They just say Nug and Fug over and over. Damn racist, homophobic whales. Or we decide they have rights... and we give them the right to vote... but they all just vote for Trump.... Someone's got to do something about these damn whales! Lol just kidding. Dems would "harvest" all those whale in ballots. 110% for Biden.
Like the gorilla who spoke sign language and told us to save the earth before it’s too late. And that nature and animals are all watching and waiting for us to help.
@@fewezt6012 A twenty minute limit on conversations with fish. The law was expanded to include whales back in 1874. The moral of the story? Never assume a UA-cam comment is factual.
Just wait until the Japanese get ahold of this technology. It could make their hunts so much simpler if they could just say, "Come over her my child," in the voice of a whale's mother.
~ Agreed ~ The Taiji Dolphins slaughter and their so called biological Whale slaughter ~ They care nothing for the Oceans as they rape them every day of these beautiful Cetaceans ~ @@ElAteoMexicano Vegan for the Animals ~ mgfⓋ ~ #veganfortheanimals #stopeatinganimals #foodsgrownnotborn
Except we DO mean them harm. We hunted them to the edge of extinction and still do. We imprison them in theme parks. They accidentally get caught in our nets.
from what i know about whales is their personalities as individuals vary about as wide as humans, for inter species communication to work we need to “talk” to whales who are interested in communicating with us too.
It makes it easier because some whale species DO have SYNTAX. So if we use AI programs like chat gpt, it can help translate their calls. Many whale and dolphin species arent just your regular animal, they might have higher intelligence. @danzigvssartre
So it's not translated for us to understand? Also, because I meow at my cat, doesn't mean I can communicate with it. Let's say that I was able to communicate with it, it will question me about food, and why XYZ, and stuff like that.
Remarkable, 20 minutes of greeting one another. Maybe next time the NOAA… who is apparently the Arbiter of communicating with whales.. will let them greet each other for a little bit more reasonable timeframe of 30 minutes..
Researchers have 20-minute "talk" with whale in the wild 0308am 25.12.23 hear what they actually say, perhaps? i think our marine biologist has been at the funny fags (the mary anna) again... HAPPY XMAS.
A 50-year-old film comes to mind called Close Encounters of the Third Kind. How come it took 50 more years to fathom? And they still have no idea what they're saying or what is being said. These ocean beings process thousands of bits of information per minute and we've known this for decades upon decades. Just like the killer whales. But then again we have no idea why they are crushing boats and upset. As far as AI and extraterrestrials, we are like tiny microbial Life playing in a sandbox without a clue of what is bigger than us.
Long ago I read a little known Arthur C. Clarke book "Dolphin Island." This type of communication ( with Dolphins) was a major part of the story. It was an early YA Sci-fi story that was really quite intriguing.
It goes to show just how much animals understand what we are saying and its only the matter of developing to change what sounds they make into words after all words are just sounds that we gave meaning too
The company is called cetia, and they take donations, please consider donating because things like this will most likely be cut from the federal budget in the near future.
I too converse with my cats in cat language. Animals are smart, and they have diverse personality too. Some of them are psycho but most of them are good.
@@Honey-Sanchez yes, animals actually understand human language if theyve been around long enough. Statement that says otherwise is pseudoscience. Even a brainless cell or virus that has no neurons are capable performing inteligent tasks. There are bunch videos of cats and dogs having conversations with their owners using talking buttons.
Researchers have 20-minute "talk" with whale in the wild 0306AM 25.12.23 sounded like a Stockhausen composition... i think the whale said: plums are dear!!! and can you get me some fries and a pizza whilst yer out?
really, no explanation on how it works? are they just playing whale noises and the whale is making noises back at them? do they have any way of understanding what they, or the whales, are saying? if so, how? if not, how is this a breakthrough, and how is it any different to me imitating the noises my dog makes? these are important details that just got brushed to the side as though we're supposed to just know.
here's what they did ua-cam.com/video/qqk8NZ_HYNw/v-deo.html Basically just played a sound and the whale responded with the same sound. They think it's a way to greet each other as whales.
Dude they weren't speaking English to them 😂 they have been observed communicating in their own way, and this was most likely a greeting. There is no "hi" because we made that word up dawg. However, the intention behind it is observed across the animal kingdom. Cats for example absolutely have a way of greeting each other, but as humans, we can sum that up to being akin to saying, "Hello." It's when I write that down and you read it however, that you may assume this to be a literal way to say hello, though it's not that simple. Think about it a little more broadly.
Ok, don’t all animals communicate. 😑 you literally just copied a whale sound and of course the whale responds back with it. But, i feel like underwater creatures responds in frequency. That’s just my take… I’d experiment in that rather than replicating whale sounds for a response from them. That’s like me saying to my cat “meow” 100 times and the cat responds back by saying meow also.
Good point i think the progressive aspect of this communication is having an idea what each whale sound means in english. Its like learning a diff language & then speaking that to communicate with another person, they will answer back due to u speaking in a language THEY understand but the important fact is that you understand them BACK. Thats y its so innovative & fascinating. I dont think whales will ever speak a human language but if we can figure out how their sounds translate to one of ours it can bridge a communication gap.
No communication and language is different, dogs can’t tell another dog “there is a cat on the next block to the left” as they dont understand more than we do they have happy and aggressive noises but not like this, this whale is talking witch many scientists up until this study thought was just a human thing. Like they said “hey my name is”
@@proudlywild1491 Yes, other animals have sounds to communicate but not proper languages. There are four things that is required for a language to be language. There's a video on it and it's really interesting. I'll find it
You may wish to get ahold of a copy of "Thousand Mile Song" and its CD of Humpback whale songs. It will blow your mind, or, at least, it has amazed me for many years, with and without MJ. Save the Whales!
Whales have alot to teach us.❤ Its high time we realize for all our technology we are perhaps not the wisest species. Smartest meh, wisest nope! But the whale!? What wisdom do they keep in their brains thrice the size of ours!!
I'm guessing e doing that because whales and dolphins are very smart and we might start a war. That sounds a little wild but we don't truly know what theyre capable of
Because whales and dolphins been smart and Communicate with each other via frequencies our ape brains cant telepathically understand but I think a big reason is because these animals can spill the beans on Atlantis 🧜♀️
the way the US developed their tank's armor is by FIRST developing the armaments as priority. so they find all new ways of ground breaking method to make an armament more effective against armor, and then, they go to develop an armor that could handle that type of armament threat. after they managed to make the responding armor, they back developing the armament to DEFEAT that newly answer of armor. after they get the munition answer to solve that new armor, they go back to developing the ARMOR to be able to withstand that new advance munition, and repeat. if russia wonder why the US armors tech is so advanced compare to russian. they dont develop military techs based on BELIEFS. that method, worth copying. this is the same pattern for developing all their other military tech. they come up with ground breaking of something, and then go trying to find something to defeat that, after finding a way to defeat it, they improve more on the corresponding tech to respond to that solution, and so on.
Actually, the more we discover things about them, the more we realise that we have many things in common. We are animals after all, mammals species are closely related. The worst bias was to think our spicie was above the others and so special.
I think its the way the information is presented here, specifically with the speaker bringing up ideas and wishes of conversations that are of course, very human. When they're actually studying and trying to apply the whale language, they most certainly understand our natural bias and work to exclude it.
So they played whale sounds and the whale made sounds back? I don’t know. Seems pretty expected. It probably thought it was another whale. Humans desperately need attention from anywhere it can get it.
Dawg just go look into the actual work being done behind the scenes. You're on a run of the mill news channel. Don't expect an actual breakdown of what's going on here. This is about an general and dumbed down as this information can get. Just saying before you comment some shid like this, go look into it more so you don't lead other people like you to start hating a project by making it look stupid. That's a net negative for everyone.
Also, scientists and archeologists have absolutely overstepped their boundaries before just because they want to learn or get something so bad. It's a balance, and also the first amendment is a terrible argument here. These are other species entirely, with their own lives. We're in their territory now, and upmost caution should absolutely be used.
Sorry the difference is this whale is using complex grammar and meaning it’s not a sound it’s language, like English, like how you go to the vet and ur dog can’t tell you what’s wrong, this whale could say “my left flipper hurts at the tip, please be careful” this was a scientific breakthrough and paved miles for animal rights, proving that some highly intelligent animals like apes, citations and possibly corvids have a brain complex enough for such things
@AnTiThesis-HaT-HoT bruz they spoke whale what are you talking about?? Besides, what does a language from species to species have to do with anything???
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
What a multi-talented guy! Marine biologist, whale communicator, delivers presents to children around the world...
If those whales are as smart as people say, they're going to have some pretty harsh things to say to us
They just say Nug and Fug over and over. Damn racist, homophobic whales. Or we decide they have rights... and we give them the right to vote... but they all just vote for Trump.... Someone's got to do something about these damn whales!
Lol just kidding. Dems would "harvest" all those whale in ballots. 110% for Biden.
Like the gorilla who spoke sign language and told us to save the earth before it’s too late. And that nature and animals are all watching and waiting for us to help.
@@n0bl3k1ng2 source?
@@n0bl3k1ng2 where is you see that?
@@n0bl3k1ng2wasn‘t it fake
“Hi! How are you?”
“I’m whale, and you?”
😂
This checks out 😂
Niceeee
🐋:hi
👩🔬:hi
🐋:what the fu-
👩🔬:ik it’s crazy right!
Who put a 20 minute limit on conversations with whales??
Bureaucrats
It’s been on the books in Kansas for 150 years.
@@TheRealMake-Makewhat has?
@@fewezt6012 A twenty minute limit on conversations with fish. The law was expanded to include whales back in 1874. The moral of the story? Never assume a UA-cam comment is factual.
They reached the Chat GPT data limit
Humans: Hi
Whale: Why the f$@% are you destroying the ocean?
I just like the idea of them knowing we don't mean them any harm and are friendly. I hope some day we can have actual back and forth convos with them.
Just wait until the Japanese get ahold of this technology. It could make their hunts so much simpler if they could just say, "Come over her my child," in the voice of a whale's mother.
~ Agreed ~ The Taiji Dolphins slaughter and their so called biological Whale slaughter ~ They care nothing for the Oceans as they rape them every day of these beautiful Cetaceans ~ @@ElAteoMexicano Vegan for the Animals ~ mgfⓋ ~ #veganfortheanimals #stopeatinganimals #foodsgrownnotborn
@@ElAteoMexicano ah yes, man-made horrors beyond my comprehension
Simply no. Your type are bad and will exploit them. Just know that you're required to give them rights if they can communicate with you.
Except we DO mean them harm. We hunted them to the edge of extinction and still do. We imprison them in theme parks. They accidentally get caught in our nets.
from what i know about whales is their personalities as individuals vary about as wide as humans, for inter species communication to work we need to “talk” to whales who are interested in communicating with us too.
Maybe that whale was on ORCA tv news that night for her epic conversation with humans.
So they talked to a female whale, then ghosted her? Nice
😂😂😂😂
Lol
They didnt want to they were made to large difference
She got fo kids wit free diffnt daddys, wouldn’t u?
Hi , Hi
Hi , Hi
Hi, Hi
Hi, Hi
What a conversation!!!!!!!
Hahahahahahahha
😆🤕😬🤣
To be fair they did put conversation in quotations.
In humpback, “hi” can mean “hello”or it can mean “fish” or it can mean just about any other thing that the whale wants it to mean.
It makes it easier because some whale species DO have SYNTAX. So if we use AI programs like chat gpt, it can help translate their calls. Many whale and dolphin species arent just your regular animal, they might have higher intelligence. @danzigvssartre
I'd like to ask a whale about an existential question
Noooooo
NOOOOO
If we don’t know they don’t know. They’re mammals and we are mammals
I mean good luck figuring out how to create a existential question in whale language
To swim or not to swim
So it's not translated for us to understand? Also, because I meow at my cat, doesn't mean I can communicate with it.
Let's say that I was able to communicate with it, it will question me about food, and why XYZ, and stuff like that.
That's what I was looking for. I want to know if there was mutual information exchange, or if it just responded to sound mimicry.
That whale will have an epic conversation topic with other whale someday
Where’s the full transcript for the convo?
"hi
-"hi"
"fish?"
-"fish"
"So have you heard of our marine lord and savior, Fishus Chris?"
-"Nah, fuck that, I'm leaving"
Whale cursing them for not saying nothing but HI while she leaves
ive actually been following the research thats been put into communication with whales. its a great feeling to see success, even from other people!
That sounded much more like the whale saying: "WtF, hahahaha, you talk, but only nonsense."
It's crazy there's an actual law that you can get fined or arrested for talking with them.
Makes you wonder what they dont want us to learn from the whales
?
They could be completely bull shitting us and we wouldn’t know 😂😂
First whale to talk to humans, that was a good day for her I think
Yeah right.
The main question that everyone wants to ask is WHAT THE HELL DID THEY TALK ABOUT with the whales.
How about reporting on that?
Remarkable, 20 minutes of greeting one another.
Maybe next time the NOAA… who is apparently the Arbiter of communicating with whales.. will let them greet each other for a little bit more reasonable timeframe of 30 minutes..
We don't want to do too much when we barely know what we're doing. Slow baby steps.
@@Gnomezonbacon it's 2024!
Would be interesting to see what they do actually say
Researchers have 20-minute "talk" with whale in the wild 0308am 25.12.23 hear what they actually say, perhaps? i think our marine biologist has been at the funny fags (the mary anna) again... HAPPY XMAS.
To be fair, most of my conservations are about as good as that.
Hi
the "Hi" conversation for 20 minutes reminds me my dates..
A 50-year-old film comes to mind called Close Encounters of the Third Kind. How come it took 50 more years to fathom? And they still have no idea what they're saying or what is being said. These ocean beings process thousands of bits of information per minute and we've known this for decades upon decades. Just like the killer whales. But then again we have no idea why they are crushing boats and upset. As far as AI and extraterrestrials, we are like tiny microbial Life playing in a sandbox without a clue of what is bigger than us.
Long ago I read a little known Arthur C. Clarke book "Dolphin Island." This type of communication ( with Dolphins) was a major part of the story. It was an early YA Sci-fi story that was really quite intriguing.
@@judyferraz7271 Thank you. I'm going to look for that book 😊
Are you talking about the killer whales breaking boats?
They thought it was funny, basically. The keel-breaking turned out to be play behaviour.
@@theneef174 Sure. That's why it was abnormal behavior that certainly had nothing to do with one of them having been recently injured. Just playing 😒
That 20 minute prank call to your mom was not ok
Woof 😭
Whale: “You look nothing like your profile pic!”…
We should wonder why they limit the conversation and why it's I illegal to communicate with dolphins and whales
Wtf are they hiding from us
Some thing that’s for sure
So we don’t accidentally mess with their migration patterns.
Scientists can talk to whales better than I can talk to humans
You could try making whale sounds and see if it attracts any of you preferred sex.
It goes to show just how much animals understand what we are saying and its only the matter of developing to change what sounds they make into words after all words are just sounds that we gave meaning too
Did we name her Twain or did she introduce herself?
What interesting about that because at some point they will be able to tell us. They definitely have sounds for names.
Her real name is chitter chitter chirp squeal squeal for two minutes chitter.
that whale is gonna have the best story to tell its kids
The company is called cetia, and they take donations, please consider donating because things like this will most likely be cut from the federal budget in the near future.
Totally incredible! I would love to know what they have to say.
I too converse with my cats in cat language. Animals are smart, and they have diverse personality too. Some of them are psycho but most of them are good.
Same with humans lol
Cat language is very simple in fact they don’t even have a ‘language area’ they just use their prefrontal cortex, whales have this brain structure
@@Honey-Sanchez yes, animals actually understand human language if theyve been around long enough. Statement that says otherwise is pseudoscience. Even a brainless cell or virus that has no neurons are capable performing inteligent tasks. There are bunch videos of cats and dogs having conversations with their owners using talking buttons.
sorry but.. no, you absolutely are not. Body language of course, but cat language?
"so long and thanks for all the fish"
Researchers have 20-minute "talk" with whale in the wild 0306AM 25.12.23 sounded like a Stockhausen composition... i think the whale said: plums are dear!!! and can you get me some fries and a pizza whilst yer out?
Human: Hi
Whale: Hei
Human: Are you Norwegian?
Whale: Ja
It's time we gave whales personhood status and protections.
What can they contribute to society
How often are there misunderstandings between people speaking the same language? This should go well
Pov: my door at 3am in the morning
Ask them if they can decode radio signals with their minds
How would we explain opposable thumbs and hands to them?
Douglas Adams would have been very interested in this development
How is this different to me saying, “meow” to my cat? Yes, she says “meow” back to me, but then again she never shuts up with the damn “meows”. 😂
Whales and Dolphin are extremely smart to the point where they even have their own language, vocabulary, and even grammar.
Twian probably thought she was catfished.
really, no explanation on how it works? are they just playing whale noises and the whale is making noises back at them? do they have any way of understanding what they, or the whales, are saying? if so, how? if not, how is this a breakthrough, and how is it any different to me imitating the noises my dog makes?
these are important details that just got brushed to the side as though we're supposed to just know.
They've been working on ChatGPT for whales for over 2 years now.
here's what they did ua-cam.com/video/qqk8NZ_HYNw/v-deo.html
Basically just played a sound and the whale responded with the same sound. They think it's a way to greet each other as whales.
Can they maybe affix something to the world’s loneliest whale to allow it to speak to and locate other whales finally?
I don’t think whales know Wht hi is or any vocabulary that us humans have
Dude they weren't speaking English to them 😂 they have been observed communicating in their own way, and this was most likely a greeting. There is no "hi" because we made that word up dawg. However, the intention behind it is observed across the animal kingdom. Cats for example absolutely have a way of greeting each other, but as humans, we can sum that up to being akin to saying, "Hello." It's when I write that down and you read it however, that you may assume this to be a literal way to say hello, though it's not that simple. Think about it a little more broadly.
For anyone out there, you can get shelf stable ramen inserts (e.g. dehydrated veggies, fish cake, etc.). Just add it and boogie.
Please, issue them with a warning about Japan's criminal activities in Antartica as soon as possible. Thanks!
Ground breaking
These people sound crazy lol
Ok, don’t all animals communicate. 😑 you literally just copied a whale sound and of course the whale responds back with it.
But, i feel like underwater creatures responds in frequency. That’s just my take…
I’d experiment in that rather than replicating whale sounds for a response from them.
That’s like me saying to my cat “meow” 100 times and the cat responds back by saying meow also.
Good point i think the progressive aspect of this communication is having an idea what each whale sound means in english. Its like learning a diff language & then speaking that to communicate with another person, they will answer back due to u speaking in a language THEY understand but the important fact is that you understand them BACK. Thats y its so innovative & fascinating. I dont think whales will ever speak a human language but if we can figure out how their sounds translate to one of ours it can bridge a communication gap.
No communication and language is different, dogs can’t tell another dog “there is a cat on the next block to the left” as they dont understand more than we do they have happy and aggressive noises but not like this, this whale is talking witch many scientists up until this study thought was just a human thing. Like they said “hey my name is”
@@proudlywild1491 Yes, other animals have sounds to communicate but not proper languages. There are four things that is required for a language to be language. There's a video on it and it's really interesting. I'll find it
Look into the research going on behind this and leading up to this. You'll understand then why it's different.
“Help, I’m in great pain Morty”
Wubalubadubdub
Umm what did she say??
It was literally just a greeting.
If all it was just Hi and Hi back and forth.
Does it not imply that the whale was probably just recreating your sounds?
So why does the "weather monitoring" "administration" get to tell researchers they only get to talk to whales for 20 minutes?
laws
You may wish to get ahold of a copy of "Thousand Mile Song" and its CD of Humpback whale songs. It will blow your mind, or, at least, it has amazed me for many years, with and without MJ. Save the Whales!
Whales have alot to teach us.❤ Its high time we realize for all our technology we are perhaps not the wisest species. Smartest meh, wisest nope! But the whale!? What wisdom do they keep in their brains thrice the size of ours!!
Why is it illegal to try and communicate with a whale?
I'm guessing e doing that because whales and dolphins are very smart and we might start a war. That sounds a little wild but we don't truly know what theyre capable of
Because whales and dolphins been smart and Communicate with each other via frequencies our ape brains cant telepathically understand but I think a big reason is because these animals can spill the beans on Atlantis 🧜♀️
@@lemonkid2543 "ape brains" 😂
@lemonkid2543 Jesus , its medication time dawg 😂
Ah yes, one more step for Big Tech to develop The Anti-Christ.
This is silly. I have longer talks with my birds! AI? God only knows. The whales might sink more boats now! 😂
the way the US developed their tank's armor is by FIRST developing the armaments as priority. so they find all new ways of ground breaking method to make an armament more effective against armor, and then, they go to develop an armor that could handle that type of armament threat.
after they managed to make the responding armor, they back developing the armament to DEFEAT that newly answer of armor.
after they get the munition answer to solve that new armor, they go back to developing the ARMOR to be able to withstand that new advance munition, and repeat. if russia wonder why the US armors tech is so advanced compare to russian. they dont develop military techs based on BELIEFS.
that method, worth copying.
this is the same pattern for developing all their other military tech. they come up with ground breaking of something, and then go trying to find something to defeat that, after finding a way to defeat it, they improve more on the corresponding tech to respond to that solution, and so on.
Well it worked in Star Trek.
I have always loved and relied on mountain house for my expeditions. Frankly I could eat their chicken and rice until the end of eternity.
Instead of this nonesence ,can we listen to the actual conversation?
Soooo is anybody gonna tell us what the friggin whale said!!!?
The whales ran out of minutes.
I'm pretty sure the whales said to f)k off...
That's a bias. We tend to humanize animals.
Random guy on the internet knows more than scientists
Actually, the more we discover things about them, the more we realise that we have many things in common. We are animals after all, mammals species are closely related. The worst bias was to think our spicie was above the others and so special.
I think its the way the information is presented here, specifically with the speaker bringing up ideas and wishes of conversations that are of course, very human. When they're actually studying and trying to apply the whale language, they most certainly understand our natural bias and work to exclude it.
They want to get their vote.
The records show they already voted for Biden
Doctor dolittle😂😂😂😂 hilarious absolutely hilarious hahaha ha ha ha
Dope
If the whale 🐳 was smart they will not have any talk for them human
My ex could of interpreted for you, she is part whale her self
So they played whale sounds and the whale made sounds back? I don’t know. Seems pretty expected. It probably thought it was another whale. Humans desperately need attention from anywhere it can get it.
Dawg just go look into the actual work being done behind the scenes. You're on a run of the mill news channel. Don't expect an actual breakdown of what's going on here. This is about an general and dumbed down as this information can get. Just saying before you comment some shid like this, go look into it more so you don't lead other people like you to start hating a project by making it look stupid. That's a net negative for everyone.
nope
Communicating with ocean mammals is illegal? That is a violation of the first amendment.
Also, scientists and archeologists have absolutely overstepped their boundaries before just because they want to learn or get something so bad. It's a balance, and also the first amendment is a terrible argument here. These are other species entirely, with their own lives. We're in their territory now, and upmost caution should absolutely be used.
I would have continue the convo....why stop there
25 million dollars for hi hi hi hi hi
Yea that's one way to look at it...
We are in 2024 so far no break through in communicating with women
2021? Didn't gpt come out in 2022-23? Lying on porpoise
Pretty cool...!
A whale is not a fish and you’re not funny…
Damn so finding Nemo was on point lol
That’s what I was thinking lol.
Beautiful 🎉god bless god
Morning?😅
20 minutes later scientist realizes he's not playing whale voices but a Joe Biden speech.
She is saying human are annoying
😎🇺🇸🏴☠️🧜 I Bet That They’re Saying…”Please America…Vote Republican 🎉🎉🎉”
Suleiman🔥🔥🔥
Wow
This is what your tax dollars are going to. Trump please
I'd pay for this 10 times over.
I bark at my dog and my dog barks back. Waste of tax dollars
Sorry the difference is this whale is using complex grammar and meaning it’s not a sound it’s language, like English, like how you go to the vet and ur dog can’t tell you what’s wrong, this whale could say “my left flipper hurts at the tip, please be careful” this was a scientific breakthrough and paved miles for animal rights, proving that some highly intelligent animals like apes, citations and possibly corvids have a brain complex enough for such things
whales have big brains - larger than human brains, actually
All animal will talk ,, Mohammed (s) Leader said us .. 1500 years ago
..
Oh god, the Whales think we all speak American-English!
Is this a joke?
@@SaltyAsTheSea No, it’s a tragedy.
@AnTiThesis-HaT-HoT bruz they spoke whale what are you talking about?? Besides, what does a language from species to species have to do with anything???
So are whales going to have ocean rights no humans in water or we eat you