How India’s first blasphemy murderer was made Pakistan’s model citizen

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 вер 2024
  • #SecurityCode
    Little in Ilm-ud-Din’s confession tells he was engaged with the communal currents post the publication of Rangila Rasul that attacked the Prophet’s sexual morality. How India’s first blasphemy murderer - Ilm-ud-Din was made Pakistan’s model citizen. Watch Praveen Swami @PraveenSwami explain in this episode of #ThePrint Security Code
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Read the article here: theprint.in/op...
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
    / @theprintindia
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Connect with ThePrint
    » Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
    » Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
    » Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
    » Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
    » Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
    » Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
    » Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
    » Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
    » Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8

КОМЕНТАРІ • 176

  • @sankalp6872
    @sankalp6872 2 роки тому +71

    Praveen Swamy has a knack for story telling. Pakistan's list of false heroes is long but the hunger is still not over. Imran Khan is the current number one.

    • @chandekam1826
      @chandekam1826 2 роки тому

      I'd prefer he'd go in the other temporal direction. Unfortunately, that's dangerous.

    • @prajodcp7145
      @prajodcp7145 2 роки тому +1

      Imran might not be a false hero

  • @J7pat7
    @J7pat7 2 роки тому +22

    Wasn't Rangila RAsul written in response to some Muslim Writing a Book that Hindus considered offensive ? So the Hindus responded to insult to their religion by writing a book . And the Muslims who first wrote the Book insulting Hinduism responded to the Hindu response by Killing them . I can't Stand Hindu Right Wingers but this story really shows the how violent and fascist Islam is . And to make this guy a hero and Jinnah defended him .

    • @nerf2752
      @nerf2752 2 роки тому

      what Hindu right wingers?

  • @shantanushekharsjunerft9783
    @shantanushekharsjunerft9783 2 роки тому +57

    The problem of fundamentalism in Islam is the fundamentals of Islam. Like Sam Harris said the more Muslim you become the more we have to worry about you. The more Jain you become the less we have to worry about you.

    • @testingtimes8759
      @testingtimes8759 2 роки тому +3

      I think you did not hear Praveen's video. Ilm uddin knew about Rangila Rasul, its writer, and his shop and had seen him several times. There was no inclination to violence or any inflamed reaction in that long period. Even till a few days before the killing, he was normal and uncaring for Rajpal. It was only when he was publicly exposed / accused of sodomy by the boy etc. And his deep humiliation and embarrassment at that incident which made humiliated life meaningless which made him search for ways to redeem himself and his hunger to regain public goodwill and regain status of normal acceptable human being which made him search for some immediately redeeming act.. some sacrifice for religion.

  • @sb9060
    @sb9060 2 роки тому +69

    *The Doctrine* is itself the root cause. Therefore, after scientifically, psychologically analysing the mindset of the murderer, no one can brush the fanaticism inbuilt in the religious doctrine itself under the carpet.

    • @kashmir9348
      @kashmir9348 2 роки тому

      Fanaticism rofl Hindoo look in the mirror or check reports on different human rights organizations or western news outlets.

    • @sb9060
      @sb9060 2 роки тому +1

      @@kashmir9348 western countries are facing the same heat of medieval fanaticism on the street.
      No Hindu is involved in western countries out of 2 crores Hindus living there. Only one religious community (jehadis) is spreading the violence.

    • @SachinDabral94
      @SachinDabral94 2 роки тому +12

      yes you can't ignore the Fundamentals and blame the fundamentalists.

    • @asmirann3636
      @asmirann3636 2 роки тому

      @@kashmir9348 Western countries built upon the genocide of many cultures cannot be custodian of human rights.
      The blood of more than a million muslims killed in Iraq, then a million muslims killed in Syria, hundreds of thousands of muslims killed in Libya, Afghanistan, Yemen and so on, is on the hands of western countries.
      So stop quoting western countries. They are hypocrite to the core.

    • @sb9060
      @sb9060 2 роки тому +2

      @@SachinDabral94 exactly.

  • @ashishsunny7963
    @ashishsunny7963 2 роки тому +91

    All of us should do so much of blasphemy of Islam that it becomes normal😒

    • @Vizorfam
      @Vizorfam 2 роки тому +2

      Go ahead and try and just wait

    • @desistarktm7270
      @desistarktm7270 2 роки тому +20

      Nupur Sharma case:-
      Why no communal riots in PAK and BAN ?
      : Bcoz Hindus are very silent there.
      Supreme court: Well. They should stay very silent in India too.

    • @thatrajasthaniguy7862
      @thatrajasthaniguy7862 2 роки тому

      गुस्ताख ए नबी की एक ही सजा, सर तन से जुदा

    • @arjavgarg5801
      @arjavgarg5801 2 роки тому +2

      @@Vizorfam cry about it

    • @un-karnish2967
      @un-karnish2967 2 роки тому +14

      @@Vizorfam Are you threatening someone of consequences?

  • @SuspectUsual
    @SuspectUsual 2 роки тому +14

    "Islam is a mother lode of bad ideas!"
    ~~~ Sam Harris ~~~

  • @hotfun07
    @hotfun07 2 роки тому +17

    Sir,
    Rangeela Rasool wasnt written in a vacuum.
    My 2 cents.

  • @rakeshkrishnan1099
    @rakeshkrishnan1099 2 роки тому +20

    Looters nd thugs were always pakistanis hero thats why today they beg for survival

  • @thatrajasthaniguy7862
    @thatrajasthaniguy7862 2 роки тому +8

    Mahashay Rajpal was not the Author he was the publisher and i can see through how you whitewash sins of Iqbal and Jinaah.

  • @sridhar47
    @sridhar47 2 роки тому +32

    Mr Praveen Swamy, why do you not mention SITA KA CHINNALA which caused the Hindu community to retaliate by writing the so called indendiary book !!!!
    How can you present one sided argument ? Aren't you supposed to be secular, treat all sides equally??
    Or are you a hypocrite ?

    • @Vizorfam
      @Vizorfam 2 роки тому

      Stop spreading fake news

    • @awesome997
      @awesome997 2 роки тому

      What else can you expect from those who hate Muslim and Islam?

    • @mathivanangovindan2220
      @mathivanangovindan2220 2 роки тому

      In India secular means Islamic terrorism appeasers 👍😌

  • @itr8247
    @itr8247 2 роки тому +7

    Ilm uddin was honored as the first citizen of pakistan in 1947.

  • @nmg1443
    @nmg1443 2 роки тому +3

    So a mental breakdown brought by a frustrated homosexual relationship was channeled into an Islamist murder.

  • @paragtikekar3872
    @paragtikekar3872 2 роки тому +3

    Wonder why Rajpal wrote such a book. Guess, this Pravin Swamy will not tell us...

    • @offencebestdefence500
      @offencebestdefence500 2 роки тому +1

      EXACTLY
      after all it's Nupur Sharma s fault that this happened in the 1920s etc

  • @bappadityadas2170
    @bappadityadas2170 2 роки тому +4

    As Per two Sharia Court Of India Judges, Islamic Blasphemy killing was unknown to whole world before that debate day of May 2022. I don't know how to react on that. Speechless and Scared to think about future Syria like India.

  • @mbchadha
    @mbchadha 2 роки тому +8

    Very well narrated facts Praveen Swamy. I heard this story from my late father who lived in Lahore. Along with Mahasha Rajpal The assailant also injured Swamy Satya nand ji

    • @zil1832
      @zil1832 2 роки тому

      Who is satyanand?

  • @ashutoshsharma3746
    @ashutoshsharma3746 2 роки тому +7

    Do write an article on udaipur and amravati murder case too 🙏

  • @Sid-MMA
    @Sid-MMA 2 роки тому +5

    The story doesn't seem to make sense . If Ilmuddin was doing it because of his sexual guilt and just as a means of suicide then why later on in court he put up a defence?? Instead, he could have simply kill himself after murdering Rajpal . Or if he couldn't kill himself he should have simply refused to hire a lawyer and confess of the murder.

    • @ankitrawat927
      @ankitrawat927 2 роки тому

      The fear of death.

    • @IndiaTides
      @IndiaTides 2 роки тому

      You make choices and you regret it. That is common in life.

  • @dsrao7288
    @dsrao7288 2 роки тому +3

    Democratic response to sensational sloganeering, chilling fatwas and targeted executions may not yield results that majority Indians are looking for.

  • @aniketpal8338
    @aniketpal8338 2 роки тому +3

    This is not the first blasphemous murder.

  • @vijaykumar-vz7xf
    @vijaykumar-vz7xf 2 роки тому +2

    An excellent dissection and exposition of how an otherwise innocuous mind struggling to find relevance in life is so easily manipulated by myths of grandeur propagated and perpetuated to draw followers into the vortex of ideological fanaticism. Also about how irrelevant the actual cause and truth of the matter is, when an incident like this has its protagonist elevated into the pedestal of martyrdom. How appealingly a story is woven around an incident and its eventual impact on current and future followers of the ideology is all that matters. Truth is for academics...and perhaps for journalists like PS to throw light on it and let the sane few, who cares, know. An adventurous pursuit, nevertheless. Hats off.

  • @chiruboy23
    @chiruboy23 2 роки тому +1

    Killing in the name of cow meat is also a kind of blasphemy murder.

  • @oneworld2724
    @oneworld2724 2 роки тому +3

    Religion survice by fear and pain and floruish by rewards to heaven and fantasies.

  • @os4879
    @os4879 2 роки тому +3

    Perfect way of explaining

  • @kishantiwari5601
    @kishantiwari5601 2 роки тому +13

    If there was a game of mental gymnastics you would win more medals than Usain Bolt.

  • @MaveRick976
    @MaveRick976 2 роки тому +2

    Not sure why anybody would be interested in this factual gibberish 😀

  • @vivekanandholla6730
    @vivekanandholla6730 2 роки тому +9

    Thank you for the information

  • @anurag4722
    @anurag4722 2 роки тому +2

    Mene pdf download ki thi book rangila raasul ki aur paadi esa laaga jese me popat mohmmad lal ki life ke baare me nhi kisi darinde ki hawaaas ke baare me pad rha hu with proof thi wo book

  • @sudipbhattacharjee9
    @sudipbhattacharjee9 2 роки тому +1

    The fella have taken all anecdotes what Illumudin told to police or casual comments as script in the heaven book....

  • @sudipbhattacharjee9
    @sudipbhattacharjee9 2 роки тому +1

    Definitely it was not the first ...

  • @vimaldob
    @vimaldob 2 роки тому

    This why India should vote for BJP

  • @fivestartgs
    @fivestartgs 2 роки тому

    The timing of this video speaks a lot about the intention.

  • @RAVIKumarmystic
    @RAVIKumarmystic 2 роки тому +1

    Rangeela rasool is available online

  • @nishant4262
    @nishant4262 2 роки тому +1

    The print is now flirting poorly with its loyal viewers/ followers

  • @thetruthpreacher7580
    @thetruthpreacher7580 2 роки тому +2

    The best part about this is he is a BJP minority morcha member.

  • @miked999
    @miked999 2 роки тому +1

    Peacefuls ✌️

  • @Mike-qb9qt
    @Mike-qb9qt 2 роки тому

    Not pakistan Islam's model citizen

  • @somnathn553
    @somnathn553 2 роки тому

    You have not concluded with your opinion.

  • @Verstoppen69
    @Verstoppen69 2 роки тому

    wdym FIRST???

  • @dilsekibaat529
    @dilsekibaat529 2 роки тому

    Yemen humanity ad on this episode is a coincidence ?

  • @shubhamsagade497
    @shubhamsagade497 2 роки тому

    This is not first

  • @hshx1n
    @hshx1n 2 роки тому

    What is the point of this? Does anyone care about honor killers from way back? We know killers are mad and this is not even making that point. Just a stab at fools who look up to this guy. But is that the job of news channel? Start a frivolous UA-cam channel and make fun of whoever you want. Trump, Biden the list goes on. The subscribers to that channel will want to see this garbage.

  • @sudipbhattacharjee9
    @sudipbhattacharjee9 2 роки тому +1

    The fella seems to know more about Ilumudin feelings than his wife's.....ha ha.

  • @Sk-cr2bl
    @Sk-cr2bl 2 роки тому

    " घर से भागा नादानी मे "
    बीवी छोड़ दी जवानी मे "
    देश बेचा बुढापे मे "
    अंधभक्त खुश है गुलामी मे " 😅😅

    • @ashwanichandola6172
      @ashwanichandola6172 2 роки тому

      Yahi kr tu
      Next number tera hi h kanaihya Lal teli ke baad

    • @jagannathpur
      @jagannathpur 2 роки тому +1

      Sorry bro to hear your wife left you...very sad ...

    • @jaydevsinhparmar238
      @jaydevsinhparmar238 2 роки тому

      Abe laude, it was child marriage and couple is victim not culprit in child marriage

    • @heatengine9283
      @heatengine9283 2 роки тому

      Real id se aa abdool.

  • @laiqnust
    @laiqnust 2 роки тому +1

    India's first blasphemy murder in India..?
    Come on, please speak the truth.
    What will you term to all those mob lynching on the name of Cow Mata etc etc..??

    • @rutvikrs
      @rutvikrs 2 роки тому +20

      We will call them Idiots? Now what about the people killing "blasphemers"?

    • @ishaanrohmetra3447
      @ishaanrohmetra3447 2 роки тому

      killing on name of prophe, abusing of idol worshippers, killing on the name of allha because other religions dont believe in allah, killing cow . you are not a minority.
      from muslim league to direct action day and so on . muslims never condemend these riots always cried for muslims.
      have any muslim rqaise voice against hindu killing?
      you were happy before 2014 because there was muslim appeasemet politis, modi came and changed that. thats why u especially radical and muslims are butthurt.

    • @priyanshupandey2670
      @priyanshupandey2670 2 роки тому

      Both are terrorist the lyncher and the one who do beheading and one who do whataboutery is terrorist sympathizer

    • @joshuatheunkownuniverse.2475
      @joshuatheunkownuniverse.2475 2 роки тому +3

      Buddy, genocide hapoened in kashmir okay

    • @IndiaTides
      @IndiaTides 2 роки тому +1

      @@joshuatheunkownuniverse.2475 Genocide happened in Bangladesh And it is actual genocide where people actually ran away from that genocide and fought back in the end.

  • @HassanAli-xl8kr
    @HassanAli-xl8kr 2 роки тому

    Print should be banned forever spreading hate against Islam and Prophet Muhammad pbhu now on continue basis shows islamphobia of Gupta.

    • @aditya_saha
      @aditya_saha 2 роки тому +12

      muhamad was a pdf.file

    • @HassanAli-xl8kr
      @HassanAli-xl8kr 2 роки тому

      @@aditya_saha may be your talking about your own self or your parents

    • @jagannathpur
      @jagannathpur 2 роки тому +2

      It must be 54- 6 guy for Gupta bro...

    • @rajatecian1
      @rajatecian1 2 роки тому

      People hate people like you (or so called pseudo knowledgeable maulana, mufti etc.)…they don’t hate religion. But you guys are so blindfolded.
      Religión is not weak like you to need your protection. Learn to mind your own business and don’t be over sensitive BS.

    • @heatengine9283
      @heatengine9283 2 роки тому

      We should ban Islam tbh.

  • @Vizorfam
    @Vizorfam 2 роки тому

    No one has right to speak ill about religion especially of minorities

    • @manteshsharma9351
      @manteshsharma9351 2 роки тому

      A Muslim saying no-one should say ill about others religion is like a Brahmin saying nobody should talk about caste injustice...
      Stop killing people you blood thirsty pieces of shit. It's been 1400 years of your bloody maniac and world has seen enough...

    • @itr8247
      @itr8247 2 роки тому

      BS. Muslims mock other religions all the time. They will get a reply in the same manner.

    • @priyanshupandey2670
      @priyanshupandey2670 2 роки тому

      Ja n lavde blasphemy is not crime by any means..

    • @arjavgarg5801
      @arjavgarg5801 2 роки тому +14

      Why especially of minorities, why of no religion, where does this mentality of giving special treatment to minorities come from

    • @clashoflands
      @clashoflands 2 роки тому +1

      Especially minorities should listen to majority if they want to live in this country

  • @HassanAli-xl8kr
    @HassanAli-xl8kr 2 роки тому

    Long live ghazi ilam ud din shaheed

  • @mohdbilalabbasi
    @mohdbilalabbasi 2 роки тому

    Ghazi ilmdin shaheed is a martyr and he will always be remembered in the annals of history as a great man of Muslim cause in India. Same goes for the killer of bigoted swami sharadhannad who started the violent shuddhi and sangathan movements. People like these swamis and modern day yogis like Adityanath, Moditva should also be dealt with firmly.

    • @devanshtrivedi6394
      @devanshtrivedi6394 2 роки тому

      What about Your maulanas then?? Who have no other work except to incite hate

    • @dattatreyajana9215
      @dattatreyajana9215 2 роки тому +26

      Then we also regard Gau rakshaks as hero's

    • @hogginarmocount9562
      @hogginarmocount9562 2 роки тому

      U means 'anals' of pisslamic cause?🤣🤣

    • @mammothmammon
      @mammothmammon 2 роки тому +3

      It is disturbing to read your comment. It puts on display the sheer level of violence inherent in the Muslim community at this moment.

    • @MechExplained
      @MechExplained 2 роки тому +4

      Well, radicalisim and f
      Democratic person being chosen to work isn't same. Try reading book and by that i meant not the only holy script you have.

  • @pasupathikmeenakshisundara3310
    @pasupathikmeenakshisundara3310 2 роки тому +1

    Dear sir ,
    With reference to CBI chennai case Petn. no :13352/2020/BANK / CC-HQ dATED 06-01-2021. A sale deed doc.no :5001/2013 Registered against madras high court madurai bench status quo order by joint 2 tirunelveli sub registrar office. After all the previous document and related to doc no : 5001/2013 is illegal as per revenue department order
    the same document has been used to get a loan from SIDBI bank MADURAI by MOD doc no ;455/2015 by joint 2 sub registrar office ,TIRUNELVELI. Another 20 cents document of the same land has been used to get a MOD loan from melapalayam UNION BANK OF INDIA branch for the same land TS:1615. Both the loans are not repaid and become NPA.
    When we asked the tirunelveli district registrar an inquiry was conducted by tirunelveli district registrar and an order issued after four and half months to approach the court for the solution. Honorable madras high court order breached during registration of document and asked us to approach the court. OPPOSITION PARTIES NOT EVEN ATTEND THE INQUIRY CONDUCTED BY THE DISTRICT REGISTRAR. The pathetic situation is district registrar says it is a mere irregularity and order issued by the district registrar in tamil language does not matches the words and meanings of the subject between one page and next page besides does not even having the page no.
    The joke the of the century is tirunelveli municipal corporation , Revenue department accepted our rights and writ over the land. But SIDBI and RBI says at the time of sanctioning loan document title is clear But District REGISTRAR says both have the right and go to the court for settlement by breaching the court order despite of status quo order issued by madras high court madurai bench.
    Please find yourself the attached district registrar order, our appeal letter and enjoy the comedy . It is guaranteed that 100 % you will be amused and relaxed.
    Please take action.