He is the commander in chief and has full authority to declassify any documents. He did just that. It's Biden who stole documents as Vice President. He doesn't have any authority to do so. He wasn't president at the time.
True. Hence Arthur Tony Schwart's biggest life regret was ghost writing the Art of The Deal giving the impression that Donald Trump was a great business man as he bankrupted millions he inherited and cheated his niece and nephew out of, as well as his failed casino, etc. He said that he wrote it for money, had no idea Trump would run for President, that asking DJT to write it was like asking him to read a book which he can not. Hence, his professor said DJT was the dumbest student that he ever taught; he does not represent their Wharton Business College. Hence, Cohn threatened and had DJT's grades sealed. How do educated people allow a con man to lead them and attack others for him?
They are also private citizens and voters - entitled to their own political beliefs. They are supposed to read the Constitution and apply the law(s) in question through the lens of the text of the Constitution as originally written and intended and American history. They're finally doing the right thing. You people just don't like the decisions they hand down. You want activist judges to read into the Constitution rights and powers that aren't there. Crybaby whiners...! 🤣🤣🤣
Whoever the MSBBC moderator is, respectfully, please do not interrupt the experts. Their opinion is what we want. Not your parsing what they say as they say it.
@@jcbell-dh1bmLol the guy who thinks you're a sucker and a loser? You can bet he and his party will do what they can to strip you of any remaining benefits. They don't care if you die on the streets, friend.
I strongly recommend reading Sotomayor's dissent. She lays bare the majority's complete abandonment of the text of the Constitution. This is bad. Virtually everything a president does can be characterized as an official act with a little legal creativity. I think Biden should consider a few official acts of his own. I don't want to hear another word about "textualist" or "originalist" philosophy from these hypocrites.
No she didn't, I don't think she read the ruling because she missed this completely. From the ruling: Quote "The immunity the Court has recognized therefore extends to the “outer perimeter” of the President’s official responsibilities, covering actions so long as they are “not manifestly or palpably beyond [his] authority.”
As president then, imprisoning six justices would be an "official act". This is not something I condone but this is what their decision allows and this scenario highlights its stupidity and ramifications.
OP is saying that if a president was corrupt enough and had enough people in his administration willing to rubber stamp jailing his opponents as an official act there would be no legal consequences as he’s immune
Or insisting they sit before Congressional Ethics Committee and answer questions about bribery, affiliations etc If they refuse they lose their seat VOTE VOTE VOTE 💙💙💙💙
Yeah this is what happens when people put leader before country and rule of law, Trump has fooled and manipulated so many people into turning their back on democratic institutions and the rule of law, this is how authoritarianism grows and blossoms
Katy has a duty to facilitate the conversation to make sure it down't run over time, so she has to fit all her question into a certain time allotment, which would require interrupting.
This is absolutely disgusting. It feels a lot like the beginning of the end of the United States of America to me. Sounds dramatic I know but the writing seems to be on the wall
End of our United Stared is not end of a preferred political party, it will affect All of us. End of All political party. Do not be fooled. Trump has fooled so many that they look like dead man walking.
BUT, the Dems have forever ignored the power of the courts while the GOP has spent millions and decades stacking the judges in their favor at all levels.
@@dmgsara You have to have more democratic senators voted into office in the US capital in order for that to be accomplished. Republicans aren’t going to vote in more judges just because they’re nominated. Get out and vote if you want something to change for the better instead of losing our democracy!
Here are a bunch of questions: Does the supreme court decision mean there is no longer such a thing as "high crimes" for the president so impeachment is also out of bounds? Can the current president remove the corrupt supreme court justices, the six that said it was okay? This doesn't make any sense but perhaps there is a way to say it is an official act. If the current president doesn't act, and the previous president wins can that person just stop obeying the rule of law and declare that elections are too corrupt so they can be cancelled? Again - this makes no sense. We are a country of laws and if one person no longer needs to follow the laws, then it's all broken. Actually - why doesn't the current president just cancel the election? Official act. (I think this is stupid, but is it allowed?)
Ladies and gentlemen, just vote. The Supreme Court kept the door open for this entire case to be thrown out essentially. Don’t depend on the government to do what you can control.
No, they've (the 6 conservative leaning members of the court) have done everything they can to obstruct the cases from going forward, we should have been well into the DC and Florida cases by May
@@telebubba5527 “pressuring” his Vp, Mike Pence… to do what, to not certify the election? Jamie Raskins first act in Congress entailed standing in the capital pleading with then VP Joe Biden to not certify the 2016 election. Countless other Dems did the same thing. Claims the election was stolen, Trump was illegitimate… Russia Russia. Democrats denied the outcome of the 2016 election based upon Hillary’s lies. It resulted in thousands of liberals tearing apart the capital during Trump’s inauguration. Look it up… the imagery alone, could have been taken from J6 but guess it was no big deal unless it involved Trump?
@@davidweinknecht9713no they threw it back to lower court to waste more time. Lower court has to home hearing and send it back to them for more delays
Always remember that one of the reasons we started this country is because the founding fathers didn’t like the idea of a leader of a country not being accountable for their actions. Only back then they didn’t call it presidential immunity, they called it divine right
And now every country with King Charles as head-of-State is a full Democracy, while the "United" States has been a FLAWED one since 2017. Just letting everybody know...
I was considering posting the same. Katy Tur trying to finish sentences of the guests is short sighted, to put it diplomatically. Katy destroyed the whole segment.
Biden has nothing to lose by doing so and is doing the US a grave disservice by not using these new king like powers. One thing is for sure, Trump will use them. Why isn't ever American in the streets protesting, this is pretty bad.
Revisionist justices overturning Roe vs Wade. And now this disgusting interpretation of the constitution. Shakespeare alluded to these foils and follies of human nature whereby "Fair is foul and foul is fair." Thanks to these greedy & power tripping justices the laws are now burried in a world of ××××! The people will be the victims.
Yes. Doesn't make it right but if a president is acting in their official duties then thats it. What comes after doesn't matter if they can couch it in officiality
The fact that this statement was written down shows these people don't even understand positions in government, and at this point, it's a waste of time. It's been 8 years, and you still think the same. Idc that you are this dumb
Don’t worry, the lower courts will absolutely clarify what is official acts and what is private acts. So he will still be held accountable for some of his criminal acts.👍🏾
Okay millions funneled to the Bidens from China and Ukraine, thats perfectly fine. Biden used his office to persecute Trump since day 1, Hilary said Trumps term as president was illegitimate, and the debate proved 100% what everyone has been saying about Bidens mental health.
Not only she does that all the time her coworkers like Joy Reid,Chris Hayes, and all the other anchors Rachel Meadow,and company with them its interrupt,interrupt,.
America is not a democracy, but if it were it died in 2008 when America elected an Arab shortly after Muslims attacked the World Trade Centers and killed over 3,000 Americans. That was when I knew America was over. Where have you been? You watched people jumping to their death to avoid burning to death after begging first responders to please save them, yet you voted for an Activist Muslim In Chief in my great Christian country called the USA, and you want me to believe that because the Supreme Court simply put in writing that we have to honor the Presidents already due powers as stated in the Constitution that somehow we've lost our democracy? Just quit commenting, please!
The idea of giving nine people, who often have shown less integrity than Mobsters, life time appointment is simply absurd. This is the court that has ruled: 1) That Bribery (Campaign Contribution) is legal and is Freedom Of Speech. 2) That Corporations are people and can give unlimited Bribes. 3) That Non-profit outfits can provide Bribes for political figures without revealing the names of the people who are providing the Bribes. 4) That the people who use Brand name meds have legal protection for side effects, but the majority of people who use the Generics, have no protection. 5) That a bunch of old men in different states can decide about women health and reproductive rights. So, don't expect anything positive from such corrupt court.
🤡 Maybe the demorats can jail their political opponents they can't defeat with a scorching "insumerectionist racist mattress tag removal" indictment 😂😂
To be clear, it's not all 9 who have integrity issues. To date, we clearly see Alito and Thomas are compromised by bribes and Alito has shown demonstrable non-judge like impartiality.
If the Supreme Court ruling is to be followed, hypothetically, he could declare that Donald Trump is a clear and present danger to the national security of the United States of America. And use the powers of the office to protect this country from that threat.
@@Pacific981 convictions and judgments prove he's not above the law but i understand why people think he is. His attempts always look like successes. Trump said it best, "Nobody cares about what's real! It's what they believe that counts!".
Why not? They are currently sitting Justices in the Supreme Court. Judgment is their job. Of course, you only think that because your side doesn't benefit.
It doesn't work like that. Court packing is not a solution because the other side will do it just the same as soon as they're in power. That would politicize the court.
theoretically or practically, what should a president do if he thinks opposition cheated? Officially he could order an investigation. Unofficially he can state what he believes. Anyway everybody should leave the left
Don't worry the Democrats are trying to wipe that out with all the immigrants in sanctuary cities in those Democrats States electoral process away from us cuz that's what it's doing and that's the plan too
Thank Carter, Obama, Bush, Clinton, and Biden for that, they are against America, not for it. You have been lied to by those cretins for so many times. If you hate America, then leave. I'm anti-stupidity btw, not anti-american.
and thank you Supreme Court for all the delays, and thank you RNC for all the money you've thrown into a dictator's pocket, and thank you all the judges like Aileen Cannon for all the decisions with no actual basis in law, and thank you to every voter who can't tell the difference between lies and reality and who actually desire a Dictatorial President. There are a lot of "thank yous" to go around.
All i gotta say is that its pretty obvious what is going on! So get ready for November people! They showing you that there are different strokes for different folks!
All of you calling for violence remember that when/if your party loses your opponents can/will do the same. Leaders using government resources to eliminate competition is 3rd world banna republic nonsense.
The Supreme Court, has called it , too close to the wire to fascism , for my comfort . And now , it is going to mean , trumpy , will more than likely , never face any accountability , and consequences for his treasonous crimes against our country . And we could too easily be stuck with a dictator , with the title of president , who will be president for life . Trumpy was very much loving how kim jon uns people treated their dear leader . And the giant military parades in north korea , russia and china . And said maybe we should try this president for life stuff . BUT I THINK HE HAS HAD TOO MUCH POWER ALREADY . AND TOO MUCH TAX PAYER MONEY FOR HIS TRAITOROUS CRIMES .
He was the presidents. Try not to listen to msnbc or cnn. go read the full ruling i think its over 100 pages and decide for yourself or you can watch "Watching the Watchers on youtube". he is reading the ruling right now
Well, that's exactly why the SCOTUS kicked it back... they didn't even read the law or even try to allege it wasn't an official. If there was even a possible chance that there was electoral foul play, any and all Presidents should take action to review these.
People need to vote in huge numbers. Make sure you are registered to vote. Check your registration - make sure it's up to date and active. In Texas you must be registered 30 days before the election.
Doesn't this supreme court ruling give Biden absolute immunity to cancel the election and remain in power, in fear of trump destroying it? Official act.
Nope Trump 24 all the way 🎉🎉🎉🎉 we the people will speak very loudly in November, at least the ones who can see things for themselves and those who can use their brains for themselves. Not those who hear and believe everything they hear without researching it.
"The relationship between the President and the people he serves has shifted irrevocably. In every use of official power, the President is now a king above the law." Justice Sonia Sotomayor More urgent need to elect the Democratic ticket top to bottom.
There are two separate sets of law in this country. The one for the average person and those for the rich and powerful.
@@Projectcloning21098 convictions and judgments
🎯
One for republican office holders and one for everyone elsr
U left out shop lifters
Always have been. We're just getting around to codifying it into law.
Stealing classified documents after his term ended is not an official act!
He declassified them
He is the commander in chief and has full authority to declassify any documents. He did just that. It's Biden who stole documents as Vice President. He doesn't have any authority to do so. He wasn't president at the time.
Tell that to
Vice President Joe Biden!
@MrDucksBill because he just think about it and they becomes declassified
Not bye the rules he didn't.@@MrDucksBill
Disgrace, simply a Disgrace the judicial system is.
Cry some more. Lol
What a win for democracy. The system is reasserting itself slowly but surely
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
The DOJ is a joke, letting Biden get away with all the crimes he and his son commited and Trump gets sandwiched with all the stupid witch hunt.
True. Hence Arthur Tony Schwart's biggest life regret was ghost writing the Art of The Deal giving the impression that Donald Trump was a great business man as he bankrupted millions he inherited and cheated his niece and nephew out of, as well as his failed casino, etc. He said that he wrote it for money, had no idea Trump would run for President, that asking DJT to write it was like asking him to read a book which he can not. Hence, his professor said DJT was the dumbest student that he ever taught; he does not represent their Wharton Business College. Hence, Cohn threatened and had DJT's grades sealed. How do educated people allow a con man to lead them and attack others for him?
Can anyone explain why supreme court justices even have a political affiliation at all? How fkn impartial are they even attempting to be?
Their human and any human can be bought.
They are also private citizens and voters - entitled to their own political beliefs. They are supposed to read the Constitution and apply the law(s) in question through the lens of the text of the Constitution as originally written and intended and American history. They're finally doing the right thing. You people just don't like the decisions they hand down. You want activist judges to read into the Constitution rights and powers that aren't there. Crybaby whiners...! 🤣🤣🤣
If official acts have corrupt intent they should still be prosecuted, for pities sake its about INTENT.
The election was stolen
The ruling states you can't use intent as evidence
Whoever the MSBBC moderator is, respectfully, please do not interrupt the experts. Their opinion is what we want. Not your parsing what they say as they say it.
They often bring in experts and interrupt. I like how no one has read it completely.
I'm an old disabled Vet on a fixed income. I can't believe what these people believe, I honestly fear for my life if Trump doesn't get back in office.
@@jcbell-dh1bmLol the guy who thinks you're a sucker and a loser? You can bet he and his party will do what they can to strip you of any remaining benefits. They don't care if you die on the streets, friend.
@@jcbell-dh1bmyour circumstances are meaningless
@@jcbell-dh1bmyou're not a veteran. STOP LYING!!!!
Si, should we presume now that Biden can activate Seal Team Six for an official act?
Ummmm, he's always been able to Einstein
According to the Supreme Court is totally legal.
If he loses the election, he should have Harris refuse to certify it. Seems OK for this horrible SCOTUS.
@@commonsenseparty1396 Good. Biden should remove all threats to America's future ASAP
Si, si! Go GI Joe Biden, Officially act to shut MAGA and SCOTUS down and save America!
What a sad messed up court system you have in America!
You won't get any argument from me.
U saw America die today. Main reason: the God damned electoral college
Yay a win for Trump is a win for democracy
You mean a court system not mirroring that of a 3rd world banana republic?
We know.
I strongly recommend reading Sotomayor's dissent. She lays bare the majority's complete abandonment of the text of the Constitution. This is bad. Virtually everything a president does can be characterized as an official act with a little legal creativity. I think Biden should consider a few official acts of his own. I don't want to hear another word about "textualist" or "originalist" philosophy from these hypocrites.
No she didn't, I don't think she read the ruling because she missed this completely.
From the ruling: Quote "The immunity the Court has recognized therefore extends to the “outer perimeter” of the President’s official responsibilities, covering actions so long as they are “not manifestly or palpably beyond [his] authority.”
That’s an interesting take. Wrong though. Even prominent Dem attorneys get it
@@AwkwardTruths Is calling a Georgia election official and asking him to "find me 11,780 votes" not “manifestly or palpably beyond [his] authority”?
@@urbangorilla33 You're not a judge and jury, stop trying to vociferate as one.
@@psychopompous3207 Weak reply. You didn't address the question or the issue. Typical of your ilk.
All of this falls directly at Mitch McConnell's feet.
Nope, all this falls at the feet of the American voter who decided that Hillary is not good enough.
Nope, all this falls at the feet of the American voter who decided that Hillary is not good enough.
McConnell could care less what any of us think
Obama, RGB
@@mosesnabea4308 The electoral college, you mean? The American people made their choice.
Mitch Mconell should be ashamed of himself….. all his fault
Be assured, he is very happy about the result.
Talk about someone that needs to put out to pasture
Maybe RGB shouldn’t have been a selfish old ghoul
Mitch is a psychopath…
1 of the only positives I can say about McConnell is he kept corrupt Garland off SCOTUS.
Supreme Court decision, officially, means , that laws and rules are elastic and bendable , it depends on who the “ criminal “ is.
For some ppl.
Bribes for pardons is now a legal act. We need an amendment to stop this ruling.
Any clue what it takes to get an amendment? Obviously not. Last one took over 200 years to ratify.
Supreme Court is a joke. They've destroyed any confidence anyone may have had in them.
@fauxque5057 Yes, but the 22nd ammendment only took 4 years. Good cherry picking of the data though.
But if the shoe was on the other foot, right?
@@tomcat8983 Democrats wouldn't be doing this crap, we have morals.
Katy we would all really like to hear your Guests finish their sentences without your continual interruptions. It’s annoying!
JUSTICE DELAYED...IS JUSTICE DENIED !
😂😂😂
@@jacobbeyer9346 nobody has ever clapped like that before...
This not the United States I immigrated in we must vote for BIDEN
Biden lied to you, he's incapable and anti-american, period.
As president then, imprisoning six justices would be an "official act".
This is not something I condone but this is what their decision allows and this scenario highlights its stupidity and ramifications.
That's not an official act.
OP is saying that if a president was corrupt enough and had enough people in his administration willing to rubber stamp jailing his opponents as an official act there would be no legal consequences as he’s immune
@@MrDucksBill
Neither were the felonies Trump’s been charged with, but he’s claiming they were.
Theirs help for u.people call 1800 cry baby they will put u in touch with a therapist
Or insisting they sit before Congressional Ethics Committee and answer questions about bribery, affiliations etc
If they refuse they lose their seat
VOTE VOTE VOTE 💙💙💙💙
Katie stop interrupting please!!!
Katie Tur, will you let that man speak!?!?!?
Bot
@@miterbenisdurty3862🙄
Oh, is that her😂
Katy Tur Let them speak!!
Yea, she’s getting all wet lol
This is not the United States I grew up in.
Your right and obummer and joey trashed it
Yeah this is what happens when people put leader before country and rule of law, Trump has fooled and manipulated so many people into turning their back on democratic institutions and the rule of law, this is how authoritarianism grows and blossoms
Trump ruined it @@dnrdufty
@@dnrduftyThere were nation wide riots by the end of Trump's term.
@@maximedamour5192 yes all caused by the left. The rest of us have jobs and no time for that nonsense
We have the power to make this nightmare stop. VOTE!!!!
Yes, end the socialist nightmare. Vote Trump.
Trump 2024
@@bubbajones4522 Define socialism for the class.
I am going to vote. But, instead of voting blue (like I have my whole life)... I'm voting for Trump.
Ummm, according to the polls now, the LESS the Dems vote the BETTER Joe does. Counter intuitive, but true.
The constant interrupting is beyond maddening. Please let your experts speak.
Katy has a duty to facilitate the conversation to make sure it down't run over time, so she has to fit all her question into a certain time allotment, which would require interrupting.
Grow a spine now dems. Time for some “official acts” of your own.
Amen take aim
Lol
Now that a president has immunity, children will never be safe around Brandon
Democrats should try to jail an ex president lol
You guys already did that remember??? Transgender men playing women’s sports
This is absolutely disgusting. It feels a lot like the beginning of the end of the United States of America to me. Sounds dramatic I know but the writing seems to be on the wall
Honestly, I'm sick to my stomach! We have a RUNAWAY CRIMINAL COURT!
Yeah you are being dramatic. It’s just the end of the reign of your preferred political party coming Nov. 5th.
@@Thatscrazy92 I guess I would just rather be dramatic than ignorant.
End of our United Stared is not end of a preferred political party, it will affect All of us. End of All political party. Do not be fooled. Trump has fooled so many that they look like dead man walking.
@@curiousuniverse438 Ignorant would be voting for a mentally declined geriatric.
The oath of office is an official act. Can he break this oath?
No disrespect but who are you referring to ?
that's an excellent point. It's sort of the heart of the case, that he in fact did break it.
Biden breaks it all the time. There is a reason for him having the lowest approval rating of any President.
At one point Donnie said that he’d never swore his oath
@@AceBadguy72 POTUS takes an oath to the people and to the Constitution. How do you knot know this..... Vlad?
The justices are kings who sit on their SCOTUS thrones until they abdicate or pass away with full bank accounts and empty souls.
Don't forget the Senators that allowed it.
BUT, the Dems have forever ignored the power of the courts while the GOP has spent millions and decades stacking the judges in their favor at all levels.
Expand the court immediately. Bring onboard additional justices. If anyone complains too bad
@@dmgsara You have to have more democratic senators voted into office in the US capital in order for that to be accomplished. Republicans aren’t going to vote in more judges just because they’re nominated. Get out and vote if you want something to change for the better instead of losing our democracy!
But y'all would pat them on the back if they didn't grand immunity. Sorry, but your liberal tears don't change the law. 😂😂😂
Katy Tur, please stop interrupting.
Here are a bunch of questions: Does the supreme court decision mean there is no longer such a thing as "high crimes" for the president so impeachment is also out of bounds? Can the current president remove the corrupt supreme court justices, the six that said it was okay? This doesn't make any sense but perhaps there is a way to say it is an official act. If the current president doesn't act, and the previous president wins can that person just stop obeying the rule of law and declare that elections are too corrupt so they can be cancelled? Again - this makes no sense. We are a country of laws and if one person no longer needs to follow the laws, then it's all broken. Actually - why doesn't the current president just cancel the election? Official act. (I think this is stupid, but is it allowed?)
Could you stop interrupting please?
Ladies and gentlemen, just vote. The Supreme Court kept the door open for this entire case to be thrown out essentially. Don’t depend on the government to do what you can control.
No, they've (the 6 conservative leaning members of the court) have done everything they can to obstruct the cases from going forward, we should have been well into the DC and Florida cases by May
I'm voting for Trump
@@fanboyhex1555 a vote for trump is a vote wasted.
TRUMP 2024 and beyond !!!
@@4Trumpthese fascists are wild.
So, pressuring you vice president to do criminal acts is official duty? Really?!? And you're then immune for prosecution? What a banana court this is!
that's not what they said, they left it to lower courts to define what those official acts might entail
Explain how Nancy pelosi
Is worth over 100 million Dollars
With a Career in politics
It wasn't a criminal act. The vice president had the power to do that and we know the election was stolen and never should have been certified
@@telebubba5527 “pressuring” his Vp, Mike Pence… to do what, to not certify the election? Jamie Raskins first act in Congress entailed standing in the capital pleading with then VP Joe Biden to not certify the 2016 election. Countless other Dems did the same thing. Claims the election was stolen, Trump was illegitimate… Russia Russia. Democrats denied the outcome of the 2016 election based upon Hillary’s lies. It resulted in thousands of liberals tearing apart the capital during Trump’s inauguration. Look it up… the imagery alone, could have been taken from J6 but guess it was no big deal unless it involved Trump?
@@davidweinknecht9713no they threw it back to lower court to waste more time. Lower court has to home hearing and send it back to them for more delays
Always remember that one of the reasons we started this country is because the founding fathers didn’t like the idea of a leader of a country not being accountable for their actions. Only back then they didn’t call it presidential immunity, they called it divine right
@@geisaune793 😆😆😆😆😆😆
And now every country with King Charles as head-of-State is a full Democracy, while the "United" States has been a FLAWED one since 2017.
Just letting everybody know...
Katie Turr needs to stop interrupting everything the experts are trying to say.
Its her job to clarify the answers. Stop being so annoying.
She's a liberal woman she can't help it's in her DNA😅😊😂
" the experts" - 5th grade rhetoric
I was considering posting the same. Katy Tur trying to finish sentences of the guests is short sighted, to put it diplomatically. Katy destroyed the whole segment.
Ex- spurts .
America your justice system is a joke
Why are you people obsessed with our country?
Jealous much ?
We like it.
Thats what Trump said ...
I agree Trump should have never had those cases brought against him. TRUMP 2024
First offical act... remove threats to democracy... Trump, Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch, Kavanaugh, Barret, Roberts.
1000 % !
Biden has nothing to lose by doing so and is doing the US a grave disservice by not using these new king like powers. One thing is for sure, Trump will use them. Why isn't ever American in the streets protesting, this is pretty bad.
You’re so sad and pathetic.
God bless your heart.
Yup
👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Wow. What a spin that headline is. They completely gutted the case against him.
Katy Tur is an awful facilitator for this discussion - the laughing, the light-hearted facade, the interruptions, what is going on?
Not to excuse it, but I assume she's rattled by the news as many of us are.
I so agree.
She’s been planted there by the right and is enjoying every bit of this. I’m sure she’s MAGA underwear!! TRUMO 2024!!
She just seems happy Trump didn't get full immunity
Totally.
Can an act be official, if it is unconstitutional?
Revisionist justices overturning Roe vs Wade. And now this disgusting interpretation of the constitution. Shakespeare alluded to these foils and follies of human nature whereby "Fair is foul and foul is fair." Thanks to these greedy & power tripping justices the laws are now burried in a world of ××××! The people will be the victims.
@@ernestclary6035”Is the Constitution, unconstitutional? This Supreme Court says yes it”
Yeehaw we comin for justice! You’re going to jail!
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Yes. Doesn't make it right but if a president is acting in their official duties then thats it. What comes after doesn't matter if they can couch it in officiality
The President can now ‘pressure’ the DOJ. These judges are absolutely horrific in their immunity from thought.
The president is the head of the DOJ. Executive branch and all.
They always could do that.
That’s not even an objective concept
Biden will not do it but Trump certainly will if he becomes president again. They have given him a loaded weapon.
The fact that this statement was written down shows these people don't even understand positions in government, and at this point, it's a waste of time. It's been 8 years, and you still think the same. Idc that you are this dumb
R.I.P. America. It was bad while it lasted.
You ain't seen nothing yet.😂
It’s already bad now are you blind?
There is something rotten in the District of Columbia.
Ya think??? 😂
90% of politicians
Yes there is. It's the entire briben administration and you voted for it. Thanks a bunch.
Yep and President Trump is exposing it all!
we've been saying that for 8 years minimum
This decision is the worst ! The president should be held to the highest standards of anyone ! Vote blue!
This applies to all Presidents
Don’t worry, the lower courts will absolutely clarify what is official acts and what is private acts. So he will still be held accountable for some of his criminal acts.👍🏾
They want special rights for Trump
Vote blue and you're KILLING our country!
Okay millions funneled to the Bidens from China and Ukraine, thats perfectly fine. Biden used his office to persecute Trump since day 1, Hilary said Trumps term as president was illegitimate, and the debate proved 100% what everyone has been saying about Bidens mental health.
This host needs to STOP talking over her guests!!
Well, this is MSNBC propaganda so...
exactly!!!
🎯🎯🎯
Not only she does that all the time her coworkers like Joy Reid,Chris Hayes, and all the other anchors Rachel Meadow,and company with them its interrupt,interrupt,.
It's not a host smart people call it propaganda. Hitler used it in the 1930s .🤭🤭
And just like that...democracy begins to fall....sad day for America
Lololololol you guys are so salty
Cry more
@@greenapetranslord4870don’t be stupid, no one wins in this scenario. The world is crying for you
America is not a democracy, but if it were it died in 2008 when America elected an Arab shortly after Muslims attacked the World Trade Centers and killed over 3,000 Americans. That was when I knew America was over. Where have you been? You watched people jumping to their death to avoid burning to death after begging first responders to please save them, yet you voted for an Activist Muslim In Chief in my great Christian country called the USA, and you want me to believe that because the Supreme Court simply put in writing that we have to honor the Presidents already due powers as stated in the Constitution that somehow we've lost our democracy? Just quit commenting, please!
Your "democracy" IS A TRAVESTY!
The idea of giving nine people, who often have shown less integrity than Mobsters, life time appointment is simply absurd. This is the court that has ruled: 1) That Bribery (Campaign Contribution) is legal and is Freedom Of Speech. 2) That Corporations are people and can give unlimited Bribes. 3) That Non-profit outfits can provide Bribes for political figures without revealing the names of the people who are providing the Bribes. 4) That the people who use Brand name meds have legal protection for side effects, but the majority of people who use the Generics, have no protection. 5) That a bunch of old men in different states can decide about women health and reproductive rights. So, don't expect anything positive from such corrupt court.
Maybe for you and your side, I LOVE IT
🤡 Maybe the demorats can jail their political opponents they can't defeat with a scorching "insumerectionist racist mattress tag removal" indictment 😂😂
I’m glad that you’re upset that you’re corrupt nation is broken.
It isn’t 9 people because only 6 republicans on Supreme Court is in favor of Donald Trump.
To be clear, it's not all 9 who have integrity issues. To date, we clearly see Alito and Thomas are compromised by bribes and Alito has shown demonstrable non-judge like impartiality.
What official acts can President Biden perform now?
He can officially protect the country from a domestic enemy, so I look forward to that.
Certainly not a debate.
If the Supreme Court ruling is to be followed, hypothetically, he could declare that Donald Trump is a clear and present danger to the national security of the United States of America. And use the powers of the office to protect this country from that threat.
Take his memory pills
Try to look alive
KATY TUR no one wants to hear from you, let the lawyers speak, good grief
exactly!!
Typical woman, am I right?
Maybe no one wants to hear from you.
I only watch MSDNC for Katy Tur, is that understood liberal?
@@760HorsePower Close as you’ll ever get to a smart, well spoken female. Get that incel?
This discusting judgement by the Supreme Court has come down on CANADA DAY! Thank God the I live in Canada!
MSNBC should start a show with Katy Tur and Joe Scarborough called The Break Off or The Cut Off.
This is a garbage propaganda outlet.
💯
The Supreme Court should have never taken the case.
Why? That's their job. Because you wanted to get the orange bad man? Justice is a beautiful thing. Especially when it makes the communists melt.😂
@@amysimpson646Putin's thrilled!! I'm pretty sure stealing documents is personal.
🤓
It’s a very sad day in America for someone can be above the law………
@@Pacific981 convictions and judgments prove he's not above the law but i understand why people think he is. His attempts always look like successes. Trump said it best, "Nobody cares about what's real! It's what they believe that counts!".
Why am I not surprised the votes were 6-3. I said many times no justice appointed by Trump should sit in on judging trump
Why not? They are currently sitting Justices in the Supreme Court. Judgment is their job. Of course, you only think that because your side doesn't benefit.
Conflict of interest. Its exactly why a judge cant sit over a case when they know the defendant personally.
@@psychopompous3207 ummm because they are biased in favor of the guy who appointed them?
Soooo... TRUE!!! ;-) Well said!!!
@@markprater4016 then the decision would be 3-3? Stalemate
IT'S ALL ABOUT THE STALL!
This is a sad day for our Country
Speak for yourself
Every day Trump is still a serious presidential candidate is a sad day for our species.
It is a sad day vote blue dems rise up get you friends and family to the polls vote for Biden keep the criminal and the nude model on the curb!
Vote
@@SweetJustice11Vote!!!!!!!!!!!!! You are right 👏🏽
Sounds like Biden can pickup the phone to Seal Team 6 or maybe just rule that no further presidential elections are required here on out.
So now you want a dictator
@@leonblack2651 who says I didn’t want one before. Just not orange cheeto.
@@leonblack2651Trump does..
If he can pressure officials for votes nothing is off the table.
wouldn't life be awesome if Biden ordered Seal Team 6 to go speak to those justices then take them back to Guantanamo
@@mattrinker2947 I prefer cheeto over potato.
Katy is a joke. She talks over everyone. Let your guess finish talking. If you cannot then don't invite these guess.
We can't wait until November. Add two justices to the Supreme court NOW. Official act!
That sure sounds unethical...You guys have a monopoly on that sort of thing.
It doesn't work like that. Court packing is not a solution because the other side will do it just the same as soon as they're in power. That would politicize the court.
Policing the results of your own election cannot be the official act of any politician. CANNOT!
BIDEN WILL NEED TO POLICE TRUMP HA
💯
You mean like Katie Hobbs
And it is not. That part is official already. Nowhere in the line of election certification is any president involved.
theoretically or practically, what should a president do if he thinks opposition cheated? Officially he could order an investigation. Unofficially he can state what he believes. Anyway everybody should leave the left
The host interrupts people more knowledgeable than her
Marxist Democrats thinks
they are knowledgeable. 🤣
Will this blabber mouth shut up and let them speak?
Will she be quiet and let them finish a thought. She acts like she's arguing a defense
The ONLY outcome that would make sense is : NO IMMUNITY as NO ONE IS ABOVE THE LAW and in America we do NOT have Kings!! Pack the court!!🇺🇸🇺🇸
So go tell that to the Clintons 🤣🤣🤣
Loser loser loser😂😂
😮 what about the Biden crime family? Snort snort
When Trump gets re-elected, maybe he'll do what the Dems want and pack the court with more conservative justices.
@@ahbalone What crimes?
The electoral college has taken us down this road.
Don't worry the Democrats are trying to wipe that out with all the immigrants in sanctuary cities in those Democrats States electoral process away from us cuz that's what it's doing and that's the plan too
The electoral college is the only reason we are a country.
That fortunately will re-elect Trump in November.
Never gonna happen but you keep holding on to your fever dream .
@@TheGonebald
Nope. If the courts can’t get rid of Trump, other remedies are necessary.
Katy interrupts way too much
Im about to be anti-american now. This aint the same america we once knew.
Thank Carter, Obama, Bush, Clinton, and Biden for that, they are against America, not for it. You have been lied to by those cretins for so many times. If you hate America, then leave.
I'm anti-stupidity btw, not anti-american.
Thank you, Merrick Garland, for dragging your feet in bringing Trump to trial.
and thank you Supreme Court for all the delays, and thank you RNC for all the money you've thrown into a dictator's pocket, and thank you all the judges like Aileen Cannon for all the decisions with no actual basis in law, and thank you to every voter who can't tell the difference between lies and reality and who actually desire a Dictatorial President.
There are a lot of "thank yous" to go around.
Trump led an insurrection against the United States o f America he needs to be held accountable.
Garland knows he didn't break the law. The process is the punishment
Russia Russia Russia
He totally did @@MrDucksBill
Anyone else would have gone to jail 😡👎🏾
Cry cry cry some more. 😆
Anyone else isn’t a former president. Statement makes no sense.
@@CatzlovichCatnipAndCabbages wait till old man Biden figure out what immunity means,......your leader is gonna be ajusted
Trump 2024 🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲
Trump lovers love a two tiered justice system
Um... overturning an ELECTION IS NOT AN OFFICIAL ACT. WTAF are you talking about?
Guess that means Joe can legally stay in office no matter what.
No election was overturned
@@mile_high_topher based
So now a coup is an official act? Where is that in the constitution? Now they’re just making up 💩!
@@mile_high_topher yeah! For democracy!
Promoting , and supporting insurrection on Congress is a federal offense. No immunity from instigating a revolution which is what occurred January 6.
Our Supreme Court is getting scarier by the day.
I can see where the Constitution frightens socialists.
Not as scary as the banana republic weaponization of the justice system being perpetrated by the communists/DNC.
WHY would you need IMMUNITY if your so INNOCENT ?
@@KayZee-zu5lp do you even show wuth evidence or do you repeat like a GOOD PARROT
@@jacobbeyer9346 look up the case...Google schlorar allows you access court cases
@@KayZee-zu5lp stop deflecting.
Ask a police officer.
Waste of air!
Does Katy Tur know how to shut her mouth for 2 seconds? How irritating!
She is irritating.
Agree 👍
Binden should take this decision and call up seal team six.
All i gotta say is that its pretty obvious what is going on! So get ready for November people! They showing you that there are different strokes for different folks!
Like Macy's pre-Christmas, I hope the Passport Office is hiring extra employees to meet the tsunami of applications headed their way.
Katie...let these people talk without interupting them!!!
I am in shock. This is outrageous and sickening. SCOTUS is an embarrassment.
Okay people don't panic if Trump can use this ruling to his Advantage so can Joe Biden
But will he
@@carlaaxelson6338no he won’t, because Biden actually has integrity; unlike Trump or his cronies.
Why would he need to? Trump is the one with the rap sheet of pending criminal cases.
All joes crimes a VP not POTUS
I mean thats a problem but without a doubt Trump has a much larger record of actually breaking the law and doing shady stuff.
SCOTUS: good luck figuring out what is an official act is suckers.
Well stealing documents and inciting the J6 riot/insurrection were not official acts.
Joe sending squads to all six of their homes seems official.
Oh that’ll be easy for them. Anything a Republican president does is official and anything a Democratic president does isn’t
1:55 in and Katy Tur has interrupted the guests seven times. oh my god.
She has esteemed experts at the table. Her opinion is irrelevant. Let them finish a sentence please.
@@one.of.the.good.karens agreed!!
All of you calling for violence remember that when/if your party loses your opponents can/will do the same. Leaders using government resources to eliminate competition is 3rd world banna republic nonsense.
Her interruptions were highly irritating to the point of me not watching it!!
The Supreme Court is on the ballot this November. The next president will appoint minimum 2 justices!!!!
Expand the court and make that number 6.
I doubt it. These dinosaurs are going to live forever
@@mile_high_topherNot gonna happen.
We need more conservative judges
@@anitagarcia8056 Not if they keep making rulings like this.
Not even surprised. Still disgusted.
Fire Garland immediately
The Supreme Court, has called it , too close to the wire to fascism , for my comfort . And now , it is going to mean , trumpy , will more than likely , never face any accountability , and consequences for his treasonous crimes against our country . And we could too easily be stuck with a dictator , with the title of president , who will be president for life . Trumpy was very much loving how kim jon uns people treated their dear leader . And the giant military parades in north korea , russia and china . And said maybe we should try this president for life stuff . BUT I THINK HE HAS HAD TOO MUCH POWER ALREADY . AND TOO MUCH TAX PAYER MONEY FOR HIS TRAITOROUS CRIMES .
Vote blue. Do not let him near the White House
Biden got off from being charged with murder when he leaves office remember the 13 solders that go killed
Stay mad pussycat!
❤
You ALMOST had him.
@@TerriKnight-x3sWe did. It didn't work!
I think you are ready for the funny farm!
Can President Biden call up Seal Team 6 and have some official business done?
Leftists are violent and nasty people.
Since 2015, the number of lawyers,former attorneys, prosecutors etc news media conpanies have had to employ to keep up with him is crazy.
The supreme justices need to step down not President Biden!!😮😮
Shut up!! stop interrupting, let them speak, what is a official act ?? who gets to decide it , is it only for Donald Trump or all sitting presidents?
For Trump, "official" means he wasn't on the toilet tweeting the order
He was the presidents. Try not to listen to msnbc or cnn. go read the full ruling i think its over 100 pages and decide for yourself or you can watch "Watching the Watchers on youtube". he is reading the ruling right now
The whole four years as a president should be official act
Congress, as it has always been. As it was intended.
Well, that's exactly why the SCOTUS kicked it back... they didn't even read the law or even try to allege it wasn't an official. If there was even a possible chance that there was electoral foul play, any and all Presidents should take action to review these.
People need to vote in huge numbers. Make sure you are registered to vote. Check your registration - make sure it's up to date and active. In Texas you must be registered 30 days before the election.
Especially in Red States!!
Yes. People need to vote in their droves for a President who does not try to worm his way out of his legal obligations as a citizen of the USA.
Vote blue
Absofuckinglutely
@@richardsnell2348you made no sense, Biden is persecuting his political adversary. Grow up.
Gee Katy, shut up and let them answer.
This anchor reminds me of Jim Carey in Dumb and Dumber, “SO YOU’RE TELLING ME THERE’S A CHANCE?!?” 🤣🤣🤣
It's a shame that right and wrong in this country have become who did you vote for. Vote Blue for Democracy
For real, crazy time we living in right now.
They haven't, you're just a zealot.
I will never vote blue. I care too much for this country.
Supreme Court seats matter folks. It's absurd that the president can conspire against his country, and as long as it's an official act it's okay.
It's now widely accepted that the election was stolen.
Biden is a disgrace!😂😂
They are fine if it’s a republican
@@ecurewitz it truly is like living in an alternate parallel reality.
Doesn't this supreme court ruling give Biden absolute immunity to cancel the election and remain in power, in fear of trump destroying it? Official act.
"Trying to find the silver lining". That's not your job. Your job is to report the news completely unbiased.
These are not journalists, they are activists.
@@bishop1kinda like SCOTUS.
@@bishop1like the justices?
@@skankhunt3624Seriously.
Actually, you don't think for all of us. Just report.
Well i would agree paying of someone or false personal business records is not official act.
Katie Tur talks to much!!! Let the experts speak. She is constantly cutting in to others.
Katy and Ari, two jabber-peas in a pod... Ari is the WORST... always interrupts to hear himself speak.
Now its up to us, to sent him to jail not the white house.
To sent him? Is this you Biden? Spellchecker??? Idioooo
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 fear not, God Almighty still sits on the throne and His will be done.
@@myfoursons5990 Individual with Clear Behavioral Problems
Nope Trump 24 all the way 🎉🎉🎉🎉 we the people will speak very loudly in November, at least the ones who can see things for themselves and those who can use their brains for themselves. Not those who hear and believe everything they hear without researching it.
@@myfoursons5990 Individual With Mental Health Problems and Behavioral Problems.
"The relationship between the President and the people he serves has shifted irrevocably. In every use of official power, the President is now a king above the law." Justice Sonia Sotomayor
More urgent need to elect the Democratic ticket top to bottom.
look, as a Republican, if you elect the democratic ticket top to bottom please dont put in a ticket full of vegetables
What exactly are the benefits of democrats? I'm genuinely interested
@@joeybydin439 free stuff?
No, he's not, but we have 3 branches of government with equal powers. GET OVER IT !!!!!!!
@@connordoyle502 lol exactly. That's about it
Yes yes YES!!!!!!