Yuval Noah Harari In Conversation with Christine Lagarde
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 вер 2018
- Christine Lagarde, Managing Director of the International Monetary Fund, hosts Yuval Noah Harari for a conversation about his new book, 21 Lessons for the 21st Century, and about who the future belongs to.
"Human stupidity is one of the most powerful forces in nature."
I would say hurricanes and volcanos are much more powerful, and are literally forces of nature. Human Arrogance astounds me. The planet has been much hotter than now. Also, the sun is heating all the planets in the solar system, our planet is actually heating more slowly than the others. Scientists that only get more funding from the government when they give results that the government wants, are the opposite of reliable. Think for yourselves, these people are not thinking with your interests in mind.
Fantastic conversation . I am impress by the humbleness of Christine Lagarde and the quality of the audience questions, and mostly that understands that all communication is in English and don't hear any American or Brit , this is amazing . Really we are as humanity have the possibility of understanding each other by oral communication.
Extraordinary indeed and must see. My admiration and gratitude to professor Harari . 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
professor harari is the great homosapiens presented the
specifically key to open the human's world in bost past
present and future of the period of life for the public clearly.
Great point. The fact that no American or Brit could be heard throughout this exchange may indicate a real shift in global thought leadership. Unfortunately they still got the biggest arm forces, so don't underestimate the human stupidity!
Ah yes, what a humble rogue.
That's why it is so incomprehensible the UK has withdrawn from Europe because this 'self-inflicted wound' will dramatically reduce the influence of English as lingua franca.
This woman is not humble she is a very great actress playing along with the narrative of them openly telling it’s our future on an open platform the government don’t understand just Silicon Valley understands it the control freaks along with the WEF
The man that introduced the talk… my god just to hear him talk is depressing, lighten up a bit, smile, I was falling asleep throughout the introduction.
Thank you for uploading Yuval! I can't watch enough of your lectures and interviews I love listening to you! Please continue sharing your great mind with the world.
I agree. He's synthesizing a set of ideas that have been around in the zeitgeist for a long while, but he provides an exposition that allows ordinary thinking people to look someway into the possible futures that are opening up in front of us - but not necessarily all of them (possible futures).
@@johnferngrove4083 it will be almost impossible to not to do in this way. Its a really nice way to seed in the world the idea that the concept of property/money must be stopped
@@johnferngrove4083 He's a historian. His job is synthesizing ideas and historical data... .
@ He's a historian. He writes much more interesting and insightful stuff than most academics. "great" is relative.
I totally agree. I just found this man 3 days ago and can't stop listening to him speak
This is by far the most interesting YNH discussion on UA-cam. Most of the questions thrown are grounded on realistic practicality which make it more challenging to answer
What a great interview! Yuval is always interesting to listen to but some of the interviewers he encounters are highly incompetent and painful to watch. Mrs Lagarde did a great job! Thanks so much for sharing!
True, I love to listen to her, she’s very bright.
So true
Bought 21 Lessons for the 21st Century today.
Thank you for continuing to produce such intriguing books.
I'm from argentina. I wish you're lectures were subtitled to Spanish. I'm sure you'd have many more views.
Plastic bottles have to disappear from any meeting debating on world social issues! Having said that, great convesation: constructive, respectful, inclusive.
Great call out
first thing i saw... easier not to put attention.
It might be bad "optics" but in reality if humans stopped using all plastics it would only offset emissions by about 1-2%. Should focus on heating, food, and transportation.
Nice sample of business as usually mindset 😏
@future money: the money now is based rather on faith (the blind one...) than on thrust...
I am enthusiastic to see that leaders of the world are in a dialogue with Yuval Noah Harari. It means we might step in the future with a greater awareness.
the first step into future with greater awareness would be a critical use and deconstruction of hararis positivistic ideology.
if it comes to his discernment, i just want to mention, that stalin and hitler, in hararis opinion, were humanists...
holy shit :D
I've been watching so many interviews of Prof Harari and still learning something new: know yourself so you won't be hacked by the society. Wow what a powerful takeaway. Thank you
Such a pleasure to watch a super comfortable and sharp Christine Lagarde host this conversation (which actually felt like a person-to-person type of conversation and not a "we're recording and I already have set questions, and it's awkward" type of convo).
Me amarro nas entrevistas com legenda pra eu acompanhar.
I have read two his books, it's amazing how deeply he is see a future.
if you want to see the future, read marx analysis of political economy. thats 150 years in the past, but still showing present AND future.
forget this harari bullshit. he calls hitler and stalin humanists. any other proof necessary, to document his stupidity?^^
¡Vaya talento de Harari, impulsado por una punzante Lagarde! Es una delicia de entrevista.
@45:48: TAXING INFORMATION ~
An intriguing idea ~
It is always a treat to listen to Yuval Noah Harari. He's an international treasure. Great writer. Wise thinker. Wonderful human being.
Nah he's an alarmist and catastrophizes to be provocative in order to sell books. He's a well-spoken charlatan with a broad reading list on interesting and highly relevant topics.
@@OMAR-vq3yb Please don't advertise your severe inferiority complex and ridiculous bias on public platforms.
Médecin is not just knowledge and patterns, is experience and intuition as well ! It’s empathy also, how you are gone get this from a machine ?
Who else searches for Yuval Noah Harari and sorts by updated date on UA-cam?
Sería maravilloso una disertación en español 🤗😘
Why is the Managing Director of the IMF interviewing Yuval? Maybe not as strange as we would like to think, is it!
She want to be next president of france by staying in public popular eye. Staging talkshows like these appeal to classes.
Yes, that was my question right at the beginning , besides she acts like a student in front of the interviewee. She didn’t have anything better to do in this time of economic turmoil?
Yuval it would be great if one of your team could list the questions, and the times when they occur, in the 'SHOW MORE' section above. Thanks
Yuval , my candidate for future Nobel Peace Prize.
99639-9127
Really a noble prize for a dictorship mentality a slave mentality a controlling few to the many
ua-cam.com/video/lGSQYHWzipw/v-deo.html
Here here - we could really use minds like his helping us design a new Govt structure in America 🇺🇸 b4 we end up a fascist dictatorship a uniquely stupid decade that has us on the razors edge of civil war & a coup d’etat by the far right
We can instead build a society that reflects reality & a new plan for how to either divorce or fight against 1% owning 99.99999% of all wealth which we will reach w in a few years should the Koch network get their way cruel immoral idiotic
@@collettebrynes1075 aww ur likely a believer in Matt Walsh or Ben Shapiro - they r scared of people like Yuval rightfully so
My mother ran a weight club. For some the answer was putting more weight on (Growth) for others it was taking weight off. It was called the ideal weight club. It focus was health promotion. Young kids want to grow up to be big. Adults want to protect their health. Personally I think Integrated Reporting which measures far more than profit is a big part of the answer.
We already have AI doctors. In 10 mins hello a diagnosis script and goodbye. No care how one feels or what fears exist or what questions one may have.
Thank you so much! You are very corajous, criative, sensitive and inteligent. Your Work is very important for humanity.
I feel like Christine's work is important for the extermination of humanity.
One of the best interviews I have seen so far in my life. It's really amazing how he pointed out us following stories and live oir lives and how we are going to depend on data for almost everything in life
Lagarde is so hot. I love how smart and humoruous she is. And humble open minded.
and a corrupt criminal maybe, who just tricked millions of people about millions of euros?^^
Yeh, Smart woman seem more atractive usually
Adipoli chetta..
Mr.Yuval please come to India somehow .. in India currently the entire political discourse revolves around Cow slaughter and worship and terribly violent , funny when beef can be artificially manufactured to consume.
I hope some influential people engage with you in India , if you want to discuss in India let me know
Thanks .
It's hard to kill a mythology that will be replaced by another mythology.
He came in 2018, your wish is granted
What is ultimate goal for human existence? Is it economic growth is it wealth? I doubt so. It cannot be answered by materialistic prosperity it requires spiritual development.
yuval your talk is very interesting annd thought provoking. Sometime they are very weighty for us to grasp. One hour is longer to concentrate and digest. Can we make 45 min.
When he said you "have to understand the algorithm", I saw that he has 250k subscribers on youtube, and that all my recommendations after this video are interviews of him. He has also managed to own the algorithm! Great talk!
Nawet nie wiesz co cię czeka.
One of his points I would refute is that gold isn't worthless and became money because of its intrinsic properties and therefore objective value. These properties include malleability, immutability and of course beauty. The only reason we have switched to using paper currency is because they started out as receipts for stored gold and later made unredeemable in 1971 with the end of the Breton woods system. The need for commodity money or "useful" money is still very real today and will probably make a come back in the next decade as today's fake money scheme collapses.
This is probably the only prediction in this entire video that will come true.
Money doesn't simply work on trust,there is always some authority behind it so that people keep on believing the story
the meat n dairy industry....., ty kindly Noah for speaking the truth
The AI machine can NEVER express genuene LOVE in the contact with another BEING nither can receive Love directly
I am not in love with the mind or personality or brain or body of another person but with the BEING ITSELF
Love is direct exchange between BEINGS
Beings have personality mind and brain and body
But Beings are NOT mind brains body nither they are personalities
Mind (feelings and thougts) is changable
Brain body is changable
But the Being is ever unique and it never changes
it is individual (not dividible)
It IS
SO
AI will serve the body and mind needs
But will never replace the contact between Beings
Never
The contact is the most important aspect of the incarnation in life in the body
To exchange Genuine Love
This is the only way that Consciuosness for Who am I CAN develop
And SelfRealization is the only purpose of Life
Not comfort or health or comodity
They are only resources
Human Beings ARE NOT RESOURCES!
THEY Are Divine Manifestations
Love for all Beings
amazing interviewer and guest amazing!!
Christine Lagarde is so humble. I'm surprised normally these people are stuck up. Really liked this.
Great deceivers
She's a nice person!
Lazyleopard...You don t know how these people are ? >............Can we meet ?
She needs some sunscreen
same here.. always found her snobbish... kind of liked her this time... a very strong character..
Ephesians 6:12
I love Yuval's dress style and code. His socks match with his shirt, that is not accidental. His jacked is fitted to highlight his body shape… All that matters is dress style and what is said comes second…
Well, it's a good job he dresses well. He doesn't actually have much to say...it's mostly waffle and speculation. There's a lot of this stuff around these days.
He speaks like you Peter, waffle and speculation… Mr Armchair general.
He wants to sell books ...everything is theoretically speaking ....another lier
Mystic Produce what has he lie about?
just like a good conman “One can never underestimate human stupidity” ;-)
1:00:11 - "we should never underestimate human stupidity" - this one made my day
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
What an awesome interview between 2 bright Sapiens!
"1:00:11 - "we should never underestimate human stupidity" - this one made my day"
its truly funny, because a historian, who calls hitler and stalin humanists just said that :D
if he wasnt that stupid, i would congrat harari for his right selfestimation.
@@wurstfinger3289
The "stupidity" of the human being can be attributed to the consequences on the causes due to the individual and collective violence exerted on others.
In a way, stupidity comes from renunciation and brings by violence a material response to an unspeakable violence to the difficult causes. which are only the mismanagement of our achievements and its cautherization.
So most of the "stupid" episodes that can be attributed to people are based on mismanagement, which is called injustice. if people consider that one can treat, for example, stupid, children and the handicapped (one can hear it afterwards. it's endless). Strangely, it's precisely children and the handicapped who are most revolted against injustice.
So we can call an episode "stupid" a random answer that breaks into the logic of decorum set up by an interlocutor who wants to establish his supremacy.
So it’s not that stupid when you think about it 😂.
random is a more common concept than one might think. it is present in the infinitely great which represents the matrix stability of the material world. and completely random in the infinitely small.
TQC quantum field theory admirably explains the material world, reconciling the notions of free will and predestination by explaining the macrocosm/microcosm of ancient philosophers. Let science be in the infinitely large and infinitely small...but this proves too much the reconciliation of science and God and that is why people who are not of integrity seek to discredit this theory because with it, many things can be explained...the study of this theory makes God return to the center of the debate of most Cartesian scholars. The official premices emanate from quantum electrodynamics, the theory is attributed to James Clerk Maxwell developed in 1864, 30 years after Tesla’s death.
Yet in my opinion Tesla already knew it. the adversity was certainly harsh. the same for the energy we could have benefited from the TQC.
And for once we hear about AI not by wanting to distort the human (under half the video) and propose to put it at the service of the human, finally, and for a better management and distribution of resources, it's worth trying to understand. maybe right for take the chance to change the way of human beeing ( if the IA wasn't be on human for To make it clear for sure !)
@Marcelo Lazzaro You're included, human.
Great Job professor Harari.
Albin Sopaj h
Soros best! Soros give me money and ideas!
It will be great if somebody put spanich subtitles on this video
''don't underestimate the power of human stupidity'' what powerful quotation Sir!
After the last couple of years, seeing how folk can be manipulated, I will never underestimate the power of human stupidity.
You say it so clear and honest, brilliant absolutely .... the only missing point that is not taken into the account in your talks is your point of view about unleashed growing number of human species that is being and will be imposed to this planet and resources to the point that is unsustainable ... if anybody heard that point of view in any of Mr. Yuval talks, could you please share the link with me..... many thanks in advance.
I'd listen to Yuval all day!
Even though he/they want to depopulate you?
I prefer to see depate b/w Elon musk and yuval noah harari
Thank you Dr.Harari for your lectures, there is a lot of issues that your expose very clear about the reality, kind regards from Honduras
Ty nie masz pojęcia co oni na nas ludzi szykują! :(
That was the essence of the whole conversation:
« Do not underestimate the human stupidity.! »
I thought it was don't underestimate the Psychopathic capabilities of the world's leaders.
@@travissharon1536
You are right, if you assume world leaders and politicians to be humans too!
@@travissharon1536 These people, wel let's say demons, imagine those people in charge of the world, may god help me.
@@travissharon1536 I am with you!!!!!
He is not alarmist. He care about humankind
This conversation moderated by Christine Lagarde is so clear and beautiful which much better than that Yuval with Google.
Could anyone please explain to me , what did he mean by "selling books to the algorithm"?
At the end of the day ,it is the humans that will read those books.
He's a sociopath! He despises in a very sadistic way other human beings who are not part of the globalist payroll. He actually needs people to buy (pun intended) his stories and cooperate on their globalist agenda. If they didn't need us there would be no point addressing us to any topic they discuss in the video, like he said in the beginning about determinism.
When Yuval said, "AI's 100% focus is on you", that touched my heart and my eyes got a pair of tears ...I am surprised, I didn't knew I was that lonely. Seriously...😅
haha...funny but true.
Two of the most interesting people alive today. I read this book and it had tremendous impact on my worldview. Very enjoyable conversation!
Que lástima, com tanta tecnologia, não estar traduzido para alguns outros idiomas!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Your scenario of humans “being hackable animals” is something to be aware of. I don’t think most people want to be “manipulated” by your idea of AI
He leído los tres libros y me han parecido muy interesantes. Los recomiendo continuamente, son imprescindibles para tener una visión de la humanidad. Un saludo!!
Jak się w nic I w nikogo nie wierzy i robi to co organizm mu każe to może ta filozofia być interesująca. Dla mnie ten pan to jak Marx und Lenin. Człowiek który uważa, że można żyć bez moralności i zasad i kultury która nas ukształtowała. Ten filozof to dla mnie kiepski filozof, który zupełnie nie ma pojęcia o wnetrzu ludzkim a tylko o zwierzęcych prymitywnych potrzebach. To człowiek, który stara się wcisnąć nam ludziom swoje zwierzęce pojmowanie świata. Ps nigdy I nigdzie nie ma jeszcze dowodów na to, że BÓG i dusza nie istnieją. Gada rzeczy które nie mają z nauką NIC wspólnego. Sorry dla mnie to jakiś wizjoner, który żyje w swoim" zwierzęcym" świecie!
57:15 W polskim tłumaczeniu jest błąd. Chłopak pyta czy będzie "more nations". Translator tłumaczy to jako "państwa", a powinien jako "narody". To przecież bardzo istotna różnica. Zmienia sens pytania i kierunek rozważań.
Thank you. It was really great.
Me too!
one of the most interesting conversations i've even seen in his channel!
great, thabk you very much :)
Thank you for sharing your knowledge Yuval.. Please continue sharing with same boldness.
lol yuval dont share knowledge yuval is an agent of liberal propaganda . Those guys are like soviets they don t care about humanity facts and truth they prefer ideology
Ms. Christine Yuval touch her heart the way he knowledge
Yuval Sir your work has provided the very first window to look at future. In knowledge, it is said we are standing on shoulders of giants.
I believe you are the person who has laid the edifice for the knowledge of tomorrow, predictions about current framework of humanity and its system. Thank you Sir :)
Film Actor’s Guild 🏆
أين الترجمه؟
Great talk, loved all your books, hope to have more like you...
Nawet nie wiesz człowieku co oni planują z tobą zrobić.
WUAUH. I LOVE YOUR SENSE OF HUMOUR. AND YOUR BOOKS.
Incidir en la memoria humana desde la enseñanza del encuadre constituido en la persoectiva grupal que abre la posibilidad dentro de la capacidad que dentro de las normas sociales y politicss permite a la unidad creativa individualizar la profecia
Muchas gracias por su aporte a darnos mas opciones para ver el futuro. Estuvo exelente.
Głupoty które właściwie robią z człowieka zwierzę. I to ma być dla nas normalnych ludzi przyszlosc a ci wybrani będą żyli za darmo, naszym kosztem i nasza krwią.
Nawet nie wiesz człowieku co piszesz.
I wonder how Christine lagarde interpreting his anology will effect measures taking in future economic policy making
Christine has a good sense of humour
Yes, I got a better opinion of her after this interview.
yea she has. thats why she has no problem with herself, beeing criminal and in one of the most responsible positions in the world at the same time.
Yes it is, eventhought she is more powerfull women in the world she is very cool.
Excellent ,great, as always
Wonderful !!! 👏👏👏👏👏
At 49.53, she says "very few understand how the financial system works ... including in this room" ... chuckle... Is this her confession that she doesn't understand how the financial system really works? He adds that in an AI future no human will understand it. Have we passed that point already? I think so...
Excellent discussion! Thank you .
Wiesz za co dziękujesz???za parę lat sama się przekonasz!
,,, imho,, future currencies will concern access to the personal sphere informational et al ...
Is money a story or is money a type of language (symbol system) used in telling certain types of stories? A language is a conventional system of symbols by means of which social groups and individual members may interact. So that money is not a mere story but a system of symbols whereby culture may weave stories, albeit at a cost...
Zen pro tip at 16:53 , contest to understand each other.
Amen
Mr. Harari, so interesting listen to you! It is the second time you mentioned Honduras (20.27). I would like to know why and if you can help us... Thank's alot!
@Humble Guy Thank you for your opinion Mr Guy. We have dificult times and our politicians are the main problem... The best for you too.
El todo esta en todo
The hottie in the heals is the real treasure here
Wow this is so inspiring
I got stunned by the boldness of his argements. Some of them were beyond my previous imaginations. The idea like robots as the sole consumers is shocking. Humans are not necessary in the consuming cycle? A huge material for thoughts and thoughts. This is a brilliant talk.
Brilliant Talk? Brilliant sick
If reincarnated as Christine Lagarde its like winning miss universe. She's hot, impressive stance with her tall height and Hermes scarves galore. Well respected by powerful people , smart bright mind. Awesome conversation with a would be winner of the Nobel prize historian, authored a lot of Woke books
Yuval Harari.
Mira, this is for you!
🤮
Yuval. Say something about the IMF corruption please.
Impossible , being invited by a monetary mafia
Ahahaha!
I was waiting for him to say something about IMF
He is historian not a politician or policeman and here is just discussion not police investigation mate!
@@regisl99
Policitians are Liars
Police men are Soldiers
Historians know facts of societies
But you think he is not qualified
You believe Liars and Soldiers
Are qualified to speak on IMF
You are so Logical
Great talk, Yuval, thank you! As usual.
Have you thought about debating Jordan Peterson? It has a potential to become an epic battle of titans! :)
I don't think so, unfortunately Prof. Peterson stuck to Bible stories that limits his own brilliance.
Jordan Peterson is nowhere near his level. You are not a great thinker when all you can is think of ways to improve the current system and therefore not think outside the box/or think outside the current "stories" you're being told.
I'll pay to watch that
He shouldn't stoop so low as to debate Peterson.
Not sure how Jordan Peterson would disagree with any of prof hararis ideas???
"We are all algorithms" Yuval Harari
for the most part
so how do you experience yourself as an algorithm?
You wish. It's Harari quoting an old nugget of wisdom every theoretical evolutionary biologist is intimately familiar with. However, I give it to him: he is very good at presenting old wisdom decked in interesting outfit.
The soul lives outside of the algorithm. What happens to the algorithm when you die?
THIS IS VERY MEMORIALE VIDEO FOR FOCUS #CONCESSNES AWAKING😆😅😍 HAPPY HUMAN OF THE WORLD #STYLIFE HARMONY FOR TO LIVE, 😚😍😃🤗😆
Huge subject for discussion.
Potential for great progress or horrible disaster. Probably some of each.
Two of my favourite minds.
Humans have a choice to create algorithms that no one understands. There is a choice. That’s the point. The same way one has choice buying things they cannot afford. There is always a debt.
SOME OF THE DATA WE DONT NEED WE BE HISTORY,
Great Yuval ji👍..... lots of Metta 💐
Amazing ideas about the world development in the next years.
Man is more than a machine, but rather the driver of a machine. He will also survive the machine he drives.
Interesting how IMF is talking to Yuval. This means IMF is actually worried about the sheep losing trust.
The body language of this old lady signals how uncomfortable she is in this conversation. An interviewer should not be like that.
@@D.2023 Indeed, she does also look uncomfortable, I guess it's because deep down any human is ashamed if they are exploiting others.
Maybe she gotta poop
I am a poet...! I love economics... :D
GOOD NEWS 😂
This idea is the start of what will be coming as l see it myself. So, a very good way to start to change and practice the economic, political (if it should exist still), industrial and the social norms here on Earth. When In finally happen, (as l believe that it will ) Human-Earthlings conquer Mars and as a start would be building infrastructure, for the gradual expansion and Terra-forming of the planet. My question has to do with Yuval's idea about the transformation of all these known practices' or processes and outlook of humans due to advancing technology. When it gets to the point when it happens, do we have any idea how we or the people after us will be "living". Progress can not wait how we change our Human Ways. What should be done to reinvent humans, or run economy which i speculate will become cashless. And how will we prepare the future activity or "work" for the generations to come. What must they be prepared of? And what will the educational structure, curriculum and courses needed for that space-faring era or evolution? Do we have to prepare the younger generation for professions that might be redundant if not obsolete? Can we think and act now, or should we prepare for it to come before we act? Mars pioneers will be self sufficient but do they need some sort of award as in salary? Do members of the populace share the common food that is harvested in the green house or the goods manufactured on Mars? Do they need to "pay" anything of whatever they produce in that planet? If a Mine worker be paid for his services in the colony so he can pay his food harvested from the green house? As commented before in a inquisitive manner- "Are we even prepared how we humans manage or exploit, conquer and destroy another planet? A New Concept shall be drafted I suppose. Systems that needs to be changed, revised or totally abolish. Common practice and beliefs that will be no longer essential to humans in Mars shall be the common cause to DO and Rethink while still on earth. Such concept as 'nation' where humans created imaginary division and we call it border. I know the "Planetary Board of Council" or whatever they may call it, can think of more issues than the example. Human Mind needs to reboot or reconfigure. The Human Algorithm we learnt and executed for hundreds of years we willingly think acceptable is in fact infected by "Virus" and human realizes it too long and nobody wants it changed. ~Peace to Self+everyone, be Contended, be Happy~