Hey Ben Wicked comparison video - just what I needed to see after my message yesterday regarding the X3 and 1 inch 360 Leica edition Even though the 1 inch doesn’t have the HER video function, can you add any HDR effect to the video in post using Insta360 studio desktop or the app ? If not, what software can you use to add HDR in post?
I think the biggest problem with a rotating 360 camera, though, is things changing around the room (sun going in/out) or anything at all moving, that could ruin the shot. The advantage of a dual lens system is that it takes the picture quickly without the slowness of having to rotate around the room.
Your videos on the X3 seem to be the most level-headed and I think you're the only person who looked at the "72mp" photos with a critical eye. So thanks very much for the work and quality you put into your videos! I might still upgrade to the X3 from my X2 simply because of two things: 1) the larger touch pad and 2) the quick menu. I often switch between videos and stills and on several occasions have accidentally recorded using the wrong mode. I would prefer the image quality of the 1" but travel is my primary use for a 360 camera and keeping the size of my gear low is important.
I bought x3 and I'm do frustrated with the 72mb photo quality. I feel the my sansung flip 3 12mb camera is better than the x3 72mb 😞 Anyone cares to illuminate me please?
Thank you for this review and comparison. It has helped inform my decision. I've really been struggling with the choice of x3 vs 1", but I've decided to go with the x3. My primary use is going to be recording scenic drives, with an upcoming winter driving tour of Southern Utah as the impetus for buying my first 360 camera.
Great video comparison! I went with the Insta360 RS 1inch 360 for the modularity and video quality. Was really torn between that and the convenience of the X3.
Bought and X3 yesterday. Will definitely be trying it out for low light and astrophotography. Not expecting dslr quality but maybe mobile phone quality. Unfortunately the 1 inch is way out of my budget
Excellent video ! I hope Insta360 will add HDR video to the 1-Inch 360 edition in the near future or maybe release a new engine module One R2 with HDR video, finally it is a modular camera, one point that you did not mention but is another point in favor of the 1-Inch 360 edition
Excellent analysis! I'm deciding if the time has come to move on from my One R to either the One RS or the X3. I thought the modularity would be useful, but I've found that I rarely change to the 4K lens (I grab my Hero 7 instead). I don't trust the waterproofing of the R and am thinking that trading modularity for better waterproofing might be a good choice. My only hesitation at this point is that the X3 is limited to 60 fps except in bullet time mode. I'd like to be able to shoot 100, or 180 fps in a direction of my choosing, but bullet time seems to point down the selfie stick.
I picked up the Insta360 RS 1inch 360. It was expensive. I regretted my purchase at 1st because I was having issue with the clarity of the videos, but I think it was just my over expectations and my lack of understanding how to edit 360 videos properly. Either way, I have it now, and gonna have to live with the purchase.
Still happy with my oneX2. I miss active HDR but I feel more comfortable with a smaller screen (when doing sports) that is less exposed to get dammaged.
Great Review!! Had the X2, and find the X3 way better! Not because of those mushy 72MP, but because the QuadBayer Sensor enables video possibilities like ActiveHDR. Unfortunately the 1inch (that I own, too) does not deliver it, as you mentioned. And I think, it will never! I don’t think, it’s marketing! It’s more about the readout speed of that huge sensor. With a tiny sensor like in the X2, you can readout fast enough to produce sequential HDR in good light. The QuadBayer Sensor of the X3 can deliver parallel HDR, which is much better. The 1inch sensor on the other can’t be read out fast enough for sequential HDR without strong artefacts - that’s why we don’t have HDR video.
Thank you for the excellent comparison. I recently purchased the X2, and although I regret not waiting for the X3, I cannot justify upgrading to the X3.
Fantastic comparaison Ben 👍As expected the photo quality of X3 is conformed to size sensor so indeed do not choose only with specs and big number as 72 MP of X3. Trisio is performing well, perfect for low budget and virtual tours. Now waiting for GoPro MAX 2 ... but not expecting huge changes on specs, may be more on sensor size (1/2 ?),HDR mode at least for photo, and 10bits colors Regards Fabien
Thanx for this video, it's complete... I just bought the Insta360 One RS twin edition, because of its versatility. And so far i am chuffed with it. Would i have chosen the X3? i think not because i would like to switch to regular actioncam for certain shots, the one inch would be to big and less versatile again, but it would be an upgrade i could consider.
Ben, it's a great comparison.. what might be the best choice for creating some serious virtual tours including low light conditions, theta z1 or theta x or one rs 1 inch?
I edit both gopros 360 max , and insta360s x2/x3 video for skydiving, in my opinion the insta360 is a much more pleasant experience. The stich lines on the max are clearly obvious in frame, where the insta360 blend in almost invisible. Hardware alone tho. Workflow/ editing gopro max is horrible with gopro quick or player. The software isn't intuitive at all and the .360 files seem very problematic when trying to use them. Insta360 studio by far is the easiest to drop the video in and edit with a key framing approach that actually makes sense. To the point where il readily export gopro 360 max to h.26 360, and then use insta360 studio to key framed them from there. I own the 360 Max, but I wish I would have bought an x3, or 1inch instead. Something for you to think about if you decide to get into 360.
@@derekremington8807 I appreciate the feedback! Insta 360 seems to be really aggressively targeting the 360 market and I've heard good things about their general responsiveness on firmware updates and the improvements of the software. I think it's a great concept but it would be a hobby for me so it would be lying around a lot and I'm not at the point where I can justify the cost. And I'm honestly not cool with some of their design choices and earlier firmware quirks and just think that GoPro is capable of doing it better if they decided to. I have to admit though that my interest is piqued and I'm fairly certain that I would talk myself into one before our next vacation. 😂
@@derekremington8807 Derek, I have a question for you since you actually edit the files: What is the maximum resolution you can export to? I've seen one person say it's only 1080p and quite a few video reviews of the X3 don't even mention it. Also, I've learned that there is also the somewhat new One RS 1 Inch 360 Edition. I wouldn't think that it's the best fit for sky diving but it might be exactly what I would be looking for.
@@markwornom1050 max resolution is quite variable. Few factors in play. The max resolution stated on the box for 360 cameras is for the entire 360 degree shot. So when you keyframe it, you are taking a small portion of that resolution out of the total. And depending on how far you zoom out or zoom in on a key framed shot (not 360 shot) that also affects resolution, zooming in giving you even smaller piece of the overall resolution if that makes sense. During editing, during the export phase, finishing a video you can upscale back up to 4k. But it's not nearly as crisp or detailed as a normal camera that is recording 4k resolution in a non 360 key frame if that makes sense. Feel free to check my channel out. I have many videos that were recorded with both standard gopro cameras, and my 360 max. You can tell the difference, but over all quality is still great. More of a use case situation really. I prefer 360 in skydiving because it allows me to do the jump and catch everything around me, without having to chase a single person as much. Il post a link. Normal gopro video looks more crisp and non distorted, where the max video still looks great but can have a fish eye effect in certain cases trying to get certain shots.
I am a bowhunter and fisherman. I fish from a kyak a few times a year as well. Low light is not a big deal for fishing, but for hunting it very much can be. Would you pick the 1 inch or the x3 for this type of application? Nothing fast moving most likely, but potential to have them out and maybe get rained on a little from a pop up rain shower while hunting before I can get it put away. Or potentially while being snowed on it may be put and on if animals are nearby. Which would you think is a better fit for this? Fishing trips in summer will be very bright settings, and pristine and distant dynamic range won’t be as critical for either fishing, or bowhunting in close quarters. What do you think being a camera reviewer and have used them?
Bought a 1 Inch at launch as I felt like the quality was finally at a level where it was worth having the separate camera just for it + impending Matterport support. Seeing those dynamic range tests was a real killer 😂 I would still make the same decision but seeing a lower level camera leaps and bounds above the 1 Inch in a department that I regularly notice as a downfall of the 1 Inch is a pain. Crazy that they didn't implement that super effective ActiveHDR in their "best".
If Leica/insta360 used a Sony IMX586 sensor then it has a quad bayer filter which can be used for real time video HDR coding as it can make 2 frames at the same time (a short and a long exposure frame what can be merged to make HDR). One inch is 4 times bigger than the RS sensor size and there is 2 of them. With this math this sensor needs 4x computational power to merge different exposure frames this means 4x the power it needs to run and 4x the heat generated. If leica used their own sensor then it is possible it is not a quad bayer, but some other alteration in which case there is no HW to make video HDR.
The normal Bayer Sensor can only shoot sequential HDR, so no chance for that active HDR like recorded in the X3 with the QuadBayer sensor. And for sequential HDR the readout might be to slow to produce decent quality under real world light surroundings.
The normal Bayer Sensor can only shoot sequential HDR, so no chance for that active HDR like recorded in the X3 with the QuadBayer sensor. And for sequential HDR the readout might be to slow to produce decent quality under real world light surroundings.
Looks like the X3 at this time seems to meet all the requirements I need. Thank you for the review of all the 360 cameras. i was wondering what other 360 mode cameras there were. You answered all my questions. Still looking at insta360 X3 videos in how they work. I currently do not have one. Take care.
As of February 2023, is there any reason to get an X3 when you can get a One RS with the 360 lens for about the same price but have more versatility? Here is how I see it (although I may be wrong so please correct me if needed): X3: Great 360 shots / Subpar Flat Action shots in 4K single lens mode One RS: Great 360 shots with 360 lens / Great Flat Action shots with 4K lens
Good comparison, thanks Ben. I don’t have a 360 camera yet. A few years back I got a Samsung Gear, but after trying it a few times I threw it away - the quality was so bad that it was unusable even for casual use. As for the current models, my challenge is that I want one that will do it all - good quality 360 video and photos, both for hiking and potentially virtual tours at some point. It seems like none of the consumer 360 cameras are at that level yet.
Thanks for your video, I've just received my x3 after watch your video ;) I think it's really good camera for beginners especially with the big screen and Insta 360 app.
Good day. I simply wanted to reach out and thank you for the tremendous video reviews you provide. I purchased the Insta360 Pro 2, and realized I purchased way too much camera for my intensions, and the form factor was unwieldy, so resold it. If price wasn't an object and my interest is in video and still, considering ease of use and form factor, would you still recommend the X3? And finally, do you have a commission link to the cameras you recommend? I am happy to purchase and to support you if there is a means to do that. Thanks kindly.
Thanks! Yes I have links in the description of this video. I think a combination of X3 and 1-inch will provide best results in all situations for 360 video 👍🏻
Still going to do more research but leaning towards the X3. I am a Realtor so I would like to be able to do virtual tours but, realistically, video is replacing virtual tours in the real estate business.
I would love if you cover the timelapse photography mode pf the insta 360 cameras. The shutter speed matters a lot when taking street imagery and slow shutyers results in some blurry pics.
Great video ! So i been struggeling to find any asnwer to this anywhere, but i will ask here as well. For nature walks, biking, fishing, a bit indoor maybe in tourist places. Mainly taking 360 pictures, but also video, not sure only 4360 or also flat. Is the X3 the best bet in that pricerange here in 2023. I am first time 360 cam byer and just got a bit fascinated by the 360 option for stills, seeing how well it has upped in quality the past few years.
thank you for the awesome video. I am curious about cropping capabilities between Insta360 x3 and the 1 inch version. I would like to be able to crop approx 6x on post edit. which one would you recommend between the x3 and the 1 inch. thank you
*awesome video* Can you maybe test the X3 microphones more indepth? Like with wind and such and during action? Compared to the RS and other main competitors? Thanks! Keep em coming 🙌🙌👌
These info means a lot to a beginner like me. I'm so thankful to chance upon your videos and your valuable input on which cam to buy. Definitely your followers now. 👍 👍 👍
Great 360 video review. Now Subscribed. IYO is the X3 a suitable fit for motorcycling? Can you recommend the connectable to handle bar selfie attachment/stick? Thx
I've had a Ricoh Theta S since 2015 and the battery is completely dead now. I haven't used it in a couple of years and have been wanting to upgrade for a while. I'm glad I waited until now with the arrival of the Insta360 X3. I didn't want to spend much more than $500 on a new 360 camera so that's the perfect price and it has everything I need and more for a 360 camera. I'm going to get one next month. I can't wait and so excited to start shooting 360 again. Thanks for your reviews and tutorials. :)
@@francomelechi8085 Good to know but I can't really be bothered at this point with such an old camera. I'd rather upgrade to something with much better quality, way more functions and features and much more user friendly.
*I just bought this because I had the One RS and I upgraded because I wanted the Me Mode because I think that's a Game Changer that no one else has and I'd be surprise it the next gen of ANY 360 will have it.*
Hi Ben, In the x3 with active hdr mode is it possible to record at 30 fps? In the insta360 R with hdr video mode you can record only at 25 fps. It means more dynamic range but no chance to use most of the templates in shot lab section of the smartphone app. Great review as usual
Please Ben Answer my question. For cinematic motorcycle riding (no enduro 60fps hardcore, just 24/30fps traveling on the road), to make youtube content (big screen) which camera you recommend?. The light conditions while motorcycle riding are generally outdoors, blue skies, blazing sun across the clouds and fast changes of light while crossing trees, and somewhat opaque rainy days here and there. I don't ride at night or in the rain. My focus is on video quality. The 1inch seems the best video quality but with no active HDR the X3 seems to be most fit for the ligh conditions. Maybe they will add active HDR as a firmware update? or you don't see this happening at all? Whats your opinion? Have you tested the 1-inch while driving?
Hi Ben. Thx for sharing your expertise. Actually, I did purchase my first 360 cam recently so I got a X3..😉 Your video did confirm my choice according what I plan to do with the action camera.
Great review Ben! Seen INSIDE any of these cams? Need OEM supply of SEPARABLE sensor modules for packaging and aerodynamics, for high speed drones/wings! (Know about 'Sphere' but would prefer bigger sensors: >=1/2"
I suspect that HDR mode might be improved on the X3 for photos. Using this on the X2 makes big difference. Then we might see much improved. I suspect that firmware upgrades will improve other aspects.
Hey! Awesome video 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 I want to get a 360 camera but I’m not sure if I should wait for a new one, you know, GoPro comes with a new camera each year, same as other technology.. Do you have any idea when insta360 could launch an X4 or a 1” v2?? 🙏🏼
This is the most outstanding 360 camera review I've seen. Worth the sub mate. Thank you. Only thing a newbie (like me) might wonder is; what is active HDR & Dinamic range? The research continues...
@@BenClaremont you are a legend mate. Now I understand why you are so surprised that such an expensive camera as the RS1inch doesn't have that. In theory it sounds like a hugely beneficial technology. But in your testing scenarios it didn't appear that the RS1inch was lacking in anything. I wonder if having larger sensors make HDR redundant to some degree. I'm about to check your other videos as you've probably explained it. Thanks again 👍
Now that my Mi Sphere is dead (by drowning) I'm looking at your comparisons with a different eye. :D Use is and will be social media, and I'm leaning towards the X3, which seem to offer the best quality for the price and the use case. I bought the Mi Sphere just to try 360, paid it just above 100$, one of the last stocks before disappearing from the stores and I got hooked! Love your content!
Thanks for this great video comparison! I would like ti buy the rs twin edition and 4k module. But the presentation of x3 Made me in confusion. I think i ll buy the x3 but in single lens mode 4k is great also like the rs? Tnx
Hi! About 2 months ago I bought the One RS 4k without the 360 Lens. Do You recommend me to buy the 360 lens or sell It and buy the X3? I mainly use It for motorcycle and travel video to post on social media. Please help me! 🙏 Thanks in Advance and congratulations for the review!
Awesome review Ben, thank you! Ive got the X3 and the RS 1"360 and Im really please they came out on top in your review! How do you think they would cope vs the One R 1" front facing lens mod??
Awesome, in-depth review. One the fence of keeping the 1" 360 or returning it to get the X3. I use it to shoot inside a plane cockpit and dynamic range is a problem. The outside is bright on day flights, but the cockpit is obviously in shade. Night video with my GoPro 360 Max is terrible. Not worth producing. So, I thought the Insta360 1" may work there.
LOL. Great timing! (also just subscribed. Hi!) I literally just bought a Ricoh Theta SC, used from ebay for $50 two days ago... It's working but with a minor scratch on the lens, hence the cheap price. I've wanted a Theta / 360 camera after borrowing one a couple years back, and using it to make 360 photos for a web-based google street-view-like walkaround of a lego theme park I made with my kid. (it had excellent focus up close, so it worked great for it!) and for $50 it was too good a deal to pass up. I know i can get better ones for ~$130 used, (or more for the SC2, etc), but this should be fine for me. :D
Very helpful review. Thanks! For the last years I used the Theta Z1, especially for real estate 360 photo assignments. HDR photo's are extremely good so far. But a walking video is a no-go. Just a messy result and not much post processing options as the Insta360. Insta360 studio does a great job what I've seen. For now I will purchase the Insta360 x3 for video after watching your very helpful reviews but probably keeping the Theta Z1 for it's great HDR photo's...
great review, what, if any, rumors are there out there about the next gen 360 video cameras? I view the X3 as a moderate feature upgrade to the x2 (which I have) so I am waiting for the sensor increase to deliver the next higher resolution. 5.7k/1080p edited is like 4 or so years in the running, when do these cameras go up higher?
Here they are!
📸 Insta360 X3: www.insta360.com/sal/x3?insrc=INRWADC
📸 One RS 1-Inch: www.insta360.com/sal/one_rs_1_inch_360?insrc=INRWADC
📸 Trisio Lite 2: www.pergear.com/products/trisio-lite-2-vr-camera?ref=6MdRX
📸 Theta X: amzn.to/3OduU4v
📸 Ricoh Theta Z1 51GB: amzn.to/3dgxmuk
📸 Insta360 One RS: store.insta360.com/product/one_rs?insrc=INRWADC
📸 Insta360 One X2: www.insta360.com/sal/one_x2?insrc=INRWADC
fantastic as usual
Hey Ben
Wicked comparison video - just what I needed to see after my message yesterday regarding the X3 and 1 inch 360 Leica edition
Even though the 1 inch doesn’t have the HER video function, can you add any HDR effect to the video in post using Insta360 studio desktop or the app ?
If not, what software can you use to add HDR in post?
I think someone trying to use your profile to scam. Or is that really you on telegram?
⚠️WARNING FOR SCAMMER⚠️- Ask to chat in Telegram !
@@robertobantugtan yes that is a scammer. I don’t use telegram and have blocked them from my channel.
By far, you deliver the best, most comprehensive 360 camera reviews on UA-cam! Nice job!
My pleasure 😇
Totally agree to Ripvanstinkle. I bought the X3 because of that awesome Video. Thank you very much.
I think the biggest problem with a rotating 360 camera, though, is things changing around the room (sun going in/out) or anything at all moving, that could ruin the shot. The advantage of a dual lens system is that it takes the picture quickly without the slowness of having to rotate around the room.
Your videos on the X3 seem to be the most level-headed and I think you're the only person who looked at the "72mp" photos with a critical eye. So thanks very much for the work and quality you put into your videos! I might still upgrade to the X3 from my X2 simply because of two things: 1) the larger touch pad and 2) the quick menu. I often switch between videos and stills and on several occasions have accidentally recorded using the wrong mode. I would prefer the image quality of the 1" but travel is my primary use for a 360 camera and keeping the size of my gear low is important.
Thanks, yeah it’s definitely a good upgrade for those things 👍🏻
Larger touch pad means easier to break or scratches
I bought x3 and I'm do frustrated with the 72mb photo quality. I feel the my sansung flip 3 12mb camera is better than the x3 72mb 😞 Anyone cares to illuminate me please?
This was the most honest and comprehensive review I've seen for this category of cameras.
What an amazingly in-depth comparison between all these 360 cameras.
Thank you for this review and comparison. It has helped inform my decision. I've really been struggling with the choice of x3 vs 1", but I've decided to go with the x3. My primary use is going to be recording scenic drives, with an upcoming winter driving tour of Southern Utah as the impetus for buying my first 360 camera.
How do you like the x3
@@A1Bokeh I'm really enjoying it.
Great video comparison! I went with the Insta360 RS 1inch 360 for the modularity and video quality. Was really torn between that and the convenience of the X3.
No worries, both are great choices 👌🏻
Same
Bought and X3 yesterday. Will definitely be trying it out for low light and astrophotography. Not expecting dslr quality but maybe mobile phone quality. Unfortunately the 1 inch is way out of my budget
Excellent video ! I hope Insta360 will add HDR video to the 1-Inch 360 edition in the near future or maybe release a new engine module One R2 with HDR video, finally it is a modular camera, one point that you did not mention but is another point in favor of the 1-Inch 360 edition
Excellent analysis! I'm deciding if the time has come to move on from my One R to either the One RS or the X3. I thought the modularity would be useful, but I've found that I rarely change to the 4K lens (I grab my Hero 7 instead). I don't trust the waterproofing of the R and am thinking that trading modularity for better waterproofing might be a good choice. My only hesitation at this point is that the X3 is limited to 60 fps except in bullet time mode. I'd like to be able to shoot 100, or 180 fps in a direction of my choosing, but bullet time seems to point down the selfie stick.
Insta360 will be introducing .
100fps (in 3k) in a firmware upgrade soon, they advise
Sir, your comment really helped me choosing X3 over One RS Twin Edition! Thanks heaps!! 👏🏼
360 1 inch has the best video quality and I hope they bring HDR with firmware update.
No way! Readout of that 1“ sensor is too slow for HDR!
I have the one x 2 for a year now and I love it. Just updated to x3 can't wait for it to arrive.
YES!! Love this twice-a-year review!!
Amazingly well produced and edited review comparison! Much appreciated!!
Amazing comparison! Looking for my first 360 camera and this helps immensely
I picked up the Insta360 RS 1inch 360. It was expensive. I regretted my purchase at 1st because I was having issue with the clarity of the videos, but I think it was just my over expectations and my lack of understanding how to edit 360 videos properly. Either way, I have it now, and gonna have to live with the purchase.
Still happy with my oneX2. I miss active HDR but I feel more comfortable with a smaller screen (when doing sports) that is less exposed to get dammaged.
Great Review!!
Had the X2, and find the X3 way better! Not because of those mushy 72MP, but because the QuadBayer Sensor enables video possibilities like ActiveHDR. Unfortunately the 1inch (that I own, too) does not deliver it, as you mentioned. And I think, it will never! I don’t think, it’s marketing! It’s more about the readout speed of that huge sensor. With a tiny sensor like in the X2, you can readout fast enough to produce sequential HDR in good light. The QuadBayer Sensor of the X3 can deliver parallel HDR, which is much better. The 1inch sensor on the other can’t be read out fast enough for sequential HDR without strong artefacts - that’s why we don’t have HDR video.
I think you’re right 😁
👍
Great video. What about action like skiing, bike riding, motorcycle, and cars?
What about it?
@@BenClaremont what 360 camera would you recommend? I have been looking for a good one for my motorcycle.
Great, simple and precise comparison videos. Thanks for the content.
Was definitely waiting for this video. Thanks! I'm sold on the X3 after watching your previous videos.
Many thanks for the clear, to the point comparison. I would say X3 is the best overall given its price.
Great comparison Ben! For 360-tours i prefer the Trisio. And for 360-video i like the 1 inch the most.
🙏🏻👍🏻💪🏻
Thank you for the excellent comparison. I recently purchased the X2, and although I regret not waiting for the X3, I cannot justify upgrading to the X3.
Fantastic comparaison Ben 👍As expected the photo quality of X3 is conformed to size sensor so indeed do not choose only with specs and big number as 72 MP of X3.
Trisio is performing well, perfect for low budget and virtual tours.
Now waiting for GoPro MAX 2 ... but not expecting huge changes on specs, may be more on sensor size (1/2 ?),HDR mode at least for photo, and 10bits colors
Regards
Fabien
why did he say the insta 360 not good for virtual tours?
Said that you would deliver, and you did 💪🏾
Great video. Shopping for my first 360 camera and this was an awesome place to start. Cheers.
Thanx for this video, it's complete...
I just bought the Insta360 One RS twin edition, because of its versatility. And so far i am chuffed with it.
Would i have chosen the X3? i think not because i would like to switch to regular actioncam for certain shots, the one inch would be to big and less versatile again, but it would be an upgrade i could consider.
Ben, it's a great comparison.. what might be the best choice for creating some serious virtual tours including low light conditions, theta z1 or theta x or one rs 1 inch?
Most excellent test report of the 360 cameras I have ever seen in 2022!
Just got the X3, already so happy with it!!!
Thanks Ben for always providing fantastic & well produced reviews & advise in all your videos you share.
Nice and useful comparison. I don't think I'm in the market for 360 yet but I could be strongly tempted if GoPro introduced a newer one.
I edit both gopros 360 max , and insta360s x2/x3 video for skydiving, in my opinion the insta360 is a much more pleasant experience. The stich lines on the max are clearly obvious in frame, where the insta360 blend in almost invisible. Hardware alone tho. Workflow/ editing gopro max is horrible with gopro quick or player. The software isn't intuitive at all and the .360 files seem very problematic when trying to use them. Insta360 studio by far is the easiest to drop the video in and edit with a key framing approach that actually makes sense. To the point where il readily export gopro 360 max to h.26 360, and then use insta360 studio to key framed them from there. I own the 360 Max, but I wish I would have bought an x3, or 1inch instead. Something for you to think about if you decide to get into 360.
@@derekremington8807 I appreciate the feedback! Insta 360 seems to be really aggressively targeting the 360 market and I've heard good things about their general responsiveness on firmware updates and the improvements of the software. I think it's a great concept but it would be a hobby for me so it would be lying around a lot and I'm not at the point where I can justify the cost. And I'm honestly not cool with some of their design choices and earlier firmware quirks and just think that GoPro is capable of doing it better if they decided to. I have to admit though that my interest is piqued and I'm fairly certain that I would talk myself into one before our next vacation. 😂
@@derekremington8807 Derek, I have a question for you since you actually edit the files: What is the maximum resolution you can export to? I've seen one person say it's only 1080p and quite a few video reviews of the X3 don't even mention it. Also, I've learned that there is also the somewhat new One RS 1 Inch 360 Edition. I wouldn't think that it's the best fit for sky diving but it might be exactly what I would be looking for.
@@markwornom1050 max resolution is quite variable. Few factors in play. The max resolution stated on the box for 360 cameras is for the entire 360 degree shot. So when you keyframe it, you are taking a small portion of that resolution out of the total. And depending on how far you zoom out or zoom in on a key framed shot (not 360 shot) that also affects resolution, zooming in giving you even smaller piece of the overall resolution if that makes sense. During editing, during the export phase, finishing a video you can upscale back up to 4k. But it's not nearly as crisp or detailed as a normal camera that is recording 4k resolution in a non 360 key frame if that makes sense. Feel free to check my channel out. I have many videos that were recorded with both standard gopro cameras, and my 360 max. You can tell the difference, but over all quality is still great. More of a use case situation really. I prefer 360 in skydiving because it allows me to do the jump and catch everything around me, without having to chase a single person as much. Il post a link. Normal gopro video looks more crisp and non distorted, where the max video still looks great but can have a fish eye effect in certain cases trying to get certain shots.
@@markwornom1050 ua-cam.com/video/yNN850XoWaQ/v-deo.html
I am a bowhunter and fisherman. I fish from a kyak a few times a year as well. Low light is not a big deal for fishing, but for hunting it very much can be. Would you pick the 1 inch or the x3 for this type of application? Nothing fast moving most likely, but potential to have them out and maybe get rained on a little from a pop up rain shower while hunting before I can get it put away. Or potentially while being snowed on it may be put and on if animals are nearby. Which would you think is a better fit for this? Fishing trips in summer will be very bright settings, and pristine and distant dynamic range won’t be as critical for either fishing, or bowhunting in close quarters. What do you think being a camera reviewer and have used them?
This was a very insightful video, thank you
Well done! On point.. sharp and crisp explanation. Love from India 🥂
Bought a 1 Inch at launch as I felt like the quality was finally at a level where it was worth having the separate camera just for it + impending Matterport support.
Seeing those dynamic range tests was a real killer 😂 I would still make the same decision but seeing a lower level camera leaps and bounds above the 1 Inch in a department that I regularly notice as a downfall of the 1 Inch is a pain. Crazy that they didn't implement that super effective ActiveHDR in their "best".
If Leica/insta360 used a Sony IMX586 sensor then it has a quad bayer filter which can be used for real time video HDR coding as it can make 2 frames at the same time (a short and a long exposure frame what can be merged to make HDR). One inch is 4 times bigger than the RS sensor size and there is 2 of them. With this math this sensor needs 4x computational power to merge different exposure frames this means 4x the power it needs to run and 4x the heat generated. If leica used their own sensor then it is possible it is not a quad bayer, but some other alteration in which case there is no HW to make video HDR.
Agreed. Apparently it’s a limitation with the 1-inch sensor that doesn’t allow a HDR video mode. Still, frustrating.
@@BenClaremont That's a real shame. Thanks for letting me know, let's hope it's improved upon in future 🤞
The normal Bayer Sensor can only shoot sequential HDR, so no chance for that active HDR like recorded in the X3 with the QuadBayer sensor. And for sequential HDR the readout might be to slow to produce decent quality under real world light surroundings.
The normal Bayer Sensor can only shoot sequential HDR, so no chance for that active HDR like recorded in the X3 with the QuadBayer sensor. And for sequential HDR the readout might be to slow to produce decent quality under real world light surroundings.
Looks like the X3 at this time seems to meet all the requirements I need. Thank you for the review of all the 360 cameras. i was wondering what other 360 mode cameras there were. You answered all my questions.
Still looking at insta360 X3 videos in how they work. I currently do not have one.
Take care.
As of February 2023, is there any reason to get an X3 when you can get a One RS with the 360 lens for about the same price but have more versatility?
Here is how I see it (although I may be wrong so please correct me if needed):
X3: Great 360 shots / Subpar Flat Action shots in 4K single lens mode
One RS: Great 360 shots with 360 lens / Great Flat Action shots with 4K lens
Thé X3 because of it is the easiest to operate on the filed, and it is the most well balanced between all usages ! Thanks Ben for this video !
Thank you, great review...I have been on the fence for 3 years with 360...still waiting for quality of video/photos to get better.
Good comparison, thanks Ben. I don’t have a 360 camera yet. A few years back I got a Samsung Gear, but after trying it a few times I threw it away - the quality was so bad that it was unusable even for casual use. As for the current models, my challenge is that I want one that will do it all - good quality 360 video and photos, both for hiking and potentially virtual tours at some point. It seems like none of the consumer 360 cameras are at that level yet.
Nice review. In my opinion the display is not important to check the picture, because it takes always a 360 view, so what for?
It’s better for changing settings and previewing your shots 👍🏻
Thanks for your video, I've just received my x3 after watch your video ;) I think it's really good camera for beginners especially with the big screen and Insta 360 app.
Insta360 responded to a UA-cam video saying in a future firmware update to the X3 they will add the 3K at 100fps.
Thanks for this video Ben! Upgrading from Mi Sphere and now I know what to get.
Great review here, prob going to go with the X3
Ben Thanks for this comparison video. There is always something to discover in the videos you produce. For the moment I'm fine with the Z1 😇
Nice review Ben! I'm going to go for the X3. Cheers
Thank for another review Ben. I am sill happy using my Z1, and do not see me upgrading to any of the other cameras at this time
Good day. I simply wanted to reach out and thank you for the tremendous video reviews you provide. I purchased the Insta360 Pro 2, and realized I purchased way too much camera for my intensions, and the form factor was unwieldy, so resold it. If price wasn't an object and my interest is in video and still, considering ease of use and form factor, would you still recommend the X3? And finally, do you have a commission link to the cameras you recommend? I am happy to purchase and to support you if there is a means to do that. Thanks kindly.
Thanks! Yes I have links in the description of this video. I think a combination of X3 and 1-inch will provide best results in all situations for 360 video 👍🏻
Thanks for your comparison. I just bought Insta360 X3.
My man, you are awesome. This was very helpful 😍
This was 100% the video I needed. This was amazing.
🙏🏻
Still going to do more research but leaning towards the X3. I am a Realtor so I would like to be able to do virtual tours but, realistically, video is replacing virtual tours in the real estate business.
I would love if you cover the timelapse photography mode pf the insta 360 cameras. The shutter speed matters a lot when taking street imagery and slow shutyers results in some blurry pics.
Great comparison between these cameras mate! Thank you
Great video ! So i been struggeling to find any asnwer to this anywhere, but i will ask here as well. For nature walks, biking, fishing, a bit indoor maybe in tourist places. Mainly taking 360 pictures, but also video, not sure only 4360 or also flat. Is the X3 the best bet in that pricerange here in 2023. I am first time 360 cam byer and just got a bit fascinated by the 360 option for stills, seeing how well it has upped in quality the past few years.
Outstanding!
I'm waiting for the next Trisio...
❤
thank you for the awesome video.
I am curious about cropping capabilities between Insta360 x3 and the 1 inch version. I would like to be able to crop approx 6x on post edit. which one would you recommend between the x3 and the 1 inch. thank you
Is it still worth it to buy One X2 now for a first timer 360 camera user, even the price is not reduced (yet)?
I would just spend the extra $20 and get the X3
Tks Ben, it would be nice to have the review for video and VT for the new Lab Pano (PilotPano) compared with your choices as best in this last video…
*awesome video*
Can you maybe test the X3 microphones more indepth? Like with wind and such and during action? Compared to the RS and other main competitors? Thanks! Keep em coming 🙌🙌👌
I will wait for One RS2 or OneX4 to buy :)) Because they are still not enough for live broadcasts and virtual tours. I'll wait for them to be full 8K.
Excellent objective review covering all the bases. Very helpful, thanks.
You’re the best Ben! What a great comparison video mate!
Glad you liked it 😁
These info means a lot to a beginner like me. I'm so thankful to chance upon your videos and your valuable input on which cam to buy. Definitely your followers now. 👍 👍 👍
🙏🏻
Great 360 video review. Now Subscribed. IYO is the X3 a suitable fit for motorcycling? Can you recommend the connectable to handle bar selfie attachment/stick? Thx
👍🏻
Thanks for the video. Considering all factors, I would go for the Insta360 X3.✌
I've had a Ricoh Theta S since 2015 and the battery is completely dead now. I haven't used it in a couple of years and have been wanting to upgrade for a while. I'm glad I waited until now with the arrival of the Insta360 X3. I didn't want to spend much more than $500 on a new 360 camera so that's the perfect price and it has everything I need and more for a 360 camera. I'm going to get one next month. I can't wait and so excited to start shooting 360 again. Thanks for your reviews and tutorials. :)
That will be a big upgrade! Hope you enjoy the new camera 👍🏻
the battery in the theta S is easily replaceable
@@francomelechi8085 Good to know but I can't really be bothered at this point with such an old camera. I'd rather upgrade to something with much better quality, way more functions and features and much more user friendly.
@@kelex12 I agree, …I still have it despite having other more performing ones
*I just bought this because I had the One RS and I upgraded because I wanted the Me Mode because I think that's a Game Changer that no one else has and I'd be surprise it the next gen of ANY 360 will have it.*
Thank you, your review has been very helpful. I am going for the Insta 360 X3
Excellent. Thanks! Just the review I was looking for!
Excellent review. Answered all my questions
I've subscribed because this has been most well explained comparison yet. Well done!
🙏🏻
Hi Ben,
In the x3 with active hdr mode is it possible to record at 30 fps?
In the insta360 R with hdr video mode you can record only at 25 fps.
It means more dynamic range but no chance to use most of the templates in shot lab section of the smartphone app.
Great review as usual
Yes you can 👍🏻
Please Ben Answer my question. For cinematic motorcycle riding (no enduro 60fps hardcore, just 24/30fps traveling on the road), to make youtube content (big screen) which camera you recommend?. The light conditions while motorcycle riding are generally outdoors, blue skies, blazing sun across the clouds and fast changes of light while crossing trees, and somewhat opaque rainy days here and there. I don't ride at night or in the rain. My focus is on video quality. The 1inch seems the best video quality but with no active HDR the X3 seems to be most fit for the ligh conditions. Maybe they will add active HDR as a firmware update? or you don't see this happening at all? Whats your opinion? Have you tested the 1-inch while driving?
Go the X3 👍🏻
Hi Ben. Thx for sharing your expertise. Actually, I did purchase my first 360 cam recently so I got a X3..😉 Your video did confirm my choice according what I plan to do with the action camera.
Well demonstrated...thank you man.
Great review Ben! Seen INSIDE any of these cams? Need OEM supply of SEPARABLE sensor modules for packaging and aerodynamics, for high speed drones/wings! (Know about 'Sphere' but would prefer bigger sensors: >=1/2"
I haven’t seen inside them, no.
I suspect that HDR mode might be improved on the X3 for photos.
Using this on the X2 makes big difference.
Then we might see much improved.
I suspect that firmware upgrades will improve other aspects.
Thanks I went with the X3 and for me it would be a entrance camera to 360 pics and video
Can you live stream with either the insta x3 or 1 inch?
My man...
THIS is how a review is supposed to be made!
Well done dude, well done 🍻
My pleasure 🙏🏻
Hands down the best 360 channel and best personality for it.
Cheers David
Hey! Awesome video 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
I want to get a 360 camera but I’m not sure if I should wait for a new one, you know, GoPro comes with a new camera each year, same as other technology.. Do you have any idea when insta360 could launch an X4 or a 1” v2?? 🙏🏼
Thanks again Ben for the content and for your fantastic analysis.
My pleasure 😇
This is the most outstanding 360 camera review I've seen. Worth the sub mate. Thank you. Only thing a newbie (like me) might wonder is; what is active HDR & Dinamic range? The research continues...
Thanks Richard! Dynamic range refers to how balanced the image brightness looks- bad dynamic range is basically shots that are too high in contrast
@@BenClaremont you are a legend mate. Now I understand why you are so surprised that such an expensive camera as the RS1inch doesn't have that. In theory it sounds like a hugely beneficial technology. But in your testing scenarios it didn't appear that the RS1inch was lacking in anything. I wonder if having larger sensors make HDR redundant to some degree. I'm about to check your other videos as you've probably explained it. Thanks again 👍
Now that my Mi Sphere is dead (by drowning) I'm looking at your comparisons with a different eye. :D Use is and will be social media, and I'm leaning towards the X3, which seem to offer the best quality for the price and the use case.
I bought the Mi Sphere just to try 360, paid it just above 100$, one of the last stocks before disappearing from the stores and I got hooked!
Love your content!
Thanks for this great video comparison! I would like ti buy the rs twin edition and 4k module. But the presentation of x3 Made me in confusion. I think i ll buy the x3 but in single lens mode 4k is great also like the rs? Tnx
Hi! About 2 months ago I bought the One RS 4k without the 360 Lens. Do You recommend me to buy the 360 lens or sell It and buy the X3? I mainly use It for motorcycle and travel video to post on social media. Please help me! 🙏 Thanks in Advance and congratulations for the review!
Can you compare the single lens mode on the X3 vs RS 4k boost mod?
Thanks for the info. Have you tried doing moving 360 capture with a Eclipse Rover? Amazing....
I haven’t
Awesome review Ben, thank you!
Ive got the X3 and the RS 1"360 and Im really please they came out on top in your review!
How do you think they would cope vs the One R 1" front facing lens mod??
Awesome, in-depth review. One the fence of keeping the 1" 360 or returning it to get the X3. I use it to shoot inside a plane cockpit and dynamic range is a problem. The outside is bright on day flights, but the cockpit is obviously in shade. Night video with my GoPro 360 Max is terrible. Not worth producing. So, I thought the Insta360 1" may work there.
amazing video, as usual! Do you think in the future it will be released a new 360 module (similar to X3) for the insta360 RS?
Probably not
LOL. Great timing! (also just subscribed. Hi!) I literally just bought a Ricoh Theta SC, used from ebay for $50 two days ago... It's working but with a minor scratch on the lens, hence the cheap price. I've wanted a Theta / 360 camera after borrowing one a couple years back, and using it to make 360 photos for a web-based google street-view-like walkaround of a lego theme park I made with my kid. (it had excellent focus up close, so it worked great for it!) and for $50 it was too good a deal to pass up. I know i can get better ones for ~$130 used, (or more for the SC2, etc), but this should be fine for me. :D
Very helpful review. Thanks!
For the last years I used the Theta Z1, especially for real estate 360 photo assignments. HDR photo's are extremely good so far. But a walking video is a no-go. Just a messy result and not much post processing options as the Insta360. Insta360 studio does a great job what I've seen. For now I will purchase the Insta360 x3 for video after watching your very helpful reviews but probably keeping the Theta Z1 for it's great HDR photo's...
insta 360 ok to use for virtual tours in real estate?
@@airbnbphotography When there is enough light, Insta360 will do the job just fine I think.
@@Elco63 the new version has so many features
great review, what, if any, rumors are there out there about the next gen 360 video cameras? I view the X3 as a moderate feature upgrade to the x2 (which I have) so I am waiting for the sensor increase to deliver the next higher resolution. 5.7k/1080p edited is like 4 or so years in the running, when do these cameras go up higher?