Unique Themes | Monthly Debrief S4E5 | May 2024 | The Players' Aid

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
  • Noble Knight Games: nobleknight.com
    Patreon: / theplayersaid
    Tee Shirts: teespring.com/...
    Website: theplayersaid.com

КОМЕНТАРІ • 76

  • @randylein7426
    @randylein7426 3 місяці тому +4

    Guys, this video is almost two hours long and still it's not enough! Thanks for the shout out for Legion Wargames, on numerous occasions, we do tend towards non-mainstream topics. FYI, Invasion Malta is the "hypothetical" invasion of Malta in either 1941, 1942, or 1943, and Leros is the historical battle of the invasion of that island.
    I was very impressed that of all the wargames you have played, over all the years (and laughs and tears) that it was Demyansk Shield that holds such a high rank as one of the best memories. The game is nearly out of stock so others agree with your assessment of the game.
    Randy Lein
    Legion Wargames

  • @strelnikoff1632
    @strelnikoff1632 3 місяці тому +7

    chock full of good war game chatter. Good episode.
    Related to Colonial Twilight (Algerian civil war), I'd recommend a little known but interesting movie, "The Last Command" (1966). Opening scene depicts the French Legionnaires surrendering at Dien Binh Phu who are eventually returned to France and assigned to Algeria only to be involved in another war for independence. A good watch for movie-history hobbyists-fans.
    Stars Anthony Quinn and the very beautiful Claudia Cardinale 💖 RIP. Currently streaming on Prime Video.

  • @AdamMisnik
    @AdamMisnik 3 місяці тому +2

    "Redvers Reverse" Battle of Colenso 1899, 2nd Anglo Boer War 1899-1902. Also from Legion Wargames, and even more obscure, is "Hill of Doves" about the battle of Majuba-Laings Nek 1881 and the 1st Anglo Boer War 1880-81 (just Dec to Mar total).

  • @willburton6622
    @willburton6622 2 місяці тому

    I think that the best introduction to COIN is The British Way!

  • @WdTPD
    @WdTPD 2 місяці тому

    LOVE this topic, and you touch on a bunch of games that I'm interested in - the game in the thumbnail specifically caught my eye (and I think you mentioned it before on the channel). As someone that was drawn to wargames thru these other type of "unique" games and topics - tribes steering the heads of ruling powers (Pax Pamir), social uprisings against puppet dictators (Cuba Libre) - this is near and dear to my heart.
    I think the thing that puts these games and topics on the fringe of the typical wargame is that they are less about firepower and "might is right", it's not about the strength of your forces and placement of troops, but the other factors and some times non-combatant involvement.
    I'm especially curious about the High Flying Dice games and recently itemized that whole Indigenous Warfare series for a potential bulk order. Grant is right, that would make an excellent mega-pack!

  • @barngames1785
    @barngames1785 3 місяці тому +2

    Guys, The Last Blitzkrieg is the BEST BCS game to play multiplayer. There are so many formations that it's just made for multiple players taking 4-6 formations apiece. With random formation activation (You draw 3 activation chits and whichever side draws 2 formation activation counters first gets to activate one of those formations. Makes it very fun! Last game I played was an 8 player game online. It took a while to finish but was a blast for everyone.

  • @MeanderingMikesManCave
    @MeanderingMikesManCave 3 місяці тому +1

    Machiavelli was originally published by BattleLine. When Avalon Hill bought out BattleLine they reprinted Machiavelli with the original cover, which was much less creepy. Then AH put out a 2nd edition in 1995, and that is when they introduced the creepy cover, which is Bartolomeo Colleoni, the general of the Venetian army during the 15th century. (Machiavelli himself was a rather handsome dude).

  • @cardboardconflicts
    @cardboardconflicts 2 місяці тому

    I’ve played Hill of Doves on the FIRST Boer War! 😁 another fantastic Legion solo game.

  • @Smoot1990
    @Smoot1990 3 місяці тому

    Vangelis Bagiartakis that did Freedom is a profound designer! He recently also created the GOTY, Hegemony!

  • @philipdennis7820
    @philipdennis7820 3 місяці тому +2

    The card game you couldn’t remember sounds like Scout

  • @tacticaljackie4023
    @tacticaljackie4023 3 місяці тому

    Great stream Alexander and Grant.

  • @JoshuaLivie
    @JoshuaLivie 3 місяці тому

    This gave me some new games to explore. I love games that give a unique experience! I like the smaller publisher recommendations too.

  • @jameshiers9679
    @jameshiers9679 3 місяці тому +1

    Yes, yes we are, and loving every minute.
    You look like you’ve lost weight Grant - looking good!
    Cheers!

  • @davidoduffy6168
    @davidoduffy6168 3 місяці тому

    Absolutely love the Monthly Debrief videos. Always good irrespective of the topic although that can also be awesome. Really enjoy the banter back and forth and also hear yo7 both very loud and clear ee Rhein addictive qualities of purchases etc . Have Ukraine 43 2nd edition yet to play it. Keep em coming boys!

  • @rodgersamuel2519
    @rodgersamuel2519 3 місяці тому +10

    "Gest" is pronounced "jest." It means a deed [an action, not an ownership document] and it's related to the word, "gesture." By extension, it also means an adventure or exploit, or a story about adventures/exploits, for exmple, a Gest of the Knights of the Round Table.

    • @derMikester
      @derMikester 3 місяці тому

      Jabo is more accurately pronounced “Yabo” in German. Ghabo no no 😊

  • @kencampbell7791
    @kencampbell7791 3 місяці тому

    Keep up the wonderful work, thanks guys. Great session!

  • @LaboratoryGrey
    @LaboratoryGrey 3 місяці тому

    I try not to say "modern classic", but The Crew is a modern classic. Glad you got to try it!
    And thanks for the suggestions. Very curious about some of the HFG titles now.

  • @henryrodriguez6260
    @henryrodriguez6260 3 місяці тому

    Great topic and vid. I agree Legion and Hollandspiele are the most consistent in tackling unusual topics. My collection is such now that I generally only add one to my collection if it covers a new topic (though I focus on ancient and medieval games).
    FYI, check out MMP TCS game on The Battle of Leros.

  • @MeanderingMikesManCave
    @MeanderingMikesManCave 3 місяці тому

    By the way, Frank Chadwick did a game on Velikiye Luki from Game Designers Workshop in 1979 called White Death. This makes me think of an idea for your channel ... select one game a month from the 70s or 80s and give it a play! Old dinosaurs need love too! 😉

  • @larryjex215
    @larryjex215 3 місяці тому

    Glad the topic suggestion was helpful! Great discussion as always and more games to add to the wishlist!

  • @martynbrawn76
    @martynbrawn76 3 місяці тому

    From old French Chanson de geste were epic poems of great deeds performed by minstrels and troubadours. Also resonant of the novel Beau Geste by P.C.Wren.

  • @derMikester
    @derMikester 3 місяці тому

    Nice monthly update as always Gents.

  • @marksieber8140
    @marksieber8140 3 місяці тому

    I often take a couple or three games in my large hardshell suitcase, floating in socks, T-shirts, and like. So far, they have survived the trips, and if TSA did open the suitcase, they didn’t mess with the arrangement.

  • @wmarclocher
    @wmarclocher 3 місяці тому

    38:18 Looking forward to how you think A Gest Of Robin Hood fits as an introduction to the COINS series.. If it is as good or better tutorial British Way.
    (Key advantage at preset for me is that Gest is easier to purchase a copy than B.W.)

  • @henriwhitehead
    @henriwhitehead 3 місяці тому

    Great banter!

  • @charleslatora5750
    @charleslatora5750 3 місяці тому +2

    Legion. The Great Game
    1837-1886 Rival Empires in Central Asia. Book/movie adjacent: Kipling's: Kim

  • @charleslatora5750
    @charleslatora5750 3 місяці тому

    Thanks for reminding me about Halls of Montezuma. Guess they're doing a second printing with a bigger box and that's coming out 3rdQtr

  • @ExLibrisbyMikeBooklover
    @ExLibrisbyMikeBooklover 3 місяці тому

    Great episode!

  • @MrProulx
    @MrProulx 3 місяці тому

    One of the best games is that big green box with the chess knight on it. Nothing tops it for me.

    • @ThePlayersAid
      @ThePlayersAid  3 місяці тому

      It's a fantastic game, but we didn't mention it in this one because there's a lot of games covering GWOT in some form or another, maybe not at that scale but that's why it was omitted.

  • @doeleen
    @doeleen Місяць тому

    Gentlemen, fantastic as always. What is the map on the table?

  • @johnsy4306
    @johnsy4306 3 місяці тому

    1. I have never had a problem with damaged boxes when bringing home loot from WBC back to the Philippines in my checked baggage so I'm a bit curious what happened with you.
    2. Allen Dickerson is designing an intro level game in the GBACW series. It's not Simple GBoH because that's a rule system. The game Allen is designing is simpler battles with fewer counters, etc.
    3 In Manila: The Savage Streets, I can see the area where my mother lives and since I only live about two minutes from her then by extension, I can sort of see where I live. Not exactly, of course, because I can't tell what streets are what except for the major ones. But I can see certain landmarks of the city on the map.

    • @ThePlayersAid
      @ThePlayersAid  3 місяці тому

      I might have overpacked it with 3 games. I tried to protect the with clothes but 2 got damaged.

    • @johnsy4306
      @johnsy4306 3 місяці тому

      @@ThePlayersAid The game I mentioned in item 2 was BY SWORD AND BAYONET

  • @coyi51
    @coyi51 3 місяці тому

    An other excellent debrief, with so many games that are on my wish list. Two small games I play are Resist & Saladin(Shakos)I must get around to buying border states. Love Legion Games, I have the three cavalry affairs, which I really enjoy, also need to get Target for tonight & Invasion Malta. Possibly on the horizon Werwolf & Russo-Japanese War. The who knows when games Failure on the Tugela & Libertadores del Sur. South American wars a source on untouched material? Many thanks Gentlemen.

  • @rikiwroteasongthud
    @rikiwroteasongthud 3 місяці тому

    Do you have a link to buy the organizers?

  • @ThymeKeeper
    @ThymeKeeper 3 місяці тому

    Fred Serval always pronounces it "jest"

  • @charleslatora5750
    @charleslatora5750 3 місяці тому

    Unique? The Lost Provinces. By Hollandspiel. 1941. Thai vs French

  • @cardboardconflicts
    @cardboardconflicts 2 місяці тому

    Maria you NEED 3 to play but I think is more interesting than Friedrich with the politics and team dynamics. System wise they very similar.

  • @A._J_.
    @A._J_. 3 місяці тому

    Noble Knight clearing out slowmovers from inventory?

  • @iansanderson2567
    @iansanderson2567 2 місяці тому

    Machiavelli is a much better game than Deplomacy. So much better, especially if you use the currency.

  • @yurlady01
    @yurlady01 3 місяці тому

    So Grant...you mentioned you are interested in playing Legion Games "The Battle of Adobe Walls". I have all 3 battles of the series and never played, and I'm about to put them to sales....If you are interested, let me know....

    • @ThePlayersAid
      @ThePlayersAid  3 місяці тому

      What are you pricing them at?

    • @yurlady01
      @yurlady01 3 місяці тому

      ​@@ThePlayersAid $60 for all 3 + shipping/handling (about $20-22 dollars, shipping from Schenectady NY Priority Mail) Adobe was the only one that is punched and clipped, but never had the chance to put it on the table; the other 2 boxes are unpunched. Let me know if this is ok for you guys.

    • @yurlady01
      @yurlady01 3 місяці тому

      Guys...We can negotiate if I went to high on the price. If you still have an interest in the one or all of them, let me know before I send the list of games to noble knight.

  • @drewkennewell4267
    @drewkennewell4267 3 місяці тому

    Gest is pronounced with a soft G fellas.

    • @ThePlayersAid
      @ThePlayersAid  3 місяці тому

      You're gonna hate our review 😅

    • @drewkennewell4267
      @drewkennewell4267 3 місяці тому

      @@ThePlayersAid Just dub in the correct pronunciation 😄

  • @ThymeKeeper
    @ThymeKeeper 3 місяці тому

    I dislike the idea of using "COIN adjacent" as "an introduction to COIN". It can get you in the door I guess, but in the end, it's not COIN. If it was, there would be no need for a new series.

    • @ThePlayersAid
      @ThePlayersAid  3 місяці тому

      I agree that COIN adjacent should be used as a blanket 'intro to COIN'

  • @martynbrawn76
    @martynbrawn76 3 місяці тому +3

    Spent many happy hours at university in the mid 1980s playing Machiavelli. I always seemed to play the Papal States and would end up squeezed between Naples and France while Venice had more ducats than they knew what to do with and would spread across northern Italy like a Rennaissance contagion.

  • @WouterSchoutteten
    @WouterSchoutteten 3 місяці тому +2

    Love the (almost) monthly debrief, still one of the best formats on YT. Informative, complete, bit of banter. Your praise for Lion of Judah really makes me want to hunt down a copy! Fascinating history and a WW2 theater rarely covered in games.

  • @ZharelAnger
    @ZharelAnger 3 місяці тому +2

    GMT directly sells 2" and 3" boxes. They are white, so you would need to either write with permanent marker or glue the old box's panels to the sides that you want to display to identify the game. Ugly yes, but it's better than putting your gameboard in a zip lock bag. Better yet, buy sturdy boxes just to carry games when you travel.

  • @ThymeKeeper
    @ThymeKeeper 3 місяці тому +2

    That Tippecanoe map is incredible. I want the game just so I can own that.

  • @lukec1146
    @lukec1146 24 дні тому

    Just picked up a unique themed game, Chaco, about the 1932-35 Paraguay/Bolivia war. Set in the desert and jungle, the logistics are key. Interesting asymmetry and WW1 type problems, this conflict resulted in the biggest loss of life in the 20 Century in South America.

  • @ArnoVdVelde
    @ArnoVdVelde 3 місяці тому

    I think I messed up. I had the opportunity to snag the Last Blitzkrieg, Baptism by fire and Brazen Chariots Opened but unpunched. For 200.
    And I just ended up getting Brazen Chariots to try it out.
    Although my hope is that one day Last Blitzkrieg will get an update with the colored banners. (baptism by fire is of such a footprint it feels less nessecary) but with MMP that might be unlikely who knows.

  • @jbthor03
    @jbthor03 3 місяці тому

    I saw a copy of Ukraine 43 at Games Plus in Chicago on a recent visit. I didn’t look to see what edition but I think it was probably 1st. You might check with them if you’re still looking. I suspect they ship games on occasion

  • @nickvandam1214
    @nickvandam1214 3 місяці тому

    1960 the Making of the President, Votes for Women, Freedom the Underground Railroad, Unforgiven: Lincoln Assassination Trial

  • @davidheath4171
    @davidheath4171 3 місяці тому

    For Thomas van Hare's book games, you can download files from his site, Historic Wings, and cut and paste like Grant said, The incredible thing is he says he has about SEVEN products due this year. MAG 23 is also great fun, and completely differen from the others too.

  • @charleslatora5750
    @charleslatora5750 3 місяці тому

    Also Worthington's ACW game Franklin. !!

  • @manuelkooijman5757
    @manuelkooijman5757 3 місяці тому

    Love Rebel Fury. It plays so quick and is not complex at all. I am not a big hex & counter war gamer but I really enjoy this. Maybe you can argue that the counters could have looked a bit more beautiful, but that is the only little gripe.

  • @davidheath4171
    @davidheath4171 3 місяці тому

    Macchiavelli!! I used to play the heck out of that . . . about 45 years ago!! Great game. I also played by post when post was post

  • @davetroock9522
    @davetroock9522 3 місяці тому

    Nice work gents! Always engaging! I learn a ton from your videos!
    Bought Mike Lambo’s Lone Sherman Pacific, based on your recommendation Grant. It’s a blast - simple set up and rules, fast and tense! Thanks muchly!

  • @brucewachtler9093
    @brucewachtler9093 3 місяці тому

    I just got a bunch of games from the Historical Board Game Company- 55 Days of Peking and Battle of Sekigahara are mechanically similar to the Cahokia game you mentioned. I also have their Stalingrad game. All have a small footprint and play quickly which I appreciate. I picked up the Road to Independence game as well based on your review of that one.

  • @richarddefortuna2252
    @richarddefortuna2252 3 місяці тому

    MMP's Tactical Combat Series has a game on Leros, too!

  • @johnsy4306
    @johnsy4306 3 місяці тому

    Gratuitously big wargame: TRIUMPH OF CHAOS v2

  • @Lowecore
    @Lowecore 3 місяці тому

    I just joined Rally The Troops recently as well, if you need a player for Friedrich or Wilderness War add me, would love to have a game with you guys! Name: WoWoW

  • @sonsofliberty75
    @sonsofliberty75 3 місяці тому

    Kevin Zucker’s company OSG sells just boxes.

    • @ThePlayersAid
      @ThePlayersAid  3 місяці тому

      Are they sturdy like GMT or a bit thinner like MMP?

  • @khanjan5004
    @khanjan5004 3 місяці тому

    Really great video update! Loved to see Tally-Ho and also Overflight! at about the 12 minute mark, even if the latter was only a brief look. Question: what is your Instagram so I can subscribe there?