventually someone is going to go to far and punch an umpire. Then the union will go on strike. If we are lucky, the League will say that is enough and get rid of them. Unions should not protect incompetence.
I'm an Astros fan and I say kudos to the Nats manager for calling the umpires out on their crap. More managers and owners need to do this in press conferences until changes are made.
@@endeavor105 He's out for awhile due to a back injury. I want him gone as well but only as retirement, I don't want him to be injured or in pain at all. He's a shitty ump but he doesn't deserve pain to be the reason he stops being in games, just his crappy ability to call balls and strikes among other things
@@Mooselaneous lmao with how many call he messed up over the years I don't think any baseball fan would have problem him getting a fastball straight to his mask😂
Yes, some of these umps are on power trips. They should be reviewed on every ejection (someone outside the union) and fined if they didn't have cause. Some of these calls can have huge financial consequences, such as terrible strike zone in a playoff game. I think the strike zone should just be automated and announced out loud without the umpire. Can only be changed if some fluke happens (bouncing or whatnot). Let the game evolve.
9:30 I was actually at that game sitting just to the right of home plate when that call was made. I think it took 5 to 10 minutes for the crowd to calm down after that horrible call that got Murphy ejected for no reason.
I always thought it would be a good idea to make umpires watch their mistakes after the games and then hold a press conference so they can formally apologize for their terrible calls. A taste of a little humility might set these egotistical jerks straight.
I think there should’ve been the game where David Ross (Cubs skipper) went off on the umpires in a game that happened a couple of days ago. The rant postgame is amazing😂
That Meyers not being called out for RLI wasn't "brutal awful umpiring", it was correct as per the rule. A runner is allowed to be where he was in the last step and if you interfere in that last step it's not an out call. There's no automatic out for not being in the running lane, if your throw is so late that the batter has made it to the last step then there's no RLI available. The manager crying with the picture was right that the rule sucks and should change but at the end he was wrong by complaining about "making the right call". They made the right call. The last one was out as well, when the catcher takes the ball (ie tag attempt begins) the runner's path to the base is established straight to it, but he ends up way behind the batter's box, that's close enough to more than three feet away that calling that out is an acceptable judgement call. And the commentators are morons who don't know the rules to the game they're being played to know about.
I'm looking at the on-screen rectangle used to give the viewers an idea of the strike zone, and my question, since the strike zone is 3-dimensional-not 2-dimensional-is, at what part of the strike zone is that 2-dimensional rectangle set?
7:46 he’s not even looking back at the ump so how could he have done that on purpose. Can’t believe he got his feelings hurt that bad from such a minor occurrence. I know umps have fragile egos but this is absurd
Wiemer didn’t swing, yes it looks like it went through but at the point of contact when the ball hits him it definitely looks like a check, he goes through because the wrists getting hit forces the bat through
New rule: every player gets one punch, they can use it whenever. If the player is actually in the right, there are no consequences. If the player is in the wrong the face all the normal consequences of that action.
There is one common thing that bad calls get every time. Publicity. You see it on highlight shows and it gets people talking. Doesn’t matter what sport it is. The only thing the major leagues hate is when the fans aren’t talking about them.
They are not going to have many fans left if it continues. Baseball is already the worst of all professional sports because of the boringness of of the game. If they don't get these umpires in line it will only deteriorate more and more.
its sad that the giants lost a game to a bad call. Its even sadder when that call was a supposed swing strike 3. Its even sadder that it ended their season and sent our rivals to the championships.
Man, I wish I was an MLB ump! Make lots of money, never worry about being good at your job, and be there as long as you choose! Those guys have got it made!
nationals vs astros, 5-4, the catcher should have made the move into fair territory so he'd have enough room to make the throw and not hit the runner. the baseline is for runners, if you run out of the baseline you're out... so tell me how that made sense. the play after literally shows my point!
If you want to argue the runner I'd out of the baseline, then fine. But at least do it for BOTH instances. I get it, different umpires and all, but I don't blame Davey for being pissed when he's on the wrong side of the call both times when the runners took nearly the same line to first base.
The Rangers catcher was not even in the way of Elvis’ slide. His right foot was on the rear most part of home plate. Where was he supposed to be, to tag Elvis out…in the left batters box?
You can't leave the bench to argue warnings given to pitchers or the benches for throwing at batters. If you do, the umpire tells you "Don't come out here--you can't argue that." If you ignore him, that's an ejection by rule, no matter how well-mannered you are.
@@hankluvsdagnytbh that’s kinda dumb. Like they couldn’t use common sense and know he’s going to want an explanation for why both teams were warned when his team did nothing wrong?
is it possible at 4:32 the umpire new it was a ball but he called a strike to end the game because if the guy hits and scores runs the game might tie going to extra innings? because he decided screw it i just wanna go home so he called it a strike.
Funny when I started this video I was thinking, “hell they could play the whole Brewers/Phillies game with Hernandez” and they sure showed a lot of it!
Great compilation 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽 I would like if you do part 3 of the Clinching Walk-Offs from 2016 to now! Walk-offs like Cal Raleigh, Oscar Gonzalez, Chris Taylor, Altuve in 2019 ALCS, Jose Ramirez winning AL Central for Cleveland in 2020 etc...... Thanks 👍🏽
That game by Hernandez should have led to Hernandez getting an immediate suspension. Until umpires are held accountable for obviously bad calls, nothing will change.
Wasn't that Angel on the first clip? Got the call right, only to have MLB overturn it on that ridiculous violation call. He doesn't get many big calls right. Can't have MLB taking away the ones he actually gets right.
Thanks for starting with the Rangers call. That is some of the biggest BS I have ever witnessed in baseball. Can't believe that is a violation. Couldn't be more textbook by Jonah Heim
Obviously all of the player, fans, coaches don't realize that the umpires are the entire show.....they are the only ones that matter and we pay to watch them be awful
Re: check swing call… it’s not “where the bat travels”. The rule is literally “struck at the pitch and missed” and it is a completely subjective call for the umpires EDIT: once more… it does not matter where wiemers bat is. Did he strike at the pitch and miss? I would say so, but again it’s subjective
Umpires make mistakes but there is no excuse for the other 3 umpires to not do anything about bad calls. Their egos are too big to change their calls and MLB continues to enable them because there is zero accountability for their mistakes.
That Brewers/Phillies debacle has me cracking up. FOR GOD'S SAKE, GET RID OF ANGEL HERNANDEZ!!! He is going to be the sole reason got robot umps becoming a thing, he is the worst umpire I've ever witnessed
So, there's a bit more to the story at 8:24. The player was being condescending to the home plate umpire most of the game, and the umpire had had enough. Walker admitted after the game that it wasn't "harmless clapping" and that he was clapping with intent to be annoying
@@thefirstechlon5522 That literally is completely relevant because it means that the umpiring wasn't "awful" and had a reasoning other than, "he was clapping"
There are too many bad calls way too regularly these days, but Angel Hernandez is without question the giver of 80+% of all of them. To this day, it amazes me how this man still holds a job as an umpire in Major League Baseball. If umpires are graded after each game, how is it possible that he still has his job. Players and coaches are held to standards and suspended and/or fined for their actions, why are the umpires not held to ANY standard or level of competence? Is it time to bring in the technology that we all know exists? I say yes.
@0:16 actually the call being overturned is correct. The catcher was in the baseline and standing/blocking home plate as he was catching the ball. According to the rules, that is illegal. He can only do that once in possession of the ball. Search "Collisions at Home Plate" on the MLB glossary website The catcher is not permitted to block the runner's path to the plate unless he is in possession of the ball, though blocking the path of the runner in a legitimate attempt to receive a throw is not considered a violation. His attempt was not to receive the throw as he was already standing there as the throw was occurring, he didn't move into it, nor did he have to make a move into the baseline to make the catch.
20:15 This is a "damned if you do, damned if you don't" situation, because you know Servais would have been out there yelling that he was out of the baseline had the umpire not called it.
theres a consistent theme of batters experiencing "oop, i missed the ball halfway through my swing, ok, no big deal, i just wont continue this swing" and the umpires just taking that personally for some reason.
Not to defend Angel Hernandez, but that's exactly why I hate the broadcast strike zone. It's a 2D rendering of a 3D concept, and it makes some pitches that are balls look like strikes and vice versa. A lot of those pitches were close enough that they probably were strikes, since the rule is that if ANY piece of the ball touches ANY part of the zone -- from the front of the plate all the way to the back -- it's a strike. Plastering a circle on a spot next to a rectangle on a flat plane doesn't consider the entirety of the ~21 inch depth of the plate and whether the ball crossed the zone at some other point, because I'll guarantee you at least some of those did. Take the first Schwarber K in that game -- the outline of the ball is absolutely touching the edge of the zone, which would make that a strike. Even if the second strikeout was the wrong call, Schwarber went into that with the notion that he was on the side of justice and had been screwed over twice, which just wasn't the case. And that's in addition to the fact that the box displayed is just flat out wrong most times. It's either miscalibrated because of the camera angle (same issue the NFL has with the yellow first down line, and they won't hesitate to tell you it's an approximation, not the absolute truth), incomplete (by rule, the top of the zone is the midpoint of the batter's torso/shirt, or roughly where the letters are on most uniforms, yet most broadcast strike zones clearly don't rise above the batters' waists, or change from batter to batter, which the real strike zone absolutely does), or just simply can't account for depth (some display where the ball is caught, some spot it on the plane at the front of the plate, but none of them can take into account the entirety of the 3D strike zone).
I don't blame the umps for really any of the check swing calls. The rule only mentions intent. If the ump thinks the batter meant to try to hit the ball, it is a swing. There is no magic criteria, even less to go on than for balks, as to whether a batter checked his swing. There are rules of thumb that some umps have mentioned in the past, but that is it really. Also, the Hyde ejection from the HBP. That is the correct call in that situation. The umps can warn at ANY time they want to. They probably thought the HBP was not intentional, but there would be retribution. Give warnings to stop it escalating. Turner being called out for RLI is completely correct. He never enters the runner's lane, then stops 1B from catching the ball. The ONLY argument you could have there is if you think he couldn't have made the catch if there wasn't a leg in the way. The last one, I definitely believe he moved more than 3 feet to avoid the tag, hence should be out.
11:30 yeah i dont get warnings there. Even if he wasn't doing it on purpose and just had no command that day....its a safety issue at that point. He needs to be done.
Some calls you agree with, some you don't: *Everyone agreed with Schwarber.*
He spoke for the entirety of Baseball when he went off.
I think Angel Hernandez and CB Bucknor, make these outrageous calls on purpose just to get a reaction out of the players, so they can eject them.
@@Southernguy41facts
It worked too, notice how you haven’t heard from Angel Hernandez this season?
This is why I always go watch 'Umpire hit by pitch' compilations. Gives me a good feeling that someone was Jesus on the cross for dipshit calls.
@@Rand0mContnt Hopefully we never will again
The umpire staring at Bumgarner was the most unprofessional thing I've ever seen from an ump in my life.
couldnt agree moe, guy never looked down for any "substance" he stared Bum down just to get a reaction so he could throw him, genuinely embarrassing
I would’ve gave him the Kobe death stare and cursed him and his wife out
Well, that and the entirety of Angel Hernandez's career
That's where the next pitcher and the catcher should "get crossed up" and let a heater get through to the ump
I'm not the biggest baseball fan but I agree... Also very "You" creepy...
Schwarber going off and the brewers nodding along… should have been a sign to probably do some investigating
Honorable mention joe west thinking he’s bigger than the game itself
Ladies and gentlemen…. We got him
Kyle's rant was an all timer...and no one more deserving than Angel Hernandez...how in the hell does he keep his job? Who does he have pictures of? Torre? Manfred? The two of them together??
Hernandez isn't that smart. Worst ump in MLB history.
Hernandez ftx money. He needs to retire
There’s a reason he hasn’t umped a game this season
@@stephenstone8480it’s because the MLB umpires have a union which makes it’s basically impossible to get fired
ton of respect for Schwarber saying the bullshit calls have been going against both teams
Can't blame Hernandez, he is actually the first legally blind ump. Ah hell I can't keep a straight face. :)
ALL FUCKING NIGHT!!! THE WHOLE NIGHT!!! BOTH SIDES!!! FUCKING HORSESHIT!!! 30 CALLS!!! *_30 CALLS!!!_*
Hernandez just does this s**t on purpose at this point. He knows because he’s a minority and protected by the union, there will never be consequences for him sucking at his job. He definitely gets off on this s**t.
The pitcher’s face was funny on the second one lol like 😬
I’ve never endorsed violence until I started watching Angel Hernandez videos. I refuse to believe no one has decked that smug face during his entire career.
If a baseball player does ever do that to him, build that man a statue and have him treated to free drinks for the rest of his life 😂.
I told someone the other day that some hero needs to take a lifetime ban for blasting Angel in the face, and I was told I'm a psycho. But I stand by it. It's the only way some of these ump bullies will learn.
@@sethheasley9538 absolutely. Even start a gofundme for that hero so he can be set for life!
@@kevinstull8552 I’d fly out just get that person the first round of drinks.
That called 3rd strike Schwarbs got ejected on was a strike and within the margin of error for the ABS (automatic balls strikes) system. A roboump would have called that a strike as well... I mean the umpires were pretty lenient with Schwarber letting him remain in the dugout AFTER he was ejected. I'm pretty sure the only missed ball/strike call that game by Angel was on McCutch. It's easy for anybody at home with a TrackMan box on their screen to see those pitches are outside of a box, but the tech has a margin of error and most of those "missed calls" were within that margin.
Schwarber going after Hernandez will remain one of my very favorite baseball moments of all time. Then having the camera cut to Cutch and have him standing there with a look that says “yeah. He’s awful.”
Hader's face after the strike call says it all. He knows he got a totally bullshit call and even he doesn't look happy about it
The Major League Baseball Umpires Association is the single best reason why Umpires are allowed to be as consistently bad as they are with zero repercussions
Maybe the teams should go on strike until the league changes this bullshit.
It's getting wayyyyyyy outta hand!
@@johnnylightning203I agree
Angel Martinez……worst.
NOPE. it is LACK OF BALLS from MLB itself
@@dv8photography joe west. #2 worst
Me and every Nationals fan are firm believers that those final 3 calls went against us intentionally. I have never seen another team get called for that ever
First one doesn’t make any sense since I think the whole league was rooting for us as the underdogs to win it all.
Padres fan here, y'all got absolutely ROBBED with those calls. Some of those umps probably owed someone a lot of money and needed to fix the games to pay it off
I'll agree with Davey Martinez that the rule needs to be fixed if its not being called consistently. That call at home was terrible. The plays at first it looked like Turner and Myers took the same path to first.
I am not a Nationals fan, but being a fan of a team that was cheated against playing the Astros (Yankees 2019) I will confirm that the Nationals were absolutely robbed in that series by the Umps doing the cheating for Houston. Houston cant win any clean, they can only win with cheating or bad calls.
I’m probably gonna get made fun of because of what team I go for but that doesn’t matter but as an Angels fan I have to agree with every nationals fan and Dave Martinez like wtf is going on with the umpires nowadays and it’s always the nationals who get screwed over with the base running like how isn’t the commissioner seeing this like it’s just absurd 😂, I recently got into baseball last year and I’ve never loved a sport this much and I have to agree with my brother because my brother loved baseball way more than me but now he hates it cause of the umpires and I totally agree with my brother because If baseball stays like this then it’s gonna be bad for the future of baseball.
I still think the Dodgers-Giants Check swing series was crazy and hilarious at the same time. They got the first one wrong and wait for the worst time for the Giants to balance it 😂
Dodger fans lose their mind over the Ruf check swing but if you look at the whole at bat it was a make up call for calling a pitch 6 inches off the plate a strike earlier in the AB.
Thankfully the Braves ended the Fraudgers season in the next round 😂.
@@kevinstull8552cry more
@@kevinstull8552thankfully dodgers are first to have 2 world series titles this decade 😂😂
This could’ve been a 30 minute Angel Hernandez compilation and we wouldn’t have been surprised
I watched the game live, and man, I could tell Schwarber was going to explode after that 6th inning strikeout. I'm glad he did. Made a fan out of me and put the spotlight deservedly on Angel's horrible officiating during that game. Also imo showed Joe Girardi in a bad light. Kyle gets THAT heated, and the opposing team was even agreeing with him, and all he does is walk out with his hands in his pockets for a casual talk? I'm glad we got rid of him after that.
I think Girardi is just done with Angel, as is the entire baseball nation.
I think Angel has thrown Girardi out the most outta any umpire, or Atleast he’s close. Everyone is sick of Angel, Joe knew he wasn’t gonna get through to him
As a Giants fan, the second and third clip were absolute torture. No team’s season should end that way.
Poetic justice was served
@@luiss.3866 but on a (not) CHECK SWING?! In the NLDS?! lol
@@luiss.3866how about I take it out ON YOUR FAMILY?!
Im a dodgers fan and humbly accept that we didn’t win fair and square! Max was pitching a good game however. Not sure what would of happened.
@@aleclovejoy8636 As a Giants fan the wind screwed you guys in Game 3 on the Lux flyout that should have gone out and tied it and gave us the win and in that one game the ump screwed you guys out of the division on the check swing so it kinda just worked out itself out tbh
LMAO I feel so bad for Washington's manager Davey Martinez. Not only did he get shafted on both sides of a weird call (one in Game 6 of the World Series mind you), every bad call just made no sense and were actually comical
No wonder the guy had heart surgery, he probably needs enough blood pressure meds for a guy who weighs 700 lbs
The Realmuto ejection was just ridiculous lol
Yeah he hurt the umpires feelings
I honestly think ESPN, umpires, sports caster, etc hate the Phillies
I love how he just laughs it off because it was just that absurd lmao
gotta love when even the broadcasters are baffled by those terrible calls
You say that as if broadcasters are the most knowlegeable baseball people in the world. There are several who are quite good, but the vast majority know about half what you think they do and about 5% of what THEY think they do. Color men in particular think just because they played, they know how to officiate.
@@hankluvsdagny no, I'm saying that if even them, who don't know shit as you implied, can tell it's a bad call, that's because it's a truly bad call
@@The_Room_2_Doggys_RevengeI don't think that's a good argument since uninformed people can just as easily be wrong
What I’ve learned: it’s 2023 and umpires still don’t umpire well (in fact I think they got worse)
I’m not from America but I am getting into baseball, i think it’s cause the umpires have all the power whereas in any other sport, there’s a whole system/association beyond the referees
Officiating across all professional sports in America are at a crisis level of bad.
The difference between baseball umpires and cricket umpires is night and day. Cricket umpires will ask for a review if they are not sure, but baseball umpires refuse to accept they are wrong.
@@MimesAgainstHunmanityBaseball (although it would make the game slower) should adopt the cricket approach but umpires don’t give a fuck because they’re protected by the Union
@@jacobcorn7758 The thing is, eventually someone is going to go to far and punch an umpire. Then the union will go on strike. If we are lucky, the League will say that is enough and get rid of them. Unions should not protect incompetence.
Dave Martinez and base lines equals chaos😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣
Martinez coming with receipts is one of the greatest moves ever.
Seriously I feel for the guy. He was right on all 3 calls. I don’t blame him for losing his shit
I'm an Astros fan and I say kudos to the Nats manager for calling the umpires out on their crap. More managers and owners need to do this in press conferences until changes are made.
Whether you agree with the call or not, it's great to see a manager who's willing to stick up for his boys even when they don't have much to play for.
angel Hernandez being gone soothes us Philly fans lol
Is he gone for real??? Praise Jeebus!!!
@@endeavor105 He's out for awhile due to a back injury. I want him gone as well but only as retirement, I don't want him to be injured or in pain at all. He's a shitty ump but he doesn't deserve pain to be the reason he stops being in games, just his crappy ability to call balls and strikes among other things
@@Mooselaneous lmao with how many call he messed up over the years I don't think any baseball fan would have problem him getting a fastball straight to his mask😂
@@Quxvo
Or to his nuts. :D
I think it soothes every baseball fan on the planet.
Yes, some of these umps are on power trips. They should be reviewed on every ejection (someone outside the union) and fined if they didn't have cause. Some of these calls can have huge financial consequences, such as terrible strike zone in a playoff game.
I think the strike zone should just be automated and announced out loud without the umpire. Can only be changed if some fluke happens (bouncing or whatnot). Let the game evolve.
The Realmuto one still blows my mind
It is a disgrace to athletics that Angel Hernandez is still allowed to call games.
Good news
9:30 I was actually at that game sitting just to the right of home plate when that call was made. I think it took 5 to 10 minutes for the crowd to calm down after that horrible call that got Murphy ejected for no reason.
And none of these umpires will face any consequences because of the Umpire’s Union. Maybe MLB should sue the Umpire’s Union, if that’s the case.
Union's got Manfred by the balls. Absolutely spineless commish.
They get fined all the time, they don’t make millions so getting fined 15 k isn’t small.
BREAKING NEWS: An umpire got suspended for betting on games. News reported this week
When the opposite team commentators think you’re ridiculous (Phillies vs Blue Jays) you know you are in the wrong
I always thought it would be a good idea to make umpires watch their mistakes after the games and then hold a press conference so they can formally apologize for their terrible calls. A taste of a little humility might set these egotistical jerks straight.
Can't even blame Kyle Schwarber there. Mans was rung up twice on pitches on another planet
exeedits-shop.com/
Any calls that should've been added? Do you disagree with any of the ones that I included? Thank you for watching!
I think there should’ve been the game where David Ross (Cubs skipper) went off on the umpires in a game that happened a couple of days ago. The rant postgame is amazing😂
I’ve watched part 1 and 2, but there was no Galarraga play?? I’d there a reason why you haven’t posted that play yet??
@@ChasebrycenI feel bad piling on Jim Joyce for that one, especially since he apologized so much for it
That Meyers not being called out for RLI wasn't "brutal awful umpiring", it was correct as per the rule. A runner is allowed to be where he was in the last step and if you interfere in that last step it's not an out call. There's no automatic out for not being in the running lane, if your throw is so late that the batter has made it to the last step then there's no RLI available. The manager crying with the picture was right that the rule sucks and should change but at the end he was wrong by complaining about "making the right call". They made the right call.
The last one was out as well, when the catcher takes the ball (ie tag attempt begins) the runner's path to the base is established straight to it, but he ends up way behind the batter's box, that's close enough to more than three feet away that calling that out is an acceptable judgement call. And the commentators are morons who don't know the rules to the game they're being played to know about.
I'm looking at the on-screen rectangle used to give the viewers an idea of the strike zone, and my question, since the strike zone is 3-dimensional-not 2-dimensional-is, at what part of the strike zone is that 2-dimensional rectangle set?
7:46 he’s not even looking back at the ump so how could he have done that on purpose. Can’t believe he got his feelings hurt that bad from such a minor occurrence. I know umps have fragile egos but this is absurd
"You're supposed to run into the catchers mitt, Bob."
Wiemer didn’t swing, yes it looks like it went through but at the point of contact when the ball hits him it definitely looks like a check, he goes through because the wrists getting hit forces the bat through
Yeah, I don't know why that is in this video
Yeah. I saw the slower replay on CloseCallSports, and it's clearly a HBP before he got to the point it was a swing. This was a good call.
He swung AFTER he got hit. If it's called a strike all hell breaks loose the other way.
Gotta love it when EXE drops
New rule: every player gets one punch, they can use it whenever. If the player is actually in the right, there are no consequences. If the player is in the wrong the face all the normal consequences of that action.
There is one common thing that bad calls get every time. Publicity. You see it on highlight shows and it gets people talking. Doesn’t matter what sport it is. The only thing the major leagues hate is when the fans aren’t talking about them.
They are not going to have many fans left if it continues. Baseball is already the worst of all professional sports because of the boringness of of the game. If they don't get these umpires in line it will only deteriorate more and more.
It always seems like Angel Hernandez is involved with over 50% of all of the worst calls.
More like 75%
He knew what he was doing when he put Angel Hernandez on the cover💀💀
First time I've ever seen Scott Service mad at anyone 😂😂
I love how some of these aren't even on calls. Realmuto with the ball, Walker with clapping. Egotistical umps
It was JTs only major league ejection. In a long career
@@ScottE-GDPI’ll do you one even better, JTs only ejection in the majors yes. Butttttt, it was a spring training game
Bumgarner is bout it bout it, that ump knew exactly what he was doing. What a tool
That Bumgarner incident was outrageous.
It almost as if the umpires are begging to be replaced by an automated strike zone...
Newsflash they’ve been trying the automated strike zone and you all bitch about that too because it isn’t good
its sad that the giants lost a game to a bad call. Its even sadder when that call was a supposed swing strike 3. Its even sadder that it ended their season and sent our rivals to the championships.
Even in a video devoted to bad umpiring, Angel stands out.
Man, I wish I was an MLB ump! Make lots of money, never worry about being good at your job, and be there as long as you choose! Those guys have got it made!
nationals vs astros, 5-4, the catcher should have made the move into fair territory so he'd have enough room to make the throw and not hit the runner. the baseline is for runners, if you run out of the baseline you're out... so tell me how that made sense. the play after literally shows my point!
If those two calls that screwed the Nats against the Astros don’t scream rigged, idk wtf does.
Yeah those were straight up bad calls, against Washington.
If you want to argue the runner I'd out of the baseline, then fine. But at least do it for BOTH instances. I get it, different umpires and all, but I don't blame Davey for being pissed when he's on the wrong side of the call both times when the runners took nearly the same line to first base.
The Rangers catcher was not even in the way of Elvis’ slide. His right foot was on the rear most part of home plate. Where was he supposed to be, to tag Elvis out…in the left batters box?
That check swing call to end the giants season was the make up call for the one that tied the game
They have GOT to do something about the Posey Rule (plate blocking).
In no way, shape or form should the first call have been overturned.
LMAO how is Angel still an ump? Even the ump union should want that guy gone
Nothing is certain except death, taxes, and a compilation of bad umpire calls featuring Angel Hernandez.
The orioles coach was so calm and bro j threw him out when they were up 14😭😭
You can't leave the bench to argue warnings given to pitchers or the benches for throwing at batters. If you do, the umpire tells you "Don't come out here--you can't argue that." If you ignore him, that's an ejection by rule, no matter how well-mannered you are.
@@hankluvsdagnytbh that’s kinda dumb. Like they couldn’t use common sense and know he’s going to want an explanation for why both teams were warned when his team did nothing wrong?
Honestly, why even go out to talk to the ump at all when your team is up 14-0 in the 8th? Who cares at that point?
4:00 that umpire has the worst depth perception and should lose his pay
To be fair, the umpire on the first one got it right. It was the booth that messed that one up.
You just know it's going to be good when Angel Hernandez is in the thumbnail... 🤣😂🤣😂
4:33 The catcher even framed it and it was still outside the strike zone.
is it possible at 4:32 the umpire new it was a ball but he called a strike to end the game because if the guy hits and scores runs the game might tie going to extra innings? because he decided screw it i just wanna go home so he called it a strike.
Literally me on the “strikes” wtf if that call. “Angel Hernandez rings him up.” Me afterwards oh now that makes sense
Funny when I started this video I was thinking, “hell they could play the whole Brewers/Phillies game with Hernandez” and they sure showed a lot of it!
Great compilation 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽 I would like if you do part 3 of the Clinching Walk-Offs from 2016 to now! Walk-offs like Cal Raleigh, Oscar Gonzalez, Chris Taylor, Altuve in 2019 ALCS, Jose Ramirez winning AL Central for Cleveland in 2020 etc...... Thanks 👍🏽
Umpiring is the only job in the world you can do wrong 95% of the time and never get fired.
Don't forget weather "forecasting"...🫤
When they called the Pablo Lopez pitch a ball I just started hysterical laughing, can't make it up
The MLB needs to change the rule about the lane violation!
6:50 this is genuinely disturbing. hope ump has been fired
umpires have real bad self esteem issues. they are getting so bad in mlb
Angel Hernandez retired. It was time, thank you for your service Angel.
In this video I learned that the umpires hate the nationals
Ángel Hernández must be blowing the MLB bosses 😂😂😂
That game by Hernandez should have led to Hernandez getting an immediate suspension. Until umpires are held accountable for obviously bad calls, nothing will change.
Wasn't that Angel on the first clip? Got the call right, only to have MLB overturn it on that ridiculous violation call. He doesn't get many big calls right. Can't have MLB taking away the ones he actually gets right.
Thanks for starting with the Rangers call. That is some of the biggest BS I have ever witnessed in baseball. Can't believe that is a violation. Couldn't be more textbook by Jonah Heim
Obviously all of the player, fans, coaches don't realize that the umpires are the entire show.....they are the only ones that matter and we pay to watch them be awful
Can you do an angel hernandez compilation
That would be like 3 hours minimum of rage inducing content. I couldn’t stand it.
Might be good material for an anger management class though.
computerize umpires button
Can someone please kindly explain what’s going on at 19:36? The manager says they need to fix a rule, yet it was called incorrectly?
Because the play before, his guy did the exact same thing and got called out for it
Re: check swing call… it’s not “where the bat travels”. The rule is literally “struck at the pitch and missed” and it is a completely subjective call for the umpires
EDIT: once more… it does not matter where wiemers bat is. Did he strike at the pitch and miss? I would say so, but again it’s subjective
100% agreed, and that's the real problem. There is literally no definition of a check swing.
Umpires make mistakes but there is no excuse for the other 3 umpires to not do anything about bad calls. Their egos are too big to change their calls and MLB continues to enable them because there is zero accountability for their mistakes.
The umpire's union is the best argument for union busting ive ever seen.
Clips like this is why I'm totally ok with robot umps coming, lol
Angel hernandez js the worst (in my opinion)
👇
It's not an opinion, it's fact
And since he can claim racism if he’s ever fired then we’re stuck with him forever
That Brewers/Phillies debacle has me cracking up. FOR GOD'S SAKE, GET RID OF ANGEL HERNANDEZ!!! He is going to be the sole reason got robot umps becoming a thing, he is the worst umpire I've ever witnessed
bro these umpires literally must be conspiring against the nationals good lord 😂
So, there's a bit more to the story at 8:24. The player was being condescending to the home plate umpire most of the game, and the umpire had had enough. Walker admitted after the game that it wasn't "harmless clapping" and that he was clapping with intent to be annoying
That literally couldnt be more irrelevant
@@thefirstechlon5522 That literally is completely relevant because it means that the umpiring wasn't "awful" and had a reasoning other than, "he was clapping"
How many bad calls are umpires allowed per game???
that brewers/philly one reminds me of the naked gun movie... Leslie Nielsen just calling everything a strike... lol
13:19 that's so cool they got Shaggy to be a commentator for this game
The sheer frequency of Angel appearing in videos like these is insane
Every one of these should be an Angel Hernandez compilation.
There are too many bad calls way too regularly these days, but Angel Hernandez is without question the giver of 80+% of all of them. To this day, it amazes me how this man still holds a job as an umpire in Major League Baseball. If umpires are graded after each game, how is it possible that he still has his job. Players and coaches are held to standards and suspended and/or fined for their actions, why are the umpires not held to ANY standard or level of competence? Is it time to bring in the technology that we all know exists? I say yes.
do part 4 love it
This is more entertaining than watching the full games on tv
When was the Dodgers - Giants game at 1:07?
@0:16 actually the call being overturned is correct. The catcher was in the baseline and standing/blocking home plate as he was catching the ball. According to the rules, that is illegal. He can only do that once in possession of the ball.
Search "Collisions at Home Plate" on the MLB glossary website
The catcher is not permitted to block the runner's path to the plate unless he is in possession of the ball, though blocking the path of the runner in a legitimate attempt to receive a throw is not considered a violation.
His attempt was not to receive the throw as he was already standing there as the throw was occurring, he didn't move into it, nor did he have to make a move into the baseline to make the catch.
Why would they throw my favorite player Jt Realmuto out of the game at 7:24?😢
This should just be a compilation of Angel Hernandez
20:15 This is a "damned if you do, damned if you don't" situation, because you know Servais would have been out there yelling that he was out of the baseline had the umpire not called it.
theres a consistent theme of batters experiencing "oop, i missed the ball halfway through my swing, ok, no big deal, i just wont continue this swing" and the umpires just taking that personally for some reason.
This is why I watch compilations of umps getting drilled by balls lol
Not to defend Angel Hernandez, but that's exactly why I hate the broadcast strike zone. It's a 2D rendering of a 3D concept, and it makes some pitches that are balls look like strikes and vice versa. A lot of those pitches were close enough that they probably were strikes, since the rule is that if ANY piece of the ball touches ANY part of the zone -- from the front of the plate all the way to the back -- it's a strike. Plastering a circle on a spot next to a rectangle on a flat plane doesn't consider the entirety of the ~21 inch depth of the plate and whether the ball crossed the zone at some other point, because I'll guarantee you at least some of those did. Take the first Schwarber K in that game -- the outline of the ball is absolutely touching the edge of the zone, which would make that a strike. Even if the second strikeout was the wrong call, Schwarber went into that with the notion that he was on the side of justice and had been screwed over twice, which just wasn't the case.
And that's in addition to the fact that the box displayed is just flat out wrong most times. It's either miscalibrated because of the camera angle (same issue the NFL has with the yellow first down line, and they won't hesitate to tell you it's an approximation, not the absolute truth), incomplete (by rule, the top of the zone is the midpoint of the batter's torso/shirt, or roughly where the letters are on most uniforms, yet most broadcast strike zones clearly don't rise above the batters' waists, or change from batter to batter, which the real strike zone absolutely does), or just simply can't account for depth (some display where the ball is caught, some spot it on the plane at the front of the plate, but none of them can take into account the entirety of the 3D strike zone).
I don't blame the umps for really any of the check swing calls. The rule only mentions intent. If the ump thinks the batter meant to try to hit the ball, it is a swing. There is no magic criteria, even less to go on than for balks, as to whether a batter checked his swing. There are rules of thumb that some umps have mentioned in the past, but that is it really.
Also, the Hyde ejection from the HBP. That is the correct call in that situation. The umps can warn at ANY time they want to. They probably thought the HBP was not intentional, but there would be retribution. Give warnings to stop it escalating.
Turner being called out for RLI is completely correct. He never enters the runner's lane, then stops 1B from catching the ball. The ONLY argument you could have there is if you think he couldn't have made the catch if there wasn't a leg in the way.
The last one, I definitely believe he moved more than 3 feet to avoid the tag, hence should be out.
11:30 yeah i dont get warnings there. Even if he wasn't doing it on purpose and just had no command that day....its a safety issue at that point. He needs to be done.