They threw the stone and hide their hands after, or more clearly they started this dispute and dipped when they saw the conflict it was creating and wanted no part of it.
They both deserve land and peace. I understand why they’re not wanting to share their land but I feel like there isn’t a better person over the other. Jews went through Holocaust and Palestinians forced out of the country are both very terrible things to go through
Passive garbage that excuses the side with all the agency. Terrorism didn't start with Palestinians it was Israeli nationalists targeting the British occupation. Designated terrorists formed government and to this day one of the front bench ministers has a portrait hanging in his office of an Israeli terrorist who did exactly what the Christchurch shooter did. In any other context that is insane to celebrate a mass shooting terrorist and get elected and to say Terrorism started with homeless Palestinians is not a balanced take in the slightest. Apartheid isn't complicated when you have a moral backbone.
clearly you're not a pro palestinian protestor. otherwise you would've kept yourself ignorant and made a big noise about something you have no idea about.
I’m going to sound even more stupider than I already feel but how did Britain ‘forget’ that they had already promised the lands to Palestinians? Unless I’m missing something (which I probably am) that seems like quite a big promise to forget.
they didn't promise the land to the palestinians, because it was aready theirs. they went to the palestinian land and promised it to the jews who were in need of a home even though that land wasnt theirs to give. Britain is very annoying in history
Every single person in this comment section forget that were more than half a million jews in ww2 living in israel, close to the arabs population back then
You so fucking dumb. It’s not about water it’s about other more important things about the land. You either so dumb or you just wasted your time seeing this video
ironically California steals water from Midwest . Without the govt helping them they would be nothing like they are. LEAVING Midwest to be welfare states.
Soo... What I understood was this so please correct me if I'm wrong. I'm trying to understand. Britain promised the same land to two different groups: the Israeli and the Palestinians. Both groups historically have lived on this land, but it was mostly Palestinians until at that time and lots of Jews were uprooted by WW2 so were looking for a home. Britain tried to do good by finding a place for the Jews to live, but made a big, rude, oopsie and offered someone else's (Palestinians') home to the Jewish people. So now the two have to fight over a small bit of dry land (few water resources) and the Jewish kept expanding and encroaching on the Palestinians to the point where a group of desperate radicals formed the terrorist group Hamas to tell the Isaeli to back off? Did I get any of that correct? Please help. Edit: And Jerusalem is important to both groups so they both don't wanna give it up.
"Expanded" needs to be explained. Everyone says the Jews bought land, they never conquered those territories. So in my point of view it's fine that they "expanded". The muslims are just pissed that they sold their whole land to a religion that they hate. Jews on the other hand live side by side with palastinians. They make up 20% of their population and most of the palastinians in Israel support the war against Gaza because they know the terror they have to endure. That's why they have the most efficient defensive system in the world.
At that time the Arabs palestinian don't call themselves palestinian in that time they call themselves only Arabs. There was the Arabs league not the Palestinian league. The Arabs that today call themselves palestinian in the past supported in big Arabs state called big syria. The big Arabs state they want is in what today syria jordan irak and lebanon. In January 1919 the Arabs even agree that the jews will have a state in the area that today israel if they get big Arabs state. Only when the Arabs learned about the secret agreement between britain and france called sies picot agreement they felt betrayed because they learned that france get syria. ONLY FROM THAT TIME THE ARABS THAT LIVED IN PALESTINA STARTED TO DEVELOP NEW IDENTITY SEPARATE FROM THE SYRIANS AND THE JORDANIANS. THE SYRIANS AND THE JORDANIANS ARE THE SAME PEOPLE LIKE THE PALESTINIAN.
The new settlers jews that came to the land in 1881 at that time did not explend any Arabs. The new jews settlers settled in places that no one lived in or bought land from landowners with full many. The land where the jews settled was very desolate and a lot of area was empty. The Arabs that lived in the land lived in villages. If the Arabs not started war in 1947 than no Arabs were deported.
The jewish settlers who started the new jewish settlement in 1881 settled in places that were deserted and uninhabited. The Arabs who lived in the area were scattered in villages. The jews dried swamps and fight desess like malria. Most of the Arabs came from Arabs countries during the ottoman rule. During the ottoman rule there were no borders in the region. And syria jordan lebanon and irak did not exist, all this area was called SYRIA PALESTINA. many Arabs came to the land in the 19th century mainly after the jews settled there to find work. Also you can fond Arabs family that lived in the land 300 400 years. But most of the Arabs arrived to the land in the 19th century. Most of the Arabs don't lived there for generations, in the other hand the jews that came to Israel from Arabs countries really lived in the Arabs countries for generations. They came to Israel after they suffered from pogroms and Humiliation in the Arabs countries. For example the pogrom called the Farhud take place in irak in the year of 1941. Also in Morocco in the city if fez was the pogrom called the Trital when Arabs slaughtered jews with sources and knives.
@@nanishal7870The Zionist Jews don't want it because they think God gave this land only to them.But they always forget that Arabs are their abrahamic cousins so they also have a share over the land(this is true, it's in the new testament).I think one secular democratic state for the land of Jews and Arabs should be better
Millions of people’s homes already established can’t just easily be moved, Resources like farmland, oil, water , businesses etc etc can’t just be moved
Boo hoo. Get a grip. You know who is probably more tired than you? Palestinians, who have to endure famine, starvation, regular air strikes, being burned alive, being detained and tortured to death for no reason. You're 'tired' about hearing about their 'problems'? People like you are why history is doomed to repeat itself. You have two choices: show some damn humanity; educate yourself properly on this matter, protest, do something active to help stop this madness...or continue to feel 'so tired by their problems', turn a blind eye, and allow genocide to continue. If the latter is really the life you want to live, then you are a pathetic excuse for a human being. Sorry not sorry.
You are setting at your sofa and writing these stupid comments while Palestine people suffering and dying , stop this stupid emotional bullshit and think by your mind before your heart
@@ronakio “I’m so tired of hearing about their problems everywhere, everyday” what a callous and privileged way of looking at life…there are real people suffering the most unimaginable pain in Palestine, the very least you can do is care…
Thank you so much for this!! I have been so confused and everything saying “a simple guide” was anything but simple 😅 my boyfriend and I would like to thank you for this insightful video you have shared!!
Thnks for the video. I was really wondering why my friend was so adamant and critical about companies giving donations to israel and boycotting them. Up to this point is till have no idea about it all i know is that this isnt something that its not up to our decision to boycot or side with any country. Both side has dealt massive distrust and sins against each other. We can educate ourselves and help but not to the point of boycot, we have no real idea how they feel they are just doing what they think is best and siding with one side will just fan the flames of hatred. Why not boycot the british? Or the UN since they started this whole mess? Ofcourse we cant because this is a generation of wrong choices and even israel and palestine has them mutual understanding and compromise is the way to end this until then this wont end. Even if one side won due to war im sure the other will retaliate to get what they think they deserve.
@@Alex13509 I said we cant, plus boycotting is weird for me like how they want to boycott inside out2. You cant solve anything without any proper discussion. On a side note your reasoning can also be said with all the woke propaganda, rasicm, and more. Why do you have to hold someone accountable for something their ancestors did? Just because they are of the same blood doesnt necessarily mean they are the same
@ltnvideo I haven't trusted Jon Oliver ever since his nursing / Healthcare episode where he cherry picked "facts" to create a narrative. My wife and I are both nurses and haven't watched him since. And before you make an accusation, we are both extremely left leaning and NOT Maga. But I still want my information to be unbiased and truthful.
British didn't give nothing. Jews already bought many Mediterranean lands from ottoman empire. The partision plan just added desert neguev - completely neutral and empty land
@@Maxy-d7l Jews were always indigenous to this land - genetic tests prove that they are genetically closer to each other and to other levantine peoples, than they are to the people in the countries that they left when immigrating to Israel (because holocaust, pogroms...). Palestinians also have levantine genetics mostly, but there was no such thing as "Palestinians" when Israel came to be. There were many unrelated Arab tribes, levantine people that were arabized during Arab colonialism, and a lot of empty land. There were also many Jews still in the land of Israel, many generations before '48, so it's not like these lands were uniquely Arab. The Palestinian identity and nationality was artificially created in the sixties, only to unite the Arabs against the so-called "evil Zionist entity". There are other peoples indigenous to the levantine, for example the Druze - do you see them making any trouble?
@@Mehiel-Sanctoria wasnt palestinian land for christians jews and muslims under the Ottoman Empire? Idk if i got it wrong the muslims provoked al nakb. Also lets say its actually the Palestinian's land. Terror isn't the answer and Israel would have the right to defend their land. I would not give a land to someone like Hamas who would want to spread terror to other countries after getting Israel. Terrorist countries arent good.
@cccccc6667 Palestine doesn't have an army to stand up to Israel, so terror is their last resort. It's awful, but it's the only thing they can do to prevent getting conquered by Israel.
@Mehiel-Sanctoria doesnt justify terrorism. Declare war or at the very least (this is still wrong) hurt the army, not random ppl that have nothing to do with the army aka civillians. Also if they are able to use their force to cause terror, cant they use that same force to fight back against Israel forces? Attacking Israel is just going to create "violence"/retaliation in this long-term problem that today's Palestinians are talking about and mistaken about. Makes sense to why a terrorist group like Hamas is leading Palestine. I wouldnt give land to Hamas or any terrorist group just for them to attack other countries and spread terror and force Islam to others while lets say hypothetically Israel is the problem even if Israel is just interested in containing the land and that's it.
Thank you so much for this brave video! I’m going to try to type a long comment. I like cats too. And I’m very grateful for this video as I said before. I heard someone say that it’s an inconvenience to listen about this genocide so often, but we’re in the age of technology and social media. How can we just sit back when we can see everything going on right before our eyes? A genocide occurring while the entire world knows about it is insane, especially when people can become aware of where their tax paying dollars are going. You’re a really great creator and I enjoy your in depth and informative videos and look forward to reading your book in the future. Hope that this was long enough.
Sooo this seems to me what happens when your WHOLE identity is your religion. I don’t have a dog in the fight but you’d think that if religion wasn’t such a major factor, they could try to get along like the melting pot of America.
Sorry but it wasn't 50/50 The Jews got the largest share, especially in the important areas. They are guests who came to take land that is not theirs, and with all impudence they divide the land.
Actually that’s not true lol. Palestinians were originally granted 70% of total land and majority of the natural resources, with Jerusalem being an international hub. A plan which Palestinians rejected.
When britain received the mandate over the region they gave the eastern part of palestina to the Hashemite family from Saudi arabia for their help in first world war that how the kingdom of jordan was created. Before that syria also was included in what was called syria palestina. Britain and france divided the area between them and created new states like syria jordan lebanon and irak. In 1919 the Arabs want big Arabs state called greater syria. Only when they learned that syria go to france they felt betrayed and started to develop new identity separate from the Syrians and the Jordanians. There is no difference between the Palestinian jordanian and syrian.
Agree with the first person. You dodged one. This video is filled with propaganda and carefully crafted narration and format to paint Israel as some legitimate entity when it is obv not. In addition to downplaying their brutality and aggression. Painting the oppressed and dispossessed Palestinian resistance as terrorism. Bunch of BS.
I think it's more so that people understand the political nature of WHY people resort to terrorism. Very few people actually side with attacking civilians, but to solve a problem like terrorism you need to understand its motives. This requires asking hard questions like why people become terrorists. Why do these people hate Israel so much? And this video does a good job of explaining that. There are also people who are radicalized by their made up religion--in which case there is no understanding because religion is itself nonsensical and made up.
People pushed to believe that the only way to fight back is terrorism, are the people who should be sided with. That’s like saying “Nobody should side with people who are suicidal.”
@@DominolitheoneTerrorism is never the way. Resistance is cool, but when you start using terrorism, it sucks. You can’t just start attacking non combatants for your own goals
Please be accurate with the facts. Please give me one example that the jewish settlers explained Arabs before the Arabs started a war against the jews in 1947. If you don't have such a case then don't invent false facts. What is true that during the warjews explained Arabs. In the first part of the war the Arabs enjoyend victories, the Arabs did not leave any jews alive in the settlements they conquered. In the second part of the war the jews went from defence to attack, and then there were also deportation of Arabs. The Arabs did not expel jews, they simply slaughtered the jews in the areas they conquered.
Do you not understand English? Did you completely miss the part where the UN got involved? After the UN got involved, it was no longer a British problem.
The Arabs were not called Palestinians. Arabs looked upon the termology of Palestinian as a insult. It was not until 1965 that Russia recommended to Arafat to call themselves Palestinians as a strategy to try and legitimise their claim. MUCH OF YOUR STORY IS FALSE.
I don’t understand how people can do research on this topic, fully understand the history, wars, and current events, and then turn around ignorantly hate Israel and support Hamas
Britain promised jewish people homes in palestinian people's homes. Britain decided to split the land 50/50 (wasnt even 50/50, israel got more). So now, what used to be palestinian land is now mostly israeli. Any logical person would be annoyed and angry if a huge part of theyre land is taken by immigrants. The natives got displaced to a smaller land so that the immigrants could have a big place to live. So evil am i right?
In the ottoman time all the area that today syria jordan and israel was without borders and called syria palestina. In a secret agreement between britain and france called sies picot agreement britain and france divided the area between them syria and lebanon go to france and the rest go to britain. When the Arabs learned about the secret agreement that syria go to france they felt betrayed and started to develop new identity separate from the Syrians and the Jordanians. There is no difference between the Palestinian jordanian and syrian. The Arabs that today called themselves palestinian always considered themselves as syrian Arabs, see the agreement between Faisal and Weizmann from January 1919 from the Paris peace conference.
This video didn’t really explain it correctly. First, Jews and Arabs have been living in the Israeli area when the British controlled it and already had conflict. The British and the UN thought the best solution was to separate the 2 groups of people. 2. Israel got the increase of land from all the wars they won. 3. Why can’t the Palestinians live on other lands? Egypt also borders the Gaza Strip but Egypt wants nothing to do with the Palestinians. If they would stop waging war, there would be no loss of lives
See? This is exactly why people say “there are no sides in war,” because situations like this happen and nobody knows who to root for, both sides have a clear and compelling argument for what and why they are fighting. You can’t just pick a side on that unless you’re tied to some sort of bias.
Izrael - is it Izrael’s or Palestinian (Arab) name? The history of Izrael shows that this name is 4,000 years old. There has never existed any ethnic group or nation called Palestinians. Cannot be mixed with Philistines who came from the area of Greece. Ha Shem said to Abraham to move from Ur to nowadays Izrael and to BUY the land in Beer Sheva, then Izrael tribes spread throughout the whole area, Jews were then under the king David, Salomon and many other kings.. Abraham had a son Izak and Izak had a son Jakob. Ha Shem changed Jacob’s name to Israel, meaning ‘let God-Ha Shem prevail.’ Ha Shem then promised Israel that all the blessings that had been pronounced upon Abraham’s head would also be his” (Russell M. Nelson, “Let God Prevail,” Oct. 2020 general conference [Ensign or Liahona, Nov. 2020, 92]).
Israel is the name of the prophet يعقوب ابن إسحاق ابن ابراهيم عليهم السلام All of them and داوود و سليمان عليهما السلام were muslim prophets of god. And the sons of يعقوب are jewish in race. What does this have to do with some white European religiously jew people coming to steal a land that isn't theirs like how the europeas stole america from indians long ago? Palestinians are the grand grand sons of the jewish race that owned the land since the times of يعقوب. What you call Israelis are foreigns who stole the land and named it after a prophet who lived there looong ago.
There is better land in other parts of the world that would welcome Jews to establish their homeland and transport their ancient heritage to other countries. My belief in God is personal and real. Life is so short and the promise land is another dimension after we leave this earth.
The real jews are Palestinians. They are the grand grandsons of the jews that lived there long ago. Like the prophets يعقوب و داوود و سليمان و عيسى عليهم السلام Those current colonilazing Israelis are European white people from the jewish religion (not race) who stole a land and started killing, raping and calling the resistance a terrorist group after naming the land after the prophet يعقوب عليه السلام
Why doesn’t the United Nations just divide the country in half, and have strict laws the other side cannot settle on the other sides land nor own property on the other side. They can build new temples on their own territory. See how religious dogma makes things harder for people, as usual. Drop religion and watch humanity flourish.
@@leodouglas4568technically not since they lost. if russia won with ukraine then they have every right to own ukraine, same with the israel palestine thing. doesnt matter who "owns " if they lost it
@@horanghaeapologist By that logic, history would look pretty wild - imagine telling all the former colonies that they were just 'losing players'! But modern principles don’t exactly work on a 'winner takes all' mentality. If we did, human rights, sovereignty, and justice wouldn’t matter nearly as much. Shouldn't we aim for a solution that respects both people rather than who's got the bigger stick?
@@leodouglas4568 I completely agree, and while the UN and other alliances are kinda scummy/useless (i mean lets be honest if russia cared about sanctions they would have stopped, china NK etc probably help each other a lot already, probably more behind the scenes). Also the fact that my country was a spanish colony for like 3 centuries and an american colony for a few decades. Then was under the Japanese for a few years(iirc). Hell, it's been centuries, but im still mad spain hasn't apologized for the shit they did to us. But like you said, these countries' leaders dont care. Theyre politicians after all
So both sides are in the wrong. And neither are right. Tell me if im wrong, but wouldnt the solution just be, share the country? Let the muslims be muslims and the jews be jews. Why fight at all. It seems insignificant.
Most people agree with that, but you have to put yourself in the perspective of Israelis and Palestinians. Everyone is a result of their environment. You can't apply reason to a conflict that is senseless in the first place.
Oh, you mean another war that they started and lost miserably? As a result, many left willingly out of shame and fear, while others refused to make peace with the Jews thus chased out. Next time, don’t start wars if you’re not prepared for the consequences-you may lose both land and lives. That’s how the world has worked since the beginning of time.
I stand with Israel. This is so stupid That’s like saying Vancouver is now owned by East Indians. Should we change the name of Vancouver now and split it up
Yea but this is what cause the war jewish people went to Palestine and the jewish lied and said this is our country but that was wrong then they made a deal that isreal get the whole island of palestine and palestine get 95% of isreal but palestine disagree and then isreal made the war happend
Before it use to happen marical in the war which has have defeated arab nation which was impossible but this days this divine intervention does not happen u why bcos the present generation does not live upto God ways .if u want to know why think n look back what u ve been doings
prove it.... just because I called you racist don't mean you are.. Most likely you are uneducated but go ahead and tell us where the "lies" are. Because once you do someone will call you a liar.
Like how they’re fighting over land that nobody even has the right to fucking own. Same thing as saying someone own the oceans or even the entire planet
@@thecowboy2541 Well, it was Jewish land thousands of years ago as the video describes. And at that point, it doesn't matter. Tens of thousands of years ago, it was land owned by a completely different group of people. That doesn't give those people the right to conquer it. Same for Romans, who also ruled the land at one point.
@ Jews have continuously on that up until the modern day. Also, if your point is the previous people who lived on our land don’t have a right to take it back that does invalidate many pro Palestinian points
So what I get from this is that it's all the British fault!
Always is. Either land Britain, America or Europe had has run into terminal issues
Yes. It's the British fault for this and many others and they are not held accountable.
That was my take-away message, too. And I'm not sure calling Britain to fix this will help. At all.
They threw the stone and hide their hands after, or more clearly they started this dispute and dipped when they saw the conflict it was creating and wanted no part of it.
no, its a democratic problem
They both deserve land and peace. I understand why they’re not wanting to share their land but I feel like there isn’t a better person over the other. Jews went through Holocaust and Palestinians forced out of the country are both very terrible things to go through
Yes but Palestinians were not the reason Jews went through holocaust but Israelis are the reason why Palestinians forced out of their land
@@nanishal7870 Most israelis just wanna live their lives so you can't really blame them. If you wanna blame anyone, blame the brits
This info is fake read my comment
@@mirzaautomobiles2803 where
@@mirzaautomobiles2803 where?
I watched lots of vids. This is the clearest one. Thanks
For something that claims to be good, religion sure does cause a lot of problems.
Religion of peace ?
It's not really religion that's the issue it's how people use it
One side clearly uses terrorism and the other clearly does not
islam creates problems, look at europe. sad but it's the reality
Very good, balanced explanation of a truly complex situation. Well done.
Passive garbage that excuses the side with all the agency. Terrorism didn't start with Palestinians it was Israeli nationalists targeting the British occupation. Designated terrorists formed government and to this day one of the front bench ministers has a portrait hanging in his office of an Israeli terrorist who did exactly what the Christchurch shooter did. In any other context that is insane to celebrate a mass shooting terrorist and get elected and to say Terrorism started with homeless Palestinians is not a balanced take in the slightest.
Apartheid isn't complicated when you have a moral backbone.
THXX This helped me so much i didnt understand a single thing about this war before this
clearly you're not a pro palestinian protestor. otherwise you would've kept yourself ignorant and made a big noise about something you have no idea about.
@@sultanabran1 Huh, i needed this for a school project, i dont care a bout this war
@@SharifBiharie yeah cool. but you're confirming my statement.
@@sultanabran1 this was such a weird an unnecessary comment to send to someone who is clearly a child??
@@leorafilms.nah. That’s just your average pro palestinian
Basically the British started this then bailed.
I’m going to sound even more stupider than I already feel but how did Britain ‘forget’ that they had already promised the lands to Palestinians? Unless I’m missing something (which I probably am) that seems like quite a big promise to forget.
they didn't forget. they went 'no my problem. bye!'
they didn't promise the land to the palestinians, because it was aready theirs. they went to the palestinian land and promised it to the jews who were in need of a home even though that land wasnt theirs to give. Britain is very annoying in history
@@Maki_Games-mz2nxjew also lived there not Arabs alone nice try changing history.
Every single person in this comment section forget that were more than half a million jews in ww2 living in israel, close to the arabs population back then
@@Sh3ryn 10% to 1/3rd
Fighting for land that lacks water? People really fucking amaze me.
You so fucking dumb. It’s not about water it’s about other more important things about the land. You either so dumb or you just wasted your time seeing this video
It does sound comical when put that way.
Gotta love religion baby
ironically California steals water from Midwest . Without the govt helping them they would be nothing like they are. LEAVING Midwest to be welfare states.
Thanks for educating me. Can hardly beleive an agreement cannot be reached to preserve human lives.
Soo... What I understood was this so please correct me if I'm wrong. I'm trying to understand.
Britain promised the same land to two different groups: the Israeli and the Palestinians. Both groups historically have lived on this land, but it was mostly Palestinians until at that time and lots of Jews were uprooted by WW2 so were looking for a home. Britain tried to do good by finding a place for the Jews to live, but made a big, rude, oopsie and offered someone else's (Palestinians') home to the Jewish people.
So now the two have to fight over a small bit of dry land (few water resources) and the Jewish kept expanding and encroaching on the Palestinians to the point where a group of desperate radicals formed the terrorist group Hamas to tell the Isaeli to back off? Did I get any of that correct? Please help.
Edit: And Jerusalem is important to both groups so they both don't wanna give it up.
"Expanded" needs to be explained. Everyone says the Jews bought land, they never conquered those territories. So in my point of view it's fine that they "expanded". The muslims are just pissed that they sold their whole land to a religion that they hate. Jews on the other hand live side by side with palastinians. They make up 20% of their population and most of the palastinians in Israel support the war against Gaza because they know the terror they have to endure. That's why they have the most efficient defensive system in the world.
At that time the Arabs palestinian don't call themselves palestinian in that time they call themselves only Arabs. There was the Arabs league not the Palestinian league. The Arabs that today call themselves palestinian in the past supported in big Arabs state called big syria. The big Arabs state they want is in what today syria jordan irak and lebanon. In January 1919 the Arabs even agree that the jews will have a state in the area that today israel if they get big Arabs state. Only when the Arabs learned about the secret agreement between britain and france called sies picot agreement they felt betrayed because they learned that france get syria. ONLY FROM THAT TIME THE ARABS THAT LIVED IN PALESTINA STARTED TO DEVELOP NEW IDENTITY SEPARATE FROM THE SYRIANS AND THE JORDANIANS. THE SYRIANS AND THE JORDANIANS ARE THE SAME PEOPLE LIKE THE PALESTINIAN.
The new settlers jews that came to the land in 1881 at that time did not explend any Arabs. The new jews settlers settled in places that no one lived in or bought land from landowners with full many. The land where the jews settled was very desolate and a lot of area was empty. The Arabs that lived in the land lived in villages. If the Arabs not started war in 1947 than no Arabs were deported.
The jewish settlers who started the new jewish settlement in 1881 settled in places that were deserted and uninhabited. The Arabs who lived in the area were scattered in villages. The jews dried swamps and fight desess like malria. Most of the Arabs came from Arabs countries during the ottoman rule. During the ottoman rule there were no borders in the region. And syria jordan lebanon and irak did not exist, all this area was called SYRIA PALESTINA. many Arabs came to the land in the 19th century mainly after the jews settled there to find work. Also you can fond Arabs family that lived in the land 300 400 years. But most of the Arabs arrived to the land in the 19th century. Most of the Arabs don't lived there for generations, in the other hand the jews that came to Israel from Arabs countries really lived in the Arabs countries for generations. They came to Israel after they suffered from pogroms and Humiliation in the Arabs countries. For example the pogrom called the Farhud take place in irak in the year of 1941. Also in Morocco in the city if fez was the pogrom called the Trital when Arabs slaughtered jews with sources and knives.
The pogrom called The Trital take place in the year of 1912.
Why can't they just create a horizontal line in the middle of the land and have it divided 50/50? Why is it so sporadic?
Israel don’t want this
@@nanishal7870The Zionist Jews don't want it because they think God gave this land only to them.But they always forget that Arabs are their abrahamic cousins so they also have a share over the land(this is true, it's in the new testament).I think one secular democratic state for the land of Jews and Arabs should be better
Jerusalem....
Millions of people’s homes already established can’t just easily be moved, Resources like farmland, oil, water , businesses etc etc can’t just be moved
we should get this guy to negotiate with them, what a wise individual!
I don't support either countries. I'm so tired of hearing about their problems everywhere, every day.
That's called "isolationism"
Poor you 😂
Boo hoo. Get a grip. You know who is probably more tired than you? Palestinians, who have to endure famine, starvation, regular air strikes, being burned alive, being detained and tortured to death for no reason. You're 'tired' about hearing about their 'problems'? People like you are why history is doomed to repeat itself. You have two choices: show some damn humanity; educate yourself properly on this matter, protest, do something active to help stop this madness...or continue to feel 'so tired by their problems', turn a blind eye, and allow genocide to continue. If the latter is really the life you want to live, then you are a pathetic excuse for a human being. Sorry not sorry.
You are setting at your sofa and writing these stupid comments while Palestine people suffering and dying , stop this stupid emotional bullshit and think by your mind before your heart
@@ronakio “I’m so tired of hearing about their problems everywhere, everyday” what a callous and privileged way of looking at life…there are real people suffering the most unimaginable pain in Palestine, the very least you can do is care…
Thank you so much for this!! I have been so confused and everything saying “a simple guide” was anything but simple 😅 my boyfriend and I would like to thank you for this insightful video you have shared!!
Thnks for the video. I was really wondering why my friend was so adamant and critical about companies giving donations to israel and boycotting them. Up to this point is till have no idea about it all i know is that this isnt something that its not up to our decision to boycot or side with any country. Both side has dealt massive distrust and sins against each other. We can educate ourselves and help but not to the point of boycot, we have no real idea how they feel they are just doing what they think is best and siding with one side will just fan the flames of hatred.
Why not boycot the british? Or the UN since they started this whole mess? Ofcourse we cant because this is a generation of wrong choices and even israel and palestine has them mutual understanding and compromise is the way to end this until then this wont end.
Even if one side won due to war im sure the other will retaliate to get what they think they deserve.
Boycott the British people for something their great grandparents did? And even if you have some explanation what would you want them to do?
@@Alex13509 I said we cant, plus boycotting is weird for me like how they want to boycott inside out2. You cant solve anything without any proper discussion.
On a side note your reasoning can also be said with all the woke propaganda, rasicm, and more. Why do you have to hold someone accountable for something their ancestors did? Just because they are of the same blood doesnt necessarily mean they are the same
watch john oliver’s piece on it. It’ll really put things into perspective.
@ltnvideo I haven't trusted Jon Oliver ever since his nursing / Healthcare episode where he cherry picked "facts" to create a narrative. My wife and I are both nurses and haven't watched him since. And before you make an accusation, we are both extremely left leaning and NOT Maga. But I still want my information to be unbiased and truthful.
Very well said
Sad that both sides are sacrificing lives over fairy tales.
Are you restarted?
@@NTSbridZ too afraid to say retarded?
Nobody talks about that part tho
Twelve tribes of Israel look it up
It is correct. They missed the part where no one wanted that land only until the British gave it to the Jews. No water there. Israel made it happen...
the levant is the most fought after piece of land in human history
Lmao
Good'ol Hasbara.
British didn't give nothing. Jews already bought many Mediterranean lands from ottoman empire. The partision plan just added desert neguev - completely neutral and empty land
It didn't start on October 7th 2023..
Yeah obviously, but the recent war between them started Oct 7
When did it start?
@@SorayaPerez-rf5ck 1948
@@Ncady the palestinain has the to defend their land
@@Maxy-d7l Jews were always indigenous to this land - genetic tests prove that they are genetically closer to each other and to other levantine peoples, than they are to the people in the countries that they left when immigrating to Israel (because holocaust, pogroms...). Palestinians also have levantine genetics mostly, but there was no such thing as "Palestinians" when Israel came to be. There were many unrelated Arab tribes, levantine people that were arabized during Arab colonialism, and a lot of empty land. There were also many Jews still in the land of Israel, many generations before '48, so it's not like these lands were uniquely Arab. The Palestinian identity and nationality was artificially created in the sixties, only to unite the Arabs against the so-called "evil Zionist entity". There are other peoples indigenous to the levantine, for example the Druze - do you see them making any trouble?
So the Palestinians are mostly in the wrong due to calling war upon the Israelites when they were peaceful
That doesn't mean it's okay to take Palestinian lands tho.
@@Mehiel-Sanctoria wasnt palestinian land for christians jews and muslims under the Ottoman Empire? Idk if i got it wrong the muslims provoked al nakb. Also lets say its actually the Palestinian's land. Terror isn't the answer and Israel would have the right to defend their land. I would not give a land to someone like Hamas who would want to spread terror to other countries after getting Israel. Terrorist countries arent good.
@cccccc6667 Palestine doesn't have an army to stand up to Israel, so terror is their last resort. It's awful, but it's the only thing they can do to prevent getting conquered by Israel.
@Mehiel-Sanctoria doesnt justify terrorism. Declare war or at the very least (this is still wrong) hurt the army, not random ppl that have nothing to do with the army aka civillians. Also if they are able to use their force to cause terror, cant they use that same force to fight back against Israel forces? Attacking Israel is just going to create "violence"/retaliation in this long-term problem that today's Palestinians are talking about and mistaken about. Makes sense to why a terrorist group like Hamas is leading Palestine. I wouldnt give land to Hamas or any terrorist group just for them to attack other countries and spread terror and force Islam to others while lets say hypothetically Israel is the problem even if Israel is just interested in containing the land and that's it.
@@Mehiel-Sanctoria if you start a war against someone you typically lose land. The Palestinian had full intent to destroy Israel completely
Thank you so much for this brave video!
I’m going to try to type a long comment.
I like cats too. And I’m very grateful for this video as I said before.
I heard someone say that it’s an inconvenience to listen about this genocide so often, but we’re in the age of technology and social media. How can we just sit back when we can see everything going on right before our eyes? A genocide occurring while the entire world knows about it is insane, especially when people can become aware of where their tax paying dollars are going.
You’re a really great creator and I enjoy your in depth and informative videos and look forward to reading your book in the future.
Hope that this was long enough.
Sooo this seems to me what happens when your WHOLE identity is your religion.
I don’t have a dog in the fight but you’d think that if religion wasn’t such a major factor, they could try to get along like the melting pot of America.
Once again, Britain made a mess.
Sorry but it wasn't 50/50 The Jews got the largest share, especially in the important areas. They are guests who came to take land that is not theirs, and with all impudence they divide the land.
Actually that’s not true lol. Palestinians were originally granted 70% of total land and majority of the natural resources, with Jerusalem being an international hub.
A plan which Palestinians rejected.
Peace and love for all❤
When britain received the mandate over the region they gave the eastern part of palestina to the Hashemite family from Saudi arabia for their help in first world war that how the kingdom of jordan was created. Before that syria also was included in what was called syria palestina. Britain and france divided the area between them and created new states like syria jordan lebanon and irak. In 1919 the Arabs want big Arabs state called greater syria. Only when they learned that syria go to france they felt betrayed and started to develop new identity separate from the Syrians and the Jordanians. There is no difference between the Palestinian jordanian and syrian.
I wish this video was made earlier before I submitted my assignment 😢
Agree with the first person. You dodged one. This video is filled with propaganda and carefully crafted narration and format to paint Israel as some legitimate entity when it is obv not. In addition to downplaying their brutality and aggression. Painting the oppressed and dispossessed Palestinian resistance as terrorism. Bunch of BS.
@@JZeidanI agree that Isreal is more to blame but did hamas not commit acts of terror
@@vladjaruss876 by your logic you still lose. No one has inflicted more terror on innocent civilians than Israel.
@@JZeidan not really
🤣 @@achalajoshi5314
This is grossly over simplified and inaccurate on several points basically a waste
Nobody should side with the terrorists.
Who? The Israelis yea we don't side with them
You’re right that’s why I stand with Palestine
I think it's more so that people understand the political nature of WHY people resort to terrorism. Very few people actually side with attacking civilians, but to solve a problem like terrorism you need to understand its motives. This requires asking hard questions like why people become terrorists. Why do these people hate Israel so much? And this video does a good job of explaining that. There are also people who are radicalized by their made up religion--in which case there is no understanding because religion is itself nonsensical and made up.
People pushed to believe that the only way to fight back is terrorism, are the people who should be sided with. That’s like saying “Nobody should side with people who are suicidal.”
@@DominolitheoneTerrorism is never the way. Resistance is cool, but when you start using terrorism, it sucks. You can’t just start attacking non combatants for your own goals
Please be accurate with the facts. Please give me one example that the jewish settlers explained Arabs before the Arabs started a war against the jews in 1947. If you don't have such a case then don't invent false facts. What is true that during the warjews explained Arabs. In the first part of the war the Arabs enjoyend victories, the Arabs did not leave any jews alive in the settlements they conquered. In the second part of the war the jews went from defence to attack, and then there were also deportation of Arabs. The Arabs did not expel jews, they simply slaughtered the jews in the areas they conquered.
Buddy really forgot
So it was just fine for them to commit genocide on the jews and take over their land but the reverse now isn't ok?
Soo this too is the britisher's fault???
Like modern day Britain. Promising place to live for the newcomers while displacing the natives
DUMB THE TEA IN THE HARBORRRRR
Do you not understand English? Did you completely miss the part where the UN got involved? After the UN got involved, it was no longer a British problem.
The Arabs were not called Palestinians.
Arabs looked upon the termology of Palestinian as a insult.
It was not until 1965 that Russia recommended to Arafat to call themselves Palestinians as a strategy to try and legitimise their claim.
MUCH OF YOUR STORY IS FALSE.
I don’t understand how people can do research on this topic, fully understand the history, wars, and current events, and then turn around ignorantly hate Israel and support Hamas
Wow you sugar coated the shit outta the Palestinians and they still look guilty. Evil is evil
Britain promised jewish people homes in palestinian people's homes. Britain decided to split the land 50/50 (wasnt even 50/50, israel got more). So now, what used to be palestinian land is now mostly israeli. Any logical person would be annoyed and angry if a huge part of theyre land is taken by immigrants. The natives got displaced to a smaller land so that the immigrants could have a big place to live. So evil am i right?
@@mikailakbarlasiny8071Exactly
It's Palestinians land give it back to them Deeb
It's Palestinian land. always was ❤
@@leodouglas4568no it literally never was. Dna literally proved it dude. The jews were displaced and Arab nations moved in.
Thank you for the explanation. This is the clearest one yet.
In the ottoman time all the area that today syria jordan and israel was without borders and called syria palestina. In a secret agreement between britain and france called sies picot agreement britain and france divided the area between them syria and lebanon go to france and the rest go to britain. When the Arabs learned about the secret agreement that syria go to france they felt betrayed and started to develop new identity separate from the Syrians and the Jordanians. There is no difference between the Palestinian jordanian and syrian. The Arabs that today called themselves palestinian always considered themselves as syrian Arabs, see the agreement between Faisal and Weizmann from January 1919 from the Paris peace conference.
This video didn’t really explain it correctly. First, Jews and Arabs have been living in the Israeli area when the British controlled it and already had conflict. The British and the UN thought the best solution was to separate the 2 groups of people.
2. Israel got the increase of land from all the wars they won.
3. Why can’t the Palestinians live on other lands? Egypt also borders the Gaza Strip but Egypt wants nothing to do with the Palestinians. If they would stop waging war, there would be no loss of lives
Seems to me like they both kinda suck 🤷 don't pick a side if you dont believe in either cause, right?
Yeah your right. Both absolutely suck
See? This is exactly why people say “there are no sides in war,” because situations like this happen and nobody knows who to root for, both sides have a clear and compelling argument for what and why they are fighting. You can’t just pick a side on that unless you’re tied to some sort of bias.
Izrael - is it Izrael’s or Palestinian (Arab) name? The history of Izrael shows that this name is 4,000 years old. There has never existed any ethnic group or nation called Palestinians. Cannot be mixed with Philistines who came from the area of Greece. Ha Shem said to Abraham to move from Ur to nowadays Izrael and to BUY the land in Beer Sheva, then Izrael tribes spread throughout the whole area, Jews were then under the king David, Salomon and many other kings.. Abraham had a son Izak and Izak had a son Jakob. Ha Shem changed Jacob’s name to Israel, meaning ‘let God-Ha Shem prevail.’ Ha Shem then promised Israel that all the blessings that had been pronounced upon Abraham’s head would also be his” (Russell M. Nelson, “Let God Prevail,” Oct. 2020 general conference [Ensign or Liahona, Nov. 2020, 92]).
Israel is the name of the prophet يعقوب ابن إسحاق ابن ابراهيم عليهم السلام
All of them and داوود و سليمان عليهما السلام were muslim prophets of god. And the sons of يعقوب are jewish in race.
What does this have to do with some white European religiously jew people coming to steal a land that isn't theirs like how the europeas stole america from indians long ago?
Palestinians are the grand grand sons of the jewish race that owned the land since the times of يعقوب.
What you call Israelis are foreigns who stole the land and named it after a prophet who lived there looong ago.
I'm Jewish and it's right if someone want to know where this think exactly he can see on our Torah btw it's not Salomon it's shlomho
underrated video
So the Palestinian ppl are upset about boarders . Who started taking hostages?
Obviously terrorism is horrible, but don't you think it is the natural outcome of oppression and genocide?
There is better land in other parts of the world that would welcome Jews to establish their homeland and transport their ancient heritage to other countries. My belief in God is personal and real. Life is so short and the promise land is another dimension after we leave this earth.
This is the best comment here. Thank you 🩷
@@jonathanchadburn2040 why don’t we just relocate Palestine
Thats the home to the jews please God help israel to get is home back
The real jews are Palestinians. They are the grand grandsons of the jews that lived there long ago. Like the prophets يعقوب و داوود و سليمان و عيسى عليهم السلام
Those current colonilazing Israelis are European white people from the jewish religion (not race) who stole a land and started killing, raping and calling the resistance a terrorist group after naming the land after the prophet يعقوب عليه السلام
Reasonably good for a minute or two worth of material
Why doesn’t the United Nations just divide the country in half, and have strict laws the other side cannot settle on the other sides land nor own property on the other side. They can build new temples on their own territory. See how religious dogma makes things harder for people, as usual. Drop religion and watch humanity flourish.
constantly fight a war is worse then just swallowing your pride and making do with what u have
My only question is how is this anybody else’s business but theirs ?
Just couldn’t get along, sad, shame on them all
Everybody should just stop and make out with eachother am I right
@ youre right, deep down inside they all just love each other, they say if someone makes you really angry it’s because you’re in love with them.
so a country warred with another country
said country who started a war lost and theyre sour that that the country that won "won" that territory
Basically yes
No, it's Palestinian land. they had every right to defend.
@@leodouglas4568technically not since they lost. if russia won with ukraine then they have every right to own ukraine, same with the israel palestine thing. doesnt matter who "owns " if they lost it
@@horanghaeapologist By that logic, history would look pretty wild - imagine telling all the former colonies that they were just 'losing players'! But modern principles don’t exactly work on a 'winner takes all' mentality. If we did, human rights, sovereignty, and justice wouldn’t matter nearly as much. Shouldn't we aim for a solution that respects both people rather than who's got the bigger stick?
@@leodouglas4568 I completely agree, and while the UN and other alliances are kinda scummy/useless (i mean lets be honest if russia cared about sanctions they would have stopped, china NK etc probably help each other a lot already, probably more behind the scenes). Also the fact that my country was a spanish colony for like 3 centuries and an american colony for a few decades. Then was under the Japanese for a few years(iirc). Hell, it's been centuries, but im still mad spain hasn't apologized for the shit they did to us.
But like you said, these countries' leaders dont care. Theyre politicians after all
I didnt know they were jews huh interesting
it's 180°another story but I can't tell it's about experimentation because a young man must be gentleman
So both sides are in the wrong. And neither are right. Tell me if im wrong, but wouldnt the solution just be, share the country? Let the muslims be muslims and the jews be jews. Why fight at all. It seems insignificant.
Most people agree with that, but you have to put yourself in the perspective of Israelis and Palestinians. Everyone is a result of their environment. You can't apply reason to a conflict that is senseless in the first place.
why didnt he mention the nakba? and how the palestinians where kicked out of their homes to poverty
Oh, you mean another war that they started and lost miserably? As a result, many left willingly out of shame and fear, while others refused to make peace with the Jews thus chased out. Next time, don’t start wars if you’re not prepared for the consequences-you may lose both land and lives. That’s how the world has worked since the beginning of time.
I wonder this as well. A quick Wikipedia search will reveal immense atrocities that the Palestinians suffered.
I stand with Israel. This is so stupid
That’s like saying Vancouver is now owned by East Indians. Should we change the name of Vancouver now and split it up
So British caused war by this information
Yea but this is what cause the war jewish people went to Palestine and the jewish lied and said this is our country but that was wrong then they made a deal that isreal get the whole island of palestine and palestine get 95% of isreal but palestine disagree and then isreal made the war happend
Jewish people lived there and eve the returness their ancestral were exiled from there. And it's Arabs who started the war not Israel nice try.
Still not understanding.....but some how getting it
Same
So a war started by the Palestine and now they crying cuz Israel won’t stop bringing them all the smoke. 😂
Of course it's Britain's fault
Not as big is Brannonwhere? 😅
bro has the sunset overdrive style bar lol
So this all started because of the British, again....
So it’s all drawn back to Britain as usual
problem is human
Use color 👍
"A lot of people on both sides have lost their lives" - PLEASE explain that these deaths contain far more Palestinians than Israelis!
doesn't really matter, if we swapped the resources then the numbers would also be swapped.
It's irrelevant anyway. Palestine is also the one that keeps attacking. They are the aggressor here and have been for years.
Before it use to happen marical in the war which has have defeated arab nation which was impossible but this days this divine intervention does not happen u why bcos the present generation does not live upto God ways .if u want to know why think n look back what u ve been doings
Free Palestine🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
You are explaining briefly and unjustly, and there is information that you did not mention, some of which is shameful.
Lmao
What is bro yapping about
Why did the UN stood idly by while the Jewish people took over Palestinian territory? They should have defended the 50/50 split.
They bought the land...
the UN literally proposed the idea of two states solution to solve this exact problem dawg
Hammas is not terreroist ok
3:07 Trump’s dream 😂😂😂😂😂
Gaza Strip
Israel: 1300+ deaths, Gaza by itsself: 44000.
both numbers are way higher. I dont know where you are getting those number from
Yet Hamas chose to play stupid games...
@@farmerchick3040 the idf blames everything on hamas they just want all Palestinians gone from palestine stealing land
@@callipoislekker the Palestinian population in Israel has grown 10X
womp womp
Lies lies lies
prove it.... just because I called you racist don't mean you are.. Most likely you are uneducated but go ahead and tell us where the "lies" are. Because once you do someone will call you a liar.
Like how they’re fighting over land that nobody even has the right to fucking own. Same thing as saying someone own the oceans or even the entire planet
called -pa- LIES -tine-
It is arab land
And before that it was Jewish land
@@thecowboy2541 Well, it was Jewish land thousands of years ago as the video describes. And at that point, it doesn't matter. Tens of thousands of years ago, it was land owned by a completely different group of people. That doesn't give those people the right to conquer it. Same for Romans, who also ruled the land at one point.
@ Jews have continuously on that up until the modern day. Also, if your point is the previous people who lived on our land don’t have a right to take it back that does invalidate many pro Palestinian points
@@thecowboy2541 No because they owned it recently. Like within a lifetime.
@@tonybelfast1389 the vast majority were not alive when they sold their property