Sen. Durbin asks for name of Zuckerberg's hotel in privacy question
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 кві 2018
- Senator Dick Durbin's question drew laughs from the chamber as Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg refused to say what hotel he stayed in overnight and who he's messaged online. Durbin also asked about the security of Facebook's Messenger Kids app.
That was a sharp start from the senator. It made Zuckerberg uncomfortable, he started to drink water to ease out.
He Bought Some Time To Think For His Answer😂
Exact
Dude poor Mark Zuckerberg....made something fun to now having to face this.
@@jacobjche dude shut up his metaverse is evil
@@jacobjche lmao
Zucc: "No, but I can tell where you stayed last night"
Exactly
I'm dead!! 😂🤣😭
In his WIFE of course!👉🗿👈®🇺🇸
🤣😂🤣
I'm dead laughing 😂
Boy he got baited into that. He fell for it. Saw that coming from a mile away.
Pretty sure he knew that was coming.
He saw it coming but he couldn’t do anything about it...
He saw it, he's not an idiot. That's why he paused when answering the initial question. He knew it was a trap and was trying to be careful answering it.
@@12HitCombo Actually he lacks social skills & awareness. He’s very book smart but not very clever.
@@PARCE93 He's not very clever? He's CEO of one of the largest companies in the world, one he build from the ground up. You don't get there by being just "book smart" and being unable to deal with people properly. That's not how running a business works. The "book smart" people are never the ones running the show.
No Mark Zuckerberg may be a weird guy, but he's far more clever and understands people far better than people realize. An incredibly obvious verbal trap like that isn't going to trip up a guy like that.
The way their smiles faded when they realized what was happening.
AHAHAHAHA 😂😂😂😅
lol, all the people "ill uninstall facebook!!" ... and then pick up their phones and post on instagram (owned by facebook lol)
Well said
@Andrew Chin if senators knew how Facebook operates thn probably they might have close fb by now😂not about senators if any1 knows how fb Google operates...they will probably use internet once in a lifetym n tht with fake id😂😂
Right!!
Thank God for duckduck😂😂
Lol
The Senator hit the nail on the head
Right on!
This never gets old! Wisdom grills talent! Awesome.
Wisdom?
He is asking about personal information about other people.
@David Murdock hey I hate Mark Zuck too but that still doesn’t make that question right.
( btw I am a liberal but why do you assume I have a short attention span or a “Liberal” one as you say it. I respect you as a human without caring about your political opinions can you not do the same?
@@randomguy2023 What about Facebook then? They do the same thing
Yeah they do but that doesn’t mean it’s OK for politicians to do it@@muhammaduwaismuhsinmuaz4385
@@randomguy2023 but it's okay for Mark to do that?
TBH out of all of them Sen D here was definitely one of the most actually educated on the internet ones to ask questions
Honestly I think FB listens in on my conversations. I was talking to my SO about getting a dog, and then bam, ads on Facebook started showing ads for dog food. (I don’t have a dog, just brought up maybe having one in the future) I actually don’t own any animals.
This happened several times. Then as a test I started talking about cats (don’t have one, never want one)
Bam, ads about cat food came up, and ads for pet insurance.
Yeah, but he s a Crook.. What you just saw. was Scripted....Not Real. that s how they Roll
@@washedpy4288 I thought the same about Google. I talked about learning Lithuanian so I could understand my fiance's parents and talk to them a bit. Seconds after that I type into Google "where to learn" and Google finished the sentence "Lithuanian".
Of all the languages it could have picked, in fact it didn't even need to be a language that I wanted to learn. It knew what i was going to type before I had ever contemplated learning a language.
Kinda scary really. I don't even allow things access to my mic and so on.
@@washedpy4288 omg 😳
@@bakersmileyface yea that’s scary for sure :o
ZUCK: Scripts\Human\Templates\Motion\~Smile.exe
Quick Tech Reviews he needs separate folder for human ?
I thought everyone knew he was a reptilian shapeshifter. Wonder what other templates he has....
Nonsense answers.lua
Confused look.anim
Version 2.8 beta
This is some xmachinima stuff.
Surprised that water didnt short out his circuits and cause him to malfunction.
They should have asked about people being sold on Facebook.
Lol
What is alarming to me is. Younger people really don't use Facebook as much as older do. I've seen older people in their 50s and up addicted to Facebook...
Lol yeah
That's not true!
@@fakereality5204 how do you know that? lmao
@@fakereality5204 well your name makes sense. Because you clearly aren’t in this reality
@@Smithy250 I have no idea why UA-cam deletes my replies.
They baited him asking styupid questions. Then this senator caught the lizard.
It wasn’t a stupid question. Are you too stupid to realize yourself admitting your own metaphor to “senator caught the lizard” meaning what? It was a strategical question!
All his questions were vague and clearly showed how misinformed he was. I’m seeing a lot of people here who truly believe Zuckerberg was on the losing end getting baited, when in reality he was getting asked vague, misinformed, and just plain stupid questions to which he had no proper response. Clearly 90% of the idiots here have never been in a proper debate
@@megachef0421 well it's clear you have been in a good number of debates calling other people idiots...
And for the matter his questions were not that bad considering he had only minutes apparently to ask all of his questions, and he was informed about other products like messenger kids which I didn't even know it existed, so I really don't know what you are talking about.
If he looked misinformed about some parts that's how prosecutors ask questions to the witness, they are not naive they are looking at how you answer them and show the flaws of your response that's what he did actually before asking about messenger kids unlike other senators that were completely uninformed. If anything you're the one being clueless here, the questions were clearly baiting him
@@megachef0421 Since you claim to have some skill in debating I will assume you at least have rudimentary knowledge of logic. If that's the case then you should be able to precisely show the invalid logic of his questions. Where is the bad math?
The tone of what you wrote makes me think that you are a Zuckerberg supporter, so while we are on the subject; Why did I log onto Pirate Bay in 2008-9ish and see one of the top 10 downloadable torrents was every user's information on Facebook. This was a massive file with all of them. It was leaked by a hacker to show exactly what information Zuckerburg was selling. I wonder how much the leaking of this file cost this slithering dipshit.
All I heard in this interview was Zucker moaning "I'll do whatever I can as long as I don't get caught!"
@@brandonshukuri6487 No, I am not a Zuckerberg supporter. There is no tone, its just the way you interpreted my comment. Im gonna use context clues, and assume you are not a zuckerberg supporter as well.
Sen. Durban asked some really good questions
I immediately picked up on the word "in general".. hats off to mister senator
Woman behind Zuckerberg is checking facebook on her phone.
Good question, but I guess he forgot what the NSA does each day
Are you joking? Have you heard of Edward Snowden? Get out of here
Except nsa doesn't sell our data to foreign countries
Alonso Ramirez one does it for money the other is to collect data about their targets for whatever political party is in power.
love ~ The NSA sells our our data for freedom, and we gladly pay that price each time we buy a smart phone, or hang out on internet
If the NSA didn't do what they did there probably would have been a dozen more 9/11's by now. You can't speak for the intelligence community because you are not a part of the intelligence community. Keep believing your batshit crazy conspiracy theories posted by people on UA-cam who use guessed it. Have no experience or insider info from the Intel community.
As a web developer, i can tell, facebook can no way be stopped from from selling your data if they want it. Its in their system they can do whatever they want
It’s obvious. He is talking about how Facebook distributes this information.
Yes they can because one one side your right they couldn't be just stopped but it's because they claim they don't share it even tho they do that's the problem
Change the law back and we all be better off for are safety
Stop using Facebook.. Problem solved.
NSA collect like everything from u xD
Instagram too, they owned by Facebook
FB inta whatsapp twitter Gmail yt ...... Basically throw your phone through the nearest open window and problem solved !
Good luck escaping google
Not really Facebook collects everyones private info. Even if you were never on facebook they have all your private info and data!!!
Their smiles and happiness faded from their faces as the time progressed.
I never thought I would say this but I love what these politicians are doing.
He's an R
The art of Asking Questions 🔥🔥🔥 👌
It's interesting seeing both sides questioning about privacy knowing both parties spy on us everyday🤣
Do they use the info for tax deductible purposes?😂😊
3 years later and nothing has been done I feel sorry for our future 😕
Like he care about that,its bren 4 years,yet they doesnt even change a single rules about privacy,instead they expanded it into whatsapp.
@@spy1679 feel they might've changed the rules at least ones so that they can invade our privacy more efficiently
Absolutely the best questions, a hard lesson of wrong and right
Parents want to stay connected with their kids and talk to them- there wasn’t an app that did that... *Alexander Bell rolls over in his grave *
I understood that reference *captain america's voice*
I love how the senator wipes the floor with zuccberg and his goons and wipes the smile off their face. That senator is smart
Love it!!!
Suckerburg
Orange face berg
This is what happens when you don't put these worms under oath. Good job by the Senator.
What they come out better than when they went in? Zuck did nothing wrong hes a programmer who created a program and is upkeeping it and selling information. Information you have concented to OVER and OVER again. Every app you install can take advantage of these things if you don't pay attention.
Correct. What good is a 'hearing' when the 'witnesses' can lie with impunity? The purpose , ostensibly, is for our congresscritters to get the truth but there are no consequences to Suck-a-Turd for his spin, obfuscation, deflections, evasions, and the always useful dodge "I'll have to get back to you on that!"
The Unoriginal Hacks i dont recall consenting away my private information on my private account set specifically for family and friends. Terms of service even says they dont sell your information to third party companies
boy , the number of people that dropped Facebook since this is astounding 🤔
And he got them all right back
I always have this feeling ,zero privacy
Do you notice how when he gets ask the tough questions he hast to take a sip of water
He is giving entirely non-committal answers.
Thats because he hasn't done anything wrong.
Totes deflection
That’s how all these hearings go
The Unoriginal Hacks, that makes no sense.
If he has done nothing wrong, he hashes out the painfully dull compliance measures his Risk Management and Legal Liability departments have been invoking since the beginning and does not give mutually exclusive answers.
He is saying nothing. His lack of information security is enough for civil suit.
Considering his cooperation with international bad actors like Iran and Pakistan, he has PLENTY to answer for.
Jacob Bonfante, you don't watch C-Span, do you?
Very often, on a target where both Dems and Reps can make hay or have to defend their boy, a lot gets outed.
If you have any context of the situation, you can tell where Zuck's lawyers coached him and on what. You can very clearly see where he won't get off script, like a bad telemarketer.
That is how you can tell that his group did not seal all of the holes in the ship, he stonewalls probing. That means his lawyers think he is guilty of something.
That is what happens when you don't give them political donations.
smart thinking my friend!
@Antonio P. del Hierro-Valdés taunting does not equal getting hit 2 times.
Messenger kids? Yo what Is he up too now?? We already have messed up kids who live off the internet and memes he is going to ruin lives..
Trainer Z It’s not his job to babysit kids. He isn’t ruining lives.
Parents were asking for it
Well memes don't necessarily mess up kids?
He is trying to secure future customer for facebook..
Sen. Durbin makes me proud of being from Illinois.
He is a smart guy.
He's just warming up. Looks like he has been defending a under adolescent child or too. With this new department he'll be busy hopefully.
I find it fascinating that the entire world is watching this and concerned about an irrelevant topic that has too many aspects and is only being shed a spotlight on just one platform when all other platforms and governmental agencies do the same. Amusing
Nervous laugh and a sip of water. This whole thing is just sad.
This is what can happen in a private sector environment. Everyone says fear the government, big brother, 1984, animal farm, but as we now see the private sector can do exactly the same thing and there are no laws or regulations keeping them in check.
Animal farm was good
the difference is that the government has a monopoly on violence.
This old man is experienced and skeptical in asking the precise questions
The only thing that really drive me crazy a out FB is, why we are not able to delete our accounts completly with all our data. This is sick.
I think eli the computer guy shows you how to do it properly
Have these people ever heard of that family tree website, you can literally find people’s cell phone numbers and addresses. This is the internet as a whole
Spot on ,Sen.Durbin ...
Finally someone asked about that in public ! Some people still don't know specially kids, that they make so much money on our information what they sell all the time.
So where are they parents...? you realy would expect of a money making corporation to race you children? thets not they responsibility
This video should have more viewers than others.
“A number of things are important here...” 😟
There needs to be a higher level of security on these “social” sites. Especially the developer platform! There are people that are connected to “developer platforms” that were never given an option of which “platform” they connected to! There are connections established between devices that most of the public doesn’t even know about when we send “messages” or join these sites. Not to mention ALL the information that is collected about your life, and then sold to other companies.
"Messenger kids" is going to make creeps come out from the woods even more than normal which is scary!!!
Caught off guard
With the * O’ s-t I need a drink of water* nervousness indicated. 😂😂
Go forward, and guard your mind and mindset, Zac.
Wow. He really walked right into that question. Lol
“Yes senator I believe everyone should have control over how their information is being used” hallow words
Quit forcing people to use messenger! Take that crap off! I never wanted messenger and I continually get alerts of incoming message.
Can't you just uh.... turn off notifications?
God bless this man for the point he was trying to make. Very clever. On the other hand facebook or instagram are not obligatory...
He sure knows how to dodge a question
This chairman is a gem
the damage is irreversible.
3:10 that lady in GREEN..😟
Creepy 👀
Questions are so smartly asked that he is drinking water on every dam question😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁
0:45-48, you can hear him swallow😂
He was under pressure!
Lol 😂 😂 what a catch
He was drinking water.
@@kevinv2767 Ikr. He was swallowing?!?!?!?! Wtfffffff. He must be guilty of manslaughter and mass-genocide.
I just had a sip of water lnao
@@michaelangelo2192 dats water
Honestly Facebook should have been shut down a very long time ago. I stopped using it and I suggest others should too.
Baron Hernandez no thanks
Yes everyone just dump this NSA tool (plus russian FSB intelligence tool as well) called Facebook.
Get a grip.
Its not just about Facebook its everywhere else on the internet they steal your information without your concent. It's no wonder we have elitist. Ignorant public people have no sense in their surrounding it's okay it's how you grew up.
People are jumping ship like crazy. I left it 1.5 years ago, and now about half of the people I know are off it.
Thank you for showing this how it feels to this guy that has stolen our private information for his needs and money needs to be sued from everyone over data
That was actually a great question. Zuckerberg danced around that one very hard... "minimal" "general"
Great Brillant question !
Awesome questions by the way
The only question that matters!
When he drank the water I almost expected to see his tongue shoot out into the glass.
How do I get a cut from MY info that's sold.
In the product itself? Is that why I can not mass delete anything in Facebook? I can deactivate and it is still stored or I can take hours a day for a few weeks to manually delete posts, pictures etc.
I loved him calling out the "in general" smart guy
But they own instagram too thoughhhh
Yeah and Whatsapp.
0:38 "oh no! I can feel my human mask shifting out of place because I frowned too fast! Better drink some of this planet's hydrogenated oxygen to look natural..."
That's deep wether u meant it to be or not
Lmfao the first :45 seconds has me lmfao
Is he human?
He don't have friend such a poor baby
No
Zuckerberg: Hahahaha! Now I see you're trying to use your Shtoyle over mine!
Was laughing and after a bit grabs a glass of water 😂
Google should be grilled like this too
.
Mark is socially awkward 😂😂drinking the water every time things get tough
In 30-plus years of representative government, this is the first time Durbin has made sense.
Priceless! Z's body language says it all.
Messenger kids is probably some kind of sick ring to see if your kid is good enough to steal. 🤬
Grilled!!!!!!!!!!!!
if you dont think apple is doing the same thing plus facial recognition guess again!
Of course they are.. Have any of you read any policy agreement before clicking Continued? Not just with fb, but with apple, Microsoft, game apps, cell phone policy agreements, Xbox, PS3, PS4 policy agreements???? Lmfao if you ever have that chance you'd probably disconnect from any and all electronics other than an old skool TV vhs and DVD player. These policy agreements sound pretty scary, a lot some of it will sound like legal mumbo jumbo too
What facial recognition are you talking about ? If it’s FaceID, that data is stored in Secure Enclave only accessible by TrueDepth hardware (it works the same way as TouchID)
Saritpong Bunseng 😂😂👆🏾 so naive
Saritpong Bunseng that is what they want to believe you.Privacy is a Big joke!
Idiots like you are the problem
How Many of u will slam FB then share it on FB?! Lol
Pretty much everyone.
THANK YOU LAWMAKERS!!!
Got nervous looking around
finally a competent senator
He always looks like you're about to take his popsicle away .
He doesn't have a soul he sold out to the evil one
there is no control
This was such a valid question
He thinks he's smarter than everyone in the room.
probably because he is
then those simple questions wouldn't of tripped him up. these people may not be tech-savvy but they know when privacy has been tampered with.
agreed. Sen Durbin's poignant questions were like teaching a guilty/remorseful son a lesson on wisdom. "be honest and don't steal other people's money".
but doesn't make it right, KB. all the money in the world won't save your soul.
the truth whats a soul
Greed always wins
Has anyone ever seen personalized ADS about products or services, they've only ever SPOKEN about, and not once searched online for? Food for thought. They're always listening, not just Facebook, the government too.
Does this happen to anyone? when ever we are looking at a product in other places and all the sudden the same product will appear in your FB wall..... happens to me so many times....
I don't think he realizes that calling the guy "Senator" over and over doesn't come off as respectful.
Actually it is, you never address someone of a higher office by their name.
+The Unoriginal Hacks - It's more the repetition I was referring to. He says "Senator" just about every other sentence. Makes him sound phony.
Scott K watched too many court drama probably.
who cares lol
Jão - I care just enough to comment. Just like you.
Zuckerberg is so so so much like Data from Star Trek TNG.
Right question sir
Google hangouts collect them, your ISP collects them, anyone who is provider you the messaging or voice call or any information exchange service, can collect that information. They could explicitly say they don't but they can easily do so.
Actually he's intelligent
He used the trick, to take a sip of water when you are asked a question, so you get a greater time to answer that question
No, it just shows he is uncomfortable with the situation, its human psychology.
@@_nlcholas bro you don't know about this, try to check it out
FB uploads pictures from your phone and computer that you didn't want to upload. Why is that?
FB then asks if you want to put these stolen pictures on your FB page, but these stolen pictures are already on FB computers!
They aren't stolen when you give permission...
The Unoriginal Hacks, I uploaded one picture, and FB uploaded at least 3 or 4 that I didn't upload. That's stealing. Or maybe its a trick permission hidden in FB's massive terms of service written in legalese.
wavenature
You don't know how your phone works, and you're probably unaware of what you've agreed to. How much responsibility should a company bare when its customers don't know how to properly use its product? Facebook isn't stealing information. People are volunteering all of it, then blaming facebook for the actions of a third party that was breaching facebook's terms and conditions. No company is perfect, even when intended. If people are concerned with losing control of their information, they maybe should have been more concerned with learning about how it was going to be used in the first place.
Ian Griffith, it sure sounds like attorneys and computer pros taking advantage of the uniformed trusting public. Do you comprehend legalese and computerese? Does the general public need to each hire lawyers to interpret all those cleverly written terms of services that are everywhere online now? Should FB and google and etc. be allowed to continue their monopoly controls of the internet services?
I don't need to hire a lawyer to understand not to give out my information. Stop being uninformed, take a little time and learn. The information is there. If you don't want to take the time to understand how your apps work, you shouldn't be using them. Do one is forcing anyone to be on FB or any other social media.
Walked into nice trap 😂 that nervous gulp
It is chatting!!!