I wish more people would take a few minutes out of there day and watch this and really see what we are doing to these animals they have nothing wrong to us please let listen if we would work together
I doubt the sound stressed you out, its the fucking wierd ass drawings they have to represent them. The whole video is basically saying animals are having a hard time communicating like they used to do as a result of human activity. thats it. the sounds themselves arnt killing animals and the ones that do are extremely close like when dolphins get injured or die when they get to close to a submarine conducting active sonar. it disturbs the ecosystem for sure but it's not affecting it enough to warrant taking resources we're putting into other means of reducing our footprint.
@@gamerx112so you’re cool if we just setup some sonar pulsing devices outside your house? They will go off regularly, daily, frequently. But don’t worry, it’s not a big enough problem to worry about. It’s no big deal.
@@gamerx112 yea no bruvvy, you pick and choose your battles, unfortunately no one will agreee with you so please dont try making another point out of it
i never imagine that somewhere on earth the under water noise is a global problem ! today after whatching this video i feel just a little bit more ''smart'' than yestarday !! thank you Oceancare ! you just won a new subscriber ! well done
Only 31K views... meanwhile Logan and Jake Paul garner millions upon millions up views with their cheap entertainment. Humanity must do something different.
Qxir makes a great point in his video about this topic: whales have no idea what we are doing - these activities have nothing to do with them, and are beyond their comprehension. Us as humans are doing what we are doing with disregard to them, we dont really know think or care about the effect of our actions on whales. What if we were the whales and the humans were aliens? What if these giant invisible god like beings were carrying out tests or activities for their own purposes, with disregard for us, that caused intense pain, blindness deafness or even hemorrhaging and death to us? That would be a taste of our own medicine.
@@tomservo5007 close in maybe depending on mode, freq.., pulse length, to name a few. Sound propagation and attenuation, plus how you are from the transmitter affects the levels you receive. I do question blanket statements about active sonar killing everything in the ocean no matter how far away.
First of all congratulations on the awesome work, marine life certainly appreciate it a lot. I know I'm very late on the cause but I just started my subtitling career and I made a volunteer translation to Brazilian Portuguese. It seens that the video doesn't has a translation to my language yet. I would be very flatter if mine was used, I'm passionate by the oceans and the marine environment preservation's causes.
And this is the exact reason why the Navy doesn't use Military sonar anymore. Military sonar found on US Navy Ship and Submarines, they used these back in the day as a way to track enemy ships and submarines but they don't use it anymore because they're way too strong, sure the waves it emits can travel longer distances to track enemy ships and submarines but animals like dolphins and whales they would get caught in the crossfire with these devices and on top of that it could disrupt the echolocation they use to find their babies so as a result Military Sonar can actually damage the environment and it puts more Animal Rights pressure on the Navy so that's why the Navy no longer uses Military Sonar.
I'd like to see your source of info and what time of ship you are referring to because as a US Navy sonar technician, I can tell you that we still use sonar for detecting tracking and classifying. If we didn't use sonar anymore, I would be out of a job. I also invite you and anyone else to learn the physics of sound in water. Cause the dB level is not constant for the entire transmission of active sonar but is subject to propagation loss, absorption, and other factors.
@@amandawoodward5596 I don't think there are very many folks who take the time to try and understand some of the basic physics of underwater sound and maybe the difference between active and passive sonar.
Oh Damn! As a fishing boat captain, I never thought my 8 foot propeller bothered them! I made the conscious decision years ago, to turn off my sonar, when I knew I was in sufficiently deep water, and was not looking for fish. I have always thought that my sonar was being the bigger nuisance! So, is there a better propulsion design to address this problem?
Thank you for your answer and your good thoughts. Surface piercing drives like Arneson are the quietest of the boat propulsion systems. Orcas seem not to mind these much. But turning your sonar off when not needed is also a huge help, as it can be very disturbing to mid- or high-frequency sensitive whales and dolphins. Choosing a sonar that is over 200 kHz is also preferable, but that may not give you enough penetration. Diesel engines with low rpms moving slowly don’t seem to be as disturbing to many whales as others, but are still somewhat noisy. Speed makes a large difference, with slower speeds almost always producing less noise.
The technology already exists to rid ourselves of fossil fuels and archaic transportation modes. The documentaries "Unacknowledged", "Close Encounters of the Firth Kind", and "The Lost Century And How To Reclaim It" by Dr. Steven Greer- and his book "Hidden Truth - Forbidden Knowledge"- elaborate.
Actually one of the loudest source levels in the ocean are the Sperm whales clicks. Do some research before making comments based on emotions. Several of my fellow sonar techs have commented here...... Read what we are saying.
Ppl only do tings for personal gains so somtin lik this wont matter to them Ppl wud sit 2 watch anothr person make a fool outta himself than 2 watch a video lik this 1
I know how to fix it, get some angry Karen neighbors to live as a fish for a set period. They’ll absolutely despise the noise and they won’t rest until they do something about it. In all seriousness, what a terrible thing noise pollution in the ocean is.
Unrelated to the videos message, I would've really appreciated if you used the actual sounds of (modern)sonar, airguns, cavitation etc. and not these...extreme...standins. Cargoship propellers do not sound like drills on steroids, warships don't use a CW ping in that frequency since WW2 and seismic airguns don't sound like a bloody bomb going off next to you. I get what you're trying to say, but accuracy in detail makes you more credible.
Well, cargoship propellers are insanely loud and sound much worse than in the video. Sonar is also incredibly uncomfortable to listen to, and MUCH worse than in this video. The airguns do sound exactly like explosions, but worse. They are loud enough to penetrate through kilometres of rock. That's significantly louder than a rocket taking off. Literally everything you wrote in your comment is just wrong. Which leads me to ask this question: why would you write it? I agree that they should have exchanged the weak little sonar ping in the video for the real thing, which sounds horrible. It would have made it more impactful. But the airguns are spot on, and the propeller here isn't as bad as the real thing either.
@@michaelcaplin8969 Actually, Cargoship propellers aren't even that noisy. They emit a rather slow and rhythmic "sloshing" that is very distinct, but hardly "insanely loud". Now, small boat propellers or even outboarders are an entirely different story, as those are actually extremely loud thanks to their high rpm. Sonar is indeed very uncomfortable to hear, given it's high frequency and incredible volume. In fact it is so loud that it can kill people (divers) if they get too close, which turns military-grade active sonar into a very useful deterrent against enemy divers trying to sabotage your ship. My point with the seismic airgun wasn't so much addressing the intensity of the sound, but rather the filesample used to represent it here. You can clearly make out that the sound from the video is a shockwave traveling through air, most likely coming from an actual explosive going off. Due to their artificial nature (and their actual purpose), seismic airguns create a repeatable (less chaotic) pulse which sounds more like "thumping". Jive Turkey has made a very good analysis of an airgun sound sample, you should check that out if you want to hear the actual noise. Of course it's recorded from a large distance but you should be able to make out the difference in tone. As to why I made the comment in the first place, it was to point out things that bothered me personally while offering alternatives to improve the content. You may disagree with me, but thats what comments are ultimately for.
Agreed. I'm a sonar tech and have listened to merchant props and they just sound like one slapping water usually. And the sonar the depicted here was a poor representation. I hate stuff like this because it tells people is killing marine mammals while not actually talking about the physics of the sound in water and why this is happening nor do they address the measures we take in order to protect marine life. But they prefer painting the navy as the bad guy and anyone else who puts sound in water. Anyone who buys anything imported can blame themselves also. Hell part of mapping the ocean requires sonar.
@@amandawoodward5596I don't know, the several videos of divers hearing military sonar pings reverberating across the sea floor sound pretty dang loud, and I know it's a lot more intense in person.
I wish more people would take a few minutes out of there day and watch this and really see what we are doing to these animals they have nothing wrong to us please let listen if we would work together
Wait a minute, so you want all of us to die for these whales and shit?
@@GhilleGhille no he does not mean that he wants us to share with animals
@@GhilleGhille what does that have to do with dying?
Harsh reality is only a very few cares for the nature and rest others only watches and show grief and sometime they don't have time to show grief
just hearing the noise in the video stressed me out, imagine what its like for the animals
I doubt the sound stressed you out, its the fucking wierd ass drawings they have to represent them.
The whole video is basically saying animals are having a hard time communicating like they used to do as a result of human activity.
thats it. the sounds themselves arnt killing animals and the ones that do are extremely close like when dolphins get injured or die when they get to close to a submarine conducting active sonar.
it disturbs the ecosystem for sure but it's not affecting it enough to warrant taking resources we're putting into other means of reducing our footprint.
@@gamerx112so you’re cool if we just setup some sonar pulsing devices outside your house? They will go off regularly, daily, frequently. But don’t worry, it’s not a big enough problem to worry about. It’s no big deal.
@@gamerx112 yea no bruvvy, you pick and choose your battles, unfortunately no one will agreee with you so please dont try making another point out of it
The film "Sonic Sea" is another excellent resource on this crucial matter.
i never imagine that somewhere on earth the under water noise is a global problem ! today after whatching this video i feel just a little bit more ''smart'' than yestarday !! thank you Oceancare ! you just won a new subscriber ! well done
lovely video, I wonder how come I never found this video before...more people need to watch this
Only 31K views... meanwhile Logan and Jake Paul garner millions upon millions up views with their cheap entertainment. Humanity must do something different.
Sums up that people are more interested in clowns and retards rather than education and knowledge
Looks like the scum of the earth just plan of killing everything.
Nah
Qxir makes a great point in his video about this topic: whales have no idea what we are doing - these activities have nothing to do with them, and are beyond their comprehension. Us as humans are doing what we are doing with disregard to them, we dont really know think or care about the effect of our actions on whales. What if we were the whales and the humans were aliens? What if these giant invisible god like beings were carrying out tests or activities for their own purposes, with disregard for us, that caused intense pain, blindness deafness or even hemorrhaging and death to us? That would be a taste of our own medicine.
constant sound is a form of torture. Military active sonar is strong enough to kill.
Based on what?
@@tomtrenter3208 Military active sonar is extremely loud, loud enough to kill directly or cause injury that will result in death,
@@tomservo5007 have you measured source levels and frequecies at various ranges and depths to quantify your statement?
@@tomtrenter3208 are you questioning the fact that sonar can kill?
@@tomservo5007 close in maybe depending on mode, freq.., pulse length, to name a few. Sound propagation and attenuation, plus how you are from the transmitter affects the levels you receive. I do question blanket statements about active sonar killing everything in the ocean no matter how far away.
Thanks Silent Oceans ;-)
keep up the Fine Work!
with you in spirit and
solidarity!
Kia kaha
thank you for this great video
We are truly jerks
No, just you
@@baguette574 DUDE THIS IS SERIOUS DONT BEHAVE LIKE A DUMBASS WHO LIKES ROASTING
First of all congratulations on the awesome work, marine life certainly appreciate it a lot.
I know I'm very late on the cause but I just started my subtitling career and I made a volunteer translation to Brazilian Portuguese. It seens that the video doesn't has a translation to my language yet.
I would be very flatter if mine was used, I'm passionate by the oceans and the marine environment preservation's causes.
And this is the exact reason why the Navy doesn't use Military sonar anymore. Military sonar found on US Navy Ship and Submarines, they used these back in the day as a way to track enemy ships and submarines but they don't use it anymore because they're way too strong, sure the waves it emits can travel longer distances to track enemy ships and submarines but animals like dolphins and whales they would get caught in the crossfire with these devices and on top of that it could disrupt the echolocation they use to find their babies so as a result Military Sonar can actually damage the environment and it puts more Animal Rights pressure on the Navy so that's why the Navy no longer uses Military Sonar.
I'd like to see your source of info and what time of ship you are referring to because as a US Navy sonar technician, I can tell you that we still use sonar for detecting tracking and classifying. If we didn't use sonar anymore, I would be out of a job.
I also invite you and anyone else to learn the physics of sound in water. Cause the dB level is not constant for the entire transmission of active sonar but is subject to propagation loss, absorption, and other factors.
@@amandawoodward5596 I don't think there are very many folks who take the time to try and understand some of the basic physics of underwater sound and maybe the difference between active and passive sonar.
@@tomtrenter3208im very interested in sonars and sound, could you enlighten me and give me some good reads to dig deeper?
Thank You 🙏🏼 🇱🇰
It's time to update the video above to include noises generated by industrial scale construction and operation of off-shore wind turbines
Really its a very serious issue
Fascinating but also very sad
Oh Damn! As a fishing boat captain, I never thought my 8 foot propeller bothered them! I made the conscious decision years ago, to turn off my sonar, when I knew I was in sufficiently deep water, and was not looking for fish. I have always thought that my sonar was being the bigger nuisance! So, is there a better propulsion design to address this problem?
Thank you for your answer and your good thoughts. Surface piercing drives like Arneson are the quietest of the boat propulsion systems. Orcas seem not to mind these much. But turning your sonar off when not needed is also a huge help, as it can be very disturbing to mid- or high-frequency sensitive whales and dolphins. Choosing a sonar that is over 200 kHz is also preferable, but that may not give you enough penetration. Diesel engines with low rpms moving slowly don’t seem to be as disturbing to many whales as others, but are still somewhat noisy. Speed makes a large difference, with slower speeds almost always producing less noise.
muy bueno, gracias, 4-1-23,Atlanticazo en Argentina, No a las petroleras offshore !!!
Fantastic video
I love whales😍😍🥰🥰❤❤❤❤
This is why marine life beaches..
The technology already exists to rid ourselves of fossil fuels and archaic transportation modes. The documentaries "Unacknowledged", "Close Encounters of the Firth Kind", and "The Lost Century And How To Reclaim It" by Dr. Steven Greer- and his book "Hidden Truth - Forbidden Knowledge"- elaborate.
That’s why they told you not to tap on the fish tank
They mean "20 times shorter" and perhaps more than 160 times "smaller" (it's cubic, not linear)
Sounds like sonar to whales is like that police officer to George
Is it possible to save the whales, and have the latest iPhone at the same time too?
There will be less things when there are less people... which is inevitable one way or another.
And now ppl are wondering why killer whales are attacking boats
What is the campaign which is against underwater noise pollution in the video called？
It’s Pumpkin (Please watch the video carefully Ծ‸Ծ
@@user-yy9mr7vm5pDon’t u think it is tea bowl steam(´·ω·`)
That's too sad
Did Ned Stark narrate this?
Holy cow humans beings are the WORST
that animation tho
Tell that to China
Actually one of the loudest source levels in the ocean are the Sperm whales clicks. Do some research before making comments based on emotions. Several of my fellow sonar techs have commented here...... Read what we are saying.
😁😁🌊🌊🌊
Ppl only do tings for personal gains so somtin lik this wont matter to them
Ppl wud sit 2 watch anothr person make a fool outta himself than 2 watch a video lik this 1
I know how to fix it, get some angry Karen neighbors to live as a fish for a set period. They’ll absolutely despise the noise and they won’t rest until they do something about it.
In all seriousness, what a terrible thing noise pollution in the ocean is.
Hi Tik tok, I love you
wtf is a 'citation'
that's a whale bruh
Cetaceans are marine animals like whales and dolphins🐬🐬🐋🐋🐋🐳🐳🐳🐳
What about the people who press in unlike !!! ???
Unrelated to the videos message, I would've really appreciated if you used the actual sounds of (modern)sonar, airguns, cavitation etc. and not these...extreme...standins.
Cargoship propellers do not sound like drills on steroids, warships don't use a CW ping in that frequency since WW2 and seismic airguns don't sound like a bloody bomb going off next to you.
I get what you're trying to say, but accuracy in detail makes you more credible.
Well, cargoship propellers are insanely loud and sound much worse than in the video. Sonar is also incredibly uncomfortable to listen to, and MUCH worse than in this video. The airguns do sound exactly like explosions, but worse. They are loud enough to penetrate through kilometres of rock. That's significantly louder than a rocket taking off. Literally everything you wrote in your comment is just wrong. Which leads me to ask this question: why would you write it? I agree that they should have exchanged the weak little sonar ping in the video for the real thing, which sounds horrible. It would have made it more impactful. But the airguns are spot on, and the propeller here isn't as bad as the real thing either.
@@michaelcaplin8969 Actually, Cargoship propellers aren't even that noisy. They emit a rather slow and rhythmic "sloshing" that is very distinct, but hardly "insanely loud".
Now, small boat propellers or even outboarders are an entirely different story, as those are actually extremely loud thanks to their high rpm.
Sonar is indeed very uncomfortable to hear, given it's high frequency and incredible volume.
In fact it is so loud that it can kill people (divers) if they get too close, which turns military-grade active sonar into a very useful deterrent against enemy divers trying to sabotage your ship.
My point with the seismic airgun wasn't so much addressing the intensity of the sound, but rather the filesample used to represent it here.
You can clearly make out that the sound from the video is a shockwave traveling through air, most likely coming from an actual explosive going off.
Due to their artificial nature (and their actual purpose), seismic airguns create a repeatable (less chaotic) pulse which sounds more like "thumping".
Jive Turkey has made a very good analysis of an airgun sound sample, you should check that out if you want to hear the actual noise. Of course it's recorded from a large distance but you should be able to make out the difference in tone.
As to why I made the comment in the first place, it was to point out things that bothered me personally while offering alternatives to improve the content.
You may disagree with me, but thats what comments are ultimately for.
Agreed. I'm a sonar tech and have listened to merchant props and they just sound like one slapping water usually. And the sonar the depicted here was a poor representation. I hate stuff like this because it tells people is killing marine mammals while not actually talking about the physics of the sound in water and why this is happening nor do they address the measures we take in order to protect marine life. But they prefer painting the navy as the bad guy and anyone else who puts sound in water. Anyone who buys anything imported can blame themselves also. Hell part of mapping the ocean requires sonar.
@@amandawoodward5596I don't know, the several videos of divers hearing military sonar pings reverberating across the sea floor sound pretty dang loud, and I know it's a lot more intense in person.
this is a joke
I wish it was, but this is something rlly serious
The hundreds of videos where divers are videoing when hearing a sonar ping say differently. It's loud enough to damage hearing and internal organs.