LMAO it's weird because people somehow forget that neal is only less than 20 years younger than hook. whats creepier is that emma and him met when she was 17.
Uhhh....Neal NEVER stopped fighting for her #1 - What about the time when Neal rush into his apartment to save her from GOLD's wrath? #2 - Or the time when they were fighting off Regina and Cora?? #2 - Or the time when he "Got her back" hunting down his crazy fiance (which Emma really had no proof of?) in the Cannery? #3 Or the time when he let go of his hand so that Emma wouldn't be sucked into the portal with him??? How people can turn a blind eye to all of this is pretty astounding!!!
Honestly. And the season before Hook was willing to let her die as long as he got what he wanted. He doesn't get to just spring a love confession like that.
I Didn’t I Still Remember All These Scenes and I Think Neal And Emma Had Plenty Of Chemistry I Mean Even Though He Hurt Emma He Did It To Protect Her He Still Remain Respectful to her choices and He Saved Her Life From His Own Dad And Risked His Own Life Many Times Because he loved them and Loved Henry Emma Broke That Promise That Neal Kept Unlike Her
Haha, I find it funny people are saying Took/Hink and Swanfire are endgame... and look what happened! Looks like sailing the CaptainSwan ship paid off. WOO!
CrehzehBehbeh If August could be brought back from wherever Blue banished him when she turned him back into a little boy (seriously - she's more evil than Rumpel and Regina combined), then Baelfire has a chance. Rumpel was collecting all that magic for something, and it wasn't just to scorch the earth after losing his son. I think he was building up power to go into the Underworld and bring his son back the old fashioned way. We've seen Medusa, Pandora's box, and King Midas - it's about time we got the Greek demigods on board. And I would totally support Keith David guest starring as Apollo, or maybe upgrading to either Zeus or Hades.
SWANFIRE! Relationships are not always smooth sailing. There are bound to be pains, hurts, arguments, but the ones that stick to their guns, stand the test of time. They are the greatest of love stories...
To everyone debating whether Emma should be with Neal or Hook. It is extremely refreshing to read comments with long logical reasoning behind the choice and respect for others opinions! I Love it!
Be still my SwanFire heart! I love Neal and Emma still loves Neal and Hook is someone that Emma and Neal are both connected to. Interesting dynamic. How exciting! Season 3 has been awesome so far and now Ariel's going to Storybrook-it's about to get really good. And shout out to Joanna Garcia who I thought did a superb job as my favorite princess ever!
The fact that the scene ends with Hook's reaction says a lot imo. If this was a SF scene it would be solely focused on Neal and Emma, but it isn't; the writers made an effort to show Emma and Hook's reactions only. You never see Neal react to a CS scene (even his reaction to the kiss was u-turned into a CS moment) but you always see Hook react to SF. To me that shows SF is an obstacle for CS to overcome, because if it was the other way round the writers wouldn't focus on Hook so much
Captain Swan. All the way. "Never stop fighting for you"?? Serously, when has Neal really ever fought for Emma?? He didn't even know he had knocked her up and she had a baby in jail!! Hook may have a dodgy past (like Emma and Neal had been saints!! They were criminals!), but for at least ten episodes now he's really changed favorably, he's let go off his anger and hate and everything he's done has been out of love for Emma. He did say that the two things he would always be willing to die for were love and revenge, and revenge has all but dissapeared from his mind. He's out to win her heart with "no trickery", only by the evidence of his deeds. They think alike, have the same intuitive skills, both know what it is to feel alone and, in Emma's words, they understand each other. Not to mention Neal looks like a sea lion. Sorry but it's true. He may be a good guy and a good father, but that's about it, the chemistry between him and Emma is about as strong as a ball of playdoh. I see fireworks with Hook. And besides, wht's one of the elements of true love?? Finding the person in spite of the adversity... And Hook has found Emma in New York. It would be a HUGE waste if the writers didn't get them together. Hook's got his heart on the right place, and he's played clean for a while now... He has earned his happy ending now.
If you ship captainswan I have some good news. You know how emma is the product of true love (snow + charming) and nobody can take her heart out. Well last episode Henry got his heart taken out which means he's NOT the product of true love.
But Henry took his own heart out... when Peter Pan very well should have been able to do it. Probably just the writers giving us all something to argue about, but I have to speculate that perhaps being the product of true love simply means no one can steal your heart (in the literal sense). Even though Henry believed in him, and he definitely had permission, Pan had Henry do the heart-ripping. I don't ship either way, I just like seeing both sides.
Oh yeah, you guys do know the writers confirmed Henry's heart can be ripped out because he did it himself? LOL. Bad news. If you want the link, tell me.
What this shows you is that first love is not necessarily true love. We know that Snow and Charming are first love and true love. But Regina and her first love were not, she is supposed to be with Robin Hood. Rumple and Milah were first loves but not true love, he is meant to be with Belle. Hook's first love was Milah too but he is meant to be with Emma. And Neal and Emma were first loves but not true love. Captain Swan is endgame. They are perfect.
Since this show has the same writers from Lost I really hope they don't try to have the same love triangle here like they did in Lost because if so Hook is totally screwed. :(( I really want Captain Swan to be endgame.
Hook and Emma all the way. As much as Neal is Emma's past and a part of her WILL always love him in some way, I just don't see a happy ending for them. Hook and Emma have an undeniably chemistry and I definitely see him winning her heart eventually. She's gonna be conflicted, sure, but I think Neal will remain her past while Hook will become her future.
Not saying that I'm a SF shipper because I'm not, but I don't exactly hate Neil... The guy needs a happy ending too. Not with Emma though. Tink probably.
Well yeah Hook did betray her in the past, but they weren't allies or anything. Besides, Emma DID betray Hook on the beanstalk and when she argue that Hook would've done the same, he said "actually no". What Neal did was way more hurtful because if he had been more confident in himself, he would've done the right thing for Emma as the savoir, but without abandoning her,
Here's a thought: Ariel and Hook. Her story is open for change because Disney put a new spin on it to give it a happy ending but in the original tale the little mermaid dies and turns to foam.
When did he start fighting for her? Confused by this sudden declaration whereas Hook's been by her side since he came back and unlike Neal he came back very fast.
SWANFIRE FOREVER! they are an epic love that will find there way back to one another..about Neal not going after Emma for 10 years lets not forget August he's the one that told him he knew who he was and to stay away & let Emma break the curse..so for me some of the blame for the 10 years is because of him & his dad was the other reason he hated magic it's what destroyed his family. I'm not saying Neal is completely innocent but it wasn't all him.
Okay, this actually seems very selfish of Neil to me, He is not acting for Emma's happiness. She literally just said to his face I need to move on I'm sorry but I have to and he says oh yeah okay I understand but just so you know I'm always gonna be there. He basically just trapped her and made it impossible for her to move on, this isn't even me as a captainswan shipper talking I think that Neil is just being insanely selfish right now. If he really loved Emma as deeply as he says he would want whats best for her and what makes her happy and he would let. her. go. I don't even care about ships anymore I will only be happy with Neil whenl he backs off and lets her move on!
I've come here straight after watching Emma and Hooks goodbye scene in 5x20 and all I have to say is: HA, all you Swanfire shippers saying Hook is evil and that Emma would never love him, you have been proven wrong!
Awwwwww.......Hooks look through the whole cave scene and after.....It's like his heart is breaking and he's trying to be the 'better man' about it. Soooooooo glad he told though. The predictable thing would have been that he kept it a secret. Really want them to have Emma explore a relationship with Hook though!
I really thought Killian had lost his shot with Emma and that Neal would get her back somehow you can just tell he was disappointed hearing him say he'll never stop fighting for her little did they know they'd end up together I shipped it from the beginning! CAPITAN SWAN! 💜
CAPTAIN SWAN IS STRONGER THAN SWANFIRE. Neal, I thought when the curse was broken you would go back to Emma but you freakin didnt! You went back with a fiance and now that you realize that emma has been warning you about Tamara and that you were wrong youre going to fight for her and make her trust you again? You even taught her more bad values in the start then left her. Plus guys have you see the way Emma and Hook look at each other?!? I mean come ON its soo undeniable
I feel like when he said he was never gonna stop fighting for her, he meant that he was never gonna stop fighting for her happiness, for her being happy and having happy ending come to her eventually. I think he knew things were never gonna truly work out between them, because while Hook has shown in many ways how he's willing to fight for her, her happiness, and her family, while fighting to be there with her, fighting his inner fears to be with her, to have her be his happiness and have him be hers, Neal showed that he was willing to fight for her happiness, and for their family, but he wasn't willing to fight to be there with her, at least not when it came to fighting and facing his inner demons, which in Neal's case is his dad, and the issues they have with each other and Rumple backing out on their deal and letting him fall through the portal so he could keep his magic
What Emma wants should matter too. At this moment, Emma wants to move on from Neal. Hook put his ego on the line and made himself vulnerable so that Emma could have a chance to rescue Neal. I think that counts for a lot.
And I thought soap fans were nasty. Geez. It's just a tv show- a really good one. Can't we all just ship who we're going to ship without any hostility to any one charater?
Neal (although he's Henry's father and very integral to Emma's story) came back at a really bad time. Although bringing him back after he fell through the portal to the EF brought some really good storylines, it also made things much more complicated for Emma. She had to deal with him abandoning her and then him coming back with a new girlfriend and then him getting shot and falling through the portal AND THEN running into him in Neverland. She has had to let him go so many times that she's tired of it. She wants it to be final and she thought she had closure when he fell through the portal.
The way I see it, once they got out of Neverland, Wendy should grow to her actual age (I mean, I'm not sure how this timeline works, but she should be as old as Neil by now, right?). Then Neil could start seeing her differently and have a fresh start. As for Emma... well, Hook is right there waiting, isn't he? I think it would be a very good way to prove that people can love again and mend their broken hearts.
I never liked Hook much, but I am starting to warm to him a bit this season. At least he's starting to get over Milah The Hag From Hell, finally. I would be okay with him finding a new love, Emma or someone else, just as long as he leaves my Rumbelle alone from how on!
Swan fire seemed pushed to the side after Capt Swan and I don’t know why Neal & Emma have a lot more history and unresolved feelings but that is never explored in any way (a flashback would have been nice) the Neal dies in the second haft of S3 and Hook swoops in. Neal was basically the end goal everything that happened in the past was leading to Neal and it just poofed away
A lot of people are saying how Emma should've ended up with Neal, but they don't get that Neal hurt Emma way too much for their relationship to be the way it was before. He also left her just because a living puppet told her too, like I don't care if people say, "Oh he was trying to help Emma fulfill her destiny." Bullshit! That was no excuse for him to abandon like that, especially with the shit she has to go through. Like I'm sure they would want to still be in each other's lives for Henry's sake, but their relationship would never be the same, it was too damage. But with Emma and Hook, they were struggling with baggage their damage pasts, Hook broke down Emma's walls and she grew to trust him, and Emma helped Hook see that he was so much more than a pirate.
Emma: I was hoping you were dead because you cause me pain Emma: I can't change the way I feel, I'm sorry Neal: That's cool babe, now stand over there and let me tell you why I'm not going to listen and leave you alone
Point. That does not negate the fact that Hook was trying to be a father figure to Neal, and he not only had a role in destroying his family, and now is going after his son's mother.
Having a child together doesn't make them soulmates. We should start noting that families nowadays are different. I would want my parents to be happy, and not be unhappy (by staying together) just for the sake of me. If Emma finds someone who truly loves her and puts her first, why should she deny a chance at happiness and stay with someone whom she wants to put behind and forget? She deserves her happy ending, and I think Henry is a smart kid on that front.
i wish neal/emma scenes weren't about hook in some way. hook got scenes with emma without neal looking over his shoulder, why can't the same apply for emma/neal scenes
The writers did that for a reason; Neal's the third wheel, he's the obstacle Emma and Hook have to overcome that's why we see Hook's reaction to a SF scene but not Neal's reaction to a CS scene.
METerrell Nope. Bagelfire's the third wheel. I would go on with a paragraph for all the reasons why Emma chose Hook over Neal, but I won't; thus, I'm tired and lazy. In the winter finale she let Hook in by saying "Good." Read her facial expression. If she had truly, deeply hated Killian's guts(which I doubt seeing as they got together in season 4), she wouldn't have led him on, wouldn't have given him hope. In that moment she wasn't the Savior, the all tough and nails girl with walls built so high they could have almost topped Mt.Everest, she was Emma Swan; the girl who had always yearned for a home, yearned to be loved. And now she has that. Even if it was for a moment. She has a family and this guy who's shown his feelings for her over and over and over again, so yes she is going to respond positively. "Good" confirms that yes, she does want him to think of her; Yes, she does want him to fight for her. Emma Swan appears vulnerable in that scene; and we don't get to see her in her vulnerable state often. It's quite obvious of her choice in the Dark Hollow. 3A was about getting Killian to fall for Emma, so 3B will now be about getting Emma to fall for Killian. Season 4 will explore their relationship, and so on and so on. I honestly don't get why you haters make up these silly little arguments. If you want a good statement, then make one. Other wise leave us CS shippers alone. Emma's gonna end up with Killian; Not Neal; End of story. Though go ahead and continue to whine; if you do so, remember all the crap i don't give.
Fallen Rain half your own post is just speculation about future seasons, I believe Swan fire is endgame because every time Emma and Neal are together they feel like a couple. Emma is not a fairytale character, so she can date around (for ex. Hook) before settling down with her true hubby (Neal).
Good point. Because my heart does break for Hook, does anyone else find it a little disturbing that he's no into the woman of his dead loves son. Anyone else believe that it's possible that he's into Emma not because of Emma but because she may remind him of Milah?
![OUAT - 4x05 'I don't remember' [Emma & Killian]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PlebMV8Rk58/mqdefault.jpg)
![OUAT - 4x05 'I don't remember' [Emma & Killian]](/img/tr.png)
Aw, it's sweet because both guys are old enough to be her grandfather. Wait . . . .
😂😂
More like great great great great grandfather.
LMAO it's weird because people somehow forget that neal is only less than 20 years younger than hook. whats creepier is that emma and him met when she was 17.
But neverland stuck him phisicallyvand mentally in child age, so what
Technically Hook was “married” to Henry’s Paternal Grandmother
Neal: I will never stop fighting for you
Me: WHEN DID YOU START
hahahaha sooo true!!!
YESSSSSS !!!! so true !!!!
+calisa14 fast-forward to 5x04
Killian: "I'm never gonna stop fighting for us" AND WE BELIEVE HIM BECAUSE IT DAMN WELL MEANS SOMETHING
+calisa14 Agree completely!
SO TRUE!
Uhhh....Neal NEVER stopped fighting for her
#1 - What about the time when Neal rush into his apartment to save her from GOLD's wrath?
#2 - Or the time when they were fighting off Regina and Cora??
#2 - Or the time when he "Got her back" hunting down his crazy fiance (which Emma really had no proof of?) in the Cannery?
#3 Or the time when he let go of his hand so that Emma wouldn't be sucked into the portal with him???
How people can turn a blind eye to all of this is pretty astounding!!!
Honestly. And the season before Hook was willing to let her die as long as he got what he wanted. He doesn't get to just spring a love confession like that.
I Didn’t I Still Remember All These Scenes and I Think Neal And Emma Had Plenty Of Chemistry I Mean Even Though He Hurt Emma He Did It To Protect Her He Still Remain Respectful to her choices and He Saved Her Life From His Own Dad And Risked His Own Life Many Times Because he loved them and Loved Henry Emma Broke That Promise That Neal Kept Unlike Her
Haha, I find it funny people are saying Took/Hink and Swanfire are endgame... and look what happened! Looks like sailing the CaptainSwan ship paid off. WOO!
Woop Woop!!!
CrehzehBehbeh If August could be brought back from wherever Blue banished him when she turned him back into a little boy (seriously - she's more evil than Rumpel and Regina combined), then Baelfire has a chance. Rumpel was collecting all that magic for something, and it wasn't just to scorch the earth after losing his son. I think he was building up power to go into the Underworld and bring his son back the old fashioned way. We've seen Medusa, Pandora's box, and King Midas - it's about time we got the Greek demigods on board. And I would totally support Keith David guest starring as Apollo, or maybe upgrading to either Zeus or Hades.
Took/Hink? Get your spelling right if you want people to take you seriously.
@@qwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnm3093 he is talking about tinker bell and hook’s ship name. So his spelling is right.
@@eylulakbas5251 then he would say took only, or hink only. You wouldn't say Captain/Swan would you?
SWANFIRE! Relationships are not always smooth sailing. There are bound to be pains, hurts, arguments, but the ones that stick to their guns, stand the test of time. They are the greatest of love stories...
To everyone debating whether Emma should be with Neal or Hook. It is extremely refreshing to read comments with long logical reasoning behind the choice and respect for others opinions! I Love it!
Be still my SwanFire heart! I love Neal and Emma still loves Neal and Hook is someone that Emma and Neal are both connected to. Interesting dynamic. How exciting! Season 3 has been awesome so far and now Ariel's going to Storybrook-it's about to get really good. And shout out to Joanna Garcia who I thought did a superb job as my favorite princess ever!
Neal: I'm never gonna stop fighting for you
Emma: Please stop fighting for me
The fact that the scene ends with Hook's reaction says a lot imo. If this was a SF scene it would be solely focused on Neal and Emma, but it isn't; the writers made an effort to show Emma and Hook's reactions only. You never see Neal react to a CS scene (even his reaction to the kiss was u-turned into a CS moment) but you always see Hook react to SF. To me that shows SF is an obstacle for CS to overcome, because if it was the other way round the writers wouldn't focus on Hook so much
What is cs and sf?
@@contessa8817 CS = CaptainSwan
SF = SwanFire. Their ship names.
SwanFire
No! poor hook. he thought he had a chance with his second love but Neil is back and still loves Emma!!!! CaptainSwan
Emma and hook = perfect
"I'll always fight for you"
Yeah so not contacting Emma for 10 years and getting engaged with someone else is considered "fighting for" someone?
The sentence basically mean “I will always fight for you”
He didn’t have “I have always fought for you”
He wasn’t taking the past into consideration
Captain Swan. All the way. "Never stop fighting for you"?? Serously, when has Neal really ever fought for Emma?? He didn't even know he had knocked her up and she had a baby in jail!! Hook may have a dodgy past (like Emma and Neal had been saints!! They were criminals!), but for at least ten episodes now he's really changed favorably, he's let go off his anger and hate and everything he's done has been out of love for Emma. He did say that the two things he would always be willing to die for were love and revenge, and revenge has all but dissapeared from his mind. He's out to win her heart with "no trickery", only by the evidence of his deeds. They think alike, have the same intuitive skills, both know what it is to feel alone and, in Emma's words, they understand each other. Not to mention Neal looks like a sea lion. Sorry but it's true. He may be a good guy and a good father, but that's about it, the chemistry between him and Emma is about as strong as a ball of playdoh. I see fireworks with Hook. And besides, wht's one of the elements of true love?? Finding the person in spite of the adversity... And Hook has found Emma in New York.
It would be a HUGE waste if the writers didn't get them together. Hook's got his heart on the right place, and he's played clean for a while now... He has earned his happy ending now.
Yasss #captainswan for life and #hooker
If you ship captainswan I have some good news. You know how emma is the product of true love (snow + charming) and nobody can take her heart out. Well last episode Henry got his heart taken out which means he's NOT the product of true love.
But Henry took his own heart out... when Peter Pan very well should have been able to do it. Probably just the writers giving us all something to argue about, but I have to speculate that perhaps being the product of true love simply means no one can steal your heart (in the literal sense). Even though Henry believed in him, and he definitely had permission, Pan had Henry do the heart-ripping. I don't ship either way, I just like seeing both sides.
Henry gave away his heart on his own will. That's not the same as what you're saying.
Oh yeah, you guys do know the writers confirmed Henry's heart can be ripped out because he did it himself? LOL. Bad news.
If you want the link, tell me.
Screw neal
#captianswan for life!!!
Thank you for posting this video:D
What this shows you is that first love is not necessarily true love. We know that Snow and Charming are first love and true love. But Regina and her first love were not, she is supposed to be with Robin Hood. Rumple and Milah were first loves but not true love, he is meant to be with Belle. Hook's first love was Milah too but he is meant to be with Emma. And Neal and Emma were first loves but not true love. Captain Swan is endgame. They are perfect.
Neal: I'm never gonna stop fighting for youMe: I'm never gonna stop shipping you two
🤮🤮🤮
Since this show has the same writers from Lost I really hope they don't try to have the same love triangle here like they did in Lost because if so Hook is totally screwed. :(( I really want Captain Swan to be endgame.
Thank you
#captianswan for life
Hook and Emma all the way. As much as Neal is Emma's past and a part of her WILL always love him in some way, I just don't see a happy ending for them.
Hook and Emma have an undeniably chemistry and I definitely see him winning her heart eventually. She's gonna be conflicted, sure, but I think Neal will remain her past while Hook will become her future.
Not saying that I'm a SF shipper because I'm not, but I don't exactly hate Neil...
The guy needs a happy ending too. Not with Emma though. Tink probably.
Hook: THIS MEANS WAR!!!
Well yeah Hook did betray her in the past, but they weren't allies or anything. Besides, Emma DID betray Hook on the beanstalk and when she argue that Hook would've done the same, he said "actually no". What Neal did was way more hurtful because if he had been more confident in himself, he would've done the right thing for Emma as the savoir, but without abandoning her,
Ok here's an idea: Tinkerbell and Neal. Call me crazy but I think it could happen eventually.
Amen!
I totally agree so don't call yourself crazy : )
Here's a thought: Ariel and Hook. Her story is open for change because Disney put a new spin on it to give it a happy ending but in the original tale the little mermaid dies and turns to foam.
Jacklyn Lawson Well, I don't know about that =P I' am kind of a Captain Swan shipper all the way
Duly noted...outstanding observation!
When did he start fighting for her? Confused by this sudden declaration whereas Hook's been by her side since he came back and unlike Neal he came back very fast.
SWANFIRE FOREVER! they are an epic love that will find there way back to one another..about Neal not going after Emma for 10 years lets not forget August he's the one that told him he knew who he was and to stay away & let Emma break the curse..so for me some of the blame for the 10 years is because of him & his dad was the other reason he hated magic it's what destroyed his family. I'm not saying Neal is completely innocent but it wasn't all him.
Okay, this actually seems very selfish of Neil to me, He is not acting for Emma's happiness. She literally just said to his face I need to move on I'm sorry but I have to and he says oh yeah okay I understand but just so you know I'm always gonna be there. He basically just trapped her and made it impossible for her to move on, this isn't even me as a captainswan shipper talking I think that Neil is just being insanely selfish right now. If he really loved Emma as deeply as he says he would want whats best for her and what makes her happy and he would let. her. go. I don't even care about ships anymore I will only be happy with Neil whenl he backs off and lets her move on!
Thank you! I honestly don't like Emma with either of them but you explained why I don't like Neal's relationship with her perfectly.
I've come here straight after watching Emma and Hooks goodbye scene in 5x20 and all I have to say is: HA, all you Swanfire shippers saying Hook is evil and that Emma would never love him, you have been proven wrong!
😊
Awwwwww.......Hooks look through the whole cave scene and after.....It's like his heart is breaking and he's trying to be the 'better man' about it. Soooooooo glad he told though. The predictable thing would have been that he kept it a secret. Really want them to have Emma explore a relationship with Hook though!
Swanfire!!!
I really thought Killian had lost his shot with Emma and that Neal would get her back somehow you can just tell he was disappointed hearing him say he'll never stop fighting for her little did they know they'd end up together I shipped it from the beginning! CAPITAN SWAN! 💜
¨Pfff he's so boring... fight for her?! Haha nice joke since you left her, and came back ready to get married with someone else!
CAPTAIN SWAN IS STRONGER THAN SWANFIRE. Neal, I thought when the curse was broken you would go back to Emma but you freakin didnt! You went back with a fiance and now that you realize that emma has been warning you about Tamara and that you were wrong youre going to fight for her and make her trust you again? You even taught her more bad values in the start then left her. Plus guys have you see the way Emma and Hook look at each other?!? I mean come ON its soo undeniable
I feel like when he said he was never gonna stop fighting for her, he meant that he was never gonna stop fighting for her happiness, for her being happy and having happy ending come to her eventually. I think he knew things were never gonna truly work out between them, because while Hook has shown in many ways how he's willing to fight for her, her happiness, and her family, while fighting to be there with her, fighting his inner fears to be with her, to have her be his happiness and have him be hers, Neal showed that he was willing to fight for her happiness, and for their family, but he wasn't willing to fight to be there with her, at least not when it came to fighting and facing his inner demons, which in Neal's case is his dad, and the issues they have with each other and Rumple backing out on their deal and letting him fall through the portal so he could keep his magic
Ainoymouno
Imohnohnohnl🎉❤
What Emma wants should matter too. At this moment, Emma wants to move on from Neal. Hook put his ego on the line and made himself vulnerable so that Emma could have a chance to rescue Neal. I think that counts for a lot.
Hook told them about Neal even if it means he'll lose Emma. Neal didn't even say a word about the other person locked up in the cage by Pan.
And I thought soap fans were nasty. Geez. It's just a tv show- a really good one. Can't we all just ship who we're going to ship without any hostility to any one charater?
In my opinion hook and Emma belong together... I wish they would and that probably sounds bad for Henry but their such a good match
This show has way too many feels!
Swanfire forever!!!
Colin's acting in this episode was flawless! CS Shipper! :D x
Neal (although he's Henry's father and very integral to Emma's story) came back at a really bad time. Although bringing him back after he fell through the portal to the EF brought some really good storylines, it also made things much more complicated for Emma. She had to deal with him abandoning her and then him coming back with a new girlfriend and then him getting shot and falling through the portal AND THEN running into him in Neverland. She has had to let him go so many times that she's tired of it. She wants it to be final and she thought she had closure when he fell through the portal.
aaaaawwwww!
captainswan!!!!!!
The way I see it, once they got out of Neverland, Wendy should grow to her actual age (I mean, I'm not sure how this timeline works, but she should be as old as Neil by now, right?). Then Neil could start seeing her differently and have a fresh start.
As for Emma... well, Hook is right there waiting, isn't he? I think it would be a very good way to prove that people can love again and mend their broken hearts.
exactly.what.i.was.thinking.
Captin Swan xD
Captain Swan is Epic !
they are amazing together ! Captain Swan
swan fire :)
I am gone I died to much loviness and truth comin out it's killin me
MY heart!!!! rip neal :(
I never liked Hook much, but I am starting to warm to him a bit this season. At least he's starting to get over Milah The Hag From Hell, finally. I would be okay with him finding a new love, Emma or someone else, just as long as he leaves my Rumbelle alone from how on!
Exactly
LOL I second that XD
I can't decide! I can't decide!
Emma, you choose, I'll have the leftover. ;)
NEAL FUCKING CASSIDY. GODDAMN, I LOVE THIS GUY.
Awwww Killie....
*LET ME LOVE YOU*
In my opinion Hook and Emma are made for each other.She belongs with Hook not with Neal!!!!
Facts #CaptainSwanForEternity ❤
I think he meant as of that very moment he would never stop fighting for her.
Swan fire seemed pushed to the side after Capt Swan and I don’t know why Neal & Emma have a lot more history and unresolved feelings but that is never explored in any way (a flashback would have been nice) the Neal dies in the second haft of S3 and Hook swoops in. Neal was basically the end goal everything that happened in the past was leading to Neal and it just poofed away
is that you have loved swanfire ?
Wait. Wasn't Neal trying to band Tamara the day he admitted he loved Emma??! 😂 that's funny
A lot of people are saying how Emma should've ended up with Neal, but they don't get that Neal hurt Emma way too much for their relationship to be the way it was before. He also left her just because a living puppet told her too, like I don't care if people say, "Oh he was trying to help Emma fulfill her destiny." Bullshit! That was no excuse for him to abandon like that, especially with the shit she has to go through. Like I'm sure they would want to still be in each other's lives for Henry's sake, but their relationship would never be the same, it was too damage. But with Emma and Hook, they were struggling with baggage their damage pasts, Hook broke down Emma's walls and she grew to trust him, and Emma helped Hook see that he was so much more than a pirate.
so you preferred emma and hook rather than emma and neal ?
@@soixsantesduh #CaptainSwanForEternity ❤
Captain Swan til the end!!!!!!!!!!!! Emma and Neal have zero chemistry!!!!!!!!!
#BetterTogether. That's because he didn't know who would be in the other cage until further revealed.
captain swan always!!
POOR KILLIAN!
Captain swan and bae and hook finally see each other again
Oh hook ! I love you captain swan all the way !!
Forget Hook and Neal. WHERES GRAHAM!
Dead( killed by Regina)
Ibrahim Anjum *sigh* I know
hook and eyeliner though
guyliner!!
Swanfire all the way
Captain Swan for the win! I mean after these few episodes, How can you not ship them?
Emma: I was hoping you were dead because you cause me pain
Emma: I can't change the way I feel, I'm sorry
Neal: That's cool babe, now stand over there and let me tell you why I'm not going to listen and leave you alone
Hook is just "love triangles? ewww! Let's go get the fairy and the kid"
Ohmygod!
Hook seemed so sad awwww ):!
And the end!
Hang in there Hook!
Gosh
Hook and Emma seriously need to hook up U3U
I want to hug hook... He deserves a happy ending
Awww poor hook :'(
Let the love triangle commence...!
Poor Hook. He's so heart broken! I wish I could fix him.
...and the love triangle begins; BRING IT ON NEAL
CAPTAIN SWAN FTW
And if we've learned ANYTHING it's First love isn't necessarily TRUE LOVE is Once Upon a Time 101
Point.
That does not negate the fact that Hook was trying to be a father figure to Neal, and he not only had a role in destroying his family, and now is going after his son's mother.
It's alright Emma, no need to go through any drama, I'll take Hook if you don't want him! But you better want him lol
This scene was cute I'm crying now
it would e so cool if somehow Graham would be alive and be the one for emma
CAPTAIN SWAN IS ENDGAME
I loved that Nesl is going to fight for Emma! He is still do in love with her!
Captain swan:)
Having a child together doesn't make them soulmates. We should start noting that families nowadays are different. I would want my parents to be happy, and not be unhappy (by staying together) just for the sake of me. If Emma finds someone who truly loves her and puts her first, why should she deny a chance at happiness and stay with someone whom she wants to put behind and forget? She deserves her happy ending, and I think Henry is a smart kid on that front.
@Chalicodragon
Fact: Milah chose to run away with Hook.
Fact: Emma is not Neal's girlfriend. She hasn't been for over 10 years.
Whatever guys but I am always going down with the Captain Swan ship.
i love how she told hime she loved him
i wish neal/emma scenes weren't about hook in some way. hook got scenes with emma without neal looking over his shoulder, why can't the same apply for emma/neal scenes
The writers did that for a reason; Neal's the third wheel, he's the obstacle Emma and Hook have to overcome that's why we see Hook's reaction to a SF scene but not Neal's reaction to a CS scene.
Lavender Creme Someone get this person a cookie!
Lavender Creme Neal isn't the third wheel, Hook is. Hook only thinks he loves Emma, and she doesn't love him at all.
METerrell Nope. Bagelfire's the third wheel. I would go on with a paragraph for all the reasons why Emma chose Hook over Neal, but I won't; thus, I'm tired and lazy. In the winter finale she let Hook in by saying "Good." Read her facial expression. If she had truly, deeply hated Killian's guts(which I doubt seeing as they got together in season 4), she wouldn't have led him on, wouldn't have given him hope. In that moment she wasn't the Savior, the all tough and nails girl with walls built so high they could have almost topped Mt.Everest, she was Emma Swan; the girl who had always yearned for a home, yearned to be loved. And now she has that. Even if it was for a moment. She has a family and this guy who's shown his feelings for her over and over and over again, so yes she is going to respond positively. "Good" confirms that yes, she does want him to think of her; Yes, she does want him to fight for her. Emma Swan appears vulnerable in that scene; and we don't get to see her in her vulnerable state often. It's quite obvious of her choice in the Dark Hollow. 3A was about getting Killian to fall for Emma, so 3B will now be about getting Emma to fall for Killian. Season 4 will explore their relationship, and so on and so on. I honestly don't get why you haters make up these silly little arguments. If you want a good statement, then make one. Other wise leave us CS shippers alone. Emma's gonna end up with Killian; Not Neal; End of story. Though go ahead and continue to whine; if you do so, remember all the crap i don't give.
Fallen Rain half your own post is just speculation about future seasons, I believe Swan fire is endgame because every time Emma and Neal are together they feel like a couple. Emma is not a fairytale character, so she can date around (for ex. Hook) before settling down with her true hubby (Neal).
I agree! Leave Nealfire alone!
(but i'm a swanfire xD)
Captain swan!!! :(
people saying that neal haven't even startet t fight for emma, so... how in the hell NEAL arrived in Neverland? guess he just appeared there
Good point. Because my heart does break for Hook, does anyone else find it a little disturbing that he's no into the woman of his dead loves son. Anyone else believe that it's possible that he's into Emma not because of Emma but because she may remind him of Milah?