Bengal Train Crash: System Defective, Says Report, But Railways Says Driver 'Disregarded' Signal

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 чер 2024
  • At least 15 people were killed and around 50 injured in the Kanchenjunga train accident that has once again raised concerns over railway safety in India. According to PTI, the signalling system between two stations, where the accident took place, was defective for hours before the mishap took place. Meanwhile, the Railways said that the driver of the goods train, which rammed into the express train, had disregarded the signal following which the accident took place. Watch this video for more information.
    NATIONAL NEWS
    #kanchanjungatrainaccident #kanchanjungaexpress #kanchanjungaexpressaccident #kanchanjungatrainaccidentupdate #bengaltrainaccident #trainaccident #darjeeling #mamatabanerjee #rahulgandhi #narendramodi #congress #bjp #modi #jailpaguri #kavach #trainsignalsystem #signalsystem #traincollision #odishatrainaccident #bengaltrainaccident
    Hindustan Times Videos brings all the News for the Global Indian under one umbrella. We break down news from across the globe from the unique lens of a Rising India. Tune in for Explainers, Opinions, Analysis and a 360 degree view of big events in India and the World which impact your present and future.
    Follow the Hindustan Times Channel on WhatsApp for News Alerts, Top Stories and Editor picks. Join Us Today - www.bit.ly/3PQ4kSv
    Subscribe to the Hindustan Times YT channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
    Visit our website www.hindustantimes.com/
    Follow us on Twitter / httweets
    Follow us on Facebook / hindustantimes

КОМЕНТАРІ • 121

  • @josejoseph8725
    @josejoseph8725 8 днів тому +62

    Signal signal signal........, what is this? Instead of upgrading whole railway system our railway minister is focussing only on vande bharat. Please bring back piyush goyal. Present railway minister focus only on rich vande bharat. He reduced general, sleeper coaches, no railway upgradation, no railway recruitment nothing. Seems like he forgot about middle-class, poor people who are regular commuters in railway. Regular commuters cannot pay ₹1000+ for daily travel in vande bharat.

    • @kalpananath1377
      @kalpananath1377 8 днів тому +6

      Definitely 😡😡

    • @AnirbanKar-2684
      @AnirbanKar-2684 8 днів тому +1

      🙌

    • @avdhutpawar1545
      @avdhutpawar1545 8 днів тому

      Piyush goel is of the shitiest minister. He is good for nothing.

    • @Mohmaya.89
      @Mohmaya.89 8 днів тому +1

      Even if the railways work with the same old existing technology, there were no so many accidents. Railways was the safest compared to road and air travel.
      If someone breaks the signal just like on road, accidents will happen. You can't make the railways minister stand on the track. Don't make politics of every mishap

    • @anjanadamodaran
      @anjanadamodaran 8 днів тому

      💯

  • @neo26
    @neo26 8 днів тому +26

    There's no accountability, govt. is yet to reveal the full investigation of the accident which happened last year in Balasore.
    Thoroughly unprofessional conduct.. Reel minister should take responsibility and fix the system in a time bound manner.

  • @sibashishpaul6681
    @sibashishpaul6681 8 днів тому +18

    Confusing, if we go by PTI report, then it seems railway is in hurry to blame goods loco pilot. What's happening mr. Railway minister? We don't need bullet train, first ensure safety of passengers।

    • @somdevbhattacharya
      @somdevbhattacharya 8 днів тому

      Kindly go through the GR&SR book of NFR. Rule No. 9.12. you will know who's fault it was. Freely available online.

  • @viki19910
    @viki19910 9 днів тому +15

    why he disregarded because of lack of proper rest for goods crew

    • @viki19910
      @viki19910 8 днів тому

      @@YTry1 nowadays they are more like buisness.. rather service. My father is a loco pilot. But now left that to become crew controller office work

  • @ghanashyamgogoi2877
    @ghanashyamgogoi2877 8 днів тому +14

    World largest democracy and 5th largest economy 😂😂😂😂

    • @Krishna-qv4mv
      @Krishna-qv4mv 8 днів тому

      It's going to be 4th biggest economy..The way u are celebrating this incident speak s alott.. someone like you would have compromised with railgogoi likhna chodh de lovedae tum log kbhi ni sudhrog

  • @Deepakkumar-ux1lm
    @Deepakkumar-ux1lm 9 днів тому +37

    Gift by mudi 3.0 to indian

    • @sandeshkadam-vt3eo
      @sandeshkadam-vt3eo 8 днів тому

      Pakistani bhikari abdul spotted 😂😂

    • @himansusabar5206
      @himansusabar5206 8 днів тому +4

      कहीं इस कांड के पीछे तेरा हाथ तो नेही है...?😊😊😊😊😊

    • @Akash-sk7cc
      @Akash-sk7cc 8 днів тому

      Fake ID kutey

    • @ashutoshpandeyz4508
      @ashutoshpandeyz4508 8 днів тому +5

      Iske pichhe tere bhai hai

  • @HadiaDaud89
    @HadiaDaud89 8 днів тому

    Very sad😢.......ab ye to Pakistan nhi nhi kiya na...

  • @Nitya222r
    @Nitya222r 8 днів тому +1

    Please end reservation in railways dont play with our lives...those quota guys cannot be good administrators

  • @user-nv7mc8mr2k
    @user-nv7mc8mr2k 8 днів тому +3

    These incidents are repeating bcz there is no proper punishment in India. 4 terr attacks happened within 48 hrs in j&k, 11 people lost lives but nobody is held responsible yet. Now who is responsible for this tragic incident ? Just saying "machine fault" will increase the negligence in near future.

  • @sujithmathewabraham9961
    @sujithmathewabraham9961 8 днів тому +11

    This is bjp done after election same like pulvama

  • @gopalkrishnapattnaik5313
    @gopalkrishnapattnaik5313 8 днів тому

    Sitting on chair & issue orders will not be the norm in RAILWAY & OTHER DEPARTMENTS. GO TO FIELD & SIT THERE & ISSUE ORDERS.... OBSERVE THE IMPLEMENTATION..

  • @anantharamansampathkumar4927
    @anantharamansampathkumar4927 8 днів тому

    Failure of automatic signal will not cause accident.Signals always fail on the safe side.Dont misreport.

  • @zeen2412
    @zeen2412 8 днів тому

    Waste money I launching new trains when that same amount could have been used to upgrade/repair/ replace outdated infrastructure. Governments never learn. Only worried about their legacy!

  • @Shoeb_Saiyed
    @Shoeb_Saiyed 8 днів тому +1

    My condolences to the families of victims.

  • @samarsingh9418
    @samarsingh9418 9 днів тому +27

    What the hell is Modi government doing after elections?? First Neet Scam and than this train accident..What next?? Btw I am a neet aspirant and it was my first attempt in 2024 as well as I was a supporter of BJP but now I don't like any party!!

    • @singhsaket4706
      @singhsaket4706 8 днів тому +8

      its bjp government who introduced strict bills to stop paper leak!,,,,

    • @user-qz2dv6no3y
      @user-qz2dv6no3y 8 днів тому

      ​@@singhsaket4706andbhakt spotted 😂😂😂don't consume gobar so much dear

    • @samarsingh9418
      @samarsingh9418 8 днів тому

      @@singhsaket4706 Ohh really then why the education minister is not ready for CBI enquiry?? Why is he constantly changing his words?? Why is he waiting for supreme court to take action?? You meant to say that just by making laws the whole paper leak case would be solved?? Just after winning the elections, Scam in the biggest exam of India i.e. Neet Do you even have any idea what are we suffering from? We don't have any secure future. Just stop justifying the mistakes!! 😡😡

    • @user-SkmBeats
      @user-SkmBeats 8 днів тому

      yeah u will vote congress who does 100x more scams . go read history, u need to vote the lesser bad party.. otherwise anti nationals will make sure the anti indian parties will win.

    • @anweshakar146
      @anweshakar146 8 днів тому +2

      You finally realized they're all fools?

  • @SimonTimothy-rf6iv
    @SimonTimothy-rf6iv 8 днів тому

    Any written authority to proceed given to a train contain a speed restriction in that territory so that any obstruction in that track can not cause a collision. Even in the Automatic Signaling territory after passing a RED Signal, the driver can move at 15 KMPH by day and 5KMPH by night so that it can stop instantly after seeing any obstruction in the track. The Driver could have deliberately ignored the speed restriction or the Signal should have shown GREEN wrongly (Failure). Signal failure might be the most probable cause of this accident as in most of the Railways, Signal Maintenance is out sourced to private parties.

  • @snehashissardar8495
    @snehashissardar8495 8 днів тому +2

    We don't want bullet trains or Vande Bharat. We want good service and safety 😡😡😡😡😡

  • @manishamallick97
    @manishamallick97 8 днів тому +2

    It’s high time to protest against such negligence on people’s life and safety…what’s wrong with the railway signalling system.the loco pilot had no fault, the signals were faulty as usual. Stop bullet train hype.

  • @IHE87
    @IHE87 8 днів тому +2

    Everytime blaming naxals actually dont be surprised balsore was clearly insider job.

  • @bellamkondamanikantha5172
    @bellamkondamanikantha5172 8 днів тому +1

    Present situation of loco pilots
    I will explain on my knowledge.
    1. Normal employees for two weeks 96hrs duty hrs but loco pilots (lp) work minimum 120+hrs
    2.safty category other than loco pilots 2 night duties in week and after night duty they got night rest but loco pilots work continues 4nights working they will give night rest(present situation lack of loco pilots).
    3.normal railway employees in railway got 52 hrs Pr in a week but loco pilots got 30hrs pr(weekoff) that is also not give on 7th day they give after 10th day now a days.
    4.every Railway employee daily meet with their family but loco pilots as per situation 2-3 days after they will reach home.
    And lot of issues are there in loco pilots cadre that is not possible in this message please understand.
    No Loco pilot want to do accident they have Also family.This is mainly Government fault not at all staff.

  • @CastleLager-lf5eu
    @CastleLager-lf5eu 8 днів тому +4

    Vishwaguru 2047 😂😂😂

  • @parthadas2259
    @parthadas2259 8 днів тому +3

    As per news goods train driver killed, so it is easy to blame goods train driver but where is anticollition device. Railway high officials should explain.

  • @ashokindian36
    @ashokindian36 8 днів тому +2

    Aswini basnab shall resign 😂🎉

  • @suvayan91
    @suvayan91 8 днів тому +1

    Every time it is the loco pilot who is being blamed.. why... What abt the infrastructure, why does the complete RCA not get publicly published? What were the findings from the previous accidents and what mitigation plans have been implemented? Where is the complete synopsis?

  • @jesdaniel8303
    @jesdaniel8303 8 днів тому +2

    As raiways minister, you have failed miserably, still the pm persists with you as RM and keeps nirmala as FM despite her poor performance. Shameless pm. 😢

  • @sureshpillay9577
    @sureshpillay9577 8 днів тому

    Pura Loco pilot ke galti koi officers responsblty nahi lega,

  • @parthapratimmukherjee4191
    @parthapratimmukherjee4191 8 днів тому +4

    Instead, railway is encouraging brokers and black marketing of tickets during tourist seasons. Services are becoming poor, even in case of prime trains like Vande Bharat. Rail service was meant for public not only just for profit seeking. Safety of passengers has become questionable once again after this accident. Even the spokespersons says "Only 15 are dead and 50 injured", huh! Human lives has become so negligible?

  • @niniwini2000
    @niniwini2000 8 днів тому +2

    I travel in this train reguarly😭

  • @ranironit8494
    @ranironit8494 8 днів тому

    In case of prolonged failure of automatic signal T/D 912 is given along with T/A 912 where last stop signal is already failed... station master has issued the wrong authority of T/A 912 instead of T/D 912...first culprit is the station master...
    Second thing is that ..when the first train 13174 didn't clear the block section, at the same time , how did the station master give the line clear authority to that goods train

  • @aryakumar-kn1rj
    @aryakumar-kn1rj 8 днів тому

    Needs to be corrected, Station name being used multiple times in this video is wrong, correct name should be Rangapani and NOT Ranipatra

  • @ishayuseth5613
    @ishayuseth5613 8 днів тому +1

    i do not believe in this theory of govt how is that possible that both the loco pilot and the assistant loco pilot was not able to see the signal......and even if they were in speed when they might have seen the signal they must have applied full brakes rather than hitting the express train with that speed......have to be some technical fault either in the display of the signal or in the locomotive of the goods train.

  • @WZZ2698
    @WZZ2698 8 днів тому +2

    Resignation railway minister minimum 😢

  • @big_man_ank1768
    @big_man_ank1768 8 днів тому +3

    When will we modernize our railways as a whole, including tracks and signals, and heck better trains even. How many vande Bharats are running currently?

  • @dawasherpa918
    @dawasherpa918 8 днів тому +7

    PM Modi Always brings bad luck for indian train.

  • @rajeswarir6983
    @rajeswarir6983 8 днів тому +1

    For what purpose vandebharath express train. Nothing is not done to the daily poor commuters

  • @atanuroy8405
    @atanuroy8405 8 днів тому

    Stone age infra and we are talking about bullet train. Such a shame. These top le el officers and railway ministry must be held accountable for such cases

  • @jirniingurang3422
    @jirniingurang3422 8 днів тому +1

    Same shit like last time in West Bengal itself

  • @truthislogical
    @truthislogical 9 днів тому +6

    Under bjp govt hindus are even in danger while travelling trains

  • @chandanchakraborty1007
    @chandanchakraborty1007 8 днів тому +1

    SHAME, SHAME, SHAME

  • @captain._levi
    @captain._levi 8 днів тому +1

    Can you imagine the anger and criticism from bakhts, if railway was under state government

  • @purkaitsurajit53
    @purkaitsurajit53 8 днів тому

    😢😢

  • @stewartmolina5894
    @stewartmolina5894 8 днів тому +3

    Union Pacific 🤔☝️🙏

  • @anantharamansampathkumar4927
    @anantharamansampathkumar4927 8 днів тому

    What the CRB said is the plausible cause as of now.Wait for CRS enquiry report.

  • @sharmisthabhattacharya9038
    @sharmisthabhattacharya9038 8 днів тому

    There maybe some vulnerabilities in the server system exploited by our neighbour's black hats..
    Terror has its various forms.

  • @kumkum9671
    @kumkum9671 8 днів тому

    GIFT OF 3.0

  • @BMD765
    @BMD765 8 днів тому +4

    Can't expect much from India 😂😂😂

  • @Athiem2
    @Athiem2 8 днів тому +2

    Railways Minister should be sacked ......we don't want any fancy train like vande Bharat when the safety of passenger is ignored.

  • @himansusabar5206
    @himansusabar5206 8 днів тому +4

    Bangladeshi terror angle..

    • @AnirbanKar-2684
      @AnirbanKar-2684 8 днів тому +1

      Tere baap ne hi kiya hoga unpadh saale 😂

  • @SamCouper
    @SamCouper 8 днів тому

    Low tech + High speed = Disaster 😂😂😂

  • @Squamousepithilium
    @Squamousepithilium 8 днів тому

    oops! they need to focus better and get trained on these works more precisely.

  • @Dihorse371
    @Dihorse371 9 днів тому +4

    Yet again? 😂😂😂

  • @avikdey6818
    @avikdey6818 8 днів тому

    Sab piche se Marta hai age se nahi Marta.ghor kalyug.moh mayajal

  • @ritistar1304
    @ritistar1304 8 днів тому

    Ye hai hamara digital India

  • @user-ye6wh6wp6f
    @user-ye6wh6wp6f 8 днів тому

    Fraud samy

  • @PYTHON9208
    @PYTHON9208 8 днів тому

    This poor country needs G7 help.
    Meloni can take a selfie at the crash site 🤣🤣

  • @somdevbhattacharya
    @somdevbhattacharya 8 днів тому

    Kindly go through the rule No. 9.12 of chapter 9 of GR&SR of NFR. Before that please do not make news.

  • @ykishore4340
    @ykishore4340 8 днів тому

    Kavach fail hua

  • @remyakesavanster
    @remyakesavanster 8 днів тому

    Do not ignore these train accidents. These are rituals performed by the so-called elite class like the ancient day narabali. If you look at the Balasore accident, the incident happened exactly after 5 days of the inauguration of the new parliament building. This accident happened just after 8 days of the swearing in ceremony of the new government in the new parliament. Please note that the new parliament building is in the shape of a coffin.
    In both the accidents, the common factor is the signal malfunction. Eye witnesses said that before the Balasore accident, there was a railway person who was 'repairing' the signal and the rail was in the wrong direction and redirected Coromandal express to the loop lane. Still there was no investigation report submitted. Clearly an inside job by the government.

  • @user-tc7fb2pb6j
    @user-tc7fb2pb6j 8 днів тому

    Its not new news its always happening its like every day incident people get used too no big deal its republic of India

  • @user-qh1tr9fw6u
    @user-qh1tr9fw6u 8 днів тому

    टठठठछडडजजघ. ट्रिपल 😮पण मग च😢😢पण मग नंतर फोन ट्रिपल चछछढणणझणदडखा ईखगषृट

  • @rranganathan4598
    @rranganathan4598 8 днів тому

    Whenever automatic signal system fails the entiire signals in section goes red. The TD 912 authority implies the driver should go at the cautious speed preparing to stop at every signal. The impact shows the goods driver is at fault. Hit the express train with full speed even ignoring the LV(last vehicle flashing red)sign.

  • @muneerm5356
    @muneerm5356 8 днів тому

    The plight of Indian Railway is the worst compared to other modes of transportation in India. They are interested only in looting the ordinary people

  • @maa.sarosotti
    @maa.sarosotti 8 днів тому

    একটা লোকের উপরে এত বড় দায়িত্বটা দেওয়া হয় তারপরেও এরা যদি এমন হাল ছেড়ে ডিউটি করে আগামী তোকেউ কাউকে বিশ্বাস করবে না

  • @subhamnaskar1156
    @subhamnaskar1156 8 днів тому

    Mal gari is responsible.

  • @Intellectual_fascist
    @Intellectual_fascist 8 днів тому

    Sanatana railways ruining future of india😢

  • @openthoughts1904
    @openthoughts1904 8 днів тому

    This modi government is ineffective , useless and racit government. I really do not understand why and how people selected this government again, pathetic. This government is busy in pooja and foreign visit.

  • @rudyalfonsus686
    @rudyalfonsus686 8 днів тому

    it's alright. Modi will pray and everything will be ok. everything perfect. we are still focus on making rocket to the moon and making third aircraft carrier

  • @gamexinfo332
    @gamexinfo332 8 днів тому +3

    Panauti pm back

  • @BhaktiRulez
    @BhaktiRulez 8 днів тому

    Might is never right it takes it tolls

  • @gamexinfo332
    @gamexinfo332 8 днів тому +3

    Desh barbaad ho rha hai 😢 panauti pm back

  • @TRUTH1288
    @TRUTH1288 8 днів тому +2

    Wrost Railway minister...🤬..This is BJPs Vande Bharat 🤬🤬

  • @RockyN-qq6pb
    @RockyN-qq6pb 8 днів тому

    Last Year Didi visited Odisha and lecturers about how she could have prevented the accident in WB and criticized Odisha govt. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
    Hypocrisy at it's peak 😂😂😂

    • @kushagravlogs5627
      @kushagravlogs5627 8 днів тому

      It is fault of modi government not state government

  • @kunalhalder615
    @kunalhalder615 8 днів тому

    So now it is risky for a job in the Indian railway and also travelling on the railway! If such incidents happen even if it is caused by faulty famous Indian engineering technology, they still blame on human causes 🙏

  • @michaelrussell4254
    @michaelrussell4254 8 днів тому +1

    Third world country, where is the automatic train protection system in your country? you spend a lot of money on your space program surely you need to spend it on your railway systems like most countries in the world has ATP