I had the wonderful good fortune to see him “in the round” in Bangor, Maine, in the 80’s and it was such a beautiful experience and at different points you could have heard a pin drop with the respectful audience. His voice is perfection and his music fills my soul with pure happiness❤️
Absolutely true, crystal clear. I have been in love from afar with Karla for almost 40 years, ever since I met her at a little coffee house open mic in LA in the late 80s. Ever since I get speechless every time I hear her sing (then I start singing harmony, under my breath :)
I first discovered her in Solana Beach...I pulled her album out of a trash can in 1982, took it back to my beach house, put it on my turntable, and knew....damn! that was it!
Karla is just as awesome as she was 35 years before this performance. I have seen her twice live and have loved her timeless music and angelic voice for a long time. She recorded this song with James Taylor as the accompanying vocalist. Pure beauty.
Lucky fan , happy for you , maybe she was in Canada , not often , I think she is outstanding, super talent for me , love her Music/ albums many years , thanks,did you hear There’s a Rose in the Garden , 1st of her songs I heard on the radio Canada , I loved it , and looked for her album, thanks 👍👍❤️❤️
the most beautiful version of this song I have ever heard,I would hope that when I pass someone would play this song and it has to b Karla s version every time I hear it it brings me close to tears
I've heard a lot of arrangements of this song, but this one is far and away my favorite, especially the album cut with John David Souther and James Taylor doing the harmonies.
Kenneth Michael Edwards (February 10, 1946 - August 18, 2010)[1][2] was an American singer, songwriter, bassist, guitarist, mandolinist, and session musician. He was a founding member of the Stone Poneys and Bryndle and a long-time collaborator with Linda Ronstadt and Karla Bonoff.[3]
Yes ,! I remember Stone Pony’s , Linda Ronstadt, I can’t help from love since That’d be the day ‘ You are right there are many very talented people , deserve listening to , 70 yr. young , love Beatles , Pink Floyd , please show these old CD , albums used to be, to the new fantastic kids , they need inspiration as well , Peace
Hang in there. Sometimes, when you are not looking, you find, or it finds you. If you do find love, trust and hang on for dear life for the road is rocky and the path full of stumbling blocks.
I too love this song that holds me but the one who highly holds me is Jesus Christ in Jesus Christ loves this girl and Mike when I get to go to heaven I know I'll be able to hear her sing it and all her other beautiful gifts that God gave her wicked God Jesus Christ songs of Glory and the honor and the praise
God's blessings and grace to you too. The scriptures, the teachings and guidance of Lord's servants ( good shepherds), hymns to glorify our Almighty Lord... All this transcendental activities can take us cross over to the Kingdom of God, our eternal original home. ❤🙏🛐
She's not underrated. Everybody here seems to like her. I do. She had the unfortunate circumstance of being a female singer song writer at the same time as carly simon, joni mitchell and carole king. She appears highly rated by people who have heard her sing.
You forget Linda Ronstadt also recorded quite a few of Karla's songs. I really much prefer Karla's musical choices and voice over Linda's. Recently saw her in Park City Utah in the spring of 2024. Ive been a fan since 1979.
@@danblumelI was comparing Ms. Bonoff to other singer-songwriters. Linda was a terrific performer, but did not write songs. She covered Warren Zevon and J.D. Souther as well.
I disagree U. S. probably you are right , Canada Music buyers , not many in late 70’s were Talking about her, me of course ,! It was more Linda Ronstadt , who didn’t write the song, peace , 👍👍🙏🙏❤️
listening to this and thinking of friends and family gone on has always affected me...She played this for a small group of College Radio people in Atlanta in '76. Mac Mcanally was there also. He jammed for us in the elevator for about an hour. Seeing him and her in a small group when we were all so young was magical. Mac was 19 and the rest of us were in our 20s....Karla was 25.
Some hurts you never get over, but must learn to live with. The pain of love will always return in dreams and there's no reason to believe it will ever go away.
Here it is, God knows how many years after Karla released this, and her's still one of the most beautiful single performances of the song. I'm floored every time I hear her sing it.
Thank you very much , I remember, a little of Stone Ponies, great group I remember ! a bit , we only had Rolling Stone , and Creem magazines to keep up ! Ok 👍👍🙏👏👏🏅🎶🎶 rock On
I saw this video released all the concert stages in Japan in 2006 in Japan. More than ten years have passed since then. I honor her and still acting still, I wish for his future success. Karla and I are the same age, so her poetry is immersed in my heart.Thank you for "pjcisum" for releasing this!
The Water Is Wide (바다는 넓고) The water is wide I cant cross over 바다가 너무 넓어 건널 수가 없어요 And neither have the wings to fly 난 날 수 있는 날개도 없는걸요 Give me a boat that can carry two #65279; 배를 주세요 두 사람이 탈 수 있는 And both shall row, my love and I 우리 둘이 저어 갈께요, 내 사랑과 내가 Oh, love is gentle and love is kind 사랑은 부드럽고, 사랑은 다정하죠 The sweetest flower when first its new 처음 꽃피울 때는 가장 향기로운 꽃이지만 But love grows old and waxes cold 사랑도 나이가 들고 차갑게 식어버리다가 and fades away like morning dew 아침 이슬처럼 사라져 버리네요 There is a ship and she sails to sea 바다로 흘러가는 배가 하나 있네요 Shes loaded deep as deep can be 짐을 가득 실었지만 But not as deep as the love Im in 당신에게 빠진 내 사랑만큼 가득하진 않아요 I know not how I sink or swim 내 사랑이 가라앉을지 헤쳐 나갈지는 나도 모르겠네요
I've known Karla since I was 17 (40 years). The water is clearly "wide" and it takes much effort to cross the waters to join with someone else. There are storms even if we are in the boat together and we all have to remain focussed on the "lighthouse" or "the North Star" to remain on course.
There is a place some of us chance to visit though few remain to live there. Sometimes after many a long year the memory is new again in dream or echoes in a song.
The water is wide I can't cross over And neither have I wings to fly Build me a boat That can carry two And both shall row, my love and I There is a ship And she sails the sea She's loaded deep As deep can be But not so deep As the love I'm in I know not how I sink or swim Oh love is handsome And love is fine The sweetest flower When first it's new But love grows old And waxes cold And fades away like Summer dew Build me a boat That can carry two And both shall row, my love and I And both shall row, my love and I
We only learned, after hearing this beautiful rendition, that Kenny Edwards passed away some years ago. We think the harmonies are so beautiful. Does anyone know where we might get the sheet music that contains this duet? Thanks Kenny, RIP.
@@southwoodside - You are wrong, as are many people, confused by the alternative title, 'O waly, waly'. It is from Somerset, England, the Scottish 'Waly waly' having a completely different melody and lyrics, c.f. 'The Scots Musical Museum'. I don't know if the young Robert Burns, who declared a collection of English songs his 'vade mecum' (carried everywhere whilst working on the farm) ever heard the original.
@@segovianity a think it's an english variant of an old scots sang. thompson was a scotsman who collected many scots sangs and took them to england. type in ...the water is wide the history of a folk song just another tune.......then type in.......esther ofarim waly waly you tube ..........
62years old okinawa nippon 素晴らしい曲なので 日本人の歌手の方もたくさん歌ってます でも やはり肺活量が少ない Karla san の歌は本当に心に染みます
この場にいた方達が羨ましいです 有難う！ また来ます
I am 59 and first fell in love with her voice at 18, still holding a flame after all these years.
Gorgeous!
Were u born in "62 ?
That makes 2 of us. And I'm sure many more.
"Someone To Laydown Beside Me".....one of the most beautiful Karla Bonoff songs!!!
Yes I agree , me a big fan of her albums , please share with family or friends, love and peace , sincerely, 👍👍🎶🎶🌎❤️❤️
I had the wonderful good fortune to see him “in the round” in Bangor, Maine, in the 80’s and it was such a beautiful experience and at different points you could have heard a pin drop with the respectful audience. His voice is perfection and his music fills my soul with pure happiness❤️
She melts me like John Denver and James Taylor. Gives me chills. I know her voice from million miles away.
Saw her about a month ago. She's still amazing. One of the most under-rated talents ever.
Absolutely true, crystal clear. I have been in love from afar with Karla for almost 40 years, ever since I met her at a little coffee house open mic in LA in the late 80s. Ever since I get speechless every time I hear her sing (then I start singing harmony, under my breath :)
I first discovered her in Solana Beach...I pulled her album out of a trash can in 1982, took it back to my beach house, put it on my turntable, and knew....damn! that was it!
So true. What a gift. I am sobbing and so grateful for her talent.
Agree. Her voice is soulful
Followed her back in the 70’s and 80’s, such a gifted singer/songwriter. A great talent!
Karla, there is no words to express how sweet your voice sound when you sing this song. Really, love you as much as the song itself. So Heavenly!
Wow! My new favorite song and singer. I just heard this a few days ago . . . and cannot stop replaying it.
色んなアーティストたちが歌っているが、私はカーラのヴァージョンが一番すきだ。
If angels sing, she shares her voice with them. Sweet as it gets.
Karla is just as awesome as she was 35 years before this performance. I have seen her twice live and have loved her timeless music and angelic voice for a long time. She recorded this song with James Taylor as the accompanying vocalist. Pure beauty.
Lucky fan , happy for you , maybe she was in Canada , not often , I think she is outstanding, super talent for me , love her
Music/ albums many years , thanks,did you hear There’s a Rose in the Garden , 1st
of her songs I heard on the radio Canada ,
I loved it , and looked for her album, thanks 👍👍❤️❤️
Karla you've melted my heart! love to you from Australia.😊
One of the most beautiful songs ever imo.
How can you not cry listening to her sing this?
I' m korean.
Deer Your comments feels good.
thank you ~~
the most beautiful version of this song I have ever heard,I would hope that when I pass someone would play this song and it has to b Karla s version every time I hear it it brings me close to tears
I've heard a lot of arrangements of this song, but this one is far and away my favorite, especially the album cut with John David Souther and James Taylor doing the harmonies.
And Garth Hudson on accordion !!
Yeah, that's right, some of us know who he is!
Give The Seekers' version of this song, a go Dean. It's the first 're'vision of this Scottish classic! They recorded it in the sixties.
Oh really? Hmm. Thanks.
@@karinberryman7970 totally agree Seekers
Kenneth Michael Edwards (February 10, 1946 - August 18, 2010)[1][2] was an American singer, songwriter, bassist, guitarist, mandolinist, and session musician. He was a founding member of the Stone Poneys and Bryndle and a long-time collaborator with Linda Ronstadt and Karla Bonoff.[3]
Yes ,! I remember Stone Pony’s , Linda Ronstadt, I can’t help from love since That’d be the day ‘ You are right there are many very talented people , deserve listening to , 70 yr. young , love Beatles , Pink Floyd , please show these old CD , albums used to be, to the new fantastic kids , they need inspiration as well , Peace
Sung so beautifully! Lovely voice.
One of my favorites of all time... I'm still in that boat, alone, waiting for someone to come and row beside me.
I too am looking for that person that will row with me.
Hang in there. Sometimes, when you are not looking, you find, or it finds you. If you do find love, trust and hang on for dear life for the road is rocky and the path full of stumbling blocks.
I too love this song that holds me but the one who highly holds me is Jesus Christ in Jesus Christ loves this girl and Mike when I get to go to heaven I know I'll be able to hear her sing it and all her other beautiful gifts that God gave her wicked God Jesus Christ songs of Glory and the honor and the praise
I believe the Holy Spirit is close to you , thank you Universe for Karla Bonoff , her name belongs on Billboards across the Nation , 👍👍👍🙏❤️❤️🎉🌎
chills up and down my spine......I had this album and played it each time I went to sea......Love Her
Wish U Always happiness
Lovely.
Thank you.
This song always makes me weep.
I saw her in concert with Jackson Browne in 1979 and have listened to her on a regular basis since then.
To those who will be reading this, God bless you and your family! God loves you 💕
God's blessings and grace to you too.
The scriptures, the teachings and guidance of Lord's servants ( good shepherds), hymns to glorify our Almighty Lord... All this transcendental activities can take us cross over to the Kingdom of God, our eternal original home.
❤🙏🛐
Beautiful version….well done and love from Canada 🇨🇦
STILL adore and love her 💛😊
She's not underrated. Everybody here seems to like her. I do. She had the unfortunate circumstance of being a female singer song writer at the same time as carly simon, joni mitchell and carole king. She appears highly rated by people who have heard her sing.
She’s an amazing songwriter besides having a beautiful voice
Her debut album is one of the best debuts ever.
You forget Linda Ronstadt also recorded quite a few of Karla's songs. I really much prefer Karla's musical choices and voice over Linda's.
Recently saw her in Park City Utah in the spring of 2024. Ive been a fan since 1979.
@@danblumelI was comparing Ms. Bonoff to other singer-songwriters. Linda was a terrific performer, but did not write songs. She covered Warren Zevon and J.D. Souther as well.
I disagree U. S. probably you are right , Canada Music buyers , not many in late 70’s were Talking about her, me of course ,! It was more Linda Ronstadt , who didn’t
write the song, peace , 👍👍🙏🙏❤️
That guitar solo was like sprinkles of water to my thirsty soul. Damn...
Love your version of this!!! I saw you open for Jackson Browne in 79 or 80 and have listened to you ever since!!
Really?
Karla, I love this. It is so touching. And I love you.
The most beautiful voice I've ever heard
listening to this and thinking of friends and family gone on has always affected me...She played this for a small group of College Radio people in Atlanta in '76. Mac Mcanally was there also. He jammed for us in the elevator for about an hour. Seeing him and her in a small group when we were all so young was magical. Mac was 19 and the rest of us were in our 20s....Karla was 25.
The best version ever. No matter who may try it, this one just nails it...
if you mean karla in general i would agree. but her version with james taylor is better than this one.
Karla is an amazing singer but I prefer Mary Travers' version.
22fret yes
This version is indeed beautiful but falls far short of Eva Cassidy's version
Listen to Maura OConnell, also very beauiful
Just a beautiful voice and the lyrics. I hope to see her in concert someday. Love you Karla !!!
Lovely, memorable. Been listening to her sing this for many, many years, and it never grows old. A certain guitar lives on.
Amazing voice!
Once saw her perform at Boulder's Chautauqua Park... Truly a magical experience...
Good voice, good song. Awesome and beautiful beyond words of expression.
The great beauty of song no better demonstrated x
Karla and Kenny what a complete and underrated combination.
Lovely melodic blend, yes, heard Nina playing lead at times on a Strat.
Some hurts you never get over, but must learn to live with. The pain of love will always
return in dreams and there's no reason to believe it will ever go away.
Here it is, God knows how many years after Karla released this, and her's still one of the most beautiful single performances of the song. I'm floored every time I hear her sing it.
Never get tired of this song. Iove Karla sweet voice. The song is just perfect for her.
58landman I agree
Absolutely. And Garth Hudson on accordion. Perfect.
Just fabulous.....thank you...
Beautiful !
Amazing rendition, perfect voice
One of the greatest songs ever written
This is soooo beautiful! Thank you.
Never heard her before. From today on I regret. Such a wonderful voice. Yes, this is fantastic for sure
Awsome rendition!
So very soothing and in a great key! Thank you!
Beautiful ..💕💕💕
What a voice! By far my favorite rendition of this wonderful song.
That's KENNY EDWARDS on guitar and harmony; he produced her and played bass with Linda. A Stone Poney. RIP.
Thank you very much , I remember, a little of Stone Ponies, great group I remember !
a bit , we only had Rolling Stone , and Creem magazines to keep up ! Ok 👍👍🙏👏👏🏅🎶🎶 rock On
Beautifully presented, magical voice, so nice! Thank you!!
absolutely Wonderful! I would love to see her in concert.
I saw this video released all the concert stages in Japan in 2006 in Japan. More than ten years have passed since then. I honor her and still acting still, I wish for his future success. Karla and I are the same age, so her poetry is immersed in my heart.Thank you for "pjcisum" for releasing this!
The Water Is Wide (바다는 넓고)
The water is wide I cant cross over
바다가 너무 넓어 건널 수가 없어요
And neither have the wings to fly
난 날 수 있는 날개도 없는걸요
Give me a boat that can carry two #65279;
배를 주세요 두 사람이 탈 수 있는
And both shall row, my love and I
우리 둘이 저어 갈께요, 내 사랑과 내가
Oh, love is gentle and love is kind
사랑은 부드럽고, 사랑은 다정하죠
The sweetest flower when first its new
처음 꽃피울 때는 가장 향기로운 꽃이지만
But love grows old and waxes cold
사랑도 나이가 들고 차갑게 식어버리다가
and fades away like morning dew
아침 이슬처럼 사라져 버리네요
There is a ship and she sails to sea
바다로 흘러가는 배가 하나 있네요
Shes loaded deep as deep can be
짐을 가득 실었지만
But not as deep as the love Im in
당신에게 빠진 내 사랑만큼 가득하진 않아요
I know not how I sink or swim
내 사랑이 가라앉을지 헤쳐 나갈지는 나도 모르겠네요
김이원 thanks
Soo ok😢
an angel she is
beautiful
Gorgeous voice
I've known Karla since I was 17 (40 years). The water is clearly "wide" and it takes much effort to cross the waters to join with someone else. There are storms even if we are in the boat together and we all have to remain focussed on the "lighthouse" or "the North Star" to remain on course.
wtf?
Small stage for that much talent!
There is a place some of us chance to visit though few remain to live there.
Sometimes after many a long year the memory is new again in dream or echoes in a song.
my favorite song by Karla Bonoff
Golly. Some lovely performance.
Always amazing!
too much beautyful voice, i have tears
Il brano è stupendo. Bellissima voce e intensa interpretazione. Grazie.
Perfect!!!! 💕
Part of the soundtrack for the movie “Bounty” with Mel Gibson. Sung by the Captain and crew when they were rowing towards Pitcairn Island.
Thanks ! Never heard a great use of music
Imho , I like it , 👍👍😀
Beautiful
가슴이 답답할 때....눈을 감고 들으면 쉼*이 되는 노래입니다.deep in mind....
언제들어도 아름다운 곡이네요
Yes, I do agree.
After 7 years from your comment
I have same feeling.
This song is simple,sweet, devoted and gentle.
AWESOME!
やっぱりこれが最高。癒すー。
Beautiful rendition!
Hey Kenny! We miss you.
Gorgeous.
I love this song and heard many covers, It seem there are many lyrics to the same
verses and each artist sing it differently.
영어 잘 하시네용ᆢㅎㅎㅎ😱🙊👍 부러움! 지금은 2020년 5월14일🐶🐷
とても、落ち着きます。
Maravillosa y tan sencilla...!
감미로운 음정이 좋아요
favorite‼︎
懐かしい！泣けた
Great!!!
잔잔한 멜로디가 듣기 좋네요
Beatiful
The Seekers. They hold the words not leave them short.
The water is wide
I can't cross over
And neither have I wings to fly
Build me a boat
That can carry two
And both shall row, my love and I
There is a ship
And she sails the sea
She's loaded deep
As deep can be
But not so deep
As the love I'm in
I know not how I sink or swim
Oh love is handsome
And love is fine
The sweetest flower
When first it's new
But love grows old
And waxes cold
And fades away like Summer dew
Build me a boat
That can carry two
And both shall row, my love and I
And both shall row, my love and I
Good!!!
素晴らしい。今もご活躍されているのでしょうか❔
capas1000
2018 9/1には、大阪のビルボードで、ライブ有りましたよ
A very nice folk song 。
From God. Makes me cry. It’s just evil world we were thrown into
And more gorgeous than that!
Nothing has change Karla ,I still have a crush on you.
Is that Kenny Edwards playing guitar? He was so amazing. He passed away some years ago. Such a loss.
We only learned, after hearing this beautiful rendition, that Kenny Edwards passed away some years ago. We think the harmonies are so beautiful. Does anyone know where we might get the sheet music that contains this duet? Thanks Kenny, RIP.
"The Water Is Wide" (also called "O Waly, Waly") is a folk song of English origin, based on lyrics which partly date to the 1600s.
Scottish actually.
@@southwoodside - You are wrong, as are many people, confused by the alternative title, 'O waly, waly'. It is from Somerset, England, the Scottish 'Waly waly' having a completely different melody and lyrics, c.f. 'The Scots Musical Museum'. I don't know if the young Robert Burns, who declared a collection of English songs his 'vade mecum' (carried everywhere whilst working on the farm) ever heard the original.
@@segovianity a think it's an english variant of an old scots sang. thompson was a scotsman who collected many scots sangs and took them to england. type in ...the water is wide the history of a folk song just another tune.......then type in.......esther ofarim waly waly you tube ..........
Watching this the day after Trump won. Sought this out. Needed to hear Karla sing this sweet song. Heart is broken.
Fucking deal with it.
LOL....Donald Trump was here!
Hahaha..."Love is gentle. Love is kind." Your response, Dimachaerus, is Trump in a nutshell. Most of us don't want America to be that way. Thankfully.
not according to the election....
Yes, according to the election. And in spite of all the 'extra' help 'he' got. He's going down. It's just a matter of how soon.
Great............