The BBC's failure to call Hamas 'terrorists' is inexcusable

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 сер 2024
  • This week, Jake is joined by Danny Cohen, the BBC's former director of TV, who hit out at the corporation for the way it responded to October 7 and why he wouldn't have resigned in protest.
    The world's oldest and most influential Jewish newspaper. Since 1841. thejc.com/subscribe
    Follow us on social media:
    jewishchron
    thejewishchronicle
    jewishchronicle

КОМЕНТАРІ • 166

  • @user-yc5bc8zb1h
    @user-yc5bc8zb1h 22 дні тому +45

    I’m English 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 , British 🇬🇧 . I despise the BBC .

    • @RebeccaTurner-ny1xx
      @RebeccaTurner-ny1xx 21 день тому

      For not being on the side of fanatical Zionists? It is _commendable_ for the UK's state broadcaster not to take the side of the UK's government on this.

  • @johnnymookergee4935
    @johnnymookergee4935 23 дні тому +59

    The CBC in Canada also calls Hamas militants, disgusting

    • @brentdubecalgary5084
      @brentdubecalgary5084 22 дні тому +7

      bbc cbc abd abc are the same

    • @timkempuk
      @timkempuk 22 дні тому +5

      ​​​@brentdubecalgary5084 that is very sad. I wonder if this is a collective thing where they have all decided between themselves to report in the same way.

    • @jittmet7766
      @jittmet7766 22 дні тому +4

      All the govt-type media channels tend to echo each other. Australian govt media does too.

    • @jittmet7766
      @jittmet7766 22 дні тому +3

      @@timkempuk Often they work with each other.

  • @ilysestariq
    @ilysestariq 22 дні тому +41

    It’s clear to see who supports antisemitism by the words that they use when making reference to Hamas.

    • @karlyoung1713
      @karlyoung1713 22 дні тому +1

      @@ilysestariq I don't make reference to Hamas just the citizens also know enough history.i find we are given half the book.

  • @njuham
    @njuham 23 дні тому +32

    Yesterday a Talkradio newsreader said "Hamas militants".

  • @Cvaut
    @Cvaut 22 дні тому +12

    BBC has lost 5 decades of credibility for ever ...

    • @LeeGee
      @LeeGee 22 дні тому +4

      @@Cvaut Agreed. May I suggest you look again at any issue for which the BBC (or any mass media) helped form your opinion? I think you'll be shocked to learn what the establishment has been doing to Tommy Robinson. His Oxford Union speech is worthwhile, as is this recent Peterson interview.

  • @sharonhutchinson1574
    @sharonhutchinson1574 22 дні тому +30

    I think what disgusted more than anything is the fact that they would not class Hamas as a terrorist organisation .

    • @nezbrun872
      @nezbrun872 22 дні тому +12

      @@user-or7cc2ht3j Hamas leaders live in luxury in Qatar. How do you think you can routinely send rockets from what you call a "concentration camp"?

    • @alrosano5786
      @alrosano5786 22 дні тому +1

      @@sharonhutchinson1574 what about the IDF ?

    • @LeeGee
      @LeeGee 22 дні тому +1

      @@user-or7cc2ht3j If you need make things up to win an argument, you have already lost

    • @jittmet7766
      @jittmet7766 22 дні тому +1

      Neither does the UN.

    • @8_7478
      @8_7478 20 днів тому +2

      ​@@user-or7cc2ht3j No understanding of what a concentration camp is.

  • @magentamagenta1274
    @magentamagenta1274 22 дні тому +18

    Tim Davie is directly responsible for condoning the systemic internal anti Zionism, anti Semitism. He has failed to uphold complaints effectively, he has failed to deliver impartial reporting, he has failed to provide unbiased media and has instead brought the BBC into disrepute. Denial and bigotry are not acceptable.
    It would also help if he employed journalists that have journalistic integrity, with standards of education, that know how to spell basic English and use English grammar.

  • @universepress777
    @universepress777 22 дні тому +8

    Free Izrael, free Persia - Long live the true Iranian KING PAHLAVI , free Lebanon, free the Kurds and other oppressed ethnic groups all around the world from this HELL ISLAMIZATION.

  • @skontheroad
    @skontheroad 22 дні тому +20

    The story about the child with Cerebral Palsy I found very awful and have been tracking it since!! I find it terrible that he is being used the way he is, by so many news outlwts claiming the IDF did this to him! And they film the mother as well, who tells us how hungry and thirsty he is and it is bc of the IDF! Presumably, she is paid for these "appearances. ".. HOPEFULLY she doesn't know what they write about them afterwards!!?? I can't blame her for needing money and that he can come in and put on a drip, which he clearly needs!
    HOWEVER, they reuse these clips over and over, including a few days ago, and as a viewer, it is horrible to watch this child in pain. Or whatever his actual situation is! They are exploiting the situation, and lying about it, which is awful in itself! But then to blame the IDF??? DISGUSTING!!

    • @jittmet7766
      @jittmet7766 22 дні тому +1

      But they always do this. have done for decades.

  • @brendalandes1813
    @brendalandes1813 22 дні тому +24

    How could anyone even think that Israel-invaded Gaza and started this was must be mad! My granddaughter has a friend who is a hostage. Who knows whether she is still alive? We want peace!!!!!

    • @edaleman2758
      @edaleman2758 22 дні тому +1

      Peace on your terms. It doesn't work like that.

    • @gheller2261
      @gheller2261 22 дні тому +11

      @edaleman What the hell are you talking about?

    • @edaleman2758
      @edaleman2758 22 дні тому +1

      @@gheller2261 haven't you noticed that the Colonists aren't dictating the rules any more?

    • @karlyoung1713
      @karlyoung1713 22 дні тому +2

      Too much cool ade is not usefull

    • @LeeGee
      @LeeGee 22 дні тому +5

      @@edaleman2758 Peace on our terms in our country. It works exactly like that. That's why there is an army.

  • @LeeGee
    @LeeGee 23 дні тому +19

    Ten and more years ago, I worked a a freelancer at BBC Radio 4, FM&T, and on the digital curriculum. I did not experience any direct anti-Semitism, but there is a horrible air of reified liberalism that makes the room go silent if you say something with which The Guardian would not agree. I got the feeling people generally meant well. It seems now, though, that things have significantly changed.

    • @Cvaut
      @Cvaut 22 дні тому +1

      BBC was once the most trusted news channel. Integrity, quality, unbiased.. democracies and other vouched.
      The last 8 months have washed all of it away.. biased, poor quality interviews, shamelessly distorted headlines, and it is most obvious that things have git corrupted and money is involved . The British taxpayer supports it, and they don't seem to be even loyal to them.. this is the case with others like CNN, too.. Sad

  • @themossad
    @themossad 23 дні тому +22

    Time to come home to Israel

    • @user-or7cc2ht3j
      @user-or7cc2ht3j 22 дні тому

      2 million ZIONIST have left already

    • @Evantrop
      @Evantrop 22 дні тому +2

      Am Israel hi

    • @deborahfreedman333
      @deborahfreedman333 18 днів тому

      Misrad klita valiyah requires a ton of paperwork.

    • @themossad
      @themossad 18 днів тому

      @@deborahfreedman333 it’s government. Government loves paperwork

  • @sharonhutchinson1574
    @sharonhutchinson1574 22 дні тому +13

    I call the bbc the Qatar broadcasting cooperation.I think they are disgustingly.I stop looking at the main stream media a long time ago and that goes for newspapers as well .I watch independent media eg Mahjar Tousi tv .

    • @exDamascus
      @exDamascus 22 дні тому +4

      Sky News Australia is one exception - in stark contrast to its Uk counterpart.

  • @themossad
    @themossad 21 день тому +5

    Nothing has changed at the BBC, it was always this way. The only thing thats changed is your eyes - you opened them!

  • @jimjames4348
    @jimjames4348 20 днів тому +3

    That was probably the thinking of the people at the BBC who decided not to call hamas terrorists to begin with, a form of both psychological warfare and constructive dismissal. The accounts of Jewish people currently working at the BBC are just as shocking.

  • @elisolomon8741
    @elisolomon8741 22 дні тому +4

    I found this piece to be extremely informative. And I cant help draw parallels with the ABC here in Australia. Our community also suffers the same bias and anti Israel rhetoric.
    And I look at you , can see you're both intelligent and highly credentialed. And just like the vast majority of Jews in Australia, you vote Labor. For the record, I never have.
    Our communities must wake up to the fact the left hate us and most mainstream media is run by the left.
    We need to collectively shift our political leaning. Or we shall collectively lose.
    God save the King.
    Am Yisrael Chai 🇮🇱

  • @enigmabletchley6936
    @enigmabletchley6936 22 дні тому +3

    Why is there a BBC Arabic? Why are British tax payers funding an Arabic service, or indeed any specialised language service?

  • @user-qz7uu2lt4w
    @user-qz7uu2lt4w 22 дні тому +2

    Relative Peace
    Hmmm
    Just two people having a conversation
    And so far a good one
    But
    Relative Peace
    Is there such a thing

  • @veralevy7036
    @veralevy7036 18 днів тому +1

    The BBC has a record of antisemitism for decades, and now they have no excuse not even through this gentleman who is not working anymore for BBC
    He could've speak up earlier, but this needs courage

  • @Funintherain13
    @Funintherain13 21 день тому

    Jake is almost annoyingly understated.

  • @revol148
    @revol148 20 днів тому

    Jake sounds just like David Baddiel !

  • @cynthiaacevedo3286
    @cynthiaacevedo3286 21 день тому

    I thought BBC knows the facts and everything.Very sad😭

  • @bell1095
    @bell1095 23 дні тому +8

    Being jewish, is no corrective against being antisemitic biased.

    • @user-or7cc2ht3j
      @user-or7cc2ht3j 22 дні тому

      Being ZIONIST is no corrective against being antisemitic biased.

  • @mdog111
    @mdog111 17 днів тому

    Were Begin and Shamir 'terrorists'? Or 'militants'?

  • @user-qz7uu2lt4w
    @user-qz7uu2lt4w 22 дні тому

    A filtered person
    Based on
    Hierarchy
    Now that
    Is an insightful statement
    Yes yes
    But needs to be said
    Reminds me of
    The Emperors New Clothes
    Any one out there heard the story
    Ya
    I’m rambling but got to fill up the time until
    Sunday when England well
    We will see

  • @Mark_Dyer1
    @Mark_Dyer1 22 дні тому

    DANNY: Your initial point - about people ingratiating themselves with tghe 'boss' is well made. This is the problem if you are Sovereign of the United Kingdom, His Majesty's Prime Minister, Archbishop of Canterbury, down to the 'lowly' NHS Chief Executive (if the latter ever leaves his/her office!). You are observing a 'world' filtered through ambition and expectation. Usually this process is benign: but - when the person deceiving you is an Islamist Imam, or an Islamist politician (Naz Shah?) - then it can become dangerous, for a great many people. There is a cleric I follow, but do not admire (Gavin Ashenden; once Chaplain to HM, the Queen) whose watchword for Christians (and, I suspect, Jews) is 'DISCERNMENT'. We need to recognise when we are being lied-to. This is an enormous 'gift': and may have stopped a great many of us from voting for the wrong person. fpr PM, in December 2019. Unfortunately, far too many of us were deceived. To be able to practise 'discernment' ought to be one of the most beneficial 'tools' at the disposal of any 'boss'.

  • @alrosano5786
    @alrosano5786 22 дні тому +1

    He mentioned moral compass 🧭? Wow 🤩

    • @8_7478
      @8_7478 20 днів тому +1

      Your surprise regarding moral compass no surprise to me about yours.

  • @OLAFJELLVIKAAS
    @OLAFJELLVIKAAS 19 днів тому

    👍❤💫

  • @user-qz7uu2lt4w
    @user-qz7uu2lt4w 22 дні тому +1

    What does it matter what they are called

  • @syung8754
    @syung8754 22 дні тому +3

    Big Bag of Cobswollop

    • @8_7478
      @8_7478 21 день тому +1

      No such word. English needs to improve.

    • @syung8754
      @syung8754 20 днів тому

      @@8_7478 thank you you big bag of C.....

    • @8_7478
      @8_7478 20 днів тому

      ​@@syung8754Your grasp of the language is incredible.😂

    • @syung8754
      @syung8754 20 днів тому

      @@8_7478 how did you know I was going to call you carbohydrate? You big C

  • @JohnHayes-od3be
    @JohnHayes-od3be 22 дні тому +2

    The victims that choose genocide and ethnic cleansing over empathy and humanity.

  • @user-xd9rn8vu1z
    @user-xd9rn8vu1z 22 дні тому +1

    The Jewish Chronicle should not be involving itself with other countries news outlets.

    • @talbenavraham1478
      @talbenavraham1478 22 дні тому +6

      Involve with or comment on?

    • @skontheroad
      @skontheroad 22 дні тому +1

      Do you have an example of what you are talking about? The Jewish Chron has only a handful of sources and news outlets to turn to when looking for news to report. If something is then found to be anti-semitic or anti-Zionist, the Chronicle has a duty to shed a light on an anti-Israel or anti-Jewish bias! ESPECIALLY on the BBC which is publicly owned!

    • @Spacecow78993
      @Spacecow78993 22 дні тому +3

      Jewish Chronicle is British based, and has all right to criticism of national broadcasting which became Palestine terororist supporter!

    • @user-xd9rn8vu1z
      @user-xd9rn8vu1z 22 дні тому

      @@talbenavraham1478 Both. The Israeli buys its way around the world by sticking its nose in other countries affairs.

    • @8_7478
      @8_7478 21 день тому

      Says the dictator.

  • @andrewwalsh2755
    @andrewwalsh2755 23 дні тому +5

    So... if a man mugs a woman... and the woman breaks the man's arm... who is the aggressor... and who is the victim?
    If Israel, from Day1, disregarded the Balfour Declaration, which was an input to the Mandate For Palestine... and displaced existing communities...
    ... and decades later, the sons of the displaced attack the sons and daughters of the displacers...
    Who is the aggressor... and who is the victim?
    Who are the terrorists... and who are the terrorised?
    What's done is done, and cannot be undone...
    The indefensible cannot be defended...
    Dissolution is the only peaceful resolution.

    • @moonshinesa8234
      @moonshinesa8234 23 дні тому +10

      Are you saying Israel ignored the Balfour declaration? As far as I know Israel received much less land than they were supposed to get. Arab countries received that “extra” land.

    • @themossad
      @themossad 23 дні тому +8

      This is a cool story. Did you make it up yourself?

    • @andrewwalsh2755
      @andrewwalsh2755 23 дні тому +1

      @@moonshinesa8234... the Balfour Declaration states that nothing shall be done to prejudice the civil rights of existing communities... but Israel chose to displace existing communities... which Was prejudicial to their civil rights?... Therefore, Israel disregarded the Balfour Declaration, an input to the Mandate For Palestine...

    • @WeShallOvercome_
      @WeShallOvercome_ 23 дні тому +9

      I hope you are aware that the conflict began before 1948, and that many of those you call ‘displaced Palestinians’ were themselves economic migrants who arrived after the Ottomans were replaced by the British. Their Arab leaders calling them back home is repatriation, not displacement. The reason their leaders told them all to leave was so they could wage war and murder all the Jews there, including the Jews who’d lived there for centuries.
      Indeed, you forgot to mention the Arab aggressors who committed genocide against the long-standing Jewish communities of Hebron and Gaza, for example. Violence begetting violence, why have you left that out?
      You’re not trying to be reductionist, are you?

    • @themossad
      @themossad 22 дні тому +1

      @@andrewwalsh2755 lol 😂

  • @andrewwalsh2755
    @andrewwalsh2755 22 дні тому +3

    This was a real eye opening discussion.
    The issues I see are misunderstanding:
    Fundamentally... Antisemitism... What is it?
    The IHRA Working Definition Of Antisemitism conflates criticism of Israel (antizionism) with hatred of Jews, just for being Jews, (antisemitism)... which the rest of the world sees as bogus... but Zionists (not Jews) seem to accept this definition.
    Proof:
    Antisemitism is morally wrong... criticism of Israel (antizionism) for genocide is morally right...
    therefore, if antizionism is antisemitism...
    then... (morally right) is (morally wrong)... I.e. not valid, a bogus proposition.
    So, on the basis of a bogus proposition, people must be driven from their jobs, their livelihoods, unable to pay their bills, their rent, their mortgages... and are to be driven from their homes???
    You see where this is going, right?
    You are offended, you want peoples social media monitored, you want them driven from their jobs... because they do not share your point of view... where will that lead?... Conflict???... 🤔
    Maybe... just maybe... you should be guided by a moral compass, rather than taking offence at something you misunderstood?
    If your moral compass says: kill all women and children... drive people who disagree with me from their homes... then it is broken... get a working one?...

    • @skontheroad
      @skontheroad 22 дні тому +6

      Here is the difference, and I suggest reading the source material (both of their Charter statements), one side wants and has repeatedly offered, peace! Whereas the other side's ultimate goal is annihilation! And dont be fooled into thinking it is just "them" who is their target. Next they are coming for, and it says so VERY CLEARLY in their mission statement, the will be coming back for YOU!!

    • @andrewwalsh2755
      @andrewwalsh2755 22 дні тому +3

      @@skontheroad... I understand... Israelis today are in an impossible position...

    • @magentamagenta1274
      @magentamagenta1274 22 дні тому

      @andrewwalsh2755 Andrew trying without any context to explain anti Semitism and applying acceptance of anti Semitism because of your skewed views is nothing whatsoever to do with moral compass.
      If people behaved in the same manner towards any other religious group or nation then give an example. Nobody would accept this kind of hatred being applied against any other religion or race.
      Where is the moral compass for the Israelis loosing their homes and business income due to terrorist bombing.
      Anti Semitism and anti Zionism are the same. All Jews have the right to exist and live peacefully in their homes, go to work safely and send their children to school safely. Whether this is in Israel or any country in the world that they live in.
      The BBC has not applied unbiased, broadcasting it has hounded and systematically applied egregious propaganda ongoing anti Semitism towards Israel, anti Zionism this affects the general population of Jews worldwide as being the truth, when it is nothing more than lies or distorted information that is baseless. It is unethical for a government broadcasting channel to do this.
      Do you see where I’m coming from.
      The people that destroy or offend the Jews in your opinion should accept this because people at the bbc may loose their job. That’s unfortunate that that is now a concern and it’s regrettable that the same concerns don’t apply to Jews and Israeli people suffering, every single day from a war started by terrorists, they are defending a tiny country, with global condemnation and criticism from armchair managers. It really is not very difficult to understand the difference between right and wrong.
      One thing that has been emphasised more than ever since this conflict began is that the decision that Israel become a sovereign state for the Jews was and is imperative for the survival of the Jewish people.
      Fundamentally anti semitism/anti Zionism/racism is wrong, toxic, vile and heinous especially when it’s used to fuel hatred through ignorance and bigotry.

    • @edaleman2758
      @edaleman2758 22 дні тому

      ​@@andrewwalsh2755 No they aren't, they can drive to Ben Gurion airport, show their other passports and get on a plane back home. Palestinians can't do that.

    • @andrewwalsh2755
      @andrewwalsh2755 22 дні тому

      @@edaleman2758... That is a peaceful solution... (I shall be censored if I use the "D" word!..)

  • @pieinher67
    @pieinher67 22 дні тому

    You can't excuse what you have done to humanity despite the endless webs that you spin.

    • @8_7478
      @8_7478 20 днів тому +1

      You have limited view on the evils of humanity.

    • @pieinher67
      @pieinher67 20 днів тому

      ​@@8_7478 no you can't handle criticism

  • @edaleman2758
    @edaleman2758 22 дні тому +6

    If Hamas are terrorists what does that make the IDF? Given it's recent deeds and it's origins?

    • @bigbinji6145
      @bigbinji6145 22 дні тому

      Just imagine if the boot was on the other foot. There would be a million Jews dead by now ..........while the IDF carefully warn civilians ( and the enemy ) to leave the building before destroying the Haams building. Those that choose to stay ( the majority ) ....are simply seeking Martyrdom ....as propagated by the UNWRA funded schools

    • @nostro1001
      @nostro1001 22 дні тому +13

      An army of a democratic country, that is held to standards that none other are held & have demonstrated to go above and beyond to exceed war laws!

    • @thomasjohansson5045
      @thomasjohansson5045 21 день тому

      An offspring of the Haganah - the organization which conducted the violent "Plan Da-l-et" in early 1948, expelling 300000 Arabs from their well functioning villages.
      A violent and out of hand immoral military organization conducting a massacre on innocent Arabs yet again while committing war crime after war crime.

    • @RebeccaTurner-ny1xx
      @RebeccaTurner-ny1xx 21 день тому

      @@nostro1001 Apartheid Israel is no democracy, as its leading human rights organisation B'Tselem states: "The Israeli regime enacts in all the territory it controls (Israeli sovereign territory, East Jerusalem, the West Bank, and the Gaza Strip) an apartheid regime. One organizing principle lies at the base of a wide array of Israeli policies: advancing and perpetuating the supremacy of one group - Jews - over another - Palestinians.
      B’Tselem rejects the perception of Israel as a democracy (inside the Green Line) that simultaneously upholds a temporary military occupation (beyond it). B’Tselem reached the conclusion that the bar for defining the Israeli regime as an apartheid regime has been met after considering the accumulation of policies and laws that Israel devised to entrench its control over Palestinians."

  • @jzm2sg
    @jzm2sg 22 дні тому +4

    Tip: unite all calls with Hindus, yazidis, African and mid East Christians, Buddhists and no religious or ex Muslims who have all had the same experience.also helps expose their diversity or anti racist tags.

  • @GaigeGrosskreutzGunClub
    @GaigeGrosskreutzGunClub 22 дні тому +1

    Damn, so is Palestine allowed to have a military to defend itself too?

  • @alrosano5786
    @alrosano5786 22 дні тому +1

    Two guys A-shame and on denial ? Pretty much !

    • @8_7478
      @8_7478 20 днів тому

      Oh the usual comments from Al Rosano. They don't listen to podcast, just make the usual anti JC remarks.

  • @user-it3dd6xm8j
    @user-it3dd6xm8j 22 дні тому +2

    So The Jewish Chronicle is complicit in the Genocide too. Who do you represent?

    • @rebeccahicks2392
      @rebeccahicks2392 22 дні тому +2

      Hamas has explicitly said that they desire the extermination of all Jews. They started the war with a massacre of civilians---their attempt to begin a genocide. The only reason Hamas hasn't been able to carry out such a massacre every day since and accomplish their goals of an actual genocide has been the fact that Israel responded as would every country. Yes war is hell, but blame the party that started the war and that is continuing to reject all ceasefire offers. In other words, blame Hamas.

    • @lforlight
      @lforlight 22 дні тому +3

      What genocide?